Wednesday, April 08, 2015

The disciples arrive back in Galilee.

If the disciples were in a hurry to return to Galilee, perhaps we might conclude that they would have arrived back to Capernaum and other villages near the Sea of Galilee by late Wednesday.

Did they have anticipation? The angel told the women Jesus would appear to us here. Where and when will that be?

History in the College Curriculum

I love history. Even those areas of history that I have no interest in studying become interesting to me if I have just a little taste of them.

My son has an excruciatingly boring world history AP textbook for high school right now. To me, it's a sin for history to be boring. People are just too funny, evil, and their antics too bizarre for history to be boring. It's not noble for me to admit that I started this walk with him with little interest in the history of India, China, Japan, and so forth. But even a taste of their history quickly piques my interest.

1. Why study history?
  • The past provides insights into the present and the future. "Those who do not learn from the mistakes of the past are destined to repeat them." This utilitarian function is the one that promises to sell most people on history. Why study leaders of the past? To avoid their mistakes and imitate as much as possible their successes. Why study military tactics in past wars? To be successful in future wars.
  • We regularly use the past to define ourselves and our values. These tellings are highly perspectivized but are a reminder again that the most powerful use of history is in shaping our sense of the present and our decisions for the future. Whether we like to admit it or not, this is far more how Scripture functions for us than as anything like a window on the past.
  • History is valid as a study in its own right, truth for truth's sake. But this is a minority report, people like me who love the past.
2. So if I were to write this novel series, there would be history in the curriculum. I've already decided that they would learn history in situ, onsite at the places where the history took place. But how would the learning be arranged?

For example, one could arrange all learning by history. Twenty years ago, when IWU came up with its four "180" courses, the idea was that students would study history, literature, art/music, and philosophy from a historical perspective. If you had two of these courses at the same time, you would roughly be studying the philosophy of Greece at about the same time you were studying the art of Greece, the literature of Greece, and the history of Greece.

You could of course teach science and math the same way.

It was a grand idea but didn't really work. For one, students didn't take the four courses at the same time. For another, a course like philosophy is really better taught topically than historically.

3. So I'm thinking out loud here. In my proposed novel, I suspect the history would largely be taught from a utilitarian perspective. However, there are going to be different centers of teaching in the novel, so there's room for different perspectives on history and identity at these different centers.

With an emphasis on Spanish and European languages in the first proposed novel, it makes sense that the first year would cover the history of Europe and the Americas. The later three novels would then engage the history of Asia, Africa, and Australia. There's an implicit teaching of geography here you can see as well.

4. I've always thought there was a certain genius to the way the Seminary course called Cultural Contexts of Ministry had a component where students started with their current church and moved backward in American history. Approached backward, the most relevant aspects of the immediate past for the present are brought extremely clearly into view. Then the further you go back, less relevant pieces of the puzzle are automatically de-emphasized.

Of course there are many lessons to be learned by playing history forward as well.

History, in my opinion, can only really be learned accurately in smaller vignettes. Any attempt to systematize long sweeps of history into simple ideological patterns (and this includes biblical narratives) inevitably skews history from a historical perspective. That doesn't mean these grand narratives don't present truths. They're just not accurate or precise with regard to history itself.

But then again, this is my philosophy of all meaning. Truth is best ascertained in small units that are connected to others by similarity and dissimilarity. I think numskull the myriad Platonic thinkers who want to move in the real world from big generals to subsumed particulars. It works fine for ideological systems. For concrete realia, not so much.

5. So my protagonist will spend three months at Cambridge at the beginning of the novel. Fair enough to overview 1000 years of British history including the key intersections with the US (Revolution, WW1 and 2). Then I think he will go to Bologna, Italy for three months, where he will study Roman and Greek history. Next Paris for three months. Napolean features in the early years of the secret society I have in mind, so Napolean and the French Revolution would play a fair role in those three months.

He would then finish the last three months of the first year in Göttingen, where he will finalize his study of WW1 and 2, as well as a study of the Holy Roman Empire from where Roman history left off. The first novel then would end back in Cambridge.

