Monday, April 11, 2022

Explanatory Notes -- Mark 11:12-19

11:12 And on the next day, them having come from Bethany, he was hungry. 13. And having seen a fig tree from afar having leaf, he came [to see] if then he will find something on it. And, having come upon it, he found nothing except leaves, for the season was of figs was not [yet].

In Mark's account, Jesus throws the money changers out of the temple on Monday. However, before he gets there, he encounters a fig tree. We learn two things about Jesus' humanness in these first two verses. First, we recognize that Jesus got hungry. This observation is probably not surprising to anyone.

Secondly, he did not operate with his omniscience while he was on earth. Jesus has to go and see to find out that this fig tree has no figs yet. From a standpoint of orthodox faith, we believe that the second person of the Trinity cannot not be omniscient. However, the Gospel of Mark does not portray Jesus as operating with omniscience while on earth. We will see this fact again clearly in Mark 13. From a theological standpoint, we conclude that Jesus in some way did not access his full omniscience on earth.

The tree has leaves but does not yet have figs. This suggests a date in late spring, probably before May. Mark gives us no reason to think that there is anything amiss with the tree. It just doesn't give Jesus the answer he wants in relation to his human hunger. 

11:14 And, having answered, he said to it, "No longer forever from you may anyone eat fruit." And his disciples were hearing.

Here we learn something else about Jesus in his humanness. He could get frustrated. As Ephesians makes clear, anger in itself is not sinful (Eph. 4:26). It is what you do when you are angry.

The text clearly wants us to understand that Jesus is frustrated, even though the tree has done nothing wrong. But there is something more going on here than meets the eye. Mark wants us to take away something from this tree. We will see what it is later in the chapter.

11:15 And he comes into Jerusalem. And having entered into the temple, he began to throw out the [ones] selling and those buying in the temple and the tables of money changers and the seats of the ones selling the doves he overturned. 16. And he was not allowing someone to bring a vessel through the temple. 

This more than any other passage demonstrates both that Jesus in his humanness could get angry and also therefore that anger in itself is not sin. Some of course might argue that Jesus staged this action. Some have argued that Jesus is symbolically enacting the future destruction of Jerusalem. [1] Perhaps, although it is not clear from this passage. In this passage, Jesus seems to be genuinely angry at what he sees as something wrong taking place.

He is overturning tables and chasing people. What a sight that must have been! It must not have lasted too long or else the Romans would have gotten involved. Roman soldiers stood in nearby towers overlooking the temple situation to make sure that nothing went amiss. Order and crowd control were high priorities for the Romans. Jesus is able to teach thereafter, again suggesting that this action did not rise to the level of high concern for the Romans.

This action is also a key debate point in conversations about whether Jesus was a pacifist. My own sense is that Jesus did not teach a thoroughgoing pacifism. He seemed to teach that God will perform acts of violence when Jesus returns to judge the world. The book of Revelation is full of violence in judgment, and John the son of Zebedee would surely have known if Jesus absolutely opposed its use. 

Jesus did teach love of enemy, so we must be careful not to try to wiggle out of his instruction to turn the other cheek. But Jesus arguably did not teach an absolute prohibition of force. It was not time to fight when he was on earth. Christians are people of peace. In most cases, martyrdom is more noble than a just fight. Those who argue for pacifism are more right than wrong about the tenor of Jesus' teaching. But he arguably did not consider it an absolute.

[1] E.g. E. P. Sanders, Jesus and Judaism.  

17. And he was teaching and saying to them, "Has it not been written, 'My house will be called a house of prayer for all nations?' But you have made it a den of plunderers."

Mark gives us hints at why Jesus was so upset at the buying and selling. On the one hand, such buying and selling was necessary. If someone traveled from Italy for the Passover, they were scarcely going to bring their own goat with them. Animals needed to be available, and currency needed to be exchanged.

Still, the sight must have sickened Jesus. This is a place for prayer, and the main thing going on in that courtyard was commerce. The temple of Lord had become the temple of mammon. 

Jesus quotes Isaiah 56:7, which prophesies that many who are not Israelites will flock to worship the Lord at the temple. Mark is the only Gospel that includes the part of the verse that says, "for all nations." Writing primarily for Gentiles, Mark no doubt wanted his audience to know that Jesus was sticking up for them long before they heard the good news.

Some have indeed argued that the core problem was that this buying and selling was likely taking place in the Court of the Gentiles. The situation must have looked to say, "Gentiles don't matter here. This is a fine place for us to turn a shekel in the space outside where the real people of God go in." Mark and the other Gospels of course do not explicitly say anything like that.

Then he alludes to Jeremiah 7:11. This is the passage where Jeremiah warns Israel that they cannot expect God's favor just because his temple is in Jerusalem. God will not defend Israel if they do injustice. Israel doesn't have a "get out of righteousness card" just because they are his chosen people. If they are unjust, God will withdraw his favor and allow them to be destroyed. [2] 

Jeremiah critiques the Israel of his day for their oppression of foreigners, their treatment of orphans and widows, their shedding of innocent blood, their going after other gods (7:6). They have figuratively made God's "house" into a den where violent people hide, plunderers, people who lie in wait to do violence to the unsuspecting and innocent.

It is easy to imagine that the moneychangers, like many toll collectors, were making a huge profit off a captive market. With a near monopoly on the sale of "clean" animals and being the nearly exclusive place to get temple coins, they had sincere worshipers over a barrel. Given Jesus' general view of the worldliness of money, it is not hard to imagine he found the scene infuriating. [3]

[2] This is relevant to a Christian attitude toward the nation of Israel today. Because of its place in salvation history, Israel deserves perpetual honor (cf. Rom. 9:4-5). But this fact does not mean that the world suspends all moral critique any more than toward ourselves or any nation. From Paul's standpoint, Israel has not yet arrived at Romans 11:26. 

[3] See notes below on Mark 12:17.

11:18 And the chief priests and the scribes heard and were seeking how they might destroy him, for they were fearing him, for the whole crowd was astonished at his teaching. 19. And when it became late, they were going out of the city.

The Jewish leaders have a nice racket going on. The Sadducees have influence and power. They are the class from which high priests are often taken. They are in favor with the Romans. They have the most to lose if Jesus creates unrest.

The scribes are the experts on the Law. In a culture where religion is the center of everything, the people who interpret God and the Scriptures are very powerful indeed. They decide what the Bible means for the people. Jesus threatens that oh-so-enjoyable status quo. Jesus has no "formal" authority, but his favor with the people gives him incredible "informal" power.

For now, they have to keep quiet. But they are waiting for an opportune moment when the tables might turn. Jesus and his followers are only in the city during the day. At night, they go back to Bethany.

Sunday, April 10, 2022

Explanatory Notes: Mark 11:1-11

I did my video commentary and podcast on Mark a couple years ago, but I didn't finish writing up the notes. I thought I would try to fill in some of the gaps of Passion Week this week (here is the original video/podcast on this text), even though for my video/podcast this week I looked at the triumphal entry in Luke 19:28-48.

_____________________________________

Mark 11:1 And when they draw near to Jerusalem, to Bethphage and Bethany, to the Mount of Olives, he sends two of his followers 2. and says to them, "Depart to the village, the [one] down from you, and immediately, entering into it, you will find a colt having been bound, upon which no one yet of mortals has sat. Loose it and bring [it]. 3. And if someone to you should say, 'Why are you doing this?' Say, 'His Lord has need and immediately sends it again here.'"

Jesus has been traveling toward Jerusalem since Peter's confession of him as Messiah in 8:29. In this chapter Jesus will reach Jerusalem. Mark 11-15 give us Passion Week, the final week of Jesus' earthly mission culminating in his crucifixion. These chapters constitute about a third of the Gospel, leading to the lighthearted description of Mark as a Passion narrative with a preface.

Bethany is less than two miles from Jerusalem. John tells us that Bethany is where Mary, Martha, and Lazarus live (John 11:1). The Mount of Olives is just across the Kidron Valley from the city of Jerusalem. You went out the eastern gate into the small valley and up the other side to the Mount of Olives. [1] The Garden of Gethsemane was at the base of the hill. [2]

Somewhere between Bethany and the Mount of Olives was a village where Jesus knew a colt would be. Mark does not say whether Jesus knew it supernaturally, or whether he had prearranged it, or even had seen it earlier. Mark simply indicates that Jesus knows. The two followers are to enter the village, find the donkey colt, and retrieve it for him.

It will be a colt on which no human has ever sat. There is something symbolic about this fact. The donkey represents purity. The donkey indicates that what Jesus is doing is something new. Jesus is not a used king. He is a brand new king.

Jesus is the Lord of the donkey, the donkey's Lord. The owners no doubt think that they are the colt's master, but Jesus is Lord of all. 

[1] The sealed Eastern Gate you see today is not the eastern gate of Jesus' day. The city wall was significantly expanded centuries ago.

[2] It is not a mountain in the sense of the Rocky Mountains or the mountains of Wales or Scotland. It is really just a large hill in comparison with the sizes of many of the mountains of the world.

11:4 And they went away and found a colt having been bound to a door outside by the lane. And they loosed it. 5. And some of the ones standing there were saying to them, 'What are you doing? Why are you loosing the colt?' 6. And they said to them just as Jesus said, and they allowed them.

