Thursday, July 21, 2022

Explanatory Notes -- Hebrews 12:1-11

I'm almost done with explanatory notes on Hebrews. Second to last installment.

________________________________

C. Endure God's Discipline (12:1-29)

The Cloud of Witnesses (12:1-2)

12:1-2 Therefore, we also having such a great cloud surrounding us of witnesses, laying aside every weight and the easily ensnaring sin, with endurance let us run the set before us race. 2 looking toward the leader and perfecter of faith, Jesus, who for the joy set before him endured the cross, despising shame, and on the right [hand] of the throne of God has sat.

The word therefore suggests that these verses tell us what our take-away should be from the example list of Hebrews 11. Given the examples of Hebrews 11, the audience should run with patience the race set before them. The examples ran the race with distinction. So should we. 

If you are running a race, you do not want any extra weight. Sin weighs a person down as they run. The sin the author primarily has in mind is the sin of doubt and lack of faith about the promises of God. We might generalize the point however to anything in our lives that causes resistance to the love of God and the love of neighbor.

Jesus is an example of such faith for the audience (cf. 5:7). He was the pioneer of such faith and his faith became complete in his suffering on the cross. In a sense, if the heroes of faith from Hebrews 11 are in the stands cheering us on, Jesus is at the finish line. He is the goal toward which we run, the consummate and final example of faith.

Jesus disregarded the shame, another example of honor-shame language in Hebrews. Another translation suggests that Jesus "despised" shame, an ironic twist because it suggests that Jesus made shameful calling his death shameful.

Jesus' sitting at God's right hand is another allusion to Psalm 110:1. Jesus' race is finished, although he will appear yet a second time (9:28). He currently sits enthroned as Son of God, Lord, and Christ at God's right hand.

Endure God's Discipline (12:3-11)

3. For consider the one who has endured such hostility on himself from sinners so that you might not be discouraged, giving up in your souls.

We sometimes forget that Jesus himself is in the hall of faith. He is the last and consummate example of faithfulness to death. We look to him not only as the one who rescues and saves us but as the one who perfected and completed faithfulness as our model. We look to him at the finish line as yet another who has run the race and completed the course.

Jesus endured hostility from sinners just as the audience either already was or were afraid they were about to. "Sinners" here presumably connects not to sin in general but to the sinfulness of opposing God and God's plan. God raised Jesus victorious from the grave and so also the audience should not be discouraged and lose heart. The worst that humans might do to them was nothing compared to the victory that would follow. 

We can give up in our "souls" even though our body continues on. This is similar to the expression "to lose heart." Perhaps the primary pastoral purpose of Hebrews is to keep the audience from losing heart and quitting their faith. 

4. Not yet to blood have you resisted in your struggle against sin. 

William Lane used this verse to argue that Hebrews must have been written before the persecution the Roman emperor Nero conducted around the year AD64 after the fire of Rome. [1] He was assuming the common view that Hebrews was a sermon sent to Rome. I share this inclination but not his conclusion.

This verse suggests that, in the current situation of the audience, no one in their community as yet has lost their lives. By contrast, 13:7 suggests that some of the earliest evangelists to the audience had indeed lost their lives as martyrs for their faith. In my view, this verse also does not preclude the possibility that some Jews from outside their community might have lost their lives in some event such as when prisoners from Jerusalem were executed in the aftermath of the Jewish War.

5. And have you completely forgotten the admonition that is directed to you as sons [and daughters], 

"My son, do not minimize the discipline of the Lord
    Nor give up when being corrected by him.
6. For the Lord disciplines the one whom he loves,
    And he punishes every son that he receives?"

12:5-11 use the analogy of a parent disciplining a child as what God is doing to the audience. God, as the audience's father, is disciplining them. They need to learn from the discipline. The author draws on Proverbs 3:12 to encourage the audience to view their troubles as a positive thing, as the Lord's "discipline." 

The word discipline has two distinct meanings, and the author may float somewhat between them. We probably naturally think of discipline as punishment, and the use of Proverbs 3:12 does seem to have some of that connotation. However, it also can have a sense of training, and the use of the Greek word paideia probably suggests some of those overtones as well.

The experiences of the audience are thus "discipline." There does seem to be at least a little sense of punishment here. Proverbs 3:12 has a connotation of correction and punishment. Perhaps the correction was a waning in commitment. As 10:25 indicates that some had stopped meeting together. The social pressure the audience is feeling is forcing them to choose. They cannot simply fade away. They must make a choice to strengthen their commitment or abandon their faith consciously.

This passage gives a small window into how parental discipline was understood by the author of Hebrews. Punishment was seen as loving redirection. There is no sense here of punishment as penalty that must be dispersed for wrath sake, for judgment sake. Correction is for the benefit of the child, not to satisfy some abstract justice.

7. Endure for training. God is treating you as sons [and daughters], for what son [or daughter] is there whom a father does not discipline? 8. And if you are without discipline, in which all have become partakers, are you then not illegitimate and not sons [and daughters]? 

I have rendered the word paideia as "training" here. The theme of discipline as training was a commonplace in ancient Hellenistic literature. The theme appears in Philo, for example. The purpose of the Greek "gymnasium" or educational system was paideia. Given the level of Greek and rhetoric in Hebrews, it is possible that the author himself underwent such training.

Legitimate children, the author says, undergo discipline by their parents, presumably their fathers in particular. It is a slightly unpleasant illustration, but the sense is that real parents discipline their children. Perhaps, the passage suggests, a father might not bother to train an illegitimate child. The father wants the best for his son, especially. That suggests the father will have expectations and perhaps be demanding because he wants to see his son excel in life.

The athletic illustration is clear. If you want to be able to run a race as best as you can, you must train. No one simply gets up one day and runs a marathon. You have to train. Even the most naturally gifted swimmer or gymnast will never come close to the Olympics without rigorous training. Our potential cannot be activated otherwise. The Lord is a trainer.

9. Then we used to have fathers [as] trainers of our flesh and we ourselves respected [them]. Will we not much more submit ourselves to the father of spirits and we will live? [2]

Hebrews' dualism once again peaks through. Our bodies, our "flesh" has a father, an earthly father. But our spirits have a Father too, a heavenly Father. In this picture, we are flesh and spirit. Each part of us has a different parentage. [3]

The statement is also an allusion to Numbers 27:16. In that verse, Yahweh is the "God of the spirits of all flesh." We think back to Genesis 2:7 where God gives breath to Adam, making him come alive. Ecclesiastes 3:21 questions whether that breath or spirit of a person returns to God at death. However, the anthropology of Hebrews is probably more along the lines of a certain Greek conceptualization as opposed to Genesis' Old Testament understanding. Plato believed that the body was the prisonhouse of the soul. In the Old Testament, a soul is a whole living being, body with breath/spirit inside it.

10. On the one hand, they for a few days were disciplining according to what seemed [right] to them. But he [disciplines us] for what is beneficial so that [we] might partake of his holiness. [4]

This verse may hint that earthly fathers were not always just in their discipline. Certainly, no human father is perfect either in the administration of punishment or training. My hunch is that ancient fathers were far less in tune with the emotional well-being of their children as we are in a post-Freudian world. They probably were quite regularly what we might think of as abusive. 

But God the Father is perfectly good and righteous in his training. He does not administer punishment on a whim, out of misinformation, or because he is having a temper tantrum. God disciplined the audience--and disciplines us--purely for our good and the good of others.

God's discipline makes it possible for us to partake of his holiness. We cannot be his unless we are his. We have to turn toward him and away from our default trajectory that is separated and alienated from him. We partake of the heavenly gift of the Holy Spirit and turn to the atonement in Christ to become purified of our stains. Through the atonement of Jesus, we are properly prepared to be in God's presence.

11. And every discipline on the one hand for that which is present does not seem to be [a matter] of joy but of grief, but afterward they repay a peaceable fruit of righteousness for those who have been exercised through it.

Here the training sense of discipline becomes clear. Those who train bear the fruit of righteousness. They do their exercises and it pays off in the fruit that follows. 

There is a saying in athletics: "No pain, no gain." It may be a little exaggerated as exercise releases endorphins that can give the person exercising a kind of high. Still, most of us can identify with the sense that the exercise itself is not always pleasurable. It is the pay off that comes after the exercise that is most rewarding. So it is with the Lord's discipline, especially when it has a dimension of corrective.

[1] William L. Lane, Hebrews ***

[2] future middle

[3] The ancients probably thought of spirit as a thin type of material, rather than the immaterial soul that Rene Descartes invented.

[4] infinitive purpose construction

Friday, July 15, 2022

Wesleyan philosophy 4 -- What is a human being?

Next installment

___________________________________ 

Non-Christian Perspectives
In Friedrich Nietzsche’s novel, Thus Spake Zarathustra, a madman interrupts a group celebrating the fact that “God is dead.” He sees what they do not see. A world in which there is no God is a world where there is no inherent right and wrong. The implication is that human life is ultimately no more significant than any other life. We may have more power, but we are no more valuable.

When I was doing my doctorate in England, I chanced upon a discussion prompt on a student’s door. The student wrote, “If humans evolved, then other forms of life are just as significant as we are.” The thought that came to me was that “if humans are merely evolved animals, then our lives are just as insignificant as those of other animals.”

It is fair enough to say that the last five hundred years have seen a general deterioration of “theism” in the European-influenced world. [1] Theism is the position that God not only exists but is involved in the world. This is the only truly Christian and indeed Wesleyan position, for if God were not involved in the world, then Christ could not be the Son of God as we believe.

