I'm tidying up my Acts notes to try to finish the Acts book this weekend. Here are my transformed notes on Simon the sorcerer:
"... The incident with Simon the sorcerer is interesting. Although he is not an opponent to Christianity in Acts, history would remember him as the beginning of all false Christian teaching, what is called, “heresy.”
"Simon must surely have been someone well known. Luke seems to want his audience to know that Simon had been out-miracled and outclassed by Philip. Simon was not quite a believer, the archetype of the stereotypical televangelist who is more interested in putting on a show and making money than truly following Christ.
"It is a sobering thought, to think of how close he came to believing and then apparently how bad an influence on faith he later seems to have had. We cannot absolutely control the spiritual destinies of others, because God in the end gives us all the choice. But it is staggering to think of the influence we can have on people’s destinies and how careful we should be.
"Think of all the children who have passed through our churches or that pass through schools where Christians teach. How sobering it is later in life to look back and realize how those little guys and gals we had under our teaching for a short moment went on into life. Some go on to be great. Some go on to live lives of ruin. Many go on to live faithful, Christian lives.
"But how sobering it is to think of the responsibility! Our words, our actions can sow seeds that blossom into faith. They can also sow seeds of discontent and discord. God gives them the ultimate choice, and God can work around us when we mess up. But it is important to take seriously the task of discipleship that we all play in the lives of others..."
Showing posts with label discipleship. Show all posts
Showing posts with label discipleship. Show all posts
Friday, November 01, 2013
Wednesday, August 10, 2011
OT Mentoring Relationships
I wrote this in relation to a Bible assignment for the "Congregational Spiritual Formation" course. I thought I would share the lead up to the assignment.
______________
In this assignment, we are asking you to look at a “one to one relationship” in an Old Testament narrative that, to us, looks something like what we would call a mentoring relationship. These are relationships in which an individual who is expected to have greater insight or experience leads another individual to grow or mature, particularly in relation to tasks they go on to perform.
By this time in the curriculum, most of you have either taken the “Bible as Christian Scripture” class or have received credit for it in lieu of work you have done elsewhere or in your undergraduate training. Accordingly, when you look at an assignment like this one, you hopefully recognize several important considerations. One is the fact that “mentoring” will not look the same from culture to culture, indeed from sub-culture to sub-culture. The way a person like Elijah related to Elisha or the way Elisha related to Gehazi was a function of the way people almost 2800 years ago related to each other in a particular ancient near eastern setting. We cannot at all be sure that their way of relating to each other is an appropriate model for us to emulate today in our contexts.
Another consideration is the fundamental principle that “description is not prescription.” Judas went out and hanged himself in the biblical narrative. Are we to go and do likewise? In the Bible as Scripture course, we recognized that narratives have an “evaluative point of view” that can help us determine what a narrative meant for its original audience to emulate and what it did not. Sometimes, in fact, the biblical text is just telling us what happened and does not have any clear point for us to take away at all. [1]
When a narrative points to a clear model to follow, we then have to locate it within the “whole council of God.” Here we refer especially to the progress of understanding (the “flow of revelation”) as the Old Testament understanding of many things is not complete without the New Testament. Even in the New Testament, we often have to figure out how the material in one part relates to material in other parts, almost always with the help of Christian reflection on the biblical texts throughout the centuries. Does God incite David to take a census (2 Sam. 24:1) or was it the Satan (1 Chron. 21:1)? Some biblical narratives have a more precise and complete picture of God than others.
Finally, we at least have to recognize the sense of many experts that ancient narratives were often more interested in making a point than with recording precise history in the modern sense. Most of us take the biblical narratives fairly straightforwardly as a record of exactly what happened. It is at least worthwhile for us to be aware of how various scholarly theories might affect the way we read certain biblical narratives.
For example, is Abraham an example of not learning his lesson when he lies to Abimelech about Sarah being his wife (Gen. 20), when he had already done the same thing with Pharaoh before (Gen. 12:10-20)? Or are these two versions of the same oral tradition (along with Gen. 26:6-11)? Some scholars think that these two stories come from different sources behind Genesis (one of which used Elohim for God and the other of which used Yahweh for God--notice that each of these stories uses one or the other, not both). We are free to disagree. What is important is to realize that some of the points we see in the biblical narratives may result as much from the way the story looks to us as from their intended meaning.
