Sunday, October 03, 2010

Israel's Destiny 3

More excerpts...
___________
So God’s plan, Paul says, is that Israel currently reject Jesus as Messiah, which in some way must have facilitated the Gentile mission in Paul’s mind. Paul also saw the acceptance of the gospel by Gentiles as somehow making his own people jealous. He does not spell out exactly what he meant, but he apparently believed it would somehow eventually lead ethnic Israel back to God, to belief in Jesus as Messiah.

His argument thus reaches its climax in 11:25-32. Part of Israel is currently experiencing a hardening (11:25). There is no question what Israel Paul has in mind here. He is talking about the “hardened” part, those ethnic Jews who have not believed in Jesus. He is talking about the “natural branches” that God has grafted out, unbelieving Jews. The purpose, as he has said, is so that the “full number” of the Gentiles can come in.

But then, Paul says, “all Israel will be saved.” Again, Paul’s statement may be difficult for us to process, but it is not ambiguous. It is the contrast between “part” and “whole.” Right now part is hardened. Then all will be saved. Some have ripped this statement out of its literary context as if to say by “all Israel will be saved” Paul is simply saying that all true Israel will be saved, hearkening back to 9:6. But not only would such a meaning be pointless to say—“all the saved will be saved.” It ignores the clear train of thought. Right now part is out. Then all will be in.

Christ will thus take away the current sins of Israel (11:27). He will “turn godlessness away from Jacob” (11:26). Paul is not very clear about what he is saying. He says that “The deliverer will come from Zion,” referring to Jesus. But is he talking about Jesus coming out of Zion in the future or about Jesus previous coming out of Zion? [1] Is Paul saying Israel will believe around the time of Jesus’ return from heaven, perhaps in preparation for Christ’s return or as a consequence of his return? Or is he simply quoting a passage that generally indicates the Jews will believe in their messiah?

Either way, Paul is clearly pointing to the eventual salvation of Israel. Right now, they are God’s enemies because of what he is doing with the Gentiles (11:28). But they are still the elect of God, the chosen ones. “God’s gifts and his call is irrevocable” (11:29), meaning that God will never turn his back on Israel. He might destroy a generation, but he will not break his word to Abraham. The Gentiles have received mercy because of Israel’s disobedience (11:30). But eventually Israel will also receive mercy because of what God is doing with the Gentiles (11:31), and God will then have mercy on everyone (11:32).

So it is not too difficult to understand what Paul was saying in these verses. What is difficult is for us to know what to do with them today! No doubt a certain kind of Christian expectation about the destiny of Israel played a role in the reestablishment of Israel as a nation in 1948. Is this political restoration what Paul was predicting?

[1] Interestingly, Paul seems to have modified the Old Testament quotation slightly, something New Testament authors regularly felt free to do.  The Greek Paul was reading said, “The redeemer will come because of Zion.”  Paul—or the tradition he was using—changed it to “The redeemer will come out of Zion.” 

Saturday, October 02, 2010

Nothing's Wrong with the Constitution!

We have the most conservative Supreme Court we have had in decades.  The nation is more against abortion that it has been since Roe vs. Wade.  And all the decisions made by the Obama administration and the Congress these last two years have been less socialist than any of the administrations--Republican or Democrat--in the 60s and 70s.  It's economic policies are hardly any more "socialist" than the Reagan administration.  Nobody even seems to know what the word means!

Good grief!  No one remembers anything before 9-11.  And everyone thinks the economic situation before the recent recession was healthy and normal--whether you're a greedy capitalist or a free credit socialist.  They worked hand in hand you know.  Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac handed out the loans to the free credit socialists and then the greedy capitalists truly caused a world economic crisis by bundling them up and playing volleyball with them.

I would normally vote for Mike Pence but his "waves of grain" commercial really ticks me off.  The whole game the Republicans are playing ticks me off (I realize that they all play games, and Elsworth isn't even competent enough to have any commercials going at all).  No information of any kind in Pence's commercial.  As it hypnotizes you with waving wheat and soft "American" tones it says, "Just vote for me and everything will be right as rain again."  It makes me feel like I'm being drugged.

Let me build a bridge to the past for you.  Vote for me and I'll take us back to an agrarian economy. 

Israel's Destiny 2

I didn't manage to work on this any more yesterday, but the rest of this chapter is my remaining goal for the rest of the day.  I'll jot down a few words for now here and then hopefully keep working elsewhere...
_______________
But to get the full picture of what Paul really thought, we cannot simply read Romans 9 by itself.  If we do not go on to read Romans 11 we will end up with a skewed sense even of Paul's view toward Israel.  For example, one perspective we sometimes find today is called "replacement theology."  It is the idea that the church has now completely replaced Israel within God's plan.  This view gets a lot of mileage out of Romans 9:6: "not all who are descended from Israel are Israel."  Such individuals see the church as the true Israel, and only ethnic Jews that believe are part of true Israel along with Gentiles who have believed.  Certainly they do not see any place in God's plan for the nation of Israel or non-believing Jews today.

This perspective likely contains some truth, but it is certainly not the whole story.  You can only get this impression if you lift Romans 9:6 out of Paul's broader discussion.  Romans 11 in particular makes it clear that Paul saw the dominance of Gentile Christianity as a temporary thing and that, in fact, ethnic Israel itself for the most part would eventually believe in Jesus.  It has not happened yet, and Paul himself might be surprised not only at how much time has passed but also to know that God allowed Israel to be destroyed for almost two thousand years.  But we cannot let these complications stand in the way of listening to what Paul was saying.  We have to let him say what he said and then deal with it in our theology.

