Thursday, March 12, 2015

26. Good leaders look for opportunities.

I sense this is getting very long, so let me skip a couple posts and get to this year (if I self-publish these notes, I'll add one post on improvements we made to our infrastructure in years 4 and 5, as well as one post about our transition to Learning Studio as a platform).

Year 6: Launching the Future (2014-15)
1. At the Convocation Service this year in August 2014, Wayne held up a plaque to be placed somewhere in the building. It signified what we had accomplished as a Seminary in our first five years, not least achieved accreditation with ATS in breakneck speed.

Then he held up another plaque. It was blank. He challenged us. What will go on this plaque to signify the next five years?

The first of those years is now almost past. I don't know what will go on that plaque, but I know some significant things that have happened this year.

2. One thought has to do with the application of John Wesley to today. Last year, Bob Whitesel took a group of students to England for an elective called, "The Land and Leadership of John Wesley." It was a reminiscent of a similar elective Bob and Russ led seven years ago. In this course, Bob took the students to various Wesley sites and explored Wesley from a standpoint of leadership principles we can draw from him.

The plan is currently that Bob will go to England every year, one year as an elective for Seminary students and then next as a trip for friends of IWU that he would do in conjunction with the development office.

Because of his associations with the Wesley Research Centre in Manchester, England, he began to raise the possibility of an association with them going forward. Wayne and I have reflected on this possibility for a couple years. This year, Wayne is moving forward with our membership, in part because he wonders if one piece on that plaque might include us being known for doing scholarship that applies the best of Wesley to today.

Colleen Derr fits in that brainstorm, for her doctoral work involved a significant element of applying Wesley to congregational formation. Another friend of Wesley in our community is Patrick Eby, who we may draw into such schemes. We will see what happens.

3. This might also be a good place for me to mention some of the behind the scenes things that Wayne does to enrich the future of the Seminary. I know he prays for us by name. I'm sure this not only includes those of us who work at Wesley and many he knows from the past. I know he prays for many students by name as well.

Wayne calls every new student who is accepted into the Seminary to welcome them. I know he keeps in contact with many of them after they graduate. There is a quiet piety and spirituality that you can see if you watch carefully. In keeping with Matthew 6, he does not trumpet it, but you know it is a key part of what makes him a great leader.

4. The biggest addition to the Seminary so far this year is the launch of specializations in Church Planting and Multiplication, as well as Church Health and Revitalization. I know these areas are dear to Wayne's heart, as well as to the Seminary board. They relate to two of the signature areas that the Board wanted to focus on as a Seminary.

This initiative, born of Wayne's desire to serve the church, has created a chain reaction that will soon be a major growth edge for the Seminary.

Last year, we explored the question of giving certificates for these sorts of things. As it turns out, there is a whole unpleasant layer of bureaucracy here. The government insists that a certificate issued by an academic institution needs to monitor the students after graduation to show that having the certificate improved their likelihood for "gainful employment." We were not looking for something that complicated.

So we decided to explore the idea of offering four course "specializations." And if you do these four courses and are not a student at the university, the Dean will send you a letter indicating that you have completed these four courses. We'll give you a piece of paper that is not an academic "certificate."

The first of these was the specialization in Church Planting and Multiplication, and Wayne tapped church planter Ed Love to design these four courses. I think we have something like 18 students running through this program right now, some of whom are Wesley students, some of whom come from outside the Seminary.

The four courses are "Multiply" (a one week intensive that visits several church plants), "Core" (about the character of a church planter), "Launch" (how to launch a church plant), and "Thrive" (how to face hurdles that come a year or so in.

Wayne tapped our own Charles Arn for the second specialization in Church Health and Revitalization. Three of the courses in this specialization were already being offered regularly: 1) Power, Change, and Conflict Management, a required course in the MA Leadership program, 2) Newcomer Integration, an elective Dr. Arn designed that is probably the most popular course the Seminary offers, and 3) Diagnosis and Prescription for a Healthy Church, another elective Dr. Arn wrote.

The fourth course we added to make this specialization is called, "Church Revitalization Field Supervision." It is a great concept where a student actually goes on a consultation with a church that needs revitalized. Wayne has developed a network of consultants that students can go with, including not least Paul Borden.

Wayne really does see the Seminary as able to do for the church initiatives like these that are so needed, but much harder for a headquarters to pull off. One person described his focus as "laser light" on coming alongside the church to help it with its mission. He is not interested in growth of the Seminary merely for growth's sake. It is the growth of the church that he sees the Seminary targeting, I believe.

5. I have mentioned Aaron Wilkinson from time to time, our Director of Admissions. I'm not sure when he drank the Wesley/IWU Kool-Aid. Maybe he is just wired that way. But it seems like he has come up with what I consider to be exponential growth concepts this year.

A key one is developing right now. We have now academically distinguished between the MA in Ministry degree as a core and what we used to call concentrations. Up till now, you had to get an MA in Ministry, Leadership concentration or an MA in Minisry, Children, Youth, and Family Ministry concentration. Now you not only can get an MA in Ministry with 18 elective hours of your own choosing (a generic MA), but after next week you should be able to plug all our specializations into the MA.

What this means is that, after next week, you should be able now to get an MA in Ministry, Church Planting and Multiplication specialization; an MA in Ministry, Church Health and Revitalization specialization; MA in Ministry, Pastoral Care specialization (done in conjunction with the Grad. Counseling division at IWU). And I see at least two more coming quickly: a worship specialization and one something in the area of administration (done in conjunction with the Devoe School of Business).

Aaron has had the idea of synchronizing our cohort schedules so that, if we do not have a full cohort for one of these specializations, the schedule will combine these smaller groups for the core courses and then the non-core can fill up as electives for the whole Seminary. It is a bold idea and the chart to the left reflects the synchronized schedule we hope to use moving forward. It's complicated. It's ingenious. It may facilitate an exponential expansion of specializations.

The Church Planting and Church Health specializations launched August 2014.

Previously on Seminary take-aways:

Pre-Seminary
1. There are key moments of opportunity.
2. You need the right people.
3. Good leaders collaborate and navigate.

Year 1: Launch Year
4. Innovation requires some trial and error. (1)
5. Innovation requires some trial and error. (2)
6. Innovation requires some trial and error. (3)
7. New leaders bring new strengths. (1)

Year 2: Growing Pains
8. Administration never ends.
9. New leaders bring new strengths. (2)
10. New leaders bring new strengths. (3)

Year 3: The Year of Maturity
11. Complexity works against sustainability.
12. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (1)
13. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (2)
14. Our guinea pigs survived.

Year 4: The Year of the Faculty
15. Faculty share governance with administration. (1)
16. Faculty share governance with administration. (2)
17. Faculty share governance with administration. (3)
18. Faculty share governance with administration. (4)
19. Growth means addition. (1)
20. Growth means addition. (2)
21. Growth means addition. (3)

Year 5: The Year of Accreditation
22. Don't underestimate the power of a symbol.
23. A good reputation is much to be desired.
24. Sustainability needs reliable infrastructure.
25. Important decisions often involve trade-offs.

Wednesday, March 11, 2015

25. Important decisions often involve trade-offs.

... continued from the previous post

9. There was another kind of organizational frustration that seemed to be rampant each August when we would have something like 60 classes beginning for the Fall. There would often be a series of misfires. Many if not most of these, I would say, had nothing to do with us. They had to do with a complex and overworked infrastructure, in my opinion.

So with new students, there were several different places at that time where their new log-in information had to be entered into IWU's system. Sometimes an individual student would be entered in one place but not in another. So a student's email would work, but they wouldn't be able to get into their courses. Or they could get into their courses but weren't receiving emails.

Sometimes the wrong "master course" had been copied for some reason. The system at that time involved us going through a long list of upcoming courses to make sure that the right course to come was correctly matched with the correct master course in the system. This process of correlating sometimes ended with things being mismatched in the system and thus with a course that needed to be deleted, re-matched, and recopied.

