This is the second of the umpteenth attempt...
A Generous Tradition
________
Heart-Oriented Tradition
Is it possible that a person’s “head” could be wrong on very many things, and yet that person be right with God? By the same token, could a person have all the right beliefs and yet be as far away from God as the most violent criminal? The best of the Wesleyan tradition says “yes.” In a very different context, 1 Samuel 16:7 puts it memorably: “the LORD does not see as mortals see; they look on the outward appearance, but the LORD looks on the heart” (NRSV).
We can put it another way. Could a person “mess up” in very many ways for various reasons, and yet that person be right with God? Similarly, could a person’s outward actions appear virtuous and honorable and yet her heart be far from God? The best of the Wesleyan tradition says “yes.” God is able to divide “soul from spirit” and to “judge the thoughts and intentions of the heart” (Heb. 4:12).
Let us ask the question one more time. Is it possible that a person be right with God because their heart is rightly oriented toward him, even if their understanding is thoroughly mistaken and their actions far from God’s ideal? The best of the Wesleyan tradition says “yes.” This sense of the heart as the focal point of God’s concern, more than your ideas or actions, reflects the Pietist influence on Wesley and, of course, ultimately traces its origins to Scripture.
One’s beliefs were certainly important to Wesley. And actions were even more important to Wesley than one’s beliefs. Certainly we will have great difficulty maintaining a good relationship with God for long outside of the community of faith. But the best of the Wesleyan tradition has always recognized that, for me as an individual, my heart is God’s focal concern. "It is what comes out of a person that defiles. For it is from within, from the human heart, that evil intentions come” (Mark 7:20-21, NRSV).
This heart orientation manifested itself in Wesley’s definition of sin as a “voluntary transgression of the law.” Is it possible to sin unintentionally? Certainly it is—we can wrong others without meaning to do so. We can also do wrong without even realizing it. It is not incorrect to call such wrongdoing “sin,” because it is this sort of sin that is the primary interest of the Levitical law—“high handed,” intentional sins left little room for forgiveness (e.g., Num. 15).
But the New Testament says almost nothing about unintentional sin. And it would be quite mistaken to think that God’s standard for sin in the New Testament is absolute perfection. Paul came closest to giving us a New Testament definition when he said that “whatever does not proceed from faith is sin” (Rom. 14:23, NRSV). This is the standard God has set for our relationship with him. It is not, “whoever does not believe the right things has sinned.” It is not even “whoever does not do the right things has sinned.” It is “the one whose thoughts and actions come from the wrong motivations has sinned.”
Some Christian traditions have struggled more than others with the postmodern challenge of these last decades. The postmodern critique pointed out how ambiguous language can be. The postmodern critique pointed out how often politics and power are involved in what we call truth. The postmodern critique exposed how unaware we often are of the cultural and historical influences on our paradigms, and how paradigms tend to change over time. We can learn from these critiques without abandoning our confidence that truth exists.
Indeed, somewhat ironically, the postmodern critique has actually reinforced the theological values the Wesleyan tradition has always had. We have always known the limitations of knowledge, even when it comes in Christian garb. Wesley was certainly a thinker, but he was also a pragmatist, the direction in which the postmodern critique pushes us. And our emphasis on transformation and divine encounter is completely unaffected. The best of the Wesleyan tradition has always known that truth is far more a matter of what is going on deep inside us than the relatively superficial thoughts we have with our conscious minds.
Sunday, February 27, 2011
Saturday, February 26, 2011
Why I Am a Wesleyan 1 (W)
Again, I apologize to those who don't care or have heard it all before. Maybe the muse will help me get it just right this time for some sort of booklet.
____________
A Generous Tradition
I appreciate aspects of all Christian traditions. I appreciate the sense of security in God that Baptist traditions have. I appreciate the emphases on grace and freedom in the Lutheran tradition. I appreciate the depth of the Roman Catholic tradition. Surely no Christian tradition has everything right, and surely we can agree on many things in almost all Christian traditions.
I personally come from the Wesleyan tradition, a tradition that traces its origins ultimately back to an eighteenth century Anglican minister named John Wesley. I do not think for one moment that he--or I--have everything all figured out. Indeed, like almost all Christian traditions in North America, the Wesleyan tradition today includes numerous little groups that spun off from their original Methodist roots.
In our current setting, you would not have to pick a "denomination," a group of churches that join together on the basis of some commonality. In fact, some churches have banded together on the common ground of opposition to denominations. The current climate includes a multitude of non-denominational churches and even the house church movement is going strong.
But a quick look at the beliefs and practices of the most virulently non-denominational church will almost always reveal the influence of historical Christian traditions. How to they baptize? What do they believe about particular issues? The answers to these questions almost always will reflect the influence of particular Christian traditions.
So I come from the Wesleyan tradition and have stayed with my tradition despite growing up, studying, and formulating my own personal understandings and practices of faith. I could no doubt express my faith and be enriched in almost any church. Why, then, am I a Wesleyan?
One reason is because the Wesleyan tradition is a heart-oriented tradition that, because it is focused primarily on our intentions and character, can be generous toward differing ideas and practices. It is not that the Wesleyan tradition is unconcerned with ideas or has no interest in the pursuit of truth. It is only that its focus on virtue and pure intentions make those concerns a second or even third order of business.
John Wesley, like most great thinkers, has left us with several memorable sayings that capture key truths. One of Wesley's was that "if your heart is as my heart, then put your hand in mind." I am a Wesleyan because the Wesleyan tradition is a generous tradition toward others. When we are at our best, we are more about finding what we have in common with others than with separating from others because of our differences.
Indeed, because of this heart-orientation, many churches in the Wesleyan tradition have developed a great freedom in church practice. For example, you will find almost every form of baptism in my own Wesleyan denomination, everything from believer's baptism to infant baptism to no baptism at all. While I have my own preferences, I delight in a tradition that does not fight over baptism, communion, or so many of the Christian practices that have so often divided Christian churches.
I am a Wesleyan because the Wesleyan tradition at its best is a generous tradition toward other traditions. Generosity in this sense is not the same as thinking all beliefs and practices are equally valid. It is simply an orientation toward others that sees the most important common ground as a matter of our intentions and character, not whether we all think or act the same way.
____________
A Generous Tradition
I appreciate aspects of all Christian traditions. I appreciate the sense of security in God that Baptist traditions have. I appreciate the emphases on grace and freedom in the Lutheran tradition. I appreciate the depth of the Roman Catholic tradition. Surely no Christian tradition has everything right, and surely we can agree on many things in almost all Christian traditions.
I personally come from the Wesleyan tradition, a tradition that traces its origins ultimately back to an eighteenth century Anglican minister named John Wesley. I do not think for one moment that he--or I--have everything all figured out. Indeed, like almost all Christian traditions in North America, the Wesleyan tradition today includes numerous little groups that spun off from their original Methodist roots.
In our current setting, you would not have to pick a "denomination," a group of churches that join together on the basis of some commonality. In fact, some churches have banded together on the common ground of opposition to denominations. The current climate includes a multitude of non-denominational churches and even the house church movement is going strong.
But a quick look at the beliefs and practices of the most virulently non-denominational church will almost always reveal the influence of historical Christian traditions. How to they baptize? What do they believe about particular issues? The answers to these questions almost always will reflect the influence of particular Christian traditions.
So I come from the Wesleyan tradition and have stayed with my tradition despite growing up, studying, and formulating my own personal understandings and practices of faith. I could no doubt express my faith and be enriched in almost any church. Why, then, am I a Wesleyan?
One reason is because the Wesleyan tradition is a heart-oriented tradition that, because it is focused primarily on our intentions and character, can be generous toward differing ideas and practices. It is not that the Wesleyan tradition is unconcerned with ideas or has no interest in the pursuit of truth. It is only that its focus on virtue and pure intentions make those concerns a second or even third order of business.
John Wesley, like most great thinkers, has left us with several memorable sayings that capture key truths. One of Wesley's was that "if your heart is as my heart, then put your hand in mind." I am a Wesleyan because the Wesleyan tradition is a generous tradition toward others. When we are at our best, we are more about finding what we have in common with others than with separating from others because of our differences.
Indeed, because of this heart-orientation, many churches in the Wesleyan tradition have developed a great freedom in church practice. For example, you will find almost every form of baptism in my own Wesleyan denomination, everything from believer's baptism to infant baptism to no baptism at all. While I have my own preferences, I delight in a tradition that does not fight over baptism, communion, or so many of the Christian practices that have so often divided Christian churches.
I am a Wesleyan because the Wesleyan tradition at its best is a generous tradition toward other traditions. Generosity in this sense is not the same as thinking all beliefs and practices are equally valid. It is simply an orientation toward others that sees the most important common ground as a matter of our intentions and character, not whether we all think or act the same way.
Friday, February 25, 2011
Not Again: What is a Wesleyan?
Sorry to do this again!!!
You may not know how big Indiana Wesleyan University is, but we have about 16,000 students now. I just found out yesterday that we have more graduate students in education that IU or any other institution in the State of Indiana. Our Adult and Professional Studies college is where most of these numbers are and they are all keen on our mission as a Christian institution. The problem is that I don't think they have a clue what it means to be Wesleyan--certainly not what the undergraduate School or seminary thinks it means to be Wesleyan.
So I find myself once again wanting to capture the identity of our brand of Wesleyanism in about 15 pages of writing that could be printed in a booklet like my little piece on women in ministry. My last attempt ended up 44 pages long--too long for a booklet, too short for a book. What's worse is that I wrote it with "audience drift," meaning that I did not consistently have one audience in view as I wrote. There's also a tightrope to walk between a sense of openness and generosity and being proud of certain identity features. I do fine in front of one audience or another, but I struggle to do justice to both at the same time.
I thought I would just try an outline today. Things to say with no more than one or two pages in each instance to say it.
1. Generous tradition toward other traditions (gen. orthodoxy, identity among diversity, flexibility in practice)
2. Heart oriented tradition (not afraid of postmodernism, pietist, revivalist, heart more than hands or head)
3. God as heart oriented (according to light, wanting to save everyone, not absolutist)
4. The cross as love and wooing (not primarily as justice)
5. Free will (which affects our politics, our parenting, our discipline)
6. Love as the law (and optimistic about it, our sense of sin as intent, as defeatable)
7. Love beyond spiritual (beyond evangelism to material needs, social justice)
8. Love into the structural (past on slavery and women, present, not fundamentalist)
9. Importance of faithfulness (works part of the equation, nature of grace)
10. Scripture as sacrament (of transformation, of divine encounter)
11. Scripture as story (of our identity, of God's walk with humanity and his people)
Any thoughts?
You may not know how big Indiana Wesleyan University is, but we have about 16,000 students now. I just found out yesterday that we have more graduate students in education that IU or any other institution in the State of Indiana. Our Adult and Professional Studies college is where most of these numbers are and they are all keen on our mission as a Christian institution. The problem is that I don't think they have a clue what it means to be Wesleyan--certainly not what the undergraduate School or seminary thinks it means to be Wesleyan.
So I find myself once again wanting to capture the identity of our brand of Wesleyanism in about 15 pages of writing that could be printed in a booklet like my little piece on women in ministry. My last attempt ended up 44 pages long--too long for a booklet, too short for a book. What's worse is that I wrote it with "audience drift," meaning that I did not consistently have one audience in view as I wrote. There's also a tightrope to walk between a sense of openness and generosity and being proud of certain identity features. I do fine in front of one audience or another, but I struggle to do justice to both at the same time.
I thought I would just try an outline today. Things to say with no more than one or two pages in each instance to say it.
1. Generous tradition toward other traditions (gen. orthodoxy, identity among diversity, flexibility in practice)
2. Heart oriented tradition (not afraid of postmodernism, pietist, revivalist, heart more than hands or head)
3. God as heart oriented (according to light, wanting to save everyone, not absolutist)
4. The cross as love and wooing (not primarily as justice)
5. Free will (which affects our politics, our parenting, our discipline)
6. Love as the law (and optimistic about it, our sense of sin as intent, as defeatable)
7. Love beyond spiritual (beyond evangelism to material needs, social justice)
8. Love into the structural (past on slavery and women, present, not fundamentalist)
9. Importance of faithfulness (works part of the equation, nature of grace)
10. Scripture as sacrament (of transformation, of divine encounter)
11. Scripture as story (of our identity, of God's walk with humanity and his people)
Any thoughts?
Thursday, February 24, 2011
Appropriating Scripture: Any thoughts?
I wrote this summary of "original meaning" appropriation (the third of three Christian methods of appropriating Scripture: 1) pneumatic, 2) theological, and 3) original meaning. Any additions or corrections?
____________
"We might thus suggest three key factors in appropriating the original meaning of a biblical book to today. First, there is the question of genre. What are the dynamics of each type of literature that come into play when appropriating that type.
Second, there is the question of continuity and discontinuity between “that time” and “this time.” The notion of continuity and discontinuity is arguably a little more sophisticated than talking about “all time” principles because, whether we like it or not, our sense of what those “all time” principles are is a function of “our time”—because we are the ones conceptualizing those principles! But in the end, what we may find is that there are some things we would not be able to do today that they could in biblical times (e.g., have slaves) and there may be some things that we can do today that they could not (e.g., have goatees).
Finally, there is the question of integrating biblical teaching. How does one Scripture connect to the other pieces of Scripture? Where does an individual passage stand in the flow of revelation? This rigorous method is surely not necessary to hear God’s voice in Scripture, but it is sound nonetheless and, in many respects, safer than the pneumatic method we mentioned above."
____________
"We might thus suggest three key factors in appropriating the original meaning of a biblical book to today. First, there is the question of genre. What are the dynamics of each type of literature that come into play when appropriating that type.
Second, there is the question of continuity and discontinuity between “that time” and “this time.” The notion of continuity and discontinuity is arguably a little more sophisticated than talking about “all time” principles because, whether we like it or not, our sense of what those “all time” principles are is a function of “our time”—because we are the ones conceptualizing those principles! But in the end, what we may find is that there are some things we would not be able to do today that they could in biblical times (e.g., have slaves) and there may be some things that we can do today that they could not (e.g., have goatees).
Finally, there is the question of integrating biblical teaching. How does one Scripture connect to the other pieces of Scripture? Where does an individual passage stand in the flow of revelation? This rigorous method is surely not necessary to hear God’s voice in Scripture, but it is sound nonetheless and, in many respects, safer than the pneumatic method we mentioned above."
Wednesday, February 23, 2011
OT Law in the New Testament: fair summary?
I've written this summary for a class. Is it fair? Have I missed an option?
"Some traditions pay more attention to Old Testament Law than others. Some American churches formed in nineteenth century dispensationalism have a tendency to see Old Testament Law in more continuity with the New Testament than other Christian traditions do (e.g., Seventh Day Adventists). High Protestant traditions like Lutherans and the Reformed like to see the Law as completely fulfilled in Christ, to where we are not bound by anything in the Old Testament except the law to love God and love our neighbor. A more partitioned approach is also possible, asking which Old Testament laws the New Testament retains, which ones the New Testament considers fulfilled, and which ones the New Testament abandons."
"Some traditions pay more attention to Old Testament Law than others. Some American churches formed in nineteenth century dispensationalism have a tendency to see Old Testament Law in more continuity with the New Testament than other Christian traditions do (e.g., Seventh Day Adventists). High Protestant traditions like Lutherans and the Reformed like to see the Law as completely fulfilled in Christ, to where we are not bound by anything in the Old Testament except the law to love God and love our neighbor. A more partitioned approach is also possible, asking which Old Testament laws the New Testament retains, which ones the New Testament considers fulfilled, and which ones the New Testament abandons."
Three Obstacles to Vision
I found some comments interesting yesterday in Carson Pue's book, Mentoring Leaders. He mentions three characteristics that sometimes blur a young leader's sense of vision (82). Putting them in my words:
1. Too many things they are able to do.
If a person only has one gift or area of interest, it's pretty easy to have a clear sense of direction.
2. Too many things they are doing.
The more involved you get, the more your life runs on autopilot and you don't stop to focus on a vision.
3. They proceed without self-awareness.
So they do not eliminate things that hold them back or mistake personality for God, etc...
