Thursday, January 16, 2020

University of Kentucky 3

previous post
____________
9. I would take Plutarch with Dr. Martin, as I recall. I always felt like I was just about ready to begin each degree as I finished it. When I finished my classics degree, I felt like I was just about ready to get a lot out of it if I were starting.

That first year doing classical Greek I felt like I was scrambling. We were given a certain amount to translate each class. Class time consisted of going around the room and translating. It was very hard for me to get through the amount of translating assigned. I would copy and blow up the pages and try to create a kind of interlinear. Sometimes I would try to work back to the Greek from the English.

One thing is certain. I was so focused on getting through the grammar and syntax that I didn't learn much about Plutarch himself. I had a nice schedule going. I might teach Greek in the morning at Asbury and then drive to an Arby's just off the campus of UK. I'd have my choice of the day with a cherry turnover and try to finish as much of the translation as I could with Cordon Bleu in hand.

I think I took Dr. Martin again for Greek Tragedy (different works) the next year. Other than that I had Thucydides with Robert Rabel the next year. By then I was a little more facile with my Greek and got a little more out of the content. I had wanted to take Plato with him and went to the first day of class. Another regret but I just didn't have the margin to pull it off and had to drop the first week. I missed out on Homer too, much to my disappointment.

There were some great students on this same venture with me. I remember one in particular who had gone to Berea College, a college where students can have free tuition if they work on campus. I wish I remembered their names. They had done classics in their undergraduate programs and seemed so much ahead of me.

10. Over the summer, I went through Wheelock's Latin. Quite a tall feat I was trying to pull off. Having only had two and a half years of high school Latin, I was going to jump straight into master's level classes. Wheelock is of course great. I used it several times to teach Latin at IWU and will use it again online at Houghton in March.

I think the first Latin course I took was with Jane Phillips. I can't remember if she had once been a nun (my high school physics teacher had been. can't remember if I mentioned her). I really enjoyed her as a professor. I remember once she expected me to know what "fracture" was (she was trying to give me a hint) but I didn't. Fracture is when the priest breaks the big wafer in front of the church when consecrating the elements in the Eucharist. Not my tradition.

I think my first Latin course was "Juvenal, Martial, and Statius." It wasn't too bad because these satirists tended to write in snippets rather than prose. I also had two semesters of Latin prose composition with Dr. Martin, going from English to Latin. That was a bear.

A highlight was taking Virgil with Louis Swift. He was Dean of the Undergraduate School at the time. He was a widely known and respected figure who has now passed. I remember a brief conversation with him at a fellowship where he mentioned he could never quite figure out the imprecatory psalms. I had never really thought much about it. I told him that I tended to take the enemies in those psalms as figurative enemies like my struggle with some vice.

Interesting that I had unthinkingly allegorized those psalms without even knowing it. But that is what unreflectivity does--it is something you don't even know you are doing. I do believe my openness to "more than literal" or figural readings of the biblical texts is rooted in a kind of typological penchant of holiness preaching. My grandfather Shepherd apparently taught a whole class at Frankfort at one time in "types and shadows" between the Old and New Testaments.

11. I'm trying to remember what other courses I took. I took a course with Rabel on Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics. We read book 10. That was very enjoyable. I had always liked Aristotle, although I have moved beyond him in almost every category. He of course is the underpinning of Aquinas.

I took two semesters of Sanskrit as linguistics courses. That was fun. I forget the professor's name but he was very kindhearted. All of my professors at UK were really nice people, and several seemed clearly to be people of faith.

I needed to have French for reading knowledge in preparation for doctoral work, so I took a French for research course. Unfortunately, it was at 8am, and I lived over a half hour away. I was not yet a morning person either. The only thing that mattered grade-wise was the final exam. So I came to the class three times--the first day, the last day, and one random time in the middle. I got an A on the exam.

I took a course on Cicero in which we read De Amicitia and De Senectute. I've tried to add up the philosophy related courses I took here and there in grad school to see if I reached the 18 hours that is standard to teach philosophy. I think I just barely make it. [1]

[1] Philosophy of Theism, Apologetics, Aquinas, Aristotle, Cicero, and then you have to decide about Barth, Plutarch, etc.

Wednesday, January 15, 2020

Teaching Fellow - Hebrew 2

previous post
____________
6. It was during those two years that I was Ichthusman. Ichthus was a Christian rock festival that Bob Lyon started in the early seventies as a sort of Christian version of Woodstock. Youth groups would come from all over and camp in tents at the Wilmore campground. The latest contemporary Christian bands would come.

For fun, Ichthusman would fight Lust Boy or Sin Man. I think Scott Brown was Sin Man one year and Jeff Finger Lust Boy the next. This is not something anyone would have asked me to do as a shy student but it fit with my new persona as a funny and unorthodox Greek teacher. I bought some old clothes at Goodwill and velcroed them so I could rip them off, leaving me standing in my underlying cape and tights.

At one point I had the idea of parachuting onto the stage. We seriously considered it until we found out that our insurance wouldn't cover such a stunt. I've only parachuted once in my life. It was my first summer in England. Rachel Leonard wanted to do it and I said I'd do it with her.

It looks so simple from the ground, but up in the air I wondered why I would agree to do such a thing. I do heights but will admit to some nervousness when I get up somewhere. It was a static line jump, meaning that a line pulled your shoot for you when you jumped. It was a propeller plane so we had to climb out on the wing and let go backward. Quite a thing.

I made myself do it. The first ten feet of falling were gone in an instant leaving a really nice float the rest of the way down. I waited for Rachel to jump. The engines went off. No Rachel. The engines came back on. It circled around. The engines went off. Finally Rachel. I guess the only reason she let go was because the guy yelled and startled her.

7. My second year I got to teach Hebrew. I think most of us would learn best by teaching someone else. I had taken a fair amount of Greek by the time I began teaching, but there were still a lot of rough edges. After teaching Greek for a year, I was pretty good at it.

I was not as strong at Hebrew. I selfishly chose LaSor as a Hebrew textbook. Lawson Stone had sung its praises once upon a time. LaSor introduced Hebrew inductively. A Fuller professor, he started with Esther 1:1 to learn the letters and by the end of the book you knew Hebrew. He paid high attention to the phonology and morphology of Hebrew, with an iconic list of rules in the back (a dagesh forte is omitted if a vocal shewa appears beneath it).

With LaSor, I believe, students learned Hebrew more quickly and more thoroughly than with a classical approach. Moreover, they learned it where they could use it even after one semester. The problem is that your head swims for the first month or so. You are seeing everything in the language from the very beginning.

The hyper-J personality is prone to panic. Frankly, I don't know if I would have enjoyed learning Hebrew that way but it was much more fun to teach. The J wants to learn a small bit, master it, then go on to the next bit. This is really not the way language works. As children, we are thrown into the whole language.

To learn a foreign language, one ultimately needs to go somewhere where that is all that is being spoken around you. This was the rule when I first went to Germany in spring 95. They were not allowed to speak English to me until I had a complete fail.

Teaching Hebrew with LaSor thus requires a bit of pastoral care. I was good at that. You have to assure people that it's going to be ok. You have to get them to trust the method. And, sure enough, it suddenly all begins to click a month or two into the course. Then you're reading real Hebrew. You're seeing the same things over and over again.

I'm proud to say that I taught Brian Russell Hebrew. He has since gone on to be and Old Testament scholar and Dean of the Orlando campus of Asbury. He was of course much more gifted at Hebrew than I was. He would constantly ask questions whose answers I didn't know.

I have always had a penchant for teaching things inductively. This was part of the initial genius of Wesley Seminary--problem based learning that induces principles from realia. There is a certain personality that hates this. It wants to learn systematically in building blocks. Most of academia is this way.

I have to view this approach, however, as somewhat artificial, even if it is helpful for some very intelligent people. It is not the way of the real world. It is a quasi-Platonic approach to life that is not actually the way the world works. I call it the Platonic fallacy. Perhaps I will return to this question.

8. Joe Dongell is a brilliant professor at Asbury. He came I think my last year as a student. He is the son of Herb Dongell, whom I had for Greek at Central. His younger brother Pete is another good friend who came to Asbury a little after me. After Fred Long, Pete also became a Teaching Fellow.

It wasn't really intentional, but my life path mimicked Joe's to some extent. Of course he had surpassed me at every step. He went to Central as I would. Then he went to Asbury as I would. He was a Teaching Fellow as I became.

While he was a Teaching Fellow, he decided to do a MA in Classical Languages and Literature at the University of Kentucky. He told me once he wanted to see if he could do well in a secular environment as well as in a Christian one. He received a full scholarship to do his master's there.