Then there were those times when it was our fault. Copying a course seemed to me to work a little like a pinball machine. First the machine loaded the ball. Then you fired the ball.

So there was a time where the course had already been initiated into the womb of the system but it had not been birthed. Any work a professor did on their master course during this period would not make it into the course once it appeared on the other side. So all the work they had done in this liminal zone was destined to be a waste, at least for a semester, unless we could get it deleted and recopied.

There was so much going on in IT at that time--with a smaller and smaller staff--that this was a bad situation. If everything copied correctly, no worries. But when a problem did occur, it could take a week or more to fix, sometimes after a course had already started. Professors or students would complain. We would send emails. Then a day or two later we would send another email. Sometimes in desperation we would end up having to make phone calls.

One of our heroes at this time--and he remains my hero even today--was Greg Stanley. There was a day when there were several Greg-type helpers around. These were the "above and beyond" types that I think make an organization great. Insert here all the necessary caveats about sabbath and family time. But if those core values are in place, an institution just will not be phenomenal if at least some key people are not eating, breathing, and sleeping the mission.

Over the years, Greg has fixed SO much for us. I am so grateful that his load has lightened so much this last year or so. (At least I think it has) We end up emailing him far less these days than we used to, and he is usually able to fix things within a day or less.

10. What changed? IWU entered into an agreement with Pearson that integrated our systems and outsourced some of the key work.

It was at the beginning of Year 5, in the summer of 2013. The interim management team at IWU decided to make this switch, under the advisement of the Executive Director of the Center for Learning Innovation at IWU, Lorne Oke. Henry Smith had become Chancellor at the end of 2012, and David Wright became President elect in late Spring. So in the Spring of 2013, the university was run by a management triumvirate of David Wright, Keith Newman, and Duane Kilty.

From a faculty perspective, it has been hard to figure out why the university made this move. The new LMS (Learning Management System), Learning Studio, is not as good as Blackboard. Every online course I teach, I miss features like being able to make comments on documents in the system rather than having to download them. Blackboard would email you when a student made a comment in a particular forum, making it easier to be a professor. The aesthetics arguably aren't as good. It did not have the possibility of embedding video at first.

We were told the advantages were "single sign on" and a move to the future--electronic books instead of paper books. Further, we would have access to the repository of teaching artifacts in Pearson's system. The switch to e-books would pay for the cost of Pearson and save the university what it was paying for Blackboard. We would charge the students the same amount they were already paying for CAPS to mail them paper books, but the electronic books they would now use would be less expensive. That difference would pay for Pearson.

11. Let me treat the good before the puzzling. First, let me center on those words "single sign on." I think most of us glazed over every time we heard those words. But I have a hunch that those words hold the key to why I have been FAR less frustrated in August and January than I used to be. Seriously, I sometimes was almost in despair in a January or August because these little problems would arise that seemed to be out there in some nebulous zone beyond my reach. And Karen and I had no idea why things just were not happening.

I believe that those problems largely went away because of the switch to Pearson. A person entered once into the system is entered everywhere. Email, courses, information are all in one single place. It's not necessarily an attractive interface, but it is easy and fairly straightforward.

Was it worth it for that peace of mind? For the Seminary, probably. I think IWU must have faced the choice of paying a lot of money to hire expensive people to run these things internally OR they could outsource it and forge this sort of arrangement with Pearson. Since IWU was not feeling particularly profitable in 2012, the decision makes sense to me.

12. As for the pie in the sky about e-books, that was, shall we say, a little problematic. In hindsight, it's now pretty amusing to me. The Seminary has always been unique enough that we could sit looser to these larger university goings on, and the e-book thing was one of them. So, for the most part, it was no skin off our noses.

For one, Pearson does not have much in the way of electronic resources in the area of ministry. There just weren't the e-books and learning modules for us to use. Here was another time where CAPS assumed everyone did things their way. Lorne and others were surprised to know that the Seminary didn't mail its books to students. So there went the dream of how to pay for Pearson in the Seminary.

In the end, our students ended up having to pay a $55 fee for every online course they take with a pre-made master course. That now pays for Learning Studio, the LMS. I forget how much more that is than what they were paying before in relation to Blackboard. It's not a lot, several hundred dollars but less than a thousand for the whole degree, if I remember correctly. We negotiated so that onsite courses would not have to pay the fee, following the model that CAS negotiated.

13. I'm amazed that the infrastructure pulled off the transition as quickly and successfully as it did. People like Sue Melton should get some kind of a medal, along with many others. Lorne Oke, Kurt Thompson worked incredibly hard.

(It was a risky move, from a leadership perspective. It was rushed through, with virtually no faculty input. Even administrative leaders had little or no say in the decision. It is one of those top down decisions that is a coup if you pull it off and it works, but heads usually roll if it does not come off well.)

I am amazed that some of those driving the change actually thought that a one-size-fits-all shift could work. For example, there was this idea that there could only be one master course for any course, whether online or onsite. So the onsite students would now get the same online course that online students get! I am flabbergasted that ANYONE could think this was optimal. How could this pattern generate anything by confusion?

So let's say you are taking a course onsite. You go online to see your course instructions for the week. It tells you have to post something by Tuesday, then discuss something or submit something by Thursday. But, of course, you are onsite. NONE of that actually applies to you.

Huh?

14. At the time, the Seminary occasionally had more than one version of a course depending on the context. The bottom line illustration is our Spanish program. You cannot use the same master course for a Spanish version of a course and an English version of a course.

Many Seminary faculty had also developed master courses for onsite versions of their classes. This seems bloody obvious to me, that a quality program would give course materials that are about that course, not another in some other domain.

In any case, Sue Melton initially had to create distinct courses in the catalog with an ES suffix so that we could have a different master course for the Spanish. So now in the catalog there is PROC-600 in English and there is PROC-600ES in Spanish. Why? Because Pearson initially resisted us having more than one master course for each course.

For the time being, our faculty now have to recreate onsite versions of their courses every time, because the system does not yet accommodate multiple versions of the same course. I hear that that situation is going to change. I believe this change will significantly improve IWU's serve.

There has been one silver lining in all this. We are now able to take a revised live course and have it made into the next master course. Before, our Blackboard infrastructure emphatically would not do something like this because all the student posts and gradebook items would then have to be removed one by one. But in Pearson, you can copy just the course content.

Hurray! Important decisions often involve trade offs. This is one amazingly beneficial change. It is much easier to fix a course while you are teaching it than to go through the system to have it changed by someone else all at once.

15. Back to the e-books. There were two amazingly significant problems with them. The one problem is the Tom Hanks problem in the movie Big. He is a boy in a man's body, and he designs this amazing toy. But since he is a boy, he has no clue about how much it costs and what a boy might be able to afford. He has designed this amazing thing that, as it turns out, no one will be able to buy in the real world.

And so it is. Even the simplest look at IWU's adult student base will tell you that they're not predominantly techies. The idea that, just because e-books are supposedly the thing of the future, it would be a good idea for IWU to switch all at once completely to them, proved to be outrageously naive. The volume of student complaint was so great that IWU had to go back to sending the books. Right now, students are getting and paying for both e-books and paper books.

It's no skin off my nose. My royalty check for some of those books was quite impressive in January. I bear no one any ill will, but these are the kinds of major misfires that end people in most places.

16. The other misstep was that these e-books had a shelf life. The students would only have them for about six months, then they would disappear. Darlene Bressler often reminds me with fondness of the moment I sighed with despondent disbelief after a University Academic Leadership Council meeting, "This is a disaster!"

Again, let's invoke some common sense here. It doesn't matter if everyone should be okay with not keeping their books forever. Of course I would dispute that, but let's say they're right. Let's say this is the future. Let's say everything's free online. Most people do not keep or use their books anyway. Book hoarders are freaks. Let's assume that this is correct for the sake of argument. Let's say 90% of the students do not care about keeping their books.

Are you going to gain any students from having the book material in their courses go away? Of course not. OK, how about losing students? Are you going to lose any students or frustrate any students with the fact that the book materials in their courses, for which they pay, go away? The answer is history.