P.S. I think Pue's preface is a cop-out. Alternating between masculine and feminine pronouns is only "distracting and confusing" (12) if you do not fully see them as interchangeable. Masculine pronouns are no longer generic to modern readers. When I see "he," I think "he" and not "she." If you really believe women can be leaders, it hurts nothing to vary your pronouns. It's hard for me not to think his decision to go with all masculine pronouns is simply a move to placate the typical reader of this sort of book, despite his preface comments to the contrary.
1. Too many things they are able to do.
If a person only has one gift or area of interest, it's pretty easy to have a clear sense of direction.
2. Too many things they are doing.
The more involved you get, the more your life runs on autopilot and you don't stop to focus on a vision.
3. They proceed without self-awareness.
So they do not eliminate things that hold them back or mistake personality for God, etc...
P.S. I think Pue's preface is a cop-out. Alternating between masculine and feminine pronouns is only "distracting and confusing" (12) if you do not fully see them as interchangeable. Masculine pronouns are no longer generic to modern readers. When I see "he," I think "he" and not "she." If you really believe women can be leaders, it hurts nothing to vary your pronouns. It's hard for me not to think his decision to go with all masculine pronouns is simply a move to placate the typical reader of this sort of book, despite his preface comments to the contrary.
Tuesday, February 22, 2011
Middle East
What's happening in the Middle East? We'll have to see.
A first thought is that we are seeing more consequences of the flattening of the world. With the internet, cell phones, and such, governments can't isolate their people, especially their young people. And once people get a taste of what is possible, it's hard to deny them. But this is also a protest against distress as much as an assertion of freedom.
It remains to be seen from country to country what the end result is. Egypt could end up better. Libya might just switch dictators. Some could go more democratic. Others more fundamentalist. We'll see. Thus far these do not seem to be ideologically driven rebellions, just people tired of oppression and economic distress. But what inserts itself into vacuums remains to be seen.
So far, it's exciting to think about what might happen. For one thing, it would be nice to knock the notion out of so many Americans' heads that all Muslims want to blow us up.
A first thought is that we are seeing more consequences of the flattening of the world. With the internet, cell phones, and such, governments can't isolate their people, especially their young people. And once people get a taste of what is possible, it's hard to deny them. But this is also a protest against distress as much as an assertion of freedom.
It remains to be seen from country to country what the end result is. Egypt could end up better. Libya might just switch dictators. Some could go more democratic. Others more fundamentalist. We'll see. Thus far these do not seem to be ideologically driven rebellions, just people tired of oppression and economic distress. But what inserts itself into vacuums remains to be seen.
So far, it's exciting to think about what might happen. For one thing, it would be nice to knock the notion out of so many Americans' heads that all Muslims want to blow us up.
Monday, February 21, 2011
Leviticus 19:1-2
I don't suppose that many of us spend long periods of time pondering Leviticus, but yesterday's OT lectionary reading made me think of the current immigrant debate:
"The Lord spoke to Moses, saying: Speak to all the congregation of the people of Israel and say to them: You shall be holy, for I the Lord your God am holy. When you reap the harvest of your land, you shall not reap to the very edges of your field, or gather the gleanings of your harvest. You shall not strip your vineyard bare, or gather the fallen grapes of your vineyard; you shall leave them for the poor and the alien: I am the Lord your God" (NRSV).
"The Lord spoke to Moses, saying: Speak to all the congregation of the people of Israel and say to them: You shall be holy, for I the Lord your God am holy. When you reap the harvest of your land, you shall not reap to the very edges of your field, or gather the gleanings of your harvest. You shall not strip your vineyard bare, or gather the fallen grapes of your vineyard; you shall leave them for the poor and the alien: I am the Lord your God" (NRSV).
Saturday, February 19, 2011
Mixed Wisconsin Feelings...
I either do not have the insight to take a definitive position or perhaps the Wisconsin political situation is complex. ;-)
Here are three conflicting impressions I've had:
1. The collective bargaining power of unions is a mixed blessing. On the one hand, it arose in a context where business was running over the individual little man. I also think that in a different period, unions have made it difficult for some businesses to be competitive by unreasonable demands. I don't know what the solution is.
2. Who would want to be a public school teacher in America today? The kids are atrocious because the parents are atrocious. Local teachers and administrators waste half their time filling out paperwork for the government. They aren't empowered to do what needs to be done locally. They're not even allowed to physically remove disruptive students from the classroom. The drop out rate for teachers in the first 5 years is enormous. They are the play thing of political debate and subject to ever changing expectations.
And now they're getting a massive pay cut in Wisconsin by cutting pension and health care from their existing salary. I heard a commentator on Fox News this morning repeat the governor's rhetoric in his own words--they're being paid too much and given too much vacation. Right. Actually, let's just put some unemployed janitors in as teachers. How hard can it be to teach someone to read, right?
3. The entire amount of the current Wisconsin budget shortfall would be covered four times over with tax cuts that have been made in the state over the last 10 years. This is a debate America needs to have. What is the "sweet spot" on taxes? Taxes fund the government. The government provides services to provide for a common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty. But taxes reduce individual spending, which diminishes profitability in the free market, which gives individuals less money to spend--which yields less taxes.
Both sides need to get their head straight, I believe. For the one side, high taxes presumably do not lead to a thriving economy or society. The impulse to keep as much money in the hands of the people that spend it (which is not necessarily the wealthy) seems to be a good impulse.
For the other side, there is no divine right against taxes. Paul said to pay taxes. Jesus said to pay taxes. I cannot even imagine how to make an informed biblical, Christian, or moral argument against taxes along the lines of the current debates.
My main hope is more local. I have a mixture of people who read this blog from time to time, people on both sides of these issues. Perhaps we can carve out just a small island of mutual understanding and of Christian clarity. As I've said before, we should be able to agree on our broad Christian values, even if working out the details is complicated.
Here are three conflicting impressions I've had:
1. The collective bargaining power of unions is a mixed blessing. On the one hand, it arose in a context where business was running over the individual little man. I also think that in a different period, unions have made it difficult for some businesses to be competitive by unreasonable demands. I don't know what the solution is.
2. Who would want to be a public school teacher in America today? The kids are atrocious because the parents are atrocious. Local teachers and administrators waste half their time filling out paperwork for the government. They aren't empowered to do what needs to be done locally. They're not even allowed to physically remove disruptive students from the classroom. The drop out rate for teachers in the first 5 years is enormous. They are the play thing of political debate and subject to ever changing expectations.
And now they're getting a massive pay cut in Wisconsin by cutting pension and health care from their existing salary. I heard a commentator on Fox News this morning repeat the governor's rhetoric in his own words--they're being paid too much and given too much vacation. Right. Actually, let's just put some unemployed janitors in as teachers. How hard can it be to teach someone to read, right?
3. The entire amount of the current Wisconsin budget shortfall would be covered four times over with tax cuts that have been made in the state over the last 10 years. This is a debate America needs to have. What is the "sweet spot" on taxes? Taxes fund the government. The government provides services to provide for a common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty. But taxes reduce individual spending, which diminishes profitability in the free market, which gives individuals less money to spend--which yields less taxes.
Both sides need to get their head straight, I believe. For the one side, high taxes presumably do not lead to a thriving economy or society. The impulse to keep as much money in the hands of the people that spend it (which is not necessarily the wealthy) seems to be a good impulse.
For the other side, there is no divine right against taxes. Paul said to pay taxes. Jesus said to pay taxes. I cannot even imagine how to make an informed biblical, Christian, or moral argument against taxes along the lines of the current debates.
My main hope is more local. I have a mixture of people who read this blog from time to time, people on both sides of these issues. Perhaps we can carve out just a small island of mutual understanding and of Christian clarity. As I've said before, we should be able to agree on our broad Christian values, even if working out the details is complicated.
Friday, February 18, 2011
Dangers of Ideological Isolation
You all can imagine that there are many times when I wish I were situated in a place where I could dedicate my thoughts strictly to the question of truth. But when it comes to things like religion and politics, there is usually another layer that is also in play. For religion, there is the question of the impact of truth and truth discussions on faith. For politics, there are questions of keeping the system moving and getting re-elected.
Like Dubois said about the identity of an African-American, those in religion and politics have two identities--who you think you are and who other people think you are. I like what Obama said to O'Reilly last week about those who hate him. He said he didn't worry about it because they didn't know him. In so many words, they only knew a caricature of him. I know I have misjudged others before because of the blanks I filled in with my mind, rather than leaning on what I actually saw of them face to face.
All of this is to thank those of you who disagree with me from time to time here on the blog. It would be more comfortable no doubt if only people who agreed with me commented here. But isn't that our problem? Democrats only talk to Democrats and get more extreme, or libertarians only talk to libertarians and get more extreme. When Wesleyans only talked to other Wesleyans, let's face it we were pretty bizarre in some ways.
So thank you for your loyal opposition. I learn from you and I hope I at least make you think from time to time.
Like Dubois said about the identity of an African-American, those in religion and politics have two identities--who you think you are and who other people think you are. I like what Obama said to O'Reilly last week about those who hate him. He said he didn't worry about it because they didn't know him. In so many words, they only knew a caricature of him. I know I have misjudged others before because of the blanks I filled in with my mind, rather than leaning on what I actually saw of them face to face.
All of this is to thank those of you who disagree with me from time to time here on the blog. It would be more comfortable no doubt if only people who agreed with me commented here. But isn't that our problem? Democrats only talk to Democrats and get more extreme, or libertarians only talk to libertarians and get more extreme. When Wesleyans only talked to other Wesleyans, let's face it we were pretty bizarre in some ways.
So thank you for your loyal opposition. I learn from you and I hope I at least make you think from time to time.
Thursday, February 17, 2011
Commentary Series Recommendation for Pastors
This is a recommendation for evangelical pastors. I'm often asked about what commentary series to buy by Wesleyan pastors and seminary students. The usual scholarly answer is less than helpful, even if it is accurate. You'll hear things like, "You really should buy commentaries based on the author and specific commentary rather than by the series."
Certainly that's true. The authors in a series are not all the same. Some are better than others. Some are better at one book than another. But how do you know which to pick? Certainly David Bauer's Annotated Guide is good.
Another thing scholars will do is recommend a series out of the reach of most pastors. For example, the Word series is excellent. The Hermeneia is probably the most scholarly of all. But these commentaries are not the most helpful to the typical pastor who may not know the original languages or not know them well. Also, these commentaries are not oriented around application but around the original meaning.
So for the typical evangelical pastor, I have generally settled on recommending the NIV Application Commentary series for the following reasons:
1. It does not require knowledge of Greek and Hebrew.
2. It addresses the kinds of questions that evangelicals ask and answers them from an evangelical perspective.
3. It does a fair job of making you aware of the kinds of background information you could not really get from the text itself.
4. It is accessible. The format is friendly to the "get it quick" user.
5. It is hermeneutically aware. Sections have clear distinctions between interpretation and application.
The main drawback for Wesleyans is that there are no authors from the Wesleyan tradition in this entire series. This is our situation in general. The Wesleyan tradition neither has the publishing power of other traditions nor general interest in publishing/buying these sorts of books. That means the most you will get at best is a broadly Arminian perspective from the NIV Application series. For some that's a strength; for Wesleyans, it means opportunities are missed. I hope to look at the new Nazarene series some time soon to see if it fills in some of these gaps.
The same goes for instances where evangelicalism is out of sync with majority scholarship. For example, Moo's IVP Application Commentary on 2 Peter/Jude tries to argue that Jude is dependent on 2 Peter. This is an attempt based purely on ideological rather than exegetical concerns. But you could argue that it is exactly this sort of interpretive perspective evangelical pastors are looking for, so that could be a strength rather than a weakness.
Certainly that's true. The authors in a series are not all the same. Some are better than others. Some are better at one book than another. But how do you know which to pick? Certainly David Bauer's Annotated Guide is good.
Another thing scholars will do is recommend a series out of the reach of most pastors. For example, the Word series is excellent. The Hermeneia is probably the most scholarly of all. But these commentaries are not the most helpful to the typical pastor who may not know the original languages or not know them well. Also, these commentaries are not oriented around application but around the original meaning.
So for the typical evangelical pastor, I have generally settled on recommending the NIV Application Commentary series for the following reasons:
1. It does not require knowledge of Greek and Hebrew.
2. It addresses the kinds of questions that evangelicals ask and answers them from an evangelical perspective.
3. It does a fair job of making you aware of the kinds of background information you could not really get from the text itself.
4. It is accessible. The format is friendly to the "get it quick" user.
5. It is hermeneutically aware. Sections have clear distinctions between interpretation and application.
The main drawback for Wesleyans is that there are no authors from the Wesleyan tradition in this entire series. This is our situation in general. The Wesleyan tradition neither has the publishing power of other traditions nor general interest in publishing/buying these sorts of books. That means the most you will get at best is a broadly Arminian perspective from the NIV Application series. For some that's a strength; for Wesleyans, it means opportunities are missed. I hope to look at the new Nazarene series some time soon to see if it fills in some of these gaps.
The same goes for instances where evangelicalism is out of sync with majority scholarship. For example, Moo's IVP Application Commentary on 2 Peter/Jude tries to argue that Jude is dependent on 2 Peter. This is an attempt based purely on ideological rather than exegetical concerns. But you could argue that it is exactly this sort of interpretive perspective evangelical pastors are looking for, so that could be a strength rather than a weakness.
Computers Win
I'm struck with the fact that a computer beat two human contestants on Jeopardy. We've all enjoyed iRobot, Matrix, Terminator, and all the sci-fi movies where computers take over the world. I am struck by the very real possibility that the thought experiment could one day be a reality.
It is naive to think that there is anything a computer could not be programmed to "simulate." Emotion, moral values, virtue, vice, intellect, research capacity--I have little doubt but that these processes could one day not long from now be programmed in a manner that gave a robot the appearance of much greater consistency than anyone in your neighborhood. This brings a number of related thoughts:
1. At first, robots and machines replaced those who do hard labor. Next, they will replace doctors and researchers. Why go to a doctor who is very fallible? Why not go to a robot who is better than any human diagnostician could ever be?
2. Our sense of these things is generally very simplistic. The American ethos makes fun of taking classes on things like psychology or the brain, then thinks its opinion is as valid as any other on these sorts of matters. The physical structure of the brain can account for far more than we would like to think in the areas of emotion, religious experience, and values.
Here's the bottom line: the notion that the existence of a detachable soul might be necessary to account for human processes is an act of faith--and one many Christians do not think is dictated by Scripture or creed. It could turn out that the word "simulate" in relation to robotic thought is a rather artificial distinction. I am not taking a position here, since the answer seems unprovable at present. I am simply saying that at present, it is unclear what "mind process" is not accounted for adequately by the physical brain.
Just to fend off alarm, if you are unfamiliar with this discussion, those like Joel Green who take this position believe in the afterlife, believe in human moral responsibility, etc. They just consider language of the soul as metaphorical and unbiblical. I have blogged on this before.
3. This also bears on some of the, in my opinion, naive statements sometimes made about God. For example, many say that God became Jesus so he could learn what it felt like to be human, as if emotional and experiential knowledge are fundamentally distinguishable from cognitive knowledge. For God this distinction is nonsensical. God created emotions, experiences, and even the potential to sin. Omniscience means that God must know not only "intellectual" truths, but experiential ones as well. This distinction is meaningless on the level of God.
Some thoughts on Jeopardy ;-)
It is naive to think that there is anything a computer could not be programmed to "simulate." Emotion, moral values, virtue, vice, intellect, research capacity--I have little doubt but that these processes could one day not long from now be programmed in a manner that gave a robot the appearance of much greater consistency than anyone in your neighborhood. This brings a number of related thoughts:
1. At first, robots and machines replaced those who do hard labor. Next, they will replace doctors and researchers. Why go to a doctor who is very fallible? Why not go to a robot who is better than any human diagnostician could ever be?
2. Our sense of these things is generally very simplistic. The American ethos makes fun of taking classes on things like psychology or the brain, then thinks its opinion is as valid as any other on these sorts of matters. The physical structure of the brain can account for far more than we would like to think in the areas of emotion, religious experience, and values.
