So where are we to go from here? Hopefully these last few pages have presented a fairly accurate sense of what the Wesleyan tradition is and has been in its some two hundred years. But as we have also argued, no tradition is perfect. Presumably there are denominations that have nothing distinctive to contribute who should merge with other groups with whom they have no significant differences. Perhaps their vision and contribution can become the unity of the church. We believe there are many small denominations in the Wesleyan tradition that have no real reason to exist independently of one another, perhaps aside from the complications of merging.
Nevertheless, we also believe that the Wesleyan tradition as a whole has much to contribute to the body of Christ at large and thus a reason for it to retain its fundamental identity amid the diversity of Christendom. Ironically, one of its contributions is its generous spirit toward other traditions. The problem with pluralism--an acceptance of all groups as equally valid in their thinking and practice--is that no group retains any real identity at all. A much more tenable position is identity within diversity. We humbly recognize that our understanding and approach to things will likely turn out to be wrong at points and we are open-hearted toward other traditions and their critique. But this attitude does not negate our sense that our theology and values are at the very least right for us and perhaps may be right at many points overall.
Nevertheless, a generous and humble sense of our place in the kingdom of God urges us to make alliances with other traditions. As we said at the very beginning, we have much more in common with the rest of Christendom than we differ. Certainly we would share with a vast host of Christianity a sense of mission to the world that goes beyond eternal destiny to salvation in the sense of Luke-Acts, the restoration of humanity on every level. Many Christian groups have lost their way on this fundamental Christian value and pose a false dichotomy between serving the needy and saving their souls. We can participate in the mission of God to rescue all of humanity in every area of life alongside all those who have the heart of Christ.
Although we differ on the theory behind the practice, Wesleyans share with Calvinists and many others the sense that God's mission is to everyone and that faithfulness to God is an essential part of our task. A Calvinist might say we must participate in a mission toward everyone because we do not know who God has chosen. An Arminian might say we must participate in the mission because anyone can be chosen. In either case, the mission invites everyone. A Calvinist might say you know a person is elect because they have remained faithful. An Arminian might say they remain among the elect because they remain faithful. Both traditions believe that we must remain faithful.
We remain faithful by making God the absolute authority of our life, which shows itself in our consistent love of our neighbor. Nothing is an exception to these two rules, a belief that Wesleyans surely hold in common with most others who call themselves Christians. No supposed interpretation of the Bible can legitimately support hateful actions toward our neighbors. One of the ways in which we are distinctive is in our belief that there are no glib excuses for failure in these areas. God expects us to succeed in loving our neighbor, and he empowers us to do it.
The Wesleyan tradition also has an activism that sees the potential for us to love our neighbors beyond the level of the individual. Christianity can be a force in the reformation of societal structures that perpetuate hatred of our neighbor. Unfortunately, those who call themselves Christians have often participated in the oppression of the minority. We have gone on Crusades to kill the Muslim. We have argued for slavery and against giving women the right to vote. We have supported Hitler against the Jews. We have lynched African-Americans in the KKK and grumbled against those who sought the right to go to the same schools and drink the same water as the majority. We have ignored the economically enslaved, the powerless immigrant, and rallied around the bombing of the unnamed other in a foreign country.
Suffice it to say, the best element of the Wesleyan tradition has always stood with the minority. They were abolitionists and supporters of women's rights. They were in favor of women in all roles of leadership. They were arrested along with other non-violent protesters in the Civil Rights movement. They take into mind the people who are crushed by legislation aimed at the self-sufficient, legal, and comfortable majority. Even when they have disagreed with the lifestyle of those whose sexual desires are toward the same sex, they have taken into mind the fact that God loves them every bit as much as the comfortable majority, that they are people we must treat with the love of Christ. This is the spirit of the Wesleyan tradition.
The Wesleyan tradition also moves forward into the twenty-first century with an ease that some other traditions do not. The postmodern challenge has exposed the frailty of human systems of thinking and of the degree to which our understanding of the Bible is and has been a function of us as readers more than of what these texts actually meant. The best philosophical answers to these challenges have been a "critical realist" or even "pragmatic realist" point of view. These perspectives focus on the heuristic value of our systems of thinking rather than on them as absolute systems that are the same as what God thinks. Our ideas stick closely to the evidence at hand and to what it is we are trying to do with our ideas. Again, this sense of thought in the service of our values and actions fits well with the Wesleyan spirit.
Similarly, once we realize that the Bible itself is an object of our knowing, the way it functions in Christian life must change. Regardless of the perfection of the Bible's message, we are stuck as its interpreters. The perfection of the Bible in practice therefore cannot rise in practice beyond the perfection of our understanding. These recognitions, along with a better understanding of the particularity of the Bible's original meaning, forces us to acknowledge the powerful, Spirit-led role that common Christian tradition has played in the appropriation of Scripture throughout the ages. We can no longer separate Scripture from tradition in the manner of the Reformation.
Again, the Wesleyan tradition slides easily into this mode, not only because Wesley was an Anglican rather than a Lutheran or a Calvinist, but because the Wesleyan tradition has a strong revivalist stream within it. This openness to the Spirit makes us comfortable with the notion of direct revelation from God in the words of Scripture and it makes us comfortable with the non-literal unity of Scripture that formative Christianity heard in its words. We can thus look forward to the challenges of the twenty-first century with Scripture as our starting point, with common Christian tradition setting the boundaries of our application, and with the Spirit to move us further along on the trajectory of the kingdom.
Monday, December 20, 2010
Latinos/as No Longer GOP
If there was any question, the GOP sealed its fate to lose the Mexican-Hispanic vote for the foreseeable future because of voting against the DREAM Act, which would have made a path for children of illegals to citizenship by going to college or serving in the military. Richard Lugar retains my vote for voting in the spirit of the America I love, the one with the Statue of Liberty that welcomes all who wish to participate in our grand society. "Give me your poor, your tired, your huddled masses longing to breathe free."
Sunday, December 19, 2010
God's Breathings 3
Once again, these developments place Wesleyan and Pentecostal traditions in a unique position to make a hermeneutical contribution in the days ahead. The problem with mainstream evangelical hermeneutics is that it has over-emphasized the literal meaning of the Bible. This trajectory was set back in the days of the Protestant Reformation itself, where the Reformers rejected allegorical and other interpretive methods used in the medieval catholic church in deference to the Bible's "plain sense." Ironically, it was this focus that in large part led to the liberalism of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century.
Chiefly, the trajectory of historical interpretation is to see each book of the Bible in its full particularity. As the study of language and culture has advanced, biblical experts have more and more been able to appreciate how well the language of the Bible's books fit in their original contexts. And they have more and more seen how different those contexts are from ours.
For example, a modern reader might assume that she can simply apply what the Bible says about lending and money directly to today. But did money work the same way two thousand years ago as it does today? Did people think about money the same way we think about money? After all, the "literal" meaning of the Bible is not how the words strike me. The literal meaning of the Bible is how it would have struck the people it says it was actually written to. The study of culture and human anthropology has raised instance after instance where words that seem to have obvious meaning to us would have meant something quite different originally.
Our point is that it was inevitable that a divide would arise between the study of the Bible and Christian theology once the Protestant Reformation restricted meaning to the literal. Liberalism is thus as much a child of the Reformation as evangelicalism. Indeed, mainstream evangelical hermeneutics itself deconstructs on this very point. It insists that only the contextual meaning of Scripture is the authoritative one, but when we listen to the New Testament in context, we find that it regularly finds authority in non-contextual meanings. The New Testament itself often finds inspired meaning in the Old Testament in "more than literal" interpretations. If we are to take seriously the Bible as the starting place for Christian thinking and action, then surely we must take seriously the fact that the Bible models a Spirit-mode of interpretation far more than a historical-contextual one.
For example, when Paul reads Deuteronomy 25:4's prohibition of muzzling an ox while it is treading grain, he finds it unlikely that the main point of this verse is about oxen: "Is it for oxen that God is concerned? Or does he not speak entirely for our sake? It was indeed written for our sake" (1 Cor. 9:9-10, NRSV). In other words, Paul sees the main spiritual point of this passage on an allegorical rather than a literal level. The New Testament thus bridges the gap between the historical and the theological by loosening the biblical text from its contextual moorings.
This is a point of immense significance. When 2 Timothy 3:16 says that "all Scripture is inspired by God and is useful for teaching, for reproof, for correction and for training in righteousness," it does not in any way restrict such instruction to the literal meaning. Given the New Testament's own consistent interpretative method, we must acknowledge that the Spirit is free to interpret and apply Scriptures in ways you could never get from a masterful sentence diagram or Hebrew word study. Revivalist and Pentecostal hermeneutics thus stand in far greater continuity with biblical interpretive methods than mainstream evangelical hermeneutics do.
The solution to the "ditch" between the original, historical meanings of the Bible and the theological meanings Christians have seen in the words since the very beginning, is a careful allowance for more than literal meanings to the text. In truth, we who see the Bible as one book do this broadening of meaning whether we are willing to admit it to ourselves or not. Since the very beginning, Christians have brought Christian tradition with them to the text. Those who have not have more often formed cults or splinter groups.
The last five hundred years--especially in America--have witnessed the rise of tens of thousands of small Christian denominations who think they are just reading the Bible and doing what it says. But what they are really doing is finding unity in the Bible by reading it against their own social context, bringing their own non-historical definitions to the Bible's words. Here is the tension. Reading the Bible as Christian Scripture, as more than particular historical texts, will require us to bring some organizing principles from outside the text. But without something to ground the meaning of the text, we are each prone to "read what is right in our own eyes," resulting in the over twenty thousand different Christian denominations we have today.
The soundest way forward is not a quadrilateral, but a "trilateral" of Scripture, common Christian tradition, and Spiritual experience. We can continue to accept that each of the biblical writings were inspired historically for their own times and places, but the more we understand what this dynamic truly means, the more complicated it becomes to apply them to today, to bridge the distance between "that time" and "this time." But it is through common Christian tradition that the Spirit has set the boundaries for how to apply them, giving us a "Spiritual common sense" we all bring to the texts, whether we realize it or not. Common tradition provides the most stable rules for how to read and apply these diverse books as a single text with a common story. It is what the Christians of the first few centuries called the "rule of faith."
Behind all inspired meaning is the Spirit. It is the Spirit who makes the Bible be Scripture for us, a sacrament of revelation. He is constantly at work in us as individual readers, as Christian groups and denominations, and as the church universal.
The Wesleyan revivalist tradition, along with the Pentecostal tradition, is thus in an excellent position to be among those leading hermeneutics forward in the twenty-first century. We have always been a Scripture-centered tradition, but we have also been a pneumatic tradition. While it is perhaps not a great boast to say that we have produced few scholars of the historical-contextual meaning of the Bible, it has left us well situated to take the lead in a more balanced approach going forward. We can acknowledge the soundness of historical interpretation as providing insight into God's workings in the history of salvation, of God meeting the audiences of the Old and New Testaments where they were at in their particularity.
But we can also acknowledge that the Spirit brought a unity to these diverse texts in the hearts and minds of formative Christianity in the first centuries of this era. The Spirit led Christians to hear a common story, a common faith, and a common ethic in these texts, transforming them from individual books to a unified Scripture. The Spirit has provided correctives throughout history when tradition has arguably gone astray, chiefly in the Protestant Reformation. Yet the Spirit also can speak to individuals and small groups today, making the text come alive with meanings and direction just for them.
Chiefly, the trajectory of historical interpretation is to see each book of the Bible in its full particularity. As the study of language and culture has advanced, biblical experts have more and more been able to appreciate how well the language of the Bible's books fit in their original contexts. And they have more and more seen how different those contexts are from ours.
For example, a modern reader might assume that she can simply apply what the Bible says about lending and money directly to today. But did money work the same way two thousand years ago as it does today? Did people think about money the same way we think about money? After all, the "literal" meaning of the Bible is not how the words strike me. The literal meaning of the Bible is how it would have struck the people it says it was actually written to. The study of culture and human anthropology has raised instance after instance where words that seem to have obvious meaning to us would have meant something quite different originally.
