Sunday, January 16, 2011

Reading Paul's letters as Scripture 2

This is my continued attempt to express what it might mean to read New Testament letters as Christian Scripture.
___________
If what you read for the previous discussion has any validity, the difference between reading New Testament letters as Scripture and reading them for what they meant originally might involve a number of differences.  For example, there may be some content in them that we find more central than others.  We may emphasize and prioritize certain parts of the letters over other texts on similar themes in the books of the Bible.  Martin Luther framed this question as some texts being “clearer” than others, but history teaches us that one person or group’s “clear” text is another person or group’s “unclear” one.  The biblical texts themselves come to us without an introduction telling us which passages are more central than the others.  We inevitably have to provide this bit of glue as we look at these texts that were originally written at different times and places to different audiences.

Not only common Christian tradition but even more so the specific Christian traditions to which we belong strongly influence what we find as clear or unclear in the Bible.  It is important to recognize that these traditional influences are at work in our understanding, in our “world in front of the text,” even if we are a part of a supposedly “non-denominational” church.  Most non-denominational churches in America at any point in history will tend to look much alike.  They tend to be Baptist in structure and flavor, usually with a strong “restorationist” sense that they are modeling themselves after the early church.  Many also add a charismatic element to their identity.

But just because you are not aware of the historical influences on your understanding does not mean there are no traditional influences on you.  All of the elements I mentioned in the last two sentences come from distinctive streams within the history of American Christianity.  In terms of ideas and practices, therefore, American non-denominational churches partake of Christian tradition just like a Methodist or a Lutheran.

Some passages appear unclear to us because we immediately sense the historical distance between us and the biblical texts.  For example, although we do find Christians around the world and even in North America who strictly try to follow New Testament comments on hair coverings or jewelry, most Christians sense the historical and cultural distance between us and texts like 1 Corinthians 11:3-16 or 1 Peter 3:3.  At the same time, we know that our particular cultures and subcultures have a massive effect on what seems clear or unclear.  Is it clear that Christians should not go to war?  It is to Quakers.  Is it clear that infant baptism is wrong?  It is to Baptists.  Is it clear that women can be ministers?  It is to Wesleyans.  Is it clear that a Christian can be in a monogamous homosexual relationship?  It is to the Metropolitan Community Church.  When you get to analyzing the golf swing, what looks so effortless becomes much more complicated.

A second feature of reading texts like the New Testament letters as Christian Scripture, rather than as ancient texts, is that we sometimes shift their meaning subtly.  This can be a reinterpretation of words or phrases.  It can be a broadening of scope beyond the original scope the words had.  Again, Fee and Stuart would reject the validity of changing the meaning of the words and try to lay down clear rules for broadening the scope of the words.  You may want to argue for their position over what Dr. Schenck is presenting.

But we might think of some of the passages over which the Christians of the first five centuries argued.  For example, when Colossians 1:15 says that Christ is the “firstborn of all creation,” was it implying that, even though Christ is pre-eminent over all creation, he was part “of” the creation?  Common Christianity rejects this position.  When Christians read Colossians as Scripture, they do not appropriate this verse so that Christ is a part of the creation, the first thing God created.  Since AD325, the Christian understanding is that Christ is “begotten, not made; of one substance of the Father.”

But what did Colossians 1:15 originally mean?  From one perspective, it does not really matter, because God has clarified throughout the centuries what Christians are to believe on this subject.  From a traditionally evangelical or Protestant perspective, however, it is quite important.  From Fee and Stuart’s perspective, a text cannot come to mean something different from what it meant originally.

For this reason, the New International Version (NIV), for so long the evangelical translation of the Bible, made it a point to translate the biblical text so as to remove any possibility of interpreting them in an unchristian way.  For example, it translates Colossians 1:15 to say that Christ is the firstborn “over” all creation.  The original meaning must turn out to be the same as the Christian meaning.  At numerous places, it adds words or refashions the text so that this issue disappears.  Here are just a few examples:

  • The NIV renders the Greek phrase “being in the form of God” as “being in very nature God” (Phil. 2:6) in conformity with Christian orthodoxy.
  • The NIV adds the word “now” to 1 Peter 4:6 so the verse cannot be read to say that the dead ever had any chance of changing their eternal destiny.
  • The NIV adds the word “just” to Jeremiah 7:22 so that it does not support the views of some scholars who argue that the sacrificial laws do not trace back historically to Moses.
  • It translates the word “entirely” as “surely” in 1 Corinthians 9:10 so that Paul does not sound like he is dismissing the original meaning of Deuteronomy 25:4.

Some of these interpretations may of course be correct.  The point is just that the NIV translators were strongly driven to make the original meaning of a biblical text conform with their evangelical theology.  What we are suggesting is that to some extent, we do not have to worry about passages with disputable original meanings because God’s Spirit has made the Christian way of reading such passages clear, regardless of what they meant originally.

We arguably rightly do some of this “reinterpretation” without even realizing it.  For example, when Paul says he was taken up into the “third sky” (2 Cor. 12:2), is it not likely that he literally pictured the universe as consisting of three layers of sky as you go straight up from a flat earth, like other Jewish writings of the day did?  Did he not likely picture the dead being located directly below, in the underworld beneath a flat earth (e.g., Phil. 2:10)?  Without even realizing it, we take these expressions as metaphorical expressions rather than as literal pictures of the world.

But is this way we think about such things another example of reinterpreting the text so that it speaks more directly to us today?  When we talk about the sun rising and setting, we know we are speaking “phenomenologically.”  We are speaking in terms of how things appear, not necessarily about how things literally are.  But is it not much more likely that the biblical authors understood such things literally?  So once again, we find that we have been able by the Spirit’s power to hit the golf ball to the green without necessarily knowing all the physics of our golf swing.

By the way, this discussion lays bare potentially grave problems with a “fundamentalist” approach to the Bible, such as the insistence that Genesis 1 must refer to “literal” 24 hour days.  If God revealed the truths of the Bible in the categories of its original audiences, then we would expect a text like Genesis 1 to sound much more like a dialog within the categories of the Ancient Near East than a dialog with the issues of modern science.  And indeed, if we really read Genesis 1 literally, we find that on Day 4 God places the sun, moon, and stars into the space between waters God created on Day 2.  In other words, after creation we would have expected to go straight up through the stars to find the primordial waters above them.

A third way in which reading texts like the New Testament letters as Scripture differs from reading them as historical texts is in our personal involvement with them.  It is conventional to speak of the “authority” of the biblical texts.  But like the golf swing that is more complicated than it looks, the potential ambiguity of what the biblical texts actually mean significantly complicates the question of authority.  Which meaning of the biblical text is authoritative?

Further complicating matters is the question of genre.  One of the reasons so much of Christian faith and ethics comes from our dialog with the New Testament letters, especially for Protestants, is the fact that these letters function—more than any other part of the Bible—on a propositional level.  The letters make statements about beliefs and give instructions about how to live.  They are thus in a form that lends itself most easily to formulating beliefs and practices.  It thus makes sense for us to speak of these New Testament letters as having authority over us as Christians, meaning that we are to do what they instruct and believe what they teach.

However, as we will explore in subsequent weeks, it is less clear what it means for a story or a psalm to be authoritative.  Psalms tend to be expressive of the feelings of the psalmist.  A story may describe something that happened without necessarily prescribing that we model ourselves after it.  We will discuss in what way these other genres and types of “speech acts” might be Scripture for us later in the course.

Yet we would argue that no one even applies all of the commands of the New Testament letters directly to today.  Fee and Stuart set down a rule, “Whenever we share comparable particulars (i.e., similar specific life situations) with the first century hearers, God’s Word to us is the same as his Word to them” (75).  In other words, standard evangelical method looks for the points of continuity and discontinuity with the original context of the New Testament letters.

They recognize the potential this dynamic brings to “explain away” the authoritative commands of the New Testament.  But they rightly see no way around it.  Does God want us to set up a system today where widows under sixty are urged to remarry and where the church provides all the material needs of widows over sixty (1 Timothy 5)?  We could, but most of us recognize that the situation of widows today may be quite different than it was two thousand years ago and, just to complicate matters, 1 Corinthians 7:39-40 give a different preference for widows to remain single.

Again, the fundamentalist approach to the Bible tends to flatten out these sorts of texts, forcing them all to say the same thing without taking into consideration much of the original context in which they were written.  Here we should recognize that it is not only ethics that can relate to specific times and places but ideas as well.  Assuming that God wanted to be understood, we should assume that even the beliefs of the New Testament letters were “incarnated” in the categories of the first century, that they “took on the flesh” of those to whom God was speaking.

Again, determining the original meaning of a biblical text is arguably a science that an atheist could do.  You read the words in their literary and historical context to determine what they mostly likely meant.  But discerning God’s will for us today in those texts—which parts relate mostly to “that time” rather than “our time”—is a spiritual dance.  It requires Spiritual discernment that cannot really be taught in a book.  Except in those occasional moments when God sends a prophet, we surely would expect God’s will to be clearer the more Christians we have who share a common vision and a common understanding.  And thus we can see an expanded meaning to what Paul meant when he urged the Philippians to “work out your salvation with fear and trembling” (Phil. 2:12).

I prefer to speak of the “sacramental” dimension of the Bible as Christian Scripture rather than in what prove to be ambiguous categories like authority or inerrancy.  A sacrament is a divinely appointed meeting place where something that seems ordinary becomes a channel of God’s grace.  What appear to be ordinary bread and wine become for you the body and blood of Jesus, shed for you.  What appears to be ordinary water becomes a catalyst for spiritual cleansing.  In the case of the Bible, what seem to be historically, contextually determined words become a channel for God’s voice to you.  The Bible does not speak in this way to atheists.  It is a dimension of the Bible as Christian Scripture.

Yet it is clear that the precise content of God’s speaking becomes somewhat vague and ambiguous as well in this sacramental view. We would again argue that this ambiguity is no different from determining which of the countless interpretations of the Bible in play are the correct ones! In practice, countless groups with the same high view of the Bible still manage to have contradictory beliefs and practices. At the root of this situation is the “polyvalence” of language, the fact that the very same words can mean different things to different people. We are thus forced to work together under the guidance of the Holy Spirit to determine God’s will for us and to rely on common Christian readings of the Bible beyond the phantom “text alone.”