Here's the bottom line: the notion that the existence of a detachable soul might be necessary to account for human processes is an act of faith--and one many Christians do not think is dictated by Scripture or creed. It could turn out that the word "simulate" in relation to robotic thought is a rather artificial distinction. I am not taking a position here, since the answer seems unprovable at present. I am simply saying that at present, it is unclear what "mind process" is not accounted for adequately by the physical brain.
Just to fend off alarm, if you are unfamiliar with this discussion, those like Joel Green who take this position believe in the afterlife, believe in human moral responsibility, etc. They just consider language of the soul as metaphorical and unbiblical. I have blogged on this before.
3. This also bears on some of the, in my opinion, naive statements sometimes made about God. For example, many say that God became Jesus so he could learn what it felt like to be human, as if emotional and experiential knowledge are fundamentally distinguishable from cognitive knowledge. For God this distinction is nonsensical. God created emotions, experiences, and even the potential to sin. Omniscience means that God must know not only "intellectual" truths, but experiential ones as well. This distinction is meaningless on the level of God.
Some thoughts on Jeopardy ;-)
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Budget Cutting is Hard...
Heard two bits of information yesterday that hit hard. The one is that the House is proposing to cut Fulbright funding over a billion dollars this week. I'm in the process of finding out whether I'll get a Fulbright to go on sabbatical next year. Suffice it to say, such a cut could hurt deeply!
The other is the proposal to cut funding entirely for public radio. I do watch the local morning news and some of the Today Show on TV. I occasionally will put on CNN or MSNBC for headline news. But NPR is my primary source of news every hour on the hour, driving in to work and driving home. I like listening to Morning Edition, Talk of the Nation, and All Things Considered because the hosts are polite and try not to take sides. I generally don't know their own positions.
These were illustrations to me yesterday of how hard it's going to be to get the deficit under control. If it were possible, I'd prefer for them to do a cross the board percentage cut--to get the budget under control in 5 years we must cut everything x%. I suppose it doesn't work that way but perhaps it could be a place to start.
What can't happen is ideological cutting. Almost everything must be cut, from defense to things like the above that preserve America's soul. Ironically, defunding the arts and value added programs like Fulbright remind me of the old Communist sense that only what is useful in a very narrow and material sense matters. It's funny how if you go far enough to one extreme you can become like the other extreme. Completely defunding things like PBS or NPR is ideological cutting and is counterproductive.
This budget cutting is going to hurt everyone if it is done right. What's the magic percentage? Start there with everything, let each area suggest specifics, and let's go from there. We'll all hurt together.
The other is the proposal to cut funding entirely for public radio. I do watch the local morning news and some of the Today Show on TV. I occasionally will put on CNN or MSNBC for headline news. But NPR is my primary source of news every hour on the hour, driving in to work and driving home. I like listening to Morning Edition, Talk of the Nation, and All Things Considered because the hosts are polite and try not to take sides. I generally don't know their own positions.
These were illustrations to me yesterday of how hard it's going to be to get the deficit under control. If it were possible, I'd prefer for them to do a cross the board percentage cut--to get the budget under control in 5 years we must cut everything x%. I suppose it doesn't work that way but perhaps it could be a place to start.
What can't happen is ideological cutting. Almost everything must be cut, from defense to things like the above that preserve America's soul. Ironically, defunding the arts and value added programs like Fulbright remind me of the old Communist sense that only what is useful in a very narrow and material sense matters. It's funny how if you go far enough to one extreme you can become like the other extreme. Completely defunding things like PBS or NPR is ideological cutting and is counterproductive.
This budget cutting is going to hurt everyone if it is done right. What's the magic percentage? Start there with everything, let each area suggest specifics, and let's go from there. We'll all hurt together.
Tuesday, February 15, 2011
Sampling the Bible/Theology Divide
John Drury gave a wonderful comparison of John Wesley and Karl Barth's interpretation of Matthew 5:48 at our weekly Theological Seminar (3:30 every week in the CM building if you're interested). It highlighted to me again the contrasting use Christian interpreters of the centuries have put to Scripture versus the original meaning. Three quick examples come to mind of late.
1. Barth has a rather sophisticated understanding of Matthew 5:48--perfect means brought to its appropriate goal, which would of course differ in specifics between God and humanity. For Wesley, of course, this verse hinted at Christian perfection. Both are wrong in terms of the original meaning. Perfection in Matthew 5:48 simply means to be complete, to go the whole way. Love your enemies and your neighbor. Be complete. The completion is exactly the same for God and for humanity in this case.
2. A student email asked of the distinction between the kingdom of heaven and the kingdom of God. Apparently, this is a well worked out distinction among Christian interpreters. In Matthew, however, they are synonymous, with the phrase "kingdom of heaven" being a matter of Matthew's style.
3. Salvation for Paul is future oriented (with the possible exception of Ephesians). It is to escape God's coming wrath on the Day of Judgment. Theologians of the centuries, I think however, have focused more on salvation in the present.
Because of the flexibility of language, I accept the validity of both types of interpretation, the original, contextual one, and the truths Christian theologians have heard in the words over the centuries. The truths they see do not necessarily contradict the original meaning. They are just interpreting the words differently.
But I'm never quite sure what to do with the difference. If you want theological enrichment, Augustine, Aquinas, Luther, Wesley are wonderful. But don't go to any of these if you want the original meaning. They were not oriented or equipped to read in context and their interpretations regularly fall far wide of the mark from an inductive standpoint.
My problem is that I find it distracting. Barth is incredibly profound, as are so many theologians. I feel like I should be able to listen to him or Wesley for the truth God gave to them on their own terms. But I am left wondering what to do with the fact that they sometimes do their dance based on misunderstanding. Perhaps this is my problem and one that shouldn't be.
1. Barth has a rather sophisticated understanding of Matthew 5:48--perfect means brought to its appropriate goal, which would of course differ in specifics between God and humanity. For Wesley, of course, this verse hinted at Christian perfection. Both are wrong in terms of the original meaning. Perfection in Matthew 5:48 simply means to be complete, to go the whole way. Love your enemies and your neighbor. Be complete. The completion is exactly the same for God and for humanity in this case.
2. A student email asked of the distinction between the kingdom of heaven and the kingdom of God. Apparently, this is a well worked out distinction among Christian interpreters. In Matthew, however, they are synonymous, with the phrase "kingdom of heaven" being a matter of Matthew's style.
3. Salvation for Paul is future oriented (with the possible exception of Ephesians). It is to escape God's coming wrath on the Day of Judgment. Theologians of the centuries, I think however, have focused more on salvation in the present.
Because of the flexibility of language, I accept the validity of both types of interpretation, the original, contextual one, and the truths Christian theologians have heard in the words over the centuries. The truths they see do not necessarily contradict the original meaning. They are just interpreting the words differently.
But I'm never quite sure what to do with the difference. If you want theological enrichment, Augustine, Aquinas, Luther, Wesley are wonderful. But don't go to any of these if you want the original meaning. They were not oriented or equipped to read in context and their interpretations regularly fall far wide of the mark from an inductive standpoint.
My problem is that I find it distracting. Barth is incredibly profound, as are so many theologians. I feel like I should be able to listen to him or Wesley for the truth God gave to them on their own terms. But I am left wondering what to do with the fact that they sometimes do their dance based on misunderstanding. Perhaps this is my problem and one that shouldn't be.
Monday, February 14, 2011
Nazarene Statement on the Bible
The Nazarenes met last week at NNU to clarify the words we so often use in talking about the Bible and to do so from a Wesleyan position informed by the lead of Wesley himself. Below are five statements they came up with. I've included a few comments in red interspersed.
1. The Bible has its origin in the heart of God. God inspired the authors and inspires readers of Scripture across the ages. God uses the Bible to call us to faithful response.
I like the fact that the Nazarenes recognize the importance of inspiration for readers along with the original inspiration. From a pragmatic perspective, unless a reader or group of readers can experience God in the words, then the text does no good whatsoever for that reader. For precision, something might also have been said about the contextual nature of the original inspiration.
2. The Bible consistently witnesses to, reveals, and teaches the Church regarding God's purpose of salvation and holy life. It is consistently confirmed by the Christian community, empowered by the Holy Spirit.
The role of the Church in the first five centuries was incredibly important in establishing the core interpretations Christians make of Scripture in relation to Christology and the Trinity. This statement begins to get at how crucial a role the Church has played in God's gift of Scripture to us, but is much weaker than it might be.
3. The Bible is inerrant in what it does: the Spirit is at work revealing through human words the character and purposes of God to redeem, in Christ, all creation.
Perhaps this statement is an attempt to re-steer language of inerrancy from the past. A more precise wording might say that the Bible is infallible in what it does. Nevertheless, this statement reflects some of the brilliant understanding speech-act theory has brought to such things. Words do things, and stating ideological truth is only one thing that words can do. This statement indicates that the primary thing that the Bible "does" is reveal the character and purposes of God. Perhaps we might more accurately say that the primary thing God does through Scripture is to transform us into his likeness (or Keith Drury would say, "to form a holy people").
4. We interpret the Bible in a dynamic process. This requires that Christians interpret in community, in prayerful humility, and relying upon the Holy Spirit. Good interpretation is informed by the tradition, anchored by essential Christian beliefs, and informed by the best contributions of saints and scholars today.
This statement strikes me as "theological interpretation" speak. I agree with what this language "does." I have recently used the analogy of a good golf swing. This statement gives key elements in a good golf swing, in the proper appropriation of Scripture. I just don't think the scholars who crafted this language fully understand their own swing.
This statement blurs two quite different activities. There is original meaning interpretation, which is squarely a function of the range of meanings words had at the time the books were written. An atheist historian could interpret the original meaning soundly, although it is certainly appropriate for us to pray for the illumination of our minds and to be informed by the best contributions of saints today.
But it is theological interpretation and theological appropriation that appropriately bring along extra-biblical elements like tradition and humility. And the Holy Spirit is essential if we are to appropriate Scripture properly today, the essential ingredient that an atheist does not bring to the text. This statement blurs together appropriate, but distinct interpretations of biblical language.
5. Christians have always engaged and interacted with the cultures in which they live. Yet the essential message of the Bible remains consistent. Christians in humility endeavor to engage the postmodern world by listening to, speaking with, living among, and embodying Christ-like love to this generation.
This is about the importance of contextualization of the message. Jesus and Paul modeled an approach to Scripture that took into account the context into which it spoke.
So those are some of my takes. Does anyone know if Maddox's talk on Wesley's use of Scripture is available? Of course Wesley was not the founder of the Nazarene Church any more than he founded the Free Methodists or the Wesleyans. We are free to be more profound than Wesley was.
In any case, here is the website about the conclusion of the conference.
1. The Bible has its origin in the heart of God. God inspired the authors and inspires readers of Scripture across the ages. God uses the Bible to call us to faithful response.
I like the fact that the Nazarenes recognize the importance of inspiration for readers along with the original inspiration. From a pragmatic perspective, unless a reader or group of readers can experience God in the words, then the text does no good whatsoever for that reader. For precision, something might also have been said about the contextual nature of the original inspiration.
2. The Bible consistently witnesses to, reveals, and teaches the Church regarding God's purpose of salvation and holy life. It is consistently confirmed by the Christian community, empowered by the Holy Spirit.
The role of the Church in the first five centuries was incredibly important in establishing the core interpretations Christians make of Scripture in relation to Christology and the Trinity. This statement begins to get at how crucial a role the Church has played in God's gift of Scripture to us, but is much weaker than it might be.
3. The Bible is inerrant in what it does: the Spirit is at work revealing through human words the character and purposes of God to redeem, in Christ, all creation.
Perhaps this statement is an attempt to re-steer language of inerrancy from the past. A more precise wording might say that the Bible is infallible in what it does. Nevertheless, this statement reflects some of the brilliant understanding speech-act theory has brought to such things. Words do things, and stating ideological truth is only one thing that words can do. This statement indicates that the primary thing that the Bible "does" is reveal the character and purposes of God. Perhaps we might more accurately say that the primary thing God does through Scripture is to transform us into his likeness (or Keith Drury would say, "to form a holy people").
4. We interpret the Bible in a dynamic process. This requires that Christians interpret in community, in prayerful humility, and relying upon the Holy Spirit. Good interpretation is informed by the tradition, anchored by essential Christian beliefs, and informed by the best contributions of saints and scholars today.
This statement strikes me as "theological interpretation" speak. I agree with what this language "does." I have recently used the analogy of a good golf swing. This statement gives key elements in a good golf swing, in the proper appropriation of Scripture. I just don't think the scholars who crafted this language fully understand their own swing.
This statement blurs two quite different activities. There is original meaning interpretation, which is squarely a function of the range of meanings words had at the time the books were written. An atheist historian could interpret the original meaning soundly, although it is certainly appropriate for us to pray for the illumination of our minds and to be informed by the best contributions of saints today.
But it is theological interpretation and theological appropriation that appropriately bring along extra-biblical elements like tradition and humility. And the Holy Spirit is essential if we are to appropriate Scripture properly today, the essential ingredient that an atheist does not bring to the text. This statement blurs together appropriate, but distinct interpretations of biblical language.
5. Christians have always engaged and interacted with the cultures in which they live. Yet the essential message of the Bible remains consistent. Christians in humility endeavor to engage the postmodern world by listening to, speaking with, living among, and embodying Christ-like love to this generation.
This is about the importance of contextualization of the message. Jesus and Paul modeled an approach to Scripture that took into account the context into which it spoke.
So those are some of my takes. Does anyone know if Maddox's talk on Wesley's use of Scripture is available? Of course Wesley was not the founder of the Nazarene Church any more than he founded the Free Methodists or the Wesleyans. We are free to be more profound than Wesley was.
In any case, here is the website about the conclusion of the conference.
Saturday, February 12, 2011
Blockbuster's Dying Breath...
Blockbuster's closing here in Marion. We loved it. It's less than a mile from our house. We were on the pass, which meant we could go in and get 2 new movies at any time with no late fees. Every month it auto-paid.
So we had not jumped on the Netflix band wagon. My step-daughter at college wondered what reason she would even have to come home with no Blockbuster for her and Spencer to use in the service of hours of endless boredom. ;-)
Alas, at the sell-out Tuesday, I bit the bullet and bought a Toshiba Blu-Ray device that has built in wireless and that you can use either for Blockbuster or Netflix. I cancelled my pass, signed up for the DVD mailing service (which simply does not satisfy last minute people like us who might go through 4 videos on a Saturday). What I expected is that I would be able to buy some sort of online pass to use with the Blu-Ray.
Not so. As a sign of Blockbuster's death, I have to pay $3.99 per video we "rent" through blockbuster.com. It's valid for 24 hours. This of course means that if we were to have any Marathon Saturdays, we will have to pay nearly $20 to do it.
The final insult was not only that the "signing" package only gives you $5 free (=one On Demand rental) but that our inaugural movie last night "wasn't eligible" for free.
My conclusion? Blockbuster will go bankrupt in the next 12 months.
So we had not jumped on the Netflix band wagon. My step-daughter at college wondered what reason she would even have to come home with no Blockbuster for her and Spencer to use in the service of hours of endless boredom. ;-)
Alas, at the sell-out Tuesday, I bit the bullet and bought a Toshiba Blu-Ray device that has built in wireless and that you can use either for Blockbuster or Netflix. I cancelled my pass, signed up for the DVD mailing service (which simply does not satisfy last minute people like us who might go through 4 videos on a Saturday). What I expected is that I would be able to buy some sort of online pass to use with the Blu-Ray.
Not so. As a sign of Blockbuster's death, I have to pay $3.99 per video we "rent" through blockbuster.com. It's valid for 24 hours. This of course means that if we were to have any Marathon Saturdays, we will have to pay nearly $20 to do it.
The final insult was not only that the "signing" package only gives you $5 free (=one On Demand rental) but that our inaugural movie last night "wasn't eligible" for free.
My conclusion? Blockbuster will go bankrupt in the next 12 months.
Friday, February 11, 2011
A Biblical Theology?