Our point is that it was inevitable that a divide would arise between the study of the Bible and Christian theology once the Protestant Reformation restricted meaning to the literal. Liberalism is thus as much a child of the Reformation as evangelicalism. Indeed, mainstream evangelical hermeneutics itself deconstructs on this very point. It insists that only the contextual meaning of Scripture is the authoritative one, but when we listen to the New Testament in context, we find that it regularly finds authority in non-contextual meanings. The New Testament itself often finds inspired meaning in the Old Testament in "more than literal" interpretations. If we are to take seriously the Bible as the starting place for Christian thinking and action, then surely we must take seriously the fact that the Bible models a Spirit-mode of interpretation far more than a historical-contextual one.
For example, when Paul reads Deuteronomy 25:4's prohibition of muzzling an ox while it is treading grain, he finds it unlikely that the main point of this verse is about oxen: "Is it for oxen that God is concerned? Or does he not speak entirely for our sake? It was indeed written for our sake" (1 Cor. 9:9-10, NRSV). In other words, Paul sees the main spiritual point of this passage on an allegorical rather than a literal level. The New Testament thus bridges the gap between the historical and the theological by loosening the biblical text from its contextual moorings.
This is a point of immense significance. When 2 Timothy 3:16 says that "all Scripture is inspired by God and is useful for teaching, for reproof, for correction and for training in righteousness," it does not in any way restrict such instruction to the literal meaning. Given the New Testament's own consistent interpretative method, we must acknowledge that the Spirit is free to interpret and apply Scriptures in ways you could never get from a masterful sentence diagram or Hebrew word study. Revivalist and Pentecostal hermeneutics thus stand in far greater continuity with biblical interpretive methods than mainstream evangelical hermeneutics do.
The solution to the "ditch" between the original, historical meanings of the Bible and the theological meanings Christians have seen in the words since the very beginning, is a careful allowance for more than literal meanings to the text. In truth, we who see the Bible as one book do this broadening of meaning whether we are willing to admit it to ourselves or not. Since the very beginning, Christians have brought Christian tradition with them to the text. Those who have not have more often formed cults or splinter groups.
The last five hundred years--especially in America--have witnessed the rise of tens of thousands of small Christian denominations who think they are just reading the Bible and doing what it says. But what they are really doing is finding unity in the Bible by reading it against their own social context, bringing their own non-historical definitions to the Bible's words. Here is the tension. Reading the Bible as Christian Scripture, as more than particular historical texts, will require us to bring some organizing principles from outside the text. But without something to ground the meaning of the text, we are each prone to "read what is right in our own eyes," resulting in the over twenty thousand different Christian denominations we have today.
The soundest way forward is not a quadrilateral, but a "trilateral" of Scripture, common Christian tradition, and Spiritual experience. We can continue to accept that each of the biblical writings were inspired historically for their own times and places, but the more we understand what this dynamic truly means, the more complicated it becomes to apply them to today, to bridge the distance between "that time" and "this time." But it is through common Christian tradition that the Spirit has set the boundaries for how to apply them, giving us a "Spiritual common sense" we all bring to the texts, whether we realize it or not. Common tradition provides the most stable rules for how to read and apply these diverse books as a single text with a common story. It is what the Christians of the first few centuries called the "rule of faith."
Behind all inspired meaning is the Spirit. It is the Spirit who makes the Bible be Scripture for us, a sacrament of revelation. He is constantly at work in us as individual readers, as Christian groups and denominations, and as the church universal.
The Wesleyan revivalist tradition, along with the Pentecostal tradition, is thus in an excellent position to be among those leading hermeneutics forward in the twenty-first century. We have always been a Scripture-centered tradition, but we have also been a pneumatic tradition. While it is perhaps not a great boast to say that we have produced few scholars of the historical-contextual meaning of the Bible, it has left us well situated to take the lead in a more balanced approach going forward. We can acknowledge the soundness of historical interpretation as providing insight into God's workings in the history of salvation, of God meeting the audiences of the Old and New Testaments where they were at in their particularity.
But we can also acknowledge that the Spirit brought a unity to these diverse texts in the hearts and minds of formative Christianity in the first centuries of this era. The Spirit led Christians to hear a common story, a common faith, and a common ethic in these texts, transforming them from individual books to a unified Scripture. The Spirit has provided correctives throughout history when tradition has arguably gone astray, chiefly in the Protestant Reformation. Yet the Spirit also can speak to individuals and small groups today, making the text come alive with meanings and direction just for them.
Saturday, December 18, 2010
God's Breathings 2
The previous post is here.
_______
One clear feature that we see throughout the Wesleyan tradition is a greater openness to the experiential dimension of Christian thought and life than some other branches of Christianity. In his own day, Wesley was accused of being an "enthusiast" (which he denied) for his emphasis on spiritual experiences that purified and empowered believers. In the early twentieth century, you would have seen people "running the aisles," shouting praises, and even experiencing "holy laughter" in countless holiness churches and camp meetings. Indeed, apart from speaking in tongues and being slain in the Spirit, the experiential practices of holiness and Pentecostal churches were quite similar, a similarity all the more ironic given that these holiness churches generally demonized tongues-speaking and forbade it in worship.
It is not hard to see why more mainstream Christian traditions might have looked somewhat askance at these revivalist movements, indeed, why these holiness denominations themselves eventually moved toward more orderly worship. When every individual claims to have a direct revelation from God, you inevitably end up with a lot of "revelations" that are nothing but random nonsense. Such movements are the stuff of false prophets and megalomaniacs, who lead off sincere but naive believers to isolated camps in Guyana or Waco. Your sense of Christian faith and action becomes hyper-subjective and the most convincing demagogue wins.
Yet in an age where the limits of human reason have become painfully obvious, Wesley's balance between reason and experience seems a powerful voice in a new generation. Wesley experts have often summarized his way of interpreting God's will as a "quadrilateral" between Scripture, tradition, reason, and experience. To be sure, Wesley saw Scripture as the determinative voice in the interplay between these potential paths for hearing God's voice. Yet, as with Luther and Calvin, common Christian tradition appears throughout his writings. As someone who lived at a time when the Enlightenment was moving toward Romanticism, it is no surprise that reason and experience also played distinctive roles in his thinking.
But it would be foolish to try to imitate the finer points of Wesley's hermeneutic today. After all, the discussion has moved on and, arguably, we have a much fuller perspective on language and meaning today by far than Wesley or indeed any Christian prior to the twentieth century did. The key contribution from Wesley is his sense of balance, with all the valid sources of truth playing a role.
The revivalist wing of the Wesleyan tradition largely passed through the increasingly turbulent waters of biblical criticism unscathed, not because of its intellectual response to historical criticism, but because of its detachment from it. To be sure, some Wesleyan scholars engaged the developments of the day and participated in the rise of neo-evangelicalism in the forties and fifties. Terms like "inerrancy" and "infallible" still appear in the doctrinal articles of these churches as a fossil of those debates.
But most of the heirs of revivalism were blissfully unaware of these movements. They were more concerned about hair or skirt length than fighting the intellectual battles of the age. This proved to be both a strength and a weakness. It was a weakness in that they were not engaged and were prone to legalism and unproductive introspection. It was a strength because they were less tainted by the categories of the debate. Even when they adopted the language of fundamentalism or evangelicalism, that language scarcely had the significance for them that it had for other groups that were on the front lines.
For example, the holiness movement of the late 1800s had a penchant for "figural" interpretations in which they took various elements of the biblical text as symbols of other theological truths. Perhaps the red cord that Rahab puts outside a window in Joshua 2:18 is a hidden symbol of the blood of Christ whereby we are saved. Holiness churches were far more prone to waves of dispensationalism than to the fundamentalist-modernist controversy. Prophecy teachers found contemporary events and nations hidden in the words of Scripture. Individuals might hear God calling them to be missionaries or to move their families in a particular turn of phrase here and there.
Again, this orientation around symbolic and hidden meanings was both a strength and a weakness. It was a weakness because holiness preachers had little or no sense of how to read the Bible in context, for what it actually meant when its books were written. Mainstream evangelicalism may have fought with certain aspects of biblical criticism, but the soundness of the historical method was all too clear to them. In a sense, many of them were ruined of any chance to hear God's voice in such "pneumatic," spiritual ways when it was painfully obvious to them that none of these meanings had anything to do with the original meaning of the Bible's books.
The mid-twentieth century move of evangelicalism to come to grips with historical criticism was to go half way. Evangelical scholars adopted the historical method, but set boundaries as to how far you could go with it. If historical evidence seemed to be leading past one of these boundaries, your method shifted from finding the most likely conclusion to finding a way to spin the evidence in a more acceptable direction.
The strength of holiness figurative interpretation is that it allowed its participants to hear the direct voice of God in the words of Scripture without having to know anything about the complicated interpretive method that evangelical intellectuals had to develop. Even to this day, mainstream evangelical institutions spend massive amounts of time teaching students the finer points of biblical languages and historical method, treating God's will as a mechanical and scientific formula. The postmodern challenge has presented these traditions with a major crisis that threatens to undermine them to their very hermeneutical foundations because in responding to modernism, they adopted its hermeneutical values.
Once again, these developments place Wesleyan and Pentecostal traditions in a unique position to make a hermeneutical contribution in the days ahead...
_______
One clear feature that we see throughout the Wesleyan tradition is a greater openness to the experiential dimension of Christian thought and life than some other branches of Christianity. In his own day, Wesley was accused of being an "enthusiast" (which he denied) for his emphasis on spiritual experiences that purified and empowered believers. In the early twentieth century, you would have seen people "running the aisles," shouting praises, and even experiencing "holy laughter" in countless holiness churches and camp meetings. Indeed, apart from speaking in tongues and being slain in the Spirit, the experiential practices of holiness and Pentecostal churches were quite similar, a similarity all the more ironic given that these holiness churches generally demonized tongues-speaking and forbade it in worship.
It is not hard to see why more mainstream Christian traditions might have looked somewhat askance at these revivalist movements, indeed, why these holiness denominations themselves eventually moved toward more orderly worship. When every individual claims to have a direct revelation from God, you inevitably end up with a lot of "revelations" that are nothing but random nonsense. Such movements are the stuff of false prophets and megalomaniacs, who lead off sincere but naive believers to isolated camps in Guyana or Waco. Your sense of Christian faith and action becomes hyper-subjective and the most convincing demagogue wins.
Yet in an age where the limits of human reason have become painfully obvious, Wesley's balance between reason and experience seems a powerful voice in a new generation. Wesley experts have often summarized his way of interpreting God's will as a "quadrilateral" between Scripture, tradition, reason, and experience. To be sure, Wesley saw Scripture as the determinative voice in the interplay between these potential paths for hearing God's voice. Yet, as with Luther and Calvin, common Christian tradition appears throughout his writings. As someone who lived at a time when the Enlightenment was moving toward Romanticism, it is no surprise that reason and experience also played distinctive roles in his thinking.
But it would be foolish to try to imitate the finer points of Wesley's hermeneutic today. After all, the discussion has moved on and, arguably, we have a much fuller perspective on language and meaning today by far than Wesley or indeed any Christian prior to the twentieth century did. The key contribution from Wesley is his sense of balance, with all the valid sources of truth playing a role.
The revivalist wing of the Wesleyan tradition largely passed through the increasingly turbulent waters of biblical criticism unscathed, not because of its intellectual response to historical criticism, but because of its detachment from it. To be sure, some Wesleyan scholars engaged the developments of the day and participated in the rise of neo-evangelicalism in the forties and fifties. Terms like "inerrancy" and "infallible" still appear in the doctrinal articles of these churches as a fossil of those debates.
But most of the heirs of revivalism were blissfully unaware of these movements. They were more concerned about hair or skirt length than fighting the intellectual battles of the age. This proved to be both a strength and a weakness. It was a weakness in that they were not engaged and were prone to legalism and unproductive introspection. It was a strength because they were less tainted by the categories of the debate. Even when they adopted the language of fundamentalism or evangelicalism, that language scarcely had the significance for them that it had for other groups that were on the front lines.
For example, the holiness movement of the late 1800s had a penchant for "figural" interpretations in which they took various elements of the biblical text as symbols of other theological truths. Perhaps the red cord that Rahab puts outside a window in Joshua 2:18 is a hidden symbol of the blood of Christ whereby we are saved. Holiness churches were far more prone to waves of dispensationalism than to the fundamentalist-modernist controversy. Prophecy teachers found contemporary events and nations hidden in the words of Scripture. Individuals might hear God calling them to be missionaries or to move their families in a particular turn of phrase here and there.