Saturday, January 15, 2011

Reading Paul's letters as Scripture 1

Feedback welcome on this background to an assignment.
______________
Although we do it all the time, the way in which Christians dance between the biblical texts and our lives today is fascinating and complex.  For example, if you watch a pro golfer, you will see what looks to be an effortless motion and swing, with the ball gliding nicely to the green.  But if you ever take a golf lesson, you will no doubt get a confusing array of instructions: hold your elbow a certain way, hold the grip a certain way, swing through but primarily use only one of your arms to guide the club.  It seems impossible to think about every element in a good swing at the same time, but a practiced golfer does it all at once.

The proper use of the Bible as Christian Scripture is a little like a good golf swing.  To talk about what goes into it sounds a lot more complex than it is, even though we as Christians do it all the time.  Why is it, for example, that we tend to emphasize certain parts of Scripture and pay less attention to others?  How do we who are Protestants know that we should emphasize “a person is justified by faith and not by works of Law” (Rom. 3:28) over “a person is justified by works and not by faith alone” (Jas. 2:24).  Since Christians have not always prioritized Scripture in this way (e.g., prior to the Reformation), not a little Christian tradition must be a part of our subconscious, even though we may not stop to think about it in that way.  After all, the Bible itself does not tell us to emphasize the one and explain the other away.

A great deal of what we who are Protestants emphasize as our doctrine, as our system of Christian belief, maps to the letters of the New Testament.  Martin Luther took his doctrine of “justification by faith” from Romans, the idea that the only way to get right with God is to trust in what Christ did for us.  Before him, Augustine took the idea that we come into the world totally sinful from Romans as well, and he took cues from Paul on how to read the Adam and Eve story of Genesis.  John Calvin in the 1500s followed Augustine’s lead.  Even if you do not know these names, it is nevertheless very likely that you have some of their interpretations in your Christian bones if you are a Protestant.

Yet, as Fee and Stuart point out fairly well, the letters of the New Testament were originally “situational.”  That is, they were written by and large to address specific situations.  Even Romans, Paul’s most systematic letter, addressed a situation where Paul was introducing himself to the Romans while defending himself against misinformation people were spreading about him and hoping that the church might support him on a missionary initiative in Spain.  Romans was not, therefore, what one of Luther’s main heirs said—a “compendium of Christian theology” (Melanchthon).  Romans is full of rhetoric meant to convince.  It presupposes a conflict of ideas with people who disagree with Paul, such that Paul might have said certain things differently in the middle of a different conflict or if there was no conflict.

Here is where the golf swing comes in.  Melanchthon knew how to swing Christian theology out of Romans.  He knew how to read Romans and Paul’s letters as Christian Scripture.  He did so without even realizing that his readings of Romans were not exactly the same as what Paul meant originally—he saw more of a timeless and absolute systematic order to Romans than it may have originally had.  In fact, Melanchthon had a very naïve understanding of how meaning works.  He thought that Christian theology was simply a matter of analyzing the grammar of the Bible.  In reality, words only take on meanings in a context, to where the very same words can mean different things depending on the context in which they are said.

In my opinion, Christians have found legitimate Christian theology by hearing related but somewhat “loosened” meanings in the biblical texts throughout Christian history.  By “loosened” I mean that we have taken context specific teaching and made it more universal and timeless.  When the Spirit was behind it, who are we to say it was not legitimate, God speaking through the words of the Bible as a living word?  In my opinion, this phenomenon of the living word has been more likely the more Christians have commonly agreed on what they heard.

Just as an example, there are many points where the standard Protestant reading of Paul may differ in this way from Paul.  For example, did Paul really teach that we are totally depraved, that there is no good left in us whatsoever?  Certainly Paul believed we are thoroughly sinful as a result of Adam’s sin, but it is not clear that he ever absolutized human sinfulness.  Similarly, many experts on Paul today would suggest that faith in Christ was not as much an emphasis for him as Luther thought.  Many would suggest that the key phrase meant the faithfulness of Christ himself and that faith in God the Father was Paul’s main focus.  We could go on to critique Luther’s interpretation of the phrase “the righteousness of God” and the phrase “works of Law.”

But does the fact that Luther’s reading of Paul changed the meaning somewhat mean that God wasn’t in his Christian golf swing?  After all, Luther’s interpretations resonated with a vast number of Christians, so much so that even the Roman Catholic Church has come to acknowledge that faith is the central element in justification, in a right standing before God.  Fee and Stuart, representing the evangelical tradition well, disagree with the sort of “loosening” of the text’s meaning that we not only think God has used to speak to believers throughout Christian history—including in the Protestant Reformation—but that the New Testament authors demonstrate repeatedly in their interpretation of the Old Testament.

For Fee and Stuart, however, “a text cannot mean what it never could have meant to its author or his or her readers” (74).  Like so many evangelical scholars, they spend a good deal of energy trying to analyze the evangelical golf swing, trying to set down rules for how to swing.  And this is understandable.  If we allow the Spirit to swing meaning from Scripture freely, then it becomes hard to nail down exactly what it means.  So evangelical hermeneuticians have developed a highly sophisticated method of extracting meaning from the biblical text.

First we must read a particular book of the Bible in context.  Then we must look for points of continuity between our time and their time.  Fee and Stuart painstakingly look for how to justify when to see biblical teaching as locked up in ancient culture and when it extends to today.  They argue that the teaching of 1 Timothy on women is culture bound and does not transfer to today while New Testament teaching on homosexual practice continues to apply.

But in practice, Christians just swing the club and they swing together.  Do they swing well?  Does the ball make it to the green?  Fee, Stuart, and others like them set out these sorts of rules and methods to try to preserve the authority of Scripture while recognizing that its books were written for another time and place.  I wonder, however, if we can pin God’s use of the Bible as Christian Scripture quite so neatly.  “The wind blows where it wants.  You hear the sound of it but you do not know where it came from or where it is going” (John 3:8).

In the end, neither the original meaning nor the rigid evangelical interpretive method of the twentieth century has given us a unified sense of the Bible’s meaning down to specifics.  Indeed, what the Protestant focus on Scripture alone has given us is a fragmentation of Christian belief and practice into over twenty thousand different Christian denominations, what one theologian called the "Protestant Principle" of inevitable fragmentation (Paul Tillich).  It seems to me that a whole lot more of tradition and individual experience inevitably is a part of our Christian golf swing than many of us like to acknowledge to ourselves.

We would argue that these three elements should always be involved in reading the Bible as Christian Scripture.  First, a sense of the original meaning, the first moment of God’s speaking.  Having a sense of the original meaning of a biblical text does often show us our idiosyncrasies and places where our tradition has gone off course.  I would argue that the Protestant Reformation largely played out along these lines.  Luther pointed out how far Roman Catholic tradition had wandered from the original meanings of the Bible.

At the same time, the books of the Bible themselves are diverse and had distinct meanings.  The first five centuries of Christianity involved a process of integrating the books of the Bible into a common understanding.  Doctrines like the Trinity or the full divinity of Jesus were not clear to the Christians of the first few centuries.  They debated Scripture with each other until these common understandings emerged.  Indeed, they even had to discern which books constituted the New Testament itself, since the New Testament books themselves do not tell us which books should be in the New Testament!  We would seem to be on most certain ground when we read the Bible through these common Christian eyes, even moreso than when we read it in terms of its original meanings.

Finally, we must finally surrender to the Spirit.  Maybe there is a problem with us feeling like we need to be able to say when the Spirit is breathing through Scripture and when He is not.  After all, the Spirit himself knows.  We want to set boundaries.  We want to tell our denominations what they can and cannot believe, what they can and cannot do.  We want to nail things down.  We want control.  God is in control.  He controls the dance.  He directs the swing when it is on target.

Thankfully, when it comes to doctrine, what Christians believe, we have inherited the bulk of our faith from Christians reading the Bible throughout the centuries.  We have the Apostle’s Creed and the Nicene Creeds, which distill the understandings about God and Christ that emerged as the Christians of the first five centuries read the Bible as Scripture.  Those interpretations emphasize certain biblical texts over others.  Those interpretations “loosen” some texts from their original scope and meaning to address new questions.  This is the dance between reading the books of the Bible as historical documents and reading them as Christian Scripture.

We Protestants also have a certain set of emphases when we read the Bible, things like the importance of individual faith and an openness to reformation in dialog with the Bible.  The smaller the subset of Christianity we are a part of, the more we can probably question our unique readings of the Bible.  Then again, who is to say that God does not call specific groups to be like different parts of the body of Christ, with their own unique callings and tasks?

This is the first of several discussions we will have throughout this course on what it means to read the Bible as Christian Scripture.  Our claim, which you are very welcome to dispute, is that reading the books of the Bible for what they meant originally is not exactly the same as reading them as Christian Scripture.  An atheist can be an excellent interpreter of the original meaning of a book of the Bible.  In fact, an atheist might prove to be more honest and objective about the evidence, since he or she may have nothing invested in how the meaning turns out. 

But we would argue that to read the Bible as Scripture requires a Christian perspective of the whole, a certain way of prioritizing, organizing, and perhaps even reinterpreting the meaning of various texts into a whole.  It is something like what John Calvin called “illumination,” although he would not have described or understood it in the terms we are using.  An atheist might understand a Christian reading of Scripture, but he or she would have no reason to adopt it.

For example, a non-Christian Jewish scholar might have an excellent knowledge of the Jewish Bible for what it originally meant.  But for such an individual, it would not be the Old Testament.  In that sense, even though the Jewish Bible and the Old Testament are exactly the same text, they have quite a different significance and, probably, a quite different meaning at points.  To read the books of the Hebrew Bible as Christian Scripture is to read them in the light of faith in Jesus as Christ and as God.  It is to read them in the light of the New Testament. 

So Christians do not worry about offering animal sacrifices as Leviticus instructs (of course modern Jews have spiritualized these as well).  Most Christians also do not see the food laws or circumcision or Sabbath observance on Saturday as ongoing timeless ways of life.  This is because we read the books of the Old Testament in a certain way that goes beyond what they actually say about themselves.  I would argue that this same dynamic also applies to the way we as Christians read the New Testament, although it is more difficult for us to see it.  In the second discussion this week, we will explore this question a little further.

Friday, January 14, 2011

Should I become an Independent?

I didn't pay much attention to the quote until Reince Priebus was elected Chairman of the Republican Party today.  Maybe you've heard it: If you are "pro-stimulus, pro-GM bailout, pro-AIG, well, you know, guess what, you might not be a Republican."  Funny, I thought I was a Republican in the tradition of Teddy Roosevelt and Abraham Lincoln, and that the party had swung way right in the last 10 years.