Has God rejected his people, Paul asks in Romans 11:1?  No.  Paul himself is an Israelite, so obviously not all Israel is toast.  As in the days of Elijah, God has chosen a "remnant" in his graciousness.  So far Paul sounds a lot like he did in Romans 9.  God gave the unbelieving in Israel a "sluggish spirit" so that they would not see or hear the message (11:8-9, NRSV).  "Their eyes are darkened so they cannot see" (11:10).

However, then he goes on.  "Did they stumble so as to fall beyond recovery?" (11:11).  Here is the key to understanding what is really going on here.  Even those "predestined for disbelief" can come back!  This is certainly not the kind of predestination of some Christian traditions.  Indeed, John Calvin logically reasoned that if God decides who will be saved, then you must remain saved till the end.  God does not change his mind but has made the decision from all eternity and your will has no part in it.

The predestined in this scheme cannot change places. [1]  Either God has chosen you or he has not.  But in the rest of Romans 11, Paul begins to chart out the eventual return of ethnic Israel from its current "hardness of heart."  What is going on right now, Paul says, is that God had a plan to bring the Gentiles to salvation.  Israel's current hardness is all part of the plan.  First, God is using their hardness of heart to bring the Gentiles in.  Then he will bring the Jews back in again too.

Clearly Paul is trying to make sense of what must have been a troubling phenomenon among the earliest Christians: Gentiles seemed much more receptive to the Christian message than the Jews themselves did.  Paul chalks it up to the mystery of God's will.  This is all part of the plan.  If you think of a tree, God has cut out a good number of the "natural branches" and grafted in some Gentile branches that were not part of the original tree (11:17).  He is making the natural branches jealous (11:11).

But this is of course not a matter for boasting, as if the Gentile branches are "eternally secure."  If God did not spare the natural branches, he certainly will not spare the granted in branches if they were to become arrogant about their new identity (11:21).  Clearly these are not the sorts of things we would expect Paul to say if the Calvinist interpretation of Romans 9 were correct.  The destiny of each type of branch is reversable.  Indeed, the way the branches conduct themselves has a direct bearing on whether they get to stay in the tree at all.  In short, Paul sees one's location in the tree as contingent on human response.  Most of ethnic Israel is currently out because of unbelief (11:20), but they can come back in if they start believing.  Many Gentiles are in because they have believed, but if they become arrogant they will be grafted back out.


[1] It is true that, just as in Romans 9, Paul is not talking specifically about individuals in Romans 11.  Paul is talking about the direction of Israel as a whole.  Someone might suggest, then, that while the direction of Israel as a whole might change, Paul's plan for specific individuals must logically remain the same.  But can you see how far removed this entire discussion is from what Paul is actually talking about?  Romans 9-11 is focused on individuals but on the fate of Israel.

Friday, October 01, 2010

I woke up after a twenty-five year sleep...

It's always fun when your kids are young and your family sees them after a gap of a couple months.  You've been there all along and so haven't noticed so much how much they've grown, but the grandparents do.  It's like they've got in a time machine to the future or been in a coma for a year (or been stuck on the island of Lost--my wife and I finally finished the series, by the way).

So I've been keeping up, mostly, with the technology shifts.  I don't have an iPad but it's on my list of things to buy in five years when the first wave of children in college is over.  I've blogged for six years.  I do Facebook.  I twitter.  I've self-published.  I'm looking at our publishers as they contemplate translating things into Spanish and thinking, hey, give me Google translate and an editor to fix things I miss and I'll have some books done in a few weeks.

But I had one of those time warp things happen to me earlier in the week.  I haven't hardly played any piano for twenty-five years (and truth be told, I never really did anyway).  But I thought I might try to learn a line a week of Rachmaninoff's Prelude in C Sharp Minor on Saturdays.  So I was thinking about where I could buy some sheet music...

And then I realized all I needed to do was a Google search, which brought up http://www.free-scores.com/download-sheet-music.php?pdf=9130, and I printed the first page for tomorrow (maybe) using the wireless in my house to send it to the wireless copier, printer, scanner in my bedroom. 

A quick look on YouTube and here is a pretty good view of the hands (and thankfully he plays slowly): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYQX-hjf3TY.  And here's an audio of Rachmaninoff himself playing it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mXGSfJn3nKQ&feature=related.

How this planet has changed since I blasted off 25 years ago!

Schenck's Commentary Faves 1

Now that I find myself the Bible professor (at least for the moment) at a new seminary that is mostly online, the question of what commentaries to use surfaces repeatedly.  Online students can get any books they need in a day or two through Off Campus Library Services (which are excellent here at IWU).  But many would like to know what commentaries to buy on Logos or in hard copy.

Bible teachers almost always stumble at this point.  If you're Ben Witherington, you've written a commentary on everything and can just recommend your books.  I used to recommend they buy David Bauer's Annotated Guide to Biblical Resources for Ministry, since he catalogs everything and gives good advice.  But I've heard Hendrickson won't let him revise it since they think everything's going online with such things.  As much as I'd like to stick it up their nose, they're probably right.

So I was working in Colossians this morning and thought to myself, "Yes, Dunn's Colossians commentary is the one.  Forget all the other mamby pambies and go buy his."  Scholars will always say, buy by the author more than the series and even then the same author is usually better at some things than others.  But who has the money for that?!  If you want to be more scholarly, I suppose go with the Word Biblical Commentary.  If you want it more for preaching, go with the NIV Application series (realizing it does lean Calvinist at points).

So here's the first of what might turn out to be eventually a list of "Schenck's Faves." 

Colossians and Philemon
James D. G. Dunn, The Epistles to the Colossians and to Philemon, NIGTC (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1996).   