It seemed like a good idea to me. I get antsy if I do the same thing over and over again anyway and I need to be learning something new all the time. So I applied for the same scholarship he had received and was accepted to work on an MA in classics at UK.

I jumped into Greek Tragedy, perhaps as early as the spring of my first year teaching. That was an eye opener. For one thing, it's poetry. The normal rules of language are typically bent in poetry. I had learned a little about meter back in high school, but now I was analyzing iambic pentameter in Greek. Hubert Martin was the professor, the nicest of people. He helped me limp through the course.

I would soon learn that some of the rules I thought were universal were not. I probably was a more effective teacher for not knowing the nuances. I learned that ἵνα didn't always take a subjunctive and that οὐ could actually be used with participles. I got a glimpse of the disdain some classicists have for "that merchant Greek" of the New Testament (none of my professors at UK said that).

Before the discovery of the Oxyrhynchus Papyri, the Greek of the New Testament was a bit of an enigma. Some suggested it might be "Holy Ghost" Greek. But when this cache of ordinary documents were discovered in Egypt in the late 1800s, it was realized that the New Testament is actually written in "street Greek," ordinary, common, "Koine" Greek.

This fact throws a bit of a wrench into the argument that we should read the Bible in the King James because of its lofty language. Apparently God didn't think so.

Tuesday, January 14, 2020

Teaching Fellow 1

previous post
_______________
1. I was 23 when I began as a two-year Teaching Fellow at Asbury. These were truly some of the best years of my life. I was not only working, but I was doing something I dearly loved--teaching Greek and Hebrew. I had close friends who pretty much thought the same way I did about God and the world. I got along very well with students and got to hang out with some really smart professors. I even dated for several months.

Don't get me wrong. I enjoy teaching the Bible, especially Paul's earlier letters. But the Bible can be controversial. People often shape their faith around a certain unreflective understanding of the Bible they learn as a child. And while they think they want to go deeper with the Bible, I don't think it's always true. What a lot of them want is secret knowledge that goes along with what they already think.

In fact, for some people, serious study of the Bible can result in the Bible becoming more distant than before. Joel Green speaks of it becoming a dissected frog. You can label all the parts but it's not jumping anymore. This was especially true in the purely "modernist" phase of biblical studies, where only the original meaning was of interest. One of the strengths of "post" modernism is the possibility of a second naivete that can accept both ancient and living meanings to an autonomous text.

I say this to explain why I enjoy teaching biblical languages so much. No one in my Greek classes ever argues over the forms of the third declension. There is no stress worrying over whether someone will tell their pastor that you said the perfect tense is completed action. And you can make all sorts of random puns of no significance whatsoever.

Teaching over the years has always involved varying degrees of ice below the surface of what I teach. There has often been a depth that just wasn't helpful to bring up. There are books I haven't written. Perhaps they would have been pointless.

One of the reasons I always enjoyed going to the Society of Biblical Literature annual meeting was to be able to talk to people who understood. When I first showed up there from IWU, Keith Reeves from Azusa expressed great surprise that a professor from IWU would be there. That would dramatically change over the years.

More than once I have thought how nice it would be to teach something uncontroversial like math or physics. I bet I would have been a great calculus teacher. And no controversy!

2. I was so excited the night before my first Greek class. I had a hard time sleeping. I even thought about having everyone get in boxes on the lawn representing noun endings. I used to have "subjunctive day" where students would arrive to a note on the board that said, "We might be in room x." I was silly. It was great fun.

A fellow before me, Rory Skelly, had put a number of Greek paradigms to music. Although I always footnote him, I have often gotten credit for these ditties. They are quite helpful. The only one I added was an adjective ending song.

The teaching fellow I replaced was Felix Sung. His parting words to me were, "And remember, people are stupid." At the time I thought it was a little harsh. I will say that not everyone has the aptitude for biblical languages. At least a couple of ministers later confessed to passing the Greek competency exam by improper means.

The senior teaching fellow was Bill Patrick, one of my best friends. Bill is brilliant. He is hilarious. Every once and a while we will still have a text exchange with short snippets of shared experiences, Deep Thoughts, and Saturday Night Live.

Bill was never good at playing games in the academy. He could have done a dissertation in his sleep. Indeed, I would have been glad simply to write up conversations with him. He has enough in his head. But at some point it all seemed foolish to him. I personally would say that some games are worth playing.

If he ever wrote a novel, I picture it being a bit like Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird. That is, I see him writing one book in a lifetime that becomes a classic (realizing that there is now a second). Bill did start a novel once. But then he read Of Human Bondage and decided that the novel had already been written. I read the novel in England, perhaps the first I read outside of school. [2]

Students seemed to enjoy me for Greek, but they learned more with him. Bill has to be one of the only Teaching Fellows to go four years. He robbed me of ever being the senior teaching fellow. :-)

3. I roomed with Brian Matherlee in the same apartment after Don Crowson got married. Brian was extroverted with not a hint of nerd. Imagine my surprise when the two prettiest new students were in our apartment. Hilariously, when he was showing them our apartment he pointed out my room and said, "And that's Ken's room."

"Who?" they said.

"Ken, he's right there." And indeed, there I was, standing right behind them, completely unnoticed. :-)

One of them was Greta (Lemons) Lebo, who would become part of my circle of closest friends for those years. Brian, Greta, Laura Lambert, Quin Monahan, Tracie Jordan, Greg Shannon, Jenny Stewart, and more. We had a booth at Applebees. I actually started to sketch a painting of five us in the booth. Finally got rid of it in the recent move, unfinished.

I forgot to mention that in 1989 the Berlin Wall fell. John Hull and Scott Gunn decided to go see Berlin on the fly. They invited me but I just didn't have the money. I was finally able to see it five years later.

4. I was ordained in 1991 at the age of 24. The rule was that you needed two years of ministry service after bacheloreate education, one after an MDIV. I don't think they counted my teaching, although I was under appointment by the Florida district. I think they cobbled together the bits and pieces of church ministry I had done here and there. I think I forgot to mention some summer ministry I did with Trinity Wesleyan in Central.

I asked for an NASB for my ordination Bible. We had used the RSV at Asbury. The EB professors liked it because it didn't have headings that would bias your outlining when you were doing a survey. But I knew it was viewed as a somewhat liberal translation, so I asked for an NASB. I didn't want another KJV and at the time I couldn't stand the NIV.

O.D. Emery was the presiding general superintendent, a long time friend of my family. Also signing my Bible was J.D. Abbott, after whose son I was named. Virgil Mitchell also signed. I had served as student body chaplain at Central my senior year under him.

Then there was the DBMS (now DBMD): Raymond Kensell (DS), Dennis Waymire (Asst DS), Richard Cowley, M. Lee Schenck (my dad), Walter McKee, and Mac McCombs (sec).

5. I taught Greek in a three hour + three hour format, a whole year, using Machen. I taught a six hour block, a one semester crash course. I also taught intermediate Greek, using Brooks and Winbery's Syntax of New Testament Greek (again following precedent). Metzger's Lexical Aids also featured. [1]

Patrick Eby had me as a torturer in those days, along with others like Jim McNeely. They not only had to parse Greek words but give the semantic nuances of the cases and tenses. I think we even did a little sentence diagramming.

[1] It occurs to me that the way I was able to get through Hebrews in Greek was Sakae Kubo's, A Reader's Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament.

[2] Between my doctorate and starting teaching, I read Crime and Punishment and Things Fall Apart.

Seminary -- Teaching Fellow 8

previous post
__________
48. When I felt a call to ministry in college, I fully anticipated I would pastor. When I graduated from Central, I did not feel mature enough yet to fly solo, so I went to Asbury. As I was at Asbury, I was increasingly drawn to biblical studies and teaching.

It's a pattern I've seen in students often. A certain personality is drawn to the life of the mind. I have mixed feelings about it. For one, there is hardly any space for professors of biblical studies these days. In the seventies, sometimes they would pay for your schooling. When I came on the market in 1996 there was almost nothing. It seems much, much worse today.

I thanked the Lord often at Indiana Wesleyan that I had a teaching job. I remember an older student who asked me about doctoral work in an area of ministry. He was clearly annoyed that I discouraged him. But today he sits with a doctorate and no permanent teaching job. When I saw Dr. Muholland in 1996, he annoyingly remarked somewhat glibly that it was a buyer's market for professors.

By the way, I did have Muholland for a J-term in a course on Greco-Roman Literature. I focused on the Stoics. I wasn't able to have him for his forte--Revelation. He had the novel hypothesis of reading Revelation as if it reflected an actual ecstatic experience of someone. :-)

So many students think they want to teach. Most do not realize who they are up against. There are some incredibly bright people out there. I cringe a little to see that I did the same. But some are actually destined for this life. There are still a handful who should go into the academy.