Someone recently asked me if there was a biblical theology in print that I would recommend as a Wesleyan. I've heard that Dennis Kinlaw has produced an OT one (I haven't found it on Amazon). I made the usual references to Ladd and Marshall recently has one.
If I were to make a prediction, we might see in a few years a glut of biblical theologies. What somewhat killed biblical theology about a generation ago is the fact that each biblical author has a unique theology. The typical biblical theology book thus goes author by author and points out what is unique for them. But with the rise of theological interpretation, we can come clean about the fact that biblical material can be organized on the basis of Christian theology external to the text itself.
In short, the hermeneutical climate would now allow for a synthesized biblical theology once again, like the pre-modern ones of yore that did not realize they were organizing the content of the biblical texts on the basis of later Christian theology, but this time with intentionality.
So my next thought is predictable. Should I dedicate a few years to writing one? My answer thus far is no. First, there is no real demand for me to write anything, especially on this level. My own denominational publishers don't publish serious scholarship, and I don't know of any mainstream publishers that would be interested since I hardly have a following in mainstream circles.
But I also became stymied when I began to think of how I would organize the topic of God. Barth, for example, organized his Dogmatics around Christ. But God the Father remains the uncontested center of Scripture, with Christ firmly subordinated to him in the New Testament. Once more it reminded me that I am not trendy enough to write this work. The great biblical theology that would sell today would have to be co-written by someone with Richard Bauckham's Christological interpretations and Joel Green's hermeneutic.
Does that person exist? Michael Gorman? Maybe some of us in the Methodist tradition could get together. Just let me write some of the parts on hamartiology, justification, and sanctification. ;-)
If I were to make a prediction, we might see in a few years a glut of biblical theologies. What somewhat killed biblical theology about a generation ago is the fact that each biblical author has a unique theology. The typical biblical theology book thus goes author by author and points out what is unique for them. But with the rise of theological interpretation, we can come clean about the fact that biblical material can be organized on the basis of Christian theology external to the text itself.
In short, the hermeneutical climate would now allow for a synthesized biblical theology once again, like the pre-modern ones of yore that did not realize they were organizing the content of the biblical texts on the basis of later Christian theology, but this time with intentionality.
So my next thought is predictable. Should I dedicate a few years to writing one? My answer thus far is no. First, there is no real demand for me to write anything, especially on this level. My own denominational publishers don't publish serious scholarship, and I don't know of any mainstream publishers that would be interested since I hardly have a following in mainstream circles.
But I also became stymied when I began to think of how I would organize the topic of God. Barth, for example, organized his Dogmatics around Christ. But God the Father remains the uncontested center of Scripture, with Christ firmly subordinated to him in the New Testament. Once more it reminded me that I am not trendy enough to write this work. The great biblical theology that would sell today would have to be co-written by someone with Richard Bauckham's Christological interpretations and Joel Green's hermeneutic.
Does that person exist? Michael Gorman? Maybe some of us in the Methodist tradition could get together. Just let me write some of the parts on hamartiology, justification, and sanctification. ;-)
Thursday, February 10, 2011
Hopes for my church... (W)
One thing Bud Bence is known for in new faculty interviews--especially when we are interviewing a Wesleyan candidate--is to ask them in the words of Robert Frost, if they have a "lover's quarrel" with our denomination. It is always an interesting question. Presumably it is of some value to be a Wesleyan when you are applying for a position at a Wesleyan university, especially in its School of Theology and Ministry or seminary.
But critical thinking is also an incredibly important skill in an educator. No one thinks the Wesleyan Church is inerrant Indeed, it is not known for its history of profound thinkers, no matter how godly our forebears might have been. It puts the candidate in an interesting position between having some critique but presumably not so deconstructive as to say you don't belong.
Of course one issue with the Wesleyan Church presently is that it's not entirely clear who we are. There are some very attractive features of our denomination that are resulting in some transplant growth among our ministers. This is an interesting phenomenon. We have some of the benefits of a denominational fellowship--a network of people who get along, a pension plan that has survived the economic crisis well, a network that makes it a lot easier to find a church than some independent church.
Yet a local church really has a good deal of the feel of a Baptist church in terms of its structure and independence, and a large church can pretty much do whatever it wants (within reason). We have district superintendents, but they don't "lord it over" local churches. It is easy for a Baptist or a charismatic minister to come to the Wesleyans thinking--they're basically like me except they believe you can keep from sinning. And some Wesleyans don't even think that.
The result is what I might call "transfer drift," ministers who join our denomination because we are a friendly denomination that looks a lot like wherever they've come from. While the "weird bits" are easy to overlook because Wesleyans themselves don't seem to take them very seriously. So ex-Baptists, ex-Pentecostals, conservative Methodists, find themselves in our pulpits and we welcome them, as long as they don't teach eternal security, don't promote tongues, and the Methodists can tell all the jokes they want about how liberal their former denomination was.
On the one hand, I like that we are such a welcoming and inviting denomination. I consider it a strength and defend it as part of John Wesley's DNA--"If your heart is as my heart, put your hand in mine." But here are some things I hope are not lost in our mindless melange of ministers:
1. We believe in a God disposed to have mercy on all, not a God who saves on the basis of what you know or as a slave to the rules of justice. He disciplines to redeem, not to destroy because his honor is insulted.
2. Sin--understood primarily as doing wrong intentionally--is not normal for a Christian. God does not have an absolute standard for sin. His standards are attainable through the power of the Holy Spirit. To do wrong intentionally is a rejection of him, and he will let a person reject him (even a Christian) to the point of eternal separation from his goodness.
3. Ministry to the poor and dis-empowered is a central element and charge of the gospel. When we have the opportunity, we should challenge the structures of society that disadvantage others simply because of their race or gender. We fully affirm the potential of women to take leadership in all positions of the church and the home.
4. We should not be a fundamentalist denomination, not only because fundamentalist approaches to Scripture cannot be defended on the merits but because fundamentalist approaches skew the prophetic voice. The "fundamentalists" of the nineteenth century took the wrong position on slavery and women, and fundamentalism in the twentieth was short-sighted on poverty and civil rights. Fundamentalism is strong on the letter but impoverished in Spirit.
There are voices in my church that currently pull in different directions from the above. There are murmurs against women in ministry. There is resistance to social justice here and there. Our default is a kind of fundamentalist use of the Bible without any real awareness of it. There is a silent acceptance of popular definitions of sin and God's justice.
The generosity of our tradition in its focus on "getting people saved" allows many of these issues to be idle disputes in the background. But these issues are the ones that distinguish us, the torch-bearing issues. They are the ones where we have a potential contribution to make. They should not constitute a "new kind of Wesleyan" or an "emergent Wesleyan" because they are the best of what we have been already. But I invite the like-minded to rally around these identity markers going forward, even if I don't have a catchy name to offer.
But critical thinking is also an incredibly important skill in an educator. No one thinks the Wesleyan Church is inerrant Indeed, it is not known for its history of profound thinkers, no matter how godly our forebears might have been. It puts the candidate in an interesting position between having some critique but presumably not so deconstructive as to say you don't belong.
Of course one issue with the Wesleyan Church presently is that it's not entirely clear who we are. There are some very attractive features of our denomination that are resulting in some transplant growth among our ministers. This is an interesting phenomenon. We have some of the benefits of a denominational fellowship--a network of people who get along, a pension plan that has survived the economic crisis well, a network that makes it a lot easier to find a church than some independent church.
Yet a local church really has a good deal of the feel of a Baptist church in terms of its structure and independence, and a large church can pretty much do whatever it wants (within reason). We have district superintendents, but they don't "lord it over" local churches. It is easy for a Baptist or a charismatic minister to come to the Wesleyans thinking--they're basically like me except they believe you can keep from sinning. And some Wesleyans don't even think that.
The result is what I might call "transfer drift," ministers who join our denomination because we are a friendly denomination that looks a lot like wherever they've come from. While the "weird bits" are easy to overlook because Wesleyans themselves don't seem to take them very seriously. So ex-Baptists, ex-Pentecostals, conservative Methodists, find themselves in our pulpits and we welcome them, as long as they don't teach eternal security, don't promote tongues, and the Methodists can tell all the jokes they want about how liberal their former denomination was.
On the one hand, I like that we are such a welcoming and inviting denomination. I consider it a strength and defend it as part of John Wesley's DNA--"If your heart is as my heart, put your hand in mine." But here are some things I hope are not lost in our mindless melange of ministers:
1. We believe in a God disposed to have mercy on all, not a God who saves on the basis of what you know or as a slave to the rules of justice. He disciplines to redeem, not to destroy because his honor is insulted.
2. Sin--understood primarily as doing wrong intentionally--is not normal for a Christian. God does not have an absolute standard for sin. His standards are attainable through the power of the Holy Spirit. To do wrong intentionally is a rejection of him, and he will let a person reject him (even a Christian) to the point of eternal separation from his goodness.
3. Ministry to the poor and dis-empowered is a central element and charge of the gospel. When we have the opportunity, we should challenge the structures of society that disadvantage others simply because of their race or gender. We fully affirm the potential of women to take leadership in all positions of the church and the home.
4. We should not be a fundamentalist denomination, not only because fundamentalist approaches to Scripture cannot be defended on the merits but because fundamentalist approaches skew the prophetic voice. The "fundamentalists" of the nineteenth century took the wrong position on slavery and women, and fundamentalism in the twentieth was short-sighted on poverty and civil rights. Fundamentalism is strong on the letter but impoverished in Spirit.
There are voices in my church that currently pull in different directions from the above. There are murmurs against women in ministry. There is resistance to social justice here and there. Our default is a kind of fundamentalist use of the Bible without any real awareness of it. There is a silent acceptance of popular definitions of sin and God's justice.
The generosity of our tradition in its focus on "getting people saved" allows many of these issues to be idle disputes in the background. But these issues are the ones that distinguish us, the torch-bearing issues. They are the ones where we have a potential contribution to make. They should not constitute a "new kind of Wesleyan" or an "emergent Wesleyan" because they are the best of what we have been already. But I invite the like-minded to rally around these identity markers going forward, even if I don't have a catchy name to offer.
Tuesday, February 08, 2011
Me to You
Steve Deneff and David Drury have written a book called Soul Shift. For some reason it does not seem to be available at Amazon but you can get it from the Wesleyan Publishing House site. This book and the sermon series of which it is a part, in my estimation, is aimed to help us as a congregation mature, as a tool of discipleship. I have deeply admired the way in which College Wesleyan Church has provided concrete ways to work out our convictions on things like service and small groups. My sense is that most churches know we should do these things but don't have a clue how to do it (I think of some of my past sermons).
The first "shift" chapter is about moving from "Me to You," and I had some reflections on it. We are so impenetrable as humans. Others can see the areas where we need to grow, but it is often very difficult for us to see them. So those of us who grew up in the church may think, "I already think about how to help others." And those of us who have had bad self-images in the past think, "It is important to have boundaries and a healthy sense of who you are."
Then I come back to one fundamental aspect of virtue, in my opinion. Virtue is not about the things that come easy to you, but the things that come hard for you. So growing in the area of "me to you" is not a measure of how much you think of others "by nature." Virtue in this area is giving to others in those areas where you don't want to give of yourself, when it is hard.
Maybe it is your personality to think of helping others. Maybe it is your personality to let others go first. But is there an area where you cling on to what is yours and could rightly think more of others? That is an area of potential growth in "me to you."
The first "shift" chapter is about moving from "Me to You," and I had some reflections on it. We are so impenetrable as humans. Others can see the areas where we need to grow, but it is often very difficult for us to see them. So those of us who grew up in the church may think, "I already think about how to help others." And those of us who have had bad self-images in the past think, "It is important to have boundaries and a healthy sense of who you are."
Then I come back to one fundamental aspect of virtue, in my opinion. Virtue is not about the things that come easy to you, but the things that come hard for you. So growing in the area of "me to you" is not a measure of how much you think of others "by nature." Virtue in this area is giving to others in those areas where you don't want to give of yourself, when it is hard.
Maybe it is your personality to think of helping others. Maybe it is your personality to let others go first. But is there an area where you cling on to what is yours and could rightly think more of others? That is an area of potential growth in "me to you."
Monday, February 07, 2011
Original Meaning Translation: Romans 1:16-17
More of my "original meaning" translation of Romans:
___________
Romans 1:16-17
16 For I am not ashamed of the gospel, for it is the power of God [leading] to salvation for everyone who has faith, both to the Jew first and to the Greek. 17 For in it the righteousness of God is revealed from faith [leading] to faith, as it stands written, "But the righteous by faith will live."
Saturday, February 05, 2011
Novel Excerpt
I couldn't think of anything to say today. I decided I needed to take some time off. But I did write a couple pages on one of some 25+ novels I've started. I'm actually 30 pages in, which puts this one in the top five already in terms of holding my interest ;-)
___________
“Do we need to turn our backpacks on?” I asked. “And will we survive a fall from such a great height?”
“My dear, what great height? You are smaller than the proton we were on, which itself is only something like one, ten trillionth of a centimeter.”
I could tell that was rather small, but I was too embarrassed to ask exactly how small that was. But I could not seem to stop myself. “And what is that in scientific frustration?”
“In scientific notation, the nucleus of an atom—itself usually made up of many protons and neutrons—is about 1 x 10-14 meters. If you took a meter and divided it into ten parts, then divided one of those parts into ten parts, and continued to divide one of the ten parts fourteen times, then you would have something about the size of the average nucleus of an atom.”
“That’s rather small,” I said.
"We may fall for hours and yet will never come close to the smallest fraction of a millimeter, hardly a big enough fall to get even a bruise”
Again, I knew that was rather small, but I was much more comfortable talking in inches and feet than in meters, centimeters, and millimeters. But I still could not stop myself. “And exactly what is a millimeter?”
“Oh dear,” Feynman said as we continued to fall. “I had hoped by this time that America would do a better job of moving its people into the scientific age. We tried, you know, to get kilometers on highway signs in the 1970s, like the rest of the world, but people just don’t like to learn new things. I can only imagine that by now that there are other countries about to surpass America scientifically.
“In any case, an inch is about 2.54 centimeters, and a millimeter is one tenth of a centimeter.”
___________
“Do we need to turn our backpacks on?” I asked. “And will we survive a fall from such a great height?”
“My dear, what great height? You are smaller than the proton we were on, which itself is only something like one, ten trillionth of a centimeter.”
I could tell that was rather small, but I was too embarrassed to ask exactly how small that was. But I could not seem to stop myself. “And what is that in scientific frustration?”
“In scientific notation, the nucleus of an atom—itself usually made up of many protons and neutrons—is about 1 x 10-14 meters. If you took a meter and divided it into ten parts, then divided one of those parts into ten parts, and continued to divide one of the ten parts fourteen times, then you would have something about the size of the average nucleus of an atom.”
“That’s rather small,” I said.
"We may fall for hours and yet will never come close to the smallest fraction of a millimeter, hardly a big enough fall to get even a bruise”
Again, I knew that was rather small, but I was much more comfortable talking in inches and feet than in meters, centimeters, and millimeters. But I still could not stop myself. “And exactly what is a millimeter?”
“Oh dear,” Feynman said as we continued to fall. “I had hoped by this time that America would do a better job of moving its people into the scientific age. We tried, you know, to get kilometers on highway signs in the 1970s, like the rest of the world, but people just don’t like to learn new things. I can only imagine that by now that there are other countries about to surpass America scientifically.
“In any case, an inch is about 2.54 centimeters, and a millimeter is one tenth of a centimeter.”
Friday, February 04, 2011
Passage for the Day
I went to a certain news website this morning and immediately went from relatively happy to a sense of crisis, fear, and alarm. One article captured the site well, a piece criticizing Obama for leaving the phrase "they shall renew their strength" out of his quotation of Isaiah 40. It's no wonder so much of America is angry, I thought. How can anyone with the Spirit of Christ take much of this, I thought. I was tempted to respond in kind.