People sometimes think I'd be able to tell you right off which one I'd pick for Romans and Hebrews, but alas, I can't decide yet.  Ask me to write them and I'll tell you :-)

The Destiny of Israel 1

I'm way, way off in my deadline for the second Paul book and have a new target of November 1.  In my mind, that means Romans 9-11 has to be done this weekend.  And since I never post more than 1000 words here at a time, that means I'll only be posting a fraction of the rest of the chapter here.  But for today, here's a pulse through the second section of the chapter.  Hopefully I can then blaze a trail tomorrow and Sunday through the rest.
____________
The Destiny of Israel
As we have said, Romans 9-11 is not really about whether God determines who will be saved and who will be damned.  Individual predestination is a related issue, but it is really tangential to what Paul is really discussing in these chapters, which is the fate of Israel.  It must have seemed peculiar indeed that more Gentiles would believe that Jesus was king than Jews themselves! [1]  One of the purposes of Romans 9-11 was to explain this strange phenomenon.  Paul's answer, in the end, was the mystery of God's will.  If this is how God wants it, then that is his business and you had better shut up about it!

But to get the full picture of what Paul really thought, we cannot simply read Romans 9 by itself.  If we do not go on to read Romans 11 we will end up with a skewed sense even of Paul's view toward Israel.  For example, one perspective we sometimes find out there today is called "replacement theology."  It is the idea that the church has now completely replaced Israel within God's plan.  This view gets a lot of mileage out of Romans 9:6: "not all who are descended from Israel are Israel"...
____________
Sorry... I've just run out of time and have to get to work on other things.

[1] We can debate what the precise percentages were, but surely Paul's argument doesn't make sense unless it was not at least perceived that Gentiles in general had reacted more positively to the message than Jews in general had.

Thursday, September 30, 2010

God's Boss 3

What we are discussing here is the question of God's "sovereignty," his authority over everything.  Friedrich Nietzsche, the famous skeptic of the late 1800s, tells how he came to the conclusion early in his life that if we are to thank God for the good things that happen to us, we have to give him credit for the bad as well. [1]  Coming to this conclusion was part of the unravelling of his faith.

But his idea is nothing new.  This is the standard view, for example, of the bulk of the Old Testament--"The LORD gave and the LORD has taken away; may the name of the LORD be praised" (Job 1:21).  Similarly, some Christian traditions like the Calvinist one tend to see God orchestrating even the details of our lives.  A very popular Christian book a few years back, The Purpose Driven Life, presented a view of life that saw God's hand in almost everything that happens to you in life, God teaching you lessons and helping you grow in almost every detail. [2]

However, I as someone from the Wesleyan tradition do not accept this view.  For one thing, we also find passages in Scripture like James 1:13, which says no one should think that God tempts them to do wrong.  "For God cannot be tempted by evil, nor does he tempt anyone."  This verse gets at the heart of Nietzsche's complaint.  If God is truly in control of the world, then he must also have control of the evil that happens in the world.

But there is a difference between God's directive will and God's permissive will, whether he directly causes everything that happens or in many cases only allows them to happen.  Yes, God is sovereign.  If he is king, all-knowing, and all-powerful, then he must ultimately be in control of everything.  The question is if he has created a world with some degree of freedom or if he micro-manages everything directly.

Some of those who take a very directive view argue that if God would allow someone to disagree with him or violate his will, then he would not truly be sovereign.  But this argument seems rather unsophisticated.  Could not a parent intentionally allow a child experience the consequences of disobedience so that the child can learn, for the growth of the child?  In fact, this is a much more mature and sophisticated picture of God, rather than one that almost sees him flying off the handle in rage every time someone disobeys him or worse--as someone who causes people to disobey him so he can how his greatness at blasting them out of the water?  In short, is God not sovereign enough to choose to allow people to disagree with him?

This is the position I take as a Christian and that I will advocate in the rest of this chapter.  Romans 9 does have some "naughty verses" for this point of view, but every theological point of view has its passages to deal with, and the Calvinist view seems to create a picture of God that is not only incoherent, but makes him at least borderline evil, indeed almost Satanic.  It does not fit with the picture of God elsewhere and, in the end, seems more a particular kind of "language game" in Paul that we should not take completely literally. 

Yes, for God to be sovereign he must "sign off" on everything that happens.  But it does not mean he must orchestrate and plan everything that happens.  The best suggested answer to the "problem of evil," although it is not perfect, is that a world in which God gives people the freedom to make good and bad moral choices is a better world than one in which they cannot help but do good.  God thus has created a world where people can disobey him for a greater good--and a world where we find evil and pain.

[1] Beyond Good and Evil

[2] biblio...

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Humility

The last of this particular set of backed up assignments.  There may be hope for normal backed-up-ness by Friday!
______
The apostle Paul gives us a good definition for humility when he tells the Philippians to "regard others as better than yourselves.  Let each of you look not to your own interests, but to the interests of others " (2:3-4).  He then goes on to quote an early Christian poem about how Jesus emptied himself of the rights and privileges of divinity and instead took on the status of a servant (2:6-7).  Even then in human form he humbled himself even further to one of the most shameful kinds of death: crucifixion (2:8). 

Paul's example of Jesus, as well as his own example, point to humility more as a way of living and behaving rather than of self-esteem.  Humility for Paul thus means to put the needs of others above those of yourself.  It is "not to think of yourself more highly than you ought to think, but to think with sober judgment, each according to the measure of faith that God has assigned" (Rom. 12:3).  Christian humility is thus not self-effacement, for we as humans are created in the image of God, both female and male (Gen. 1:27).  God made humanity a little lower than God (Ps. 2:5) and to denigrate each other is to insult God who made us (e.g. Jas. 3:9).

At the same time, humility is also an attitude, of which arrogance is the opposite.  An arrogant person is one who does not realize that everything they have is a gift from the Lord, that that we entered this world naked and will exit it the same (Job 1:21).  Dust we are, and to dust we shall return (Eccl. 3:20).  The humble recognize who they are before God (cf. Isa. 6) and rejoice in the greatness of his love.