It doesn't matter what you think should be the case if in the real world, it just isn't the case.

17. Enough griping. It has not cost the Seminary much and the net benefit of the switch, as I said, has probably been positive for the Seminary. There are benefits to being embedded in a larger institution.

Previously on Seminary take-aways:

Pre-Seminary
1. There are key moments of opportunity.
2. You need the right people.
3. Good leaders collaborate and navigate.

Year 1: Launch Year
4. Innovation requires some trial and error. (1)
5. Innovation requires some trial and error. (2)
6. Innovation requires some trial and error. (3)
7. New leaders bring new strengths. (1)

Year 2: Growing Pains
8. Administration never ends.
9. New leaders bring new strengths. (2)
10. New leaders bring new strengths. (3)

Year 3: The Year of Maturity
11. Complexity works against sustainability.
12. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (1)
13. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (2)
14. Our guinea pigs survived.

Year 4: The Year of the Faculty
15. Faculty share governance with administration. (1)
16. Faculty share governance with administration. (2)
17. Faculty share governance with administration. (3)
18. Faculty share governance with administration. (4)
19. Growth means addition. (1)
20. Growth means addition. (2)
21. Growth means addition. (3)

Year 5: The Year of Accreditation
22. Don't underestimate the power of a symbol.
23. A good reputation is much to be desired.
24. Sustainability needs reliable infrastructure.

24. Sustainability needs reliable infrastructure.

1. I once heard David Drury describe the importance of reliable operations in an organization something like this, presumably alluding to Daniel 2: "Operational dysfunction eats at the feet of an organization until it falls under its own weight."

It's not enough for a movement to be exciting or for a pastor to be a spectacular speaker. People will come to hear George Whitefield preach. But it takes a Wesley to start an organization. The entertainer will bring the crowd, but they won't be there in a year if there isn't an organizer there too. There are people you will follow into battle, but wars are ultimately won with organizational skills.

But I knew precious little of project management coming into this thing and operated more in terms of "solve problems as they arise" than what would be a more built to last motto--"prevent problems from happening by putting good systems in place." I've already written a little on this topic.

2. In May 2010, Wayne moved Karen Clark's job from that of secretary to "Coordinator of Operations." This was a key indicator that the operational load was already ramping up significantly in less than one year. This said to me that the operations of the Seminary could not be contained within a 9-5 window. (I secretly think Wayne was also hoping that Karen would now go to some meetings he didn't want to go to ;-)

I think that, now, with a whole team working under her supervision, Karen's job has finally become manageable. I know there were some days where we were all really just barely keeping our heads above water, but I think infrastructure has finally evened out her load.

3. Tenley Horner has been serving as secretary to Wayne, Karen, and myself since June 2011. Like Karen, I think that, this last year, her job has finally evened out to something manageable. And we've learned that she was a travel agent in a previous life. She was not the first in that position, but the job stabilized with her. (I also finally convinced her that my books do not need alphabetizing... I know where they are.)

4. The "scheduler" job has finally stabilized with Becky Perry, who started as an interim in the position in March 2014 but soon became permanent. The scheduler job is incredibly important. This person sends out contracts, gets new adjuncts through the hiring process, pressures me to assign adjuncts for classes and manages our astore.

We try to keep the classes assigned six months out, but I surprisingly tend to work a little behind the goal (we're currently scheduled into August). Obviously we plan out the full-time faculty's load before the academic year begins. When we have a new venue, we will often plan out the professors for the whole two years of the cohort. But Wayne is always making new contacts. It's not bad to have a little slack in the system.

With Becky, the scheduler role has also finally stabilized. It's been a while since we've had an emergency last minute hire. It's been a while since we've banged our heads against the wall trying to figure out why things weren't going anywhere.

When the Seminary started, Karen did all these things. Then there was Karen and Tenley's jobs. Then there were student workers. Then there was Cecilia, but she was absorbed by the Spanish program. Bianca tried to fill in the gap for a short period.

The first hope for a more permanent scheduler was Juan Guerra (mind you, the position is still part time and was for Juan as well). Juan was our part time scheduler from April 2013 to February 2014. Juan is a wonderful guy from Venezuela with a business background. He is co-owner of La Charreada here in town, and I always wondered why in the world he was interested in doing part time business with us when he had multiple restaurants in Indiana where he was providing leadership. That world finally called him back full time. Thankfully, we can still see him at La Charreada!

With Becky, that position has finally stabilized too. Interestingly, both she and Tenley were originally secretary to the Graduate Dean, who with them was Jim Fuller.

5. While the work of the downstairs offices was slowly evening out, the faculty also saw two key places where our Seminary infrastructure was inadequate. One was that of the coordination of adjuncts. The other was the need for some sort of project manager for all the special projects the Seminary inevitably had going all the time.

It is ironic that, at Wesley, it has been the Dean that is less methodical and process oriented while many on the faculty are very process oriented. I know I have frustrated them from time to time.

For example, I used to hold ad hoc adjunct trainings for adjuncts on Adobe Connect. I should mention that I don't like going to training sessions or in services. I like to figure things out by doing them. Don't make me go to a training session on how to make a PowerPoint. That's death. Let me make a PowerPoint and be on call if I need help.

So it was the Seminary faculty that finally insisted that we appoint one of them as Adjunct Coordinator. This is someone who would not do an ad hoc training but would do a more formal training. This is someone who would check in on each adjunct while they were teaching, someone who could be a more normalized go-to person for the adjuncts.

So Colleen Derr is now going on two years as our Adjunct Coordinator, and she has done a splendid job. Our adjunct team is now more on top of things than ever. Colleen even directed the creation of an Adjunct Handbook for our adjuncts.

6. There had been an earlier attempt to distribute some of this load by assigning all the courses in the Seminary to various members of the faculty. For example, if an adjunct was teaching Non-Profit Management, then Bob would be the faculty member that the adjunct teaching that class would contact for help. At first, I thought that these lead faculty might also check in on the adjuncts teaching their courses, but this largely did not happen, thus leading to the idea of an Adjunct Coordinator.

We still add this "lead professor" as an extra professor to every live version of the course under their supervision. So Colleen serves as the pedagogical reference point, and the supervising professor for a given course serves as a content reference.

7. I mentioned that Colleen put together an Adjunct Handbook. She did this with the help of Tera Tietjens, who at the end of this month will finish her first year as faculty secretary. Tera has been an amazing help because now, when the faculty see a problem, they can work with her to get it fixed.

It is hard to express how much stress her presence has relieved among the faculty. She has also relieved stress from the office support downstairs because she can handle some tasks that inevitably used to fall to them.

Wayne also carved out funds at the end of last year for the faculty to have research/teaching assistants, pretty much undergraduate students. Their presence has also lightened the stress of the faculty considerably.

8. The faculty also believed in Year 5 that the Seminary needed something like a Project Manager. Although I'm now getting into Year 6, Kelli Clark, Karen's daughter, first came in as a student worker. But her organizational skills are so great that Wayne has been using her as a project manager. She has been doing a superb job of handling the schedules for special projects and making sure they keep on schedule. I haven't heard mention of the need lately.

9. There was another kind of organizational frustration that seemed to be rampant around August when so many of our classes were beginning for the Fall. But I'll save this one for tomorrow...

Previously on Seminary take-aways:

Pre-Seminary
1. There are key moments of opportunity.
2. You need the right people.
3. Good leaders collaborate and navigate.

Year 1: Launch Year
4. Innovation requires some trial and error. (1)
5. Innovation requires some trial and error. (2)
6. Innovation requires some trial and error. (3)
7. New leaders bring new strengths. (1)

Year 2: Growing Pains
8. Administration never ends.
9. New leaders bring new strengths. (2)
10. New leaders bring new strengths. (3)

Year 3: The Year of Maturity
11. Complexity works against sustainability.
12. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (1)
13. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (2)
14. Our guinea pigs survived.