To purify myself, I give you this passage from someone this website would attack if he had a different name and was saying this today:
“You have heard that it was said, ‘You will love your neighbor and hate your enemy.’ But I say to you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, so that you may be children of your Father in heaven; for he makes his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sends rain on the righteous and on the unrighteous. For if you love those who love you, what reward do you have? Do not even the tax collectors do the same? And if you greet only your brothers and sisters, what more are you doing than others? Do not even the Gentiles do the same? Therefore, love the whole way, as your heavenly Father loves the whole way."
To purify myself, I give you this passage from someone this website would attack if he had a different name and was saying this today:
“You have heard that it was said, ‘You will love your neighbor and hate your enemy.’ But I say to you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, so that you may be children of your Father in heaven; for he makes his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sends rain on the righteous and on the unrighteous. For if you love those who love you, what reward do you have? Do not even the tax collectors do the same? And if you greet only your brothers and sisters, what more are you doing than others? Do not even the Gentiles do the same? Therefore, love the whole way, as your heavenly Father loves the whole way."
Thursday, February 03, 2011
The Kingdom: Commenced and Coming
Bob Whitesel was telling me at lunch how revolutionary George Ladd's theology of the kingdom was at Fuller when he was there in seminary. It's an odd story to me, because to me I have always found both Albert Schweitzer's rendition of Jesus (the kingdom is entirely yet to come) and C. H. Dodd's rendition (the kingdom is entirely here already) as so strangely extreme in the light of the gospels. Ladd's idea of "inaugurated eschatology"--the kingdom has begun in the person of Jesus but is not fully here and will not be fully here until Christ's return--has always seemed commonsensically the best description both of the gospels and of Christian theology.
But Bob has helped me see that these ideas, which for me in seminary were simply different ideological positions, were originally ensconced in what was going on at the time of these scholars. Ladd, for example, gave theological justification to a burgeoning charismatic movement for whom it was important to see the spiritual gifts of the kingdom as present reality. John Wimber, for example, was about to start the Vineyard movement at the time.
No doubt the same could be said for Schweitzer and Dodd, especially Dodd. It's a reminder that historical Jesus research often has as much or more to do with those doing it as with the historical Jesus. I'm not at all saying such investigations are illegitimate. I'm just confirming what so many have said before: when we see Jesus as our model for today, we often see Jesus as a mirror of ourselves.
But Bob has helped me see that these ideas, which for me in seminary were simply different ideological positions, were originally ensconced in what was going on at the time of these scholars. Ladd, for example, gave theological justification to a burgeoning charismatic movement for whom it was important to see the spiritual gifts of the kingdom as present reality. John Wimber, for example, was about to start the Vineyard movement at the time.
No doubt the same could be said for Schweitzer and Dodd, especially Dodd. It's a reminder that historical Jesus research often has as much or more to do with those doing it as with the historical Jesus. I'm not at all saying such investigations are illegitimate. I'm just confirming what so many have said before: when we see Jesus as our model for today, we often see Jesus as a mirror of ourselves.
Wednesday, February 02, 2011
David versus Josiah
I am always trying to point out the difference between reading the Bible inductively and reading it as Christian Scripture, both of which I consider important for Christians. We naturally read the Bible as Scripture and this way of reading is completely appropriate, but it is a form of "reader-response," an "ideological" reading from a Christian point of view. Inductive reading, reading the biblical texts for what they actually say and what they likely meant originally in context, is very difficult for us to do. It takes massive paradigm shifts for most of us even to know what I'm talking about.
Another example occurred to me this morning. From an inductive standpoint, it seems to me that Josiah is more important for the deuteronomistic history (Joshua-Kings, with Deuteronomy as lead off) than even David is. Does not the lead off in 1 Kings 13:2 point to Josiah at least as the climax of 1 and 2 Kings? 2 Kings 23:25 point to him as the greatest king of all Israel's history. In fact, from an inductive standpoint, an argument can at least be made that a Jewish reader of, say, 500BC, would see Josiah as the most likely candidate for who Deuteronomy 18:15-19 pointed toward.
Yet when we read the Bible as Scripture, David clearly outshines Josiah in the story. Josiah plays no role in the New Testament, but David is a type of Christ, a key feature in Jesus' identity as king. Acts 7:37 and other passages clearly read Deuteronomy 18 in relation to Christ. So when we read the Historical Books as Christian Scripture, David is by far the most important person in the story. Inductively, David is important--after all, he dominates the space of the narrative. You just might argue that he is not as important as Josiah in terms of the original meaning of Samuel-Kings.
Another example occurred to me this morning. From an inductive standpoint, it seems to me that Josiah is more important for the deuteronomistic history (Joshua-Kings, with Deuteronomy as lead off) than even David is. Does not the lead off in 1 Kings 13:2 point to Josiah at least as the climax of 1 and 2 Kings? 2 Kings 23:25 point to him as the greatest king of all Israel's history. In fact, from an inductive standpoint, an argument can at least be made that a Jewish reader of, say, 500BC, would see Josiah as the most likely candidate for who Deuteronomy 18:15-19 pointed toward.
Yet when we read the Bible as Scripture, David clearly outshines Josiah in the story. Josiah plays no role in the New Testament, but David is a type of Christ, a key feature in Jesus' identity as king. Acts 7:37 and other passages clearly read Deuteronomy 18 in relation to Christ. So when we read the Historical Books as Christian Scripture, David is by far the most important person in the story. Inductively, David is important--after all, he dominates the space of the narrative. You just might argue that he is not as important as Josiah in terms of the original meaning of Samuel-Kings.
Tuesday, February 01, 2011
Heaping Coals of Fire (Rom. 12:20)
Keith Blackburn did a paper last semester on Romans 12:20 on that well known expression about "heaping coals of fire" on the head of your enemy. He had heard a nice "this is what this really meant" story and wanted to verify or discount it.
So I dug out Robert Jewett's relatively recent Romans commentary, quickly on its way to become the commentary on my list of Ken's Picks, although I want to use it a little more before committing. (By the way, I wrote too much on my second Paul book so Wesleyan Publishing House is probably going to split it in two, making the next volume, Paul: Soldier of Peace, entirely on Romans.)
So here's the situation as best I can figure it out. First, Paul is quoting Proverbs 25:22. Since Proverbs draws on some Egyptian literature, it is likely that it alludes to an Egyptian practice of a repentant person carrying a thing with hot coals in it on their heads to symbolize their repentance. The idea of the Proverb would thus be to feed and give drink to your enemy so that he or she will repent of their animosity toward you.
Of course Paul is unlikely to know the Egyptian background of the Proverb, which makes that information irrelevant for interpreting Romans (this is a key point of learning that many "scholars" do not even get. Doing a Hebrew word study or contextual exegesis of an OT passage is irrelevant to the interpretation of a NT passage that engages the OT if the NT author isn't likely to have known such things. By and large, the NT authors used the Greek OT and didn't read the OT using historical methods).
So there may have been interpretive traditions around that Paul had in mind, ones that we apparently have no information about. On the other hand, Paul may have been in the same boat we are as far as reading the verse in context. We can tell the context is about something positive, not negative. We can tell you are doing something good for your enemy, and it is moving them toward reconciliation with you.
And this is exactly the meaning Paul sees in Romans 12:20 as the Spirit leads him to write to the Romans. It is possible, although we cannot really say, that the expression was just as much a dead metaphor for Paul at the time as it is for us. We pretty much get what it is saying without really knowing where it came from.
So I dug out Robert Jewett's relatively recent Romans commentary, quickly on its way to become the commentary on my list of Ken's Picks, although I want to use it a little more before committing. (By the way, I wrote too much on my second Paul book so Wesleyan Publishing House is probably going to split it in two, making the next volume, Paul: Soldier of Peace, entirely on Romans.)
So here's the situation as best I can figure it out. First, Paul is quoting Proverbs 25:22. Since Proverbs draws on some Egyptian literature, it is likely that it alludes to an Egyptian practice of a repentant person carrying a thing with hot coals in it on their heads to symbolize their repentance. The idea of the Proverb would thus be to feed and give drink to your enemy so that he or she will repent of their animosity toward you.
Of course Paul is unlikely to know the Egyptian background of the Proverb, which makes that information irrelevant for interpreting Romans (this is a key point of learning that many "scholars" do not even get. Doing a Hebrew word study or contextual exegesis of an OT passage is irrelevant to the interpretation of a NT passage that engages the OT if the NT author isn't likely to have known such things. By and large, the NT authors used the Greek OT and didn't read the OT using historical methods).
So there may have been interpretive traditions around that Paul had in mind, ones that we apparently have no information about. On the other hand, Paul may have been in the same boat we are as far as reading the verse in context. We can tell the context is about something positive, not negative. We can tell you are doing something good for your enemy, and it is moving them toward reconciliation with you.
And this is exactly the meaning Paul sees in Romans 12:20 as the Spirit leads him to write to the Romans. It is possible, although we cannot really say, that the expression was just as much a dead metaphor for Paul at the time as it is for us. We pretty much get what it is saying without really knowing where it came from.
Monday, January 31, 2011
Original Meaning Translation: Romans 1:11-15
More of my "original meaning" translation of Romans:
Romans 1:1-7
Romans 1:8-10
___________
Romans 1:11-15
11 For I desire to see you in order that I might share some spiritual gift with you so that you might be strengthened, 12 and this is to be mutually encouraged with you through the faith in one another, both yours and mine. 13 And I do not want you not to know, brothers, that I have often intended to come to you and I was hindered until now, in order that I might have some fruit even among you as also among the other Gentiles. 14 Both to Greeks and barbarians, both to wise and to foolish I am a debtor. 15 So the purpose for me [is] to proclaim the good news also to you who are in Rome.
Romans 1:1-7
Romans 1:8-10
___________
Romans 1:11-15
11 For I desire to see you in order that I might share some spiritual gift with you so that you might be strengthened, 12 and this is to be mutually encouraged with you through the faith in one another, both yours and mine. 13 And I do not want you not to know, brothers, that I have often intended to come to you and I was hindered until now, in order that I might have some fruit even among you as also among the other Gentiles. 14 Both to Greeks and barbarians, both to wise and to foolish I am a debtor. 15 So the purpose for me [is] to proclaim the good news also to you who are in Rome.
Saturday, January 29, 2011
Pacifism and Prioritizing Values
How's this for a text box on pacifism in a philosophy textbook?
__________
A pacifist is someone who believes violence is wrong in every situation, that non-violence is an absolute. However, even in this instance, the pacifist has chosen one value over another. In certain circumstances, he or she considers non-violence a higher ethical priority than helping or saving the lives of others.
__________
A pacifist is someone who believes violence is wrong in every situation, that non-violence is an absolute. However, even in this instance, the pacifist has chosen one value over another. In certain circumstances, he or she considers non-violence a higher ethical priority than helping or saving the lives of others.
Friday, January 28, 2011
Procedure is not Truth
After one too many episodes of Law and Order, I continue to be frustrated with the way our system enables those who are found not guilty because of procedural issues, with the consequence that those with enough money to hire clever enough lawyers have a much better chance of getting off than someone without resources.
Of course this does not mean that those without resources who are found guilty are not guilty. It just means many who should be found guilty are not.
The logical fallacy of letting someone off because their Miranda rights weren't read to them or because evidence was found without a search warrant is heinous. The question of justice is a question of truth and guilt, not one of procedure. I understand that these "rights" were instituted to protect the innocent and to prevent corruption (I personally reject the notion of intrinsic rights on any subject, only common responsibilities toward others). But if it were at all possible these two issues should be separated. The police should get in trouble for not following proper procedure and the guilty should be found guilty, regardless of the procedure by which their guilt was discover.
Sure, make the stakes high for a police person who does not follow the proper procedure, especially if the person is found not guilty. Maybe even kick them off the force or suspend them without pay for six months. Make the stakes high for not following procedure. But, somehow, it ultimately has to be about guilt or innocence, not a ridiculous game that makes us a laughing-stock and that favors not the innocent, but the guilty.
Of course this does not mean that those without resources who are found guilty are not guilty. It just means many who should be found guilty are not.
The logical fallacy of letting someone off because their Miranda rights weren't read to them or because evidence was found without a search warrant is heinous. The question of justice is a question of truth and guilt, not one of procedure. I understand that these "rights" were instituted to protect the innocent and to prevent corruption (I personally reject the notion of intrinsic rights on any subject, only common responsibilities toward others). But if it were at all possible these two issues should be separated. The police should get in trouble for not following proper procedure and the guilty should be found guilty, regardless of the procedure by which their guilt was discover.
Sure, make the stakes high for a police person who does not follow the proper procedure, especially if the person is found not guilty. Maybe even kick them off the force or suspend them without pay for six months. Make the stakes high for not following procedure. But, somehow, it ultimately has to be about guilt or innocence, not a ridiculous game that makes us a laughing-stock and that favors not the innocent, but the guilty.
Thursday, January 27, 2011
Romans 1:8-10
An "original meaning" translation I'm doing as I write a Bible study on Romans 1-8.
Romans 1:1-7
Romans 1:8-10
8 First, on the one hand, I am giving thanks to God through Jesus Messiah concerning you all because your faith is being announced in the whole world, 9 for God is my witness--whom I serve in my spirit in the gospel of his Son as I am constantly making mention of you-- 10 always asking in my prayers if somehow at last at some time it might work out for me in the will of God to come to you.
Romans 1:1-7
Romans 1:8-10
8 First, on the one hand, I am giving thanks to God through Jesus Messiah concerning you all because your faith is being announced in the whole world, 9 for God is my witness--whom I serve in my spirit in the gospel of his Son as I am constantly making mention of you-- 10 always asking in my prayers if somehow at last at some time it might work out for me in the will of God to come to you.
Wednesday, January 26, 2011
Women Church Planters
Rev. Joanne Lyon, current head of the Wesleyan Church, met a couple weeks ago with the faculty and administration of our seminary and we discussed our mutual visions for the church. I think everyone would agree (see Wayne Schmidt's coming post Monday on the seminary blog) that our values and sense of direction are very much the same.
One interesting idea that popped out of the synergy of that discussion was the idea that some of our women who feel called to ministry might lead church plants. While the Wesleyan Church remains firmly in support of women in ministry from a theoretical perspective, many Wesleyan churches in practice would resist a woman pastor. The result is, as Keith Drury once wrote, that we can end up sending our best women off to other churches like the United Methodists.
So what do you do when you're the pastor of a small group of twenty dead folk with frowns on their faces, sometimes darkness in their hearts, and a death grip on the non-direction of the church? You either close the church or you ask God to empower you to build a living congregation around the dead flesh... until they can outvote the dead wood.
In the same way, the spark of an idea was to take some of our most talented women who are called but stalled in the church and start some new, living church plants. Work around the dead flesh.
One interesting idea that popped out of the synergy of that discussion was the idea that some of our women who feel called to ministry might lead church plants. While the Wesleyan Church remains firmly in support of women in ministry from a theoretical perspective, many Wesleyan churches in practice would resist a woman pastor. The result is, as Keith Drury once wrote, that we can end up sending our best women off to other churches like the United Methodists.
So what do you do when you're the pastor of a small group of twenty dead folk with frowns on their faces, sometimes darkness in their hearts, and a death grip on the non-direction of the church? You either close the church or you ask God to empower you to build a living congregation around the dead flesh... until they can outvote the dead wood.
In the same way, the spark of an idea was to take some of our most talented women who are called but stalled in the church and start some new, living church plants. Work around the dead flesh.
Tuesday, January 25, 2011
Seminary Update
We are now a year and a half into Wesley Seminary at Indiana Wesleyan University and I thought I would give an update since I haven't really said much since we ramped up what seems like so long ago. Here are some highlights:
1. Our first MDIV cohorts are now half way through their degree program. They've taken a 6 hour course on the Missional Church, a course on Leadership, a course on Worship, and now they are in a course on Proclamation. They've taken spiritual formation courses in which they've looked at change, at themselves, at goals, and now they're beginning a course on being mentored. Many of them came to campus to take courses on cultural contexts, on tools and aspects of Scripture in ministry, on Christian theology.
2. We have about 9 cohorts of MDIV students (over 100 students), adding to about 100 MA students. The leading groups feel a little like guinea pigs, but hopefully they're not too scarred. We've had a quick revision loop to try to improve things, which means they've seen some changes every semester as we have tried to get things right.