The two disciples find the colt exactly as Jesus said. And just as Jesus indicated might happen, some bystanders ask them what they are doing. They do not question the answer. Some have suggested Jesus had prearranged it, and Jesus gave the disciples the code words to say. Of course, the text says nothing like that. The story reads as if Jesus just knew what would happen.

11:7 And they bring the colt to Jesus, and they cast their cloaks on it, and he sat on it. 8. And many spread their cloaks on the way, and others, having cut branches from the fields.

The Gospel of Matthew will make clear what presumably everyone around Jesus already knows. Jesus is intentionally fulfilling the prophecy of Zechariah 9:9. Jerusalem, your king is coming, riding on the colt of a donkey. Jesus' entry is thus a prophetic act. He is implicitly declaring that he is the Messiah, the anointed king of Israel.

The cutting of branches may deliberately echo another Scripture, Psalm 118:27. There are several verses in this psalm that the early Christians read in terms of Jesus and Psalm Sunday in particular. It is a psalm about returning to the temple after previously being rejected. The gates of righteousness open for the figure approaching the house of the Lord. Jesus may have seen what we call Palm Sunday as a fulfillment of this psalm.

11:9 And the ones going in front and those following were saying, "Hosanna! Blessed is the [one] who comes in the name of the Lord! 10. Blessed [is] the coming kingdom of our father David! Hosanna in the heights!"

The connection to Psalm 118 now becomes explicit. "Hosanna" seems to come from the Hebrew or Aramaic of Psalm 118:25. The Hebrew reads "Anna YHWH, Hoshiah na": "O Lord! Bring salvation!" The implication is that the approach of Jesus to the temple is the arrival of salvation. 

The statement, "Blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord" is a direct quotation of Psalm 118:26. The point again seems clear. Jesus is salvation on its way. Jesus' arrival in Jerusalem is the arrival of salvation for the city. He is the king. He is the son of David. He is the restoration of the kingdom. 

11:11 And he entered into Jerusalem, into the temple, and having looked around at all things, the hour already being late, he went out to Bethany with the Twelve.   

Unlike Matthew and Luke, Jesus does not immediately throw the money changers out of the temple in Mark. He symbolically enters Jerusalem. He symbolically goes to the temple. But he does not act. He returns to Bethany with his twelve disciples for the night.

Saturday, April 09, 2022

The Order of the Books -- Galatians

From one of my many projects...

__________________

A number of scholars think that Galatians was the first letter Paul wrote and thus the first book of the New Testament written. I’ll share that option at the end of the chapter. Let me first share how I picture the story unfolding, expanding on what Paul himself says in Galatians 1-2.

In Acts 13-14, Paul and two other individuals carry out a mission to the island of Cyprus—the so-called “first” missionary journey. The other two men are Barnabas, who is actually the leader of the mission, and John Mark, who goes along to help and assist. Mark was Barnabas’ cousin and is traditionally thought to be the author of the Gospel of Mark.

In all likelihood, Paul had already been preaching about Jesus’ death, resurrection, and return for almost a decade and a half before this time. After Jesus appeared to Paul around the year AD33, he got into trouble preaching in Damascus and Arabia (which at that time was just to the east of Damascus, Gal. 1:17). Then he probably preached for ten years in his home territory of Tarsus and perhaps even north in Cappadocia (Gal. 1:21).

After the three of them went to Cyprus, Paul suggests they go north to Asia Minor (modern day Turkey). Mark is not happy about the idea. He goes home. But Paul and Barnabas go north and found the churches of a region known as Galatia. These include cities like Antioch (of Pisidia), Iconium, Lystra, and Derbe. It is to these cities that Paul later addresses the letter called Galatians.

Galatians 1-2 tell the backstory that has led to the writing of this letter. Initially, Paul had been a vigorous opponent to the Jesus movement (1:13). He had been a Pharisee (Phil. 3:5). Pharisees were a Jewish group who followed the Jewish Law according to interpretations and traditions that were very strict and detailed. They were especially concerned with what you ate, how you ate it, and who you ate it with.

According to Acts 9, Paul was on his way to Damascus in the north to drag certain Christians back to Jerusalem. But Jesus appeared to him, blinding him and revealing himself to Paul. Paul indicates in Galatians that he had very little contact with Peter or any of the other disciples of Jesus during that time (1:18-19).

Fourteen years after he came to Christ, around the year AD49, the question of non-Jews came to a head. The leadership of the church in Jerusalem comes to an understanding. We find Paul’s side in Galatians 2. Acts 15 gives us another picture of the decision. They decide that Gentiles do not have to convert fully to Judaism to be saved. Gentile men do not have to get circumcised.

In Galatians 2, Paul describes it as a somewhat private meeting in Jerusalem. On the one side of the meeting is he and Barnabas. They meet with the core disciples of the church in Jerusalem—Peter, John, and Jesus’ half-brother James. Paul and Barnabas bring along a young Gentile convert named Titus as an object lesson.

Titus is “not forced” to be circumcised and fully convert to Judaism (2:3). The wording makes us wonder if that was their ideal. But they concede that a non-Jewish man could be saved from the coming wrath of God without becoming circumcised and fully becoming a Jew.

This decision was not unopposed. Paul mentions “false brothers” who did not agree (Gal. 2:4). They were Christians who were zealous for the Jewish Law. They wanted any Gentile believers to become Jews if they expected to be part of the Christ movement. Acts 15 says that there were Pharisees who had believed but apparently had not stopped being Pharisees (Acts 15:5).

Acts 15 apparently did not end the disagreement. Jesus’ brother James had become the leader of the church in Jerusalem. He had conceded that Gentiles did not have to convert to Judaism to escape the coming judgment. Gentiles did not have to keep all the Jewish Law. But he was apparently concerned that Jewish Christians themselves would become lax in their Law-keeping.

First, Peter comes up to Antioch. At first, he eats the weekly Lord’s Supper with the Gentile believers. All is well. But then some people come from James in Jerusalem. All the prejudices against Gentiles come into play. Where did this meat come from? Was it prepared properly? Are these Gentile Christians sexually immoral because “we all know” about those Gentiles?

Peter and the other Jewish Christians stop eating the weekly meal of the Lord’s Supper with them. Paul is incensed. He basically calls Peter a hypocrite in front of the whole church (Gal. 2:11-14). Even Barnabas seems to side with Peter, perhaps not so much because he agreed but because he wanted to address the issue in a way that submitted to authority.

As difficult as this situation must have been, God brought good things from it. Paul and Barnabas agree to disagree and separate. This doubles the mission. So while the argument may have been unpleasant, the good news ends up traveling to Greece much more quickly as a result.

God may also use this conflict to catalyze Paul’s sense that we are “justified by faith” and not by works of the Jewish Law. To be “justified” is to be right with God. Paul emphasizes that a person became right with God by faith in God, by trusting in God and committing to God.

It seemed hypocritical to Paul that Peter would insist on the Gentiles at Antioch keeping Old Testament purity laws when Peter himself wasn’t very careful. Remember, Paul had been a Pharisee. He knew a lot about purity laws. Peter had never kept the Law as scrupulously as he had.

As a Pharisee, Paul had kept the Jewish Law very well. In Philippians 3:6, he said he had been blameless at keeping it. So when Jesus called him, he realized God must be looking for something quite different. “Works of Law,” circumcision, purity rules, food laws, Sabbath observance—these were not the heart of getting right with God. Rather, it was faith or trust in God.

A Gentile could have faith in God without being circumcised. A Gentile could have faith in God and still eat pork. A Gentile could have faith in God and not observe the Jewish Sabbath. A Gentile could be justified by faith.

Paul may not have had the full theology worked out in Antioch. But his ongoing debates with both believing and non-believing Jews helped refine his argument over time. The biggest flash point after Antioch sparked his letter to the Galatians.

Paul and Barnabas founded the churches of Galatia in the years 46-48. Then he visited the churches again at the beginning of his “second” missionary journey around AD50. He may even have visited them a third time at the beginning of his third missionary journey around AD53. It is from one of these churches (Lystra) that he took one of his key young co-workers, Timothy.

Up to that time, these churches had been “running well” (4:7). However, some new voices had entered into the community. These were what we might call “Judaizers.” They were individuals who insisted that Gentiles must fully convert to Judaism in order to be saved from the coming wrath and be part of the kingdom of God. They were either Jewish believers by birth or Gentiles who had themselves converted to Judaism.

Paul is very angry with them when he writes Galatians. He probably would consider them “false brothers” as in Galatians 2:4. They want the Gentile Galatians to get circumcised. Oh yeah? Paul says. If they like circumcision so much, they should just cut their whole male organ off (5:12).

Paul’s struggle with these Judaizing elements in the church would leave traces in his next few writings—Philippians, 2 Corinthians, and especially Romans. The edge might have cooled down, but we just don’t really get the allusions to this conflict before, in 1 Thessalonians or 1 Corinthians. We only get the hint that he has taught his Gentile churches that “all things are lawful for me” (1 Cor. 10:23). In Galatians, he is in the thick of argument about this claim, and we can see him working out the details of that theology, which will culminate in Romans.

The core of his argument is in Galatians 2:15-21. Jewish believers know that keeping the Jewish Law is not enough to make them right with God. They know they need the “faithfulness of Jesus.” There is debate about this phrase in 2:16. I suspect Paul is making a play on words. In the first place, I wonder if he is referring to the faithful death of Jesus (cf. Phil. 2:8). He would imply that Christians of his day agreed across the board that the cross was essential for the restoration of God’s people.