Again, this orientation around symbolic and hidden meanings was both a strength and a weakness. It was a weakness because holiness preachers had little or no sense of how to read the Bible in context, for what it actually meant when its books were written. Mainstream evangelicalism may have fought with certain aspects of biblical criticism, but the soundness of the historical method was all too clear to them. In a sense, many of them were ruined of any chance to hear God's voice in such "pneumatic," spiritual ways when it was painfully obvious to them that none of these meanings had anything to do with the original meaning of the Bible's books.
The mid-twentieth century move of evangelicalism to come to grips with historical criticism was to go half way. Evangelical scholars adopted the historical method, but set boundaries as to how far you could go with it. If historical evidence seemed to be leading past one of these boundaries, your method shifted from finding the most likely conclusion to finding a way to spin the evidence in a more acceptable direction.
The strength of holiness figurative interpretation is that it allowed its participants to hear the direct voice of God in the words of Scripture without having to know anything about the complicated interpretive method that evangelical intellectuals had to develop. Even to this day, mainstream evangelical institutions spend massive amounts of time teaching students the finer points of biblical languages and historical method, treating God's will as a mechanical and scientific formula. The postmodern challenge has presented these traditions with a major crisis that threatens to undermine them to their very hermeneutical foundations because in responding to modernism, they adopted its hermeneutical values.
Once again, these developments place Wesleyan and Pentecostal traditions in a unique position to make a hermeneutical contribution in the days ahead...
Friday, December 17, 2010
God's Breathings 1
The Wesleyan tradition was not encased in stone with Wesley. Wesley's heirs are a diverse collection of churches with more and less direct connections to him historically. In the United States, Wesley's most direct heir is the United Methodist Church, which retains Wesley's sense of openness to those of a kindred spirit and perhaps a hint of his "methodical" personality. However, the 1800s saw a host of Wesleyan denominations come into existence both because of various quarrels with the Methodist church and then in the late 1800s/early 1900s with a wave of revivalism that swept America.
These smaller Wesleyan denominations, such as my own, often were at one or two removes from many aspects of Wesley's own thought and practice. For example, Wesley remained an Anglican his entire life. He believed that infant baptism was important to wash away the original sin of Adam. But if you look at the various Wesleyan denominations who reflect his influence, you will find some that have been more influenced by Anabaptist streams of American Christianity on such issues. Indeed, the Salvation Army tends not to baptize at all, showing an affinity some Wesleyan denominations formed with Quaker streams. And the smaller the Wesleyan denomination, the more likely it is to look more Baptist in its worship style than the high church Wesley.
Similarly, "Christian perfection" for Wesley was something that came on God's time schedule. In his more pessimistic moments, Wesley saw it as something few would experience and, even then, most likely near the end of their lives. By contrast, the "holiness revivals" of the late 1800s saw "entire sanctification" as something God wanted to give you as soon as possible, and a culture of spiritual experience resulted that would eventually lead to the Pentecostal revivals of the early twentieth century. Both the holiness movement and the Pentecostal movement flowed from the same revivalist waters of the late 1800s.
The long and short of it is that John Wesley is more the grandfather of the Wesleyan tradition than its father. Those of us in the Wesleyan tradition today face both the necessity and the opportunity to determine what elements of Wesleyan tradition we believe should come forward. We have taken this perspective throughout these pages, trying to preserve the genius of Wesley without being a slave to his thinking or practice. He was, after all, a child of his age as we are of ours...
These smaller Wesleyan denominations, such as my own, often were at one or two removes from many aspects of Wesley's own thought and practice. For example, Wesley remained an Anglican his entire life. He believed that infant baptism was important to wash away the original sin of Adam. But if you look at the various Wesleyan denominations who reflect his influence, you will find some that have been more influenced by Anabaptist streams of American Christianity on such issues. Indeed, the Salvation Army tends not to baptize at all, showing an affinity some Wesleyan denominations formed with Quaker streams. And the smaller the Wesleyan denomination, the more likely it is to look more Baptist in its worship style than the high church Wesley.
Similarly, "Christian perfection" for Wesley was something that came on God's time schedule. In his more pessimistic moments, Wesley saw it as something few would experience and, even then, most likely near the end of their lives. By contrast, the "holiness revivals" of the late 1800s saw "entire sanctification" as something God wanted to give you as soon as possible, and a culture of spiritual experience resulted that would eventually lead to the Pentecostal revivals of the early twentieth century. Both the holiness movement and the Pentecostal movement flowed from the same revivalist waters of the late 1800s.
The long and short of it is that John Wesley is more the grandfather of the Wesleyan tradition than its father. Those of us in the Wesleyan tradition today face both the necessity and the opportunity to determine what elements of Wesleyan tradition we believe should come forward. We have taken this perspective throughout these pages, trying to preserve the genius of Wesley without being a slave to his thinking or practice. He was, after all, a child of his age as we are of ours...
Thursday, December 16, 2010
Be Faithful 3
The previous post is here.
____________
The second way in which the Wesleyan tradition differs from some other Christian traditions is in its sense that those who do not remain faithful to God will not be part of the kingdom of God. For this reason, some have accused Arminians of believing in "salvation by works," of believing that we are not saved by "faith alone" but by our deeds. Since the Reformation began in part over this issue, with Luther arguing against the Roman Catholic Church for this reason, some groups consider this distinctive of Arminian theology defective.
Similarly, these same groups might describe Wesleyan-Arminians as "Pelagian" or "semi-Pelagian." Pelagius was a Christian in the 300s/400s who believed that humans could still do some good in their own power, without God helping them. In response, Augustine argued that we are currently in a state of "total depravity," that it is only by the power of God that anyone might do or even want to do any good in the world.
To be fair, none of these charges are true of the Wesleyan tradition. For example, John Wesley accepted Augustine's teaching on total depravity. The difference is that while Calvin saw God's empowerment as a matter of "all or nothing." Wesleyan theology sees God empowering people to make moral choices, both toward and away from God. Accordingly, God not only empowers everyone potentially to move toward God. God also empowers those who have already come to him, who have become truly right with him through Christ and received the Spirit, also to choose to move away from him.
Without the possibility of such moral choice, the central claims of Christianity seem incoherent. If God does not give everyone the possibility of salvation, then the central claim that God is love does not seem to make sense. But if it does not matter how one lives thereafter, then serving God is potentially a trivial matter, and our moral choices potentially become meaningless.
Of course you might notice that the last few paragraphs say nothing about the Bible. Indeed, Paul knows nothing of these debates. They are debates that arise, as we said at the beginning, from theological systems that various thinkers have developed as they have filled in the blanks. Perhaps it is the Holy Spirit who has helped them fill in these blanks, but it is significant to make the distinction between what is Bible and what is later Christian tradition.
It is not necessary to go into details about how Protestant Christian tradition has expanded on Paul's language and meaning. For example, it would be more accurate to Paul to say that humanity is thoroughly depraved rather than totally depraved. And Paul never says that we are justified by faith alone. The only place in Scripture where the word "alone" is used with either the word faith or works is in James 2:24 where James says that a person is justified by works and not by faith alone.
Indeed, many Pauline experts believe that Paul had as much the faithfulness of Jesus in view as faith in Jesus. Further, it seems likely that it is not so much faith versus works in general that was Paul's focus as works of the Jewish Law, especially those that clearly separated Jew and Gentile ethnically. Such boundary issues would especially include things like circumcision, food laws, and sabbath observance. Augustine's universalization and systematization of Paul thus involved some significant shifts in meaning.
And so it is no surprise that Romans 2:6-10 and 2 Corinthians 5:10 have recently drawn the attention of Pauline experts. Arguably, both of these passages say explicitly that believers will be judged by Christ for their works even after they are justified. A picture emerges where we are made right with God at first, solely because of our trust in what God has done through Jesus. But after that point, God expects us to be faithful.
Indeed, a proper understanding of grace in its first century context supports this understanding. Grace (charis) in the New Testament is best understood against the backdrop of ancient patron-client relationships. In these prevalent relationships, individuals of means would give to those without means. Such gifts (charisma) were not earned. That is to say, the gift was disproportionate to anything the recipient might give in return. Technically speaking, gifts also came without any strings attached, meaning that the "client" would not be asked to give the gift back.
However, when we view New Testament grace from this perspective, we see how naturally Wesleyan-Arminian theology fits Paul's thinking. No patron would continue to give patronage if a client disrespected him or her. And while there were technically no strings attached, there were often informal expectations that came along with the gift. Further, while the gift would be something you could not possibly earn, there might be things you could do to trigger the gift.
Our default expectation of Paul is thus that he would see God's acceptance as a gift, something you could not possibly earn but something you might seek. He would expect, along with the gift, that you would serve him and submit to his lordship--after all, he was empowering you with his Spirit to do so as part of the gift itself! Finally, we would expect that if a person continued to sin willfully, insulting God's grace (cf. Heb. 10:26, 29), God eventually would stop extending his gracious forgiveness for those sins.
And arguably this is exactly what we find in Paul's writings. Perhaps the consummate example is the fact that Paul does not consider his own eternal destiny decided. In 1 Corinthians 9:24-27, Paul indicates that he himself might be disqualified for the prize of salvation if he does not continue in faithfulness. Hebrews 3 later builds on the imagery of 1 Corinthians 10 to say that just because a person has begun the journey to the promised land does not mean a person will make it. Hebrews 3:14 uses a perfect tense to say that even though we have become a partaker of Christ (completed action), that status will not continue unless we hold firm to the end.
Indeed, Hebrews is notorious for its warning passages that tell believers they will not inherit the promise if they intentionally turn their backs on God. If they fall away, they will not be able to repent again, like ground that after much watering only yields thorns (6:4-8), like Esau who could not find a place of repentance even though he sought it with tears (12:16-17). It seems impossible to work around what Hebrews is saying here, that a person can be genuinely "in" and yet not make it because they turn away.
So also Paul presses on in hope to get that "upward call" of God in Christ Jesus (Phil. 3:14). He has not yet attained a guarantee of the resurrection (Phil. 3:11-12). It is something he strives toward. He must continue to be faithful if he hopes to be perfected when Christ returns. His sufferings are like a sharing in Christ's sufferings "if somehow I may attain the resurrection from the dead" (Phil. 3:11, NRSV). What we find is that Paul himself talks like an Arminian, and it is arguably only the theological system of various Protestant groups that makes this thinking problematic.
____________
The second way in which the Wesleyan tradition differs from some other Christian traditions is in its sense that those who do not remain faithful to God will not be part of the kingdom of God. For this reason, some have accused Arminians of believing in "salvation by works," of believing that we are not saved by "faith alone" but by our deeds. Since the Reformation began in part over this issue, with Luther arguing against the Roman Catholic Church for this reason, some groups consider this distinctive of Arminian theology defective.
Similarly, these same groups might describe Wesleyan-Arminians as "Pelagian" or "semi-Pelagian." Pelagius was a Christian in the 300s/400s who believed that humans could still do some good in their own power, without God helping them. In response, Augustine argued that we are currently in a state of "total depravity," that it is only by the power of God that anyone might do or even want to do any good in the world.
To be fair, none of these charges are true of the Wesleyan tradition. For example, John Wesley accepted Augustine's teaching on total depravity. The difference is that while Calvin saw God's empowerment as a matter of "all or nothing." Wesleyan theology sees God empowering people to make moral choices, both toward and away from God. Accordingly, God not only empowers everyone potentially to move toward God. God also empowers those who have already come to him, who have become truly right with him through Christ and received the Spirit, also to choose to move away from him.
Without the possibility of such moral choice, the central claims of Christianity seem incoherent. If God does not give everyone the possibility of salvation, then the central claim that God is love does not seem to make sense. But if it does not matter how one lives thereafter, then serving God is potentially a trivial matter, and our moral choices potentially become meaningless.
Of course you might notice that the last few paragraphs say nothing about the Bible. Indeed, Paul knows nothing of these debates. They are debates that arise, as we said at the beginning, from theological systems that various thinkers have developed as they have filled in the blanks. Perhaps it is the Holy Spirit who has helped them fill in these blanks, but it is significant to make the distinction between what is Bible and what is later Christian tradition.
It is not necessary to go into details about how Protestant Christian tradition has expanded on Paul's language and meaning. For example, it would be more accurate to Paul to say that humanity is thoroughly depraved rather than totally depraved. And Paul never says that we are justified by faith alone. The only place in Scripture where the word "alone" is used with either the word faith or works is in James 2:24 where James says that a person is justified by works and not by faith alone.