6. These four locations also feature in the other three proposed novels, so all of the history does not need to be learned in the first novel. (Indeed, it all doesn't need to be learned at all.) Concentric circles is the ticket, circling round the same territory first in large and then adding more details each time...

Tuesday, April 07, 2015

World Languages

Started another novel Friday (that makes over 50 I've started). We'll see how many Fridays keep me writing. I only want to give glimpses, but the idea is a four novel sequence that stretches over the most fantastical college education a nerd destined to be a world leader could dream up. The idea is to dream up an astounding college education that would actually be possible to design and implement in a dream world.

So students in this secret society have to learn operational bits in many languages, but I identify five as key: English, Spanish, Russian, Arabic, and Chinese. Each of the four novels in the series would focus on one of the last four. And some of the action in each novel relates to the regions that speak each language.

If I continue to write on Fridays, you'll learn that the first novel is set heavily in Europe, and Spanish is the language the protagonist learns in the first novel. The society uses Latin as its base language, and there are key settings of learning in Bologna, Paris, and Göttingen, as well as Cambridge. Because of these settings, the protagonist will also learn operational bits of Italian, French, and German in the first novel.

The next snippet on Friday... maybe...

Monday, April 06, 2015

Return to Galilee

Neither Matthew nor Mark tell of any appearances in Jerusalem. But they both predict that the disciples will see Jesus in Galilee.

We can imagine that the disciples headed for Galilee on Monday morning. It was a three day journey. So they would arrive late Wednesday or Thursday.

The easiest route followed the Jordan River north.

Sunday, April 05, 2015

Faith becomes sight!

The two men rushed back from Emmaus to find that Jesus had also appeared to Peter and some of the women. All the disciples but Judas and Thomas were there.

He showed them his hands and feet, so that they wouldn't think he was a ghost. He ate some fish. This was not the appearance of a spirit but the first resurrection body. You could even see his scars from the crucifixion.

After he was gone, they would follow the instructions of the angels and go to Galilee, where they would see Jesus again.

Guest at Dinner

Rumors that Jesus' body could not be found were swirling among the followers of Jesus. Could it be resurrection? What was going on?

In early afternoon, two men were making there way back to a village called Emmaus. Another traveler joins them and hears their questions. He has some ideas they haven't thought of. He mentions Scriptures to them like Isaiah 53 and others that could be taken to mean that the Messiah would die for the sins of his people. Did not Psalm 16 say that God would not let the body of his Messiah decay?

They invited the mysterious man for supper, and as he broke the bread, they immediately recognized who he was!

What's happening?!

Mary Magdalene finally tells Peter. Jesus' body is not in the tomb.


Peter and a follower of Jesus in Jerusalem named John immediately get up and race for the tomb Joseph of Arimathea had originally prepared for himself. Sure enough, Jesus' body is not there.

Peter was puzzled. What has happened here? But John wonders, "Is this resurrection?!"

Mysterious morning...

The women took note of where they had buried Jesus, but they were not able to anoint him for burial because of the Sabbath. They come back first thing Sunday morning at sunrise.

But he is not there. They are confused. They are afraid. They tell no one at first...

Saturday, April 04, 2015

Low in the grave he lay...

I do not believe that any biblical texts properly speak of today except to say that Jesus was in "Paradise" (Luke 23:43). He is not yet "made alive in spirit" (1 Pet. 3:18). He has not yet proclaimed the good news to the dead (1 Pet. 4:6), for the good news has not yet come. The good news comes tomorrow morning, Easter morning.

Today, for us, there is only silence.

Friday, April 03, 2015

Friday Novel

His father's death was unexpected.

By and large, Alan had not taken his brief eighteen years of life very seriously. He barely passed his classes, although not for lack of intelligence. Often he didn't even show up, and he never did anything when he did. Occasionally something would pique his interest, but rarely. He was able to do well enough on the tests to pass without studying, which was the only thing that kept his high school career solvent.

He had a strange relationship with his father, who was a Roman Catholic priest. Very odd, to be the son of a Roman Catholic priest. His father didn't have a church, but worked for the Archbishop of Chicago in some capacity that Alan never quite understood. His mother, with whom he lived, called his father a "glorified gofer"--someone who basically just did whatever they asked him to do.