District ministerial boards were not always understanding. "Weren't you called to ministry? Why are you diverting from ministry to teaching?" Of course the church has a long tradition of ministerial teachers. There is a clear category in the Discipline for it. But, again, I feel this charge.

I have preached extensively in my life. I have visited the sick and counseled the distressed. I have led worship. I have engaged in evangelism and taught small groups. I have been on church boards and led in several contexts. I have youth pastored and supply pastored. It is not as full of ministerial experience as I prefer when hiring a ministerial professor, but it is experience. I hope it might be said of me on the positive side, "Some people have twenty years of experience. Some people have experienced the same year twenty times."

49. As my time as an Asbury student began to draw to a close, I came to a fork in the road. A kind of fleece came into play. Every year, Asbury hired a graduate to teach Greek and Hebrew for two years as a Teaching Fellow. I applied.

The fleece was this. If I was given the opportunity to be a Teaching Fellow, I would go on to do doctoral work in New Testament and follow the path toward becoming a professor. If I did not get the position, I would take a church in Florida and proceed into pastoral ministry. Perhaps the door would open at some later time to go on for further study.

I was chosen as Teaching Fellow, and the rest is history. I think I was chosen not only because I had done good work in biblical studies but because they thought I might be a good teacher. I think they thought I might relate well to students.

This has been a key to me in hiring. The academy sometimes can focus on a certain kind of intellectual who is destined to publish a lot and be a name. But can they teach? Can they relate to students? Will they enrich the relational dynamics of the team? Would you all like to go out to lunch with them or will everyone steer clear of them?

Knowledge is wonderful. I love it. I love brilliant people. The students love it when a professor is brilliant... if he or she can equip them for life. And there are few things worse than a brilliant person who is self-centered and demeaning to others. There is a place in the academy for the genius who is moving the front edge of knowledge but doesn't interact much with students. But they are largely the stuff of research institutions. These days most institutions can't afford to have too many of them around.

Monday, January 13, 2020

Seminary -- Singing and More 7

previous post
___________
41. I would petition to get out of two of the "Pastor as" courses. One, I think, was "Pastor as Evangelist." I had taken an evangelism course at Central. The other was "Pastor as Liberator." This was, for lack of a better description, a social justice course. It would no doubt have been very good for me, but I wanted to take more Bible, and Asbury granted my petition.

Incidentally, coming from where I came, I thought of the Liberator course as somewhat liberal. We grumbled about having to take such courses. Now I view this as a major blind spot in my background. Indeed, it would seem a trick of the Devil to get God's people to mock something that was central to Jesus' earthly mission. It would seem to me at the present moment that a good deal of the church finds itself fighting God while thinking itself fighting for righteousness.

Because I already had taken theology at Central, I was able to do some slightly more advanced work at Asbury. I took a patristics course with David Bundy. I was especially happy to do an independent study with him on Aquinas. A friend named Mark Mealey also studied with him at the same time. I can't remember if he did Aquinas and then later did a study with him on George Lindbeck, the father of post-liberal theology.

It was the first time I had really used my Latin since high school. I found Aquinas' thought very stimulating, particular his distinction between being (esse) and essence (essentia). I wondered if it was only in this universe that God's being was simple, that it reduced to a point in this universe while we cannot say what it is outside this universe.

As a side note, Russ Gunsalus remembers running into me in the basement of the library looking at copies of ancient manuscripts. I guess it looked impressive, but I knew the truth. Just because I was interested in unusual things didn't mean I was really competent at them. It has always been sobering to realize that, say in the Philo group at SBL, the things that count me as brilliant in some circles are basics assumed of everyone before even getting started in others.

Bundy is of course another genius. He was head librarian at Asbury, another Free Methodist (at the time). I secretly wondered if he was too liberal to be an official professor. :-)

He was brilliant, even if he had a little trouble getting to the finish line sometimes. Rumor had it that he learned Dutch one weekend in Amsterdam. Of course I know about rumors like that because some have circulated about me. Russ Gunsalus and I had him come do an assessment of our library when Wesley Seminary was founded. I saw him a couple years ago at SBL Denver. Abson Joseph and I had breakfast with him.

42. I had at least two courses with Jerry Walls. Since I had philosophy at Central, I was able to substitute some more advanced classes for that requirement. I did philosophy of theism and apologetics. We read Swinburne for the first, as well as some from Jerry's doctor father, Tom Morris.

An argument from Swinburne that has stayed with me is that the argument from design is not just about the question of evolution, for example. It is the fact that there are laws of nature at all. Even the theory of evolution proceeds according to rules that reflect an order to creation. Of course now I would consider the fine-tuning argument to be a consummate example of order in nature. Similarly, I would put miracles as a kind of argument from design.

In my final paper, I brainstormed something that sounds a bit heretical, namely, that the Trinity reflected a kind of metaphysical modalism. God the Father referred especially to God outside of the universe. The Spirit referred especially to God inside of the universe. Christ, the Logos, was the metaphysical bridge between inside and out, the connection between God within and without.

I might add that this class was my first exposure to analytical philosophy. I am not really too fond of it although I do use simple syllogisms in my thinking. I wonder if some analytical philosophers use their syllogisms to circumvent common sense. I used to beat myself up for being stupid in reading Plantinga and such, but I wonder if some of those were examples of the arguments not working.

The apologetics class introduced me to James Sire's, The Universe Next Door. Now there's a book that had a major impact on me. His sense of the disintegration of theism over the last five centuries has remained my go-to typology when I teach philosophy, although I've made it my own.

Walls was a huge IU and Bobby Knight fan. Somehow one Christmas I got recruited to sing with him and I think Todd Thompson a song he had written to the tune of Silent Night. Must have been a talent contest or something. "Bobby Knight. Bobby Knight. He's not tall but he is bright. Round Indiana he's our man. For each game he has a plan. Thinking and D are his keys. Thinking and D are his keys."

A couple of IWU students invited Jerry to come to speak about apologetics a couple years ago. There was a Scott Burson connection too because they had co-written some stuff. His most recent work of interest is an edited text Two Dozen or So Arguments for God, which draws on the work of Alvin Plantinga.

43. I think that about exhausts the courses I took at Asbury. I did take one on theological German with Steven O'Malley. We used Jannach's German for Reading Knowledge. When Dave Ward needed to pass a German competency test for Princeton, we worked through it together.

I had taken an interest in German the summer before I went to seminary. I checked out records from the Broward County library and listened to them. Of course in those days I thought Schenck was a German name. It turned out to be Dutch. However, I can still claim a German heritage through my Dad's mother.

I did an independent study on Hebrews with Bauer. My initial interest in Hebrews was from the fact that it had been called the Leviticus of the New Testament. Leviticus had a lot to do with holiness, so I had associated Hebrews with holiness too.

I believe I tried to read through all of Hebrews in Greek for that course. Hard to believe I would have been able to do it then, but I think I basically did. 1 John was the first book I read all the way through in Greek. Then the second was Galatians. I suppose Hebrews was the third.

Dr. Bauer invited me to present a scholarly paper on Hebrews. I presented it, I think, my senior year. It was titled, "Hebrews and the Rest of God." Many who heard it misinterpreted it. By "rest" I meant the resting of God in Hebrews 4. I think Grant Graff took it to mean "here's some of God but where's the rest?"

It was pretty boring. My friends came and endured it. I think Vicky Gibson may have even come from across the street at the college. It's also possible it was my first year as teaching fellow.

I would later drive to Atlanta and present it at a regional SBL, my first SBL paper. I didn't know anyone in the room. It was a small room. I was sure to fill out the time so there was no time for questions. I got up, read it, sat down. It was over and forgotten very quickly. I threw in some German and French to sound sophisticated... and no doubt butchered it. Quite anticlimactic after a lot of work.

44. I've neglected to say much about my non-classroom life during my student years at Asbury. Stewart Fowler was my first roomate, a very nice Free Methodist from Oregon. We would go to Florida on Spring Break with him, Len Philips, and another gentleman whose name I forget. I later heard a rumor that we had been soul winning in Fort Lauderdale and that I had said great words, but I don't remember that part. We may have witnessed to one person on the beach :-)

My next roomate was Don Crowson. We would move into an apartment down near the train tracks my final year. Don is a great guy and perhaps a tad strong willed. So it was a delight to see him begin to date Mary Uible, who might also have had a tad bit of a strong will. A particularly fond memory (please forgive me) was a stand-off in front of her house in Ohio, with them in a standstill over who would drive back to Wilmore. Her parents finally just went back in the house. I won't say who won or how much conversation there was on the trip back.