Year 4: The Year of the Faculty
15. Faculty share governance with administration. (1)
16. Faculty share governance with administration. (2)
17. Faculty share governance with administration. (3)
18. Faculty share governance with administration. (4)
19. Growth means addition. (1)
20. Growth means addition. (2)
21. Growth means addition. (3)

Year 5: The Year of Accreditation
22. Don't underestimate the power of a symbol.
23. A good reputation is much to be desired.

23. A good reputation is much to be desired.

1. We became Associate Members of the Association of Theological Schools (ATS) in June 2012, just as we were graduating our first batch of MDIV students. We immediately went to work on the next step--full accreditation. We would have had five years to start the process but we had been waiting to go through each next step as quickly as possible.

The first step was an "Internal Readiness Study," in which we were to go through the basic categories of the ATS standards and indicate our readiness to be evaluated for accreditation. I put together a relatively brief 16 page study by November 1. It was relatively short for such things, but covered all the bases and my impression was that the brevity was appreciated. Tom Tanner from ATS was then on our campus two weeks later (Nov. 14-15) and recommended us for candidacy status.

2. We then had two years to do a fuller Self-Study, basically a majorly elongated version of the readiness report. The document Dr. Tanner left us expected to see the study by December 1, 2014.

Not wanting to dally, we submitted the Self-Study in December of 2013. The goal was to have a site visit in good time for the Board of Accreditation to vote on us in June. The main part of the study was 85 pages with 97 pages of appendices. It covered our story, our infrastructure, our degrees, our venues.

Most of the time, this sort of work should be done by faculty. There would ideally be a single voice editing the piece, but nothing would prevent the first draft of various sections being distributed. Since we are so young and I had the longest view of things, it seemed appropriate for me to put it together. I do like to write, if you haven't noticed.

But the faculty gave feedback and editorial suggestions on the pieces as they came together. The broader infrastructure of the university gave the needed data for their pieces of the puzzle. Several of the faculty (Safiyah, Colleen, Kwasi, principally) helped with some last minute assessment data crunching.

Few will be surprised that the assessment piece was the piece I most procrastinated. Here the Chalk & Wire training Lenny and I had done in January 2011 had provided an excellent framework for how to set it up.

In what will not be surprising to anyone who knows me and most of academia, there was about four years' worth of assessment work that had accumulated. We had been saying forever that we were going to set up Chalk & Wire, and then the university decided in the Spring of 2013 to switch to a different learning platform that would have its own assessment system, thus postponing an automated assessment two more years.

As the university was slowly phasing out Blackboard, our own LMS (Learning Management System), I suddenly found that data from the past, which I had assumed would always be there to cull from, was slowly disappearing into a data abyss. We were nevertheless able to recover enough data to give across the board results which indicated that, yes, our courses were pretty much achieving the stated outcomes of our degree programs.

(Since I have no shame, I'll admit to using such tactics as contacting some students from the first couple cohorts to recover artifacts of certain assignments, as well as some professors. I even pulled some documents off the temporary internet files part of my own hard drive.)

3. The site visit went well. The team was especially impressed with the fact that whether they spoke to students, faculty, board members, broader university personnel, or administration, everyone had the same vision, the same enthusiasm, the same optimism. They did give some good long term advice.

They were concerned that our infrastructure grow to meet our volume. We needed to shift from start up mode to long term sustainability. They were concerned that our faculty were overloaded, that we needed to continue to add faculty (they'll check up on this in October 2016). And of course they would like to see in February 2017 that we have not only implemented the Learning Outcomes Management (LOM) system we said we were going to, but that we have gathered data and revised curriculum accordingly.

But they recommended seven years of accreditation (the maximum). They approved our three degrees (MA in Ministry, MDIV, and MPTh). They approved Indy North as a complete degree site. They approved 12Stone® and Instituto Biblico Wesleyano in Bogota as extension sites.

We were fully accredited in June in time to feel really good about ourselves at the 2014 biennial meeting in Pittsburg.

4. I don't think I have mentioned that our goal from the very beginning was to have 50% of our courses taught by full-time faculty and no more than 50% of our courses taught by adjuncts. Depending on where you are coming from, this may either seem like way too few full-time or too big a goal. We have never hit this ideal yet. In the 2013 year, 38% of our courses were taught by full-time faculty. Since then we have added two full-time faculty and one more is in the chute.

Suffice it to say, the contemporary college or seminary will surely have to rely heavily on adjuncts to survive financially in this day and age. There are ethical concerns here too, as adjuncts are people who need to make a living wage, have health care, and so forth. I don't know the answer, but math is math too. One key feature of a dying seminary is an outrageously low student to faculty ratio.

There is more than one way to calculate this ratio. For example, by one reckoning, you might include faculty teaching overloads, along with faculty who teach for us who are full-time somewhere else in the university. There is about a 5% difference between the ratio figured on the basis of faculty within load and the ratio figured on any course taught by a full-time faculty.

The question of overload is disputed. I believe that overload should ideally be decided by individual faculty capacity rather than blanket policy. It may be surprising for the public to know that many faculty skirt along financially, and overload and adjuncting elsewhere has become a key element in the lives of many faculty.

The question is one of capacity, I believe. There are faculty who teach crazy overload and consistently get crazy positive evaluations. If they don't teach overload for us, they will just adjunct somewhere else. And full-time faculty will generally have better evaluations than adjuncts.

In the end, and I got this from John Drury, policies often are introduced by a certain administrative personality that implicitly doesn't trust people to make sound decisions. Policies are often substitutes for competent leadership ("Policies replace people"). If your leaders can competently decide who is capable of doing a good job on overload, then you don't need to have a rigid or absolute policy.

I am always amazed at administrators who can't understand why they are in financial dookie after pushing small class sizes and limited faculty overloads.

Previously on Seminary take-aways:

Pre-Seminary
1. There are key moments of opportunity.
2. You need the right people.
3. Good leaders collaborate and navigate.

Year 1: Launch Year
4. Innovation requires some trial and error. (1)
5. Innovation requires some trial and error. (2)
6. Innovation requires some trial and error. (3)
7. New leaders bring new strengths. (1)

Year 2: Growing Pains
8. Administration never ends.
9. New leaders bring new strengths. (2)
10. New leaders bring new strengths. (3)

Year 3: The Year of Maturity
11. Complexity works against sustainability.
12. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (1)
13. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (2)
14. Our guinea pigs survived.

Year 4: The Year of the Faculty
15. Faculty share governance with administration. (1)
16. Faculty share governance with administration. (2)
17. Faculty share governance with administration. (3)
18. Faculty share governance with administration. (4)
19. Growth means addition. (1)
20. Growth means addition. (2)
21. Growth means addition. (3)

Year 5: The Year of Accreditation
22. Don't underestimate the power of a symbol.

Monday, March 09, 2015

22. Don't underestimate the power of a symbol.

Year Five: The Year of Accreditation (2013-14)
1. We moved into our own seminary building in May of 2013.

For the first four years of our existence, we had our offices in the old Noggle Christian Ministries building, and we had our classes in Noggle. But many of us thought it was important for Wesley Seminary to have an address, even though we are primarily an online seminary.

I agree with ATS that the face-to-face launch of our classes creates a connection that would take a lot more time and effort to create if there were no "embodied" components to the curriculum at all. The same goes for the MA launches. There is something about being on campus for two days that creates a connection and a cohesion that just would take more time and effort if the degree programs were entirely online. It could be done, but it would take a lot more work.

Similarly, the existence of this building grounds the Seminary's existence in a time and place. It's important. There is a Protestant shallowness sometimes that goes purely cognitive, as if some Gnostic disembodied thinking was all that really counts.

But most humans aren't like that. They find themselves in identity-forming stories, symbols, and rituals. If you walk into 12Stone®, you'll see sculptures of Gideon that echo a story that helped form the church's identity.

Wayne and others put a great deal of thought into the symbolism of the Seminary building. It points outward, with a large glass looking out at the world, because "the world is our parish." It has both the red brick style in the middle that says, "We belong to IWU" and the more international, variegated style on the sides.