Deism then became a position of many thinkers in the 1600s and 1700s. With the rise of a scientific worldview, the world was increasingly seen as a machine that ran on its own once it was initiated. God created the world, made the clock and wound it up, but now is no longer involved. A deterministic view gained prominence as the world seemed to become predictable according to strict laws of cause and effect. Interestingly, it is about this time also that Calvinism rose to prominence, in keeping with the deterministic Zeitgeist of the age.

The distinction between natural and supernatural was born. Previously, the beings of the cosmos were understood to be on a continuum of being. Heaven might be thinner material but still a type of material, an “etherial” type. Rene Descartes subtly changes the paradigm. The soul is now immaterial, part of a different realm that is supernatural, above the natural. Nature proceeds by cause and effect. The angels belong to a different realm.

Evolution made it possible for Deists to become full-blown naturalists. A naturalist, as the name suggests, rejects the supernatural. Natural, cause-effect explanations of the world become adequate. This path easily leads then to Nietzsche’s “nihilism,” a sense that everything is ultimately meaningless.

This nihilist bottom point, at its most pessimistic, concludes that human beings are little more than roadkill waiting to happen. When you look at the experimentation the Nazis did on Jews and others, you are seeing the endgame of naturalism in nihilism. Why not dehumanize other people or other races? Why not only live for yourself and what is in your own selfish interests?

In psychology, the behaviorist B. F. Skinner more or less reduced humans to animals that can be manipulated. He was not wrong about our capacity for manipulation, but he was wrong to think that we are only animals. The Christian does not see any human being as a mere animal. Yes, we are highly sophisticated animals from one point of view. But that is not the most important definer of who we are.

As a final note, the 1950s saw an attempt to look at nihilism from a “glass is half full” perspective. Sure, viewed negatively, nihilism says there is no real meaning to life or the world. But you could also look at it this way: we can make up any meaning we want.

Atheistic existentialism was a sense that we choose the meaning of life. Jean Paul Sartre famously said that, having been thrown into the world, we are responsible for everything we do. We choose our path. We define who we are. Albert Camus similarly said that the primary question of philosophy was, “Why not suicide?” If you have chosen to live, you have an implicit choice hiding somewhere for your existence. Find out what it is and go with it.

But let me show you a better way…

A Core Christian Perspective
From a Christian perspective, all human beings are created in the image of God. That makes all human beings inherently valuable. Genesis 1:27 presents humanity as the pinnacle of God’s creation. The image of God there primarily has to do with “ruling” over the rest of the creation, analogous to the dominion that God has. This of course is not a rule to destroy but is best taken as a charge to steward God’s creation. With great power comes great responsibility.

Over the years, Christians have expanded their sense of the image of God beyond this ”political image.” John Wesley also spoke of a natural image and a moral image. The natural image involved our rational faculties in that we can think, similar to the fact that God thinks. The moral image is our capacity to do good, a capacity marred by the sin of Adam and our sinful natures.

While these other possible dimensions to the image of God make sense, they largely come from later Christian theology rather than from the Bible. The idea of a moral image has some basis in Ephesians 4:24 which speaks of our new selves in Christ as created after the image of God in true righteousness and holiness. However, Wesley’s theology built a theological scaffolding around this concept that had as much to do with Augustine in the 400s as with Paul.

I doubt that the most beneficial use of image-of-God language is to boast about humanity’s place in the cosmos. Yes, we are stewards of God’s creation. Yes, we are called to be holy. Yes, we were made “a little lower than God” in one sense (Ps. 8:5). But our takeaway should not be to build ourselves up but to value the lives of others because they are image-bearers. We should not curse other humans because they were made in God’s likeness (Jas. 3:9). Because humans are the image of God, all human life must be respected.

What is a human being? A human being is the only of God’s creations, at least on earth, that is created in God’s image. All human beings are inherently valuable because all human beings are created in God’s likeness. I did not put “intrinsically” because our value is based ultimately on the value that God gives to us. In a sense, our value is derivative, dependent on God. However, God is going nowhere. God loves us eternally; therefore, all human beings are eternally valuable.

What is the meaning of life? Victor Frankl (following Nietzsche) suggested that our purpose in life is to find a “why” of our own, in good existentialist fashion: "A person with a 'why' can live with any 'how.'" However, he was not correct in the ultimate sense. God is the ground of all meaning to the universe. As the Westminster Confession put it, “What is the chief end of man?” Answer: “To glorify God and enjoy him forever.”

Amid all the other meanings to our lives–our relationships, our families, our impact on the world and others–the ultimate meaning of life is our relationship with God. Life finds its ultimate meaning in our faith and love of God, and the love of others then naturally issues therefrom. “You have made us for yourself, O Lord, and our heart is restless till it finds its rest in you” (Augustine’s Confessions). Not all may perceive such restlessness, but Christians believe that humanity finds its truest self in God.

It goes without saying, then, that no truly Christian perspective will tolerate a view of any “other” that dehumanizes them or denies them their full identity as image-bearers. The original US Constitution, which treated slaves as three-fifths of a person, was not Christian in that reckoning. Any devaluing of the immigrant or the other ethnicity or the other gender is not Christian.

Any devaluing of another race violates a Christian understanding of humanity. Even the violent criminal deserves a certain dignity as created in the image of God, even though they have denied that dignity to others. No dead human body should be left outside to rot like roadkill, no matter how immoral the person may have been in life because he or she is someone who was created in the image of God.

Wesleyans and Gender
Christians disagree on questions of egalitarianism and complementarianism The first allows virtually all roles equally to men and women, while the second specifies certain roles for the one and the other. Complementarianism can only be truly Christian if it affirms the equal value of women despite specifying differing roles for them in society and the church. I would argue that the trajectory of Wesleyanism tends toward egalitarianism, although there are many Wesleyans who are complementarians.

The Wesleyan Church holds that women can hold all roles of leadership within the church and society. A key passage in this regard is Galatians 3:28: “In Christ, there is neither Jew nor Greek. There is neither slave nor free. There is not ‘male and female.’” While this passage primarily has in mind equal access to justification, holiness and Pentecostal circles have historically seen the coming of the Spirit at Pentecost as the great equalizer. For example, Acts 2:17 indicates that one of the signs of the age of the Spirit is that sons and daughters will prophesy.

The last two decades have seen a significant emphasis in Wesleyan and other circles on the essential role of the body in our human identity. In the 2000s, there was an emphasis on bodily resurrection in books like N.T. Wright’s Surprised by Hope and Joel Green’s, Body, Soul, and Human Life: The Nature of Humanity in the Bible. Wright emphasizes that the notion of the immortality of the soul is not particularly biblical. Green similarly does his best to explain away dualistic imagery in the Bible.

This movement took a different turn in the wake of Obergefell and the legalization of gay marriage in the US. Books like Timothy Tennant’s For the Sake of the Body virtually call any dualistic conceptualization of humanity as Gnostic. In addition to biblical arguments for traditional sexuality, physical embodiment is emphasized as a kind of natural revelation of distinct human identities that are different but equal.

While I would argue that the Bible is pretty clear on what forms of sex are appropriate and inappropriate, I suspect that the anti-dualism movement has gone well beyond what might be biblically justified. Dualism in itself is not Gnostic. [2] It seems to me that while more holistic approaches to human identity are perfectly acceptable, we cannot honestly deny that the New Testament operates extensively with dualistic imagery in relation to human identity. [3]

So even if the language is ultimately metaphorical, it is perfectly biblical to conceptualize a human being as a soul or spirit in a body. “Though our outward person is wasting away, our inward person is being renewed day by day” (2 Cor. 4:16). And we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ to give an account for the things we did in the body. (2 Cor. 5:10). Wright is not wrong, but he arguably goes too far, as does Green.

While there is thus currently a trend of Wesleyans toward a more complementarian approach, this is largely due to social reaction. Many in the Wesleyan Church still see the Day of Pentecost as the great equalizer that made the nature of our bodies irrelevant when it comes to spiritual things and matters relating to leadership in the church and the home. We should not "essentialize" gender except where our bodies are overwhelmingly clear (e.g., who gets to be pregnant). [4]

This is not a Gnostic position. Sometimes it is argued that it is the egalitarians who are being assimilated into secular culture. However, where did secular culture get this equal valuing of all human beings regardless of race or gender? It is arguably the continued fumes of a Judeo-Christian worldview! Ironically, then, I would claim, some in the church are proving to be less Christian on this issue than the surrounding culture when it comes to the equal valuing of all human beings. A push away from equal status and value would be a true corruption of the church by culture away from Pentecost.

Wesleyans and Determinism
Strictly speaking, Wesleyans do not believe in free will. I might add that Augustine’s understanding of the Fall, the sinful nature, and so forth involved development from Paul’s own categories. Paul did not think of Sin as a nature but as a power over our flesh. The “I” of Paul in Romans 7 is not corrupted–-it wants to do the good (Rom. 7:18). The spirit is just overcome by the flesh (note the dualism).

Total depravity, understood in an absolute sense, is thus an Augustinian category more than a Pauline one. We might call Paul's view something more like "thoroughgoing depravity." However we parse the details, Wesleyan and Christian orthodoxy holds that we cannot do good in our own power. We cannot come to God on our own. Our moral image is marred and corrupted. Without help from the Spirit, we are powerless in the face of the power of Sin.

For John Calvin, then, the only solution was irresistible grace. God chose to save some. He predestined them for salvation. They were unconditionally elected. They were empowered to do limited righteousness. The switch was flipped on for them entirely by God. They would be saved. The rest remained in their default state of corruption and damnation.

Jakob Arminius in the late 1500s disagreed. He found in Scripture a sense that God gave a choice to far more than just certain elect. Even though it was all by God’s power, election was conditional upon our choice. Wesley used the phrase “preventing grace” to refer to empowerment from God for us to be able to choose one way or the other, despite our underlying depravity.