His father's past before becoming a Jesuit priest was even more ambiguous. His mother had met him in Italy while doing a semester abroad in Florence. He was at the University of Bologna. She had never met anyone like him before. He had been to so many places and knew so many things. In just the year she knew him he had traveled to India and China...







In Darkest Day

Jesus hung on the cross from about nine to three. The Gospels give us seven "words":
  • "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (Mark, Matthew)
  • "Father, forgive them. They do not know what they are doing." (Luke)
  • "Today you will be with me in Paradise." (Luke)
  • "Father, into your hands I commit my spirit." (Luke)
  • "Woman, behold your son. Here is your mother." (John)
  • "I am thirsty." (John)
  • "It is finished." (John)
These words express the emotions of aloneness, compassion, and peace. So we know that when we are forlorn, when we are in despair, when we are alone, we know we have a advocate in heaven you can empathize with us.

When we have lost our family, when we have no place to belong, Christ is full of compassion. He gives us each other as family in the church. When we have lost our way, when we have gone down the wrong path, he is longing to be with us and to see our souls restored.

When we enter the valley of the shadow of death, when we are in a dark night of our souls, Jesus gives us peace. He leads us through to the end, if we will surrender to his hands.

Thursday, April 02, 2015

My Acts books are out!!

I was excited to get my copies of the latest book in my life application series on the New Testament! It's the volume on the book of Acts, along with two devotionals to go with it.


The Early Church: Reaching the World








There are also two devotionals that go with it. So individuals/small groups in a congregation could easily be working through these devotionals while the pastor preached through Acts, using this book as a resource. WPH is also preparing possible sermon notes to go with the devotionals, since I don't have the time. That means, between the two devotionals, about 12 weeks worth of sermons.

This devotional gives six weeks of devotionals (5 days a week) on Acts 1-12:



Devotional on Acts 1-12







And here's the one with six weeks of devotionals on Acts 13-28.



Devotional on Acts 13-28

Giving a good "letting alone"

1. I probably should know where this expression comes from. Maybe one of my broader family members came up with it himself--"Give them a good letting alone." My impression is that it was a shaming act. If someone was doing something they shouldn't be doing, if someone was letting sin rule in their life, you gave them a good letting alone. You avoided them. You didn't go to their house, for example.

I'm guessing it had something to do with passages like 2 Thessalonians 3:14: "Take special note of anyone who does not obey our instruction in this letter. Do not associate with them, in order that they may feel ashamed" (NIV).

It seems like some of the sentiment among some Christians toward being a photographer at or providing pizzas for a gay wedding comes from some similar sentiment. The train of thought seems to go something like this: "If I serve such a person in my business, I am condoning this sin." "As a matter of conviction, I must show my protest to such and such a lifestyle, person, or practice by refusing to conduct business with them."

2. Suffice it to say, I have serious questions about this line of thinking. For example:
  • It shows remnants of clean-unclean thinking that the New Testament more or less abolishes in relation to the world (though not entirely in the church).
  • It does not seem to fit the practices or trajectory of Jesus at all!
  • It does not accomplish the same purpose as shaming in the New Testament world. In fact, it's effect is quite the opposite and spiritually harmful to the person doing the shaming.
a. With regard to the first one, Paul puts this shaming practice into clear perspective in 1 Corinthians 5:9-13. He is not talking about Christian engagement with the world but with sinful license in the church. And he is not picturing today's seeker-sensitive mega-church but a small house church of about 40 or 50.

Paul explicitly expects Christians to have interchange with sexually immoral people like adulterers in the world. Any comments he makes on shaming have to do with a small, tight Christian community.

You thus can't use Paul to argue to deny service in your business to someone you know for a fact is cheating on his or her spouse. Paul never expected the church to try to make the world follow Christian expectations.

b. Jesus of course ate with sinners. The Pharisees of the Gospels criticized him strongly for it. It's helpful from time to time to remind ourselves that the impulse to avoid "unclean people" was the practice of those who opposed Jesus and Paul. It was emphatically not the practice of Jesus or Paul. Indeed, it was the main reason they were hated by some.

c. Ultimately, the purpose of shaming in the New Testament is redemptive. In an honor-shame world, shaming is motivation for someone to change their behavior, to conform to the honor expectation. But it seems that most of the shaming today doesn't serve that sort of a purpose. It has the flavor of a protest rather than an attempt to reclaim. Indeed, in our day and age it probably inculcates the wrong spirit--one of vindictiveness.