I guess I'm being shown the door, even though I probably voted about half and half last election. ;-)

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

The Text of the Bible

I don't know if we'll ever rescue all the instructional videos I've done.  Argh!  I don't know if I ever did one on the text of the Bible.  Here's one I recorded last week for an online class:

The Text of the Bible


Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Economics and Ethics

I was listening to a piece on NPR about a move to introduce some sort of code of ethics into the guild of economists.  Many economists resist this sort of thing because they view their trade as a science, a matter of "fact" rather than "value," a matter of "this is how it works" rather than "this is what we should do."

Actually, it is this last contrast where some economists contradict themselves.  I agree that economics is a science--if you do this, such and such will happen in consequence.  An economist can thus suggest that "if you do such and such," "such and such will happen."  Of course there are different schools and so we cannot speak of a consensus on many things, but the basic sense of the discipline as science is clear.

It is when the question of "should" that ethics inevitably becomes part of the process.  Boyer, in his Idea of the Christian University, wisely suggested that it was at this point that a person's Christian values became a part of the equation.  For example, an economist might say--this particular course of deregulation or this particular bank failure will create great economic crisis in the short term, but will result in a more stable market sooner, while more moderate regulation and a bailout will result in a slower and less substantial recovery, but fewer people will commit suicide, so to speak.  (I'm not speaking to the specifics of recent events or the Depression, only trying to give a general impression).

It is at this point that those implementing economic principles, whether it is economists suggesting a particular course of action or the political system, bring ethics into the equation.  The implementation of economic theory always and inevitably involves ethics.

Sunday, January 09, 2011

Original Meaning Translation: Romans 1:1-7

Wesleyan Publishing House had the great idea of publishing Bible studies along with my two books on Paul.  So a Bible study group might work through Philippians or 1 Thessalonians together, while the study leader reads through the main Paul book.  Now with the second Paul book in process, I need to write the first two Bible studies that will go with it, which cover Romans.

I'm not going to write them here, but I thought I might give my own translation of Romans as I worked through them.  I was tempted to do an original meaning dynamic equivalence or free translation.  But I decided to go extra formal, to give a fairly straightforward window into the Greek, even though it may not turn out to be very good English.  By the way, don't worry, the Bible studies use the NIV as the default translation, although because it is so bad at places, I sometimes shift to others as necessary.

Romans 1:1-7
1 Paul, a slave of Messiah Jesus, called [to be] an apostle, having been set apart (and still set apart) for the gospel of God, 2 which he promised earlier through his prophets in the holy writings, 3 concerning his Son, who came from the seed of David according to flesh, 4 who was appointed Son of God in power according to the Spirit of holiness through the resurrection of the dead, Jesus, Messiah, our Lord, 5 through whom we received grace and apostleship [leading] to the obedience of faith among all the Gentiles for the sake of his name, 6 among whom you yourselves are also called by Jesus Messiah, 7 to all who are in Rome, beloved of God, called [to be] holy ones.  Grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Messiah.

Martyr-Proof Ideology

I was reflecting on the tactic of killing off someone because you want to disempower their ideas.  We possibly saw this yesterday in Arizona, but we saw it last week also in Pakistan and it happens repeatedly.  If the ideas have largely centered in one person, killing the person can kill the idea--or at least disempower it.  In a strange way, this dynamic also applies to the pastor of a local church.  If she has centered her ministry around herself, then it may fizzle after she leaves.

On the other hand, if the idea is truly held by the group, then others will immediately rise to take the martyr's place and may in fact be energized by martyrdom.  This cuts both ways, whether the ideology is good or bad.  Killing the leaders of Al-Qaeda, for example, may not in any way disempower their movement any more than killing Christians does in the stories we tell ourselves about Christian martyrs ("The blood of the martyrs is the seed of the church").

So there are some ideas we would no doubt like to see disappear and there are some we would like to see transcend.  If we want them to transcend, they had better be bigger than us.

Friday, January 07, 2011

Gathering Impressions

The Gathering was a meeting of the pastors and denominational leaders of the Wesleyan Church.  I asked myself who I was looking at among this group of worshiping believers.  I was not looking at the believers in the pew.  I was looking at those who stand behind the pulpit, along with their families.  I was not looking at Wesleyan educators, although understandably top college administrators and marketers were here on the job.  Also since many ministry faculty are ministers, some of us were here as well.  And of course those who lead the denomination at HQ were here.

So what did I go out to see?  These pastors are really the operational core of the Wesleyan Church.  Those who were up front, those from HQ, those like me who are educators, we are not the dynamo of the church.  Certainly the people in the churches are most the church, but they do not frame the direction of the church, at least not at this time.  The denominational leaders, educators, and people on the platform can try to influence the pastors, but ultimately, they as a whole, if they share a common vision, are the real influencers.  They signify the church's direction, its future.

So what are my impressions of the direction of the church, after these days here?

Heart
First, the pastors of the Wesleyan Church are good people.  I have countless friends here: childhood friends, college friends, seminary friends, former student friends, colleague friends.  I like the people of the Wesleyan Church.  The crowd here (including the Spanish service I went to yesterday) love to sing songs of praise to God.  I thought the worship leader for the conference was excellent.

The primary emphasis of their ministries (my impression) is to get people to pray the sinner's prayer.  Here I think you can distinguish the bulk of these pastors from the large church pastors and young pastors.  The emphasis of the growing churches and the young pastors, I think, is to love people on their way to a true and lasting relationship with Christ and one another.

There does remain a strong stream (I think) that does not like having a woman leader, simply because she is a woman.  If you ask, "But wouldn't you agree that Joanne Lyon is a more gifted leader than anyone else at HQ?"  Usually they will agree.  "Don't you think she has as much vision for the church as anyone."  Usually they'll agree.  I have not been able to find any real reason for this attitude other than an unhealthy bias.

I have a hunch personally that the bulk of Wesleyan pastors are quite "culturally captive," and this is a concern for me.  I am speaking of American conservative culture that takes its cues from the moguls of American fundamentalist Christianity.  It is a culture that has a difficult time distinguishing Republican politics from Christian values.  It is neither historically Christian and certainly not historically Wesleyan.

Hands
The second emphasis of the ministries of these pastors (my impression) is to get people to stop sinning.  Again, here I want to distinguish the bulk of Wesleyan pastors from the large church and young pastors.  The successful pastor will preach more "for" things than "against" things.  They preach changed lives for the better rather than against those out there somewhere (the people they preach against aren't usually sitting in front of them) who are doing the wrong thing.  The pastors who are attracting large congregations and the younger pastors want to see people's lives healed.  They want to see marital problems solved, etc (versus preaching against how much divorce is going on out there).

Head
There is some good thinking going on in the Wesleyan Church.  I heard that Wayne Schmidt's presentation was excellent, although I was still on a plane at the time.  Also, more than one person told me that Brenda Salter-McNeil, the African-American women who spoke Wednesday morning, was the best speaker of the entire conference (again, I was uploading material for an online course ;-)

What is most encouraging to me about our denomination is our involvement and empowerment of Hispanic ministry and Dr. Lyon's engagement with bringing "good news to the poor" in our broader society and world.  This bristles some because of the cultural captivity I mentioned, but these may actually be some of the only distinctive contributions our fellowship is making to the kingdom of God at this time at all.

This is a hard word and perhaps I am wrong.  As I looked out at the collection of people I love, I found little reason for us to exist as a denomination.  There are some people with vision, but I don't think the "operational core" of our church has any clear vision or identity.  Indeed, those streams within the church that might most point toward such vision are the very things that cause so many Wesleyan pastors to bristle.

So does the Wesleyan Church have any reason to exist?

Thursday, January 06, 2011

Gathering 2

First of all, let me apologize for yesterday’s post.  After being here for a day, I can see that those who put the program together did a good job of setting things up.  The problem was mine—I don’t know any of the Wesleyans on the program.


I was delighted yesterday to meet with a number of new friends from the church in Puerto Rico, heard Gabriel Salguero speak on the difficulties of bringing multiple ethnicities together in worship, met Dr. Samuel Pagan who is from Puerto Rico but teaches in Bethlehem.  I did not realize the connections between Christian Palestinians and the Spanish-speaking world!  Dr. Pagan’s wife Naomi has published a children’s book that has Spanish, English, and Arabic side by side—amazing!


I’m also very curious about what strong sub-currents might be running within the denomination below the surface.  I’m picturing a river where you see a gentle flow on the surface but where strong and independent currents are running below, almost as if a completely different river.  Anyone else feeling that?

Wednesday, January 05, 2011

In Florida at the Gathering

The Wesleyan Church stumbled onto a good thing a few years back when they created something called "The Gathering."  No, it's not Highlander, although the jokes are already circulating now that the WC may be moving toward a single general superintendent ("There can only be one." ;-)

It's my sense that the regional minister's conference has been dead in the WC for a couple decades now, but perhaps that was just fallow ground enough for a "minister's reunion" to go gang busters.  I'm not sure what attendance is at this one.  I wonder if they should have scheduled it between Christmas and New Years.  I wasn't able to bring my family, for example, because public school started back up yesterday.  But attendance was unexpectedly large at the first one.

OK, I was wrong.  Excellent line up.  Good work to the committee.

Tuesday, January 04, 2011

Merit Pay for Teachers?

For the first time in a long time, Republicans now control the Indiana State legislature and it looks like education reform is high on the agenda.  One element of the measures proposed is merit pay for teachers.  In theory, I am very much in favor of rewarding our teachers astronomically for those who demonstrate massive giftedness in our public schools.  I couldn't do what they do, given the behavior issues and ADHD environment.

Here's the deal.  Merit pay is a bad idea if it is solely linked to student scores.  This rewards the teachers who, either by politics or even incompetence manage to get the easy students.  The biggest problem in the classroom is the massive behavior management issue, not the incompetence of teachers.  Merit pay linked to scores does not take into account the incredibly gifted teachers who take on the children in our schools who are overwhelmingly likely to spend the majority of their life in prison or on the streets.

So merit pay is a great idea to me but only if it is administered in the light of a whole range of competencies.  What we need more than anything right now is brilliant classroom managers.  Almost anyone with a classroom full of "normal" children could improve test scores.  There just aren't very many classrooms like that in the failing schools of Indiana.