Wesleyans thus do not believe that our eternal destiny is predetermined. Along with the Quakers, many Wesleyans have historically believed that God “lightens everyone coming into the world” at some point (John 1:9). Instead of an on-off switch, it is more like a dimmer switch. God turns the light up enough for us to choose.

At the same time, we should not assume that the dimmer switch will always be on. God is under no obligation to leave that "prevenient grace" for our whole life, for us to choose when we get around to it. It seems enough to satisfy justice that God simply give everyone a chance at some point.

Over the years, Wesleyans have had varying senses of human freedom within this overall sense of freedom to choose for or against salvation. Wesleyans have often seen God as having a detailed, perfect, individual will for our lives, often without realizing the tension of this concept with our sense of free will. But as we saw with the free will theodicy, it is important for us to recognize a God-given human freedom to mess up any plan. This freedom suggests that what actually happens in the world is often not God’s ideal but God’s concession.

There are also what I consider to be silly objections to free will. “It would violate God’s sovereignty.” Really? What if a sovereign God wanted to give us some freedom? Would God thereby make himself unsovereign? That’s just silly. If a sovereign God wants to give his creation some freedom, that’s his right and his business. “Who are you O clay to question the potter, ‘Why have you made me thus?’”

Similarly, the idea that we cannot have free will if God knows the future seems pretty silly as well. If God in some way is outside of time, then we can simply say he has seen what will happen without causing it to happen. I use the illustration of someone watching the recording of a football game that they were actually present at. God, having already watched the game, knows what is going to happen as he watches it with us in time.

In the end, God is both immanent and transcendent. He is both in the universe going through time with us and outside the universe looking in on all time. As transcendent, he knows the future. As immanent, the Spirit goes through time with us. This is the traditional Christian perspective, and Calvinism in this regard is the outlier.

Debated Issues
The Soul
The idea of a detachable soul is philosophically very helpful. It is a potential answer to a number of potentially thorny questions. Where do humans gain the capacity for free will? Why does human personhood begin at conception? If evolution were true, what made the difference between previous hominins and humanity in the image of God? A potential answer? The soul.

Most Christians throughout history, including Wesleyans, have believed that we have a detachable soul as part of our human identity. However, there is at least the possibility that biblical imagery of the soul is a picture, an expression of an eternal truth in the categories of a particular Greek worldview. The core belief is that we will continue to exist as personal, conscious individuals for all eternity. More than one metaphor might express that truth.

Here we note that the concept of a detachable soul is not as thoroughgoing in Scripture as we might think. In the Old Testament, the nephesh is not a detachable part of a person but the whole living person. “God molded the man from the dust [body] and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life [spirit], and the man became a living soul [a whole, living being]” (Gen. 2:7) The word sometimes translated “soul” in the King James Old Testament is thus never a reference to a detachable part of a person. In fact, even the living beings in the sea in Genesis 1 are also called nephesh chayyah (e.g., 1:20), “living soul.”

The New Testament often continues this concept of a soul. “Whoever loses his life [psyche] for my sake will find it” (Matt. 10:39). Obviously we don’t lose our spiritual soul to find it. Nevertheless, other passages do use the Greek sense of a detachable soul. “Do not be afraid of those who can kill the body but not the soul. Fear the one who can destroy both body and soul in Gehenna” (Matt. 10:28).

Most Wesleyans continue to understand the concept of the soul literally. A human being is thus a soul in a body. However, there are also what we might call “non-reductive physicalists” in the broader Wesleyan camp. These are individuals who believe that we are holistic embodied beings (physicalists) even though our bodies do not fully define us. Although we are unitary beings, we cannot be reduced to our bodies as the naturalist does. We are destined for eternity and glorified bodies.

Evolution
I have heard broader Wesleyans who believe in evolutionary creation speak of Adam as the first human with a soul. The notion that the genetic population of early humanity was never less than 10,000 complicates but would not necessarily make this scenario obsolete. God could at a certain point in time create souls for all the offspring of a certain pair. Such hypotheses are of course wildly speculative.

The non-reductive physicalist who believes in evolution might have a harder time demarcating when humanity truly began. Perhaps they could see the beginning of humanity in how God related to hominins rather than in some clear alteration or demarcation in human biology or anthropology. God would simply decide when humanity came to be in his image, and we would be so from then on.

Certainly, none of these questions are necessary if we go with the traditional view that humanity started full stop with the special creation of Adam. This is certainly the view Wesley had a century before the theory of evolution and the view of the vast majority of Wesleyans today.

Beginning of Personhood
The Wesleyan Church affirms that “life begins at conception.” On the one hand, I am not sure that this phrase is the best expression of what we are saying. The sperm was alive. The egg was alive. I believe it would be more precise to say something along the lines of “Human personhood begins at conception” or “The moral responsibility for preserving human life begins at conception.”

This belief emerges especially from our broader theology of life inasmuch as abortion does not seem to be explicitly addressed in Scripture. God certainly knits us in our mother's womb, as the psalmist says in Psalm 139:13 (also Jeremiah and Paul). We see this verse as an indication of God's care and concern for children developing in the womb. It is a beautiful expression of what we believe about all babies in the womb.

However, it is not a proof of that belief. We see that implication because we bring a broader belief to that text. The text itself is the reflection of one grown, sentient individual looking back on a future that God had already activated and preserved. It makes no explicit statement about all children in the womb. We see this passage as an affirmation of all life in the womb because we bring this premise with us to the psalm. We affirm the premise so it is not wrong to read the psalm with such overtones. 

Exodus 21:22 is also a passage sometimes mentioned in this discussion. It relates to a situation where a pregnant woman has “children come forth” in a fight between two men. However, similar statements in the other law codes of the Ancient Near East seem to have a miscarriage in mind. The historical context thus inclines us toward interpreting the verse as it was generally interpreted prior to the debates of recent decades. The mention of “children” coming forth is also curious since having multiple children in the womb was surely not the majority phenomenon. Perhaps it implies an unpleasant picture with not only child but various other tissues emerging in a miscarriage.

At the same time, the possibility that this Exodus passage does not treat the consequence of bringing about the child's death on the same level as harming the mother would not make the opposite case either. The Old Testament world was a brutal, vicious world. We do not stone rebellious sons or people caught in adultery. That is to say, most Christians believe that the civil law of the Old Testament was specifically directed at Israel in its ancient Near Eastern setting. The spirit of the New Testament would seem to support a less harsh, more compassionate civil code than that which Israel had in the context of the ancient world.

Here again, a belief that God creates a unique soul at conception is one way to theologically explain our sense that moral obligation for the life of the child begins at conception. Certainly, the bias of Scripture is toward the preservation of life. “Be fruitful and multiply.” It would go against the spirit of Scripture for abortion to provide a license for a promiscuous life. Any focus on “my freedom” that is selfish or trivializes life would go against the grain of Scripture.

Capital Punishment
What of war? What of capital punishment? There are Wesleyans who see a thoroughgoing “pro-life” stance as one that extends from conception to capital punishment and a pacifist stance. I deeply respect them.

However, there does not seem to be a biblical mandate for these positions. They are also theological extensions that go beyond the biblical text. For example, when the sixth commandment says not to murder, it does so in the midst of a law that frequently prescribes capital punishment and is established by way of the conquest of Canaan. In context, the sixth commandment not to murder clearly does not include these other ways of killing that are endorsed elsewhere under certain situations. It has in mind someone intentionally murdering another man or woman.

In Romans 13:4, Paul indicates that the Roman government does not “wield the sword” for no reason. This would seem to be an implicit acceptance by Paul of capital punishment by the empire. Similarly, soldiers are nowhere told in the New Testament that they must abandon their way of life, even though a number of centurions appear in the biblical pages.

That is not to say that capital punishment is something that Christians should be excited about. Arguments can be made that our current system of criminal justice often puts the wrong people to death. There is nothing wrong with believing as much time as possible should be given to a person in hope that they would repent. So there is no biblical mandate or prohibition on the topic of capital punishment. We must “work out our salvation with fear and trembling.”

War
War is also present throughout the Bible. In the New Testament, the church is not in a position to decide whether to go to war. On the one hand, Mark 13 seems to assume that Christians were generally not involved in the Jewish War of 66-72. However, the epithet Simon the Zealot remains curious, especially since the Zealots probably did not form as a distinct group until around the time of the Jewish War.

“Just war theory” has generally been accepted throughout church history by most Christians. War should not be pre-emptive but a last resort. It should be waged by a legitimate authority for a just cause for the right reasons with a probability of success. Generally, those who go to war would claim these things even when it is certainly not the case. In the end, those who are pacifists are usually closer to the spirit of Christ than those who are quick to justify violence of any sort.

In the end, we have to work out our salvation together with fear and trembling. We often act like our positions are obvious in Scripture and reason, but our arguments are sometimes weaker than we think. They are sometimes influenced by traditions and culture in ways in which we are not aware. On such serious matters, we should be humble seekers rather than presumptuous assumers.

Conclusion
What is a human being? A human being, more than anything else, is an image of God, created in his likeness, beloved by him. All human beings, from the most virtuous to the evilest, are therefore inherently valuable. No human being could ever be roadkill.

The Bible is thoroughly in favor of life. "Thou shalt not murder" is a clear commandment that is affirmed in both the Old and New Testaments, where murder is the intentional killing of an innocent man, woman, or child. However, the Bible does not equate murder with all killing. The Bible assumes that death in war and capital punishment can be appropriate actions. 

[1] I am drawing heavily here on the work of James Sire, The Universe Next Door.