In the last chapter, we saw that the cross was central to Paul’s preaching. We get some details in Galatians 3. Although it is hard for us to follow—because our worldview is different—Paul indicates that Jesus absorbed the curse of the world on the cross. Jew and Gentile alike were under a curse because of our sin (Gal. 3:10-14). Jesus took on that curse by being cursed on the cross. If we become incorporated “in Christ” by receiving the Holy Spirit, then our curse is removed and we can be right with God.

It is a difficult argument for us to follow. The bottom line is that trusting in Christ so that we are right with God is a different “system” than the Jewish Law. The Jewish Law only tells us that we have a problem. It cannot solve it. Only the faithfulness of Jesus and, to take the phrase a different way, faith in Jesus can make us right with God. We trust in what God did through Jesus. We get on the Jesus ship and we are shielded from the curse of the Law.

The Holy Spirit makes this happen. Without the Holy Spirit, as Paul will develop especially in Romans 6-8, we cannot hope to succeed against the temptations of our flesh. Without God’s Spirit helping us, we are destined to be moral losers. But the Spirit inside is like being plugged into God. “Walk in the Spirit and you will not fulfill the desires of the flesh” (Gal. 5:16). The fruit of the Spirit are love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control (5:22-23). This is the result we should get when we are plugged into God’s power supply.

There are other theories of when Galatians was written. A very popular one is that Galatians is the first letter Paul wrote, even before the Jerusalem Council. In this theory, the Jerusalem Council of AD49 cleared up all these debates. Very tidy and harmonious! However, it seems like more time has passed than that since Paul first founded these churches. He has arguably visited them more than once (4:13). They have believed long enough to have been running well for a bit (5:7). In Galatians, Paul often mentions being persecuted, which probably implies more time has passed. In the end, Galatians feels like it belongs more to Paul’s Philippians, 2 Corinthians, and Romans phase than to the time of 1 Thessalonians and 1 Corinthians.

Tuesday, March 22, 2022

The Cub by Nicholas Squirreliavelli

Working on a writing project with my daughter Sophie, presenting philosophy in an animal story with animalized versions of key philosophical works interspersed. Here is our first draft of The Prince, aka, "The Cub."

_________________________

The Cub

It is hard to become a lion king and even harder to stay one. In the old days, your dad might be a king and then you would become one. The people were used to your dad. It was easier.

Of course there often were sneaky lions wanting to overthrow you. They play to the animals who are unhappy. You have to smash anyone who gets too powerful. Keep your friends close and your enemies closer.

This is even more important when you come to power and you have not inherited it. Smash all those who might compete with you immediately. Be vicious. Eliminate anyone who might oppose you. It is much better to do it all at once than to trickle out the elimination of your enemies. Never do an enemy a small injury. Make it so severe that you never need fear revenge.

You have to be both a lion and a fox. When you are powerful enough to crush your enemies by force, destroy them like a lion kills a wolf. But sometimes the clever lay traps for you and you have to be sneaky to defeat them. In such cases, outsmart them like a fox. Never attempt to win by force what you can win by deception.

To be a fox is to lie. The world is full of bad animals. If the world were only full of good animals, the cub could always be good. But because the world has so much bad, the cub must sometimes pretend to be good while doing bad things to those who oppose him or her. Otherwise the truly bad will destroy you. When brutality is the only option, it is holy.

The end justifies the means. Promise what you must now in the present then take it back when you need to in the future. It is better to act and repent than to regret not having acted. Keep your true plans secret while portraying yourself as only true and virtuous in public.

It is much safer to be feared than to be loved. Certainly, it is dangerous if the animals of your kingdom hate you. But they do not have to love you. It is best if they fear but do not hate you.

There will always be animals outside your kingdom that want to defeat you. A cub must thus always be preparing for war. The art of war must always be on his or her mind. Hunt on your territory to prepare yourself. That war is just that is necessary for you to prevail. You cannot avoid war. Postponing only gives the advantage to your enemy.

Let your administrators do unpopular things for you. Make strong statements against the enemies of your kingdom to stir up the spirit of your people. Perhaps even invent enemies and destroy them to win favor. Speak strongly in favor of your friends and allies. Put them in your debt so that they will strongly support you.

Get some animals to tell you the truth, but only when you ask for it. Your animals should only tell you what you want to hear when you want to hear it. But it is important to ask for what they think is true from time to time and to listen. But you must always be in charge of what they tell you.

Many believe that the world is only governed by chance or God. That’s half of it to be sure. But your choices are the other half. God or chance may be half of what happens, but that gives half the governance to you. Use it wisely.

Sunday, March 20, 2022

Key Excerpts from Machiavelli's The Prince

The current Russia-Ukraine conflict got me thinking about Machiavelli's The Prince. Here is a quick collection of M's thoughts.

____________________________

1-3. Leadership of "states" (dominions over people, either principalities or republics) is either hereditary or newly acquired. Hereditary leadership is easier to maintain because it's the tradition. 

New principalities acquired either used to have a principate or used to be free. They are acquired either by your own forces or outside forces. They are acquired either by valor or by good fortune. A "mixed" principate is one where a new part is added.

The possibility of change arises because some think change will improve things (grass is greener). When acquiring a new principate of similar language and customs, the main thing is to end the bloodline of the former principate but leave the laws and customs the same.

It's harder to keep a new territory of different language, custom, and law. Some options are to send colonists or go live there yourself. Occupation doesn't work so well. Be either soft or harsh. If you're harsh, crush them so they can't come back with revenge. People hold grudges against "small insults."

It's easy to line up followers in a new rule among the weaker. But beware, they just as easily switch to follow others too. So don't let powerful individuals close from the outside (foreigners) or let internal people get too much power. 

"A prince must not only oversee current scandals, but future ones as well." Catch problems early and squash them before they fester.

4. Principalities are governed in two ways--by a central authority and distributed leaders who owe their positions to that authority or by distributed leaders who inherited those positions. The first is much easier to rule. France was the second, and there were always malcontents that were trouble.

5. When taking over a place where they used to have freedom under their own laws, it's more difficult. You probably will need to destroy their laws. You could go live there. To let them live under their own laws after installing a group of leaders and taking tribute. Only the first route will succeed in the long term. Immediately eradicate their customs and traditions.

6. Those who come to power by their own power and resources (their own "virtue") crush all their enemies, clear the deck, and succeed. P.S. He puts Moses in this category.

7. It is very hard to succeed if you come to power by good fortune (i.e., by appointment). Cesare Borgia is a near exception, who by his deception, craft, and brutality used then eliminated others. You have to clear the deck. Being nice to people now won't make them forget harm you did to them in the past.

8. Here M treats people who rise to power by villany. He does not seem to oppose their methods--he says he won't comment (and then does). He speaks of the "good and bad use of cruelty." "In cases of necessity, I judge it simply expedient to imitate them." They achieved power but not glory. 

"Cruelty well used (if one can ever say cruelty is good) is when it is practiced suddenly and decisively, but not prolonged." "Act quickly and commit the first offenses right away."

9. When citizens make someone a leader, it is important for the leader to keep the citizens dependent on the state and friendly toward him. Their main desire is not to be oppressed. "a prince needs a friendly populace. Otherwise, in adversity, there is no hope."

But beware of other leaders and magistrates. "In times of trouble, they will try to ruin him."

10. Prince should be able to defend himself. Forget about open territory. Have a fortress. The people from the outside land will get over it after the attackers leave. "The nature of man is such that he feels obligated both for benefits given and benefits received."

11. Church principalities are easy to hold, once established.

12. The fundamentals a state has to have are good laws and a strong army. Mercenaries won't do it. [He really assumes that anyone who has the capacity and opportunity will take control by force. Very dark sense of human nature.]

13. Auxiliary arms--using someone else's troops. Losers rely on them. They are more dangerous than mercenaries because the one who owns them will take you over. "Without its very own native troops, no principality is secure... fate hangs on fortune." Tacitus--"No human thing is so weak and unstable as a reputation of strength not based on actual force."

14. War is the only art that concerns a person in command. [What an adversarial sense of the world!] Neglect of the art of war is why princes lose their states. In peace, a prince needs to be more armed than in war. Hunting is good preparation. And you learn your terrain.

"A prince must always be reading history and study the records of excellent men, the reasons for victory and defeat." No laziness in peacetime.

15. [This is where the interesting material really gets going.] A lot of people aren't good. The person who always tries to be good will fail because of the people who are not good. "A prince who wants to maintain his position needs to learn how not to be good, and then either use or not use the good as necessary." "There will be traits considered good that, if followed, will lead to ruin, while other traits considered vices which, if practiced, will achieve security and well-being for the prince."

"Any man who tries to be good all the time is bound to come to ruin among the great number who are not good"

16. "Liberality, as it is usually practiced, is harmful." "In our times, no great things have been done except by those who were perceived as misers." "Nothing harms your own resources like liberality." But spend liberally the resources of others. "It is wiser to be known as a miser, which gives you a bad name but not a hated one."

17. "Every prince would want to be thought compassionate rather than cruel. But I need to warn him to be careful about compassion." "It is much safer to be feared than to be loved if one must renounce one or the other." However, short of being loved, the prince shouldn't be hated.

18. Everyone talks about how princes should be people of honesty who keep faith. Not true. Successful princes live by their wits and hold keeping faith in low regard. "A prince needs to know how to handle beasts and men." Laws are the way of man. Force is the way of beasts.