On the side of the building facing the campus, there are twelve pillars, each with a different part of the Apostle's Creed on it. Henry Smith liked to think of the oval section on the campus side in terms of Wesley's field preaching. Karen Clark, as in so many cases, made a lot of nuts and bolts decisions that have helped to make the building what it is.

When the planning first started, there were a number of houses where the building now stands. Other places were considered. For example, President Smith wondered if it would be nice long term for the Seminary to be next to Noggle. On the other hand, that would have killed some nice green space and where would students have parked?

Bob Whitesel thought it might be nice for the building to be on the back side of campus, where people would see it coming in from I-69. On the other hand, some thought the south side of campus might eventually become a kind of Graduate School Park, with the Seminary as a kind of kick-off. There had been a ceremony to lay the cornerstone on April 12, 2012, and we were in the building by May of the next year.

2. I might add, since I have not found a place to mention it thus far, that the Seminary has a weekly blog. I started it on this site the very first month of our existence in July 2009. My first posts were predictably theological. With each new person they got more practical, and we switched to the current site in January 2012. There was talk of an online journal. For a while we populated a resource page with the stipulation that all the materials be practical.

I also think it is significant that we have a Facebook group, Wesley Seminary Cafe. In the early days, when it felt like we were having some communication problems, this site allowed me to get out information quickly in emergency situations. It was/is also a convenient place to post job openings and other announcements.

When they come in, Kami Mauldin encourages new cohorts to form their own Facebook groups to keep each other informed and motivated. (And I encourage them to add someone from the Seminary so they stay positive when they're about 2/3 through.)

3. I've mentioned the beginning of a Benjamin MA in August 2013. That August we also started an MDIV cohort in Bogota, Colombia. Joanne Solis-Walker flew down and launched the cohort. A church helped underwrite at least some of their tuition. They took a break for a year and then started back up in January of this year (2015).

Meanwhile, we started two new MDIV cohorts in Bogota January 2015, one Wesleyan and one non-Wesleyan. Joanne did the orientation online in December so they could go ahead and start online this Spring. Then she will go down with Hugo Magallanes in June for the face-to-face launch.

4. In my next post, I will talk about the process that resulted in our ATS accreditation in our fourth year. But we had been dreaming of a next step long before that process was complete. We both had the people, the drive, and the mission to think it would eventually be appropriate to launch a DMIN program. Even as I write, we are in process on this goal.

But there were steps to take before we would even start that process. We determined that we would not begin to plan specifically about a DMIN until after ATS granted us accreditation. (remembering that we had been accredited through the Higher Learning Commission since before we began)

We also knew that there would be lots of our former MA in Ministry alumni who would be interested in a DMIN from us. As I recall, the ATS materials at that time read that a student needed to have been in ministry for two years after the first postgraduate theological degree in order to be eligible to apply for a DMIN. This was one of those situations where ATS meant something without saying it. "First theological degree" meant an MDIV or its equivalence to them, at least 72 hours of relevant graduate work.

Our MA in Ministry is a 36 hour degree. Thus was born the idea for what we eventually called a "Master's of Practical Theology" or an MPTh. It would be another 36 hour master's whose very existence was to form a bridge from a 36 hour MA to MDIV equivalence so someone could apply for a DMIN program, ours in particular.

Yet again, we formed a task force. As I recall, Lenny Luchetti had the winning idea. We would use our existing MDIV courses. The MPTh would basically be half an MDIV. Pick 3 of the 6 praxis courses, do the four foundational courses, do the Pastor, Church, and World course with other MDIV students and then take a capstone that meets with the MDIV capstone.

It was ingenious. A whole degree built out of existing parts. Kudos to Lenny! Our first MPTh students started trickling in January 2014.

Previously on Seminary take-aways:

Pre-Seminary
1. There are key moments of opportunity.
2. You need the right people.
3. Good leaders collaborate and navigate.

Year 1: Launch Year
4. Innovation requires some trial and error. (1)
5. Innovation requires some trial and error. (2)
6. Innovation requires some trial and error. (3)
7. New leaders bring new strengths. (1)

Year 2: Growing Pains
8. Administration never ends.
9. New leaders bring new strengths. (2)
10. New leaders bring new strengths. (3)

Year 3: The Year of Maturity
11. Complexity works against sustainability.
12. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (1)
13. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (2)
14. Our guinea pigs survived.

Year 4: The Year of the Faculty
15. Faculty share governance with administration. (1)
16. Faculty share governance with administration. (2)
17. Faculty share governance with administration. (3)
18. Faculty share governance with administration. (4)
19. Growth means addition. (1)
20. Growth means addition. (2)
21. Growth means addition. (3)

Sunday, March 08, 2015

Sweet Briar College

Events like this one are sad, a hundred years of stories that now will only survive in the memories of alumnae, a cache of historical documents, and a potentially idle property. Here's one person's suggestion for how to turnaround a place like this one.

Gobry's five points are spot-on. This place could be turned around if it dies enough to break its current parameters. That's always the formula for closing: a straight jacket set by the founder, a stubborn faculty, and a visionless administration.

So the all-women piece has to go. A hefty number of majors and faculty has to go. It has to go distance. I personally think bringing in enough technology to have virtual students from afar participate with those sitting in the classroom opens up the floodgates both in terms of faculty and students. Counter-incentives can be put in place for those who choose to come on campus.

He's right on having a target audience. He's right on focus and whittling down all the majors.

Easy-peezy. This college could be turned around in someone's sleep.

Wesleyan-Arminian Reflections on Christ and Salvation

Here are now the links to my reflections on the first two parts of my ongoing series on theology from a Wesleyan-Arminian perspective. These are in my "theology in bullet points" series. I'm almost ready to self-publish Part 1. Part 2 is now finished as of today. I'll start the final section next Sunday.

Part 1: God and Creation
God and Creation

Part 2: Christ and Salvation
The Doctrine of Christ (Christology)
1. Christ has been the Son of God from eternity past.
2. Jesus is "God with us," God's Word become flesh.
3. Jesus on earth was a prophet of the kingdom of God.
4. In his death, Jesus became the priest of all humanity and creation.
5. In his resurrection, Jesus became the king of all humanity and creation.

The Doctrine of Atonement 
1. God chose Christ's death as the means to reconcile the world to himself.
2. In his death, Jesus showed us the love of God.
3. In his death, Jesus satisfied the order of things.
4. In his death, Jesus took humanity's place.
5. In his death, Jesus defeated the power of death.

The Doctrine of Salvation (soteriology)
1. Jesus saves.
2. Saving us is part of God's plan.
3. God was reaching out for us long before we knew it.
4. God used Israel to prepare the way for Christ.
5. God justifies us in response to our repentance and faith.
6. God fills us with his Holy Spirit as a seal of ownership.
7. God adopts us as his children: we are born to new life.
8. The power of the Spirit breaks the power of Sin.
9. The dead in Christ will rise.
10. Christ will come again to save his people and judge the world.
11. God will restore the world and we will enjoy him forever.

S11. God will restore the world and we will enjoy him forever.

This is now the eleventh and final post in a unit on salvation in my ongoing series, theology in bullet points. The first section had to do with God and Creation, and I have also finished units on Christology and Atonement.
____________
God will restore the world and we will enjoy him forever.

1. "God so loved the world that he gave his only Son, so that everyone who believes in him may not perish but may have eternal life." Life that never ends is the destiny of those whose sins are atoned for by the blood of Christ.

It is the promise of Scripture for believers in Christ that "we will be with the Lord forever" (1 Thess. 4:17). In the resurrection, Jesus has already done the work to destroy death and, after the resurrection takes place and all the dead are appropriately judged, there will be no more death (1 Cor. 15:26). "This perishable body must put on imperishability, and this mortal body must put on immortality" (15:53). So believers, in their resurrection bodies, will be immortal. [1]

2. We do not know a lot of the details of eternity. But we know that "God himself will be with them; he will wipe every tear from their eyes. Death will be no more; mourning and crying and pain will be no more, for the first things have passed away" (Rev. 21:3-4). There are some who picture this eternity as boring, given the way it has been presented to them, but we should dismiss such a thought not only as foolish but impossible.