[2] Gnosticism considered the physical realm to be evil. Biblical dualism (and Plato for that matter) only considered the physical realm to be inferior. "The spirit is willing but the flesh is weak" (e.g., Matt. 26:41). "The phrase 'yet once more' makes clear the removal of what is being shaken, as that which has been created, so that what is unshakeable may remain" (Heb. 12:27). 

[3] As someone who loves physics and cosmology, let me also suggest that there is a certain “earthism” to these arguments. Who knows how God might have created sentient creatures in other parts of the universe? I have a feeling we are going to feel pretty silly when we meet some creatures from other galaxies in heaven.

[4] To essentialize gender, as I define the phrase, is to stereotype men and women in ways that go beyond explicit physical characteristics.

Sunday, July 10, 2022

Sermon Starters -- "On God's Side"

Occasion: Silver Lake Wesleyan Camp, Sunday, July 10, 2022

Text: Joshua 5:13-15 

Introduction

  • Joshua is about to conquer Jericho, and the commander of the LORD's armies appears to him. Joshua asks him if he is on Israel's side. He is on neither side.
  • I always found this story puzzling. How could he not be on Israel's side?
  • Background: when cities and empires went to war, their gods were also going to war (Trojan War was a battle between gods. Roman practice of invoking gods of a city they were attacking)
  • It dawned on me. God is on his own side. God has his own agenda. Israel's defeat of Jericho was on God's agenda. But Israel would lose their next battle against Ai. We need to be on God's side!
  • Think of the time of Jeremiah, when again Israel assumed God would always be on their side.
  • God is not on our side--we had better be on God's side!
1. God was on a mission long before we arrived. If Jesus tarries, he will be on a mission long after we are gone.

  • Our chickens' view of the world
  • Our view of space -- William Shatner's trip to space
  • God made the sun! Think of some of our squabbles (Should you say "crap" or "darn"?)
  • Our view of time -- getting through high school once seemed like forever. I used to be the youngest everywhere (high school at 17, college at 20, seminary at 23). Not any more. I can picture how my mom feels at 96.
  • Setting dates for the Lord's return. God must shake his head. Not again.
  • We are pea-brains... even with our interpretations of the Bible
2. Our earthly "teams" come and go. They are eternally trivial.
  • The Corinthians -- Apollos group versus Paul group
  • Do you have to be a Democrat or a Republican to be a Christian? Stories of people who've said one or the other
  • Posts and feeding frenzies on Wesleyan Pastor's group on Facebook
  • Hutu and Tutsi, Civil War
  • At some point we need to splash some water in our faces, humble ourselves, and recognize it's not my team or their team. We had both better be on God's team.
  • Paul and Barnabas knew how to agree to disagree (argument over Mark and Antioch)
3. Our team can get very upset with us when they are out of sync with God's team.
  • Joshua 24 -- "You cannot serve the Lord... Who is on the Lord's side?" 
  • Parenting with different children. The one that is strong willed. The one that is soft-hearted. I image God deals with us in the same way. Some of us need a little bit of holiness and fire. Some of us God is gentle with.
  • Those of us who are most stubborn about our team are probably the ones who need the most reminding that God's the one in charge.
  • John Snow, mercy to the people north of the wall, his murder for mercy -- something much bigger was going on. They kill him for doing the right thing.
  • Full surrender can be painful. It can go farther than our pea-brains can go.
  • Love God, love neighbor -- these are the principles that cut across all distractions.
Conclusion
  • My own heart. I'm so convinced I know what's up. I've got to listen. I've got to be disciplined not to throw stones (or too much sarcasm). Not everyone who disagrees with me is my enemy.

Saturday, July 09, 2022

Wesleyan philosophy 3 -- What about God?

The third installment
_____________________

If philosophy involves “meta-thinking,” thinking about thinking, then we are not surprised that there are a number of areas of philosophy that are the “philosophy of” some other discipline. There is a philosophy of history and philosophy of art. There is a philosophy of science. From a Christian perspective, the most important of these is surely the philosophy of religion.

What is the relationship between faith and reason?

When I think of the philosophy of religion, I especially think of three questions. I have already weighed in on the first one, namely, “What is the relationship between faith and reason?” While there are those who see faith as virtually provable and those who see it as virtually irrational, it seems to me that Wesley and Wesleyans have usually seen faith as reasonable although not necessarily “provable” from a human standpoint.

It seems to me that, historically, Wesleyans have not shied away from arguments for the existence of God, even if argument is not the heart of faith. I do think that, in recent decades, there has been somewhat of a move away from apologetics in some Wesleyan circles. True, no amount of argument brings a person to Christ. The Holy Spirit’s movement coupled with a faith response is the only path to God. God can use argument to do that, but no one is argued into the kingdom of God. God can use reason to clear a path, but reason never is what ultimately leads someone to God.

Faith is far more a matter of our “hearts.” Satan and demons presumably have a perfect head knowledge of God that far exceeds any human theologian who has ever lived. They would always get 100% on any test of knowledge about God. Their heads, in this respect are perfect in understanding.

Yet James 2:19 tells us they tremble before God. Is this not the point of James 2? If our faith is merely a knowledge of God, it is insufficient for salvation. “Though I have all knowledge,” Paul says in 1 Corinthians 13:2, but do not have love, my knowledge is pointless. Knowledge is thus a secondary feature of our faith, and our trust in and allegiance to God is primary. When 2 Timothy 3:16 speaks of all Scripture being God-breathed and being profitable for instruction and correction, it is not likely thinking of theology in the first place but in our faith and the way we live.

I suspect God might easily prove the divine existence to us. God might certainly do so in terms of our experience, but I suspect God could mount an irrefutable and possibly unfathomable rational argument. The problem is that our human minds are both finite and fallen. As finite, we cannot grasp the measurelessness of God’s reason. As fallen, our attempts to grasp God’s perfection will inevitably fail us to one degree or another.

The Ontological Argument

I take as a case in point the “ontological argument.” It might be advanced in several forms. Anselm’s version went something like this, in my words:

  • I can conceive of a greatest possible Being. The greatest possible Being exists in my mind.
  • But part of being the greatest possible Being means that God actually exists and is not just an idea in my head.
  • Therefore God actually exists and is not just an idea.

In my opinion, Alvin Plantinga’s more recent version of the argument is much better and clearer. I would express it in the following way:

  • There is a possible world in which God exists.
  • But if God exists in one possible world, God must exist in all possible worlds.
  • Therefore, God exists in all possible worlds, including mine.

I actually consider this a circular argument. It seems easy to say that it is possible that God exists, but the first premise is really asking whether God actually does exist. In other words, it does not prove anything. It simply poses the question of God’s existence in a way that seems at first to be less committal than it really is.

However, I suspect that God agrees with the ontological argument. As a person of faith, I believe this argument is correct. However, I believe it as a matter of faith. As a matter of reason, I do not think this argument actually proves anything, and most philosophers would agree. The problem is not God’s. The problem is that our human reason is finite.

The Cosmological Argument

So the second question that I think of when I think of the philosophy of religion is the question of whether God exists. Ultimately, as I have said, it is a matter of faith rather than proof. The opposite of faith is not reason but proof. Hebrews 1:6 says that, “without faith it is impossible to please him, for the one who comes to God must have faith that he exists and that he rewards those who diligently seek him.”

There are a number of classic arguments for the existence of God. We already mentioned the ontological argument, which goes back to Anselm in the 1000s. Perhaps the most famous argument is the “cosmological argument” or the argument from cause. Thomas Aquinas in the 1200s presented a classic version. However, I might present it something like the following:

  • The universe would seem to be a constant sequence of causes and effects.
  • This sequence does not seem to go back infinitely.
  • Therefore, there must have been a first cause to the universe.

1500 years before Aquinas, the Greek philosopher Aristotle called this cause the “Prime Mover,” the unmoved mover that set everything in motion.

In the last seventy years, this argument has become more and more scientifically compelling. In the 1950s, it was very popular to believe that matter was constantly being generated somewhere in the universe and thus that the universe need never have had a beginning. Discovery of a gradually decreasing cosmic background radiation from the early universe eventually suggested a “big bang” near the beginning of the universe.

While some Christians do not like the concept of a big bang, this hesitance is because of the time frame that is usually suggested and the fact that such a bang is often discussed within an atheistic framework. However, the idea that God caused the universe to begin at some point in the past with a bang is more or less how Christians have long interpreted Genesis 1:1. There is nothing intrinsically unChristian about the notion that the universe began suddenly at a point in time! In fact that is precisely what we believe.

Once we have suggested the universe had a Creator, we have said very little about who or what that Creator was. In the end, natural revelation (what we might infer about God by reason and observation) needs special revelation (God’s direct revelation to humanity in Christ and Scripture) to arrive at anything close to the Christian understanding of God. Arguments for the existence of God thus must play a supporting role in our understanding. They are inadequate to bring us to a full knowledge of God.

We might infer, however, that a Creator who makes the universe out of nothing, which is what Christians have historically believed, must have enough power and knowledge to create what is created. The Creator out of nothing must then have all power in relation to the universe and all knowledge of the universe’s workings. Creation out of nothing might or might not suggest a full knowledge of the future, but it certainly implies a full knowledge of the universe’s possibilities. By faith, however, Wesleyans have traditionally believed that God has all actual knowledge of the future and not merely a knowledge of all the possibilities.

The age old question, “Where then did God come from?” simply does not understand the argument above. Nothing in any of the above argument suggests that the Creator must have a cause. The cosmological argument says, “This universe must have a cause.” It says nothing about what must be for that cause. Indeed, this question confuses God (whose essence must be outside this universe) with the universe. It treats God as if God is part of the universe.