I was in an accountability group for a while. I believe Jim Maness, Ross Taylor, and another gentleman were in it. I could be misremembering. I don't think Jim Dunn was in it, but I associate him with Jim Maness in those days.

45. I went on a mission trip to Bolivia with Bill Gould. We sang. Scotty/Rachel Gulledge and Mike/Cathy Rash, friends from Central, were also on the trip. That was my second trip out of the country after the Philippines--three continents down. I tried to learn Spanish from a book driving home my whole way back in May before the trip (I would look and then memorize, look and then memorize).

There had been an older gentleman from Colombia who had attended my church growing up, Carlos Gonzalez. He tried to teach me Spanish, but it didn't work because I couldn't see the words written down. My father couldn't even get "buenos dias" to save his life. He tried and failed every Sunday. [1] I had grown up with Spanish all around me, but had never learned it.

The trip was very enjoyable, except for one night on a cold bus up country. I remember Mike getting paranoid when everyone laughed after what he said was translated. He hadn't said anything funny, at least not in Southern. He said he had really enjoyed the "cheese biscuits" that morning. I guess it was a peculiar thing to try to translate.

There was another time I was trying my best to listen to an older man speak to me in Spanish. The national superintendent, noticing, said to the man, "El no habla Español." What a downer.

Another funny moment when was when someone asked what my name was. "Ken," was the response, which sounds very similar to "Quien," which means "who?" So the guy thought the conversation was, "What is his name?" "Who?" So he repeated the question. "What is his name?" "His name is who."

What? Who is Ken? Yes, Ken is who.

Somewhere in there was interaction with Albin Whitworth, a great organist at Asbury. I did a lot of singing in those years. In fact, I sang in virtually every church I was ever a part of until I came to College Wesleyan in Marion. I forgot to mention that I sang in the college choir at Central. I sang regularly at Stonewall Wesleyan Church in Lexington during the six years I was there. Those where the days of accompaniment tapes.

The best chapel of every year, as far as I was concerned, was just before Christmas when chapel was Handel's Messiah. There would be scores at the door and we would sit in four sections near the front--sopranos, altos, tenors, and basses. There would be soloists. It was wonderful. I sang bass.

I was in a quartet with Brian Matherlee (lead), Todd Thompson (alto), Ray Jones (tenor), and me as bass. We did a fair amount of singing. Todd had an interesting story that I hope he doesn't mind me sharing a little of. He was the son of a district superintendent from North Carolina. Not exactly knowing what to do with his life, he followed the path he knew best--he studied for ministry.

But after four years at Central and four years at Asbury, he found himself not sure about his vocation. I remember him struggling to find direction, reading What Color is Your Parachute? He would finally go on to study philosophy in England at Sheffield and, I believe, is teaching even now in North Carolina.

Brian and I would become roomates after Don and Mary got married, living in the same apartment in "downtown" Wilmore. We continued to sing. He learned to play the guitar. One piece we did was "More Than Words," by Extreme. We sang it at a wedding reception. The quartet also did "In the Good Old Summertime" and "Mr. Sandman."

46. I worked in the cafeteria during my three years as a student. The first year, Ed Ross and I washed dishes. The last two years I was cashier. I enjoyed it. It was a way of being social without having to go out of my way. They came to me. There weren't a lot of single girls on campus, but I saw them every day in the line. :-)

Since I get bored easily, I quickly started drawing the menu board instead of just putting the list up. The menu items might be on a plane or the menu items might be the ingredients on a cereal box. At Christmas I decided to give menu board calendars for the next year. I did drafts of all my boards on napkins, so I was able to pick what I thought were the top twelve funniest. I found the napkins as I was preparing to move to New York.

I did some improv too, following the Who's Line Is It Anyway? approach. Those were fun. I don't know that I had ever really considered myself funny, but it seems like I was getting there.

Their names escape me at the moment, but there was a Wesleyan couple from California who had been in the acting world prior to coming to Asbury. The wife had actually done an improv class with Robin Williams before he did Mork and Mindy. They decided to put on a version of Godspell. It was a lot of fun and Todd Thompson was in it too. He and I did "All for the Best" in a duet. [2]

47. I attended Stonewall Wesleyan my whole time at Asbury. This was a matter of duty. It was how I had been programmed. You're a Wesleyan. You go to a Wesleyan Church. When you visit a town on a Sunday, you find the local Wesleyan Church to attend.

When I started, almost none of the seminary professors or students attended Stonewall. I mentioned earlier the pastor who had foolishly driven the seminary professors away. It was a little bit of a drive. No offence but the services weren't particularly exciting.

The pastor was Larry Freels. Kerry Kind also attended in those days and would often lead the song service. It seemed like Freels did everything he knew to do to try to grow the church. I remember us trying neighborhood visitation once. It just kind of continued on without much growth.

We did some social action. I remember us standing on the side of the road with abortion signs once. What was funny is that I had broken the middle finger on my right hand playing softball--a fly ball that hit my finger just wrong. So it was in a splint. They gave us the finger, and because of my split, I was giving them the finger right back. :-)

I've come to think that there are three basic kinds of small to medium size pastors. First, there is the preacher. People come to hear them preach. Then there is the pastor. The preaching might be average, but this pastor really cares for the congregation. Then there is the administrator. These days, this person might think about becoming an executive pastor in a larger church with a staff.

Although I didn't take Pastor as Evangelist, but I seem to remember hearing a new concept from other students that seemed very important to me. A church needs to be structured differently as it grows. For example, if the pastor tries to do everything himself, the church will never be able to grow beyond 150-200. This resonated with me in relation to the pastors of my youth.

[1] His French from the war was horrible too. We need "boo-coo" tires for beaucoup. I'm still not sure if "sinny-finny en" was "ce n'est fi rein."

[2] That reminds me that I sang "Old Man River" in a musical at Central.

Sunday, January 12, 2020

Seminary - Practical Ministry 6

previous post
_______________
35. I studied Hebrew with Lawson Stone my second year at Asbury. [1] He had arrived the same year I came as a student. I very much enjoyed him as a professor. He was fresh out of Yale, vibrant, and clearly a genius.

In those days he seemed excited about new ideas, very open-minded. I've already mentioned that he did a special seminar on Isaiah 1-12 in Hebrew. I think Dave Smith may have been in there too. He wanted to use the tools of EB in Hebrew.

I've always wondered if it was hard to teach in the shadow of your mentor, in this case Dennis Kinlaw. Kinlaw was a colossus of a man, a spiritual giant. He was also an Old Testament scholar. Steve Deneff often mentions him from the pulpit of College Wesleyan as someone who had a big spiritual impact on him as well.

Asbury College was blessed to have a great revival among its students in 1970. It was a normal chapel, but people started going to the altar. And they kept going. And they kept praying. And they stayed and they stayed. And people drove in from all over to join. It lasted for almost 8 days without interruption.

In a way, Asbury College, now University, lived under the shadow of that event for years. Other campuses did too. Even last year at IWU there was a chapel that a professor hoped would spark a spiritual revival. He got permission from the president for students to be excused if they stayed after it was over. I think many did stay for the better part of the day.

So you are always looking for it to happen again. Is this chapel going to start another revival? Wait, two students are staying after chapel to pray. Is this going to be the start of a new revival? I wonder if it is hard to move forward when you are always hoping to revisit the past.

I'm pretty sure that Lawson was open to some critical ideas in 1988 that Kinlaw would not have been. Kinlaw may have been a spiritual giant, but in my mind he was not as great of an Old Testament scholar. My first year as teaching fellow (summer 1990 I think) he did the faculty retreat for the seminary, and I distinctly remember him imploring the faculty to be careful with his baby. In my mind the baby was perhaps the best it had ever been.

These sorts of dynamics are very typical as an old guard passes things on to the new guard. I remember a large church pastor in Florida once reading a quote about how bad the youth of the day had become (Larry Freeman). [2] The quote was about how the younger generation was going to pot and how the world was getting worse and worse. Then he came to the punchline--the quote was from Plato in the 300s BC. Freeman's point--not always true because sometimes the world is spiraling into the abyss--is that the older generation often thinks the younger generation is going to pot.

We used Seow for Hebrew. When I was a teaching fellow, Stone also taught Akkadian and Aramaic. I took the Akkadian class, in part to help Lawson get the numbers. I went to the first day of Aramaic, but I felt like my Hebrew wasn't quite good enough for me not to get really confused. It remains a regret, although a good decision probably at the time.

36. I did take some practical courses at Asbury. Obviously the biblical courses are the ones that most resonated and stayed with me. They were the ones that got at the heart of my search to know the truth and what God required of me.