"You need to be a fox to know snares, a lion to scare wolves." A prince who is only a lion will fall into traps. A prince who is only a fox will be eaten by wolves. "Because men are imperfect and don't keep faith with you, neither must you keep faith with them."

The lion cannot protect himself from traps, and the fox cannot defend himself from wolves. One must therefore be a fox to recognize traps, and a lion to frighten wolves.

A prince needs to know how and when to deceive. He needs to know when to act badly as well as when to act rightly. [The end justifies the means.] He needs to always seem compassionate, faithful, honest, humane, and religious. But he needs to do whatever needs to be done and have a variable nature.

"A prince deceives to win and maintain the state."

19. It is important for a prince not to be hated or scorned. Other than that he doesn't have to worry about his reputation. Taking your people's stuff is how to become hated. Also to be avoided is the perception of being lazy, effeminate, or fearful. He should be decisive and his judgments should not be reversible.

Two threats to a prince--external and internal. If he is well-armed and has friends, he's good. The best way to avoid plots is to be loved by the masses. "A prince need not worry about conspiracies when he enjoys popularity." "Everyone sees what you seem to be, few know what you really are, and those few do not dare take a stand against the general opinion"

"A prince should let others administrate unpopular measures and only claim credit for popular measures." "A prince will always be hated by someone." "If he has to choose, he cannot afford to be unpopular with the most powerful faction."

20. "A clever prince, some say, cultivates enemies when he can so that his reputation increases when he puts them down." "The prince who fears his own people more than enemies should build forts. Those who fear enemies more should forget forts." "The best fortress is not to be hated by the public."

21. "A prince is always esteemed when he takes a strong stand against enemies or in favor of friends." It always happens that someone who is not your friend will urge you to neutrality." "Princes should avoid obligations to others."

"One can never side-step an uncertainty without stepping into another one. Prudence weighs the qualities of the uncertainty and chooses the best of the alternatives."

22. Three types of ministers--those that understand themselves, those who understand others, those who understand neither. The first two are good. Don't pick a minister who thinks more of himself than you. 

23. The only way to guard against flatterers is to have people tell you the truth. But to keep respect, you should only let them tell you the truth when you ask for it. "A prince who is not himself wise cannot be counseled well."

24. "Men are more drawn by the present than the past." "That defense is only good and certain that rests on yourself and your own virtue."

25. Many believe the world is governed by fortune or God and that there is nothing we can do about fate. "However, free will is not entirely powerless. Fortune may be half arbiter of our world, but she leaves half of the world to our governance." "A prince who relies on fortune gets ruined when fortune changes. A prince succeeds who can adapt to his time."  Also some pretty misogynous comments I won't repeat.

26. An appeal to the Medicis to take back Italy.

A quote from Livy: "That war is just which is necessary."    


 There is no avoiding war, it can only be postponed to the advantage of your enemy.

Alexander never did what he said, Cesare never said what he did.

An unavoidable war is called justice. When brutality is the only option left it is holy.”

The first method for estimating the intelligence of a ruler is to look at the men he has around him.”

Never attempt to win by force what can be won by deception

If an injury has to be done to a man it should be so severe that his vengeance need not be feared.

A prince must not have any other object nor any other thought… but war, its institutions, and its discipline; because that is the only art befitting one who commands

Never do an enemy a small injury.”

The new ruler must determine all the injuries that he will need to inflict. He must inflict them once and for all

There is no avoiding war; it can only be postponed to the advantage of others.

Chapter 18

The promise given was a necessity of the past: the word broken is a necessity of the present.”

It is better to act and repent than not to act and regret.

We have not seen great things done in our time except by those who have been considered mean; the rest have failed.”

Keep your friends close, keep your enemies closer.”

a prince who wants to keep his authority must learn how not to be good, and use that knowledge, or refrain from using it, as necessity requires."


Saturday, March 12, 2022

Deconstruction Novel -- chapter 9.1

Jerry Pattengale wrote a bit of a review of the novel on higher education that Erin Crisp and I wrote, How Angie Saved Chicken U. It has an ISBN but is not quite up on Amazon yet. Since he mentions the long-term novel I have been writing on Fridays/Saturdays, I thought I would give continued proof of concept. :-) Here's from this morning:

________________________________

Matt had met with Dr. Baine. Now it was Brad’s turn to meet with Dr. Todley, the history professor. As before, the group came up with some questions for Brad to cover. As with Dr. Baine, I would go too as a second witness.

Brad wanted to know more about why he shouldn’t vote for a third-party candidate or why he had to vote at all. April wanted to know more about the “separation of church and state.” Dr. Todley didn’t seem too concerned about it to her. Jessica wondered if there were any scenario when he might vote for a Democrat.

Matt didn’t really have any questions. He just wanted Brad to get Dr. Baine into trouble about abortion.

Dr. Todley was happy to meet. He did not yet have any of the group in class, but he saw these issues as extremely important and wanted to influence as many students as he could to vote Republican. For him, the future of America as a Christian nation was at stake. 

“So your ‘lunch bunch’ has some questions about the debate?” He took the lead.

“Yeah, we wanted to follow up with both you and Dr. Baine to hear more about your thoughts on the election. I come bearing questions,” Brad said.

“I hope they’re not Trojan questions,” he said with a completely straight face. Brad did not realize he had echoed the Greek story of the Trojan horse. It leaped out of his subconscious like the Greeks hiding inside the horse.

“No, my questions won’t jump out and attack you by surprise,” Brad smiled. He looked down at the paper where he had written down the questions.

“Why don’t you just give me the paper and I’ll go down the list?”

“Sure, if you can read my handwriting,” Brad said and handed him the paper.

“Separation of church and state,” his eyes fixed on the second question. “No such thing,” he said firmly.

“You all need to take my American history class next semester. There are all kinds of lies they teach you in the public school about American history, and that’s one of them. The phrase ‘separation of church and state’ appears nowhere in the Constitution or the official founding documents of the United States.

“In fact, as late as 1877 the state of New Hampshire required that all state representatives be Protestants. Until 1833, any elected official in Massachusetts had to confess their belief in the Christian religion.”

“So where does the idea come from?” Brad asked.

“It’s a misinterpretation of the first amendment. What it says is that ‘Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.’ It’s about there not being an official religion of the nation as a whole. It was never meant to cut religion out of all public life. And nothing in the Constitution prohibits the individual states from having Christianity as their official religion.”

Brad didn’t really know enough about it to ask detailed questions or what pushback a different history professor might make.

“So is there any limit to what Christian laws the government might make?” ...

Friday, February 25, 2022

University Chemistry I

Alas, I have a day job. I was not able to keep up with my hoped schedule for chemistry 2. Hopefully, I will finish before I die. In the meantime, since I wasn't able to keep up, I will admit temporary defeat and try to fill in the blanks I have left for videos on chemistry 1. 

Again, I am following Brown, LeMay, Burston, and Murphy. This website approaches the subject from the standpoint of the textbook.

________________

Module 1: The Basics 

Week 1: Matter and Measurement (chapter 1)

Week 2: Atoms, Molecules, and Ions (chapter 2)

Module 2: Stoichiometry and Reactions

Week 3: Stoichiometry (chapter 3)

Week 4: Review and Test 1

Module 3: Solutions and Heat

Week 5: Aqueous Reactions and Solution Stoichiometry (chapter 4)

Week 6: Thermochemistry (chapter 5)

Module 4: Thermochemistry 

Week 7: Thermochemistry continued

Week 8: Review and Test 2

Module 5: Electronic Structure and Periodic Properties 

Week 9: Electronic Structure of the Atom (chapter 6)

Week 10: Periodic Properties of the Elements (chapter 7)

Module 6: Chemical Bonding and Molecular Geometry

Week 11: Basic Concepts of Bonding (chapter 8)

Week 12: Molecular Geometry and Bonding Theories (chapter 9)

  • molecular shapes, VSEPR model, shape and polarity, orbital overlap, hybrid orbitals, multiple bonds, molecular orbitals, second-row diatomics

Module 7: Gases and Intermolecular Forces

Week 13: Gases (chapter 10)

Week 14: Intermolecular Forces, Liquids, and Solids (chapter 11)

  • comparisons of states, intermolecular forces, liquids, phase changes, vapor pressure, phase diagrams, solids, solid bonding

Module 8: Properties of Solutions

Week 15: Properties of Solutions (chapter 13)

  • solution process, saturated solutions, solubility, concentration, colligative properties, colloids

Week 16: Final Exam

Saturday, February 05, 2022

Deconstruction novel continues...

Just wanted to say that I continue the discipline of writing the Deconstruction novel on Friday nights/Saturday mornings. But I don't think I'll continue putting excerpts here.

In other news, Erin Crisp and I wrote a fable in 2 days this week: How Angie Saved Chicken U. I was inspired by the fable, How Stella Saved the Farm. I think my company, Campus Edu, is going to publish and distribute it. It captures my sense of what might happen to save the struggling Christian college. I am more doubtful about whether such colleges will end up taking much of the advice. 

Saturday, January 29, 2022

Deconstruction 7.1 -- After the Debate

My discipline of writing a novel called Deconstruction continues, the story of several young people at a Christian college in the years 2016-2020. Here was the last post.