The Teleological Argument

Another longstanding argument for the existence of God is the argument from design. In the 1700s, a pastor named William Paley advanced it with the example of the eye. The eye, he argued, is far to intricate to have happened by chance. If you find a watch, you presume there was a watchmaker. So when we consider aspects of nature like the eye, we should assume that they had an intelligent Designer.

There is a clear common sense to this argument. How could we possibly explain the intricacies of nature without supposing that there was an infinitely intelligent Designer behind it? On the other hand, the theory of evolution in the late 1800s seemed to many to undermine this argument severely. Suddenly God did not seem to be necessary at all to explain the origins of complex life.

However, we do not need to fight the battle for the teleological argument over evolution. There is an even more compelling argument to be made on the level of the entire universe, and it is sometimes called the “fine tuning argument.” The fine tuning argument is a strong argument not least because its force is readily admitted by physicists who are atheists. It basically says that the laws and parameters of the universe are so finely balanced that we are either fortunate beyond all imagination or there must have been a designer.

For example, if there were more mass in the universe, the universe would have crunched before any planets let alone life could form. If there were less mass the universe would have spread so quickly that no planets let alone life could form. The balance between matter and antimatter must have been just ever so slightly off. If it had been exact, E = mc^2 and there would only be energy in the universe.

If the balance between the strong nuclear force and the electromagnetic force were different, protons would repel such that no atomic nuclei could form or electrons would be sucked into the nucleus. The same between the force of gravity and the electromagnetic force. Instead, these forces balance out perfectly for us to have atoms.

If the universe had an inverse cube law instead of an inverse square law for gravity and the electromagnetic force, atoms and planets could not have formed. If all the hydrogen had become helium in the early universe, there would be no suns. If carbon did not have precisely the energy threshhold it has to form its nucleus, we would never have had carbon to form life.

These “finely tuned” aspects of the universe go on and on. As yet, there is no clear reason for the universe to be exactly this way by chance. Indeed, those cosmologists who are atheists usually resort so some theory of a multiverse. Out of what must be an astronomical number of universe failures, we would just happen to be on the completely unfathomably lucky one that was just right, a Goldilocks of universes.

A much simpler explanation is simply to suggest that there is an intelligent Designer. Again, we may need special revelation to know the character of that Designer. For example, this argument does not necessarily suggest that God is good. For that, we may very well need Scripture.

The Moral Argument

C.S. Lewis reluctantly came to the conclusion that God exists because of what we might call the “moral argument” for the existence of God. In his autobiographical Surprised by Joy, Lewis indicates that the key moment in his return to God was when he came to a choice between a world where good and evil were not real, only figments of our imagination and a world where there was some grounding of these ideas in reality. He finds it unfathomable that they not be real. This leads him eventually back to God.

We might call this argument for God the “argument from the existence of evil.” It concedes what the 1800s thinker Friedrich Nietzsche thought, namely, that good and evil are not real but concepts that “supermen” can invent for other people and fool them into believing. Fyodor Dostoevsky, the Russian writer, had earlier gone the other way from Nietzsche, but still claiming that “If there is no God, then everything is permissible.”

Lewis and many others simply found this notion untenable, which led him eventually to believe in God as the guarantor of right and wrong. We should note that there are non-theists who have argued for the reality of good and evil apart from God’s existence. Philippa Foot and John Rawls would be two recent philosophers who tried to give a rational basis for morality apart from God. In the end neither give any absolute basis for morality in relation to an individual’s decisions.

Lewis gives a more fully formed moral argument for God’s existence in his book, Mere Christianity. I might summarize it something like the following:

  • All humans have a concept of right and wrong, even though they might differ some on the specifics.
  • There must be some grounding of this universal concept in reality.
  • This grounding is in the existence of a good God.

I will confess that, while I agree by faith that right and wrong are grounded in the goodness of God, I have never found this argument compelling as an argument. C.S. Lewis had what I might call serious “Platonic” tendencies. That is to say, he tended to see ideas as having a reality indepedent of our brains. Plato believed that true reality was the world of thought. Accordingly, our basic conceptions were not just thoughts but realities that existed apart from ourselves.

It is no coincidence that Anselm, who formulated the ontological argument, was heavily influenced by Plato. If we can conceive of God, a fundamental conception of the greatest possible Being (which is a different kind of conception than conceiving of a unicorn), then God must actually exist apart from ourselves. Lewis’ train of thought shows similar Platonic influence. If there is a universal conception of right and wrong, then these concepts must have a real existence apart from ourselves, a transcendent one that goes beyond the world of sight and touch and taste and smell.

Charles Darwin, the “father of evolution” famously suggested that morality evolved among humans as an advantage to survival. Many others have taken up that line of thinking since. While I believe by faith that God grounds morality, I am not sure that I can prove this belief. It remains for me a matter of what I consider reasonable faith rather than proof.

Experiences of God

For the vast majority of Christians, the strongest personal argument for God’s existence is either a personal encounter with God or a faith in the accounts of others having personal encounters with God, not least in the Bible. An old hymn says, “You ask me how I know he lives? He lives within my heart.” A personal encounter with God and Christ is a very strong personal argument for God’s existence that is difficult to refute.

A former seminary professor of mine hated this hymn. He would respond that we know Jesus lives “because of the testimony of the apostles.” We will take up that argument for Jesus’ resurrection in a moment. We will also mention the argument from miracles in a moment.

Beyond any individual experience of God I might have are the countless testimonies of encounters with God that others have given throughout the centuries, including all those testimonies in Scripture. A very, very large number of people have believed themselves to have encountered God. If even half of these encounters were mistaken, how do we account for such a pervasive sense of divine encounter in the history of humanity?

Such transcendent experiences are so common that even those who do not have a belief in the Christian God or in a personal God have retained a sense of transcendent spirituality. Even the force of Star Wars gets at such a common sense that there are forces beyond those we learn in a physics class. If this sense of higher powers is coupled with the cosmological and teleological arguments above, we begin to get a sense of a personal divine power.

Miracles

The common definition of a miracle is something that happens that seemed highly unlikely, almost impossible to happen. That is not the technical definition of a miracle. A miracle in the philosophical sense is something that is actually impossible that happens. It is an event that stands outside the cause and effect chain of the world. A miracle would be if someone who was truly dead for over a day came back to life.

There are many, many people who have made such claims throughout history and in the Bible. If there were five loaves of bread and two fishes and Jesus was able to feed five thousand people full with them by multiplying them, that would be a miracle. Walking on water or turning water into wine, these are impossible actions. They are miracles. A check coming just in time on the day you needed it, that could be a miracle behind the scenes but it could also be a great coincidence. It was not something that was impossible to occur.

If you observe a miracle done in Jesus’ name, that is a very compelling argument for God’s existence. Many, many individuals have claimed to have seen or experienced such miracles.

The Resurrection

The most important miracle, indeed the foundational miracle of Christianity, is the resurrection of Jesus from the dead. We cannot prove the resurrection of Jesus–it is an inductive argument and thus open-ended. However, we can make an argument that belief in the resurrection of Jesus is very reasonable if we allow for the possibility of miracles.

There are, of course, those who do not allow for the possibility of miracles. We think here especially of David Hume in the 1700s, who made the assumption that everything happens on the basis of cause and effect and thus that miracles are impossible a priori (before even looking at any claims that one might have happened). Hume had a “presupposition” that miracles could not happen.

This is an extremely flimsy claim. He simply dismisses the possibility on the basis of assumption. His argument amounts to a feeling. “Well, I’ve never seen a miracle” or “Smart people don’t believe in miracles.” These are not arguments, they are condescending assumptions without any proof whatsoever. Show me a real argument Mr. Hume. Disprove all the claims of miracles that have occurred throughout history. If even one miracle slips through, then your arrogant dismissal proves to be the ignorant assumption.

No, any person who is really interested in knowing what is true must allow for the possibility both of the supernatural and of miracles. That allowance does not prove they happen. It simply is the required openness of inductive reasoning.

The argument for the historicity of the resurrection is generally two prong. The first part is the empty tomb. They second has to do with eyewitnesses.

The empty tomb is the unanimous testimony of the ancient world and it is a very reasonable conclusion given the New Testament. All four Gospels assume an empty tomb. The women are unable to find the body. Given the status of women in that world, someone making the story up would surely not have invented women discovering the empty tomb, since they were not considered reliable sources of information.

The earliest argument we have against the resurrection is in Matthew 28 where there is a rumor that the disciples stole Jesus’ body. Note that this rumor assumes that there is no body. So even those who did not believe in the resurrection conceded that there was no body and an empty tomb.

It would be difficult to account for the resurrection believe of the early church if Jesus’ body could be located. These individuals were apparently willing to die for their beliefs. The apostle Paul is a case in point. 2 Corinthians 11-12 tell of the persecution and suffering he endured as he shared the good news around the world. It seems unlikely that he would endure such pain if he were not fully convinced of Jesus’ resurrection, a belief that seems doubtful if the location of Jesus’ body were known or highly in dispute.

So Jesus’ body was missing. We couple this fact with the fact that a host of people testified to seeing Jesus alive after his death. 1 Corinthians 15 gives a very early list within the lifetime of most of the witnesses. The Corinthians loved to question Paul, but we have no evidence that this list was contested by them or anyone in the early church. It has a historical ring of truth to it.

Paul points first to Peter, then the other inner circle of disciples, who believed that they saw Jesus alive after his death. Tradition suggests that almost all of these individuals were willing to die for that belief. If they were not strongly convinced of the resurrection, it is doubtful they would have made such a sacrifice. Over 500 people at once are mentioned in 1 Corinthians 15. He so much as says, “Check my references.” Then of course there was Paul himself. It is unreasonable to think that he was anything but fully convinced he had seen Jesus alive.