When I was called to ministry in college, my attention was initially more drawn to theology. My honors project engaged the Bible for sure but it was focused on theological questions. When I started out, I assumed I knew what the Bible taught. The undiscovered country was theology.

In seminary, the world of the Bible opened up to me. With shifts in my understanding, I had to go to ground zero in the Bible. In my circles, the Bible is the foundation. So while my interests at Central had heavily been theological, at Asbury they were now primarily biblical.

One piece of the puzzle was that I didn't want someone to be able to throw me into a faith crisis. I wanted to know everything. I wanted to know all the counter-arguments too. I wanted to face the beast of doubt and be prepared for anything someone might throw at me.

37. I took "Pastor as Leader." Aside from the professor introducing us to Ong, the main thing I remember is that he was big on "systems theory." I'm still not entirely sure what the big deal about systems theory is other than it views the church like a machine with inputs and outputs. No offence to the professor, but I'm pretty sure that the leadership courses that Keith Drury taught at IWU and that Bob Whitesel taught at Wesley Seminary were probably more helpful in general for doing the work of the ministry.

I won't give the name of my "Pastor as Teacher" professor. It is a deep irony to me that most of the Christian education teachers I have known throughout the years have been pretty boring. Keith Drury is one exception. I did learn some helpful things in the class though. I was reminded of the moral development theory of Kohlberg. I had learned it first with Hal Robbins at Central. I learned about the Kolb learning cycle. Knowing that people do not all learn the same way is a key insight if you are going to be a good teacher.

I had Don Boyd for "Pastor as Liturgist." Boyd had been a Wesleyan Methodist District Superintendent in the Allegheny District of Pennsylvania. During the merger of the Wesleyan Methodists with the Pilgrims, they had pulled out and become their own group. Some New York Pilgrims had done the same.

Boyd was DS during all that mess. My sense is that both the Pilgrims and the Wesleyan Methodists who didn't go with the merger both thought the other side was too liberal. And also that it was moving toward the one world religion of the end times.

My grandfather Schenck and a couple of my uncles didn't merge either. One uncle told my dad at a campground on the way to Florida that he would pray for my Dad's soul if he went with the merger. We packed up and left the next morning before the other family got up. My dad would be a delegate at the merging conference at Anderson in 1968.

Boyd was teaching mostly United Methodists, and he had clearly come to love liturgy. Our final project was a worship file where other students graded us. I knew precious little about liturgy as someone who had grown up as a holiness Wesleyan. Let's just say I was annoyed to be graded down on my materials because of a United Methodist student's eyes.

I only finally let go of the file box in my move to Houghton. Some will know that I became a go-to person for a while in Marion whenever there was a desire for something a little more on the Book of Common Prayer side. In time, Constance Cherry and David Riggs on campus and Emily Vermilya at College Wesleyan became the masters in residence.

If I continue this series into my IWU days, I'll mention there that I was never a purist. Rather, I believe you can worship God from any number of styles of worship, from Hillsong to the mass. I stand-up for the legitimacy of liturgical worship over and against my background that saw it too "catholic" or full of "vain repetition." But I do not think it is the only way to worship and find the other side legitimate too.

38. I was able to take David Seamands for "Pastor as Care-Giver" before he retired. He was of course renowned. His book Healing of Memories would be deeply meaningful to me. [3] Seamands' lingo was always a little sappy to me, but the substance I found very helpful.

So he speaks of "damaged love receptors." The idea is that God is transmitting his love to you. The problem is that some of us have damaged love receptors. Our antenna are broken. God loves us. God has forgiven us, but we can't feel it.

This idea resonated with me in the extreme. My theology told me that God loved me. My theology told me that I was forgiven. But I couldn't feel anything from God most of the time.

Seamands suggested that we often need help from each other when this is the case. We need others to come alongside us as antenna repair people. This was a puzzling point for me. If I had enough faith, why wouldn't God just repair me himself? As an introvert, I didn't want to go to others for help.

In the end I would simply say, "That's just the way God has set things up." It reminds me of an old song. "God uses people, ordinary people. He uses people who are willing to do what he commands."

In my spiritual journey, there has often been a lag between my head and my feelings. When I talked to Dongell or Huffman or my mother or David Thompson, their advice and thoughts were not immediately satisfying. They had to seep in. They had to work their way into my spiritual gut.

In a way, Seamands' work marked the closing of my ten years of guilt. I was moving into a period of peace, one of the happiest periods of my life.

39. As an aside, I never took Don Joy for a class. His sex class was very popular and of course I was intrigued. But to sign up for it seemed a little desperate. :-)

Joy wrote a book called Bonding. As I recall, in it he argued that man was created androgynous, both male and female. So when God created Eve, he divided man into Adam and Eve, male and female. Marriage, then, was getting the band back together.

I heard that he had run it by the Old Testament faculty at Asbury and they had told him it didn't work exegetically. Interestingly, I was reminded of this theory while going through John Walton's The Lost World of Adam and Eve. He says something about the definition of "side" in Hebrew that sounded a little like Joy's theory, which I doubt Joy came up with himself.

40. The final practical course I took was "Servant as Proclaimer" with Don Demaray. It was a great class. The way he had it structured was great, and I found his book quite helpful.

We presented the parts of a sermon before presenting a whole sermon. I remember that, when I presented my introduction, I talked about how I had run the Lexington 5K a couple times in the spring without having run at all over the winter. I was able to do that when I was in my early twenties. The point of the introduction was that if you aren't training for your spiritual life, you will choke when the race suddenly comes upon you.

I got good marks on the intro from him. The evaluation side would always first involve positive feedback from him and the class. Then he would say, "And now the other side." I also remember him quite frequently saying at the beginning of class, "Let's pray that this will be the best class ever. Why not?" Of course I would always then think to myself. "They can't all be the best class! There have to be some less exciting ones. Otherwise we all would eventually explode!"

In typical idealistic Ken fashion, in those pre-pragmatist days, I switched my topic for the final sermon. Mistake. I was on a good trajectory. I think I tried to preach on the problem of evil. I agreed to go ahead of when I was originally scheduled, agreeing to switch with someone, and didn't have enough time to perfect it. Argh!

[1] I don't regret it, because I loved Lawson as a professor, but I missed Eugene Carpenter by a a year. He would move to Bethel in Mishawaka. I did have some interaction with him at Bethel. He tragically died on a lake a few years ago.

Carpenter taught Hebrew inductively from Genesis 1. I bought his tapes and listened to them over the summer after my first year at Asbury. Part of my familiarity with Genesis 1 in Hebrew comes from those tapes.

[2] I found him reading the quote annoying at the time, and I post this story knowing one possible response. I'll simply mention the genetic fallacy--whether something is true or not does not depend on its source.

[3] His earlier book, Healing for Damaged Emotions was also meaningful to me, although I thought the title was funny.

Saturday, January 11, 2020

Seminary -- Inerrancy 5

previous post
______________
26. The question of how Matthew 2:15 interpreted Hosea 11:1 must have stayed on my mind. Matthew thinks of it in relation to Jesus leaving Egypt as a child. Hosea was writing about the exodus of Israel from Egypt, and how they went ahead to serve other gods.

I have heard people explain the connection on a higher level. As Moses led Israel out of Egypt so Jesus is the new Moses who will save us from our sins. Quite possible. I do indeed believe that Matthew meant his readers to think of Jesus as a greater Moses.

But this is a higher level of thinking than my Thompson Chain Reference KJV. It had almost forty prophecies that I'm pretty sure it took as predictions about Jesus. Hosea 11:1 is not a prediction about Jesus. It refers to the past, not the future. It is about Israel, not Jesus or the Messiah. It tells about how Israel was unfaithful to God, while Jesus was without sin.

There is no problem here. Matthew is using Jewish exegesis. He sees a broader similarity than Hosea had in mind. Jewish exegesis had no problem with taking a snippet from the passage rather than the whole in context.

The problem was with my expectations. In the world of fundamentalist apologetics, the fulfillment of prophecy is sometimes used as an argument for the truth of the Bible and Christianity. But that set me up for the wrong expectation of Hosea. I expected it to be a prediction. It wasn't.

27. Most of the Old Testament passages that the New Testament authors saw fulfilled in Christ had an original meaning in their own context. Again, there is nothing wrong with the way the New Testament authors read these passages. The error is with those who try to twist the Old Testament into straightforward predictions.

This is quite a matter of discussion in certain circles. There are whole books written with the intent of showing that, after all, the Old Testament authors did mean the same thing as how the New Testament authors took them. But this is more cooking of the books. As someone who used to try to make the Bible say what my tradition wanted it to say, I fully recognized the far-fetched machinations of book cookers.