What we know is that eternity will be far more fantastic than anything we have ever experienced in this life, and it will be neverendingly so. No doubt the first moment with God would make us feel exceedingly stupid for even having such a thought. We cannot even imagine the joy, pleasure, and awesomeness of eternity.

We can imagine that there will be greater activity in heaven than there is on earth, not the boredom of a nursing home. We can imagine that there will be things to learn in heaven--will we not have the whole, redeemed universe at our disposal to explore and more? Will there not be challenges in eternity, as God gave Adam a challenge in the Garden of Eden? There may not be sex (Mark 12:25), but no doubt there will be unimaginably better things. [2]

There will be complete equality in the kingdom. Women will not be given in marriage to men (Mark 12:25), which implies that there will be no subordination of wives to husband as was the norm of the cultures at the time of the Bible's writing. Since we are now in the age of the Spirit (e.g., Acts 2:17), it would be foolish for us to perpetuate that earthly pattern now, since it is not the trajectory of the kingdom. Similarly, we should do all we can to eliminate slavery on earth, since it is contrary to the kingdom ideal.

3. We should probably take the millennium of Revelation 20 as symbolic of Christ's incipient reign now in the Church. This position is called amillennialism. The reason is that 1) Revelation is highly symbolic and 2) the idea is found nowhere else in Scripture. No core doctrine should really be based on an idea that only appears in one biblical text. Amillennialism does not take a position on how things will be in the time before Christ's return.

However, it is not heretical to hold to the two other interpretations of the millennium because this issue is not a central doctrine, let alone a matter of dogma. The postmillennial perspective tends to see the millennium as something that is a little more literal, referring to the present era of history since Christ, when the good news has increased and spread throughout the world. Postmillennial views tend to see the world becoming more and more Christian over time.

The premillennial view takes the millennium of Revelation 20 literally of a thousand year period after Christ's return and the first resurrection. As such, it does not see the final resurrection and judgment until after Christ's reign, and it would thus see the possibility of rebellion against God even after the judgment pictured in most of Revelation. Premillennialism tends to see the world as getting worse and worse before Christ's return.

Again, since Scripture is not clear on these things and Revelation is highly symbolic, this is not an issue over which Christians should fight. We will know how it is destined to play out after it plays out.

4. Another question has to do with the central location of eternity. After all, Hebrews pictures a removal of the created realm (Heb. 12:26-27). 2 Peter 3:10 says that "the elements will be dissolved with fire." Similarly, Jesus tells his followers in John that "if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come again and will take you to myself, so that where I am, there you may be also" (John 14:3). This verse sounds like Jesus is preparing a place for them in heaven.

Again, since there are multiple verses that can be interpreted in different ways, the location of eternity should not be considered a matter of dogma. What is central is that we will have eternal life with Christ forever. However, the general consensus of Christian history and the dominant voice in Scripture suggests that eternity will be based on a restored earth.

So 2 Peter 3:13 goes on to say that "we wait for new heavens and a new earth." In other words, the destruction of the current elements is only in transition to a restored and renewed earth. Paul says in Romans 8 that the creation is yearning for its liberation "from its bondage to decay" (Rom. 8:21). As our bodies will be transformed into resurrection bodies, so the creation will be transformed into a new creation.

The kingdom of God will thus most likely be on earth. Jesus pictures this sort of a kingdom when he speaks of people coming from east and west and north and south to feast in the kingdom (Luke 13:29). Since Revelation 21 has the support of the rest of the New Testament, we might take its New Jerusalem as more literal than some other figures in the book.

To what then does John 14 refer? Perhaps reading the New Testament theologically we might think of the place Jesus went to prepare in heaven as a place for temporary dwelling in heaven prior to the full arrival of the kingdom of God. [3] It is hard to know whether to take the details of Revelation 21 literally, but it is always possible that the dwelling Christ prepared is in the new Jerusalem that will come down to earth.

5. The kingdom of God was inaugurated when Christ rose from the dead. Jesus brought it near when he came to earth, when he began his earthly ministry (e.g., Mark 1:15). His death made it possible and his resurrection brought his heavenly enthronement, the true commencement of his reign. His reign at this time is both "now and not yet." It has commenced. It is here. But it is not fully here yet.

When Christ returns, God will bring final salvation. He will eliminate evil and evil humanity. He will "save," free the creation from its bondage to decay. He will restore humanity and the creation to its intended glory. Christ "will reign for ever and ever" (Rev. 11:15). [4] This is the fullness of the kingdom of God, forever on earth as it is in heaven (Matt. 6:10).

Next Sunday: Sp1. The Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son."

[1] Again, the Bible does not teach that our immortal souls live forever but that our immortal bodies will live for ever. This is not our current body, but the body of our resurrection (e.g., 1 Cor. 15:44).

[2] There is no basis for the sentiment sometimes heard that we will not know our spouses in the kingdom of God. This passage merely says that there will be no marriage. Indeed, we have no way of knowing whether our resurrection bodies will even distinguish gender.

[3] By reading the Bible "theologically" I mean reading it beyond the original intentions of its authors but from a later Christian point of view that synthesizes the original words of Scripture in the light of the later clarifications the Spirit made in the Church.

[4] There is some tension between this statement in Revelation 11:15 and what Paul says in 1 Corinthians 15:28. The consensus of Christian history, however, sees all three--God the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit--reigning forever.

Saturday, March 07, 2015

21. Growth means addition. (3)

... continued: growth means addition

b. So the first new venue that Dr. Schmidt added in our fourth year was the new Benjamin MDIV cohort in Indy, November 2012.

A second was an online MA cohort that was more or less based in 12Stone® Church in Atlanta. We had partnered with 12Stone to offer an elective there in June 2011, "Church Laboratory." The idea was to expose Seminary students to the DNA of a super-growing church. Bob Whitesel teamed up with Dan Reiland as professor of the class.

Then in the summer of 2013 12Stone and Wesley launched an MA cohort. Bob kicked it off with Non-Profit Management. He spent a fair amount of time dialoging with 12Stone to develop a format for the partnership, developed something like a 10 page book on it. We called Kwasi and him liaisons.

There wasn't a lot of time for contextualization of an online course. IWU has a system. There is a Platonic pattern of sorts, a "master course" from which all "live" versions of a particular course are copied. In 2013, courses only copied a week before the course began, and that's all the prior time a professor had to change things before the official start. Same for students. (The switch to a new Learning Management System in 2014 has given professors two weeks).

So we weren't going to be able to do much changing of the curriculum in relation to 12Stone. There were a few changes. I think we were able to switch out a textbook or two.

The key contextualization was that someone on staff for 12Stone would record an introduction to the course, giving a 12Stone perspective. Then during some Monday evening during the course, that same person would have an hour long Q & A with the class on Adobe Connect, a software that allows for a live online session.

And, of course, we had to get regulatory permission from the State of Georgia.

I would say the 12Stone MA cohort is the sharpest group of students I've ever taught online, a real set of sharp cookies. The Scripture class I taught was one of the most stimulating classes I've ever taught. If we get a full cohort, we hope to start a second MA group this summer.

c. These sorts of innovations required us to work out the details of shared governance. Let's say the administration, by which I principally mean the VP and Dean, with the support of the Seminary board and upper administration, wanted to engage a strategic partnership with some church or other partner. To what extent does the administration have to have faculty support to do so? If we launch a new cohort of an existing program with a new partner, who is in control of the specific content within the curriculum at that new location? To what extent can the Dean grant exceptions to various features of the requirements, for example, by substituting a different course for a core requirement that fits better with the needs/desires of the partner?

Obviously you would hope that everyone would be on the same page in such ventures, but there are tensions from time to time and it becomes important to clarify the chain of authority in shared governance.