So we have an empty tomb and we have hundreds of people convinced they have seen Jesus alive. If you allow for the possibility of resurrections, this would seem to be an extremely strong case. And if Jesus rose from the dead, there is a strong argument for the existence of the God who raised Jesus from the dead.

The Soul-Making Explanation for Suffering

The third key question that the philosophy of religion asks is why God allows evil and suffering to persist in the world if God is truly good. This is the problem of evil and suffering. The question goes something like the following:

  • A good God would want to end evil and suffering.
  • An all-powerful God could end evil and suffering.
  • Then why does God not stop evil and suffering?

Two key answers have been given over the last 2000 years. The first is what we might call the “soul-making theodicy,” where a theodicy is an explanation for how God can be just when he allows evil and suffering. We associate it with a Christian named Irenaeus in the 100s AD. It is basically summed up as “no pain no gain” or, to borrow a phrase from Nietzsche, “what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.”

The sense is that suffering and particular present challenges to us that have the potential to help us grow in character. A body that never moves will atrophy and become weaker and weaker. However, exercise helps a body grow stronger. Moderate tearing down of the muscles results in them becoming stronger.

Accordingly, a world without serious multiple choices is not a world where we might easily become morally better. Rather, as we face moral challenges, we become stronger in our “souls.” When we face suffering, we can either wither away or rise to the challenge, by God’s grace and with the help of the Holy Spirit. Our “souls” are made stronger. The world of pain and suffering is like a moral workout gym. In The Problem of Pain, C.S. Lewis spoke of the chisel of God whose blows hurt so much but hold the possibility of making us into beautiful moral creatures.

The Free Will Explanation for Evil

The second approach to the problem of evil came from Augustine in the 400s. We might call it the free-will theodicy. In this approach, God gave Adam and Eve a free choice between good and evil because a world in which we are free to make that choice is a better world than one in which we are forced to be good. [1]

However, having given that choice to Adam and Eve, they chose poorly. As a result, evil is in the world. Augustine popularized the idea of The Fall, where the power of Sin over the world was introduced by Adam’s sin. Similarly, suffering entered the world through Adam’s sin.

Augustine’s theodicy distances God from the evil and suffering world by placing the blame on humanity itself, on Adam in particular. God does not dictate that evil must come into being. God creates a good world where evil is possible. Adam–and perhaps Satan–is then responsible for the specific existence of evil. [2]

The Augustinian approach to the problem of evil has been particularly important in the Wesleyan tradition. Some hyper-Calvinists have taken John Calvin (1500s) beyond his own teaching to see God predestining both Satan and Adam to sin. This approach is problematic for Wesleyans because it makes God directly responsible for evil. [3]

For Wesleyans, evil is a matter of the permissive will of God, things God allows, rather than the directive will of God, things God more or less commands. Wesleyans would also extend the free will theodicy beyond Adam. Wesley taught that the “prevenient grace” of God empowers us to be able to choose or not choose God individually even today. In that sense, the existence of evil today–and the suffering caused by evil–is not simply Adam’s fault but the fault of each individual who does not choose God throughout history. This is a far more satisfactory answer to the question than Augustine’s solution in itself.

What is good and evil?

Lurking in the discussion above is of course the question of exactly what good and evil even are. Augustine discussed them in terms of twisting a good end. However, given his Platonic tendencies, I wonder if his thinking comes perilously close to thinking of good as a thing. The Neoplatonism he drew on did indeed see evil as the absence of light, the absence of good.

The Bible presents love as the ultimate criteria of good and evil. When asked to summarize the commandments of God, Jesus summed them up as to love God and to love neighbor (Matthew 22). All of God’s commands fit within one or another of these categories, and the primary way we demonstrate love of God is by loving others, including our enemies.

Love here is not a feeling. It is not even “liking” someone. In relation to others, it is an orientation of attitude and action that acts in a way that is meant to benefit the other. In relation to God, it is a complete recognition of ultimate authority and an alligiance to God’s lordship. These two loves never contradict or conflict with each other.

Evil is thus any intentionality that is contrary to love of the other. Evil is any intentionality in relation to God that is contrary to allegiance to him. Evil thus existence within the sphere of human intentionality. It is not a thing. It is an intentionality contrary to love.

Adam and Jesus could be tempted because a good desire was directed toward an inappropriate object. In Adam’s case, the desire for knowledge and excelling were good but directed toward a forbidden object. In Jesus’ case, he wanted to avoid suffering in the Garden, a perfectly healthy desire, but in a context that would have gone against the will of God the Father and his love of humanity. A sinful nature is thus not a prerequisite for temptation.

Suffering is pain, which is understandable. It is not good or evil in itself. It only becomes evil when an intelligence chooses to inflict or allow it in an unloving way. In the case of God, we assume that God only allows suffering when it serves a greater good.

A Wesleyan Answer to Evil and Suffering

We can synthesize the various answers above into a coherent Wesleyan approach to the question of evil and suffering. We might summarize it in the following points:

  • God created a world with the possibility of evil and suffering. He did not directly create evil but the possibility of evil.
  • A world with moral choice is a good world. A world with suffering is not necessarily a bad world if that suffering brings about good. The creation of a world with these possibilities thus does not contradict the claim that God is good and loving. A hyper-Calvinist view, however, virtually equates God with Satan.
  • The power of Sin came over the world because of Adam’s sin, with Adam as the first human. The theory of evolution, if accepted, would require some modifications which I might discuss in the next entry.
  • All human beings are presented by God with a similar moral choice to Adam. The prevenient grace of the Spirit gives every person a choice at some point to choose God. That choice brings the possibility of good for all, as well as choice for evil.
  • A good deal of human suffering results from the evil choices of human beings. In general, suffering does pose the possibility for “soul-growth.” Suffering in itself is thus morally neutral.
  • We conclude that evil and suffering can exist even though God is all-good and all-powerful.

Christians also believe that Christ will return at some point of history and bring evil intentionality to an end. Scripture also indicates that suffering will end at that point (1 Cor. 15).

[1] Later, in the 1700s, Gottfried Leibniz would argue that this is the best of all possible worlds. He could not conceive that God could create any world but the best. It is difficult to know, however, what the “best” even means in the context of creation out of nothing. If God creates universes out of nothing, then surely whatever God creates would be the best for that universe by God’s fiat.

[2] See Greg Boyd’s Satan and the Problem of Evil for a more thorough exploration of Satan as the primary culprit for suffering and evil.

[3] The Calvinist distinction between primary and secondary causes is a distinction without a difference. Secondary causes for Calvinists amount simply to things God does through others.

Monday, July 04, 2022

Explanatory Notes -- Hebrews 11:23-40

11:23 By faith Moses, having been born, was hidden [for] three months by his parents because they saw the child was beautiful and they did not fear the command of the king.

The next section of Hebrews 11 turns from Abraham to Moses. If Abraham was the father of all Israel, Moses was the great lawgiver, the one through whom God revealed the Law. Together these two were the most important of all figures in the story of Israel. 

If Hebrews was a sermon to a church in Rome, the mention of a king surely would have brought Caesar to mind. If Hebrews dates to the time just after Jerusalem was destroyed and its Jewish leaders were paraded and slaughtered in Rome, the stakes of resisting the king would be firmly in mind. In such a context, the author of Hebrews makes a crystal clear point to the audience. No matter what Caesar might do, you should be like Moses' parents, who obeyed God over earthly authorities.

Faith here is faithfulness despite obstacles. They "keep faith" with God despite earthly opposition. They trust God despite what things look like with their eyes.

11:24 By faith Moses, having become big, denied to be called a son of the daughter of Pharaoh, 25. having chosen rather to be mistreated together with the people of God than to have the pleasure of sin for a time, 26. having considered the reproach of the Christ [to be] greater wealth than the treasures of Egypt, for he looked to the reward.

The message of these comments was not too subtle for the audience. Perhaps some of them were Roman citizens. Perhaps some of them came from privilege. Perhaps some of them were "sons of the daughter of Pharoah," in a sense. 

The author of Hebrews makes it clear that the best path in the long run, the right path, was the path of Moses. Moses was willing to endure persecution now, in the present, looking for a future reward. Moses figuratively endured the "reproach of Christ," although Christ had not yet come. The audience must endure the reproach of Christ literally, being willing to endure suffering for him.

There are often worldly pleasures that are very enjoyable in the moment but lead to long term pain. Having an affair may seem pleasurable in the moment, but the long term consequences are generally horrible. So the audience of Hebrews might avoid suffering by denying Christ now, but the consequences after Christ's return would not be enviable.

11:27 By faith he left Egypt, not having feared the wrath of the king, for he endured as [one] seeing the invisible.

Faith is the evidence of things not seen. Just as we believe the world was not created out of things we can see, just as Noah built an ark long before he saw rain, Moses believed in a God that he had not yet seen. He would see him forty years later, at the burning bush. But he endured in faith long before he saw him. Similarly, he could not see the promise of Israel's deliverance yet. He had to believe it would eventually come.

This statement is a little puzzling in light of the Exodus story. In Exodus 2:15, it is precisely because Pharoah is trying to kill him that leads Moses to flee Egypt. It would be easy to read the story to indicate Moses fled precisely because he did fear the king. 

On the one hand, the point of Hebrews is a matter of Hebrews. The inspired point God was making through the author of Hebrews came through the way he read the story. The original meaning of Exodus is tangential.

It is also possible the author is saying that Moses left Egypt even though the promise was that Israel would be delivered from Egypt. How could Moses be part of Israel's exodus if he was no longer around. The faith then would be the faith that he would eventually come back.

The audience may have to flee Rome. Many Christians also fled Jerusalem before it was destroyed by the Romans. You can flee in faith rather than fear. You can flee because it is not God's time to stay. 