P.S. There were only two passing schools in Marion last year and, because the failing schools shewed their worst and dullest to them, there may not be any passing schools this year.  The problem is not the teachers; it's the kids as they have emerged from their "families."

Monday, January 03, 2011

Second Paul Volume Done!

Well, only six months late--and almost a year since I finished the first volume--I have finished Paul: Soldier of Peace.  (The first volume was Paul: Messenger of Grace)  It will probably be July before it comes out.  I'm even more excited about this book than the first, even though I'm sure I could have done better if I'd taken even just another week.  But it must be done!

I believe this book will pretty much be the only book out there that brings Wesleyan (revivalist) theology into dialog with the developments of the last thirty years of Pauline studies (admittedly, I have not yet dived into the new Romans commentary from Beacon Hill).  Certainly there are scholarly commentaries that dialog with recent developments in Pauline studies (e.g., Robert Jewett's Romans commentary in the Hermeneia series, probably the current gold standard).  And there have always been Wesleyan interpretations of Romans.

What I don't think exists are Wesleyan treatments of Paul that fully take into account the immense changes in Pauline studies in the last thirty years.  I suspect the first five chapters of this book on Romans will be astoundingly eye-opening to a Wesleyan audience that just has no idea.  If I had the resources, I would put a copy in the hands of every Wesleyan pastor.

The last five chapters look at the most disputed writings of Paul (Colossians, Ephesians, 2 Thessalonians, and the Pastorals).  Here I don't think I have dodged any of the landmines, although I leave it up to the reader to decide what they think on issues like pseudonymity.  What I have not done is wished the issues away.  There is just no getting around the fact that the Pastorals and Ephesians are significantly unlike Paul's central writings in many respects.  If we are actually interested in listening to what they have to say, we have to take the differences into account, whether we think Paul has changed his mind or his secretary or whether we think these documents were written to convey Paul's voice to a generation some time after his death.

Now the able hands of Kevin Scott at Wesleyan Publishing House will take off the rough edges ;-)  Thanks to all the great help there and for all the sharpening those of you in blogland have brought to the writing as well.

Sunday, January 02, 2011

Ten Most Impactful Teachers...

... on me.

This is not about personality but about moments or courses of impact.

1. Fifth grade: Mr. Guinn, Wilton Manors Elementary School
He shared with us at one point that he ran 5 miles a day.  At the time, I thought that was astounding.  It was part of the inspiration to be a runner (I thought of doing this while running a few minutes ago ;-).

2. Tenth through Twelfth: "Uncle Mel" Atkinson, Fort Lauderdale High School (FLHS)
I took Chem 1, 2, and 3 with him.  I did a search on him yesterday and see he died in 2009.  He was my favorite high school teacher.  He was a "populist" teacher, which means he took a lot of time to talk about life and take everyone along, not just the people interested in Chemistry like me.  I became a Chemistry major initially in college under his influence.

3. Eleventh and Twelfth: Phil Pickett, FLHS
I mentioned him in my post yesterday.  Had him for Trig/Analytic Geometry and Calculus.  Probably the best teacher I've ever had anywhere.

4. Twelfth: Larry Stock, FLHS
Had him for Humanities.  Man, the teachers at my high school were as good as any I ever had anywhere.  In two semesters we went from the Sumerians to the Impressionists.  We did art, architecture, philosophy, world history.  We read the Republic.

I remember him telling us about a couple of his former students who traveled Europe after high school who understood so much more from his class.  I experienced it too when I went off to England to do my doctorate.  He taught us what a "flying buttress" was ;-)

Died about three years ago, I think.  Some of my class who still live in Lauderdale went to the funeral.  Again, a lot of colleges couldn't match my high school, a public school, no less.  I don't have room to mention Mr. Hatley or Ms. McGuire or Mrs. Gaus or Mr. Packard...

5. College: Martin LaBar
I had other profs I was closer to in college, several who were very memorable and whom I still call friends (Bob Black was probably my favorite overall, but Drs. Schmutz, Bross, Sinnamon, Dongell, and Elliott were also memorable).  But the class that would eventually have the most impact on my thinking in college was a 1 hour integrative course where we read (or at least were supposed to ;-) Thomas Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.  Dr. LaBar was a genetics professor who is known to lurk in these blog parts.  I didn't have him for any other course, but this book is surely one of the top ten books to read to reach enlightenment.

6. Seminary: Bob Lyon, Asbury Seminary
Dr. Lyon has passed now.  I learned Textual Criticism from him and his article on baptism in the New Testament taught me an attempt at objectivity in handling evidence I had known in science but not in religion.  Dr. Lyon was not perfect, but he was brilliant and led the "LO Society," "Loyal Opposition" to the generic stream of mindless conformity that so often typifies the status quo.

7. Seminary: David Bauer
Asbury truly taught me how to aim at objectivity in biblical scholarship.  I learned IBS, baby, Traina style.  Dr. Bauer is truly a scientist of inductive Bible study.  By the way, Lawson Stone was also awesome, just out of Yale at the time.  He was enthusiastic and creative, exactly the kind of person you picture when you picture a genius.

8. University of Kentucky: Lewis Swift
He wouldn't know me from Adam.  The dog-gone guy was Dean of UK and adjuncting a class in Virgil's Aeneid in Latin.  The guy was wicked smart and dropped French and Latin phrases into his everyday speech without thinking.  He wasn't putting on airs.  He really thought like that.  Other great professors there: Jane Phillips, Robert Rabel, Hubert Martin.

9. Durham: James D. G. Dunn
Truth be known, Dr. Lyon's piece on baptism is little more than Dunn's Baptism in the Spirit, a book that like all of Jimmy's books is a model of objectivity.  You may not like his recent, Did the First Christians Worship Jesus?, but you will scarcely find anyone else so willing to follow the evidence to what seems to him to be its logical conclusion as Dunn.

10. Durham: Loren Stuckenbruck
He's now chair of the Biblical Studies department at Princeton Seminary.  One of the smartest people I have ever met.  No one need ever worry about me thinking I'm smart.  I'm a complete moron compared to people like Loren.  I have seen genius and it is not I.

I should give honorable mention to David Bundy who, rumor had it, learned Dutch one weekend in Amsterdam.  He wasn't at Durham but was a master linguist like Loren.  Bundy was librarian at Asbury when I was there.  I did an independent study with him in Aquinas at Asbury.  He's currently librarian at Fuller.

How's that?  I wish anyone out there at any stage of their education the chance to study with minds like these!

Saturday, January 01, 2011

FLHS: Mr. Pickett understood

I had an incredible high school AP math teacher my junior and senior year, Mr. Pickett at Fort Lauderdale High School (FLHS).  My class (1984) by the way was great.  They still get together in Ft. Lauderdale during the holidays.  In fact all the classes before and after me were great.  They were the stuff of what we picture high school to be at its best.  At least I thought so.

And now to the obscure you could only expect of me ;-)  I had Mr. Pickett for Calculus my senior year.  He was, by the way, even better than my college calculus teacher.  He was so good for me that I can still remember things he said, and I don't remember anything from real life. ;-)

I remember him talking about the "epsilon-delta" confusion in the first weeks of calculus.  He told us not to worry about it.  He said the only person he knew who claimed to understand it was a fellow student of his at Florida State, who occasionally would fall down the stairs because he wasn't paying attention to where he was going.  He said they would yell, "Are you okay, x?" And he would yell back, "Yeah."

I took that as a challenge.  I would eventually look at this epsilon-delta confusion.  I would understand it.  And I did when I was in college.  It isn't actually that big of a deal.  It's mathematicians dotting their i's and crossing t's in a way that seems complicated--much ado about nothing for the rest of us.

The point is that Mr. Pickett understood.  I know he did.  He just knew it was completely unnecessary for us to know.  It would have blown almost everyone's circuit breakers over something completely unimportant unless you're going to be a math professor.

So here's to Mr. Pickett, wherever you are.  He moved back to South Carolina the year or so after I graduated, much to the loss of FLHS.

P.S. Yes, I remain a nerd on my own time. ;-)

New Year's Resolutions

Happy New Year!

I glanced back at the resolutions I published last year and, typical, I didn't do so well.  One of them I take up again--to finish plowing through Josephus.

I want to make some different kinds of goals this year.  First, not to get so freakishly behind as I have been these last six months.  I've been unbelievably late on everything and unable to catch up on anything.  In the next week I will at long last finish off several albatrosses around my neck and around those who have waited on me.

So going forward:
1. I'm getting old.  I shouldn't plan to write more than 6 pages a week of anything, tops.  That means not taking on any more writing assignments till I've finished my current plate and then only moving forward slowly.  By the end of the year, I would like to have finished another scholarly book, or be close.  Thus far I really only have one book that falls in that category, Cosmology and Eschatology in Hebrews.

2. I should read at least 30 pages a week of something a bit more scholarly.

That's about all I'm sharing.  Anyone else have resolutions?

Friday, December 31, 2010

1 Timothy and Law

1 Timothy focuses on a different part of the Jewish Law than Romans and Galatians do.  The focus of the Law Romans and Galatians is on “works of Law,” the things that most distinguished Jew from Gentile ethnically (e.g., Gal. 2:16).  In Paul’s central writings, the Law pertains to the former age—it is something to which believers die when they die with Christ (e.g., Gal. 2:19).  Believers are thus no longer “under Law” (1 Cor. 9:20), even though they now fulfill the “righteous requirements of the law” (Rom. 8:4).

By contrast, the focus of “law” in 1 Timothy is not on its “past-ness,” as in Paul’s central writings.  The law in 1 Timothy is the common moral standard for all people—basically the Ten Commandments.  It is still in force, but because Christians keep this standard, it is not something Christians need to think much about.  “[T]he law is not made for the righteous but for lawbreakers and rebels” (1 Tim. 1:9).  The list that follows roughly corresponds to the Ten Commandments.

It is for the “ungodly and sinful,” those who have other gods before God.  It is for the “unholy and irreligious,” those who would take God’s name in vain.  It is for “those who kill their fathers and mothers,” who do not honor their father and mother.  It is for murderers.  It is for the sexually immoral and men who practice homosexuality (1:10, ESV), sexual prohibitions related to the heading of adultery.  Finally, slave traders, liars, and perjurers relate to the commands not to bear false witness or to covet.

Unlike Paul’s central writings, 1 Timothy thus focuses on the law as basic and universal moral standard, something Christians do not need worry about because they already keep these requirements.  Those who need worry about the law are thus criminals and lawbreakers.  This is quite a strikingly different way of talking about the law than we find in Romans and Galatians, where the Law retains a strongly Jewish flavor and is relegated to the age before Christ.