Indeed, many Pauline experts believe that Paul had as much the faithfulness of Jesus in view as faith in Jesus. Further, it seems likely that it is not so much faith versus works in general that was Paul's focus as works of the Jewish Law, especially those that clearly separated Jew and Gentile ethnically. Such boundary issues would especially include things like circumcision, food laws, and sabbath observance. Augustine's universalization and systematization of Paul thus involved some significant shifts in meaning.
And so it is no surprise that Romans 2:6-10 and 2 Corinthians 5:10 have recently drawn the attention of Pauline experts. Arguably, both of these passages say explicitly that believers will be judged by Christ for their works even after they are justified. A picture emerges where we are made right with God at first, solely because of our trust in what God has done through Jesus. But after that point, God expects us to be faithful.
Indeed, a proper understanding of grace in its first century context supports this understanding. Grace (charis) in the New Testament is best understood against the backdrop of ancient patron-client relationships. In these prevalent relationships, individuals of means would give to those without means. Such gifts (charisma) were not earned. That is to say, the gift was disproportionate to anything the recipient might give in return. Technically speaking, gifts also came without any strings attached, meaning that the "client" would not be asked to give the gift back.
However, when we view New Testament grace from this perspective, we see how naturally Wesleyan-Arminian theology fits Paul's thinking. No patron would continue to give patronage if a client disrespected him or her. And while there were technically no strings attached, there were often informal expectations that came along with the gift. Further, while the gift would be something you could not possibly earn, there might be things you could do to trigger the gift.
Our default expectation of Paul is thus that he would see God's acceptance as a gift, something you could not possibly earn but something you might seek. He would expect, along with the gift, that you would serve him and submit to his lordship--after all, he was empowering you with his Spirit to do so as part of the gift itself! Finally, we would expect that if a person continued to sin willfully, insulting God's grace (cf. Heb. 10:26, 29), God eventually would stop extending his gracious forgiveness for those sins.
And arguably this is exactly what we find in Paul's writings. Perhaps the consummate example is the fact that Paul does not consider his own eternal destiny decided. In 1 Corinthians 9:24-27, Paul indicates that he himself might be disqualified for the prize of salvation if he does not continue in faithfulness. Hebrews 3 later builds on the imagery of 1 Corinthians 10 to say that just because a person has begun the journey to the promised land does not mean a person will make it. Hebrews 3:14 uses a perfect tense to say that even though we have become a partaker of Christ (completed action), that status will not continue unless we hold firm to the end.
Indeed, Hebrews is notorious for its warning passages that tell believers they will not inherit the promise if they intentionally turn their backs on God. If they fall away, they will not be able to repent again, like ground that after much watering only yields thorns (6:4-8), like Esau who could not find a place of repentance even though he sought it with tears (12:16-17). It seems impossible to work around what Hebrews is saying here, that a person can be genuinely "in" and yet not make it because they turn away.
So also Paul presses on in hope to get that "upward call" of God in Christ Jesus (Phil. 3:14). He has not yet attained a guarantee of the resurrection (Phil. 3:11-12). It is something he strives toward. He must continue to be faithful if he hopes to be perfected when Christ returns. His sufferings are like a sharing in Christ's sufferings "if somehow I may attain the resurrection from the dead" (Phil. 3:11, NRSV). What we find is that Paul himself talks like an Arminian, and it is arguably only the theological system of various Protestant groups that makes this thinking problematic.
Wednesday, December 15, 2010
Be Faithful 2
The previous post.
__________
Against this general Protestant background, the Wesleyan-Arminian tradition stands out in two clear ways. First, the Wesleyan tradition is more optimistic about just how righteous God wants to make us in this life. Most Romans experts have come to realize that Romans 7 is not about Paul's current struggle with temptation ("I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I do," 7:19). It is Paul vividly acting out the struggle of a Jew who wants to keep the core commands of the Jewish Law, but who does not have the Spirit to empower him or her to do it. Yet most of popular Christianity continues to see Romans 7 as the default struggle of a Christian with sin.
In that sense, this is a great time for the Wesleyan tradition, for Pauline scholarship has come these last few decades to affirm our basic understanding of Paul on sin in Romans. For example, one cannot take Romans 7 to be about a believer's current struggle with temptation unless you rip it from Paul's entire train of thought in chapters 6-8. In Romans 6, Paul's clear point is that Christians are not to remain in sin (6:1) and that they are not to sin (6:13). We "used to be slaves to sin" (6:17), but "thanks be to God" we have been set from from sin and have become "slaves to righteousness" (6:18).
Paul repeats this imagery throughout these chapters, including in the section that leads into the last part of Romans 7 (e.g., 7:5-6). Even within the "I don't do what I want to do passage" the same pattern emerges. In 7:14-24, Paul vividly and dramatically assumes the perspective of a person who is a slave to sin. This leads up to 7:25, where Paul presents his "thanks be to God" again as it is "through Jesus Christ our Lord" that we are freed. Romans 8 then goes on to expand on the person set free from the law of sin and death (8:1), who is not "in the flesh" (8:8) and is able to keep the righteous requirement of the law (8:4) because she walks (behaves) in the Spirit (8:5). As Paul says in Galatians 5:16, "walk by the Spirit, and you will not carry out the desire of the flesh" (NASB).
We find this same attitude toward sin throughout the New Testament. Never in the New Testament do we find any default expectation that Christians will sin. For one thing, unintentional sin is a concept that, while biblical, is hardly a concern of the New Testament. Sin that is of concern in the New Testament is conscious, intentional, "high handed" sin. Many passages are misinterpreted because of later theological lenses.
For example, 1 John 1:8 speaks of having sin in the present rather than doing sin now, and 1:10 clarifies that the issue is someone who claims not to need Christ's atonement at all. In Philippians 3:12, Paul does not say that he is not perfect in the way we think of perfection in English. The previous verse makes it clear that by perfection he is speaking of resurrection. He is not yet guaranteed resurrection, because he must continue on in faithfulness to be assured the "upward call" (3:14). Only James 3:2 points to our common human failings, and here the word "sin" is not used. The notion of sin as anything short of absolute perfection is not the operational definition of sin in the New Testament, which would be better defined as to do wrong, especially to do wrong intentionally.
It thus turns out that the Wesleyan tradition, along with other pietist traditions, seems to treat sin much as Paul did in his original context. Indeed, Paul was far more in continuity with his Jewish background on these issues than the high Protestant traditions have previously allowed, and they have understandably struggled more with the "new perspective on Paul" than the Wesleyan tradition has. Wesleyan and pietist traditions thus accurately have an optimism about the degree to which God wants to empower a believer to become righteous.
Indeed, the Wesleyan tradition has taught that believers might, by the Spirit's power, go the entirety of the rest of their Christian lives without ever intentionally wronging God or another, and that they might do it with joy. If you are confronted with a choice--you know God's will is A but you are tempted by B--Wesleyans believe you can consistently, perhaps even without exception, choose A. Although Wesley used the word "perfection" in relation to this goal, that language is probably unproductive today--it can lead to unprofitable introspection and self-doubt. The basic point is clear: "No testing has overtaken you that is not common to everyone. God is faithful, and he will not let you be tested beyond your strength, but with the testing he will also provide the way out so that you may be able to endure it" (1 Cor. 10:13).
__________
Against this general Protestant background, the Wesleyan-Arminian tradition stands out in two clear ways. First, the Wesleyan tradition is more optimistic about just how righteous God wants to make us in this life. Most Romans experts have come to realize that Romans 7 is not about Paul's current struggle with temptation ("I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I do," 7:19). It is Paul vividly acting out the struggle of a Jew who wants to keep the core commands of the Jewish Law, but who does not have the Spirit to empower him or her to do it. Yet most of popular Christianity continues to see Romans 7 as the default struggle of a Christian with sin.
In that sense, this is a great time for the Wesleyan tradition, for Pauline scholarship has come these last few decades to affirm our basic understanding of Paul on sin in Romans. For example, one cannot take Romans 7 to be about a believer's current struggle with temptation unless you rip it from Paul's entire train of thought in chapters 6-8. In Romans 6, Paul's clear point is that Christians are not to remain in sin (6:1) and that they are not to sin (6:13). We "used to be slaves to sin" (6:17), but "thanks be to God" we have been set from from sin and have become "slaves to righteousness" (6:18).
Paul repeats this imagery throughout these chapters, including in the section that leads into the last part of Romans 7 (e.g., 7:5-6). Even within the "I don't do what I want to do passage" the same pattern emerges. In 7:14-24, Paul vividly and dramatically assumes the perspective of a person who is a slave to sin. This leads up to 7:25, where Paul presents his "thanks be to God" again as it is "through Jesus Christ our Lord" that we are freed. Romans 8 then goes on to expand on the person set free from the law of sin and death (8:1), who is not "in the flesh" (8:8) and is able to keep the righteous requirement of the law (8:4) because she walks (behaves) in the Spirit (8:5). As Paul says in Galatians 5:16, "walk by the Spirit, and you will not carry out the desire of the flesh" (NASB).
We find this same attitude toward sin throughout the New Testament. Never in the New Testament do we find any default expectation that Christians will sin. For one thing, unintentional sin is a concept that, while biblical, is hardly a concern of the New Testament. Sin that is of concern in the New Testament is conscious, intentional, "high handed" sin. Many passages are misinterpreted because of later theological lenses.
For example, 1 John 1:8 speaks of having sin in the present rather than doing sin now, and 1:10 clarifies that the issue is someone who claims not to need Christ's atonement at all. In Philippians 3:12, Paul does not say that he is not perfect in the way we think of perfection in English. The previous verse makes it clear that by perfection he is speaking of resurrection. He is not yet guaranteed resurrection, because he must continue on in faithfulness to be assured the "upward call" (3:14). Only James 3:2 points to our common human failings, and here the word "sin" is not used. The notion of sin as anything short of absolute perfection is not the operational definition of sin in the New Testament, which would be better defined as to do wrong, especially to do wrong intentionally.
It thus turns out that the Wesleyan tradition, along with other pietist traditions, seems to treat sin much as Paul did in his original context. Indeed, Paul was far more in continuity with his Jewish background on these issues than the high Protestant traditions have previously allowed, and they have understandably struggled more with the "new perspective on Paul" than the Wesleyan tradition has. Wesleyan and pietist traditions thus accurately have an optimism about the degree to which God wants to empower a believer to become righteous.
Indeed, the Wesleyan tradition has taught that believers might, by the Spirit's power, go the entirety of the rest of their Christian lives without ever intentionally wronging God or another, and that they might do it with joy. If you are confronted with a choice--you know God's will is A but you are tempted by B--Wesleyans believe you can consistently, perhaps even without exception, choose A. Although Wesley used the word "perfection" in relation to this goal, that language is probably unproductive today--it can lead to unprofitable introspection and self-doubt. The basic point is clear: "No testing has overtaken you that is not common to everyone. God is faithful, and he will not let you be tested beyond your strength, but with the testing he will also provide the way out so that you may be able to endure it" (1 Cor. 10:13).
Tuesday, December 14, 2010
Earmarks do a lot of good...
I can think of a better system for doing the good that earmarks do, but since everyone seems to assume unthinkingly that they are bad, I want to put my hands up for the good they do.
"Earmarks" are basically add-ons to legislation that are often tangential to that legislation. They are currently under fire because 1) they seem sneaky, 2) they are associated with "special interest groups," and 3) the current libertarian atmosphere. They seem sneaky because they are like the little fish that attach themselves to whales. You want the whale, not the Remora attached to it. But because you want the whale, you take the Remora too. It's too hard to get legislation through to propose a bill just about that bridge that would bring commerce to the little island you live on. So you slip it in with something else.
Certainly special interest groups lobby for them. The ethanol companies in my state would sure love that tax deduction, and that will help my state's economy. Then there's the libertarian thing. Why should I as a citizen of Indiana be paying for some bridge in Alaska?
After saying all that, I oppose doing away with earmarks until some other system to replace the good it does is in place. The things these earmarks do are often the difference between the necessary and the beneficial. Can we live with the ferry taking us to the island? Yes. But how much better things would be if we had a bridge, and my state does not have the extra money to build it.
As far as the libertarian argument goes, the principle is that what goes around comes around. I may pay for your bridge today, but you will help my university tomorrow. We all become better together than any of us could be alone. This is the fatal flaw of libertarianism. The sum is greater than its parts.