3. We have 4 full time faculty now and hope to add 2 or 3 more this Spring. We started with Bob Whitesel, consultant extraordinaire, added Charles Arn, omnipresent online professor. Then the second year we added John Drury the theologian and Lenny Luchetti the proclaimer.
Since every practice course is team taught with independent Bible, theology, church history, and integration professors dropped into the mix with the practice professor, we have this semester 3 additional individuals adjuncting Bible assignments (including Steve Lennox onsite), 3 additional individuals adjuncting theology assignments (including Chris Bounds), 3 additional individuals adjuncting church history assignments (including Bud Bence), and 4 additional individuals adjuncting our purgatorial Integration Paper assignments. Thanks to all those who have been willing to enrich our students for some extra change!
4. Wayne Schmidt continues to do a masterful job leading the seminary. His vision is for a seminary that looks like Revelation 7:9. He and Joanne Solis-Walker have created a Hispanic version of our MDIV, whose first all Spanish cohort will begin in March. He has continued good relations with the AME church in Indiana that Russ Gunsalus forged at the beginning. He is the right person in the right place doing the right thing, full of wisdom and stature and favor with God and all the people.
5. Our infrastructure continues to grow. Karen Clark and Nate Smith in the office are a machine beyond belief. Nate Lamb and Dianne Clark are an incredibly efficient and welcoming gateway to the seminary. We are in the process of hiring Spanish speaking admissions and enrollment specialists. And of course we have great office help like the ever efficient Joel Leichty.
6. We are in dialog with many possible venues for cohorts ranging from having them at Bethany in Canada to New Zealand to South Carolina. What I usually say is that if someone in our network can find 15 students for a cohort, we can start a cohort. Certainly such groups can do their intensives in Marion. But we can explore other locations too. For example, anyone is welcome to sign up for a one week intensive elective at 12Stone church in Atlanta this summer, June 1-7, called "Church Laboratory."
Even if you do not want to join an MA or MDIV, you can sign up for a one time course. Are you looking to be ordained in the Wesleyan Church and already have a bachelor's degree? Why do FLAME for no credit? You can take Wesleyan Church History and Polity online for 8 weeks starting in March. We regularly offer Theology of Holiness in the same format and will be offering it going forward online as an elective each Fall. Charles Arn is doing an 8 week online course in Welcoming Newcomers in March as well. Lenny Luchetti is teaching Narrative Preaching onsite for a week in May. I'm teaching Hebrew for Ministry for 8 weeks online or onsite in Indy starting May 31.
You don't have to join a degree to take courses in the seminary. Just find something you like and take the class.
7. I have never been busier. The last two practice courses--Congregational Formation and Congregational Relationships--are in the writing. After that, I will feel like I have played the role God especially called me to do. We will apply for ATS accreditation this October on schedule. We are setting up an amazing assessment system with the wonderful Chalk and Wire people. We continue to eat together, pray together, and very dear to my heart, drink coffee together.
Thanks to God for letting me be a part of this amazing work!
1. Our first MDIV cohorts are now half way through their degree program. They've taken a 6 hour course on the Missional Church, a course on Leadership, a course on Worship, and now they are in a course on Proclamation. They've taken spiritual formation courses in which they've looked at change, at themselves, at goals, and now they're beginning a course on being mentored. Many of them came to campus to take courses on cultural contexts, on tools and aspects of Scripture in ministry, on Christian theology.
2. We have about 9 cohorts of MDIV students (over 100 students), adding to about 100 MA students. The leading groups feel a little like guinea pigs, but hopefully they're not too scarred. We've had a quick revision loop to try to improve things, which means they've seen some changes every semester as we have tried to get things right.
3. We have 4 full time faculty now and hope to add 2 or 3 more this Spring. We started with Bob Whitesel, consultant extraordinaire, added Charles Arn, omnipresent online professor. Then the second year we added John Drury the theologian and Lenny Luchetti the proclaimer.
Since every practice course is team taught with independent Bible, theology, church history, and integration professors dropped into the mix with the practice professor, we have this semester 3 additional individuals adjuncting Bible assignments (including Steve Lennox onsite), 3 additional individuals adjuncting theology assignments (including Chris Bounds), 3 additional individuals adjuncting church history assignments (including Bud Bence), and 4 additional individuals adjuncting our purgatorial Integration Paper assignments. Thanks to all those who have been willing to enrich our students for some extra change!
4. Wayne Schmidt continues to do a masterful job leading the seminary. His vision is for a seminary that looks like Revelation 7:9. He and Joanne Solis-Walker have created a Hispanic version of our MDIV, whose first all Spanish cohort will begin in March. He has continued good relations with the AME church in Indiana that Russ Gunsalus forged at the beginning. He is the right person in the right place doing the right thing, full of wisdom and stature and favor with God and all the people.
5. Our infrastructure continues to grow. Karen Clark and Nate Smith in the office are a machine beyond belief. Nate Lamb and Dianne Clark are an incredibly efficient and welcoming gateway to the seminary. We are in the process of hiring Spanish speaking admissions and enrollment specialists. And of course we have great office help like the ever efficient Joel Leichty.
6. We are in dialog with many possible venues for cohorts ranging from having them at Bethany in Canada to New Zealand to South Carolina. What I usually say is that if someone in our network can find 15 students for a cohort, we can start a cohort. Certainly such groups can do their intensives in Marion. But we can explore other locations too. For example, anyone is welcome to sign up for a one week intensive elective at 12Stone church in Atlanta this summer, June 1-7, called "Church Laboratory."
Even if you do not want to join an MA or MDIV, you can sign up for a one time course. Are you looking to be ordained in the Wesleyan Church and already have a bachelor's degree? Why do FLAME for no credit? You can take Wesleyan Church History and Polity online for 8 weeks starting in March. We regularly offer Theology of Holiness in the same format and will be offering it going forward online as an elective each Fall. Charles Arn is doing an 8 week online course in Welcoming Newcomers in March as well. Lenny Luchetti is teaching Narrative Preaching onsite for a week in May. I'm teaching Hebrew for Ministry for 8 weeks online or onsite in Indy starting May 31.
You don't have to join a degree to take courses in the seminary. Just find something you like and take the class.
7. I have never been busier. The last two practice courses--Congregational Formation and Congregational Relationships--are in the writing. After that, I will feel like I have played the role God especially called me to do. We will apply for ATS accreditation this October on schedule. We are setting up an amazing assessment system with the wonderful Chalk and Wire people. We continue to eat together, pray together, and very dear to my heart, drink coffee together.
Thanks to God for letting me be a part of this amazing work!
Monday, January 24, 2011
The Gospels as Scripture
More material for a class. Feedback welcome.
____________
The central part of the Scriptural story, the central part of the Christian story, is when the problem of the story is overcome. The problem of our story is the alienation of the creation from God, including humanity. The goal of the story is the reconciliation of humanity and the creation to God. The incarnation, death, and resurrection of Jesus are the means by which God brings this reconciliation about.
The Gospels thus stand as the heart of the Bible read as Scripture. Think of the central part of the Apostle’s Creed: “I believe in Jesus Christ, his only Son, our Lord, who was conceived of the Holy Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary, suffered, dead, and buried. The third day he arose from the dead. He ascended into heaven and is seated at the right hand of God, the Father, Almighty. From there he will come to judge the living and the dead.” When we read the Gospels as Scripture, we read them with all these things in mind. The New Testament letters and Acts may unpack them in terms of doctrine, but the story of the Gospels is the starting point.
It is right for us to read them in this way as Christian Scripture, even though we may also know how to read the Gospels in terms of their original historical-cultural context. For example, the incarnation—Jesus as God becoming flesh—is only a feature of John’s Gospel. Only Matthew and Luke tell of Jesus’ virginal conception. Mark and John do not mention the virgin birth. From a historical/contextual perspective, we lack sufficient evidence to say whether they knew about it or believed it.
Matthew, Mark, and Luke do not speak of Jesus as God becoming flesh, as John does. From a historical/contextual perspective, we lack sufficient evidence to say whether they knew about it or believed it. Indeed, many Christians prior to the 300s did not read John to say that Jesus was fully God in the same way that God the Father was God. We find contemporary Jews who used language similar to that of John 1 in relation to the “word” of God (logos), which was above all the rest of the creation as the “firstborn” of all creation, but was still created. Further, the word for worship in Matthew could be used of human kings (proskyneō).
What the last two paragraphs say is that to read the Gospels as Christian Scripture is to see more in them than they may have originally meant or than we can prove that they meant. The tools of inductive Bible study require us to read an individual book in its own right, not to see more meaning in the text than is required or justified by what that text actually says, following its own clues. Inductive Bible study thus can never conclude that Mark or John believed in the virgin birth, for they do not mention it, and we lack sufficient historical evidence to say that Christians at the time commonly did. But when we read Mark and John as Scripture, we are free to read them with the assumption of the virgin birth.
As Christians, we read the Gospels also with the assumption that Jesus is the second person of the Trinity. The Nicene Creed (AD381) says that Jesus was “the only-begotten Son of God, begotten of the Father before all worlds; Light from Light; true God from true God; begotten, not made; of one substance with the Father; by whom all things were made.” These distinctions all reflect debates that took place in the centuries after the New Testament, but Christians ever since have believed them. For example, at the Council of Nicaea (AD325), they debated whether Christ was of similar substance to God the Father or of the same substance, one substance with the Father. We have believed as Christians that Christ was fully God like God the Father ever since.
It would be anachronistic to read these positions into the original meaning of John or any other New Testament text. Christians carried out these debates on the playing field of Scripture, but they were discussing issues that went well beyond anything the historical context of the New Testament books addressed. No inductive reading of the New Testament books in context will surrender clear answers on these issues. Indeed, it is possible to argue that we must believe in a Spirit-inspired, unfolding development and progress of understanding in the church in order to arrive at the Nicene Creed.
But it is perfectly legitimate for us to read the Gospels in the light of these later Christian beliefs. After all, this is the way that we understand the Christian story. So this is the way we bring the stories of the gospels into our Christian story. We incorporate the stories of the gospels into the overarching story of Scripture, a unified story we believe the Spirit has inspired the church to see in the words of Scripture. The Spirit working through the church has provided the glue of a story we experience as seamless and unified.
However, we can also see the historical writing of each Gospel as a moment in salvation history. Most experts would say that Mark was the first gospel, written perhaps in the late 60s or early 70s. Historical scholars have hypothesized any number of possibilities—many impossible either to prove or disprove—about how Mark’s material came together. It currently seems beyond question that we find in Mark what were originally oral traditions, many of which must have circulated widely.
Most experts believe that Matthew and Luke, perhaps in the 70s or 80s, then used Mark as the starting point for their Gospels, both incorporating almost all of Mark into their presentation.[1] A majority—although this issue is more subject to debate—continue to believe that Matthew and Luke also had another common source, mostly a collection of Jesus’ sayings. It is then thought that the Gospel of John reached its current form last, perhaps some time in the 90s. Even here, though, some argue that John may have been written in stages.
Many scholarly theories, such as those presumed in the last two paragraphs, can neither be definitely proved or disproved. There is a sociology to such theories. Experts “get used to” certain ideas, ideas they may never have fully explored on their own. They will know the basic case, evidence most people will not know, but they may never have struggled with other possibilities to the level of those who first came up with an idea. New evidence can also arise. The point is that scholarly agreements can change, just as scientific theories or historical reconstructions can.
The reading of the Gospels as Scripture is not contingent either on historical reconstruction, nor is it dependent on historical accuracy. Both the modernist drive to get back to the historical Jesus and the fundamentalist drive to harmonize the content of the Gospels are both equally out of focus. Certainly there are features of the story that must be historical for the Christian story to be true in its normal, orthodox, historical sense. Jesus must really have existed. He must have truly risen from the dead in history. But even such minimal historicity is enough to support faith in the incarnation. [2] Our point is not to dispute the historicity of the Gospels, only to point out that Christian faith does not clearly stand or fall on the historicity of the bulk of the Gospels.
The fundamentalist reading of the Gospels is also not necessarily the same as a Christian reading of the Gospels as Scripture. The fundamentalist reading insists that we be able to fit all the details of the Gospels together as history, while reading the Gospels as Scripture only requires that we read the Gospels in relation to the one story. It is not that we have any interest in saying that Jesus did not do something in the Gospels or did not say something. It is only to say that we can read the Gospels as Christian Scripture regardless of these decisions—many of which can neither be proved or disproved from a historical standpoint.
We derive immense truth from the parables without even considering their historicity. In the same way, reading the Gospels as Scripture is not dependent on historicity. The problem with the fundamentalist drive to harmonize is that it often requires us to disregard what the Gospels actually say. We create a “fifth gospel” that differs more from any of the four gospels than any of them actually differ from each other, and all this effort in the name of an idea we have, rather than in the interest of listening to what each individual gospel itself has to say.
Reading the Gospels as Scripture is not dependent on such things. It need not ignore the kinds of things those who truly are experts have hypothesized or discovered. But it also must not think that a unified reading of the four Gospels is bound by an inductive reading of each individual text. We are free to see more in the Gospel texts than they themselves say, while recognizing the writing of each individual Gospel as a moment in God’s never-ending walk with his people, a moment in salvation history.
We believe that the second person of the Trinity came to earth and was conceived by the Holy Spirit in the Virgin Mary. He walked the earth as one of us. He experienced what we experience. He was tempted in every way as we are but did not sin. He did miracles through the power of the Holy Spirit, just as we can. He healed; he cast out demons. He went to Jerusalem and died to reconcile humanity and the creation to God. He rose from the dead, and God enthroned him as king of the universe. He will come again to reconcile all things to God. When we read the Gospels as Christian Scripture, we read them with this faith in mind.
[1] A minority argues that Matthew was first, with Mark then abridging it and Luke reordering it.
[2] For example, even the virginal conception does not seem essential to Jesus' divinity. No one miracle, no one healing or exorcism, no one event or saying of Jesus seems essential for Jesus to be divine. Certainly the Christian story would be anemic without these elements, but we could still believe the Apostle’s or Nicene Creed even if most of the stories of the Gospels were not historical.
____________
The central part of the Scriptural story, the central part of the Christian story, is when the problem of the story is overcome. The problem of our story is the alienation of the creation from God, including humanity. The goal of the story is the reconciliation of humanity and the creation to God. The incarnation, death, and resurrection of Jesus are the means by which God brings this reconciliation about.
The Gospels thus stand as the heart of the Bible read as Scripture. Think of the central part of the Apostle’s Creed: “I believe in Jesus Christ, his only Son, our Lord, who was conceived of the Holy Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary, suffered, dead, and buried. The third day he arose from the dead. He ascended into heaven and is seated at the right hand of God, the Father, Almighty. From there he will come to judge the living and the dead.” When we read the Gospels as Scripture, we read them with all these things in mind. The New Testament letters and Acts may unpack them in terms of doctrine, but the story of the Gospels is the starting point.
It is right for us to read them in this way as Christian Scripture, even though we may also know how to read the Gospels in terms of their original historical-cultural context. For example, the incarnation—Jesus as God becoming flesh—is only a feature of John’s Gospel. Only Matthew and Luke tell of Jesus’ virginal conception. Mark and John do not mention the virgin birth. From a historical/contextual perspective, we lack sufficient evidence to say whether they knew about it or believed it.
Matthew, Mark, and Luke do not speak of Jesus as God becoming flesh, as John does. From a historical/contextual perspective, we lack sufficient evidence to say whether they knew about it or believed it. Indeed, many Christians prior to the 300s did not read John to say that Jesus was fully God in the same way that God the Father was God. We find contemporary Jews who used language similar to that of John 1 in relation to the “word” of God (logos), which was above all the rest of the creation as the “firstborn” of all creation, but was still created. Further, the word for worship in Matthew could be used of human kings (proskyneō).