And I am not talking about popular thinkers. I am thinking of recognized evangelical scholars like Walter Kaiser and Greg Beale. There is a whole commentary devoted to such book-cooking.

There is nothing wrong with Matthew hearing the virgin conception in Isaiah 7:14, but there was a first meaning, a "near" meaning in the day of Isaiah. Virgins conceive all the time, when a woman gets pregnant the first time she has sex. Psalm 16, Psalm 22, all of these texts had an original meaning that made perfect sense in ancient Israel. And there was nothing wrong with the New Testament authors and early Christians hearing echoes of Jesus in them either.

28. I found these things troubling when I first realized them. Fundamentalist apologetics had set me up for failure. I return to something I said earlier in this narrative. I might have had less of a faith crisis if I had come from a more reflective Christian background.

Matthew's use of Hosea is not in error. It was my expectations that were in error. I thought that Matthew had wrongly interpreted Hosea, which in my twenty-one year old mind looked like an error. But there's nothing wrong with Matthew interpreting Scripture like a first century Jewish Pentecostal.

At the time, it put me into a pickle. There was no denying that Hosea was not a prediction about Jesus. But I thought Matthew thought it was, and thus that Matthew was in error. At the time I understood inerrancy to mean there could be no errors of any kind in the Bible in terms of what I considered an error to be in my culture and paradigms.

So did God want me to believe something that wasn't true? Was this a test of obedience? Was I willing to make myself believe something that wasn't true to show that God was first in my life? Now there's a twisted thought.

For one thing, I'm not sure you can make yourself believe something you know isn't true. Maybe you can. But I would eventually conclude that God is a God of truth. Truth goes with God, and God goes with truth. If you could prove God didn't exist, he would say before he left, "Oh, ok. Well that's that then." :-)

I don't mean to suggest that truth is bigger than God. I mean to say that truth and God go hand in hand. At some point I truly fused my quest for truth with a longing for what God knows. I have often worried over what people might think about various conclusions I might reach. But at a certain point I no longer worried about God in this regard. If I became certain that something was true, then I was simply discovering what God already thought. God knew.

29. But what about the Bible? I was now in preparation for Wesleyan ordination. I had to appear before the District Board of Ministerial Standing and answer questions about things like inerrancy.

When I did, by the way, Rev. Taylor, former pastor of Lakeland, asked an insightful question. He said something like, "We've known you your whole life Kenny. You are Lee's son. Sometimes a young man grows up and doesn't believe the same things he did when he was young. Do you still believe the same?" I believe I answered truthfully that, while I had made the beliefs my own and thus had put them into my own framework of understanding, I still had the same basic beliefs."

In the summer of 1988, I was trying to figure out how to believe in inerrancy. Russ Gunsalus and I, for some reason, made a visit to David Thompson to ask him how he managed as a Wesleyan to affirm it. I think Russ and I had been in Ron Crown's class together.

I don't really remember what Thompson said. Perhaps Russ does. As is often the case, I remember that I didn't find his answer entirely satisfying. I just remember that he was caring.

As I recall, Thompson had undergone a certain dark night of the soul at one point. He had left teaching to pastor in the DC area, but he entered a phase where he didn't feel anything. He couldn't pray himself so instead read the prayers of others. Eventually, the feeling returned and he returned to Asbury.

I deeply respected him and continue to respect him to this day. He was incredibly authentic. What you see is what you get. I had him for Minor Prophets EB and deeply enjoyed it.

Back in Fort Lauderdale, I asked my pastor about inerrancy. He gave an answer I have heard from others. The Discipline says the Bible is without error in the original manuscripts, which we don't have. So perhaps something that looks like an error to me was different in the original manuscripts.

It was a nice attempt to help. But of course I had just finished a course in textual criticism. We pretty much know what the original manuscripts said.

30. I appreciated that President David McKenna had refused to let Asbury get torn up over the inerrancy debates of those days. I believe someone told me that he had dictated that Asbury would not fight over it. He was a Free Methodist.

By the way, the Wesleyans and Free Methodists had almost merged in 1976. I was there. I remember the vote. My Dad wasn't really in favor because we thought the Free Methodists were liberals. They actually put inerrancy into their Articles of Religion in preparation for merger. I was there in 1976. I remember what I thought was a vote. I thought we had voted to merge.

But a trick of parliamentary law thwarted the merger. The presiding general superintendent didn't want to merge for the same reason my family didn't. What I thought was a vote was actually a round of applause to "receive" the recommendation of the committee, not to "adopt" it. We would never merge.

31. The Wesleyan Church has never defined what it means to say the Bible is without error. I wrote a blog piece some time ago to give my take. I have always liked the way Asbury put it, "without error in all it affirms." Kevin Vanhoozer gives an even better framework that I would put like this, "The Bible is infallible in that it never fails to accomplish what it sets out to do. When that purpose is to convey information, it is inerrant."

As a biblical scholar, it gets complicated. First, there is the question of genre. It is not reasonable to expect Acts to conform to the expectations of the modern historical genre. We expect Acts to function like ancient history because that's who it was originally written for. We know from Thucydides that ancient history could involve invention of speeches--something a modern history would never do.

I have gone through the Chicago Statement on Inerrancy. I believe it means to prohibit drawing certain conclusions about the biblical text. But I do not think it succeeds at its intended goal because once you bring the question of genre into the discussion, the biblical text becomes much more flexible in the range of possibilities.

The Bible is incarnated revelation. That means that it was revealed extensively in the categories of the ancients. Paul apparently believed there were three layers of sky straight up until you got to God (2 Cor. 12:2). The Hebrews apparently believed that the sky was a dome in which God fastened the stars (Gen. 1:15). These are not errors because they are not the point of the revelation. They are the cultural frameworks within which God revealed his points.

The Bible seems to reflect a progression of revelation. The Old Testament largely does not understand that there is a conscious afterlife (e.g., Ps. 6:5; Job 7:9; Eccl. 9:5). The New Testament does.

I do not know how to come to any other honest conclusions than these. I can fit them within Vanhoozer's framework. They go well beyond the fundamentalist framework.

The Bible is infallible. It never fails to accomplish what God wanted or wants it to do. God uses it to do all sorts of things within the parameters he sets (to promise, to identify, to inform, to transform, etc...). Sometimes his purpose is to inform. In such cases the Bible is always true within the parameters God sets. Perhaps I will return to this discussion again later, for my explanations here took shape over many years.

32. I will say that Dr. Wang and Dr. Oswalt had the opposite effect on me than what they probably intended. I had Wang for Romans. Dave Smith and I were both in that class as well. [1]

I remember one day that a returning missionary asked him as we were getting up from class if a certain passage could be interpreted differently than how Dr. Wang did. It took several tries for Dr. Wang even to understand what he was saying. When he finally did, he said with a smile, "Oh, ok. I [will] come back next time with more reasons why I am right." [2]

It was a lighthearted comment, but in a way it did typify his approach to critical issues. The goal was never to try to be objective. The goal was to find arguments to support the answer we were supposed to come up with.

I remember hearing of an assignment he had for his exegesis class from Acts 13:48. The verse says, "Everyone who was appointed to eternal life believed." It sounds Calvinist. What I heard he wanted the students to argue is that the form was a middle rather than a passive: "Everyone who appointed himself to eternal life believed."

This is cooking the books. The middle is rare. One should always consider the passive to be the default likelihood unless there is something in the context that pushes you in a different direction. As I have said often, the search for truth is not about finding a possible argument that fits your prior conclusions. It's about going with the most probable conclusion given the evidence and logic.

33. Dr. Oswalt's Old Testament Interpretation class had the same effect on me. To be fair, he presented the different possible interpretations fairly and somewhat objectively. In those days, it was hard to draw a conclusion on many things. I remember reading some in Donald Guthrie's New Testament Introduction. He presented each case so fairly that I really couldn't tell what to pick as he presented each option.

But I was beginning to feel like there was a reason most scholars believed that there were sources behind the Pentateuch. There was a reason most scholars dated Isaiah 40-66 to the sixth century. *

Oswalt's commentary on Isaiah 40-66 sees these chapters as a prophetic vision Isaiah had in which he is, to put it in my words, transported into the 500s BC. However, as I see it, there are only two reasons to believe these chapters come from Isaiah himself: 1) the fact that it is currently packaged with Isaiah 1-39 and 2) the fact that the New Testament authors seemed to think these chapters are the voice of Isaiah.

Inductively, one would not draw this conclusion. Isaiah 40-66 nowhere mention Isaiah. He is not said to be the author of these chapters. Their setting is clearly the sixth century. Cyrus, Persian king of the sixth century, is mentioned by name. Jerusalem is in ruins and has been for some time (Isa. 61:4). Isaiah 36-39 is a bridge inserted from 2 Kings. Inductively, one would conclude that these chapters were appended from a later time and that the entire book was edited into a whole.