The audience might get exiled from Rome. That would especially be something that the wrath of the Roman emperor might unleash. In that case, leaving Rome without fear of the emperor would be especially apropos.

11:28 By faith he has made the Passover and the sprinkling of the blood so that the destroyer might not touch their firstborn. 29. By faith they crossed the Red Sea as through dry land with regard to which, having made an attempt, the Egyptians were drowned.  

Moses did come back from Midian. Forty years later after God appeared to him at the burning bush. God did use Moses to lead Israel out of Egypt. The night before the exodus, there was the Passover. 

The perfect tense--"he has made the Passover"--is fascinating. The Passover and Moses are not merely figures from the past. The Passover "stands made." It continues to this day. Moses continues to this day in the heavenly city. The inauguration stands written in Scripture. The author sees these events through the eyes of a Scripture whose message continues regardless of the figures in history who are mentioned. Melchizedek continues to have "no end of life" because he never dies in the text.

The audience is sprinkled with the blood of Jesus. The destroyer will not touch them in the judgment. Even if the Romans threaten persecution, their superior worldly power does not promise them victory any more than the Egyptians were certain to win against Israel. With God on their side, the Israelites escaped through the Red Sea on dry ground, while the Egyptian army drowned.

 11:30 By faith the walls of Jericho fell, having been surrounded for seven days. 31. By faith Rahab the prostitute did not perish with those who disobeyed, having received the spies with peace.

Leaving the Pentateuch, the author moves into the book of Joshua. From an earthly standpoint, it might have looked like Jericho was unassailable. With God on their side, Israel prevailed. Faith was the substance of an outcome that was hoped for. 

Rahab stood on the side of those who seemed vulnerable to the powers of the city. The audience, if in Rome, might have to choose whether to stand on the side of individuals pursued by the Romans. Playing it safe now would not lead to happy consequences later when Christ returns in judgment. Rahab bet on Israel and Israel's God. So the audience should persist and stand with Christ.

11:32 And what yet am I saying? For the time will fail me telling about Gideon, Barak, Samson, Jephthah, both David and Samuel and the prophets...

At this point the style of the example list changes. Instead of going into detail about a prominent hero of faith like Abraham or Moses, the author starts to list the names of individuals whose stories the audience likely knew from Scripture. Gideon, Barak, Samson, and Jephthah are all from the book of Judges. David and Samuel are chiefly from the books of 1 and 2 Samuel. A close examination of their stories can reveal some less than godly elements, but it is the ideal version of these individuals that Hebrews has in mind, the version some of us learned in Sunday School as children.

There is a name for the literary device used here. It is called "praeteritio." You say that you are not going to talk about what you then go on to talk about.

One of the most striking aspects of this verse is the fact that the author identifies himself with a masculine singular participle--"Time will fail me telling." In Greek, you must choose a gender and number for the word telling, one that goes with the word me. By making the participle masculine singular, the author indicates that he is a male.

As tiny as this grammatical feature is, it seems strong enough to prevail against interesting hypotheses that the author might be a woman. Aldof von Harnack suggested Priscilla in the early twentieth century, and others like Ruth Hoppin have more recently supported the theory. [1] However, the only likely way around the participle would be if the author were hiding her identity. Since the author and audience seem well acquainted with each other, we must conclude it almost certain that the author was a man.  

11:33 ... who through faith conquered kingdoms, worked righteousness, obtained promises, stopped the mouths of lions, 34. quenched the power of fire, escaped the mouths of sword, were strengthened from sickness, became strong in war, drove away foreign armies.

The first examples the author gives involve winning on earth. They fight and win against other kingdoms, such as when Deborah and Barak defeat the enemies of Israel. They bring about the desired change for righteousness, such as when Hezekiah ends the sacrifices to other gods. They obtain promises, such as when they return from exile.

Daniel is not eaten by the lion. The three young Hebrew men are not destroyed in the fiery furnace. Elijah is not killed. Hezekiah is healed. Gideon wins. David defeats Goliath.

These examples hold out hope to the audience. They may face persecution in the days to come. But God might also deliver them from it. They might escape.

11:35 Women received their dead from resurrection, but others, not receiving redemption, were tortured in order that they might obtain a better resurrection. 36. And others received a trial of mocking and scouraging, and even of chains and jail. 37. They were stoned. They were sawed in two. They died by murder of sword. They went around in sheepskins, in goatskins, lacking, afflicted, treated badly, 38. of whom the world was not worthy, wandering in deserts and mountains and caves and holes of the land.  

The audience, however, is not promised escape. They might not escape. Yes, there was a woman whose son was raised from the dead by Elisha. But there have been other mothers whose sons were not raised. The author likely alludes to the story in 2 Maccabees 7 were a mother loses all seven of her sons to persecution. That chapter includes the strongest anticipation of bodily resurrection of any known Jewish writing outside the New Testament. There is a tradition that the prophet Isaiah died by being sawed in two.

The mention of individuals, likely prophets, going around in sheepskins and goatskins not only has us thinking of Elijah, but of John the Baptist. It is at least possible that the author here blurs into the time of Jesus. Certainly, we know that Elijah hid in a cave. 

11:39 And these all, having been witnessed through faith, did not receive the promise. 40. God having foreseen something better concerning us, that they might not be perfected without us.

The mention of having been witnessed ends the chapter as it started. This same concept of witnessing started this example list in 11:2. This literary structure, as mentioned above, is called an "inclusio." The similar words at the beginning and end of the chapter bind the chapter together with bookends of a sort.

The heroes of this chapter were all part of the old covenant. They were prior to Jesus' death and enthronement at God's right hand. The promise was made about what Jesus would make possible and what Jesus would make happen. In 10:2 and 7:19 we learned that the sacrifices of the Jewish Law were not actually able to take away sins. They were not able to "perfect" the worshipper by cleansing their sins.

Every sacrifice under the old covenant was thus a raincheck for the one truly effective sacrifice of Jesus Christ. None of the heroes of faith in the old covenant actually received the promise, which required Christ to come. They were all looking forward to Christ and the coming unshakeable kingdom. They were not able to be "perfected" or truly cleansed of their sins without Jesus.

But now Jesus has come! Now perfection is possible. Now sins can truly be saved. They had been waiting. Now the time had come. The day of perfection had arrived for the faithful of the past and present to experience together! 

[1] Priscilla's Letter: Finding the Author of the Epistle to the Hebrews (Lost Coast, 2000). 

Friday, July 01, 2022

A Tribute to Fallen Chickens (May 9, 2022)

We knew that it was difficult to transport chickens. We had 33 of them when we left NY, believe it or not. If I knew then what I know now, we would still have them all. But we ended up losing four of them on the trip from New York back to Indiana. I want to remember them before I forget.

Millie




Millie was a smart Easter Egger. She loved milk worms and was not afraid to jump on your lap to plead for them. 

 





Cocoa (grey) lived. She was a good friend to Millie, another Easter Egger pictured here next to Millie. We almost lost her on the trip. But she was able to pull out of her dehydrated stupor. She is now back to being the fastest blueberry stealer in the west.




Sandy

The second fallen one was Sandy, the Ostralorp. Nobody messed with Sandy. We put aprons on a number of the hens because we had too many roosters and they were frankly causing the hens to loose some feathers. But Sandy had a way of not getting bothered. She was a solid soul.






Here's a drive-by of Sandy. She was not as quick to come up to you as some others, unless you had milk worms.





JD





The third fallen was JD, one of my favorites. He and George were Ayam Cemanis. I privately called him the Jesus rooster. He was big and strong enough to beat all the others, but it wasn't his thing. The ladies liked him because he didn't jump on them as much, it seemed. I have a very fun memory of him chasing George around the yard when he had enough. George might have thought himself the superior, but not when JD stood up for himself.






JD was still able to open his eyes when we arrived that fateful morning, but he was not able to drink. He died very soon after our arrival.






George



George was able to walk for a second after we arrived. Then he lost his standing power. I was able to get him to drink all morning and early afternoon. I fear I gave him too much? Perhaps it was inevitable.









He was a funny bird. He loved to come in the house. He would go in the corner or hide behind something. Here's Cocoa with him inside. He was Angie's favorite, and I liked him a lot too. I have a pair of jeans whose first rip came from him. He would occasionally attack my feet.

He was always getting into fights either with Fred, his big brother, or JD. That took a lot of energy. He would get himself all bloody like a boxer and we'd put flour and blue goo on him.









Farewell to the fallen, May 9, 2022

Here is a final picture with Millie, Sandy, and George in it.

 

Wesleyan philosophy 2 -- What is good thinking?

Deductive Reasoning
There is a style of logic whose official form seems to go back to Aristotle from 384-322 BC. You might call it “syllogistic logic” because it has a format that involves “syllogisms.” With syllogisms, you have premises that build to logical conclusions. If the premises are true and the logic is valid, then the conclusion must also be true.

I have never been able to imagine a scenario where this approach to truth claims would not be valid. I recognize that such logic might possibly take on a different form in a different culture. For most of us, especially in daily life, our reasoning is more intuitive and implicit. We do not usually tell our spouse, “premise 1, premise 2, conclusion.” (Some of us might from time to time, but our spouses may consider us rather weird and annoying.)

While this particular form of logic might be cultural in some sense, I cannot see where it does not reflect underlying absolute truths of this universe. Another culture might express such truths in other forms, but I consider that a difference in form rather than substance.

The moniker, “Western logic” seems a bit peculiar. Ancient Greece was a quite different world than mine. There was no Europe at that time. Ancient Greece was different from Renaissance Italy and Enlightenment Prussia too. “Western” mainly says, “not Eastern, not Africa, not Middle East, not South American," and so forth. I suppose it means a modern European perspective on Aristotelian logic that has carried over from Europe to academic philosophy in the United States.