I'm sure there is a better way to do it, maybe a pie from which every state received a certain percentage for these sorts of projects. But until something like that is in place, it would impoverish us to do away with earmarks. Cut them down? Absolutely. Be very careful about the ludicrous ones? Absolutely. But recognize the great value they have played in enriching America as a whole? Certainly.
"Earmarks" are basically add-ons to legislation that are often tangential to that legislation. They are currently under fire because 1) they seem sneaky, 2) they are associated with "special interest groups," and 3) the current libertarian atmosphere. They seem sneaky because they are like the little fish that attach themselves to whales. You want the whale, not the Remora attached to it. But because you want the whale, you take the Remora too. It's too hard to get legislation through to propose a bill just about that bridge that would bring commerce to the little island you live on. So you slip it in with something else.
Certainly special interest groups lobby for them. The ethanol companies in my state would sure love that tax deduction, and that will help my state's economy. Then there's the libertarian thing. Why should I as a citizen of Indiana be paying for some bridge in Alaska?
After saying all that, I oppose doing away with earmarks until some other system to replace the good it does is in place. The things these earmarks do are often the difference between the necessary and the beneficial. Can we live with the ferry taking us to the island? Yes. But how much better things would be if we had a bridge, and my state does not have the extra money to build it.
As far as the libertarian argument goes, the principle is that what goes around comes around. I may pay for your bridge today, but you will help my university tomorrow. We all become better together than any of us could be alone. This is the fatal flaw of libertarianism. The sum is greater than its parts.
I'm sure there is a better way to do it, maybe a pie from which every state received a certain percentage for these sorts of projects. But until something like that is in place, it would impoverish us to do away with earmarks. Cut them down? Absolutely. Be very careful about the ludicrous ones? Absolutely. But recognize the great value they have played in enriching America as a whole? Certainly.
Be Faithful 1
All the mainstream Christian traditions would share in common the sense that we must be faithful to God who has graciously called us and welcomed us into his coming kingdom. Even the Lutheran tradition, which perhaps wants to talk the least about "works" in the Christian life, will hesitantly acknowledge that if a person is in Christ, then his or her life should improve. The standard Protestant understanding is that salvation is "by grace alone" (sola gratia), meaning that it is strictly a matter of God's favor, not something we can earn. It is "by faith alone" (sola fide), meaning it is only because of our faith, which itself is a gift of God, "not from works, so that no one can boast" (Eph. 2:8). It is "by Christ alone" (sola Christi), and we can find no other path to God.
Where traditions differ is in how optimistic they are about how much God wants to "sanctify" us, actually make us righteous. They also differ about whether the way we live after God has "justified" us, made us right with him, has any impact on the continued state of our relationship with him. You can see the logic of some. If we are not made right with God by works, then our works cannot make us "un-right" with God either.
For the Calvinist, grace is "irresistable," so the only one who could take it away is God himself. And if God has given it to you, then why would he take it away? If God has chosen you, you will make it. You will persevere till the end. For the Lutheran, salvation is totally by faith, so while our works should improve as Christians, they have nothing to do with our salvation one way or another. In fact, even talking about them is unhealthy because it might tempt us to boast in our own goodness. Baptists have combined the Arminian sense of assurance (you can know now that you are saved) with the Calvinist sense that the elect will persevere (because God's grace is irresistable), resulting in the hybrid view that once a person is truly saved, that person will always be saved: "eternal security."
Against this general Protestant background, the Wesleyan-Arminian tradition stands out in two clear ways. First, the Wesleyan tradition is more optimistic about just how righteous God wants to make us in this life...
Where traditions differ is in how optimistic they are about how much God wants to "sanctify" us, actually make us righteous. They also differ about whether the way we live after God has "justified" us, made us right with him, has any impact on the continued state of our relationship with him. You can see the logic of some. If we are not made right with God by works, then our works cannot make us "un-right" with God either.
For the Calvinist, grace is "irresistable," so the only one who could take it away is God himself. And if God has given it to you, then why would he take it away? If God has chosen you, you will make it. You will persevere till the end. For the Lutheran, salvation is totally by faith, so while our works should improve as Christians, they have nothing to do with our salvation one way or another. In fact, even talking about them is unhealthy because it might tempt us to boast in our own goodness. Baptists have combined the Arminian sense of assurance (you can know now that you are saved) with the Calvinist sense that the elect will persevere (because God's grace is irresistable), resulting in the hybrid view that once a person is truly saved, that person will always be saved: "eternal security."
Against this general Protestant background, the Wesleyan-Arminian tradition stands out in two clear ways. First, the Wesleyan tradition is more optimistic about just how righteous God wants to make us in this life...
Monday, December 13, 2010
Love Neighbor 3
The last bread crumb was here.
__________
The history of the Wesleyan tradition, indeed the origins of my own branch of it, went beyond the principle of helping the individual needy to a concern for the structures of society as they perpetuate inequity. Addressing the "hateful" structures of a society is loving your neighbor written large. The Wesleyan Methodist Church traces its origins to 1843 when a group of Methodists withdrew from the Methodist Episcopal Church primarily in opposition to slavery as an institution in the United States. Along with Quakers, some of these individuals participated in the underground railroad and one can still see the bullet holes in one of the church buildings that survives in the South.
In keeping with their sense of the trajectory of the gospel, they were some of the first in recent times to acknowledge that God could call women as well as men to preach the gospel, in keeping with the promise of this age of Christ, when God's sons and daughters would prophesy (Acts 2:17). It was in the building of a Wesleyan Methodist Church in Seneca Falls, New York, that the movement to give women the right to vote, the birth of the women's rights movement, took place. And Luther Lee, one of the founders of the Wesleyan Methodist Church, preached the sermon at the service of the first woman to be ordained in America, Antoinette Brown, in 1851.
As we mentioned above, the Wesleyan tradition could take these positions because it recognized the priority of the principles of Scripture over its time-bound particulars. This is not to say that our parents in the faith had worked through their hermeneutic in sophisticated terms. It is only to say that they recognized that in their time, it seemed impossible to play out the core principles of the gospel and perpetuate structures that Scripture allowed, such as slavery.
At the same time, we are prone to miss the ministry role that, for example, women actually played in the ministry of the early church. We would argue that only one passage in the entire Bible potentially stands in tension with women in ministry--1 Timothy 2:11-15--at that it is really much more about the husband-wife relationship than women preaching. By contrast, we have ample evidence that in practice women worked side-by-side with men in ministry. There was nothing unusual for Phoebe to be a deacon in Romans 16:1 or for Junia to be an apostle in Romans 16:7. The book of Acts also treats the ministries of women like Priscilla (Acts 18:26) or Lydia (Acts 16:15), just as Paul speaks of Euodia and Syntyche (Phil. 4:2-3).
We wonder if today even the structure of husband headship in the home, a concept whose language and categories come more from Greek political theory than from the Old Testament, is a structure God would have us abolish today in the name of Christ. The subordination of Eve to Adam in Genesis 3 was a consequence of the Fall, and Christ has atoned for all the sins of Adam, let alone the sins of Eve. We know that women are not in any way innately inferior to men intellectually, spiritually, or as leaders. Nothing stops us today--indeed we improve our witness to the world--if we advocate for women as complete co-partners with men in all areas of life, including the home, without putting on them the artificial distinctions of ancient culture. In the kingdom women will not be "given to men" in marriage, in subordination as they were. What would stop us from making the structures of earth now more like the structures of heaven?
There may be other societal structures our love of neighbor will want to speak prophetically to. Those of us who are "white"--a construct that only means we do not look like those who are "other"--do not realize the ease with which we move through life in comparison to others. We do not have police or store owners scrutinize us more carefully because of how we look. We do not face the likelihood of distrust in many of our dealings with others. We often to not realize the additional obstacles that those who look differently face on a regular basis. The same has often been the case for women in contrast to men.
Those of us who grew up in middle-class homes where you are expected to go to college and walk into a predictable career also do not often realize the obstacles--both real and psychological--that might keep others from emerging from cycles of poverty and dependence. The path out may seems obvious to us--go get a job. But usually those who would say such things do not realize the difficulties such a seemingly simple proposition may pose (we have cars, attainable jobs that pay enough and are in good proximity, either no children or someone to take care of them). But perhaps even more serious, what seems like a common sense path to us may be to others like some skill we do not have would be to us. Suggesting someone in generational poverty go get a job might be like someone asking me to replace a water pump.
Suffice it to say, it is the charge of the Wesleyan tradition to be on guard against structural hatred of our neighbor, and to work for its abolishment and reformation. Many in our tradition failed in this charge in the twentieth century. We were not outraged that African-Americans had to ride in the back of the bus or drink from a different water fountain. Indeed, many begrudged those "trouble makers" who were causing such a societal ruckass. We largely slept through the civil rights movement, to our shame.
Even today, many grass-roots Wesleyans are more concerned about the fact that illegal immigrants have broken the rules in getting here than about the lives of real people and the potential consequences of reactionary laws to children and adult alike. Suffice it to say that this attitude is not only out of sync with the Wesleyan tradition. It does not know the mind of Christ as revealed in the New Testament, nor the dictates of the Old Testament law toward strangers in Israel's midst. No "true Wesleyan," the name of some of an early journal of our tradition, will have such attitudes today. The working out of principles is complicated. These values are not.
__________
The history of the Wesleyan tradition, indeed the origins of my own branch of it, went beyond the principle of helping the individual needy to a concern for the structures of society as they perpetuate inequity. Addressing the "hateful" structures of a society is loving your neighbor written large. The Wesleyan Methodist Church traces its origins to 1843 when a group of Methodists withdrew from the Methodist Episcopal Church primarily in opposition to slavery as an institution in the United States. Along with Quakers, some of these individuals participated in the underground railroad and one can still see the bullet holes in one of the church buildings that survives in the South.
In keeping with their sense of the trajectory of the gospel, they were some of the first in recent times to acknowledge that God could call women as well as men to preach the gospel, in keeping with the promise of this age of Christ, when God's sons and daughters would prophesy (Acts 2:17). It was in the building of a Wesleyan Methodist Church in Seneca Falls, New York, that the movement to give women the right to vote, the birth of the women's rights movement, took place. And Luther Lee, one of the founders of the Wesleyan Methodist Church, preached the sermon at the service of the first woman to be ordained in America, Antoinette Brown, in 1851.
As we mentioned above, the Wesleyan tradition could take these positions because it recognized the priority of the principles of Scripture over its time-bound particulars. This is not to say that our parents in the faith had worked through their hermeneutic in sophisticated terms. It is only to say that they recognized that in their time, it seemed impossible to play out the core principles of the gospel and perpetuate structures that Scripture allowed, such as slavery.
At the same time, we are prone to miss the ministry role that, for example, women actually played in the ministry of the early church. We would argue that only one passage in the entire Bible potentially stands in tension with women in ministry--1 Timothy 2:11-15--at that it is really much more about the husband-wife relationship than women preaching. By contrast, we have ample evidence that in practice women worked side-by-side with men in ministry. There was nothing unusual for Phoebe to be a deacon in Romans 16:1 or for Junia to be an apostle in Romans 16:7. The book of Acts also treats the ministries of women like Priscilla (Acts 18:26) or Lydia (Acts 16:15), just as Paul speaks of Euodia and Syntyche (Phil. 4:2-3).
We wonder if today even the structure of husband headship in the home, a concept whose language and categories come more from Greek political theory than from the Old Testament, is a structure God would have us abolish today in the name of Christ. The subordination of Eve to Adam in Genesis 3 was a consequence of the Fall, and Christ has atoned for all the sins of Adam, let alone the sins of Eve. We know that women are not in any way innately inferior to men intellectually, spiritually, or as leaders. Nothing stops us today--indeed we improve our witness to the world--if we advocate for women as complete co-partners with men in all areas of life, including the home, without putting on them the artificial distinctions of ancient culture. In the kingdom women will not be "given to men" in marriage, in subordination as they were. What would stop us from making the structures of earth now more like the structures of heaven?
There may be other societal structures our love of neighbor will want to speak prophetically to. Those of us who are "white"--a construct that only means we do not look like those who are "other"--do not realize the ease with which we move through life in comparison to others. We do not have police or store owners scrutinize us more carefully because of how we look. We do not face the likelihood of distrust in many of our dealings with others. We often to not realize the additional obstacles that those who look differently face on a regular basis. The same has often been the case for women in contrast to men.