If God reveals himself in our categories, then it is no surprise that God would speak to the New Testament authors within their framework of thinking about Old Testament authorship. As far as packaging, it's not God's fault if I draw the wrong conclusion because of how a collection is put together. There is a good chance that Isaiah 40-66 was on its own scroll anyway.

I could say similar things about source hypotheses about the Pentateuch. Genesis never mentions Moses. Exodus through Deuteronomy talk about Moses in the third person--not the way an author would normally speak about him or herself. Deuteronomy even narrates Moses' death. No one would inductively conclude that Moses was the author of the Pentateuch. The only argument in its favor is, once again, the fact that the New Testament seems to refer to it in that way.

34. After emerging from my struggle over whether God would want me to believe a lie, I adopted an approach to go with the most likely conclusion given the evidence and logic. I don't necessarily mean what I blab or say in the classroom, but in what I think. God and I are best buddies in this. He understands. He knows my heart. I'm not worried about him condemning me for what I think. I want only to think what he thinks.

The Bible is revelation but it is not the totality of God's thoughts. And it is God's thoughts incarnated into numerous ancient contexts. There is also natural revelation. There is greater precision to be had on many items that the ancient audiences couldn't have fathomed. Truth is thus bigger than the Bible. The Bible is in the truth.

See if you agree with this line of thinking. It is very scary, but it seems inevitable to me. If the Bible was revealed in the categories of its original audiences--which makes sense because God revealed these words to them first--then to follow only the literal meaning of the Bible is to lock up truth in ancient categories. But surely we know many things that the ancients did not. Here is the conclusion. To read the Bible in a fundamentalist way is thus to make God look stupid, because he is thus not allowed to be smarter than the categories of the ancient world.

[1] Dave remembered recently that I volunteered to read a German commentary for that class. I had recently taken O'Malley's Theological German course. It was a farse, however. I just wasn't that good at German at that time.

[2] There were stories of Dr. Wang's accent that students enjoyed sharing. I don't know if they were true or not. One was about a terrible accident with people "breeding in the streets." By the way, I believe Ken Foutz and Dr. Wang had been roomates at Emory.

Seminary -- Baptism in the Spirit 4

previous post
______________
18. Probably the most formative role Dr. Lyon played in my development didn't have anything to do with the one class I took with him. He did technically supervise me as a Teaching Fellow, but he pretty much let us do our thing. [1] Rather, Bob published an infamous 1979 article in the Wesleyan Theological Journal entitled, "Baptism and Spirit-Baptism in the New Testament."

It would embody a transition within the holiness movement. Mel Dieter once remarked that the decline of teaching on entire sanctification followed directly from the detachment of sanctification from the Spirit-fillings of Acts. Lyon's paper was central to that detachment. I tend to agree with Dieter.

However, I agree with Lyon's paper too. Not too long into my time at IWU, I guardedly inquired of the New Testament scholars in the Wesleyan Church at that time. I did not find one who thought the Spirit-fillings of Acts were instances of entire sanctification. You might find a theology professor here or there, but even that is rare.

Outside the Wesleyan tradition, I don't think you would find any original meaning New Testament scholar who would equate the Spirit-fillings of Acts with the experience we Wesleyans call entire sanctification. [2] Certainly no one in church history prior to the 1700s seems to have interpreted it that way. It would seem that, to draw such a conclusion, you have to be wearing Wesleyan glasses.

I am not questioning here the doctrine of entire sanctification. I am simply pointing out how difficult it is to base it in Acts. See more below.

19. Let me backtrack. In 1977, James Dunn published a book called, Baptism of the Holy Spirit. At the height of interest in tongues, Dunn did an exegetical study of what it means in Acts to be baptized in the Holy Spirit. His work is careful, "scientific," and tends toward objectivity. [3] Indeed, it was this characteristic of his work in general that would eventually make me want to do my doctoral work with him.

He concludes that the expressions "receiving," "being baptized with," "being filled with" the Spirit are all roughly equivalent expressions in Acts and that they all refer to a threshold experience that ideally would take place around the same time as water baptism. [4] This is the consensus position. It is, in my opinion, the conclusion that an objective person will reach. Lyon's article simply channeled Dunn's book.

I did not come to agree with this conclusion lightly. It was a difficult conclusion that went against the conclusions I had made in my college honor's project. But the honor's project had prepared the way. I had finished it with the gnawing feeling inside that my conclusion could easily be flipped.

The fact that the Samaritans did not receive the Spirit in Acts 8 when they are baptized is not treated as normal in Acts. It seems problematic. Peter and John have to come up to fix the problem. Cornelius in Acts 10 is not a Christian yet--he had not yet heard the gospel. He receives the Spirit before he is baptized.

Even more significantly, Acts never articulates a doctrine of entire sanctification. To infer it, we have to bring it to the definition of "filled with the Spirit." Acts never says, "and their hearts were cleansed of the sinful nature." The closest it comes is Acts 15:9 which says Cornelius' heart was purified by faith. But, again, to say this is entire sanctification you have to infer a lot of theology that the text doesn't actually say.

The book of Acts itself focuses on the power of the Spirit as the main consequence of being filled with the Spirit--power to speak boldly, power to heal, power to speak in other languages. A side comment, overloaded with outside theological meaning, comes to take precedence over the inductive priorities of the text.

This is a great example of unreflective, "pre-modern" interpretation. There are some dots from the text here--water baptisms, filling with Spirit, hearts purified. But the structure into which those dots are placed has at its core material that is not based on dots in the text of Acts. This includes not only a theology of the sinful nature (based on an Augustinian reading of Paul) but also the equation of it with the "heart" here. It also involves making primary what is secondary or not articulated at all.

By the way, I had a great EB class in a J-term on Acts with Bauer. It was there that I did an extensive assignment on the filling with the Spirit in Acts. I believe it was there that my transition of interpretation took place. I received very favorable remarks from Bauer and, who knows, that assignment may have played a key role in me later becoming teaching fellow.

20. I might also mention that once I understood that receiving the Spirit was a threshold experience, it unlocked a whole layer of New Testament theology. Indeed, it uncovered a major blind spot in my theology of the Holy Spirit. In James Bross' college systematic theology class I had first learned that Wesleyans did believe in an initial sanctification upon conversion, something I don't remember hearing in the preaching of my youth. Now I began to realize that receiving the Holy Spirit is the defining moment of conversion, the experience that defines who is in Christ.

This is not a minor point. The preaching of my youth had obscured the central role of the Holy Spirit in defining the people of God. It had misinterpreted statements like being "sealed with the Holy Spirit" in 2 Corinthians 1:22. The old timers thought of this as sealing a jar, a final act. It was actually about a seal of ownership, an identity-defining act.  Meanwhile, I had not been able to see the richness of verses like Ephesians 1:14, which speak of the Spirit as the down payment and guarantee of our inheritance.

21. My friend Scott Key used to argue that the breathing of John 20:22 was the disciples getting saved, so that the Day of Pentecost was when they were sanctified. But this is mixing two different books with two different narrative worlds. In the story of Luke-Acts, the Day of Pentecost is the fulfillment of the promise of Luke 3:16 (cf. Acts 1:5).

Blurring together the narrative worlds of the Gospels is an example of unreflective, "pre-modern" interpretation. I would eventually be exposed to the work of Hans Frei, who helped express the unreflective situation. To put it in my words, the "pre-modern interpreter" blindly equates the story with history. He or she does not realize that they are reading distinct presentations of the story.

The Gospels are not exactly video tapes or transcripts. Most people are good with the illustration of four people on four corners of an intersection who see an accident and each describe the same event in a distinct way. We are reading about Matthew's Jesus and Mark's Jesus and Luke's Jesus and John's Jesus. They all are about the same historical Jesus, but in each Gospel we are getting a presentation of Jesus from a distinct point of view.  More on such things to come.

The unreflective reader jumps into the text and sees it as the same kind of history as what they did this morning. The reflective reader realizes he or she is reading a book written by someone at a particular place and time. They are inspired, yes, but they were inspired in a particular situation separate and distinct from the situation of Jesus in history. [4]

Even though we jump into the story, prior to reflectivity, we tend to interpret the story through the interpretive lens of our theological tribes. As a Wesleyan, I read Acts with special glasses on. I would later come to think that our exegesis is most subject to skew when we are dealing with the key verses of our sect. Our competitors are usually able to see our special pleading better than ourselves. A Republican can often see the blind spots of a Democrat better than a Democrat, and a Democrat can often see the blind spots of a Republican better than a Republican.