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Christian Schools and Churches

One of the Wesleyan churches in Marion has a school associated with it.  Until recently, it had a middle and high school, but because of the recent financial crisis, it bit the bullet and limited itself to pre-K through 5.  Now it looks perhaps to rebuild.

I am not wise in the way of such things, but their situation does raise all kinds of questions that churches around America and in other places might profitably ask.  For example, to what extent do Christian schools sometimes become albatrosses around a church's neck, to where the school becomes the ministry to their communities?  In other words, they have to expend so much energy and resources keeping a school going that they can hardly do anything else.  It reminds me a little of the situation many districts have faced with camp meetings that serve a very small niche minority but require massive amounts of the district's resources.  Hard to get out of the business once you're in it.

At the same time, the public school situation here in Marion is quite challenging, to say the least.  It's not the teachers, despite the rhetoric we hear from state and national officials.  The children are just out of control because of their home issues past and present, and the system has pruned back the kind of staff that used to handle these things (e.g., doing away with "time away" and making the teachers deal with it, with whatever social worker and office staff is available in a never ending day moving from crisis to crisis).  The good teacher is the person who manages to teach the teachable while managing the psycho distractions.  It's a bloody mess.

So there probably is a market in Marion for a good private school, and we have a couple.  The question mark is always whether your child is going to receive a "mainstream" education there.  The market for Christian schools is often what I might call "reactionary fundamentalist" of various kinds.  Are the kids going to learn mainstream history and science or will it look something more like what the school board in Texas has been about these days?  Are they going to learn English in the second grade by memorizing the five different sounds the phoneme "ra" can have, because of some bizarre sense that anything but an extreme phonics approach is that liberal whole language approach?  That's the sort of psycho-stuff that often fuels the founding of Christian schools in America, in my opinion.

One thing in today's newspaper is encouraging to me about the possible return of upper grades at the local Wesleyan Christian school.  There is talk about partnering with IWU.  I personally would have loved to see IWU have started a charter school a few years back when we bought the property of Center School.  What better way to give to the community and train teachers.  If the local church school could extensively use student teachers from IWU, that might be a win, win in some ways.

Of course, I could just be babbling nonsense about things I don't know.  Never done that before ;-)

Order in Society (Pastorals cont)

We find some miscellaneous teaching in 1 Timothy and Titus that also fits into the category of an orderly society. For example, along with the instruction about widows, 1 Timothy 5 also has instructions about how to treat older men and women. You are to treat older men in the church with respect, like you would treat your own father. As the church is your family, you should treat younger men like brothers, older women like your mother, and younger women like your sisters (5:1-2). By extension, you should take care of widows with no one else to care for them.

However, if the widow has children or grandchildren, they are primarily responsible (5:4). 1 Timothy 5:8 is a key expression of family values in the first century: “If anyone does not provide for his relatives, and especially for his immediate family, he has denied the faith and is worse than an unbeliever.” While such strong words sound rather extreme to our modern ears, the principle of taking care of our own and those within our reach remains strong even today.  In keeping with this saying, those of us in the Wesleyan tradition could see a person’s intentional neglect of family going to such an extreme that it could lead to loss of faith.  For most of us, it is an apt reminder of our responsibility to help those we can, especially those who most depend on us.

Titus has similar instructions, except they are directed at these individuals.  Older men are to be “temperate, worthy of respect, self-controlled, and sound in faith, in love and in endurance” (Tit. 2:2).  Older women are “to be reverent in the way they live, not to be slanderers or addicted to much wine, but to teach what is good” (2:3).  They are to train the younger women to “to love their husbands and children, to be self-controlled and pure, to be busy at home, to be kind, and to be subject to their husbands” (2:4-5).  Again, we have argued that it is not the specific structures of ancient society that apply to us today as Scripture but the principle of living at peace with each other in a manner most appropriate to our cultural and social contexts.  We are to work out the best ways to “love our neighbor” in our social context.

Young men are to be self controlled (2:6).  Titus 2:8 gives the bottom line of all this social instruction, very similar to 1 Peter 2:12.  The goal is “that those who oppose you may be ashamed because they have nothing bad to say about us.”  This underlying principle makes it clear that the specifics of the instructions here have everything to do with the shared social values of the first century Mediterranean world.  To apply them directly to today in every respect thus has the ironic consequence of bringing the opposite effect.  If we artificially put women in a particular social location, rather than giving them fully equal opportunities to men, we give the world a great deal bad to say about us.  Indeed, we create a situation where the world’s values are more Christian than ours!

1 Timothy and Titus also have teaching on slaves.  Slaves are to be subject to their masters (Tit. 2:9), just as wives are to be subject to their husbands.  They are to try to please them and not talk back to them or steal from them (2:9-10).  They are to be fully trustworthy.  Again there is the same goal as with family relationships—to make Christ look attractive to the world (2:10).  They should treat them with full respect so that God’s name is not slandered (1 Tim. 6:1). Slaves with believing masters are to treat them even better than they would unbelieving masters (6:2).

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

Women in 1 Timothy, Closing Remarks (W)

If you ever go to modern Israel, you will find some interesting practices in relation to the Old Testament Law.  One fascinating one is the fact that you cannot get both meat and dairy products with the same meal or in the same store in Israel.  I once saw a young man ushered right out of a restaurant that primarily served lamb meat because he had brought in pizza from across the alley.  Pizza has cheese and was not allowed in the same shop.  Why, you ask?  It is because of a verse in Exodus that forbids boiling a goat’s kid in its mother’s milk (23:19; 34:26).

Now whatever this verse was originally about—probably against some Canaanite practice—it was not about eating pizza and lamb meat in the same meal.  It highlights the fact again that the books of the Bible just were not written to us originally.  When passages seem to make the least sense to us, we are often looking at words that spoke directly to the time they were written but not so clearly to our time and context.

I am convinced that the teaching of 1 Timothy on women falls into this category of things locked up in the past, despite the fact that many segments of the church are comfortable with its instructions.  For example, most Christians today would be hard pressed to think of why it would be preferable for a widow not to remarry or why she would need to get remarried because of an inability to refrain from her sexual desires.  We assume these instructions made perfect sense in their first century context, but it is not at all clear they do now.

And most Protestant churches have not seen any virtue in a man needing to be married only once to be an effective leader, especially if his first wife died.  True, the Orthodox Church still holds to this requirement, and many Protestants still have problems with a minister who is divorced.  But it is not clear what intrinsic reason we could come up with today that would make much sense.  Why would a widowed minister who remarries be less wise or less effective than one who remained single?

The position of many segments of the church today on women, both women ministers and women in the home, also strikes of the Jewish rule against eating pizza and meat in the same meal.  I like to think of it this way.  Let us say we are on a plane whose pilot is incapacitated, and we have a choice between having a woman take over who actually knows how to fly a plane or having a man take over who has no knowledge of flying whatsoever.  Of course we would have the woman fly the plane, because she is the most competent to do so.

In our current context, insisting that a man be the senior pastor or the head of the home simply because of his genitals makes about as much sense.  Let us speak plainly.  This is plain irrationality.  It makes a mockery of the idea that God is all-wise and omniscient.  It makes a mockery of God and Christ before the world.

And what is worse, this headship for its own sake, this genital-based leadership—not a theory you will find in any book on leadership, mind you—is headed in the opposite direction of the kingdom.  It is, in the words of Colossians, to submit to the “elemental spirits of the world” (Col. 2:20) rather than see the trajectory of the kingdom, where wives are not given to men in marriage (Mark 12:25) and there is not “male and female” any longer (Gal. 3:28).  It is to approach blasphemy, as if Christ only died for some sins but not all, not the sins of Eve.  Indeed, we can tell we are in the age of the Spirit precisely because our sons and daughters prophesy (Acts 2:17).

We have shown in these two volumes that no Scripture, rightly interpreted, prohibits women from any level of leadership and ministry in the church, indeed, that we find such women in the New Testament.  Let us be clear on this score.  Paul did not see husband-headship in conflict with the prophetic ministry of a woman, which 1 Corinthians 11 proves. And, therefore, the silence of women in 1 Corinthians 14:34-35, if these verses are even original, cannot be about spiritual speech but only about disruptive speech. 

Now we see that 1 Timothy 2:12 is also about the husband-wife relationship and thus does not have any bearing on a woman’s prophetic ministry.  And in any case, surely Paul’s central writings and Acts have a better claim to stand at the center of our understanding, rather than some interpretation of a writing that is in so many ways the exception in the Pauline corpus rather than the rule.  All we have left to debate is whether husband-headship is timeless or, like eating pizza with meat, is a feature of Paul’s ancient context.  Since it is irrational to base leadership on genitals—physical organs not particularly known for their wisdom—I have little doubt personally where God is leading his church today.

Ministers as Parents (W)

Excerpt from chapter 9 of second Paul book:
____________
1 Timothy and Titus’ comments on the children of ministers may be a cause of particular concern to some.  Pastors’ children are notorious in church lore for misbehavior.  What then are we to make of the comment that an overseer can scarcely be trusted with the church if he cannot control his own children or if his children lose faith?  No doubt such sentiments have brought violence from some ministers in the past, thinking that they must beat their children into submission to keep their children under control.  And parenting studies will no doubt confirm that this approach leads in exactly the opposite direction today, to where their children will then be even more likely to be disorderly and to lose faith.

In short, what counted as good management of a family in the ancient world will not count the same today.  Our children are not sequestered in the home.  Through television, through the internet, through the public schools, it is scarcely possible to control all the influences on our children.  This fact has led some to forbid television.  It has led some to isolate themselves socially from the rest of the world.  Such people can perhaps protect their children for a time, but they also have removed themselves from the mission.  Few will come to faith in Christ as a result of their witness.

In the end, our children have free will too.  What is timeless about the instructions of 1 Timothy is that the pastor should be an exemplary model of righteousness for his or her children.  Their children should see that their mother or father is consistent at home and at church.  They should see that their father or mother practices what he or she preaches.  They should see that their parent truly is serving and selfless at home and at church.  They must be present at home and in the lives of their kids, not married more to the church than to their spouses and families.  None of these things is a guarantee of a child’s salvation, but they should be a guarantee of a clear conscience.