A Grief Observed 2

One of those days!  I got a phone call from my step-daughter around 10 that something was wrong with our Great Dane.  So I took him to the vet.  One thing led to another.  X-ray showed that his intestines had twisted around his stomach and spleen.  First they tried to depressurize.  Then emergency surgery.  Then I was getting my kids out of school to say good bye before they euthanized him.

Such is life and such is a small trial run for bigger crises and tragedies.  I heard the familiar yawn of Bruce this morning at 6:10 saying, "I'm ready to go out and eat now."  He scarfed down his food--the ultimate cause of the problem.  Big dogs sometimes gulp down too much air because they eat too quickly.  Six hours later he was dead.

Telling my children is the hardest part, a microcosm of deeper griefs.  "We'll get through this."  The great "No" that is impossibility.  Keep active.  Keep moving.  Get your mind on other things.  Tomorrow will be a little better and the next day a little better.  It won't hurt any more than it hurts right now.

Monday, September 27, 2010

Interesting quote about the New Atheists

Jonathan Parsons pointed out this piece in the Chronicle of Higher Education (http://chronicle.com/blogPost/A-Black-Mark-for-Calvin/27197/) on John Schneider at Calvin College.  He has been exploring possible ways to fit evolutionary biology with Calvinist Christianity.

What caught my eye for this blog is not that debate but this comment by Michael Ruse, who describes himself as someone who has become a non-believer over time.  He indicates that both individuals like himself, an atheist who respects the intelligence of someone like Schneider, and people like Schneider, who are trying to fit faith with their academic disciplines, seem to get it from both sides.

He says this:

"These days it is not easy for those of us who argue that science and religion can live in harmony. For my pains, I have been likened to Neville Chamberlain – the pusillanimous appeaser of Munich.

"Just last week, the editor of the British magazine the New Humanist, who argued for some modicum of accommodation, was called a quisling – after the Norwegian Nazi who supported the Germans in their Second World War occupation of his country. But really, what does this matter to us? I rather thrive on abuse. The case of a brave scholar like John Schneider shows too well that even today, at top-quality institutions, being willing to push the boundaries of understanding can come at great personal stress and possible cost. Such people will never get any respect from the New Atheists, who simply hate everything and anything to do with religion and who have nothing but contempt for believers. The rest of us should realize just how very perverting religion can be in even the best places and should applaud those who are believers who stand up against its misuse."

Interesting!  The Trinity of ignoramus new atheists that come to my mind are Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchins, and Sam Harris.  I can respect a person who does not believe because they have intellectually come to particular conclusions.  But I experience these sorts of new atheists not only as naive in their portrayal of religion but as downright jerks.

The Bible and Preaching

My post on the seminary blog for the week: The Bible and Preaching: Four Tips

Sunday, September 26, 2010

Spiritual Life... 21st century...

I've been putting a slow pulse through a new book idea on the side.  I'm not going to write much of it here--I do enough of that sort of thing.  I thought I might give a little glimpse on some Sundays.  Believe it or not, it has to do with spiritual formation.  Here's today's excerpt:
______________
What I do feel confident about is that we are in the middle of a major cultural shift. We are shifting away from a world of sequence—where we do things in order from beginning to end—to a world of associations—where we slide from one thing to another by unplanned connections. We live in a world where a dictionary like Wikipedia will come together overnight instead of a ten year project where each entry is assigned to a scholar. This new world offers a level of stimulation that can feed the attention deficit like never before, but it will also make it harder for more and more people to engage successfully in the sequential world of conventional spirituality.

At this point some will complain, as if we can actually do something about it. Yeah, that’s going to happen. The internet is here to stay. Teachers who think they can shut wireless out of the classroom are destined for failure. Parents who think they can somehow hold back the flood of endless text message exchanges are destined to lose before they even start trying to fight. This is just the way things are going to be from here on out.

Plato bemoaned how writing softened the memory. Our parents’ math teachers bemoaned the calculator. Just ten years ago traditional educators bemoaned online education and called the internet a fad. Publishers have bemoaned the rise of the electronic book. Bemoan on—and adjust or go out of business.

The way we do spiritual formation will have to adjust too...

Saturday, September 25, 2010

God's Boss 2

Romans 9-11 deal with the question of why it is that so many Gentiles had come to believe on Christ when God's people themselves, the Jews, by and large had not.  In the older interpretation of Romans--that it was about how to get to heaven--these chapters seemed completely out of place.  One scholar even suggested a long time ago that these chapters did not even belong here, that they had been spliced in at an arbitrary place.

But if you have been reading the last few chapters, hopefully you can see that they are completely appropriate here.  Romans 1-4 dealt broadly with the fact that Jews, just like Gentiles, were sinners and violators of the Law.  All have sinned, Paul said (3:23), both Jew and Gentile, and thus Jews needed Christ's atonement just as Gentiles did.  Romans 6-9 deal broadly wih the question of the Jewish Law.  What was the purpose of the Law, then, if keeping it did not make a person right with God?

So questions like, "Why has Israel not believed?" or "Has God abandoned his people?" fit perfectly with the things Paul has been discussing thus far in the letter.  In Romans 9, Paul's answer is basically, "Who are you to question God?  God is God and can do whatever he wants."  Of course Paul goes on to answer these questions, so it is unbelieving Jews and Judaizing Christians he has in mind, people who reject that Gentiles can be part of God's people without getting circumcised and converting to Judaism.

His answer to such people is that God is the one who decides who he will have mercy on and who he will not.  Paul is not primarily talking about individuals, another important piece of the puzzle here.  His logic, especially if taken completely literally, does have implications for individuals.  But individual predestination is not what he is discussing.  He is discussing God's right to have mercy on the Gentiles if he wants to do so.