Those of us who grew up in middle-class homes where you are expected to go to college and walk into a predictable career also do not often realize the obstacles--both real and psychological--that might keep others from emerging from cycles of poverty and dependence. The path out may seems obvious to us--go get a job. But usually those who would say such things do not realize the difficulties such a seemingly simple proposition may pose (we have cars, attainable jobs that pay enough and are in good proximity, either no children or someone to take care of them). But perhaps even more serious, what seems like a common sense path to us may be to others like some skill we do not have would be to us. Suggesting someone in generational poverty go get a job might be like someone asking me to replace a water pump.
Suffice it to say, it is the charge of the Wesleyan tradition to be on guard against structural hatred of our neighbor, and to work for its abolishment and reformation. Many in our tradition failed in this charge in the twentieth century. We were not outraged that African-Americans had to ride in the back of the bus or drink from a different water fountain. Indeed, many begrudged those "trouble makers" who were causing such a societal ruckass. We largely slept through the civil rights movement, to our shame.
Even today, many grass-roots Wesleyans are more concerned about the fact that illegal immigrants have broken the rules in getting here than about the lives of real people and the potential consequences of reactionary laws to children and adult alike. Suffice it to say that this attitude is not only out of sync with the Wesleyan tradition. It does not know the mind of Christ as revealed in the New Testament, nor the dictates of the Old Testament law toward strangers in Israel's midst. No "true Wesleyan," the name of some of an early journal of our tradition, will have such attitudes today. The working out of principles is complicated. These values are not.
Sunday, December 12, 2010
Ephesians on Wives
Excerpt from chapter 7 of second Paul volume:
___________
Ephesians 5:22-33 goes on to talk not only about the relationship between husbands and wives in the church but, even more significantly, about the relationship between Christ and the church. Indeed, most of what Ephesians says in these twelve verses is perhaps more about Christ and the church, only using the husband-wife relationship as a metaphor for this more significant relationship. As far as the husband-wife relationship, Ephesians assumes the standard relationship of wife to husband in the Mediterranean world and then sanctifies it, makes it holy. There is nothing uniquely biblical or Christian to say that “the husband is the head of the wife” (5:23). Again, Aristotle had said very similar things three hundred years before when he spoke of the “rule” of the husband in the household.
What is distinctly Christian in Paul’s day was thus the heightened value he gave to women, not the subordination of the wife to the husband, willingly or not. Ephesians actually has very little to say to wives here. It merely seems to tell wives to submit to the authority of their husbands as all must submit to Christ’s authority (5:24), then it moves on to give instructions to the husband. In the last chapter, we asked whether this structure was more a matter of ancient culture or what God’s ideal might be for the present. While various Christians will disagree, we argued that because such structures will not exist in the kingdom of God, God would be pleased for us to abolish them now.
There is no reason for such structures either in relation to the intellect or potential leadership ability of women. The only reasons anyone might suggest are either cultural or simply because it is the rule. But in Western culture, giving women the same potential authority as men is not a detraction from the witness of the gospel. In our context, husband headship simply for its own sake actually diminishes the world’s estimation of Christ. And the example of Jesus and Paul quickly suggests that God does not usually make rules for their own sake, especially when the rule is a potential hindrance to the gospel. We thus take the prophetic stance that taking the household codes out of their own world and applying it to our quite different one is contrary to the gospel and the trajectory of the kingdom.
Ephesians admonishes husbands to love their wives, even to the degree that Christ loved the church and sacrificed himself for it (5:25). Some women have suggested that they would willingly submit to their husbands if they had this attitude. Certainly both husbands and wives should have this kind of love for each other. At the same time, we want to challenge such women in the same way we might have challenged slaves before the American Civil War. The woman who responds in this way is like the slave of the early 1800s who might have said, “If my master treated me like a brother or sister, I would gladly serve him.”
But the full gospel today goes way beyond, “masters, treat your slaves as if they are your brothers.” It is time for us to play the gospel out in a fuller way than even the New Testament church did in its day. It sells the kingdom short and can bury your God-given potential in the ground. Some of those most opposed to women in ministry are not men, but women who enjoy not having to take the lead, even though they have more spiritual wisdom than their husbands several times over. God does not expect every woman to lead any more than he expects every man to lead. But every woman and man should heed the charge of 1 Thessalonians 5:19 not to “put out the Spirit’s fire”!
If God calls you as a woman to lead, you had best not disobey. If God has given you the greater wisdom in a moment of decision, why impoverish those who might benefit? If you as a husband can see your wife's greater wisdom in a moment of decision, what value is there in resisting it? Clearly we must be sensitive to our circumstances. God is a God of peace. But God also is not a God of timidity!
___________
Ephesians 5:22-33 goes on to talk not only about the relationship between husbands and wives in the church but, even more significantly, about the relationship between Christ and the church. Indeed, most of what Ephesians says in these twelve verses is perhaps more about Christ and the church, only using the husband-wife relationship as a metaphor for this more significant relationship. As far as the husband-wife relationship, Ephesians assumes the standard relationship of wife to husband in the Mediterranean world and then sanctifies it, makes it holy. There is nothing uniquely biblical or Christian to say that “the husband is the head of the wife” (5:23). Again, Aristotle had said very similar things three hundred years before when he spoke of the “rule” of the husband in the household.
What is distinctly Christian in Paul’s day was thus the heightened value he gave to women, not the subordination of the wife to the husband, willingly or not. Ephesians actually has very little to say to wives here. It merely seems to tell wives to submit to the authority of their husbands as all must submit to Christ’s authority (5:24), then it moves on to give instructions to the husband. In the last chapter, we asked whether this structure was more a matter of ancient culture or what God’s ideal might be for the present. While various Christians will disagree, we argued that because such structures will not exist in the kingdom of God, God would be pleased for us to abolish them now.
There is no reason for such structures either in relation to the intellect or potential leadership ability of women. The only reasons anyone might suggest are either cultural or simply because it is the rule. But in Western culture, giving women the same potential authority as men is not a detraction from the witness of the gospel. In our context, husband headship simply for its own sake actually diminishes the world’s estimation of Christ. And the example of Jesus and Paul quickly suggests that God does not usually make rules for their own sake, especially when the rule is a potential hindrance to the gospel. We thus take the prophetic stance that taking the household codes out of their own world and applying it to our quite different one is contrary to the gospel and the trajectory of the kingdom.
Ephesians admonishes husbands to love their wives, even to the degree that Christ loved the church and sacrificed himself for it (5:25). Some women have suggested that they would willingly submit to their husbands if they had this attitude. Certainly both husbands and wives should have this kind of love for each other. At the same time, we want to challenge such women in the same way we might have challenged slaves before the American Civil War. The woman who responds in this way is like the slave of the early 1800s who might have said, “If my master treated me like a brother or sister, I would gladly serve him.”
But the full gospel today goes way beyond, “masters, treat your slaves as if they are your brothers.” It is time for us to play the gospel out in a fuller way than even the New Testament church did in its day. It sells the kingdom short and can bury your God-given potential in the ground. Some of those most opposed to women in ministry are not men, but women who enjoy not having to take the lead, even though they have more spiritual wisdom than their husbands several times over. God does not expect every woman to lead any more than he expects every man to lead. But every woman and man should heed the charge of 1 Thessalonians 5:19 not to “put out the Spirit’s fire”!
If God calls you as a woman to lead, you had best not disobey. If God has given you the greater wisdom in a moment of decision, why impoverish those who might benefit? If you as a husband can see your wife's greater wisdom in a moment of decision, what value is there in resisting it? Clearly we must be sensitive to our circumstances. God is a God of peace. But God also is not a God of timidity!
Love Neighbor 2
The first of this section is here.
________
Certainly the idea that we should love our neighbor seems uncontroversial enough for a Christian. But the question of how that love works out in practice has often been controversial. Nevertheless, very many Christians in many traditions would share the loving values that also seem common sense to the Wesleyan tradition.
For example, one of the distinctives of John Wesley's ministry was the attention he gave to coal miners and others that many of his social status deemed beneath them. He was a key participant in a movement within England that not only ended in the abolition of slavery not long after his death, but that very well may have saved England from the bloody revolution that took place in France near the end of his life. In the 1800s, the ongoing Wesleyan tradition gave birth to the Salvation Army, whose mission to the poor is so well known that few realize it is also a denomination in the Wesleyan tradition.
It is fascinating how so many Christians not only ignore the clear and consistent principle of helping the needy in Scripture, but have actually convinced themselves that those who do are almost evil. Perhaps some of this push back goes back to the early twentieth century in America, when those who most pushed a "social gospel" were Christians who had largely stopped believing in things like the virgin birth or Jesus' bodily resurrection. But a key perspective is to see this group's concern for the poor as all that was left of their Christianity rather than some substitute for it. Proponents of a social gospel looked to Jesus as their supreme moral example, even though they did not consider him to be God. We can feel free to critique their rejection of orthodox faith, but how deeply ironic to critique their moral impulse to ask, "What would Jesus do?"
Bringing good news to the poor and the dis-empowered thus remains a core Wesleyan value. It is not only a key value of the Pentateuch, where Israel was to help the needy in its land (e.g., Deut. 15:11). The need for "social justice" was also a key point of God's critique of Israel in the prophets (e.g., Isa. 10:2; Amos 2:7). A key element of Jesus' announcement of the coming kingdom was "good news to the poor," so much so that Luke makes it the inaugural message of Jesus' earthly ministry (Luke 4:16-21, quoting Isaiah 61:1-2). The Parable of the Sheep and the Goats assigns eternal destinies based on whether a person has fed the hungry, given drink to the thirsty, and clothed the naked (Matt. 25:31-46).
And helping the poor and dis-empowered was a key value of the early church (Acts 2:44-45; Gal. 2:10; Jas. 2:15-17; 1 John 3:17). Understandably, the majority of these examples and instructions are directed toward the needy within the church. However, the principle is to love everyone, to do good to everyone, even if the needy within the church are a focal concern (e.g., Gal. 6:10).
The application of principles must take into account the complications of life. Today we would identify many more types of people as needy than only those who are hungry. There are the addicted, the generationally poor, the abused. The goal of loving them remains, of moving them to healthy forms of life. We want not only to give out fish but to teach to fish and to help others want to fish in the first place.
Yet it is also the nature of things for us to come up with excuses for not following through on what we need to do. And thus things like the abuse of help for the needy or setting up an artificial tension between social and spiritual gospels can get in the way. The principles remain clear. The sins or abuses of others has nothing to do with our impulse to love and serve them. And the social gospel is not in competition with the spiritual gospel. They are the same gospel, and a person probably will not receive your word of "salvation" if they are hungry or greatly in need.
________
Certainly the idea that we should love our neighbor seems uncontroversial enough for a Christian. But the question of how that love works out in practice has often been controversial. Nevertheless, very many Christians in many traditions would share the loving values that also seem common sense to the Wesleyan tradition.
For example, one of the distinctives of John Wesley's ministry was the attention he gave to coal miners and others that many of his social status deemed beneath them. He was a key participant in a movement within England that not only ended in the abolition of slavery not long after his death, but that very well may have saved England from the bloody revolution that took place in France near the end of his life. In the 1800s, the ongoing Wesleyan tradition gave birth to the Salvation Army, whose mission to the poor is so well known that few realize it is also a denomination in the Wesleyan tradition.
It is fascinating how so many Christians not only ignore the clear and consistent principle of helping the needy in Scripture, but have actually convinced themselves that those who do are almost evil. Perhaps some of this push back goes back to the early twentieth century in America, when those who most pushed a "social gospel" were Christians who had largely stopped believing in things like the virgin birth or Jesus' bodily resurrection. But a key perspective is to see this group's concern for the poor as all that was left of their Christianity rather than some substitute for it. Proponents of a social gospel looked to Jesus as their supreme moral example, even though they did not consider him to be God. We can feel free to critique their rejection of orthodox faith, but how deeply ironic to critique their moral impulse to ask, "What would Jesus do?"
Bringing good news to the poor and the dis-empowered thus remains a core Wesleyan value. It is not only a key value of the Pentateuch, where Israel was to help the needy in its land (e.g., Deut. 15:11). The need for "social justice" was also a key point of God's critique of Israel in the prophets (e.g., Isa. 10:2; Amos 2:7). A key element of Jesus' announcement of the coming kingdom was "good news to the poor," so much so that Luke makes it the inaugural message of Jesus' earthly ministry (Luke 4:16-21, quoting Isaiah 61:1-2). The Parable of the Sheep and the Goats assigns eternal destinies based on whether a person has fed the hungry, given drink to the thirsty, and clothed the naked (Matt. 25:31-46).