Education is Broken

I am more and more convinced that the American system of education is ludicrously wasteful.  It is designed for a small number of students gifted in a particular way, with a particular learning style.  It is designed for the cultural leader, the future scientist, the researcher, just as the liberal arts college is.  But this is a small percentage of the population.  What is worse is that it often doesn't even give these individuals the best they could get and, because of the drain from the vast majority who are just in the wrong system, it fails to serve even these well.

I'll say it again.  The vast majority of American students need to be prepared to get a job and be healthy contributors to society.  Sure, they need to be able to read and write, but even a minimally effective elementary school system can give them everything they need in general for that.  Beyond that they need 1) to know how to be good members of society in general and 2) to know a skill that will get them a job. Accordingly, the vast majority of high school is a waste of time, except that it gets them off the streets.

Where to begin, where to begin?  I have little confidence at this time in any top down correction.  I think it should best start local, with the government validating, supporting, and then getting out of the way.  Here's my suggestion.  Local businesses should coordinate with local high schools and city administration to create career tracks in high school. The high school would offer courses that equip students for those jobs and those employers would provide internships, job placement, and would be involved in the high school curriculum.

I'm not limiting things to blue collar jobs.  More advanced employers could continue this track through local colleges and work with them as well.  Ball State has a program where a student's last two years of high school are done on campus, doubling for the first two years of college.  Given the waste of time that is most high school senior years, this is a great idea.

Newton had made most of his major discoveries before he was 22.  We're wasting our brightest kids' time.

Monday, December 27, 2010

Constructing Jesus 2 (S)

The first post in this review:
Chapter 1: Memories of Jesus

Chapter 2, "The Eschatology of Jesus" is about 190 pages.  At my pace, it will take me over a month to get through it..  And I have some other things I need to fit in.  So here are the next thirty pages or so, pp.31-59.

The basic point of these pages, as of the chapter as a whole, is that "Jesus held what we may call... an 'apocalyptic eschatology'" (32).  By this he means a cluster of themes from post-exilic Jewish literature relating to coming crisis between good and evil in which things on the earth will get very bad but God will come at set everything right.  Allison does not believe that such expectation was usually if ever about the distant future but was by assumption a near expectation.  "The rule in the ancient sources is this: if it is coming, it must be close" (45).

Pages 33-43 are what seems to be a typical sort of list for Allison.  He catalogs point after point of apocalyptic expectation in the gospels.  Allison's point is very commonsensical and persuasive.  It doesn't matter whether any one of these events or sayings was historical for the general impression to be true.  "[M]ore material pertains to eschatology than to exorcism" (43).  I perceive a global pattern and it is apocalyptic" (44).  "[O]ur choice is not between an apocalyptic Jesus; it is between an apocalyptic Jesus and no Jesus at all... The pertinent material is sufficiently abundant that removing it all should leave one thoroughly skeptical about the mnemonic competence of the tradition" (46-47).

He then begins a list of nine supportive considerations, two of which were part of my reading this week.

1. Jesus' location between John the Baptist and the early church.
This is again such a no brainer it amazes me that anyone seriously questions it.  You find it in Sanders, Wright, earlier in Meyer.  If John the Baptist preached the imminent coming of God's kingdom and if the early church did, then Jesus must have.

2. "God raised him from the dead."
Again, Allison makes imminent sense.  Paul knew Peter and James.  They all claimed to believe Jesus had risen bodily from the dead.  Therefore, "that settles the issue" (55).  He of course is not saying that all the initial followers of Jesus believed this.  He is only saying that these individuals must have.

Further, if they had not believed in resurrection prior to the Jesus event, they would not have interpreted it in this way.  "[T]he disciples looked for the resurrection of the dead before Good Friday; otherwise they would have interpreted their experiences in some other way" (59).

Sunday, December 26, 2010

Elders in the Early Church (W)

The W means Wesleyan, which means that in this post I am writing for the church rather than for scholars.
___________
The instructions about church leadership focus on two roles: the overseer and the deacon. Some have argued that the clarity of these two positions speaks to a period later than Paul, but it would be hard to prove it. We find Paul speaking of these two offices in letters everyone agrees he wrote, like Philippians (cf. 1:1). If 1 Timothy is earlier, the overseer here is probably one of several overseers or elders in a local Christian assembly, not a solo pastor or senior pastor like we have today. On the other hand, if 1 Timothy is later, the word increasingly came to mean something more like our word “bishop,” the head leader of the Christians perhaps in a whole city. [1] The role does not seem this extensive yet in the Pastorals.

In the New Testament, we do not find clear reason to think that the word “overseer” (episkopos) yet meant anything substantially different from the word “elder” (presbyteros). Titus 1:6-7 glides seamlessly from one term to the other with no distinction, clearly considering both words to mean the same thing. In 1 Peter 5:1-2, Peter is called a “fellow elder,” and “elders” (presbyteros) are charged to “pastor” or “shepherd” the flock. Although it very well may not have been in the original copy of 1 Peter, these same elders are charged to “oversee” (episkopeō) this flock. The implication is that at least some early Christians must have seen the function of the elders of a local assembly as overseeing that local assembly.

We thus suspect that each local assembly in the early church had multiple elders and overseers. The word “elder” probably had a literal sense that such individuals were in fact older. [2] The ancient world, as most cultures outside the Western world, associated age with wisdom. Was there a senior leader? It is hard to imagine that there was not. [3] But these individuals probably were not like pastors today whose only job is to pastor the church, and we can imagine that this function could even have rotated from time to time. We can imagine that leadership in part emerged organically as those who were gifted to lead rose to the surface. Acts 14:23 also pictures Paul and Barnabas appointing elders in cities, and it is very easy to see them laying the mantle of leadership on specific individuals as they moved from one location to another.

However, we also should not underestimate the role of itinerant and prophetic leadership in the early church. Apostles like Paul moved around from place to place and while it is clear a place like Corinth felt free to question his authority, he saw himself as a superior authority to any local elder or overseer. The letter of recommendation Paul gave to Phoebe as a deacon in Romans 16:1 probably is only one instance of many such letters as itinerant teachers moved from one place to another. Indeed, we will argue in the next chapter that one aspect of the situation behind the Pastorals is the increasing sense that such travelling teachers were corrupting the church with false teaching.

Prophecy was also a key element of the earliest church. As we saw in chapter 7, Ephesians even considers these early prophets to be part of the foundation of the church, along with the apostles. We argued there that very prominent prophets were in mind, individuals like Agabas in Acts 11 and 20. But local churches had prophets as well, both men and women, as we saw in 1 Corinthians.

Were there women apostles, elders, and overseers? We argued back in chapter 5 that Phoebe was a deacon (Rom. 16:1) and Junia was an apostle (Rom. 16:7). As for overseers and elders, we do not have the name of a single elder or overseer in the New Testament, which includes both men and women. [4] So we will fill in the silence with our general sense of things. On the one hand, given the patriarchal nature of ancient culture, we would expect elders and overseers primarily to be male. Yet it was also the nature of such cultures to make exceptions when a particularly gifted (or they might have thought “deviant”) woman came along.

For example, there is no question that the majority of military leaders in Israel were men. But there was always a place for the exceptional woman like Deborah, who was such an outstanding leader of soldiers that Barak refused to go to battle without her (cf. Judg. 4:8). Judges sees her identity as a prophetess (4:4) flowing neatly into her role as a “general” over men, a clear sign that the distinction some make today between spiritual and administrative leadership is a modern construct completely foreign to the biblical text. The situation in the formative stages of the New Testament church was probably the same. The bulk of elders, overseers, and deacons were likely men. But when a Priscilla came along (Rom. 16:3), you recognized God’s Spirit on her and, if she was old enough, included her as an elder, probably even before including her husband Aquila.

So it is not surprising that 1 Timothy 3 seems to assume that both overseers and deacons will be male, although it nowhere says that women cannot take these roles. When Paul told the “brothers” at Thessalonica to respect those who work among them, was he excluding the “sisters” in the assembly (1 Thess. 5:12)? Surely not. In the same way, the assumption in 1 Timothy 3 that overseers and deacons are male says nothing in itself about whether a woman might also be an overseer or a deacon.

We would argue that 1 Timothy 3 should be interpreted in the following way on this issue. If Paul is its author, we do see in them the general assumption that overseers and deacons will be male, but we will see this assumption much as we see Paul's instructions to "brothers"--the "sisters" were also included even if not named explicitly. Given what we know of Paul’s ministry from his other writings and Acts, we should assume that women also played these roles in his churches. On the other hand, if 1 Timothy was written several decades after Paul’s death, we might infer that the structure of church leadership had become somewhat more regularized and that fewer women took these roles. Even then, however, we have evidence from the first few centuries of the church that women still took these roles from time to time, so even in this case it is not an absolute assumption, only a general one.


[1] The word appears to have moved in this direction by the time Ignatius of Antioch wrote his famous seven letters ca. AD110.

[2] Interestingly, Timothy is young in 1 Timothy (cf. 4:12), too young perhaps to be an elder. 1 Timothy 4:6 actually uses the word “deacon” of him, although most translations are perhaps correct to translate the word in this instance as “servant.” Nevertheless, given that 1 Timothy gives instructions about deacons, it is intriguing to think of Paul addressing Timothy as a deacon.

[3] My discussion here may be frustrating to those who like to idealize the early church, as if there was a single structure, a single pattern of leadership, a single God-ordained way of doing things that provides an easy model for us to follow. But the fact of the matter is, human relationships are complicated and emerge from the specific dynamics not only of culture but of the specific personalities involved. The Bible does not provide us with the easy answers simple minds seek. God expects us to do some thinking here too. The simple answers on these sorts of things are usually the wrong ones.

[4] Although he does not identify his own name, it is perhaps reasonable to assume that "the elder" of 2 and 3 John is "John the elder."

Saturday, December 25, 2010

Merry Christmas All!

Merry Christmas to anyone milling around the web today!

What I most appreciate about Christmas is not the great significance the day has for us today in retrospect--typified by angelic hosts, rich Magi and jealous kings.  What I appreciate the most is the insignificance of the original day, the sense that God visited little nowhere places like Bethlehem and Nazareth, under the cloud of scandal to a woman who was not married, noticed primarily by shepherd outcasts who happened to be nearby.

Who is there in any place that God does not care about?