"Not all who are descended from Israel are Israel," Paul says (9:6).  It is those who have believed who are, those who have pursued a right standing with God through their trust in Christ (9:30-32).  It is only a portion of Israel that are truly Israel, a "remnant" (9:27).  Meanwhile, Paul says later, while he has grafted some of the natural branches out, he has also grafted some Gentile branches in (9:17).

Paul pushes back strongly on anyone who would question God's judgment in doing such things.  "Who are you, O man, to talk back to God?" (9:20).  "Shall what is formed say to him who formed it, 'Why did you make me like this?'" (9:20).  Clay does not have the right to complain about the way the potter has made it, and if God wants to make some pottery for noble purposes and other pottery for skeet shooting, that is his right as God (9:21-22).

Certainly it is!  But it is essential to recognize that Paul is making an extreme point.  The tone reminds me of some of the things parents have said to their children when they are acting up.  "If you don't stop I'm going to pull this car over and make you walk!"  "I'll take your TV and throw it in the trash!"  "I brought you into this world, and I can take you out!"  They are extreme statements that, thankfully, the vast majority of parents do not actually mean.  If they followed through with them, they would go to jail. [1]

God is certainly in charge.  God certainly is the boss.  I personally believe that God could command us to sacrifice our children if he wanted to (cf. Gen. 22).  The sovereignty of God, his absolute authority, is a key Christian belief.  It is also a key Christian belief that God does not act on his freedom in certain ways because of who he is.  The heart of the predestination-free will debate is the fact that the logic of Romans 9, when taken straightforwardly, seems to conflict not only logically with the central Christian belief that God is love, but it seems to conflict with both the way Paul operated and with other things the New Testament says.  By the end of the chapter, we hope to have sorted out these sorts of tensions as best we can.

[1] And let's be very clear here, what the predestinarian is suggesting here goes well beyond the outrage we would feel toward someone who took a newborn, tossed it in a trash bin and left it for dead.  The double predestinarian is suggesting that God makes certain people fail and then torches them in all eternity because they failed.

Next: God's directive and permissive will

Friday, September 24, 2010

Gospel

I'm trying to crank out something due a long time ago.  For whatever reason, things flow out of me better when I at least think someone is listening.  So here goes cranking:
_______
The word gospel has meant different things in different contexts, most of which relate broadly to the idea of "good news."  The gospels of Matthew and Mark both make the "gospel of the kingdom" the essence of Jesus' earthly teaching (e.g. Matt. 4:23; Mark 1:15).  This fact suggests that Isaiah 52:7 provides key background to how Jesus saw his ministry.  In particular, Jesus likely saw his ministry as part of the restoration of God's reign within Israel and the world, including the defeat of the evil powers that currently rule the earth.

The original context of Isaiah 52:7 was of course the return of Israel from captivity in Babylon around the year 538BC.  The statement in that verse, "our God reigns," seems to connect directly to Jesus' preaching of the kingdom of God, the rule of God returning to earth as it is in heaven.  Early Christians like Paul primarily read this verse in its Greek translation, where they found the verb "to proclaim the good news" (euangelizomai).  It is thus quite possible that the early Christian use of the word gospel started among Greek-speaking Christians who connected Jesus' preaching of the rule of God to the Greek sense of a gospel as the announcement of good news of a momentous sort.  For example, a famous inscription from 9BC about the Roman emperor Augustus of him as a savior whose enthronement was good news (euangelion) for humanity.

A major focus of the gospel in Matthew, Mark, and Luke is Jesus' ministry to the poor.  The verb "to proclaim the good news" also appears in the Greek of Isaiah 61:1, which Luke pictures Jesus quoting as the very inaugural address of his ministry (Luke 4:18): "The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he has anointed me to bring good news to the poor."  Matthew 4:13 also connects Jesus ministry of healing to his proclamation of the good news.  Matthew, Mark, and Luke thus understood the gospel not only in terms of the coming reign of God over the earth but also in terms of the liberating ministry of Jesus to those who were oppressed and disempowered on earth.

In Jesus' ministry, the good news was about God's reign.  When we get to Paul's writings, the gospel is about Jesus Christ himself as king.  Romans 1:3-4 give us a good sense of what Paul means by the word.  The gospel is about Jesus being king.  He is descended from king David in his humanity and enthroned as "Son of God" as part of his resurrection.  It is important to recognize that the title "Son of God" has everything to do with Jesus being king, being the Messiah, the Christ.  The background for this phrase is firmly in Old Testament passages like 2 Samuel 7:14 and Psalm 2, both of which were originally about kings of Judah.  Other New Testament books also picture Jesus' exaltation to God's right hand as a kind of enthronement as Son of God (e.g. Acts 13:33; Hebrews 1:5).

Paul's sense of the gospel of Jesus is thus much like the inscription about Augustus.  The good news is that Jesus has been enthroned as king.  As king he will bring justice and salvation to the earth.  The gospel thus extends beyond the fact that Jesus is king to the benefits and blessings that have come in consequence.

Mark 1:1 probably has a similar sense of the word gospel as Paul.  The beginning of Mark narrates the beginning of the good news that Jesus Christ is king.  Perhaps it is then a coincidence of history that the word gospel came to refer not just to the good news of Jesus as king but to the genre of books like Mark that present the good news about Jesus.  Thus we now refer to books like Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John as gospels, whereas originally their audience would have thought of them as biographies (Matthew, Mark, John) and a history (Luke-Acts).

Pledge to America

I increasingly feel like an outsider to both political parties.  I am not a Democrat and don't identify with their most vocal advocates.  But I scarcely identify with the Republicans I see on TV these days either (Bainer and McConnell).  I skimmed the Pledge to America put out by the GOP yesterday.  Here were some of my thoughts on the first 6 pages:

1. "We pledge to honor precepts that have been consistently ignored – particularly the Tenth Amendment, which grants that all powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people."