The clarity we gained is that the faculty as a whole control the curriculum as a whole. But no individual faculty has ultimate control over the curriculum for a specific course. And, as Tom Tanner of ATS once told me, "Policies are not people." Exceptions are the stuff of good academic administration in individual circumstances. Obviously if you never follow a policy, it's either a bad policy or you're a bad guardian of the policies. And exceptions are best made for individuals, rather than collections of individuals. But the academic Dean has the power to grant petitions.

Further, the administration determines where the curriculum established by the faculty is offered, and the Dean assigns the faculty to teach specific courses. So if the administration believed it was in the missional or strategic interest of the Seminary to start a cohort at a particular location and none of the faculty was interested in teaching there or in teaching in the manner the partnership suggested, the academic Dean could assign other appropriate adjuncts there, assuming they are academically qualified.

d. There are costs, however, to political maneuvering. I like the image of spending your capital. A leader only has so much capital to spend. "You have to choose your battles." "You can't kick every barking dog" (a little older proverb ;-). An administration and faculty at odds with each other can only persist so long before one or the other has to give. An administrator can only overrule the faculty for so long, and a faculty member can only defy the administration so long. Again, the ideal is that both collaborate on ventures with a normal give and take.

Perhaps I am mistaken about some of the dynamics to the start of the adult programs at IWU, but my impression is that then President Jim Barnes wisely set up the adult programs as a separate unit of the university. Let me be clear, I breathe the air of a professor. I am returning to teaching because I love teaching and writing. I am far more a faculty person by my default nature than an administrator.

So I am not indicting all faculty individuals as a whole here. I am only saying that the stereotypes of faculty in general are not entirely false. We are not nearly as omniscient as we think we are and most of us are no smarter than people who are doers--we just have a different personality and thus channel our smarts in different ways.

So the rumors that large numbers of faculty types tend to oppose online education or what seem to be obvious innovations is not entirely false. I think a good deal of it is selfish. We want to be a "sage on the stage" not a "guide on the side." A lot of us like hearing our own voice, myself included. We stroke our egos by thinking we know oh so much and delight in the thought of people sitting at our feet to learn. Obviously educational institutions rather need to be about serving students, and we need to be focused on their education rather than on our knowledge. It's not about transmission but reception.

So my impression is that Barnes created the adult wing of IWU slightly out of the reach of the traditional faculty. That allowed him to innovate with the modalities whether the faculty liked them or not. It allowed him to shape a faculty of a different flavor. Over time, it allowed him to shape a curriculum in an innovative way. IWU might not be here today if he hadn't.

e. Two other new venues of this sort are currently in the works. It is quite possible that Heartland Church in Indianapolis will contribute some students to another onsite evening MDIV class at IECN on Monday nights this Fall. And they may contribute some MA students as well to a new Leadership cohort. These students will probably take two intensives at Heartland itself, the same two we have substituted for 12Stone's version of the MA (Strategic Leadership and Leading People). And they may do one hour spiritual formation classes onsite at Heartland Church too. A second partnership is also in the works with Prairie Lakes Church in Iowa.

I have had a surprising thought as we think about a second MA cohort with 12Stone. We have chosen to be a practical seminary. Our connections with teaching churches embody that emphasis. We are doing our students a great service by connecting ministers with the DNA at 12Stone. I have a student in spiritual formation on campus who interned at 12Stone, and you can tell his intuitions have been shaped by his time there. For the rest of his ministry, he will be more effective without thinking about it, because he has absorbed some of their DNA into his system.

So it fits with our identity to connect people outside of 12Stone with 12Stone and other growing churches.

But what of the students within 12Stone? How much can we really add practical value to them? I know we can do some, but think about it. When it comes to nuts and bolts type practical, are we ever really going to seem more practical than taking a leadership seminar with Dan Reiland or Kevin Myers? Indeed, ironically, it seems like they have the practical--at least in its tactical dimensions--more than adequately covered. Do we not have more to offer them along the lines of practical theology than practical in the tactical and operational senses?

4. Growth also comes by way of new degrees, specializations, etc.

In the last year or so, our greatest growth edge has been with the MA specialization in Children, Youth, and Family, almost single handedly redesigned by Colleen Derr. When the Seminary started, we had an MA concentration in Youth Ministry. It had largely run its course. We were repeatedly unable to recruit a full cohort, and started dropping occasional new students into existing cohorts.

The online leadership cohorts were doing okay, but the onsite ones had almost completely dried up when the Seminary started. More on that later. The start of the Seminary and the creation of an MDIV degree led to some reformulating of the Leadership concentration, as I have mentioned. The new momentum of the Seminary in general I believe refreshed the MA Leadership concentration as well.

With the advent of Colleen Derr as a professor in July 2011, she had a vision for a broader MA. So in May of 2012, we approved modifications that would make it a concentration in Youth and Family Ministry. (The name was further broadened to Children, Youth, and Family Ministry in June 2013).

We should not be surprised that the interest in this MA has been tremendous. Aiming for at least 15 in a new cohort start, we have sometimes had to start two cohorts. (Our current goal is not to have more than 18 in an online cohort)

Tom Tanner of ATS has recently indicated that the real growth edge in seminaries has to do with specialized MAs. It looks like Wesley is about to explode in this regard. More on this to come.

5. It is probably worth mentioning a program that the Seminary did not start, because what you don't do affects who you are as much as what you do. Indeed, you can consider it a strength that Dr. Schmidt does not try to do everything as a Seminary. Overreach or over-broadening of target can sabotage the mission as well. Certainly my own capacity is far from infinite.

a. In October 2010, individuals from the KERN foundation relaunched a conversation about an initiative they had to see the student debt of ministers go down. What they were especially interested were programs that could take a student from high school to an MDIV equivalence in 5 years. So they were especially in dialog with embedded schools that had both an undergraduate program and an MDIV degree.

In January 2011, then Provost David Wright proposed to them that IWU would form a task force to explore the possibility of a 5 year MDIV equivalence. David Drury, who at that time was Executive Pastor of College Wesleyan Church, was tapped to serve as a Project Manager. We met with KERN and other schools at a hotel off of O'Hare Airport in Chicago at the end of March. Then in April, the task force met at the IWU Kokomo site and formulated a specific proposal.

The end result was that the undergraduate School of Theology and Ministry (STM) started a KERN program. They designed a program that would recruit high school students into the KERN, would get them to the bachelor's degree in 3 years, then would get them a MA in Christian Ministry by the end of the fifth year, a package that was MDIV equivalent. The fourth year would be residential on campus and the fifth would be done in conjunction with an internship at a teaching church.

The decision to locate the KERN in STM made sense. As now President Wright says, "It takes a person." There was no one in the Seminary to shepherd this one, and I was barely keeping my head above water with what was already on my plate as Dean. Wayne had long conceptualized the Seminary as serving adult students, individuals who were already in ministry, less students just out of college.

By contrast, there were those in STM that wanted it (e.g., Russ Gunsalus, who was then over youth ministry, and Keith Drury) and they saw it as exactly what those in delayed adolescence needed. I remember what I considered the most convincing argument for having it in STM--these students want to hang around a little longer with the undergraduate professors they have grown to love, not switch to strangers.

(What made the most sense to me in theory was for the students to do three years with the undergrad, whose strengths were in Bible and theology, and then finish their MDIV with Wesley in two years, whose strengths were the practice of ministry. That way they would end up with an MDIV in 5 years. Trinity has a program like this one.)

b. The unintended consequences of this move were that IWU was now on a trajectory where STM, Seminary, and eventually CAPS all might have ministry related graduate programs. So Duke University has academic graduate programs in fields like biblical studies and theology, and Duke Divinity School has programs in biblical studies in these areas too.

Defining what ministry-related graduate programs the Seminary does and which STM does and which CAPS Religion does remains a key task in the days to come. Right now, you might say that STM does "launch" degrees and degrees relating to Bible, theology, church history, as well as degrees of a more academic nature (e.g., a PhD would more likely emerge from STM than the Seminary, which hopes to add a DMIN next year). The Seminary focuses on adults and more ministry-practice degrees.