And helping the poor and dis-empowered was a key value of the early church (Acts 2:44-45; Gal. 2:10; Jas. 2:15-17; 1 John 3:17). Understandably, the majority of these examples and instructions are directed toward the needy within the church. However, the principle is to love everyone, to do good to everyone, even if the needy within the church are a focal concern (e.g., Gal. 6:10).
The application of principles must take into account the complications of life. Today we would identify many more types of people as needy than only those who are hungry. There are the addicted, the generationally poor, the abused. The goal of loving them remains, of moving them to healthy forms of life. We want not only to give out fish but to teach to fish and to help others want to fish in the first place.
Yet it is also the nature of things for us to come up with excuses for not following through on what we need to do. And thus things like the abuse of help for the needy or setting up an artificial tension between social and spiritual gospels can get in the way. The principles remain clear. The sins or abuses of others has nothing to do with our impulse to love and serve them. And the social gospel is not in competition with the spiritual gospel. They are the same gospel, and a person probably will not receive your word of "salvation" if they are hungry or greatly in need.
Saturday, December 11, 2010
My Two New Bible Studies
Wesleyan Publishing House had a good idea to go along with the two books on Paul I'm writing (the first is already out; I am incredibly excited about the second because it will be, as far as I know, the only book that goes through Romans fully bringing Wesleyan theology into dialog with developments in the study of Paul these last thirty years).
The idea WPH had was to have shorter 6 week Bible studies that were like companion pieces to the two Paul books. Two of the Bible studies are now out: one on Philippians and one on 1 Thessalonians:
What is great about these, I think, is that the parameters for writing were so tight that I had to be very concise in what each snippet of 4 or 5 verses meant and also had to apply every 4 or 5 verses. I think the result is better for pastors and laypeople than any normal commentary. You get minute meaning and application virtually paragraph by paragraph.
The constraints of the format made these painful to write but I think they might very well be the most helpful pieces I've written for use in the local church. I can't wait to write the two on Romans scheduled to come out late next year.
Thank you for enduring a short moment of personal happiness ;-)
The idea WPH had was to have shorter 6 week Bible studies that were like companion pieces to the two Paul books. Two of the Bible studies are now out: one on Philippians and one on 1 Thessalonians:
What is great about these, I think, is that the parameters for writing were so tight that I had to be very concise in what each snippet of 4 or 5 verses meant and also had to apply every 4 or 5 verses. I think the result is better for pastors and laypeople than any normal commentary. You get minute meaning and application virtually paragraph by paragraph.
The constraints of the format made these painful to write but I think they might very well be the most helpful pieces I've written for use in the local church. I can't wait to write the two on Romans scheduled to come out late next year.
Thank you for enduring a short moment of personal happiness ;-)
Love Neighbor 1
So the principle to "love neighbor" is also a Christian absolute of action. There are no circumstances where God would have us act unloving toward our neighbor, where love is perhaps best understood in terms of the Golden Rule, aptly summarized in the Sermon on the Mount: "In everything do to others as you would have them do to you; for this is the law and the prophets" (Matt. 7:12, NRSV). Love again is not about how you feel toward others but how you choose to act toward them both in your mind and action. And the rules of psychology are such that if you get in the habit of loving choices, by God's power and through the accountability of others, the feelings will follow.
A disposition to love and show mercy does not in itself contradict acts of justice. Such a disposition certainly requires acts of discipline. Love is not absolute permission, nor does a society that fosters a sense of cheap grace or self-aggrandizement truly show love to its members. While justice is not an absolute principle, it is the most loving way to structure a society, and exceptions to justice should be rare on the level of society as a whole, or else society would disintegrate. Sometimes love must also choose between who to be loving toward. Is it possible that love of one's own or love of the oppressed could force a nation to war or to self-defense?
Again, the Wesleyan tradition has historically been more optimistic than other Christian traditions about the extent to which God wants to empower a believer to be loving toward others. It has gone so far as to suggest that believers can be so empowered that they might very well make loving choices toward others consistently, perhaps even without exception, for the remainder of their time on earth, and do it with joy. In my opinion, it is counterproductive to spend much energy in introspection wondering whether or not we have fulfilled this expectation, as many in our tradition have done in the past. The key point is that you can indeed do the loving thing the next time such a choice presents itself, and you should plan on it!
A disposition to love and show mercy does not in itself contradict acts of justice. Such a disposition certainly requires acts of discipline. Love is not absolute permission, nor does a society that fosters a sense of cheap grace or self-aggrandizement truly show love to its members. While justice is not an absolute principle, it is the most loving way to structure a society, and exceptions to justice should be rare on the level of society as a whole, or else society would disintegrate. Sometimes love must also choose between who to be loving toward. Is it possible that love of one's own or love of the oppressed could force a nation to war or to self-defense?
Again, the Wesleyan tradition has historically been more optimistic than other Christian traditions about the extent to which God wants to empower a believer to be loving toward others. It has gone so far as to suggest that believers can be so empowered that they might very well make loving choices toward others consistently, perhaps even without exception, for the remainder of their time on earth, and do it with joy. In my opinion, it is counterproductive to spend much energy in introspection wondering whether or not we have fulfilled this expectation, as many in our tradition have done in the past. The key point is that you can indeed do the loving thing the next time such a choice presents itself, and you should plan on it!
Friday, December 10, 2010
Love God 3
The bread crumbs back.
________
So we are arguing that the dominant characteristic of God for the Wesleyan tradition, at least in terms of how he relates to the creation, is love rather than justice. We are arguing that God wants everyone to be saved but as sovereign king has decided not to force anyone to be saved. We are arguing that even when he acts in judgment he primarily does so in hope of redemption--as discipline rather than retribution. Christians do believe that God can and does act in final judgment, without hope of redemption, but surely this is an act of final recourse for God, one he would prefer not to do.
Our obligation in return is to "love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind" (Matt. 22:37). This is the absolute of absolutes in Christian ethics, one of the two great absolute commands of the Christian life, and indeed, the second actually folds into this first one. If we love God we will also love our neighbor. There are no exceptions to these two principles. There is no circumstance where God would have us not love him or not love our neighbor.
At the same time, the question of how to love God can quickly become rather nebulous ground. Indeed, it would be easy for a Christian to twist this command in order to violate God's will. 1 John says, "The love of God is this, that we obey his commandments" (1 John 5:3). Ah, but what are his commandments, says the interpreter, who then goes on to load the first commandment with all sorts of things that violate the second commandment, to justify hatred of one's neighbor.
So let us be clear: love of God will never contradict love of neighbor. The Parable of the Good Samaritan bids us love our neighbor (Luke 10:25-37). Jesus bids us love our enemy (Matt. 5:43-48). No one is left. Any application of Scripture or any Christian system of thought that tries to justify hatred of people, is in conflict with the first and second great commandment. Love of God can never be used to justify love of neighbor. We can hate injustice. We can hate certain ideas. We can hate sin. But we must act in love toward all people.
Here it is perhaps important to say that love in the Bible is not a matter of feeling or emotion. Love has to do with the way we act toward others, both mentally and especially concretely. We can be angry at another person and yet not sin in our thoughts or actions (Eph. 4:26). We can thus even be angry at God and not sin as well (cf. Ps. 13:1). Indeed, if we act in love toward God and others long enough, our feelings will eventually change to follow suit
To love God with all our heart is to "do everything for the glory of God" (1 Cor. 10:31). It is to live according to Colossians 3:17: "whatever you do, in word or deed, do everything in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him." John Wesley and the Wesleyan tradition have historically had a very optimistic view of the degree to which the Holy Spirit wants to empower a believer to love God. Wesley called it "Christian perfection" and his followers "entire sanctification." The Wesleyan tradition has taken very seriously the word "everything" in these two verses.
We can debate whether that focus on "everything" became unhealthy at times, leading the introspective Wesley to wonder if he was even a Christian in a moment of doubt late in life. We split hairs with others over minute questions like whether the sin principle inside us could be entirely eradicated or only suppressed. We will briefly return to this background in the section below on Christian faithfulness. Our personal sense is that these were areas where the Wesleyan "system" itself led us down unprofitable paths.
To love God, however, boils down to our choices, both in our minds and actions. And to love God in everything means that we have no idols, that we have "no other gods before God" (e.g., Exod. 20:3-4). To love God with all our heart, mind, soul, and strength is for us never to make a choice with our mind or body that gives greater loyalty to something or someone else other than God.
A distinctive of the Wesleyan tradition is our optimism about the degree to which God wants to empower us to fulfill this principle through the power of the Holy Spirit. We think a believer might from this day forward consistently, perhaps even without exception, act in this way in mind and body for the rest of their lives--and do so with joy. This is the essence of what our tradition has meant by entire sanctification.
________
So we are arguing that the dominant characteristic of God for the Wesleyan tradition, at least in terms of how he relates to the creation, is love rather than justice. We are arguing that God wants everyone to be saved but as sovereign king has decided not to force anyone to be saved. We are arguing that even when he acts in judgment he primarily does so in hope of redemption--as discipline rather than retribution. Christians do believe that God can and does act in final judgment, without hope of redemption, but surely this is an act of final recourse for God, one he would prefer not to do.
Our obligation in return is to "love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind" (Matt. 22:37). This is the absolute of absolutes in Christian ethics, one of the two great absolute commands of the Christian life, and indeed, the second actually folds into this first one. If we love God we will also love our neighbor. There are no exceptions to these two principles. There is no circumstance where God would have us not love him or not love our neighbor.
At the same time, the question of how to love God can quickly become rather nebulous ground. Indeed, it would be easy for a Christian to twist this command in order to violate God's will. 1 John says, "The love of God is this, that we obey his commandments" (1 John 5:3). Ah, but what are his commandments, says the interpreter, who then goes on to load the first commandment with all sorts of things that violate the second commandment, to justify hatred of one's neighbor.
So let us be clear: love of God will never contradict love of neighbor. The Parable of the Good Samaritan bids us love our neighbor (Luke 10:25-37). Jesus bids us love our enemy (Matt. 5:43-48). No one is left. Any application of Scripture or any Christian system of thought that tries to justify hatred of people, is in conflict with the first and second great commandment. Love of God can never be used to justify love of neighbor. We can hate injustice. We can hate certain ideas. We can hate sin. But we must act in love toward all people.
Here it is perhaps important to say that love in the Bible is not a matter of feeling or emotion. Love has to do with the way we act toward others, both mentally and especially concretely. We can be angry at another person and yet not sin in our thoughts or actions (Eph. 4:26). We can thus even be angry at God and not sin as well (cf. Ps. 13:1). Indeed, if we act in love toward God and others long enough, our feelings will eventually change to follow suit
To love God with all our heart is to "do everything for the glory of God" (1 Cor. 10:31). It is to live according to Colossians 3:17: "whatever you do, in word or deed, do everything in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him." John Wesley and the Wesleyan tradition have historically had a very optimistic view of the degree to which the Holy Spirit wants to empower a believer to love God. Wesley called it "Christian perfection" and his followers "entire sanctification." The Wesleyan tradition has taken very seriously the word "everything" in these two verses.
We can debate whether that focus on "everything" became unhealthy at times, leading the introspective Wesley to wonder if he was even a Christian in a moment of doubt late in life. We split hairs with others over minute questions like whether the sin principle inside us could be entirely eradicated or only suppressed. We will briefly return to this background in the section below on Christian faithfulness. Our personal sense is that these were areas where the Wesleyan "system" itself led us down unprofitable paths.
To love God, however, boils down to our choices, both in our minds and actions. And to love God in everything means that we have no idols, that we have "no other gods before God" (e.g., Exod. 20:3-4). To love God with all our heart, mind, soul, and strength is for us never to make a choice with our mind or body that gives greater loyalty to something or someone else other than God.
A distinctive of the Wesleyan tradition is our optimism about the degree to which God wants to empower us to fulfill this principle through the power of the Holy Spirit. We think a believer might from this day forward consistently, perhaps even without exception, act in this way in mind and body for the rest of their lives--and do so with joy. This is the essence of what our tradition has meant by entire sanctification.