I wholeheartedly disagree and so would Abraham Lincoln.  This is backward looking and a clear sign that old South-North issues are at work here.  The Civil War settled this 150 years ago.  The future is global, not tribal. 

This part of the Constitution is a layer from 1791 and goes back to a time when the states were just beginning to meld after having been independent of each other before.  It was transitional legislation that became increasingly moot the longer we existed as one nation and particularly after the Civil War.  To emphasize this amendment is like emphasizing the right of Wesleyans to own a machine that runs on alcohol, insisted by Luther Lee at the founding of the Wesleyan Methodists because he had a patent on such an engine and didn't want the fact that Wesleyans didn't drink have any implications for his patent.

2. "We pledge to honor families, traditional marriage, life, and the private and faith-based organizations that form the core of our American values."

This is Calvinist code for--we insist on making those who aren't Christians conform to our values.  The concrete manifestations of this sentiment are not only unconstitutional, they are not even the way God operates in the world, who currently allows people either to choose or reject Him freely.  It reflects the inability of American Christians to distinguish between America and ancient Israel.  It reflects the ongoing impact of dispensationalism on American fundamentalist culture.  Christians in other parts of the world (and in other times and places) do not think like this.

3. "Washington has not been listening."

The Tea Party didn't win the last election (what, is it 30%).  The party that was elected has tried to carry out the values of those who elected it.  Elections have consequences.  The stalemate in getting anything done, for good or ill, has been caused by an unprecedented filibustering by the Republicans in Congress.  Perhaps it was for the better.  But what has most annoyed Americans about Washington these last two years is not the Health Care Bill but the refusal of the two parties in Washington to work together.  The voice of the people right now is primarily an anti-establishment vote, not a pro-Republican one.

Nevertheless, if Americans elect a new majority in Congress, then the shoe will be on the other foot, and the Democrats will have to decide whether they are going to filibuster too.  The President will have to decide how often to veto.  Elections have consequences.  We'll see whether a Democratic minority will be more noble or cut from the same cloth as the current Republican 40.

4. "We will rein in the red tape factory in Washington, DC by requiring congressional approval of any new federal regulation that may add to our deficit and make it harder to create jobs."

What does this mean?  We're a big country with a lot of people.  The precise mix between regulation and deregulation is an art, not a simplistic thing.  In effect this sentiment puts another layer of red tape on regulation.  Sometimes it could be good, or will it simply make it easier for special interests and big business to muck up restraints that could really help people?  That's really what this is about, right, making it harder for Congress to regulate Wall Street or reform health care?

5. "We will also prevent Washington from forcing responsible taxpayers to subsidize irresponsible behavior by ending bailouts permanently, canceling the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP), and reforming Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac."

This one scares me.  Anyone who thinks that the bailouts did not save the world economy is someone I want far away from Washington.  The bailouts were a Bush and Obama--by-partizan--thing and they saved the world.  This is the scary, scary thing about the Tea Party.  They don't understand 21st century math.  Which is better, for example, to have a GM that is still afloat, has paid back its loans, and still has thousands and thousands employed or if it had gone under and all those people were among the unemployed right now, dragging the economy even further down than it is with them employed? 

The question of whether it's fair is irrelevant and those who think it is simply a fairness thing should be far away from power.  It's a world survival thing.  This is very, very, very dangerous thinking and those who think like this are not smart enough at 21st century math to have control over the economy.  I guarantee you that whoever had been in power, including any Tea Party candidate right now, would also have bailed out some of these banks because there's a point at which you realize the world is at stake, and you have to ignore politics and those who don't know the details of what's going on.  I guarantee you, anyone who had been in power two years ago would have taken the advice of their economic advisors and bailed out some of these banks.

It may very well be that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac need reforming.  They probably do.  But make no mistake, it was the unbridled derivative trading of housing debt on Wall Street (=21st century math) that precipitated this economic crisis, not some African-American defaulting on a $20,000 house. 

Those are my opinions.  I am open to being convinced otherwise, but you'll have to be right to do it...

Thursday, September 23, 2010

God's Boss 1

Certain passages in the Bible are what I like to call "naughty verses." They are verses that we find difficult to fit into our general understanding, verses that at least seem to say things that go contrary to what we expect the Bible to say. Romans 9 is one such "naughty passage" for me. In Romans 9:22, for example, Paul speaks of certain humans that God has "prepared for destruction." 9:18 also gives a picture that, if we take it as it is, seems to say that God "hardens" certain people so that they will not do the sorts of things that lead to his mercy.

In other words, some of the verses in Romans 9 seem to say that God makes some people for skeet shooting. He makes them bad so that he can show his glory when he blows them to bits. Some Christians today and in the past for some reason love this image of God. A teacher like John Piper has made Romans 9 the ground zero of his thinking about God. He teaches something called "double predestination," the idea that God not only predetermines who will come to him and be saved, but also who will not come and be damned.

Suffice it to say, this view of God is difficult to reconcile with any meaningful sense of the idea that God is love. It says that God is nice to a certain select few that he has chosen according to his fancy, and he is mean to everyone else. Some who take this view might say that God only chooses who will be saved, that we were all damned anyway. In their view, God does not choose for anyone to be damned because we are all damned already. He only shows his mercy by choosing to save some who are already condemned. Adam had the freedom not to sin and he messed up. Now we cannot help but sin and so are all damned by default.

I appreciate this latter kind of "predestinarian" or "Calvinist," this doctrine taking its name from John Calvin. This last kind of Calvinist at least recognizes the difficulty of reconciling any normal definition of love with this view of God. But I'll at least hand it to the double predestinarian that Paul at least seems to go all the way in Romans 9. Paul pictures the damned complaining to God--why are you complaining about me, God? You made me this way (9:19-21)! So I at least have to hand it to the John Pipers of the world for taking Paul literally.