What the last two paragraphs say is that to read the Gospels as Christian Scripture is to see more in them than they may have originally meant or than we can prove that they meant. The tools of inductive Bible study require us to read an individual book in its own right, not to see more meaning in the text than is required or justified by what that text actually says, following its own clues. Inductive Bible study thus can never conclude that Mark or John believed in the virgin birth, for they do not mention it, and we lack sufficient historical evidence to say that Christians at the time commonly did. But when we read Mark and John as Scripture, we are free to read them with the assumption of the virgin birth.
As Christians, we read the Gospels also with the assumption that Jesus is the second person of the Trinity. The Nicene Creed (AD381) says that Jesus was “the only-begotten Son of God, begotten of the Father before all worlds; Light from Light; true God from true God; begotten, not made; of one substance with the Father; by whom all things were made.” These distinctions all reflect debates that took place in the centuries after the New Testament, but Christians ever since have believed them. For example, at the Council of Nicaea (AD325), they debated whether Christ was of similar substance to God the Father or of the same substance, one substance with the Father. We have believed as Christians that Christ was fully God like God the Father ever since.
It would be anachronistic to read these positions into the original meaning of John or any other New Testament text. Christians carried out these debates on the playing field of Scripture, but they were discussing issues that went well beyond anything the historical context of the New Testament books addressed. No inductive reading of the New Testament books in context will surrender clear answers on these issues. Indeed, it is possible to argue that we must believe in a Spirit-inspired, unfolding development and progress of understanding in the church in order to arrive at the Nicene Creed.
But it is perfectly legitimate for us to read the Gospels in the light of these later Christian beliefs. After all, this is the way that we understand the Christian story. So this is the way we bring the stories of the gospels into our Christian story. We incorporate the stories of the gospels into the overarching story of Scripture, a unified story we believe the Spirit has inspired the church to see in the words of Scripture. The Spirit working through the church has provided the glue of a story we experience as seamless and unified.
However, we can also see the historical writing of each Gospel as a moment in salvation history. Most experts would say that Mark was the first gospel, written perhaps in the late 60s or early 70s. Historical scholars have hypothesized any number of possibilities—many impossible either to prove or disprove—about how Mark’s material came together. It currently seems beyond question that we find in Mark what were originally oral traditions, many of which must have circulated widely.
Most experts believe that Matthew and Luke, perhaps in the 70s or 80s, then used Mark as the starting point for their Gospels, both incorporating almost all of Mark into their presentation.[1] A majority—although this issue is more subject to debate—continue to believe that Matthew and Luke also had another common source, mostly a collection of Jesus’ sayings. It is then thought that the Gospel of John reached its current form last, perhaps some time in the 90s. Even here, though, some argue that John may have been written in stages.
Many scholarly theories, such as those presumed in the last two paragraphs, can neither be definitely proved or disproved. There is a sociology to such theories. Experts “get used to” certain ideas, ideas they may never have fully explored on their own. They will know the basic case, evidence most people will not know, but they may never have struggled with other possibilities to the level of those who first came up with an idea. New evidence can also arise. The point is that scholarly agreements can change, just as scientific theories or historical reconstructions can.
The reading of the Gospels as Scripture is not contingent either on historical reconstruction, nor is it dependent on historical accuracy. Both the modernist drive to get back to the historical Jesus and the fundamentalist drive to harmonize the content of the Gospels are both equally out of focus. Certainly there are features of the story that must be historical for the Christian story to be true in its normal, orthodox, historical sense. Jesus must really have existed. He must have truly risen from the dead in history. But even such minimal historicity is enough to support faith in the incarnation. [2] Our point is not to dispute the historicity of the Gospels, only to point out that Christian faith does not clearly stand or fall on the historicity of the bulk of the Gospels.
The fundamentalist reading of the Gospels is also not necessarily the same as a Christian reading of the Gospels as Scripture. The fundamentalist reading insists that we be able to fit all the details of the Gospels together as history, while reading the Gospels as Scripture only requires that we read the Gospels in relation to the one story. It is not that we have any interest in saying that Jesus did not do something in the Gospels or did not say something. It is only to say that we can read the Gospels as Christian Scripture regardless of these decisions—many of which can neither be proved or disproved from a historical standpoint.
We derive immense truth from the parables without even considering their historicity. In the same way, reading the Gospels as Scripture is not dependent on historicity. The problem with the fundamentalist drive to harmonize is that it often requires us to disregard what the Gospels actually say. We create a “fifth gospel” that differs more from any of the four gospels than any of them actually differ from each other, and all this effort in the name of an idea we have, rather than in the interest of listening to what each individual gospel itself has to say.
Reading the Gospels as Scripture is not dependent on such things. It need not ignore the kinds of things those who truly are experts have hypothesized or discovered. But it also must not think that a unified reading of the four Gospels is bound by an inductive reading of each individual text. We are free to see more in the Gospel texts than they themselves say, while recognizing the writing of each individual Gospel as a moment in God’s never-ending walk with his people, a moment in salvation history.
We believe that the second person of the Trinity came to earth and was conceived by the Holy Spirit in the Virgin Mary. He walked the earth as one of us. He experienced what we experience. He was tempted in every way as we are but did not sin. He did miracles through the power of the Holy Spirit, just as we can. He healed; he cast out demons. He went to Jerusalem and died to reconcile humanity and the creation to God. He rose from the dead, and God enthroned him as king of the universe. He will come again to reconcile all things to God. When we read the Gospels as Christian Scripture, we read them with this faith in mind.
[1] A minority argues that Matthew was first, with Mark then abridging it and Luke reordering it.
[2] For example, even the virginal conception does not seem essential to Jesus' divinity. No one miracle, no one healing or exorcism, no one event or saying of Jesus seems essential for Jesus to be divine. Certainly the Christian story would be anemic without these elements, but we could still believe the Apostle’s or Nicene Creed even if most of the stories of the Gospels were not historical.
Sunday, January 23, 2011
Wesleyans and Communion (W)
I thought this was posted somewhere here, but I didn't find it in a search or on my sidebar. This is a piece I wrote once upon a time. This piece is more about the practice of communion in the Wesleyan Church, extrapolating the theory embodied in the practice rather than any well thought out theology.
_______________
1. For Wesleyans, as for other Christians, communion is, first of all, a remembrance of what Christ did for us in his atoning death. Christians also call it the "Eucharist," a "thanksgiving" for what God has done through Jesus Christ's death in reconciling humanity to himself. This is the predominant lens through which Wesleyans understand communion in practice, even if it is not the only one. Nevertheless, it is an element Wesleyans share with the church universal.
At some point in the communion services of most churches, the minister retells the story of the Last Supper:
“On the night he was betrayed, he took the bread. And when he had given thanks, he broke it gave it to his disciples saying, ‘Take, eat. This is my body that is given for you.’
“Likewise after supper he took the cup. And when he had given thanks he gave it to them saying, ‘Drink you all of this, for this is my blood of the new covenant which is shed for you and for many for the remission of sins. Do this, whenever you drink it, in remembrance of me.’”
One Wesleyan once described communion as a kind of “passion play,” where you watch the story playing itself out in the words of the minister.
2. In conjunction with this aspect of communion, we might mention another strong characteristic of communion in the Wesleyan Church. Our tradition used to have regular "altar calls" in which individuals were invited to come forward and pray. Sometimes Wesleyan churches will still call for a moment of commitment or recommitment to Christ. But certainly in practice we would strongly associate the time of communion as a time for us to confess our sins and recommit ourselves to Christ. Communion thus serves as a kind of reset button on our relationship with God. Before you go forward, you repent of any un-confessed sin and commit to move forward with God.
3. Thirdly, we would view communion as a sacrament, a divinely appointed moment to meet God and experience his grace, a divinely appointed moment in which God takes ordinary things like bread and juice and catalyzes his presence and power in the believer. While Wesleyans often do not emphasize this aspect of communion as much as they should, it is part of the language we use to describe communion, and it is of course solidly rooted in John Wesley himself.
To say that communion is a means of grace means that something mysterious goes on in communion, that in some strange way we cannot explain, people meet God when they take communion. We mean to say that a person seeking God is likely to find him in communion. We mean that a person who is having trouble experiencing God’s presence or who is in a dark night of the soul is more likely to feel God’s presence if they take communion than if they do not. Wesley himself thought that since it was ultimately God’s choice as to when he spoke to you but that we should avail ourselves of the means of grace to make ourselves ready.
Does the Wesleyan Church have a view on historical debates like transubstantiation, consubstantiation, and other issues? We have never had such debates in our fellowship. A Wesleyan leader once suggested that by saying “The body of our Lord,” we left it to the partaker to work out exactly what that might mean to them. In that sense, the Wesleyan allowance for some breadth of belief in relation to the historical debates of the church applies to these issues as well. John Wesley himself agreed with Calvin on this issue, that Christ was spiritually present in the elements but that they did not literally become the body and blood of Jesus.
Wesleyans generally expect that an ordained minister will "preside" at communion, especially when it comes to the moment when we ask God to make the elements become the body and blood of Christ for us. However, we do not consider it an absolute. It enhances the sacredness of the moment for someone set apart by God and recognized as such by the church to call on God to make this moment into a sacramental moment. But we allow that God can set apart individuals for special moments and times by his own reckoning, outside mortal channels.
4. Communion is about communion with the body of Christ. It is easy to forget that one of the principle functions of communion in the early church was to emphasize the unity of Christians with one another. 1 Corinthians expresses this same point to the Corinthians, who were sorely in need of it: “Though we are many, we are one body, because we all partake of the one bread.”
It is worth reminding ourselves, in the midst of our individual wafers and cups, that Jesus and his disciples shared a common cup and a common loaf. Wesleyans inNorth America do not celebrate communion with wine, so hygienic reasons might keep us from drinking from a common cup. However, many churches practice communion by intinction, where you or the minister breaks off a piece of bread from a common loaf. Then you dip the bread into a common cup.
This way of doing communion preserves the unifying principle much better than individualized plastic cups and wafers. Also, having people come forward helps with the other two functions we have mentioned: 1) it focalizes partaking to a moment of decision in front of the minister and 2) the imagery of the common bread and juice makes the act look like more than a little snack in the pew (this helps children to see it as a different kind of activity too).
Communion should be open to every Christian or seeker present when it is offered. If it is part of a wedding, it should ideally be offered to everyone present. Wesleyan churches are supposed to take communion at least once every three months. Notice the direction this wording is headed—we are welcome to take it far more often than that. John Wesley’s conviction was that you should take communion “as often as you can.” Indeed, he considered it a “sin of infirmity” to miss the opportunity inadvertently when it was available.
The Wesleyan liturgy emphasizes that the person partaking of communion should do so as an act of seeking communion with God. That means a non-Christian can make communion a time of seeking faith. Wesleyans do not require baptism for a person to partake of communion. All we require is that the person be seeking God, “you who do earnestly repent of your sin.”
We have never debated the question of children in communion, but we can see how the practice might vary depending on whether a Wesleyan church more practiced infant or believer's baptism. For churches that practice believer's baptism, there will be a tendency to keep children from communion until they are old enough to make a conscious decision for Christ. For churches that practice infant baptism--and thus see the children more as "in" until they make a choice otherwise--there will be a tendency to have them participate in the common meal as they would have in the early church.
_______________
1. For Wesleyans, as for other Christians, communion is, first of all, a remembrance of what Christ did for us in his atoning death. Christians also call it the "Eucharist," a "thanksgiving" for what God has done through Jesus Christ's death in reconciling humanity to himself. This is the predominant lens through which Wesleyans understand communion in practice, even if it is not the only one. Nevertheless, it is an element Wesleyans share with the church universal.
At some point in the communion services of most churches, the minister retells the story of the Last Supper:
“On the night he was betrayed, he took the bread. And when he had given thanks, he broke it gave it to his disciples saying, ‘Take, eat. This is my body that is given for you.’
“Likewise after supper he took the cup. And when he had given thanks he gave it to them saying, ‘Drink you all of this, for this is my blood of the new covenant which is shed for you and for many for the remission of sins. Do this, whenever you drink it, in remembrance of me.’”
One Wesleyan once described communion as a kind of “passion play,” where you watch the story playing itself out in the words of the minister.
2. In conjunction with this aspect of communion, we might mention another strong characteristic of communion in the Wesleyan Church. Our tradition used to have regular "altar calls" in which individuals were invited to come forward and pray. Sometimes Wesleyan churches will still call for a moment of commitment or recommitment to Christ. But certainly in practice we would strongly associate the time of communion as a time for us to confess our sins and recommit ourselves to Christ. Communion thus serves as a kind of reset button on our relationship with God. Before you go forward, you repent of any un-confessed sin and commit to move forward with God.
3. Thirdly, we would view communion as a sacrament, a divinely appointed moment to meet God and experience his grace, a divinely appointed moment in which God takes ordinary things like bread and juice and catalyzes his presence and power in the believer. While Wesleyans often do not emphasize this aspect of communion as much as they should, it is part of the language we use to describe communion, and it is of course solidly rooted in John Wesley himself.
To say that communion is a means of grace means that something mysterious goes on in communion, that in some strange way we cannot explain, people meet God when they take communion. We mean to say that a person seeking God is likely to find him in communion. We mean that a person who is having trouble experiencing God’s presence or who is in a dark night of the soul is more likely to feel God’s presence if they take communion than if they do not. Wesley himself thought that since it was ultimately God’s choice as to when he spoke to you but that we should avail ourselves of the means of grace to make ourselves ready.
Does the Wesleyan Church have a view on historical debates like transubstantiation, consubstantiation, and other issues? We have never had such debates in our fellowship. A Wesleyan leader once suggested that by saying “The body of our Lord,” we left it to the partaker to work out exactly what that might mean to them. In that sense, the Wesleyan allowance for some breadth of belief in relation to the historical debates of the church applies to these issues as well. John Wesley himself agreed with Calvin on this issue, that Christ was spiritually present in the elements but that they did not literally become the body and blood of Jesus.
Wesleyans generally expect that an ordained minister will "preside" at communion, especially when it comes to the moment when we ask God to make the elements become the body and blood of Christ for us. However, we do not consider it an absolute. It enhances the sacredness of the moment for someone set apart by God and recognized as such by the church to call on God to make this moment into a sacramental moment. But we allow that God can set apart individuals for special moments and times by his own reckoning, outside mortal channels.
4. Communion is about communion with the body of Christ. It is easy to forget that one of the principle functions of communion in the early church was to emphasize the unity of Christians with one another. 1 Corinthians expresses this same point to the Corinthians, who were sorely in need of it: “Though we are many, we are one body, because we all partake of the one bread.”
It is worth reminding ourselves, in the midst of our individual wafers and cups, that Jesus and his disciples shared a common cup and a common loaf. Wesleyans in
This way of doing communion preserves the unifying principle much better than individualized plastic cups and wafers. Also, having people come forward helps with the other two functions we have mentioned: 1) it focalizes partaking to a moment of decision in front of the minister and 2) the imagery of the common bread and juice makes the act look like more than a little snack in the pew (this helps children to see it as a different kind of activity too).
Communion should be open to every Christian or seeker present when it is offered. If it is part of a wedding, it should ideally be offered to everyone present. Wesleyan churches are supposed to take communion at least once every three months. Notice the direction this wording is headed—we are welcome to take it far more often than that. John Wesley’s conviction was that you should take communion “as often as you can.” Indeed, he considered it a “sin of infirmity” to miss the opportunity inadvertently when it was available.
The Wesleyan liturgy emphasizes that the person partaking of communion should do so as an act of seeking communion with God. That means a non-Christian can make communion a time of seeking faith. Wesleyans do not require baptism for a person to partake of communion. All we require is that the person be seeking God, “you who do earnestly repent of your sin.”
We have never debated the question of children in communion, but we can see how the practice might vary depending on whether a Wesleyan church more practiced infant or believer's baptism. For churches that practice believer's baptism, there will be a tendency to keep children from communion until they are old enough to make a conscious decision for Christ. For churches that practice infant baptism--and thus see the children more as "in" until they make a choice otherwise--there will be a tendency to have them participate in the common meal as they would have in the early church.
Saturday, January 22, 2011
Wesleyans and Infant Baptism (W)
Someone asked... here's a position piece edited from a previous post.