_____________________

The next day at lunch, our group debriefed from the debate. Jessica hadn’t gone. Such things were far too boring for her. Matt thought that Dr. Todley was the obvious winner. April thought the same about Dr. Baine.

Brad wasn’t sure, nor was I. Dr. Todley’s best arguments had to do with abortion, it seemed to us. But Dr. Baine had made us realize something that had never even occurred to us—America’s past seemed a lot brighter to us because we were white than it probably did to someone of color.

All of us agreed that we would have liked to have heard responses to some of the points the other side made. Matt didn’t feel like Dr. Baine had been clear about when human life began. April wanted to know what Dr. Todley would say about abortion declining more under Democratic presidents. Brad was curious about what Dr. Todley thought Jesus was really like.

A scheme emerged. Matt would have coffee with Dr. Baine, and Brad would do the same with Dr. Todley. We as a group would collect our questions for each one and commission them to ask them. Then we would regroup afterward and share the results.

Friday, January 28, 2022

Book Review -- How Stella Saved the Farm

My next read on innovation is a fable called How Stella Saved the Farm: A Tale about Making Innovation Happen. This is just a great book and I look forward to reading Govindarajan's prose book. Of course everything works out in the end, so I enjoy that. The book isn't a tragedy. 

A middle or elementary school person could read this book. Yet its business principles are superb. Let me just summarize some of the elements:

  • The problem is that the human farms are big and use farm equipment, while the animal-led farm is small and more manual. How could they possibly compete?
  • Their normal is "faster, stronger, more efficient," but it just isn't enough. They need to do something new and different. They have a contest to make proposals.
  • The winning proposal is alpaca wool.
  • There are all sorts of inter-animal tensions throughout the book. They work through them all. That part might be a little unbelievable, given that these represent people with their varying personalities.
  • I note that gathering information from customers is part of their research ("ethnographic study").
  • The head horse has to change the new org chart repeatedly. She has to find the right people for the right positions. It involves some trial and error. There's resistance to change and complaints that they don't have the money or capacity to innovate.
  • She decides they need a dedicated team. Then they find some overlap. But it is likely building a new company from the ground up.
  • It costs way more than they planned. There were fails and complications. 
  • The rooster comes up with three laws for running business experiments:
  • 1) Learning first, profits second. "If you put learning first--learning through disciplined experimentation--you'll make better decisions and you'll actually get to profitability sooner."
  • You make a hypothesis. You predict what will happen. You measure results. You assess lessons learned. You start over.
  • 2) The second law is that "inside a big experiment, there are little experiments." I thought of the saying, "Fail often. Fail fast. Fail forward."
  • 3) The third law is that the innovation leader's job is to exercise a disciplined experiment. The evaluation of an innovator is whether she has a clear hypothesis, is identifying the most critical unknowns, is investing time and analyzing results, is communicating the plan to the team, is reacting quickly to new information, etc.
This may be the best business book I've ever read.
 

Thursday, January 27, 2022

Explanatory Notes -- Hebrews 11:8-22

11:8 By faith Abraham, being called, obeyed to go into a place that he was about to receive as an inheritance and he went out, not knowing where he was going. 11:9 By faith he sojourned in the land of promise as a foreigner in tents, dwelling with Isaac and Jacob, his co-inheriters of the same promise. 10. For he was awaiting the city having foundations, whose architect and builder [is] God.

The theme of being strangers in the land is a major part of the next few verses on Abraham. He was in a land that was promised to him, but he was not in possession of that land. There is a sense of alienation from the people around him. He does not belong. He doesn't know where God is leading him. They live in tents rather than permanent houses. The city they are in is not their city.

These images were no doubt meant to speak to the audience of Hebrews. If they were in Rome, indeed, if some of them were Roman citizens, they were alienated from their own city. They lived there but did not belong there. It could also apply to Jerusalem, which was arguably the center of the early church and its fundamental Jewish identity. If Jerusalem were recently destroyed at the time of writing, we can imagine the sense of disequilibrium and alienation that would have resulted.

Whatever the precise scenario, the author reorients them around the heavenly city, the heavenly Jerusalem. This city was designed and constructed by God, not Romulus. [1] The heavenly city has real foundations. Earthly cities like Rome or Jerusalem had far inferior foundations. 

The sense of the land being his by promise but not yet obtained may suggest the theme of new creation. The land would belong to him after the resurrection, after the removal of the current created order and the recreation of all things. So the audience may live on the earth, but it would not be theirs until after the new creation.

[1] Note once again that God the Father is the creator of the cosmos in most of Hebrews rather than Christ. 

11:11 By faith also Sarah herself, sterile, received power for the foundation of seed, even beyond the time of age, since she considered faithful the one who had promised. 12. Therefore, even from one [man]--and these from one having been dead--as the stars of the sky in multitude and as the sand on the shore of the sea without number. 

There are some variations in the Greek manuscripts of 11:11, mainly centering around whether it is Abraham or Sarah's faith that is in question. In either case, the point is that the descendants of Sarah and Abraham did not exist. It was like they were dead. It would have been easy not to believe even though God had promised them descendants as numerous as the stars in the sky or the sand on the beach.

But God is a God who raises the dead! God raised Jesus from the dead and, if the audience should have to die for their faith, God will raise them from the dead. They fear they are going to face persecution again, as before. They are possibly afraid that the promises they have heard are not real, that Jesus perhaps is not the Messiah, perhaps even that the God of Israel is not a true God.

Hebrews reminds them of salvation history. Death is not the end of the story. God brought Sarah and Abraham multitudes of descendants when it was humanly impossible. And God did this because they had faith.

At points like this we might remember that Sarah did not seem to be full of faith in Genesis 18. We remember what we have said of Old Testament engagement throughout. The moment of inspiration for Hebrews is independent of the moment of inspiration for Genesis. The inspired point of Hebrews is what the Holy Spirit breathed through the author of Hebrews. It does not have to be the same meaning or point as the Old Testament text.

11:13 In faith these all died, not having received the promises but from afar having seen them and having greeted them and having confessed that they were strangers and exiles in the land. 14. For those who speak such things make it clear that they are seeking a country. 15. And if, on the one hand, they were remembering that [one] from which they went out, they would have had opportunity to return. 16. But now, they desire a better [one], that is, a heavenly [one]. Therefore God is not ashamed to be called their God, for he prepared for them a city.

Now the author of Hebrews steps back and gives the general point. The audience may die before they receive the promises of Christ's return and the shaking of the created realm, before the judgment and the true Jerusalem. Or perhaps Christ will come immediately and deliver them. Whatever happens, they must continue on in faith like Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.

Abraham died in faith. He had been given the promise of the land, but he died before his descendants were in full possession of it. He saw the promise from afar, but he did not fully receive them while he were in this world.

So he was an alien in the land of his own promise. He was a stranger. He was an exile. His true country was not the one from which he came. Otherwise, he might have returned. Rather, he was looking for a better country, a heavenly one. He was looking for the heavenly Jerusalem, the heavenly city that God had prepared for him.

These remarks would have been extremely poignant in the aftermath of Jerusalem's destruction. Worried about the truth of a religion whose central city had been destroyed. Worried about a God who would let his temple be obliterated. Given the way people thought about gods and their temples at the time, this must have shook many early Christians deeply. 

We are heirs of those who have long reformulated their faith around heaven and not around any earthly site. They were just in the process of figuring such things out.

11:17 By faith Abraham has offered up Isaac, being tested, and the one who has received the promises was offering the only-born, 18. to the one whom it was spoken, "In Isaac your seed will be called," 19. having reckoned that even from the dead God was able to raise, whence also he received him in a parable.

Death cannot stop God's promises. Just as Isaac's birth was a miracle of life from death, so Isaac's escape from sacrifice was such a rescue. And the audience can know for sure that God can both rescue them from dying if it should come to that, and God can raise them from the dead if they are martyred for their faith. Abraham had a promise. Even death cannot stop the life of God!

The tenses of this verse are fascinating. Abraham "has offered" Isaac. The perfect tense suggests that Isaac remains offered. The tense seems to speak to the permanent witness of Abraham's faith in Scripture. Scripture "stands written," as the often used perfect tense indicates. Regardless of what happened to Abraham in history, the testimony of Scripture stands forever.

Abraham's constant obedience in faith is thus the witness of this text. The imperfect tense is then used at the end of the verse, he "was offering." The continuous flavor of that tense may also suggest the constant, ongoing faith of Abraham while being tested.

The echo of God offering Jesus may also be present. The statement at Jesus' baptism, "This is my son whom I love" echoes the Genesis 22 story where God tells Abraham to offer his son whom he loves. So Abraham's faithfulness in offering Isaac is like God's faithfulness in offering his only-born son as well.

11:20 By faith also concerning things about to be, Isaac blessed Jacob and Esau. 21. By faith Jacob, dying, blessed each of the sons of Joseph, and he bowed down on the head of his staff. 22. By faith Joseph, nearing the end, remembered concerning the exodus, and commanded concerning his bones.

The witness of Scripture is that Isaac, Jacob, and Joseph all showed the same faith in the unseen that Abraham did. Isaac saw a future of promise for Jacob and Esau and blessed them. Jacob and Joseph may have died in Egypt, but they believed in a future where their descendants would return to the land and possess it. Jacob blessed Ephraim and Manasseh, who would also die before their descendants inherited. Joseph commanded that his bones be returned, believing in an exodus that was four hundred years in the future.