This assignment is thus about opening ourselves up to the Spirit to hear insights about mentoring by reflecting on certain Old Testament narratives. You are welcome to find the evaluative point of view of the narrative in question, to locate the text in the flow of revelation, to consider possible considerations of source and oral tradition, and to take into account possible differences in culture between our time and the time of the narrative before then drawing conclusions (the Foundations professor will no doubt reward you for such sophistication). You are also welcome to hear the Spirit speak to you through the story as it stands and as you see it, recognizing that God regularly brings wisdom through encountering Scripture, even when that wisdom is not what the text actually meant.
[1] Gordon Fee and Douglas Stuart (2003) put it this way: “Narratives record what happened—not necessarily what should have happened or what ought to happen every time. Therefore, not every narrative has an individual identifiable moral of the story” (84). While we can question whether recording what happened was the primary focus of ancient narrative, their point is certainly a significant element in the equation.
Works Cited
Gordon Fee and Douglas Stuart. (2003). How to Read the Bible for All Its Worth.3rd ed. Grand Rapids: Zondervan.
______________
In this assignment, we are asking you to look at a “one to one relationship” in an Old Testament narrative that, to us, looks something like what we would call a mentoring relationship. These are relationships in which an individual who is expected to have greater insight or experience leads another individual to grow or mature, particularly in relation to tasks they go on to perform.
By this time in the curriculum, most of you have either taken the “Bible as Christian Scripture” class or have received credit for it in lieu of work you have done elsewhere or in your undergraduate training. Accordingly, when you look at an assignment like this one, you hopefully recognize several important considerations. One is the fact that “mentoring” will not look the same from culture to culture, indeed from sub-culture to sub-culture. The way a person like Elijah related to Elisha or the way Elisha related to Gehazi was a function of the way people almost 2800 years ago related to each other in a particular ancient near eastern setting. We cannot at all be sure that their way of relating to each other is an appropriate model for us to emulate today in our contexts.
Another consideration is the fundamental principle that “description is not prescription.” Judas went out and hanged himself in the biblical narrative. Are we to go and do likewise? In the Bible as Scripture course, we recognized that narratives have an “evaluative point of view” that can help us determine what a narrative meant for its original audience to emulate and what it did not. Sometimes, in fact, the biblical text is just telling us what happened and does not have any clear point for us to take away at all. [1]
When a narrative points to a clear model to follow, we then have to locate it within the “whole council of God.” Here we refer especially to the progress of understanding (the “flow of revelation”) as the Old Testament understanding of many things is not complete without the New Testament. Even in the New Testament, we often have to figure out how the material in one part relates to material in other parts, almost always with the help of Christian reflection on the biblical texts throughout the centuries. Does God incite David to take a census (2 Sam. 24:1) or was it the Satan (1 Chron. 21:1)? Some biblical narratives have a more precise and complete picture of God than others.
Finally, we at least have to recognize the sense of many experts that ancient narratives were often more interested in making a point than with recording precise history in the modern sense. Most of us take the biblical narratives fairly straightforwardly as a record of exactly what happened. It is at least worthwhile for us to be aware of how various scholarly theories might affect the way we read certain biblical narratives.
For example, is Abraham an example of not learning his lesson when he lies to Abimelech about Sarah being his wife (Gen. 20), when he had already done the same thing with Pharaoh before (Gen. 12:10-20)? Or are these two versions of the same oral tradition (along with Gen. 26:6-11)? Some scholars think that these two stories come from different sources behind Genesis (one of which used Elohim for God and the other of which used Yahweh for God--notice that each of these stories uses one or the other, not both). We are free to disagree. What is important is to realize that some of the points we see in the biblical narratives may result as much from the way the story looks to us as from their intended meaning.
This assignment is thus about opening ourselves up to the Spirit to hear insights about mentoring by reflecting on certain Old Testament narratives. You are welcome to find the evaluative point of view of the narrative in question, to locate the text in the flow of revelation, to consider possible considerations of source and oral tradition, and to take into account possible differences in culture between our time and the time of the narrative before then drawing conclusions (the Foundations professor will no doubt reward you for such sophistication). You are also welcome to hear the Spirit speak to you through the story as it stands and as you see it, recognizing that God regularly brings wisdom through encountering Scripture, even when that wisdom is not what the text actually meant.