Thursday, December 09, 2010
Why I like Obama and despise Congress
Once again, I am left shaking my head at:
So he's acted the way he has acted consistently. He is a realist. He is getting what he can get and compromising as necessary. Congress, meanwhile, continues to be as gridlocked as ever. If it's this bad now, things will go nowhere for the next two years.
- House Democrats who won't compromise on extending tax cuts for those earning over $250,000.
- Republicans who won't compromise on extending unemployment benefits for another year.
- Those who think Obama operates like an ideological liberal.
So he's acted the way he has acted consistently. He is a realist. He is getting what he can get and compromising as necessary. Congress, meanwhile, continues to be as gridlocked as ever. If it's this bad now, things will go nowhere for the next two years.
Wesleyans and the DREAM Act
Last night the House passed the DREAM Act. Today the Senate may not. I was thinking it provided a possible test case for Arminian vs. Calvinist theology in action. Gabriel Salguero, who is a Nazarene in the Wesleyan tradition, who teaches at Princeton, and who is one of several helping us contextualize our Missional Course into Spanish, has been one of several engaged with the White House on this bill. Similarly, Norm Wilson, a Wesleyan who teaches in IWU's undergraduate program, has been encouraging Wesleyans to support the bill.
What is the bill?
The bill addresses individuals whose parents brought them illegally to the United States before they were 18. Such individuals often are far more American than, say, Mexican. In some cases, they might not even remember Mexico, might not know how to survive in Mexico, have nowhere to go in Mexico. In some cases their parents have been deported and they are just floating around here. Maybe they have gone through our public schools and they mainly know our way of life.
In short, these are individuals in a kind of limbo. Legally, they do not belong here. Culturally, they may belong here far more than in some other place.
The DREAM act gives them a path to legality. They can enroll in college or the military for two years and if they demonstrate they are profitable members of society, they can become legal. The key criteria are that they have lived here for at least 5 years and came here before they were 18.
So how does the flavor of your Christian theology potentially affect your attitude toward this issue.
CALVINIST: Because the rules and God's justice are the main thing for the Calvinist, I suspect Calvinists will have a tendency to want to see us stick it to these kids. Tough luck Charlie. Your parents broke the rules and so you have to pay. We're going to send you back where you belong and if you have a hard time there, well, your parents should have thought of that before they broke the rules.
ARMINIAN: In God's eyes, you are just as important as I am. Legal, illegal, they are precious in his sight. The goal is redemption. What separates you from me is a piece of paper. I will do to you what I would have you do to me. If it were me, I would have nowhere clear to go and a potentially dangerous and unknown path to a place that has become a foreign land to me. If it were me, I would want you to have mercy on me and let me make a go for myself, let me contribute something to your society, which I would own as my society. I suspect that the true Arminian would be biased to be sympathetic to this Act--only the details would then lead me to be against it.
I don't think there are any such details in this case. This Act is all about biases. Are you a legalist without compassion? You will tend to be knee jerk against it. I think anyone with the heart of Christ will have a bias toward passing it.
What is the bill?
The bill addresses individuals whose parents brought them illegally to the United States before they were 18. Such individuals often are far more American than, say, Mexican. In some cases, they might not even remember Mexico, might not know how to survive in Mexico, have nowhere to go in Mexico. In some cases their parents have been deported and they are just floating around here. Maybe they have gone through our public schools and they mainly know our way of life.
In short, these are individuals in a kind of limbo. Legally, they do not belong here. Culturally, they may belong here far more than in some other place.
The DREAM act gives them a path to legality. They can enroll in college or the military for two years and if they demonstrate they are profitable members of society, they can become legal. The key criteria are that they have lived here for at least 5 years and came here before they were 18.
So how does the flavor of your Christian theology potentially affect your attitude toward this issue.
CALVINIST: Because the rules and God's justice are the main thing for the Calvinist, I suspect Calvinists will have a tendency to want to see us stick it to these kids. Tough luck Charlie. Your parents broke the rules and so you have to pay. We're going to send you back where you belong and if you have a hard time there, well, your parents should have thought of that before they broke the rules.
ARMINIAN: In God's eyes, you are just as important as I am. Legal, illegal, they are precious in his sight. The goal is redemption. What separates you from me is a piece of paper. I will do to you what I would have you do to me. If it were me, I would have nowhere clear to go and a potentially dangerous and unknown path to a place that has become a foreign land to me. If it were me, I would want you to have mercy on me and let me make a go for myself, let me contribute something to your society, which I would own as my society. I suspect that the true Arminian would be biased to be sympathetic to this Act--only the details would then lead me to be against it.
I don't think there are any such details in this case. This Act is all about biases. Are you a legalist without compassion? You will tend to be knee jerk against it. I think anyone with the heart of Christ will have a bias toward passing it.
Wednesday, December 08, 2010
Love God 2
The first post in this section is here.
_____
The Wesleyan tradition thus shares with many Baptists, Catholics, and various other pietist traditions some sense of "free will." We should be careful how we define it, however. We probably should not say that people can come to God any time they choose. And historically, the Wesleyan tradition is not saying people have any power in themselves to move toward God. We are saying that, at some point of everyone's life, God gives everyone the opportunity and empowerment to move toward him.
Now mind you, this is all Wesleyan theological glue. The biblical text no more spells these parts of our system out than it spells out the Calvinist idea that God does not really want everyone to be saved. We are picking some truth and playing it out, justifying it in the theological system of our creation. When we Wesleyans talk about prevenient grace, we are doing our best to work out a system of ideas that undergirds aspects of truth and practice we think are clear. We might think of these ideas as more suggestive than definitive, pictures more than equations.
One way to get a sense of Wesleyan identity here is to say that, for Wesleyans, God's mercy is his primary operating mode in this world than his justice. God would rather forgive than punish. Indeed, we would prefer to see God's punishment as formative rather than punitive. This orientation means when God disciplines us in this world, he does so to make us better and ultimately to save us, rather than to ensure that judgment is dispensed.
This orientation has all sorts of implications for life. Does a parent punish a child because she or he has it coming or to help the child to learn not to do harmful things? Do we discipline to redeem or to satisfy wrath? To be sure, we find both images in Scripture, but we remember that God revealed Scripture in the categories of its audiences, rather than purely on God's own terms.
Again, this communicative model coheres with the Wesleyan sense of God. God comes down; God reaches out and communicates in terms his audience can understand because he wants them to come to him. The other model pictures it unworthy of God to come to you. You must come to him and understand him on his terms and, since you are incapable, you are lost except for those lucky, arbitrary few he sends for.
So while many Wesleyans and Wesley himself believed in "penal substitution," many Wesleyans also sit rather loosely to it. Penal substitution is the idea that Jesus took our punishment on the cross, usually in a rather legalistic way. Did Jesus take our place on the cross? Certainly there is a sense in which he did. Paul says in Galatians 3 that we were under a curse and Christ transferred our curse to him. Did Jesus take our punishment? There is a general sense in which he did, since a sacrifice involves this dynamic of satisfying God's anger.
But the way these individual truths are often combined into a system can become quite questionable. So by the reckoning of some, God's justice demands that he get the exact amount of punishment required of every sin. So in order to reconcile us to God, Jesus had to take on himself this exact amount of punishment, which in effect was infinite because the smallest disobedience of God demands infinite punishment. To do so, Jesus had to be God to be able to satisfy infinite punishment, but he had to be human so that the right party was experiencing the punishment. Jesus' descent to hell satisfied this requirement of justice.
Again, what a logical system! And yet it is equally unbiblical. Is God really such a "bean counter" of offenses against himself? What of the Parable of the Prodigal Son, where the father has the authority simply to forgive his dishonoring son? What of the Parable of the Unforgiving Servant where the master has the authority simply to write off his servant's debt.
Something about Jesus' death does seem to satisfy the order of things. It is hard to imagine us as humans sensing the magnitude of our need for reconciliation without it. Nor does it seem we could grasp the magnitude of God's love for us without the cross. But could God have forgiven us by his command, simply because he chose to do so? It is hard for me personally to think he could not have. After all, do I not in love exercise this grace with my own children from time to time? Am I greater or more loving than God? Surely not.
_____
The Wesleyan tradition thus shares with many Baptists, Catholics, and various other pietist traditions some sense of "free will." We should be careful how we define it, however. We probably should not say that people can come to God any time they choose. And historically, the Wesleyan tradition is not saying people have any power in themselves to move toward God. We are saying that, at some point of everyone's life, God gives everyone the opportunity and empowerment to move toward him.
Now mind you, this is all Wesleyan theological glue. The biblical text no more spells these parts of our system out than it spells out the Calvinist idea that God does not really want everyone to be saved. We are picking some truth and playing it out, justifying it in the theological system of our creation. When we Wesleyans talk about prevenient grace, we are doing our best to work out a system of ideas that undergirds aspects of truth and practice we think are clear. We might think of these ideas as more suggestive than definitive, pictures more than equations.
One way to get a sense of Wesleyan identity here is to say that, for Wesleyans, God's mercy is his primary operating mode in this world than his justice. God would rather forgive than punish. Indeed, we would prefer to see God's punishment as formative rather than punitive. This orientation means when God disciplines us in this world, he does so to make us better and ultimately to save us, rather than to ensure that judgment is dispensed.
This orientation has all sorts of implications for life. Does a parent punish a child because she or he has it coming or to help the child to learn not to do harmful things? Do we discipline to redeem or to satisfy wrath? To be sure, we find both images in Scripture, but we remember that God revealed Scripture in the categories of its audiences, rather than purely on God's own terms.
Again, this communicative model coheres with the Wesleyan sense of God. God comes down; God reaches out and communicates in terms his audience can understand because he wants them to come to him. The other model pictures it unworthy of God to come to you. You must come to him and understand him on his terms and, since you are incapable, you are lost except for those lucky, arbitrary few he sends for.
So while many Wesleyans and Wesley himself believed in "penal substitution," many Wesleyans also sit rather loosely to it. Penal substitution is the idea that Jesus took our punishment on the cross, usually in a rather legalistic way. Did Jesus take our place on the cross? Certainly there is a sense in which he did. Paul says in Galatians 3 that we were under a curse and Christ transferred our curse to him. Did Jesus take our punishment? There is a general sense in which he did, since a sacrifice involves this dynamic of satisfying God's anger.
But the way these individual truths are often combined into a system can become quite questionable. So by the reckoning of some, God's justice demands that he get the exact amount of punishment required of every sin. So in order to reconcile us to God, Jesus had to take on himself this exact amount of punishment, which in effect was infinite because the smallest disobedience of God demands infinite punishment. To do so, Jesus had to be God to be able to satisfy infinite punishment, but he had to be human so that the right party was experiencing the punishment. Jesus' descent to hell satisfied this requirement of justice.
Again, what a logical system! And yet it is equally unbiblical. Is God really such a "bean counter" of offenses against himself? What of the Parable of the Prodigal Son, where the father has the authority simply to forgive his dishonoring son? What of the Parable of the Unforgiving Servant where the master has the authority simply to write off his servant's debt.
Something about Jesus' death does seem to satisfy the order of things. It is hard to imagine us as humans sensing the magnitude of our need for reconciliation without it. Nor does it seem we could grasp the magnitude of God's love for us without the cross. But could God have forgiven us by his command, simply because he chose to do so? It is hard for me personally to think he could not have. After all, do I not in love exercise this grace with my own children from time to time? Am I greater or more loving than God? Surely not.
An Arminian Fellowship?
Another throw away thought I had Monday. I was thinking this morning how much my theology has in common with more than just the Wesleyan tradition. For example, Scot McKnight wouldn't agree with me on everything, but he is broadly Arminian I think. So is the Evangelical Covenant Church of North Park. So is the Anabaptist tradition here at Messiah. In fact, the bulk of Baptists are broadly Arminian (General Baptists).
What I'm saying is that a lot of Christian traditions agree on God's provision for everyone to be saved and his empowerment for us to choose him. We might differ on how you spin "the security of believers," but we are pretty much agreed on the first four parts of the TULI-P.
I wonder if anyone has ever thought about putting together an Arminian fellowship? Not sure why other than the fact that it is good to break bread together.
Just an idle thought...
What I'm saying is that a lot of Christian traditions agree on God's provision for everyone to be saved and his empowerment for us to choose him. We might differ on how you spin "the security of believers," but we are pretty much agreed on the first four parts of the TULI-P.
I wonder if anyone has ever thought about putting together an Arminian fellowship? Not sure why other than the fact that it is good to break bread together.
Just an idle thought...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