In each of these cases, the audience is instructed to persist in faith. Perhaps they will escape persecution. Perhaps they will not. But like the patriarchs, they must continue to run with patience the race set before them.

Tuesday, January 25, 2022

A Book Observed -- Solving Problems with Design Thinking

I like to keep record of books I read or dawdle with here. I read/skimmed/audibled another book on design thinking: Solving Problems with Design Thinking. There's an overlap in author with the previous book I read. This book gives 10 case studies of design thinking innovation.

Incredibly boring book to me. I swear, these two books on Design Thinking could be subtitled--"how to make innovation as boring as possible so that managers can handle it." I almost get angry when books that could be written more interestingly instead are ventures in self-torture. My time's too precious to throw away. If I teach this MBA class again, I won't be requiring this book.

Perhaps another metric for me on the value of a book is how many tweetable insights and quotes it has. There were some in the book. Here are a few:

  • If you take only one thing from this book... it is the awesome power of ethnography, the deep insights produced by getting to know the situation and journeys of your customers as well as the people inside your organization that facilitate providing products and services.
  • Don't kill your strategies with completeness. Leave room for the people who must make them real to make them their own.
  • Nobody experiences anything by being told about it.
  • Thinking smaller--placing small bets and learning fast--is an undervalued innovation strategy.
  • One of the greatest challenges of the quest for innovation is impatience, "which makes us rush to solve instead of taking time to understand."
  • "The design thinking approach forces you to stay in the question and not define exactly what the problem is." Barry MacDevitt
  • "It is more often the recasting and recombination of myriad elements rather than one big 'new to the world' idea."
  • "Innovation is a team sport."
  • "Research demonstrates that too much information actually degrades the quality of our decisions."
  • Leaving space for stakeholders to be part of the discovery of new ideas.
I would say chapter 12, "Where Do We Go from Here?" is the chapter to read in the book. After the ten case studies, it suggests five key benefits to design thinking:
  • the way it helps reframe the questions--you get a better sense of what the real questions are (empathy is a key element here, feeling for your customer and employee)
  • collaborating to leverage difference--it brings the people who otherwise might pull against each other into the same room and thus overcomes potential barriers
  • curates the evidence to distill the essence of your situation
  • leaves space for insight, rather than just the creative ones having all the answers (allows emptiness to invite engagement)
  • accelerates speed through collaboration that cuts through inertia and bureaucracy

Saturday, January 22, 2022

Deconstruction 6.1 -- The Debate begins

I continue to write a novel called Deconstruction, set in a Christian college in the years 2016-2020. Here's the previous excerpt.

______________________

The chapel was packed to the brim the evening of the debate. Dr. Todley had a podium on the right and Dr. Baine was on the left. If anyone missed the symbolism, Dr. Todley pointed it out as an opening joke.

A senior named Todd was the moderator. He was president of the Young Republicans club. April found out there was no Young Democrats club on campus because the administration wasn’t sure it would be appropriate for us as a Christian college. And besides, they couldn’t find a faculty person willing to be its advisor.

Both professors gave an opening statement. Then Todd asked them three questions each, with a chance for each to respond. Then they gave closing remarks, followed by an open Q & A session.

Dr. Todley went first. His basic argument was that although candidate Trump was not a perfect candidate, he was 75% on the right path while Clinton was 100% on the wrong path. The Republican platform was godly while the Democratic one was not. A vote for anyone else but Trump was a vote for abortion. That issue alone meant a Christian had to vote for Trump. It even ruled out not voting or voting for a third party candidate. Meanwhile, Trump was surrounding himself with good people who would help him grow as a baby Christian. He would get better and better. A solid round of applause greeted the end of opening remarks.

Then Dr. Baine tried to argue that the situation wasn’t quite as black and white as Dr. Todley had made it out to be. He claimed that Democratic values aligned pretty closely with Jesus’ values. For example, he claimed Democrats do more to help the poor and the marginalized, while Republicans tend to give the rich massive tax breaks. He argued that abortion had decreased more under Democratic presidents than Republican ones because Democrats address the root causes that lead women to get abortions in the first place. He concluded that Trump had a hateful spirit and a lawless attitude that was dangerous for democracy. The response was significantly less enthusiastic.

Todd proceeded with his three questions. Given Clinton’s stance on partial birth abortion, how could a Christian vote for her? Given recent revelations about Trump and grabbing women, how could a Christian vote for him? Finally, which candidate was more likely to “make America great again”? ...

Saturday, January 15, 2022

Hebrews 1:5-14 Explanatory Notes

Hebrews 1:1-4 (video/podcast)
_____________
1:5 For to which of the angels at some time has he said, "You are my Son; I today have given you birth?"
    And again, "I myself will be to him as Father, and he himself will be to me as Son."
    6. And again, when he leads the firstborn into the ordered world he says, "And let all the angels of God worship him."

1. This will not be the only time that the author strings three Scripture quotations together in the pattern of
    1) quote
    2) and again quote
    3) and again quote.
We see it again in 2:12-13. This pattern suggests that these three quotes all go together.

The theme that links the three quotes is that of Sonship. Hebrews 1:4 ended by mentioning the name that Jesus has inherited, a name that is greater than the angels. While it is tempting to identify this name as "Yahweh" or "Lord," [1] the train of thought pushes us to see the name--or perhaps more precisely, the office--as that of Son. The office or title that Jesus inherits is that of "Son of God."

"Son of God" is a royal title. It is the title of a king. Psalm 2 itself was an enthronement psalm, likely read at the coronation of a king of Judah. The king was "begotten" on the day of his enthronement as the son of God (Ps. 2:7). The author of Hebrews seems to know this fact, and this understanding of the Messiah's birthing seems also attested in the Dead Sea Scrolls. [2]

Hebrews is not making a comment in relation to Jesus' eternal Sonship, although this statement in no way precludes it. That just simply is not what Hebrews is talking about. [3] Hebrews is making a statement about Jesus' exaltation and enthronement to God's right hand. In fact this entire chain of quotations (called a catena) is a celebration of Jesus' enthronement as cosmic king. This timing is clear from the previous two verses (1:3-4) which talk about the inheriting of the title Son after making a cleansing for sins and sitting at the hand of Majesty in the heights.

The second quote (2 Sam. 7:14) even more clearly refers to the human king Solomon. In conversation with David, God indicates that Solomon will be the son of God. This sense of the human king as God's "son," God's representative and family on earth, was common in the Ancient Near East, and the author of Hebrews seems to be aware of this understanding.

2. We better understand Hebrews 1:6 when we see it as the third quote in this series. In isolation, it is not entirely clear what entrance it has in mind. There are at least three possibilities.

Given our knowledge of the Gospel of Luke, it is natural for us to think of the angels singing in Luke 2 at Jesus' birth. Jesus comes into the world, and the angels worship him. It is thus quite possible that we are again introducing foreign elements into Hebrews from elsewhere. In many datings of Hebrews and Luke, it is not likely that the Gospel of Luke was yet written. The author of Hebrews may not even have known that story. 

If we take the word again with "he leads," you might take 1:6 in relation to the second coming. "When God leads his firstborn again into the world..." This is tempting because the verse in question from Deuteronomy 32:43 is in the context of God vindicating his people in judgment against those who hate him. 

In the end, the structure of the three quotes probably tips the scales in favor of the verse referring once again to the exaltation and enthronement of Jesus at God's right hand. We get a picture of the heavenly throne room where God is seated on the throne. Jesus is led into the highest heaven, the truly ordered world, and the servants of God, the angels, bow before their enthroned king.

This picture fits the imagery of Hebrews well. Hebrews has a pervasive dualism between the heaven where God dwells and the created realm of skies and earth. The heavenly Jerusalem is the true Jerusalem (e.g., 12:22). [4] We are destined to be with the angels in the true Mt. Zion in heaven along with other "spirits of the righteous having been perfected" (12:23). This is the coming, "ordered world," that the author is speaking about (2:5), not the earthly one.

3. The wording of the quotation in verse 6 is quite interesting. You will not find this exact wording in any English translation of Deuteronomy 32:43. Perhaps it existed as a variation in manuscripts the author of Hebrews had but that we no longer do. 

The typical Hebrew version we have says, "Praise his people, you nations." The oldest Greek translations we have say instead, "Let all the sons of God worship him." That is much closer to what Hebrews says. It is just the beginning of strong evidence that the author of Hebrews operated out of the Greek translation of the Old Testament and not the Hebrew.

We do find "Let all the angels of God worship him" in a later Christian version of this passage called the Odes. It is just not clear whether it is drawing from the tradition of Hebrews or represents another translation that was already in existence. The bottom line is that the author of Hebrews is either paraphrasing the Greek or quoting a version that no longer exists.

7. And, on the one hand, to the angels he says, "The one who makes his angels spirits and his ministers flames of fire,"

If the first three quotes go together (1:5-6), the second triad of quotes also go together (1:7-12). The structure this time is an "on the one hand" in verse 7 and an "on the other hand" in verse 8. Hebrews 1:8-12 then has two quotes, both of which contrast with what is said about the angels in 1:7.

Hebrews quotes Psalm 104:4, which in the Hebrew says, "making the winds his messengers and flaming fire his ministers." But the Hebrew word for "wind" can also be translated, "spirit." Hebrews flips the sense of the psalm, following the Greek translation. The psalm talks about making winds into messengers. Hebrews talks about making angels ("messengers") into spirits.