3. The bottom line is that I think the "give them a letting alone" approach to sin is just plain bad theology. Sometimes it's well intentioned, no doubt. But it would seem to be another example of the Devil twisting people into doing something evil in the name of good.

Last Supper... for a while

What a somber night, Thursday night, as Passover begins for Jesus at sundown! The darkest day in all history begins as night falls. A final meal before death, before denial, before betrayal. The next meal of this sort with his disciples will be in the kingdom of God, when he returns.
  • Peter is confused. He is willing to fight for Jesus, but isn't prepared for Jesus' willing surrender.
  • Is Judas trying to manipulate God into establishing the kingdom? Surely God won't allow his king to be killed! Surely he will send ten thousand angels to rescue him and will install Jesus as king.
  • Jesus is resolved. He would rather this cup pass from him, but he is submitted to God. He does not run away. He waits, and Judas arrives.

Wednesday, April 01, 2015

Anointed for Burial

Matthew and Mark both mention Jesus being anointed by an anonymous woman two days before Passover, with generic disciples protesting. If we think of Passover beginning on sundown on Thursday, this might have been at sundown on Tuesday. By Jewish reckoning, that's the beginning of Wednesday.

As usual, John is the Gospel that is hard to fit together from a precise historical perspective. There are features of John that show clear blending with this story, such as the oral kernel, "You will always have the poor with you," and other features. But the timing and apparently the location seems different in John. There, it is six days before the Passover and at the home of Mary and Martha, rather than of Simon the Leper.

[It's a reminder that we are looking at the Gospels the wrong way if we view them as video recordings--especially John. We should read them more for the truths and moral lessons we get from the stories than as modern histories.]

Several truths I take from Mark 14:1-11:
  • The worship of Jesus is ultimately even more important than the mission. Not everything about faith is utilitarian. There is a time for beauty. There is a time to stop and praise. God himself is ultimately more important even than saving souls or helping the poor!
  • Jesus is in the home of Simon the leper. Even to the end, he is including people who have been excluded. He is sanctifying the unclean and making it clean.
  • She is symbolically preparing him for burial. Why did he die again? He died to absorb the sins of his people, humanity, the world. He died as the greatest embodiment of God's love for us and God's desire to reconcile the world to himself. He died to defeat the powers of death and hell.

Tuesday, March 31, 2015

What's up with RFRA?

I am truly fascinated at the firestorm over the Religious Freedom Renewal Act. I'm sure Governor Pence had no idea. So many thoughts and questions.

My main question is why it has gone up in flames in Indiana and not in any of the other places where similar laws have passed. This morning I woke up with a hypothesis.

1. I don't think it's so much what the law itself says or actually does. The law presents itself as a law that is "for" religious people. Take Indiana Wesleyan University. Part of our purpose is to form students in a certain Christian way, so it is important to us that faculty broadly embrace the religious values of the university as a matter of their free will.

So we would not hire an atheist to teach here. We do not hate atheists. We have students who are atheists. Our cafeteria feeds atheists, and atheists do not automatically receive parking tickets on campus. We respect atheists as people. It just would contradict our purposes to have them teach courses about God.

So this act purports to protect these religious freedoms. They are not meant to be against people but to allow people with certain convictions to be different. It's about the freedom of religion. If a certain synagogue believes that their building would become unclean if an uncircumcised man enters, then I am okay with them prohibiting uncircumcised men from entering.

2. But I think the reason why this particular law has caused such a furor is the context, the perceived reasons for the law. So, it would be different if there were some religious person who was being oppressed and this law was a response. Instead, this law comes in the context of a state that is on a certain trajectory in relation to issues of same-sex marriage. It's proponents have set up the context of the law in relation to the issue of same-sex marriage.

And there is the reason for the firestorm, I suspect. The law has come in a context that makes it seem against a group of people rather than for a group of people. Perception is reality. I can see clearly that no amount of explanation is going to change the perception on this one. You can re-read the law out loud and explain it till you're blue in the face. The damage seems to be done.