Thursday, December 23, 2010

Two paragraphs on 1 Timothy 2:12

From chapter 9 of my second Paul volume:
__________
However, I also believe that the popular interpretation of this verse is also slightly mistaken. Its most popular use is to argue against women in ministry—at least women ministering to adult men or taking senior leadership in a church. But the words for “woman” (gynē) and “man” (anēr) here can also mean “wife” and “husband.” In fact, they usually do have this meaning when the two words are used in close proximity. Given the general assumption of 1 Timothy that women need to be married (because a single woman is prone to be a gossip and a busybody—5:13), this verse surely assumes that the woman in question is married. Also, the Adam/Eve relationship and the significance of childbearing are an intrinsic part of the argument that follows (2:13-15). So a much more accurate translation would be, “A wife should learn quietly with complete submission. I don’t allow a wife to teach or to control her husband. Instead, she should be a quiet listener” (CEB).

What we have in these verses is thus not an argument against women in ministry, but a reiteration of the need for the woman to submit to the authority of her husband, as in the household codes of Ephesians 5:22 and Colossians 3:18. Since in 1 Corinthians 11 Paul sees no contradiction whatsoever between husband headship and women participating fully in the prophetic life of the church, 1 Timothy 2:12 does not address the issue of women in ministry at all. It addresses the apparent need for social order within the early church in relation to husbands and wives, particularly in the worship setting. We can imagine that house churches created interesting social conflicts in the relationships between women and men, since women normally directed the private activities of the home. [1] But Christian worship made the private domain of the home a public domain of worship, and we can perceive Paul’s writings wrestling with the kinds of tensions this situation created.

[1] It is not exactly accurate to say that men were the head of the home in the ancient world. They were generally the head of the household, but in general, women directed the activities of the private home and men conducted public activities outside the home. Cf. the picture of the virtuous wife in Proverbs 31.

CEB gets it right! (1 Timothy 2:11-12)

I continue to enjoy the Common English Bible's translation choices.  Why do the same old thing every other translation does, not to mention that I generally agree with it.

Here is 1 Timothy 2:11-12:

"A wife should learn quietly with complete submission. I don’t allow a wife to teach or to control her husband. Instead, she should be a quiet listener. Adam was formed first, and then Eve."

I disagree with where it goes from there, trying to gloss over what is just a very difficult passage.  I would translate the remaining verses as:

"And Adam was not deceived, but the wife, having been deceived, has come to be in a state of transgression, but she will be saved through childbearing, if they remain in faith and love and holiness with modesty."

The CEB has, "Adam wasn’t deceived, but rather his wife became the one who stepped over the line because she was completely deceived. But a wife will be brought safely through giving birth to their children, if they both continue in faith, love, and holiness, together with self-control."

Paul die at end of Acts?

The argument for Paul’s death at the end of Acts is two-fold. First, it is very likely that Luke-Acts was written after Paul’s death and, thus, that the author of Luke-Acts knew the outcome of Paul’s trial before Nero. For example, the overwhelming majority of experts on the gospels would say that the Gospel of Luke used some form of the Gospel of Mark as a primary source. Since they also date Mark to the late 60s or early 70s of the first century, Luke would have to be written later, which places it several years after Paul’s death.

However, the real clincher for a post-70AD date for Luke-Acts is in the way Luke 21:20 clarifies Jesus’ prophecy in Mark 13:14. Both Mark 13:14 and Matthew 24:15 have the ambiguous prediction of an “abomination that causes desolation” standing where it should not be standing, namely “in the holy place,” the temple (Matt. 24:15). Accordingly, we are a little surprised when we find Luke 21:20 speak of “Jerusalem surrounded by armies” and its desolation. Given where this statement comes in the prophecy and the fact that Luke is using Mark as a source, we can tell that this is Luke’s interpretation of the prophecy. After all, if Jesus said it this way instead of the way it is in Mark, why are Matthew and Mark so ambiguous? They almost seem to be saying different things!

By far the most likely explanation is that Luke has clarified the meaning of the Jesus prophecy because he already knows what the prophecy was referring to, because he is writing after it has happened. He has “translated” the prophecy dynamically, like The Message paraphrases the Bible in conversational English. Jewish translations we have from the time—including the New Testament itself—show that translators regularly rendered the Bible with this sort of freedom to paraphrase. And so it is overwhelmingly likely that Luke was written after Jerusalem’s destruction in AD70, and thus several years after Paul’s death.

So, secondly, if the author of Acts knows how Paul died, we have to take very seriously the way he foreshadows doom for Paul in the last chapters of the book.  Particularly striking are some of Paul’s final words to the Ephesians in Acts 20:25: “Now I know that none of you among whom I have gone about preaching the kingdom will ever see me again” (NIV). If this statement is true—and surely the author of Acts would not have included it if it was not—then the popular evangelical reconstruction of a fourth missionary journey cannot be correct. For example, Paul would not have revisited Ephesus again to account for him leaving Timothy there as in 1 Timothy 1:3. Nor would it be likely that he had gone on from there to visit Colossae.

This sense of foreboding continues when Paul lands in Palestine. The prophet Agabas comes to Paul, ties his hands up with Paul’s belt, and predicts that “In this way the Jews of Jerusalem will bind the owner of this belt and will hand him over to the Gentiles” (Acts 21:11). Then the people there plead with Paul not to go to Jerusalem. They weep and break Paul’s heart, and Paul signals his willingness to die in Jerusalem (21:13). This build-up seems overly melodramatic if it is only foreshadowing imprisonment, when Paul has been imprisoned before. Acts thus seems once again to foreshadow Paul’s destiny when Herod Agrippa II tells the Roman governor Festus in effect that it is a pity Paul appealed to Caesar: “This man could have been set free if he had not appealed to Caesar” (26:32). The possibility of death is again mentioned explicitly (26:31).

So if the author of Acts knew the outcome of Paul’s trial and implies it was negative, then it seems very likely that the outcome of Paul’s trial was negative. The question we then might hear is why Acts does not then tell us. The assumption is that if the author had known the outcome of the trial, he would have told us. But of course Acts was not written for us, and it is quite likely that the original audience did know the outcome of Paul’s trail. It was thus not necessary for Acts to say. Perhaps the author thought it would end Acts on a negative note, particularly when a consistent theme in Acts is to show that Christians had fairly smooth relationships with Roman officials.

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

Philo Cheat Sheet

I recently reviewed Adam Kamesar's (ed), The Cambridge Companion to Philo for the American Journal of Philology.  It occurred to me that I could create a (more or less) one page "cheat sheet" on Philo that really would go a very long way.  Here's my first draft:
_________

  • Prominent Jew of Alexandria, Egypt, ca. 20BCE-50CE.  More Jews lived in 2 of the 5 quarters of Alexandria than in all of Jerusalem.
  • Alexandria had a very significant synagogue and the city had a history of a mixture of philosophy with biblical interpretation that preceded Philo by centuries (e.g., Aristobulus, 2nd century BCE).  Eudorus of Alexandria (not Jewish) may be the fountainhead of "Middle Platonism," the transition from earlier Platonism/Stocisim to Neoplatonism.
  • Very wealthy family, brother Alexander was chief customs official for Egypt (alabarch), nephew Tiberius Julius Alexander apostacized from Judaism and was procurator of Judea from 46-48.  Philo likely had a Greek gymnasium education.
  • Philo himself protests that he did not like having to engage in politics, but perhaps he protests too much.  It was Philo that led a delegation to Rome for the Jews of Alexandria after the crisis of 38CE.  This trouble is sometimes called a "pogrom" in which some Jews were killed, their property was plundered, and they were quasi-ghettoized to escape the violence.  It seems precipitated by a trip from Herod Agrippa I to the city that created ethnic tensions.
  • The outcome of the crisis was that Jews by and large were not considered citizens of the city, as attested by a copy of Claudius' decision.  They had at least liked to consider themselves such before.  The Romans added an extra top layer on the previous social stratification when they took over the city.  Previously Greeks had been upper class with Egyptians and Jews vying for second place.
  • Philo did not know Hebrew.  The Hebrew knowledge he seems to have probably came from cheat sheets of the day.
  • Philo valued the Jerusalem temple as a Jew and Jewish customs, although he considered their literal value far inferior to their allegorical significance.
  • Philo had little place in his writings for a Jewish Messiah, although there are a couple potential allusions.
  • Philo had no place for bodily resurrection in his thought.  Indeed, only the most virtuous had a meaningful destiny among the stars (heavenly beings).  Angels are also disembodied spirits.
  • Philo dabbled in philosophy, but he is more than anything else an interpreter of the Jewish Scriptures, and he mixes together various philosophical threads depending on the passage he is interpreting.
  • Only 48 of Philo's writings have survived.  We know of some that are missing.  They were largely preserved by Christians, ignored by Jews (perhaps because they were in Greek, in part; perhaps because Christians liked them, in part).  Origen took them to Caesarea around 200CE and they were preserved there.
  • Philo wrote 3 great commentary series with increasing level of demand and expertise: The Exposition on the Law is most basic, Questions and Answers on Genesis and Exodus serve to teach a beginning Jewish audience, and The Allegorical Commentary is most esoteric and allegorically demanding.
  • The rest are usually grouped into "apologetic/historical writings" and "philosophical writings."  The best books to start reading in Philo's corpus are his writings Against Flaccus, The Embassy to Gaius, and his two book Life of Moses.  To transition to his more advanced works, On the Creation of the World is interesting.  Students of the New Testament may find his surviving books On Dreams and Who is the Heir of All Things interesting.
  • Philo's canon is largely limited to the Torah, perhaps an artifact of when Jews first moved to Egypt.  He has nice words to say about Jeremiah in a second category.
  • Philo is somewhat unique in that he believed Scripture could have both a literal and an allegorical meaning (vs. Stoics).  As others, he often shifted to allegory when the literal seemed impossible to him ("defect of the letter").  The allegorical often related to the literal as the body to the shadow (cf. Col. 2:17; Heb. 8:5).
  • Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob were allegories for moral progress (prokopton).  Abraham is the person who learns virtue by being taught. Jacob learns virtue through practice.  Isaac does not need to learn because he is self-taught.
  • Adam, Eve, and the serpent constitute an "allegory of the soul," where Adam represents the mind arbitrating between our senses (Eve) and pleasure (serpent).  Philo accepts on a practical level the Aristotelian goal of moderation of passion (metriopathea) but prefers the Stoic complete removal of them (apatheia).
  • The logos for Philo is a mixture of Platonism and Stoicism.  When he speaks of it (Middle) Platonically, it is the copy of God as pattern (the "image of God"), while the world is the copy of the logos as pattern.  When he speaks of it Stoically, it is a fragment/seed of the divine in all of us.  
  • The Adam of Genesis one is thus the ideal pattern of humanity (neither male nor female) while the man of Genesis 2 is the shadowy, physical copy.
  • The logos is the instrument God used in creation, the collection of ideas God used in making the world.  It is the glue that holds all things together.  The parallels to John 1 and Colossians 1 are clear.
  • The logos was a "second God."  It was created but not created like the rest of creation.  It is intermediary, a quasi-hypostasis.  Philo also interpreted the words Yahweh and Elohim as powers of God, namely, his royal and creative powers respectively.
  • The goal of ethics for Philo is godliness, the progress of the soul (prokopton) embodied in Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob taken allegorically.  He disagreed thus with the Stoics, who saw the goal as coming to grips with who you are (oikeiosis).
  • Philo clearly had an impact on formative Christianity of the second through fifth centuries.  Whether his ideas had an impact on the New Testament, directly or indirectly, is debated.  Clearly there are a number of parallels, among which Hebrews is regularly mentioned.
  • It is often suggested that Philo does know of some interpretive traditions in Palestine that would flow into the rabbinic tradition of the following centuries.  In general, however, the rabbis do not engage his thought much at all.
There you have it, in 30 minutes ;-)

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Constructing Jesus 1 (S)

I've wondered if I should code my posts occasionally, to help various people know which ones to skip ;-) For example, this one would get an S for Scholarship. That would mean I am dealing with material on a scholarly playing field, which has different rules from a church playing field.