There are two main points of contact between what 1:7 says about angels and what 1:8-12 say about Jesus the Son of God. First, the angels are ministers or servants of God. By contrast, Jesus is the Son of God, the king. Second, winds and flames are transitory. They blow on or burn out. By contrast, Jesus' reign is forever and ever.

8. But on the other hand to the Son,

     Your throne, O God, [is] forever and ever 
          and the staff of straightness [is] the rod of your kingdom.
          9. You loved righteousness and hated lawlessness.
     For this reason, God, your God, anointed you,
          oil of rejoicing in the presence of your companions.

The first quote is from Psalm 45:6-7. When a New Testament author like the author of Hebrews quotes something, the meaning of that quote in Hebrews is a function of how Hebrews is using it. So the meaning of these verses in Hebrews may not draw upon every aspect of the quote. Presumably, there were key "points of contact" between the quote and the rhetorical goals of Hebrews. Similarly, the meaning of the quote in Hebrews does not have to equate exactly to its original meaning. [1]

In this case, there seems to be a significant amount of continuity between the two meanings. Psalm 45 is a royal psalm, a psalm for the wedding of a king. So Hebrews 1 focuses on Jesus as the Son of God, the king enthroned at his exaltation to God's right hand. Psalm 45:6 is really quite remarkable, for it calls a human king "God." That it refers to a human king is clear from the bridge and her virgin attendants who follow (45:13-14), as well as the mention of sons (45:16).

The psalm thus does not literally mean that the king is a god, of course. The king is godlike, even God's representative on the earth. The next verse (45:7) goes on to distinguish between the king as "God" and the king's God, who is the literal God. Calling the king "God" in the psalm is thus like calling the king "Son of God."

We see most clearly what the author of Hebrews had in mind when we compare this quote with Hebrews 1:7. The two key points of 1:7 are that the angels function as servants and that their role as ministers is temporary. Psalm 45:6-7 show that Jesus is king, not a servant, and his reign is forever, not temporary.

Jesus' throne is forever and ever. They function like winds and flames. Jesus was anointed as Christ, as king, as Son of God from among humanity. They serve humanity as ministers (cf. 1:14).

10. And "You from the beginning, Lord, founded the land,
                and the works of your hands are the skies.
     11. They themselves will perish, but you will remain.
     And all as a garment will become old,
          12. and as a wrap you will roll them.
          As a garment even they will be changed.
     But you [are] the same and your years will not be used up.

The second quote is from Psalm 102:25-27. Amazingly, the author of Hebrews draws on a passage about Yahweh as creator and applies it to Jesus. We remember that 1:2 already says of Jesus that he was the one "through whom God made the worlds." It is hard to know whether the author meant this imagery metaphorically or literally. After Hebrews 1, God the Father is consistently called the creator (2:10; 3:4; 11:3).

To know the author's primary point in using the quotation, we turn again to 1:7, which contrasts with both quotations. On the one hand, the angels are ministers. Jesus is not only the Son of God, but here is "Lord." The Hebrew behind the word Lord here is Yahweh. Although the author of Hebrews functioned out of the Greek translation of the Old Testament, it is quite possible he is equating Jesus with Yahweh.

Richard Bauckham at this point has made a strange suggestion, namely, that Jesus inherits the name Yahweh at his resurrection. According to Bauckham, Jesus was always Son of God, but he inherits the name Yahweh at this point. We would probably dismiss this suggestion out of hand if it didn't provide a plausible reading of Philippians 2:9-11. There, God gives Jesus the "name above all names" at his exaltation after death. Yahweh is very plausibly the highest name.

Whatever Hebrews precisely had in mind, it is clear that this is an office and identity far higher than that of the angels, who are "ministering spirits" (1:14).

Similarly, whereas the role of the angels is temporary and transitory, like the creation, Jesus' role will continue forever. They are like winds and flames. They are like the skies and the land that will eventually grow old and be wrapped up like a garment.

The quote is parallel to what the author will say in 12:26-27, where God "shakes" and "removes" the skies and the earth. This shaking is part of the soon-coming judgment of the world. So the current configuration of the created realm is about to be "rolled up," just as the role of the angels as ministering spirits to humanity is about to end (see Hebrews 2). 

Meanwhile, Jesus remains forever. His years will not come to an end. 

The imagery of the changing of a garment may imply that Hebrews looks for a new creation with new skies and a new earth. 12:26-27 are quite stark in their removal language, but it would be unprecedented for Hebrews to see a complete and final removal.

13. But to which of the angels has he said at some time, "Sit on my right [hand] until I should put your enemies as a footstool for your feet"?

This verse forms what is called an "inclusio" with 1:5. The framing of the quote is very similar, "to which of the angels has he said at some time." An inclusio serves like bookends, indicating that the material between the two bookends goes together. 

Psalm 110:1 is actually quoted here. It was alluded to in 1:4, but here the author brings it fully into the open. The centrality of this verse for Hebrews is so great, that George Buchanan once suggested Hebrews might be a sermon on the verse. It is a verse about the exalted Jesus. Yahweh tells his Messiah that he is enthroning him.

The entire catena or chain of quotes thus reiterates over and over that Jesus is king, that God has put him in a position much higher than that of the angels. 

14. Are they not all ministering spirits sent for ministry because of those about to inherit salvation? 

The celebration of Hebrews 1 ends with a clear statement of the role of angels in salvation history. They are "ministering spirits." They are not kings. They will not rule. They are servants. By contrast, Jesus is king. Jesus is Son of God. Jesus is Lord. Jesus will reign forever and ever.

In chapter 2, we will learn that humanity was intended to rule the creation, but they have not fulfilled this role because of sin. The angels serve as ministers to them as they await salvation. And Jesus became one of them to solve their problem. But now Jesus is greater than the angels again (1:4). Soon, their role as ministering spirits to humanity will end because humanity will rule with Christ as brothers and coheirs. 

[1] So Richard Bauckham

[2] 4QFlorilegium

[3] J. B. Lightfoot and others are thus introducing foreign elements to the text's arguments when they read these verses in the light of later Christological debates.

[4] See also 11:10, 16; 13:14.

Deconstruction 5.2 -- lead up to the debate

I continue to work on this novel as a discipline on the weekends.

___________________

The climax of the election frenzy on campus in the fall of 2016 happened the week after the “grab them by the p* video” surfaced. That came out on a Thursday, October 6. The history professor, Dr. Todley, was worried that the students might not vote for Trump after the video. For him, a Christian could only vote for the Republican. There was never any other choice in a presidential election.

He was from Indiana. He wasn’t quite as much a Yankee as someone from New York, but there were definitely times you could tell he was an outsider. The South was a little more complicated on the “you can’t vote for a Democrat” line. Most of our grandparents and before had been staunch Democrats. Now our parents were Republicans.

The big change came after the whole desegregation mess of the 60s and 70s. President LBJ may have been a Democrat, but our grandparents thought he was a traitor. In the Reagan years, some of those old-time Democrats started to change parties.

I’ve decided that people come up with all sorts of different reasons for why they vote the way they do. Most of them aren’t the real reason. Although he was a smart man, Dr. Todley would always find a reason to vote for a Republican. Even down-ballot, where abortion wasn’t at stake, he would find a reason to conclude the Republican superior.

Several of us took his US History class that spring. In a moment of weakness, he admitted that he had only ever voted for a Democrat once for county council. The candidate was one of his neighbors. But he went on to regret it.

I had an interesting conversation with my grandfather about Trump. In the same conversation, he both ripped on Reagan as an awful president and then gave his unbridled praise for Trump. Wow, I thought to myself. I’m looking at an archaeological dig here. I’m seeing the Democrat layer that was still in place in the 80s and the Republican layer of the 2000s. Each corresponded to a different wife.

So Dr. Todley was right to worry that some professors and students might vote for Clinton. They might be Republican of late, but there was a deeper history of voting Democrat in their families hiding in there too.

For an opponent, it was hard to find a professor on campus who would admit they planned to vote for Hillary. The biology professor, Dr. Baine, finally agreed because he felt there needed to be a counterbalance. He had already admitted to our table that he was voting for Clinton. So Matt was quick to call him a liar when he said he hadn’t decided who to vote for yet. The position he took in the debate was that a Christian couldn’t in good conscience vote for Trump. The only real Christian choice, he argued, was to vote for a third party candidate, Clinton, or not to vote at all.

Monday, January 10, 2022

Why Campus 6 -- Spreading the Good News

I had not put up a link here to my final post in the series, Why Campus? I thought I'd do that so that anyone would have easy access to all seven posts in the series. Here they are in one place:



Preface: The Future of Modality in Higher Education

Why Campus?

1. Expanded markets

2. Enriched curricula

3. Enhanced courses

4. Quantum leaps

5. Softer landings

6. Spreading the good news

Sunday, January 09, 2022

Book Review: Designing for Growth

Designing for Growth: A Design Thinking Tool Kit for Managers

I started this book in December. Just finished it this week. It is an introduction to design thinking. It was straightforward. It was simple to understand. I'll confess I found the book very boring. It may not have helped that I tried to cover a lot of it as an audiobook while driving to and from Chicago.

Design thinking is basically a way to operationalize creativity. The book's basic thesis is that managers often don't feel like they are particularly creative or innovative, even though they need to be. Similarly, designers are often far more creative than they are organized. This book is meant to create a Reese's Peanut Butter cup that mixes the peanut butter of the manager with the chocolate of the designer.