While I believe more metaphorical and intuitive forms of logic are valid and get at the same truths, I find Aristotelian logic and its heritage to be more precise and thus more helpful at truth-processing than more impressionistic, everyday arguments or more narrative versions. The syllogism is a bit like math, and it is hard to argue that 1 + 1 does not equal 2. Accordingly, if all truth is God’s truth, then syllogistic logic is part of natural revelation and thus absolute truth in its substance. I can’t see any way around it. I find it extremely unhelpful to align it with certain people groups, except perhaps in relation to its form.

I call this sort of reason, “micro-reason.” It is not worldview reasoning or even paradigmatic reasoning. Such larger “macro-reason” is very open to question and examination. "Macro-reason" is the use of micro-reason to argue for truths. It is micro-reason in action. When our contemporaries question Wesley’s quadrilateral, they must surely be questioning macro-reason with larger assumptions and the application of micro-reason. When they do so, they are using micro-reason or fundamental logic.

Micro-reason is used in all thinking, as soon as we connect two atoms of thought together. We cannot interpret the Bible without using our micro-reasoning. [1] We cannot process a word from the Lord through the Holy Spirit without micro-reasoning. From Tertullian to Kierkegaard to Barth, these “I believe it because it is absurd” folk used micro-reason. Even Jacques Derrida, as opaque as his deconstructionist writings are, used micro-reason, although he tried very hard to obfuscate it. Micro-reason is thus foundational, underlying truth of any propositional kind, including truths we might draw from the Bible.

This sort of micro-reason or fundamental logic to the universe ultimately boils down to fundamental presuppositions. At some point, you hit basic definitions and assumptions that cannot be proved. Geometric proofs ultimately are built on the basis of fundamental axioms that cannot be proven. They are simply assumed.

One of the fundamental tests for truth is the coherence test. Does a proposed truth contradict itself? The law of non-contradiction states that a claim cannot both be true and untrue if it is stated literally. So if you find a fundamental contradiction in a collection of truth claims, at least one of your truth claims must be false in some way.

It does not seem to me that any of these understandings of logic contradict faith in general, let alone Wesleyan faith. Logic seems to be fundamental to the way God has made this universe. It is part of absolute truth. It is part of natural revelation. We cannot avoid it, not even when we are trying to listen to Scripture and interpret it.

Inductive Reasoning
Deductive reasoning starts with certain assumptions and then draws conclusions, like an upside-down V. By contrast, inductive reasoning is like a normal V. You draw in evidence and make inferences. Unlike deductive reasoning, inductive reasoning tends to be open-ended. Unless you have all the possible data, there is always the chance that the next piece of data you collect will throw the coherence test out of whack and sink your hypothesis.

The scientific method is inductive. You collect evidence. You form a hypothesis. You collect more data and test the hypothesis. You refine the hypothesis if necessary. Eventually, you have enough proven results to present a theory, and so forth. This process never strictly ends as long as there is more data to collect. Paradigms form. Paradigms shift. And so on.

A recent display at the Smithsonian declared the scientific method to be white in nature. We face a similar question to that we mentioned in relation to Aristotelian logic. In this case, we point back to Francis Bacon, who was English and lived from 1561-1626.

I consider any such designation extremely unfortunate and undesirable because of how incredibly successful the method has been. It seems to me that it describes the approach that people in all times and all places have used in one form or another for discovery. Where can we find water? Such and such suggests we might dig here. Let’s dig. No water. Let’s try over here. Water. While there may be cultural dimensions to the way the scientific method is expressed and formulated, let us strongly refrain from associating it with any ethnicity or people group. That almost begs for racist inferences of a most heinous nature.

Thus while the results of any particular scientific quest are not absolute truth, the scientific method as a model for seeking truth would seem to be part of the logic of the universe. It is sound reasoning. The results, however, are more often than not eternally tentative.

If the coherence test is a test for truth that relates to deductive reasoning, the “correspondence test” is a test that relates to inductive reasoning. Does the claim that I am making correlate with the data I have? A third test for truth is the pragmatic test. If I operate on the assumption that this hypothesis is true, does it “work” in the world? Does it get me from a to b? You may have heard the expression, “for heuristic purposes.” The idea is that I assume something to see if the hypothesis “works” without assuming it is actually true.

Logical Fallacies
Many different logical fallacies lurk and abound in our reasoning. Some are formal and relate more to deductive reasoning. Others are informal and relate more to inductive reasoning. They are fallacies because they violate the fundamental laws of logic above. Note that one’s conclusion might be true and yet poorly argued.

Below are some logical fallacies. We should point out that they are fallacies because they do not necessitate a certain conclusion. Practically speaking, sometimes this sort of reasoning turns out to point to something that proves to be true in the “real world.” By calling them logical fallacies, we mean that you cannot be certain the conclusion is true. The conclusion does not follow for certain.

  • Hasty generalization – you form a conclusion without enough evidence yet
  • Ad hominem fallacy – you attack the person rather than the argument they are making
  • Circumstantial fallacy – you assume a conclusion without direct observation but from surrounding, “circumstantial” evidence.
  • “After this, because of this” – A form of the circumstantial fallacy. Just because something followed something else chronologically doesn’t prove the first thing caused the second.
  • Genetic fallacy – The origins of a conclusion or the reasons why someone believes a conclusion neither prove nor disprove the conclusion.
  • Fallacy of diversion – basically, changing the subject
  • Fallacy of equivocation -- slipping a different meaning to your terms in mid-argument
  • False alternative – You give an "a or b" choice when there are actually other options as well.
  • Slippery slope fallacy – Once you start moving in a particular direction, it is not guaranteed that you will continue moving further in that direction.
  • Circular reasoning/begging the question – assuming your conclusion in your argument
  • Fallacies of composition and division – You assume everything in a group is a certain way because something in that group is that way. Also the opposite: because of a general trend of a group you assume everything in that group manifests that trend.
  • Appeal to ignorance – Absence of evidence does not disprove a claim
  • Appeal to the majority – something isn’t true just because most people believe it
  • Appeal to improper authority – citing someone who is not an authority on an issue does not support your case
  • Appeal to emotion – something isn’t true because it “feels so right”
  • Appeal to force – you can’t make something true by forcing people to affirm it

These basic fallacies would seem to be sound warnings. They do not indicate for certain that your conclusion is false, but they do indicate that your logic for reaching those conclusions is invalid. They are the stuff of political and religious rhetoric. We would be wise to know them well so that we can spot when our minds are potentially being manipulated.

There is nothing unWesleyan about the idea of these fallacies. This would seem to be a good thing because they would seem to be part of the absolute truth of the universe as God has created it. Their form may have cultural elements, but the underlying truth to which they point would seem to be unassailable. They are part of natural revelation.

[1] Unavoidably, micro-reason is thus logically prior to Scripture because we cannot interpret Scripture or any revelation without using it. When we speak of the priority of Scripture to reason in the quadrilateral, we are speaking of it in relation to what I am calling "macro-reason."

Sunday, June 26, 2022

Clear Instructions and Online Education

I would seem to be quite bright in some ways and quite stupid in others. Perhaps the two are related. One of my strengths is to see the big picture when others cannot. One of my weaknesses is not seeing what's right in front of me. 

This past year, I've taken a number of classes with Southern New Hampshire, the "Game Programming and Development" major. I have enjoyed the courses for the most part. Honestly, the courses have not really made me competent at anything. I find the 8 weeks just enough to get a taste of each subject. They are like bookmarks on subjects I would need to return to if I wanted to go anywhere with them.

Mind you, 8 weeks is pretty much standard now for online courses. It's not something that can really be negotiated, I don't think. I took a Calculus II course with Arizona State last year that was 7 weeks long and brutal. They didn't cut out a thing. But it's almost inevitable, IMO, that these 8-week courses won't cover as much material as a normal 15-week one. To me, it's an argument for self-paced learning.

I messed up on a final project for an SNHU class recently because of accompanying documentation that was supposed to go with a project. Mind you, I had some distractions and turned it in during the middle of the night. The code I turned in was almost up to snuff. The grade was more because of a failure to include things I could have easily included. How did that happen?

It happened because I didn't double-check the rubric. This is a pet peeve of mine with the courses I've taken with Southern New Hampshire. The instructions for assignments are usually pretty thin. To get a sense of what you need to turn in, you pretty much have to go to the rubric and translate it into steps yourself. I find this incredibly annoying. The best courses have been those when individual professors have stood in what seems to me a glaring gap at times (and they do have some really good adjuncts).

I have wondered if there is an intentional desire for students to learn how to go to the web to figure out things ourselves. I doubt it. It just seems that there is an unintentional and quite inappropriate gap between the knowledge base you need to complete some assignments and that which is provided. 

Now this may be my stupidity in part, my inability to see what is right in front of me. It could be my incredible blindness at times. I'm not leaning in that direction, but I have to accept it is possible. I had a high school teacher who couldn't believe that I could read a whole book and not have noticed who the author was. She was wrong.

Here's another pet peeve of mine. It was true at IWU with their online programs and they wanted it to be true of the seminary some 7 years ago. I'm sure they've given in. 

I wanted instructions to spell out what day of the week assignments were due on. So if your first discussion post was due on Thursday, I wanted to say so. They did something like "Day 4." WHY?????

Southern New Hampshire doesn't even do that. Somehow, when you take your first class, you pick up that discussions are on a Thursday-Sunday flow and assignments are due Sunday. But they don't say anything like that in the instructions for an individual assignment.

This has been an annoyed student. When I create online courses, they have clear instructions. Just saying.