But the key to understanding Romans 9-11 is threefold. First, we need to understand the role these verses play in the overall thought of Romans. In particular, Paul is not really discussing our individual fates. He is trying to answer the question why so many Gentiles have believed in Jesus and most Jews have not. Second, we need to realize that fatalism and determinism were key features of the world in which Paul lived. In that sense, there is a cultural dimension to his arguments here. Finally, I would argue that the "language game" of predestination does not function primarily on a literal level. It serves two basic purposes: first, to affirm that God is in control and second, to assure the "elect" of their "destiny."

Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Redemption 3

Romans 8 ends on a triumphant note, a fitting end to the first eight chapters of the letter (1:16-8:39 in particular). Paul begins to reflect on our current situation in contrast to the one that is coming. Currently, he and other Christians are suffering (8:18), but a "glory" is coming. If the default state of humanity is currently that "all have sinned and are lacking the glory of God" (3:23, author's translation), those in Christ look forward to a "glory that will be revealed" (8:17-18).

Christ has set in motion the complete solution to the problem Adam's sin created. Already can our sins be forgiven, already can we be considered "innocent" in God's divine court. Already does the Spirit give life to our mortal bodies here and now so that we can walk in newness of life. But we still await the complete redemption of the creation, currently enslaved to corruption and decay (8:21) and we await our full attainment of the glory of God lost through sin.

These are the verses where Paul connects the enslavement of human flesh to the enslavement of the material creation. Of course he would connect these, because in his categories they are made of the same weak materials. They are both subject to spiritual powers, whether to the power of Sin as they currently are or to the power of the Spirit as they can and will be. These metaphors work for us as well, although if we were to speak on a literal level we would no doubt talk of brain structures and quantum variables.

Our "flesh" will thus always be our weakest point, where we are speaking of our skin, the part of us that belongs to this world. It is not a matter of a sinful nature being eradicated or suppressed. It is a matter of whether we are controlled by the Spirit or not. If we are controlled by the Spirit, then the power of Sin over our flesh is dead. But the weakness of our flesh and its potential to sin is always as close as our loss of the Spirit.

In our current location, embodied in weakness, potentially empowered in Spirit, we will always face potential struggles. Some of these come from the world around us. But if we neglect our connection to the Holy Spirit, they will come from our bodies as well. We have two powerful intercessors in our fight. Christ's atonement has already interceded for our justification at God's right hand (8:34). But the Spirit gives constant intercession for us as well, even beyond what we know we need (8:26).

So we are conquerors in this fight against Sin, at least we should be. No one in the world can accuse us when the Judge of all is on our side. Human courts and human authorities can cause us trouble, but their judgments are not the ones that count. God has already arranged for us to be transformed into the same kind of resurrection body that Jesus already has. This is the original meaning of Romans 8:29, that we are predestined to be "conformed to the likeness of his Son." Paul's emphasis is not on determinism, on God's "predestination." The emphasis is on what God has in store for us because he knew us ahead of time.

Nor is Paul discussing the question of whether I can mess up what God has in store. When Paul says that nothing can separate us from the love of Christ, the context clearly has in mind the "present sufferings" he has been talking about all along (8:18). No external force "in all creation" has any power to dislodge us from the destiny in the kingdom toward which God is leading us (8:39).

Paul links the redemption of the enslaved creation to the redemption of bodies that will take place for those who are alive and remain at Christ's return (8:22-23). The created realm presumably came under the power of Sin when Adam sinned. Therefore, it seems very likely that Paul saw eternity and the kingdom of God being on a redeemed, transformed earth rather than in heaven.

Tuesday, September 21, 2010

Leadership Failure, Spiritual Failure?

One of the assignments for my spiritual formation class this week is to reflect on this quote from Samuel Rima's book, Leading from the Inside Out: "every leadership failure is, at its root, a spiritual issue" (129). I want to admit that I may redirect this assignment in the future. It mostly seems a helpful question only if you agree with the quote, and the more I reflect on it, the more I disagree pretty strongly with it as a Wesleyan.

The Wesleyan tradition makes a sharp distinction between sin and weakness. Sin in particular for a Wesleyan coalesces around choices. I do not believe, for example, that having a tendency to be late to things is a sin. It can be a sin if I choose to be late to spite the person I'm meeting with or if I choose to ignore the effect my actions have on others.

To be sure, there are habits that are sinful that lay just below much conscious intentionality. My tendency to be late can "wrong" others by messing up their schedules. But I don't personally consider it a sin in general for a student to be 5 minutes late for class every day. I consider it a weakness. Weaknesses can easily slide into sins, but I see a pretty significant distinction.

A person who is consistently late to things or tends to be disorganized may very well fail in leadership. Certainly a person who is on time and organized has definite advantages in this respect. But I would not call a leadership failure for these reasons a moral or spiritual issue. In that sense, I disagree with Rima's statement. I knew a leader who was a great guy, very intelligent, and highly informed, but he was often unprepared for meetings and sometimes didn't pull the right triggers at the right time.

He ended up changing jobs. I don't know that I would call him a leadership failure, but I certainly wouldn't say there was any spiritual failure behind his leadership issues.

In the same way, I would just as strongly disagree with Bobby Clinton's sense that you cannot be a successful leader if your spiritual life is not in order. Poppycock. Many ministers are highly successful leaders because they are type A personalities. Their home life and families go to pot, their children rebel because they are busy leading the church effectively. They are spiritual failures on a grand scale--and highly effective leaders.

How many episodes of SVU and Criminal Minds show how the immense success of a particular kind of driven person correlates directly with failed home life. You can play around with words--they're not really successful leaders. That's circular and ridiculous. The question is whether an individual can cast appropriate vision and manage effectively and be a spiritual failure. Yes, you can!