W might then stand for Wesleyan, which would tell a potential reader that I am dealing with the particulars of my denomination, ordination, and place of employment.  The titles usually make my political and personal posts clear enough...

Anyway...
______________
One of my goals for the Advent to Easter period is to read through Dale Allison's final historical Jesus book, Constructing Jesus: Memory, Imagination, and History. I've never met Allison, but I like him. I like him because I sense he is someone who really tries to let the chips fall where they lie. He is friendly to faith but doesn't cook the books.

Last week I read the first chapter of his book, "Memories of Jesus." His first chapter has two basic points, as far as I can see: 1) "memory is fuzzy" (13) and 2) "We are rightly more confident about the generalities than about the particulars" (19). The rest of the chapter is details, clarifications, and objections.

Memory is Fuzzy
1. Long term memory is reconstructive (fills in missing elements), reproductive (accurate reproduction of material), and involves imagination.
2. Post-event information is often incorporated into memory.
3. Present biases often get read into earlier memories--our present selves read into our former selves.
4. Memories tend to become less and less distinct over time.
5. The order of how things happens gets moved around.
6. We create patterns out of our memories that serve our self-interests.
7. Groups rehearse memories that they hold dear.
8. Put into stories, memories take on a beginning, middle, and end.
9. Vivid memories are no more accurate than others.

Generalities
This is the most important contribution of the chapter. While so much historical Jesus scholarship has atomized the biblical texts and pursued the historicity of small sayings, Allison protests that it is rather the themes that appear repeatedly that are most reliable. For example, the gospels repeatedly present Jesus casting out demons and healing. These are some of the most likely reliable memories of Jesus of all (from a historian's standpoint) because they are general impressions that are pervasive.

Allison thus rejects the classic criteria of authenticity from the "New Quest for the Historical Jesus," which was oriented around arguing over each individual saying one by one.  Allison, by contrast, argues that we need not be able to prove beyond a reasonable historical doubt any one healing or exorcism story to affirm that Jesus was accurately remembered as healing and casting out demons.

He also clarifies and answers objections. For example, he is not saying we have to stop with generalities, only that generalities are the place to start. So Jesus was a teacher, beyond the likely historicity of any one bit of teaching.

Next chapter is very long: "The Eschatology of Jesus." I'll have to break it up into chunks.

Monday, December 20, 2010

Moon Turns to Blood Tonight...

... at about 2:45am EST.  See you outside only to realize that it is too cloudy for me to see the first winter solstice eclipse since 1638. ;-)

The Insanity of Prophecy Chasers

A paragraph from chapter 8 of my second Paul book:

"It is hard to know what to take from the specifics of 2 Thessalonians 2. However, the history of the interpretation of passages like this one is clear enough. Those who have connected contemporary events with the details of passages like this one have not only been consistently wrong; they have been wrong every single time to date as far as we can tell. A case in point was a little booklet called Eighty-Eight Reasons Why the Lord Is Coming Back in 1988. What a sobering thought! If I engage in prophetic speculation, the odds are astronomically against me being correct on pretty much everything. I am far more likely to win the lottery every week for the rest of my life than to be correct on any one detail of prophetic interpretation."

Wesleyan Vision

So where are we to go from here? Hopefully these last few pages have presented a fairly accurate sense of what the Wesleyan tradition is and has been in its some two hundred years. But as we have also argued, no tradition is perfect. Presumably there are denominations that have nothing distinctive to contribute who should merge with other groups with whom they have no significant differences. Perhaps their vision and contribution can become the unity of the church. We believe there are many small denominations in the Wesleyan tradition that have no real reason to exist independently of one another, perhaps aside from the complications of merging.

Nevertheless, we also believe that the Wesleyan tradition as a whole has much to contribute to the body of Christ at large and thus a reason for it to retain its fundamental identity amid the diversity of Christendom. Ironically, one of its contributions is its generous spirit toward other traditions. The problem with pluralism--an acceptance of all groups as equally valid in their thinking and practice--is that no group retains any real identity at all. A much more tenable position is identity within diversity. We humbly recognize that our understanding and approach to things will likely turn out to be wrong at points and we are open-hearted toward other traditions and their critique. But this attitude does not negate our sense that our theology and values are at the very least right for us and perhaps may be right at many points overall.

Nevertheless, a generous and humble sense of our place in the kingdom of God urges us to make alliances with other traditions. As we said at the very beginning, we have much more in common with the rest of Christendom than we differ. Certainly we would share with a vast host of Christianity a sense of mission to the world that goes beyond eternal destiny to salvation in the sense of Luke-Acts, the restoration of humanity on every level. Many Christian groups have lost their way on this fundamental Christian value and pose a false dichotomy between serving the needy and saving their souls. We can participate in the mission of God to rescue all of humanity in every area of life alongside all those who have the heart of Christ.

Although we differ on the theory behind the practice, Wesleyans share with Calvinists and many others the sense that God's mission is to everyone and that faithfulness to God is an essential part of our task. A Calvinist might say we must participate in a mission toward everyone because we do not know who God has chosen. An Arminian might say we must participate in the mission because anyone can be chosen. In either case, the mission invites everyone. A Calvinist might say you know a person is elect because they have remained faithful. An Arminian might say they remain among the elect because they remain faithful. Both traditions believe that we must remain faithful.

We remain faithful by making God the absolute authority of our life, which shows itself in our consistent love of our neighbor. Nothing is an exception to these two rules, a belief that Wesleyans surely hold in common with most others who call themselves Christians. No supposed interpretation of the Bible can legitimately support hateful actions toward our neighbors. One of the ways in which we are distinctive is in our belief that there are no glib excuses for failure in these areas. God expects us to succeed in loving our neighbor, and he empowers us to do it.

The Wesleyan tradition also has an activism that sees the potential for us to love our neighbors beyond the level of the individual. Christianity can be a force in the reformation of societal structures that perpetuate hatred of our neighbor. Unfortunately, those who call themselves Christians have often participated in the oppression of the minority. We have gone on Crusades to kill the Muslim. We have argued for slavery and against giving women the right to vote. We have supported Hitler against the Jews. We have lynched African-Americans in the KKK and grumbled against those who sought the right to go to the same schools and drink the same water as the majority. We have ignored the economically enslaved, the powerless immigrant, and rallied around the bombing of the unnamed other in a foreign country.

Suffice it to say, the best element of the Wesleyan tradition has always stood with the minority. They were abolitionists and supporters of women's rights. They were in favor of women in all roles of leadership. They were arrested along with other non-violent protesters in the Civil Rights movement. They take into mind the people who are crushed by legislation aimed at the self-sufficient, legal, and comfortable majority. Even when they have disagreed with the lifestyle of those whose sexual desires are toward the same sex, they have taken into mind the fact that God loves them every bit as much as the comfortable majority, that they are people we must treat with the love of Christ. This is the spirit of the Wesleyan tradition.

The Wesleyan tradition also moves forward into the twenty-first century with an ease that some other traditions do not. The postmodern challenge has exposed the frailty of human systems of thinking and of the degree to which our understanding of the Bible is and has been a function of us as readers more than of what these texts actually meant. The best philosophical answers to these challenges have been a "critical realist" or even "pragmatic realist" point of view. These perspectives focus on the heuristic value of our systems of thinking rather than on them as absolute systems that are the same as what God thinks. Our ideas stick closely to the evidence at hand and to what it is we are trying to do with our ideas. Again, this sense of thought in the service of our values and actions fits well with the Wesleyan spirit.

Similarly, once we realize that the Bible itself is an object of our knowing, the way it functions in Christian life must change. Regardless of the perfection of the Bible's message, we are stuck as its interpreters. The perfection of the Bible in practice therefore cannot rise in practice beyond the perfection of our understanding. These recognitions, along with a better understanding of the particularity of the Bible's original meaning, forces us to acknowledge the powerful, Spirit-led role that common Christian tradition has played in the appropriation of Scripture throughout the ages. We can no longer separate Scripture from tradition in the manner of the Reformation.

Again, the Wesleyan tradition slides easily into this mode, not only because Wesley was an Anglican rather than a Lutheran or a Calvinist, but because the Wesleyan tradition has a strong revivalist stream within it. This openness to the Spirit makes us comfortable with the notion of direct revelation from God in the words of Scripture and it makes us comfortable with the non-literal unity of Scripture that formative Christianity heard in its words. We can thus look forward to the challenges of the twenty-first century with Scripture as our starting point, with common Christian tradition setting the boundaries of our application, and with the Spirit to move us further along on the trajectory of the kingdom.

Latinos/as No Longer GOP

If there was any question, the GOP sealed its fate to lose the Mexican-Hispanic vote for the foreseeable future because of voting against the DREAM Act, which would have made a path for children of illegals to citizenship by going to college or serving in the military. Richard Lugar retains my vote for voting in the spirit of the America I love, the one with the Statue of Liberty that welcomes all who wish to participate in our grand society. "Give me your poor, your tired, your huddled masses longing to breathe free."