[1] Gordon Fee and Douglas Stuart (2003) put it this way: “Narratives record what happened—not necessarily what should have happened or what ought to happen every time. Therefore, not every narrative has an individual identifiable moral of the story” (84). While we can question whether recording what happened was the primary focus of ancient narrative, their point is certainly a significant element in the equation.
Works Cited
Gordon Fee and Douglas Stuart. (2003). How to Read the Bible for All Its Worth.3rd ed. Grand Rapids: Zondervan.
Tuesday, February 08, 2011
Me to You
Steve Deneff and David Drury have written a book called Soul Shift. For some reason it does not seem to be available at Amazon but you can get it from the Wesleyan Publishing House site. This book and the sermon series of which it is a part, in my estimation, is aimed to help us as a congregation mature, as a tool of discipleship. I have deeply admired the way in which College Wesleyan Church has provided concrete ways to work out our convictions on things like service and small groups. My sense is that most churches know we should do these things but don't have a clue how to do it (I think of some of my past sermons).
The first "shift" chapter is about moving from "Me to You," and I had some reflections on it. We are so impenetrable as humans. Others can see the areas where we need to grow, but it is often very difficult for us to see them. So those of us who grew up in the church may think, "I already think about how to help others." And those of us who have had bad self-images in the past think, "It is important to have boundaries and a healthy sense of who you are."
Then I come back to one fundamental aspect of virtue, in my opinion. Virtue is not about the things that come easy to you, but the things that come hard for you. So growing in the area of "me to you" is not a measure of how much you think of others "by nature." Virtue in this area is giving to others in those areas where you don't want to give of yourself, when it is hard.
Maybe it is your personality to think of helping others. Maybe it is your personality to let others go first. But is there an area where you cling on to what is yours and could rightly think more of others? That is an area of potential growth in "me to you."
The first "shift" chapter is about moving from "Me to You," and I had some reflections on it. We are so impenetrable as humans. Others can see the areas where we need to grow, but it is often very difficult for us to see them. So those of us who grew up in the church may think, "I already think about how to help others." And those of us who have had bad self-images in the past think, "It is important to have boundaries and a healthy sense of who you are."
Then I come back to one fundamental aspect of virtue, in my opinion. Virtue is not about the things that come easy to you, but the things that come hard for you. So growing in the area of "me to you" is not a measure of how much you think of others "by nature." Virtue in this area is giving to others in those areas where you don't want to give of yourself, when it is hard.
Maybe it is your personality to think of helping others. Maybe it is your personality to let others go first. But is there an area where you cling on to what is yours and could rightly think more of others? That is an area of potential growth in "me to you."
Wednesday, January 17, 2007
Disciple versus Christian
I'm a little sorry these posts have been coming almost one a day these last few days... I just seem to have had a lot of thoughts.
Our pastor always has thought provoking sermons. One of the distinctions he played with a little bit Sunday was the distinction between being a disciple of Jesus and being a Christian. This distinction is of course putty in the hands of the Barna crowd I suspect, but I don't think Steve was barking up that tree.
One of his comments was that the disciples were disciples a long time before Acts calls them Christians. He posed the question whether we tend to have the order the wrong way around. We talk about becoming a Christian and then only later about discipleship.
I also note that, in addition to the Barna follower of Jesus who doesn't buy into religion is the person who is a Yoder follower of Jesus. This is the pacifist, turn the other cheek follower. Such a person isn't necessarily unorthodox, but clearly places a certain primacy on the earthly ethics of Jesus and may not consider Paul or the other parts of the NT quite as significant.
Well, a whole bunch of thoughts are swirling around my head. I'll just stream them down here and anyone is welcome to pick any one up:
1. To what extent should we think of Jesus' earthly mission as a very specific mission to upper Galilee?
I think Marshall overdoes this in Beyond the Bible but I think there is a valid point in it too. The earthly Jesus tells us he was not omniscient on earth. He clearly targets Jews not Gentiles and "lost sheep," Galilean Jews at that. He mostly functions within the paradigms of ancient Israel rather than proclaiming an "all time" universal message. What this means is that we should not assume that the message of the earthly Jesus was meant to be "transcultural" (I don't like that word) or timeless in every respect. An aweful lot of his earthly teaching was likely addressed at a specific time and place in Galilee.