Monday, September 20, 2010

Posts, Seminars, and Birthdays

First, I wanted to draw everyone's attention to an excellent post by John Drury on our Wesley seminary blog: http://wesleyanseminary.wordpress.com/2010/09/19/developing-ecclesiologists/ he puts the essence of WesSem @ IWU as well as anything I've seen.

Secondly, I wanted to remind anyone in the Marion area of the Monday Theological Research Seminar that meets today from 3:30 till we finish (but no later than 5). Today Dr. Steve Lennox is up with a paper he will also present at SBL in November: "Disability in Ancient Egypt." Next week is Chris Bounds, "Grace in the Early Church."

Finally, today's my 44th birthday. Every day is a day for goal setting for me, but birthdays and New Year are especially so. A year from now I'd like to be in Munich, Germany on sabbatical writing a book. I can see some things keeping that from happening but hope springs eternal. I hope that a year from now my second Paul book, the philosophy book, a few more Bible studies, and my research on the afterlife from my last sabbatical are either published or in the shoot.

And I've been working on some strange Schenck goals for several months now. I've admitted to myself that I will never achieve some of my earlier life goals. I'll never break a 5 minute mile. Frankly, I doubt I'll ever break a 6 minute mile again. I'll never be able to jump up and flip and land on my feet--something I used to think I would work up to.

But a few are still on the bucket list. I want to understand quantum mechanics and relativity before I die. I want to get a novel published. I want to be able to play some piano pieces by Rachmaninoff and Mendelssohn. Toward the first goal, I try to read two pages of math, physics, or chemistry a day. The idea is that by the time I'm fifty, I will have reviewed and expanded my knowledge of university calculus, physics, and chemistry. Then I hope to work through textbooks I've had for twenty some years on quantum mechanics and relativity in my fifties.

It's a little depressing to me how hard it has been to get my brain to wrap around things that used to flex so easily to me before. I understand what I've heard before. It's not that an older person can't learn new languages or new things in math and science. It just takes a lot longer. Ain't that the truth.

But it is going in. Once I get things, I am seeing some patterns I didn't recognize before. Well, I may have to give many of these dreams up too eventually. But at least for today, I understand what it means to say that the graph of a polynomial of odd degree with a positive lead coefficient will start at negative infinity on the left and eventually stretch up to positive infinity on the right. :-)

Saturday, September 18, 2010

Redemption 2

So it would seem, after working through Romans 6-8, that Paul does not in any way teach that sin is a normal part of a believer's life, despite justification by faith. Indeed, this is exactly the accusation he has been trying to fend off! Rumors are circulating about him that he teaches, "Let us do evil that good may result" (Rom. 3:8). People are saying he teaches sin is a good thing. He has worked hard in Romans 6-8 to show that this accusation is false. His message is that we cannot continue sinning (6:2, 15), that those who are "in the flesh" cannot please God (8:8).

But after we have finally heard Paul and shaken off the popular misinterpretation of Romans 7, we are still left with the problem of application. The reason Christians have been able to ignore Paul's repeated statements on sin in Romans 6-8 is because they identify so much with the second half of Romans 7: "what I want to do I do not do, but what I hate I do" (7:15). Experience trumps the surrounding two chapters. How then do we deal with the pervasive sense of sin so many have in their lives?

In this regard, the Wesleyan tradition from which I come has always been more optimistic than other traditions, at least on the books. At least in the past, we have preached that God can perform miracles in your spiritual life just as we believe he does with physical sickness. But "holiness," as our tradition used to call this hope, could also degenerate into petty legalism over what a person wore or how they did their hair. At one point in the mid-twentieth century, many of those who most tauted holiness ironically were thoroughly sinful in their attitude toward others and did almost no good at all in the world.

Part of our pessimism is how introspective our world has become. We are probably more aware of our inner feelings than any generation in any time or place prior to the 1800s. We experience intensely as Jesus reveals that the heart is the source of our actions or when Paul prioritizes faith over works. But we probably experience these shifts more intensely than Jesus and Paul themselves spoke them, and we can hyper-analyze our motives well beyond anything they intended. Our standard of living above sin goes far beyond the biblical expectations. We think anything short of absolute perfection is sin. The New Testament standard is much closer to John Wesley's sense of sin as intentionally doing wrong. [1]

Then there are addictions and tendencies. Our strengths often have corresponding weaknesses. If we are a decisive and assertive leader, we can have a tendency to run over people. If we are compassionate and understanding, we can have a tendency not to help others develop discipline or empower their weaknesses. Sometimes we develop addictions we could never overcome in our own power. We have developed a keen sense of these sorts of things in our last two centuries of introspection. While the New Testament understands slavery to sin, its world did not think in terms of genetics and environment.

Paul's argument against sin in Romans 6-8 was a defensive one. He was making it clear that his theology did not encourage or excuse sin. Because he taught a person could not get right with God by keeping the Law (focusing on the Jew-specific parts), he needed to make it clear he was not excusing violation of what we often call the "moral" law. [2] This debate is far removed from the issue we are discussing now, to what extent sin is a normal part of a Christian's life.

1 John has the mix just right. On the one hand, anyone who thinks they have never sinned does not understand the human condition (1 John 1:8, 10). Yet intentionally doing wrong cannot be normal for a Christian. After all, we have God's "seed" inside us (1 John 3:9). Nevertheless, Christians do sometimes sin and when this happens, we need to seek God's forgiveness through Jesus Christ (2:1)...

[1] One can, of course, wrong others without intending to do so, and one can have an evil heart without realizing it, as has sometimes been the case of those who most preached victory over sin.

[2] The biggest problem with understanding Paul here is that he uses the word "Law" to refer to both and what we call the "moral law" was not a category Jews used--it is a later Christian way of processing what parts of the Old Testament Law we still keep and the parts we do not.