It is very useful. The four basic steps are:

1. What is? -- Where are you currently in your organization?

2. What if? -- This is a phase of focused brainstorming.

3. What wows? -- This phase involves actually prototyping and talking to potential customers for input.

4. What works? -- Going beyond prototyping, you do a learning launch with a small sample.'

That all makes sense. The ten steps that the four questions expand out into are:

1. Visualization -- necessary throughout

What is?

A four-step project management sequence is interspersed with these four questions. The first project management step is to have a "Design Brief" that clarifies what problem you are trying to solve and sets kicks off the designing process.

2. Journey mapping -- looking at things from the customer side

3. Value Chain mapping -- looking at things from the organizational side

4. Mind mapping -- Get a group together to find patterns in those mappings. This is a crucial step to determine where you currently are as an organization.

What if? 

The project management tool emerging from the first question is Design Criteria. Hopefully, you now have insight into where your organization is. What are the perceptions of your organization? What is the ideal end state of the process for your organization?

5. Brainstorming -- Giving clearly defined parameters, begin to generate ideas that address anecdotes and stories depicting the problems you are trying to solve. Keep iterating by asking probing questions that question your assumptions, explore the extremes, look back from the future, etc.

6. Concept Development -- Now choose the best ideas that emerged out of the brainstorming process. Combine them. Mix and match them. Look for that spark of creativity.

What wows?

You kick off pursuit of the third question with a "Napkin Pitch." What does the customer want? What assets does your organization have to give? How will the customer benefit? What is the competition?

7.  Assumption Testing -- Begin to plan out how you are going to test the assumptions with which you have emerged from concept development. Will your new concept pass basic business tests like 1) will customers buy it, 2) can you create and deliver it, 3) can you scale it, and 4) how easily can competitors copy you?

8. Rapid Prototyping -- Fake creating the new service or entity. Run it by a very small number of people for feedback. "Fail fast to succeed sooner."

What now?

You launch the final stage with "The Learning Guide." How are you going to test the direction in which you are heading? How much is it going to cost? What remaining assumptions do you need to test?

9. Customer Co-Creation -- Bring some potential customers in and get their input. 

10. Learning Launch -- Now build a more realistic version of your product or service and try it out on a small sample with a small team working on it. A couple months, maybe 100 people. Don't spend too much but spend enough to know whether you're really on to something.
 

Sermon Starters: God-Given Resolutions

Brookside Wesleyan Church, Wellsville, NY
January 2, 2022

Text: Micah 6:6-8

Prayer

Intro: New Year's Resolutions

  • Did you make any? Have you already broken any? The person who resolved to get to start getting to work on time and overslept the first day.
  • 27% break their resolutions by the first week of January.
  • Most exercise resolutions are through by January 12.
  • 41% don't last more than a month
  • Over half have stopped by six months.
  • 80% of resolutions fail by end of year.
  • What if we let the Lord make our new year's resolutions? What would he set for us?

1. God wants us to do justice. (mishpat)

  • Harry Potter 5, getting expelled from Hogwarts... "Justice"
  • We don't always agree about what justice would be -- e.g., discussions about whether certain people should be acquitted or not?
  • What is justice like for God in the prophets?
  • In Micah 6:11 -- "wicked scales" -- people who cheat other people out of greed
  • In Micah 3:1 -- abuse of power by leaders, those who take bribes and thus favor the rich and powerful
  • Captain America -- "I don't want to kill anyone. I just don't like bullies."
  • Chickens in the yard -- We have too many roosters. Our head rooster takes care of the hens.
  • Zechariah 7:9-10 -- "Thus says the LORD of hosts, Render true judgments, show kindness and mercy each to his brother do not oppress the widow, the fatherless, the sojourner, or the poor; and let none of you devise evil against his brother in your heart."
  • That's what biblical justice looks like.

2. God wants us to love mercy. (hesed)

  • Hesed is perhaps the richest of all Hebrew words. It is one of the most frequent descriptions of God's nature in the Old Testament. 
  • Jonah 4:2 -- "Isn’t this what I said, Lord, when I was still at home? That is what I tried to forestall by fleeing to Tarshish. I knew that you are a gracious and compassionate God, slow to anger and abounding in love, a God who relents from sending calamity."
  • The story of Jonah and Nineveh -- his actions and attitudes are the opposite of hesed. God wants to see Nineveh restored, even though he knows the path they are on.  

3. God wants us to walk humbly with him as our God.

  • Pride in the Bible is putting ourselves in the place of authority that belongs to God.
  • "The nail that sticks up is the first to get hit."
  • Putting ourselves in the driver's seat -- planning to build bigger barns.
  • Illustration -- "Easier to ask forgiveness than to ask permission."
  • Did you consult God on that project of yours?
  • We are free to be servants of God.
Conclusion

  • God's resolutions have more teeth than yours and mine -- we can't just throw them away when we miss a day.
  • But that's not the way to think about them. God's resolutions are for our good. God's resolutions are about shaping us, not grading us.

Saturday, January 08, 2022

Deconstruction Novel excerpt from chapter 5

For the previous post, see here. Each weekend I am writing on a novel about some students at a Christian college from 2016-2020 and the current phenomenon being called faith deconstruction.

_________________________________ 

... For Matt, the Supreme Court ruling on gay marriage was one of the worst moments in American history. “Obama has brought so much judgment on America because of his sin,” he said once.

“But he isn’t even on the Supreme Court,” April responded in frustration.

“Doesn’t matter,” he continued. “He supported it. We’ve got to elect Republicans as president so we can stop these activist judges and reverse Roe v. Wade and Obergefell. There’s just no other choice. You can’t be a Christian and vote for a Democrat.”

April looked at him in disbelief. Her parents had always voted for the Democratic candidate for as long as she could remember. Her dad was a Methodist pastor.

Brad represented the fourth type of student. They agreed with April and Jessica that Trump was a deeply immoral man. But they believed Hillary was worse. More than anything, they were worried about her stance on abortion. That issue more than any other would keep them from ever voting for a Democrat in a presidential election.

As he put it, Brad would “hold his nose" and vote for Trump. There were some professors who seemed like that. Most of the ones in that category either didn’t vote at all or voted for the Libertarian or Green candidate. April believed that this group of Christians cost Clinton the election.

I didn’t know who to vote for. I listened intently to the lunch debates of my friends. They didn’t really even notice that I was there most of the time.

Once, out of the blue, Jessica blurted across the table, “Hey, David, who are you voting for?” I was startled that I would be put on the spot like that, but glad that she knew my name.

“I don’t know yet,” I quietly answered a few seconds later. But by then their argument had continued...

Friday, January 07, 2022

University Chemistry II for stable geniuses

I mentioned in my review of last year that I had taken Calculus II for Engineers this past fall with ASU online. I was scheduled to take physics and chem 2 this spring (psycho), but yesterday I hesitantly decided it just wasn't a good use of my resources right now. (I actually CLEPed out of Chem I last summer trying to get into the Chem 2 class. They wouldn't count my AP from high school or my chemistry from SWU in the 80s. I get it.)

Some may know that for over a decade I have slowly been putting physics, calculus, and chemistry videos on YouTube. I thought, why don't I go ahead and put up the equivalent of that Chemistry II course on YouTube this spring. But instead of the crazy 7.5 week courses that ASU does (mega-psycho), why not pretend it's a 16-week online class?

So here's a possible schedule for videos this spring. Without the pressure of a grade hanging over my head, we'll see what happens. But I'll try to pretend at least a little. Let's try to cover eight chapters in Brown, LeMay, Bursten, and Murphy's Chemistry: The Central Science.

As usual, we'll see. I have a day job.

Module 1: Chemical Kinetics (chapter 14)

Week 1: Videos on reaction rates, the rate law, and the change of concentration with time (14.1-4)

Week 2: Temperature and rate, reaction mechanisms, and catalysts (14.5-7) 

Module 2: Chemical Equilibria (chapter 15)

Week 1: equilibrium and the equilibrium constant, heterogeneous equilibria (15.1-4)

Week 2: calculations and applications of equilibrium constants, Le Chatelier's Principle (15.5-7)

Module 3: Acid-Base Equilibria (chapter 16)

Week 1: types of acids-bases, ionization of water, pH  (16.1-5)

Week 2: weak acids and bases, constants, chemical structure (16.6-11)

Module 4: Aqueous Equilibrium Continued (chapter 17)

Week 1: common ion effect, titrations, solubility equilibria (17.1-3)

Week 2: precipitation, qualitative analysis for metals (17.4-7)

Module 5: Chemical Thermodynamics (chapter 19)

Week 1: spontaneous processes, entropy (19.1-3)

Week 2: Gibbs Free Energy, Energy and Temperature/Equilibrium Constant (19.4-7)

Module 6: Electrochemistry (chapter 20)

Week 1: redox reactions, voltaic cells, EMF (20.1-4) 

Week 2: batteries, corrosion, electrolysis (20.5-9)

Module 7: Nuclear Chemistry (chapter 21)

Week 1: radioactivity, nuclear transmutations and decay (21.1-4)

Week 2: nuclear reactions and power (21.5-9)

Module 8: Coordination Compounds (chapter 24)

Week 1: complexes, ligands, nomenclature (24.1-3)

Week 2: isomerism, crystal-field theory (24.4-6)