Showing posts with label Stanley Hauerwas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stanley Hauerwas. Show all posts

Saturday, May 19, 2012

Force is the Exception 4

continued from yesterday
____________________
... By contrast, the earthly Jesus modeled for us what it looks like when we are out of power or it is not God's will to use what power we have to bring change to the structures of society. Of course some have argued that Jesus gave us an example for all times and all situations. They argue that Christians should never engage in violence such as war and that a person should never strike another, even in self-defense. [1] God is the one who fights for us. We are not to fight for ourselves. Even then, God's fighting is full of love for all individuals involved.

These voices are important because they are surely more correct than incorrect. The usual responses to them are also well known. "What about Jesus throwing the money-changers out of the temple?" Some have argued that Jesus only used his whip to drive the animals out of the temple court, not the people (John 2:15). [2] As honorable as this interpretation is, it seems based more on wishful thinking than the text itself (Mark 11:15).

It seems that Jesus could get "righteously angry" and act accordingly. And although this was only one occasion in an entire ministry without violence, it showed that force was an option on some level. Non-violence was apparently not an absolute for him, even though it was the default, the standard for the vast majority of cases.

Another response looks to the Old Testament, where God seems to command Joshua to obliterate whole cities entirely, including animals (e.g., Josh. 6:21). We have to be careful when applying texts such as this one, for the Old Testament is not complete in its understanding of God without the New Testament. Even within the Old Testament itself, there are often multiple perspectives to be considered. Nahum with its delight over the destruction of Nineveh must be balanced by Jonah with its concern for Nineveh. Ezra with its commands to divorce foreign wives must be balanced by Malachi's hatred of divorce.

The Christian approach to war that seems to take the whole Bible best into account is sometimes called "just war theory."  It believes that war can be justified from a Christian perspective if four conditions are met. [3] First, the impending damage from an aggressor needs to be "lasting, grave, and certain." Second, every other means of putting the aggression to an end needs to have been ineffective or impractical. Next, the war should be likely to be successful. Finally, the use of force should not result in a greater evil than it solves.

These principles seem to capture the Christian spirit, where the use of force is a course of last resort.  Force is never used to advance one's own territory or ambition. One always tries non-violent means to resolve situations first. The goal of war is not to devastate the enemy but to protect one's own or others.

Can one wage war and not violate love of neighbor and love of enemy?  Certainly one can wage war to protect one's own people.  One can wage war to protect the people of the country you are fighting.  The problem is that the true intentions of a leader arguing for war will not always be clear. We often do not realize our own true intentions. Any reasonable doubt at all argues against the use of force.

Then there is the question of justice. Would a nation attack another in the name of justice, if it were following Christ's example?  If the answer is simply to get back at the other nation, the answer is no.  But such matters are also very complex. You may have heard the old Latin saying, "If you want peace, prepare for war." The idea is that strength is in itself a deterrent from the aggression of others.

Again, we are prone to hide our true intentions and hatefulness behind such honorable sounding sentiments. And few of us will ever be in a position to make such decisions, although we vote for those who do. For example, following just war theory, a Christian would not have supported the American invasion of Iraq.  Not only was imminent danger from Iraq uncertain, it turned out to be non-existent. Even after the war, it remains to be seen whether, in the end, the resultant situation in the Middle East and the world is better than before the war.

Yet many Christians at the time almost considered it unchristian even to have questions about the Iraq War. This is an indication of the extent to which popular Christianity is removed not only from the actual example of Jesus but from Christian understandings that have been accepted since the time Christians had a voice in such matters. It calls us as believers to be much more cautious in our support of American military action in the future.

The case of World War 2 was much clearer. Hitler had shown his aggression in the most obvious of terms. It even astounds the mind for us to realize now what he was doing to Jews and others behind the scenes, things that were not obvious at the time. For nations like Britain, the question was as much one of survival as of winning. Many today even fault England for engaging in dialog too long. The most balanced position would seem to be that there are very rare occasions where Christians might support a war in the spirit of Jesus.

Of much more immediate importance to us as individuals is how we should apply Jesus' ethic to our daily lives...

[1] Some key names in this reading of Jesus include John Howard Yoder, The Politics of Jesus, and Stanley Hauerwas, Resident Aliens.

[2] Yoder, Politics.

[3] This approach is often associated with Augustine in the 400s. The current list is largely taken from the Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 2309.

Monday, November 15, 2010

Stanley Hauerwas on campus (and IWU Religion Coffee Talk 2)

Stanley Hauerwas was on campus today for the undergraduate Fall Religion Colloquium. Here's the link to John Drury's summary of what he had to say.

While I was there, I thought of some more IWU Coffee talk.  The first was that we give each other knowing looks when people use "worldview" language.  It's not that we don't acknowledge presuppositions.  It's the overly cognitive and oversimplified use of them.

The second, mentioned in the first post, is an aversion to Barna's understanding of the church.  We love the local church and think a Christian out in the woods every Sunday worshipping God probably won't remain a Christian very long if s/he doesn't get back into a local assembly of believers.  Stanley Hauerwas put it today even more starkly than I would.  He believes that God mediates salvation through the church.

The third thing, which I remembered in conversation, is that the undergraduate faculty give each other knowing looks when people confuse John Wesley with the Wesleyan Church.  As K. Drury likes to say, Wesley is more our grandfather or even great-grandfather than our father.  Phoebe Palmer is more like our mother or grandmother even.

In short, we like Wesley but don't really care about those who want to correct the Wesleyan Church because it is not enough like John Wesley.  John Wesley didn't found the Wesleyan Church.  There is no need for any more dissertations about John Wesley.