Previously on Seminary take-aways:

Pre-Seminary
1. There are key moments of opportunity.
2. You need the right people.
3. Good leaders collaborate and navigate.

Year 1: Launch Year
4. Innovation requires some trial and error. (1)
5. Innovation requires some trial and error. (2)
6. Innovation requires some trial and error. (3)
7. New leaders bring new strengths. (1)

Year 2: Growing Pains
8. Administration never ends.
9. New leaders bring new strengths. (2)
10. New leaders bring new strengths. (3)

Year 3: The Year of Maturity
11. Complexity works against sustainability.
12. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (1)
13. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (2)
14. Our guinea pigs survived.

Year 4: The Year of the Faculty
15. Faculty share governance with administration. (1)
16. Faculty share governance with administration. (2)
17. Faculty share governance with administration. (3)
18. Faculty share governance with administration. (4)
19. Growth means addition. (1)
20. Growth means addition. (2)

Friday, March 06, 2015

Immigration Connection

Check out this article by David Drury that relates especially to a course we are offering at Wesley Seminary in May that will train a person to help someone move toward legal status. It is part of God's mission to care for those who are stuck in the middle.

20. Growth means addition. (2)

... continued growth by new venues

1. In our fourth year, 2012-2013, Wayne facilitated the launch of two new venues for the Seminary--a contextualized, urban MDIV cohort in Indianapolis and a contextualized MA cohort based out of 12Stone® Church.

Somehow, Wayne Schmidt has a way of running into the right people at the right time. I don't know how he does this. Russ Gunsalus has this gift too. I don't think I've mentioned the connections Wayne made with the AME and CME churches of Indiana in his first year. Some pastors from Indiana North actually went with Wayne and other Seminary students to a special AME event together in the summer of 2010.

Sometime in 2012, Wayne happened to be sitting next to Bishop Benjamin, of Light of the World Church in Indianapolis, at a dinner in Indianapolis. Reverend Benjamin was about to retire from this large, primarily African American church. While there were seminaries available for individuals in his church who might want ministerial education, there were no seminaries who were willing to contextualize a curriculum with them for an urban, African-American context.

By contrast, this sort of contextualization was the very stuff of Wesley seminary.

2. So it is no surprise that there were soon discussions about starting a contextualized urban cohort in Indianapolis that might serve Bishop Benjamin's ministry network. I consider it providential that the seminary had just added Kwasi Kena and Safiyah Fosua to its faculty. The Benjamin cohort wouldn't have been half as fantastic as it has been for these students if they had not taken on this challenge! In fact, we probably would not have even done it.

There are some strong reflections to have here. Was it too much to ask of them, to take on this extra work in their very first year? How much pressure did they feel to do it, not yet knowing whether IWU would allow a person to say no to such proposals? They have told me the horror stories that some people of diversity can experience when asked to join a diversity challenged institution.

There is a kind of load creep that often happens. The diverse person may gradually be given more and more diversity related tasks with little or no additional support. Whenever anything vaguely related to diversity comes up, this person is called on. The importance of sharing the load of diversity can slip from the mind of the institution as the diverse individual, perhaps increasingly hidden from sight, bears a greater and greater burden.

Certainly IWU is committed not to let such things happen!

3. One of the first questions was where. Hold it at Light of the World church? Quickly the conversation turned to IWU's Indianapolis Education Center North (IECN). The Graduate Ministry program had previously held MA classes there, and people like Bob, me, and Chris Bounds had taught for it. Certainly that would be easier when it came to matters of accreditation.

4. I must bear the blame for one of the biggest burdens on this new cohort. We scheduled their classes on Saturdays. I did not feel that we had enough time in an evening to do the MDIV in an evening class. Our onsite version of the MDIV typically does spiritual formation from 9-10am, then the praxis course from 10am-4pm, with of course time for lunch. Within that five hours, a praxis and foundations professor divide up the time roughly 2/3 to 1/3.

The particular onsite formula has varied a little depending on the schedules of the three professors involved. There were times where the foundations were in the morning or the spiritual formation at lunch or perhaps there was a one hour foundations slot at the end of the day. As more and more have moved to a 10-6 or 6-10 format, the foundations professor only has to drive to Indy 6 times in the semester.

So, since I did not think 4 hours on a weekday evening was enough seat time, we scheduled the first Benjamin MDIV cohort for Saturdays. What a sacrifice, both for professors and students. Three years worth of Saturdays committed! What a burden to put on Drs. Kena and Fosua! They have not taught all the classes, but they have had a hand in most.

Teaching this Saturday cohort was life-changing for me and I count them all dear friends. I know other professors have felt the same. Their sacrifices and real world ministries make me feel like I don't do anything for the kingdom at all. They will truly inherit the earth.

5. We wanted the curriculum for this cohort to be contextualized for an urban, African-American context, a task that largely fell on Kwasi's shoulders. Early on we met with a number of potential professors largely suggested by Bishop Benjamin. That first class, they came and taught segments.

Kwasi picked books and resources appropriate for the group for both the MDIV and then later for an MA group. He modified assignments (Safiyah too). I've hardly ever seen a cohort that was tighter.

6. Necessity is the mother of invention, and Dr. Fosua and Dr. Kena have innovated the format beyond anything that occurred to me. I only wish I had come up at the start with the options they have developed. For one, Dr. Fosua, as their spiritual formation professor for the program, has arranged the schedule so that she only has to go down to Indy four times throughout the semester. The praxis course then could go from 9-4 on the other weeks.

Another innovation is to meet a little less face-to-face and then carry the material of the class forward into one online discussion for the rest of the week. Then they might only need to meet from 9am-1pm each Saturday.

7. We launched a second Benjamin MDIV cohort in November 2014. Dr. Kena and Dr. Fosua have to be given the credit for its innovative format. It meets on Monday nights. This first semester, because the group is just bonding, she meets with the group from 6-7pm. I suspect in later semesters she'll just go down every four weeks for a whole evening of spiritual formation.

Then from 7-10, the praxis course is in session with one of the two team professors in a 10-6 formation. This semester its Kwasi Kena and Luigi Peñaranda for Missional Church. But to finish out the requisite hours, they finish the week with an online discussion. That way they get the seat time while only meeting for 4 hours face-to-face one evening a week.

8. In August 2013, we started a Benjamin MA on Monday nights. For these, the Benjamin team that had met at the beginning went into action. There were some interesting dynamics here and I believe some good lessons learned. With only a couple full-time IWU professors teaching, it has required more effort for this cohort to feel connected to the Seminary. With Saturdays full, Dr. K and Dr. S have not been able to teach for it.

I think we have also seen just how significant the feeling of belonging to the Seminary is. All the other cohorts have either started on campus at the Seminary or have started elsewhere with full-time Seminary faculty launching it. This cohort, initially floating in the generic sea of the IECN campus, has struggled much more to have an identity.

IWU branch campuses also have their own advisors, so that added an extra layer of complication. And of course it's a little weird for a campus chaplain to come to give a devotion to a Seminary cohort, especially when they're meeting for an hour of spiritual formation. :-)

Previously on Seminary take-aways:

Pre-Seminary
1. There are key moments of opportunity.
2. You need the right people.
3. Good leaders collaborate and navigate.

Year 1: Launch Year
4. Innovation requires some trial and error. (1)
5. Innovation requires some trial and error. (2)
6. Innovation requires some trial and error. (3)
7. New leaders bring new strengths. (1)

Year 2: Growing Pains
8. Administration never ends.
9. New leaders bring new strengths. (2)
10. New leaders bring new strengths. (3)

Year 3: The Year of Maturity
11. Complexity works against sustainability.
12. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (1)
13. There are advantages to being embedded in a broader university. (2)
14. Our guinea pigs survived.

Year 4: The Year of the Faculty
15. Faculty share governance with administration. (1)
16. Faculty share governance with administration. (2)
17. Faculty share governance with administration. (3)
18. Faculty share governance with administration. (4)
19. Growth means addition. (1)