____________
Before we say anything else, it is important to point out that Wesleyans do not think baptism saves you. We do not think that baptism keeps anyone from hell or protects them from the consequences of original sin. If a person has faith, we believe it is possible to get into the kingdom of God even if you are never baptized. We believe some Quakers and Salvation Army folk will be in the kingdom of God. Similarly, we do not think that baptism guarantees in any way that a person is right with God.
So the question of infant baptism for Wesleyans is two-fold: what does baptism symbolize and what grace can baptism catalyze. But given the previous paragraph, we simply do not argue over infant baptism. It is not an issue for us as a tradition. We have some who prefer infant baptism because of its symbolism, and we have some who prefer believer's baptism because of its symbolism. But it would be silly for us to get too out of sorts about either because none of us believe that baptism saves you.
As far as grace is concerned, God can meet us most anywhere. In a sense, believer's baptism is grace "after the fact." You have already believed. You have already received the Holy Spirit as God's seal of ownership, presumably. You have already received the Spirit as a down payment guaranteeing eternal life. What grace, then, is given by baptism at that time, since the cleansing of the Spirit has already taken place? Perhaps empowerment or a strengthened assurance?
We thus understand and sympathize with those who think it is significant to be able to remember your baptism. In a Western, individualist culture, we understand the power of individual decision and the strength of being able to look back and hold on to a powerful memory in times of trouble and doubt. We also understand why this position tends to see baptism more in symbolic than sacramental terms--it is after the fact.
The symbolism of infant baptism is also quite significant, but it focuses more on your sense of belonging to a community, a family that passed its faith on to you. It is no wonder that this symbolism has resonated in cultures that are more group-oriented. For Wesleyans who practice infant baptism, it is not an assurance of ultimate salvation. It is laying a claim on the child's life for Christ. It is binding the church and parents to do everything in their power to raise up the child in the way he or she should go. Infant dedication does the same thing but it puts the child on the "outside" of the people of God, while infant baptism places them on the inside of the line (as in ancient Israel) and challenges the child never to leave.
There is some key theology at work here. Wesleyans believe that God wants everyone to be a part of the kingdom of God. We tend to believe that God gives everyone a chance to be saved, even those who have never heard. Wesleyans call it "prevenient grace," the grace that comes to us before we even know it. We do not believe God would condemn someone who was true to the "light they had" even if they did not know the name of Jesus.
So we do not believe that God will condemn young children who are not mature enough to understand. Nor do we believe he will condemn those who are mentally challenged. There are people whom God would never have condemned at any point of their entire life because they responded appropriately from the very first moment God made himself known to them.
It was thus completely in keeping with John Wesley's theology that he preferred infant baptism, and it is for this reason that Wesleyans can still baptize infants today. It is laying a claim on them for God and saying, "You are in and we will do everything we can do to help you to stay in, even though it is ultimately your choice. But we are challenging you to stay in rather than holding you symbolically 'out,' at arm's length, until you make a move."
What is the grace then that might be involved in infant baptism? Perhaps it is a grace to keep you in and a grace on those around you to catalyze it? There is a real sense in which the rise of believer's baptism corresponds to the rise of Western individualism. We are not comfortable with the group dynamics of earlier times and often don't realize that the biblical world itself was similarly group oriented.
A whole host of clarifications to Paul's theology come into play here. For example, justification by faith must be balanced out with the faithfulness of Christ and the far more prevalent sense of us being incorporated into his faith and his death. Predestination and election language in Paul is primarily focused on us as a group rather than on us as individuals. Paul can even say that an unbelieving spouse is sanctified by a believing one, including the children, even apart from the faith either of the spouse or the children themselves (1 Cor. 7).
The fact that the baptisms recorded in the New Testament are all adult baptisms doesn't settle the issue. In point of fact, the Bible never tells us an incident where someone is baptized as an adult who was in the church as a child. All the adult NT baptisms are people entering the church for the first time as an adult. The NT does mention more than once that whole households were baptized--we just don't know who was in them. On the whole, the group-embedded nature of the ancient world must make us reckon with the strong possibility any children in these families would have been baptized in keeping with the family decision of the parents.
A personal relationship with God and Christ is of course essential. Every individual must confess Christ and appropriate his death if they understand the nature of things at all. But we must strongly suspect that such relationships were always embedded in the community of faith in New Testament times. In that sense they were personal, but not individual relationships with God and his Christ.
And of course infant baptism is not a Roman Catholic thing. Luther, Calvin, and Wesley all believed in and practiced infant baptism. Believer's baptism is really a result of Anabaptist influence on American Christianity in the last few hundred years, a minority voice that has really only flourished in America.
Wesleyans are free to practice baptism in any way other than one that believes the act of baptism itself saves us. We are free to baptize infants, and we are free to baptize individuals when they come to conscious faith. We are even free not to baptize at all, although the vast majority of us would agree that baptism is too powerful an act for us to miss out on.
____________
Before we say anything else, it is important to point out that Wesleyans do not think baptism saves you. We do not think that baptism keeps anyone from hell or protects them from the consequences of original sin. If a person has faith, we believe it is possible to get into the kingdom of God even if you are never baptized. We believe some Quakers and Salvation Army folk will be in the kingdom of God. Similarly, we do not think that baptism guarantees in any way that a person is right with God.
So the question of infant baptism for Wesleyans is two-fold: what does baptism symbolize and what grace can baptism catalyze. But given the previous paragraph, we simply do not argue over infant baptism. It is not an issue for us as a tradition. We have some who prefer infant baptism because of its symbolism, and we have some who prefer believer's baptism because of its symbolism. But it would be silly for us to get too out of sorts about either because none of us believe that baptism saves you.
As far as grace is concerned, God can meet us most anywhere. In a sense, believer's baptism is grace "after the fact." You have already believed. You have already received the Holy Spirit as God's seal of ownership, presumably. You have already received the Spirit as a down payment guaranteeing eternal life. What grace, then, is given by baptism at that time, since the cleansing of the Spirit has already taken place? Perhaps empowerment or a strengthened assurance?
We thus understand and sympathize with those who think it is significant to be able to remember your baptism. In a Western, individualist culture, we understand the power of individual decision and the strength of being able to look back and hold on to a powerful memory in times of trouble and doubt. We also understand why this position tends to see baptism more in symbolic than sacramental terms--it is after the fact.
The symbolism of infant baptism is also quite significant, but it focuses more on your sense of belonging to a community, a family that passed its faith on to you. It is no wonder that this symbolism has resonated in cultures that are more group-oriented. For Wesleyans who practice infant baptism, it is not an assurance of ultimate salvation. It is laying a claim on the child's life for Christ. It is binding the church and parents to do everything in their power to raise up the child in the way he or she should go. Infant dedication does the same thing but it puts the child on the "outside" of the people of God, while infant baptism places them on the inside of the line (as in ancient Israel) and challenges the child never to leave.
There is some key theology at work here. Wesleyans believe that God wants everyone to be a part of the kingdom of God. We tend to believe that God gives everyone a chance to be saved, even those who have never heard. Wesleyans call it "prevenient grace," the grace that comes to us before we even know it. We do not believe God would condemn someone who was true to the "light they had" even if they did not know the name of Jesus.
So we do not believe that God will condemn young children who are not mature enough to understand. Nor do we believe he will condemn those who are mentally challenged. There are people whom God would never have condemned at any point of their entire life because they responded appropriately from the very first moment God made himself known to them.
It was thus completely in keeping with John Wesley's theology that he preferred infant baptism, and it is for this reason that Wesleyans can still baptize infants today. It is laying a claim on them for God and saying, "You are in and we will do everything we can do to help you to stay in, even though it is ultimately your choice. But we are challenging you to stay in rather than holding you symbolically 'out,' at arm's length, until you make a move."
What is the grace then that might be involved in infant baptism? Perhaps it is a grace to keep you in and a grace on those around you to catalyze it? There is a real sense in which the rise of believer's baptism corresponds to the rise of Western individualism. We are not comfortable with the group dynamics of earlier times and often don't realize that the biblical world itself was similarly group oriented.
A whole host of clarifications to Paul's theology come into play here. For example, justification by faith must be balanced out with the faithfulness of Christ and the far more prevalent sense of us being incorporated into his faith and his death. Predestination and election language in Paul is primarily focused on us as a group rather than on us as individuals. Paul can even say that an unbelieving spouse is sanctified by a believing one, including the children, even apart from the faith either of the spouse or the children themselves (1 Cor. 7).
The fact that the baptisms recorded in the New Testament are all adult baptisms doesn't settle the issue. In point of fact, the Bible never tells us an incident where someone is baptized as an adult who was in the church as a child. All the adult NT baptisms are people entering the church for the first time as an adult. The NT does mention more than once that whole households were baptized--we just don't know who was in them. On the whole, the group-embedded nature of the ancient world must make us reckon with the strong possibility any children in these families would have been baptized in keeping with the family decision of the parents.
A personal relationship with God and Christ is of course essential. Every individual must confess Christ and appropriate his death if they understand the nature of things at all. But we must strongly suspect that such relationships were always embedded in the community of faith in New Testament times. In that sense they were personal, but not individual relationships with God and his Christ.
And of course infant baptism is not a Roman Catholic thing. Luther, Calvin, and Wesley all believed in and practiced infant baptism. Believer's baptism is really a result of Anabaptist influence on American Christianity in the last few hundred years, a minority voice that has really only flourished in America.
Wesleyans are free to practice baptism in any way other than one that believes the act of baptism itself saves us. We are free to baptize infants, and we are free to baptize individuals when they come to conscious faith. We are even free not to baptize at all, although the vast majority of us would agree that baptism is too powerful an act for us to miss out on.
Friday, January 21, 2011
A Song for Nervous Flyers
To be sung to the tune of "This Is My Father's World," about 30 seconds after take-off:
There is nothing I can do,
To keep this plane in air.
It's totally outside my hands.
It's pointless to give a care.
There's nothing I can do.
I could not make it fall.
E'en if I wanted it to crash,
There's nothing I can do.
There is nothing I can do,
To keep this plane in air.
It's totally outside my hands.
It's pointless to give a care.
There's nothing I can do.
I could not make it fall.
E'en if I wanted it to crash,
There's nothing I can do.
Thursday, January 20, 2011
Pew Translation?
Kyle Ray in effect asked me at The Gathering to stop waffling and endorse a translation for the pew. I continue to struggle but I'm trying to formulate an answer:
First, preach on Sunday from whatever version seems to best communicate the message you believe you should bring this Sunday. In other words, I'm not necessarily recommending that you standarize your preaching version. The problem of course is when you want the congregation to read along and you are not using a PowerPoint for them to follow along. If they are following along in the pew, you don't want the version read from the front to be too different.
... which of course raises the question of a pew translation all together. If you don't have them at this point, I wouldn't bother. Invest in a good AV system so you can project the version of the morning on a screen instead.
For a detailed study of the text in a class or in sermon preparation, you want a heavily formal equivalence translation like the NASB, RSV, or ESV, although the last does show its theological bias occasionally. The NRSV and CEB are going to be better in some cases, but they will also fool you sometimes when it comes to gender (brothers and sisters).
I'm going to tentatively fall off the log with the CEB, the Common English Bible, as the leading candidate in my mind right now for pew translation, if you're going to have one. This is not my final answer but I like it for several reasons: 1) it is very understandable and 2) it has less theological bias in my opinion and in some cases is the only version that gets it right.
We'll see. The NLT makes a fine pew Bible too and is even more dynamic. I use the NRSV in my worship service. It remains the standard version for biblical scholarship at large.
First, preach on Sunday from whatever version seems to best communicate the message you believe you should bring this Sunday. In other words, I'm not necessarily recommending that you standarize your preaching version. The problem of course is when you want the congregation to read along and you are not using a PowerPoint for them to follow along. If they are following along in the pew, you don't want the version read from the front to be too different.
... which of course raises the question of a pew translation all together. If you don't have them at this point, I wouldn't bother. Invest in a good AV system so you can project the version of the morning on a screen instead.
For a detailed study of the text in a class or in sermon preparation, you want a heavily formal equivalence translation like the NASB, RSV, or ESV, although the last does show its theological bias occasionally. The NRSV and CEB are going to be better in some cases, but they will also fool you sometimes when it comes to gender (brothers and sisters).
I'm going to tentatively fall off the log with the CEB, the Common English Bible, as the leading candidate in my mind right now for pew translation, if you're going to have one. This is not my final answer but I like it for several reasons: 1) it is very understandable and 2) it has less theological bias in my opinion and in some cases is the only version that gets it right.
We'll see. The NLT makes a fine pew Bible too and is even more dynamic. I use the NRSV in my worship service. It remains the standard version for biblical scholarship at large.
Wednesday, January 19, 2011
Holy Centigrade, Batman
I was sitting in a Greek pub here in Ontario, Canada--about a mile and a half from my lodgings and chomping on a gyro--when the news said it was going to be 15 below zero. "15 below," says I! That's cold!
Then I remembered that only we scientifically backward Americans still use Fahrenheit. That's only about 7 degrees. That's no worse than Indiana.
It was a fine walk home.
Then I remembered that only we scientifically backward Americans still use Fahrenheit. That's only about 7 degrees. That's no worse than Indiana.
It was a fine walk home.
Tuesday, January 18, 2011
One Second Prejudice...
... two seconds to Christ.
I was thinking last night that a lot of us are not far from the right attitudes and choices. We humans tend to be so unthinkingly inconsistent. Maybe all some of us need is someone next to us to ask the obvious question--one extra second and we might actually be Christ-like.
"But Ken, don't you believe you should love your neighbor as yourself?"
"Well, Yes."
And that's all it might take for us to move from spiritual mediocrity to Christ-likeness. Here are some scenarios:
"I can't stand all the attention they give to Martin Luther King Jr. All this special treatment to make African-Americans feel good."
"Really, Ken? Are you saying that African-Americans are getting special treatment because of their color? That's never happened to whites over blacks, right? Shouldn't you be happy that after centuries of slavery, after no help whatsoever normalizing after slavery was over, after lynchings and clearly prejudicial laws for a century, you begrudge giving a day to honor someone who in a non-violent way worked to allow African-Americans to be able to sit anywhere on a bus?"
And just that extra second makes me realize how completely ridiculous my first second of prejudice was. But there are many other issues.
"We need to get rid of all these Mexicans and send them back. See that woman over there? I bet she's illegal."
"What's really ticking you off, Ken? Did she do something to you? You really think she's hurting you some way or is some sort of a hardened criminal? Why does it get to you so much? You've never even seen her before."
Just the extra second of putting yourself in someone else's shoes, of asking how you would want to be treated if you were them, if a person really is a Christian, that's all it can take to move from a mind that has nothing to do with Christ to a Christ-like mind.
I was thinking last night that a lot of us are not far from the right attitudes and choices. We humans tend to be so unthinkingly inconsistent. Maybe all some of us need is someone next to us to ask the obvious question--one extra second and we might actually be Christ-like.
"But Ken, don't you believe you should love your neighbor as yourself?"
"Well, Yes."
And that's all it might take for us to move from spiritual mediocrity to Christ-likeness. Here are some scenarios:
"I can't stand all the attention they give to Martin Luther King Jr. All this special treatment to make African-Americans feel good."
"Really, Ken? Are you saying that African-Americans are getting special treatment because of their color? That's never happened to whites over blacks, right? Shouldn't you be happy that after centuries of slavery, after no help whatsoever normalizing after slavery was over, after lynchings and clearly prejudicial laws for a century, you begrudge giving a day to honor someone who in a non-violent way worked to allow African-Americans to be able to sit anywhere on a bus?"
And just that extra second makes me realize how completely ridiculous my first second of prejudice was. But there are many other issues.
"We need to get rid of all these Mexicans and send them back. See that woman over there? I bet she's illegal."
"What's really ticking you off, Ken? Did she do something to you? You really think she's hurting you some way or is some sort of a hardened criminal? Why does it get to you so much? You've never even seen her before."
Just the extra second of putting yourself in someone else's shoes, of asking how you would want to be treated if you were them, if a person really is a Christian, that's all it can take to move from a mind that has nothing to do with Christ to a Christ-like mind.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