Once again, Pence is left looking like a deer in the headlights.

3. As a sideline, these laws do not usually result in any discrimination of the sort we are hearing about, from what I hear. In case of conflict, anti-discrimination laws generally trump. That's probably Indiana's best bet, to pass a strong anti-discrimination law as a clarification.

As for Christians, the New Testament has done away with the category of clean and unclean, at least in the public sphere. We are strangers and aliens in that land anyway. We need to stop thinking of America as sacred space we need to keep from being defiled.

Every time we waste our energies trying to make broader America behave by our rules, the less we will have any capital left to spend when our churches and institutions actually do need defending.

A Day of Proving

On Tuesday in Mark, Jesus' authority was questioned and his honor was tested:
  • By what authority do you do these things? Jesus responds by asking what authority John the Baptist had. He then tells the Parable of the Tenants.
  • They ask Jesus about paying taxes. Jesus implies they have nothing to do with him.
  • Sadducees try to trick Jesus about resurrection.
  • Someone asks Jesus the greatest commandment.
  • Then Jesus asks a question that stumps them all.
How do these stories relate to us?
  • On one level, they don't. We aren't Jesus. None of us have the level of authority he does. None of us have be as clever as he was in responding to his critics.
  • Then again, God does give spiritual authority and insight to people. On one level, this is a self-authenticating authority. On another, truly spiritual people will recognize it too. Then again, which ones are they?
  • Jesus reminds us that our kingdom is not of this world. We are strangers and aliens here in our earthly countries.
  • Some people like to ask questions to make themselves sound smart. Jesus isn't interested in how clever we are. He's interested in our hearts. He's interested in our love.
  • But Jesus does know what he's doing. He knows the answers to our questions and to countless questions we haven't even thought of.

Monday, March 30, 2015

Temple Cleansing Thought

The Gospels as a whole are not entirely clear on the chronology, but in Mark Jesus seems to cleanse the temple on Monday.

Sanders thought Jesus was symbolically predicting the destruction of the temple, but it is interesting that none of the Gospels directly connect this action with the prediction of its destruction later on (e.g., Matt. 24, Mark 13, Luke 21). This suggests to me that the earliest Christians did not initially see it that way.

But it does seem like Jesus is making some kind of sweeping critique of the way the temple is being run. The temple once again has become a "den of thieves," evoking Jeremiah 7.

Some take-aways from Mark 11:
  • God's house is open for everyone seeking him. ("house of prayer for all nations")
  • Anger in itself is not sin. It's what you do with it.
  • Just because you have the title ("Christian," "pastor") doesn't mean you have the favor.

Sunday, March 29, 2015

Palm Sunday Thought

What were the disciples thinking today? Were they thinking that Jesus was coming to Jerusalem to become the king of Israel? Were they thinking that the kingdom of God was about to erupt in full force?

They were right about the destination, but wrong about the timing. Jesus would reign. He would be king, but not before he had gone through Friday.

Sometimes the path to victory goes through trial, and there is no other way to get there but to walk the difficult path ahead.

Friday, March 27, 2015

A Curriculum and Novel Idea

A well-known President of a nearby university once had an idea for a marketplace where a student might convert life and learning experiences into college credit. This was over a decade ago and it was an idea before its time. We see movement in that direction by places like WGU and Southern New Hampshire, who grant a certain amount of "credit by assessment" or "credit by competency."

I had another idea for a novel this week. Not one that would probably be of interest to anyone but nerds like me, but one that could actually be a university curriculum. What if you took the detailed outcomes of a liberal arts education and allowed certain exceptional students to achieve them on their own? I hate that what came to my mind could only be achieved either by those with means or a system with massive financial underwriting.

But what if, to learn world history, you went to study with mentors in various parts of the world? There on site, you could also learn relevant discoveries in science and math, as well as the philosophies of the people there? You would be exposed to the key languages of the world and could be required to learn some basics of each.

What an amazing curriculum that would be! Certainly something I could create in a novel. But it's actually something that some entrepreneurial university could pilot as well. I know there are components of this sort of thing already being done.