2. There is an important distinction to be made between the particulars of what Jesus preached in Galilee and the presentation of Jesus in the gospels. I am not arguing for a strong discontinuity between the two. But, in my strong opinion, the gospels were not written primarily to record for posterity the earthly life and ministry of Jesus. The gospels were written to proclaim the good news of the kingdom of God to their own audiences decades later than Jesus. In that sense I would argue that the gospels have the same authority as Paul's writings, not more or less. They are the inspired work of New Testament theologians just like Paul's writings.
3. Something very significant takes place at Pentecost that could not have taken place until after the resurrection. Because the Holy Spirit would not come until after Jesus' ascension, we are comparing apples and oranges to some extent when we place before and after Pentecost on some sort of timeline we would compare to the timelines of our lives.
This is one of the hermeneutical problems with the earlier generation of Wesleyans who saw in the disciples' pilgrimage a model for the ordo salutis of our lives today through entire sanctification. The coming of the Spirit at Pentecost was a unique event in salvation history, the transition from one age to another. We are all born after Pentecost and we all become Christians (or disciples) after Pentecost in the age of the new covenant. Technically, there could not have been any true "Christians" before Pentecost, for you cannot be a Christian without the Spirit (Rom. 8:9) and the Spirit had not yet come.
But none of this is really what Pastor Steve was talking about--I'm just doing a stream of consciousness with some thoughts he inspired. Steve was posing a legitimate question: do we need to follow Jesus for more than 10 seconds before we can realistically expect to find him, to encounter him? That's what he will be exploring for the next few weeks.
Our pastor always has thought provoking sermons. One of the distinctions he played with a little bit Sunday was the distinction between being a disciple of Jesus and being a Christian. This distinction is of course putty in the hands of the Barna crowd I suspect, but I don't think Steve was barking up that tree.
One of his comments was that the disciples were disciples a long time before Acts calls them Christians. He posed the question whether we tend to have the order the wrong way around. We talk about becoming a Christian and then only later about discipleship.
I also note that, in addition to the Barna follower of Jesus who doesn't buy into religion is the person who is a Yoder follower of Jesus. This is the pacifist, turn the other cheek follower. Such a person isn't necessarily unorthodox, but clearly places a certain primacy on the earthly ethics of Jesus and may not consider Paul or the other parts of the NT quite as significant.
Well, a whole bunch of thoughts are swirling around my head. I'll just stream them down here and anyone is welcome to pick any one up:
1. To what extent should we think of Jesus' earthly mission as a very specific mission to upper Galilee?
I think Marshall overdoes this in Beyond the Bible but I think there is a valid point in it too. The earthly Jesus tells us he was not omniscient on earth. He clearly targets Jews not Gentiles and "lost sheep," Galilean Jews at that. He mostly functions within the paradigms of ancient Israel rather than proclaiming an "all time" universal message. What this means is that we should not assume that the message of the earthly Jesus was meant to be "transcultural" (I don't like that word) or timeless in every respect. An aweful lot of his earthly teaching was likely addressed at a specific time and place in Galilee.
2. There is an important distinction to be made between the particulars of what Jesus preached in Galilee and the presentation of Jesus in the gospels. I am not arguing for a strong discontinuity between the two. But, in my strong opinion, the gospels were not written primarily to record for posterity the earthly life and ministry of Jesus. The gospels were written to proclaim the good news of the kingdom of God to their own audiences decades later than Jesus. In that sense I would argue that the gospels have the same authority as Paul's writings, not more or less. They are the inspired work of New Testament theologians just like Paul's writings.
3. Something very significant takes place at Pentecost that could not have taken place until after the resurrection. Because the Holy Spirit would not come until after Jesus' ascension, we are comparing apples and oranges to some extent when we place before and after Pentecost on some sort of timeline we would compare to the timelines of our lives.
This is one of the hermeneutical problems with the earlier generation of Wesleyans who saw in the disciples' pilgrimage a model for the ordo salutis of our lives today through entire sanctification. The coming of the Spirit at Pentecost was a unique event in salvation history, the transition from one age to another. We are all born after Pentecost and we all become Christians (or disciples) after Pentecost in the age of the new covenant. Technically, there could not have been any true "Christians" before Pentecost, for you cannot be a Christian without the Spirit (Rom. 8:9) and the Spirit had not yet come.
But none of this is really what Pastor Steve was talking about--I'm just doing a stream of consciousness with some thoughts he inspired. Steve was posing a legitimate question: do we need to follow Jesus for more than 10 seconds before we can realistically expect to find him, to encounter him? That's what he will be exploring for the next few weeks.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