Friday, December 05, 2008

Friday Review: Hauerwas--"The Way the Words Run"

Chapter 1 of the Richard Hays Festschrift: The Word Leaps the Gap. This chapter is by Stanley Hauerwas, "Why 'The Way the Words Run' Matters: Reflections on Becoming a 'Major Biblical Scholar.'" The "major biblical scholar" of the title is none other than Hauerwas himself, who has just published a theological commentary on Matthew in the Baker series.

I've never read Stanley Hauerwas' Unleashing the Scriptures, but I've read enough references to it to know I am at least half sympathetic to Hauerwas' hermeneutic--that is, except that Hauerwas is a far truer postmodern than I am. And as such, he strongly resists laying out any "superdescription" of how his readings work. As a true postmodern, he would like you catch the way he reads Scripture, to apprentice with him and be trained.

Of course he is not really interested in you watching him per se. He wants you to follow Jesus with the biblical text as you read it situated in the church. I offer not a summary, but a response to some interesting quotes from this piece, at least half of which is long footnotes. The essence of the piece is a response to critique Richard Hays offered in his Moral Vision of the New Testament. Hauerwas recognizes that Hays' thought has evolved somewhat in the more recent compilation he coedited with Ellen Davis, namely, The Art of Reading Scripture.

1. "Hays was kind enough to attend to my account of the role of the Bible in theological and ethical reflection" (2). "I use the word 'role' to avoid the word 'use'" (2 n.2).

It is going to hurt for me to suggest that use is way more accurate to what actually takes place in the relationship between Christians and the biblical text. This is way more true of theological hermeneutics than even original meaning interpretation, in my opinion.

2. "fundamentalism and historical criticism are but two sides of the same coin: they are both developments of the Protestant stress on sola scriptura, transformed by the printing press into "sola text." These developments were given ideological formation by democratic social orders that created something called the individual citizen, which presumed the ability to read the Bible without spiritual formation and moral guidance. As a result, the Bible was separated from the community necessary for it to be read as the word of God, that is, the church" (3).

This is Hauerwas' own summary of his earlier book, Unleashing the Scripture. I would agree with the bulk of this statement.

3. In Moral Vision, Hays suggests that Hauerwas' argument should lead him to become a Roman Catholic (4), a question Wieland Willker raised of a post of mine this week.

Hauerwas is not concerned to work out a finely tuned method, of course. He is truly postmodern. This comment is reflective: "Attempts to develop a hermeneutical theory that can resolve such differences in advance are doomed to failure. The church did not develop a theory to resolve conflicting readings; rather, the church was given an office to ensure that one church's readings would be tested by other churches. The name of that office is 'bishop'" (7 n.15).

In my own hermeneutic, it is neither Scripture nor the Church that are the final answer but the Spirit. The consensus of the Church reading Scripture is as sure as any indication of the Spirit's direction we might have. In that sense I reflect the emphasis of my revivalist roots, now balanced with the emphasis of the evangelical (Scripture) and catholic (Church).

I've written it up in popular form in my self-published, Who Decides What the Bible Means?

4. "contemporary preaching too often takes as its task to find 'applications' for the text, when its task should be to lead a congregation away from one narrative world and into another" (6 n.12).

"I avoid using the language of 'interpretation,' because I think such language suggests that the text has a 'meaning,' which must then be interpreted" (7 n.14).

"There is, moreover, no 'original historical sense,' and it is not at all clear why the 'literal sense' should be identified as that which the 'original' authors and readers understood. The very presumption of 'original' needs to be left behind" (6 n.13)

"I remain unconvinced that the so-called historical knowledge is a trump or even is necessary for how the Scripture is to be read by the church" (9).

While I agree with the legitimacy and primacy of Hauerwas' theological reading of Scripture, my main disagreement is his apparent denial of an original meaning for the biblical text. A theological reading without any reference to the original meanings of the Bible will be prone to run away into the celibacy of the clergy and purgatory. In this respect I remain a pietist Protestant--the consensus of the church at any point in time is not definitive or preclusive of reformation. I believe in meta-language, even if it is ultimately itself metaphorical or expressive.

5. "That historical critics will not let the church avoid the bits of Scripture that do not confirm our contemporary sensibilities is also a contribution we dare not ignore. Of course, I do not believe that historical criticism was necessary for the recovery of the significance of Jesus' life or for forcing us to attend to the unpleasant parts of Scripture. It just worked out that way" (12).

:-)

All true truth is God's truth, so our faith is always potentially enriched by any true pursuit of truth for its own sake.

6. Hauerwas refers to several co-conspirators in this movement that is significantly in play in Christian biblical studies. They should be mentioned.

a. Hays himself in the Art of Reading Scripture.
Hauerwas mentions some of the nine key theses of this book: "Scripture has multiple complex senses given by God," "Scripture is rightly understood in light of the church's rule of faith as a coherent dramatic narrative," and "Though the Bible contains the voices of many different witnesses, the canon of Scripture finds its unity in the overarching story of the work of the triune God," seem particularly relevant.

b. The Baker theological commentary series:
"this commentary series is based on the assumption that the Nicene tradition, in all its diversity and controversy, provides the proper basis for the interpretation of the Bible as Christian Scripture" (13).

Again, I affirm the legitimacy and primacy of this way of reading Scripture. I also affirm without reservation that hermeneutically this is a reader-response approach to the text of Scripture in which the words are not read in context and that the contextual, "original" meaning of Scripture will regularly diverge with this manner of reading, often simply being something almost completely different and, indeed, at times directly conflicting with the meaning thus found.

7. "the way the words run" names the way a community has learned to read texts through training..." (15).

"Christians so naturally read scriptural texts as shaping a form of life... moral readings" (15 n.36).

Reminds me of a comment by Keith Drury, something like "the only real function of the Bible in the life of the church is to create a holy people."