The network that tends to resist your party is often a great place to uncover your blind spots.

22. So on what subjects and passages are the Seventh Day Adventists most likely to be unreflective about? Why on the ones that have to do with the Sabbath, the ones they care the most about. An old time Wesleyan is most likely to be unreflective on the exegesis of passages having to do with holiness. A Baptist is most likely to be unreflective about passages they think teach eternal security.

Before I knew what to call it, I began to develop what Paul Ricoeur called a "hermeneutics of suspicion." If my interpretation comes out the way my tribe wants it to be, then I should double check myself. What am I missing? If my interpretation is a little too convenient, I get nervous. If you're not willing to change your position, given enough evidence to the contrary, then you're not really a lover of truth.

Now I am still Wesleyan. I have tried to be reflective about my inherited beliefs. They have passed through the fire. I have tweaked them in the light of study. I still get nervous when I am teaching Romans 9 that I am Wesleyanizing it, but I have tried to be objective. One of the most exciting conclusions of my scholarly life is to find that the best of current scholarship, especially the "new perspective on Paul," has tipped interpretation in the Wesleyan direction.

I hope I have moved in many areas into what Ricoeur called a "second naivete." The first naivete is our unreflective phase on an issue when we don't even realize we are wearing glasses or that an issue might be interpreted a different way. Then we go through the fires of examination and emerge at least partially reflective.

I might add here that there is a tradition in town that most do not realize is a tradition. Let me call it generic evangelicalism. The hermeneutical irony of this tribe is that it doesn't think it's a tribe. It might call itself "non-denominational" or a community church. It thinks it has transcended denominations and traditions not realizing that it is basically Baptist with some charismatic highlights. In the past it has been somewhat free will Baptist.

In the internet age, there is increasing blurring of the classic traditions into each other. Because the resulting mix is not limited geographically or denominationally, it is easy to think it has transcended tribe. But it is a tradition nonetheless, a new pre-modernism, a new unreflectivity.

There are scholarly tribes too. I'm sure I will talk more about that later.

23. As Lyon opened my eyes to read Acts in context, I found solace in the fact that John Wesley himself did not formulate Christian perfection in terms of Acts. Let me say that as a Wesleyan, I grew up knowing precious little about John Wesley. John Wesley had nothing directly to do with the holiness tradition of my youth.

This is an interesting fact. When they find this fact out, many Wesleyans react with a clarion call, "Back to Wesley!" It seemed to me that there were a fair number of Wesleyans who attended Asbury who ended up something else. They became United Methodist or maybe Free Methodist. Nazarenes largely attended their own seminaries.

Let me be descriptive. After Asbury, I believe many Wesleyans found the Wesleyan Church to be woefully unreflective. Now, don't get me wrong, sometimes they were simply finding a new level of unreflectivity. But it seems to me that, as their learning took them to a higher level in some area, they found it hard to go back to the Wesleyan Church.

For some it was in the area of worship. I'll talk about Don Boyd soon enough, whom I think was still technically Wesleyan but who really had become a United Methodist. For others it was in the area of biblical studies. God led me back to the Wesleyan Church after my doctoral work but I would have been fine with becoming a Methodist or Anglican. For others it was Wesley as they realized that the Wesleyan Church was part of a holiness tradition that knew little of the forces that had shaped it to be what it had become.

I never got the "Back to Wesley" bug. Wesley was not inspired. I believe he was deeper than Phoebe Palmer, but he was not Scripture. At IWU I was sympathetic to Keith Drury's push back here. Wesley is not our father. He is more like our grandfather or great grandfather. We are free to move beyond him.

I believe theology has to be "constructive" to engage new areas of context and new areas of insight. This is not the Tom Oden approach, who didn't want to have a single new thought in his theology. He is backward facing. Ken Collins as a Wesley scholar is backwards facing. You can tell from comments scattered here and there that I am more a fan of Randy Maddox than Collins' approach.

Wesley was great, but he lived in the 1700s. We are not doing God justice if we don't stand on the shoulders of those who stood on the shoulders of those who stood on the shoulders of Wesley.

24. So I would learn about Wesley in Steve Harper's Wesley's Theology for Today. Harper's little book The Way to Heaven is still a quick entree into Wesley's thought, not to mention my A Horse Strangely Warmed, Wesley's life through the eyes of his horses. :-)

I also had Larry Wood for contemporary theology. I wish I could take the course over now. I would get much more from it.

Wood would push back as hard as he could on the impact of Lyon. Wood did not challenge him on the exegesis, as I recall. But Wood pushed back on the thing that gave me solace--the fact that Wesley did not formulate Christian perfection in terms of Acts.

Wesley looked to verses like Matthew 5:48--"Be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect." Take Hebrews 6:1--"Let us go on into perfection." To be sure, Wesley as an unreflective interpreter did not quite get the interpretation of these verses right either. There was a period of time where, one by one, I realized, "Well, that verse isn't really about entire sanctification. Well, that verse isn't exactly about entire sanctification."

I reconstructed the doctrine on a logical and experiential basis. God cannot be anything less than total Lord of your life. It is obvious that we must give everything to God. "If Jesus isn't Lord of all then he isn't Lord at all." This is the goal. In a perfect world, it should be true from the first moment of our Christian walk.

But it usually isn't. Most people experience a process of first realizing that they have not given an area to God. Then they come to a moment of surrender in that area. Eventually, we come to a point of crisis where we need to determine that we are going to give everything to God. Usually there is one hold out, one thing that we have the last battle over.

When we surrender all to God, only then does he take all of us. We consecrate on the altar. He sanctifies and consumes the offering. We become fully devoted followers of Jesus Christ.

New things will of course enter our lives. We may at some point have to re-surrender something we had once surrendered. But it seems to me that our sense of entire sanctification as Wesleyans fits human experience and is a logical inference from biblical theology.

We can still use the same key verses, especially if we realize that we are using them with a broader sense than they might have originally had. Same basic thrust but a broader application. The disciples were filled with the Spirit more than once. Acts 4:31 seems to me very appropriate to preach entire sanctification. How can you be truly "full" of the Spirit if you haven't given the whole vessel to God? 1 Thessalonians 5:23 can be used similarly.

25. Perhaps Wood's most significant contribution to the debate is his work showing that Wesley had no problem with John Fletcher's equation of sanctification with the Spirit-fillings of Acts. Fletcher was an Anglican priest and part of the Methodist movement in England. Apart from Wesley, he was Methodism's first real theologian.

Fletcher was apparently the first person in all of history to equate entire sanctification with Acts. What Larry Wood has done is to show that Wesley was not in disagreement with him on this point. I will say, however, that this is potentially a point where we can get so focused on the trees of detail that we miss the big picture. It is simply undeniable that Wesley's works do not build the case for sanctification in this way.

Wood was fun as a professor. I love it when professors are quirky intellectuals. I used to say there should be faculty trading cards with the superpowers of each one on them. At IWU I would joke that a faculty is like a zoo and each animal has its own exciting feature you want to see.

Wood almost seemed to be in some Platonic realm when he taught. I heard about a time once that he was confused about what class he was in and gave the lecture for a different class without realizing it. He would pull a chair to the front of the classroom, sit down, and just start talking about whatever, not really looking at us but looking up now to the left, now to the right. By the way, I think Chris Bounds once gave the wrong final lecture to a class at IWU.

26. I was a co-editor of The Short Circuit my final year at Asbury, along with Ross Taylor and Chris Fisher. It was the student paper. That was a fun experience. My job was mainly to write/gather articles and/or make the occasional cartoon. We also had faculty quotes.

I think it was Chris Fisher who had the idea of a cartoon of Moses receiving his Myers-Briggs letters... JEDP. I think I drew it. Chris didn't like Myers-Briggs. He thought it became a self-fulfilling prophecy. I said he only felt that way because he was a "P" personality. :-)

I wrote up a piece once on the Spirit-fillings in Acts. Somehow some people in Florida found out about it. That was an uncomfortable and somewhat painful discussion. I was not trying to be rebellious. Sometimes the evidence just doesn't seem to go your way and you have a choice. Am I going to go with my tribe or with what seems to be truth?

In the end, truth is what God thinks. More to come.

[1] Frankly, the only time I remember doing anything with him during that time was once Bill Patrick, he, and I went to Fazoli's in Nicholasville for lunch. He ordered a "Freddie" to the puzzlement of the cashier. A Fettuccine Alfredo.

[2] By an original meaning New Testament scholar, I mean someone who 1) can read the New Testament competently in Greek, 2) knows the content of the New Testament text thoroughly, 3) knows the history of interpretation of the New Testament, and 4) understands and follows competently exegetical methods. From this description, it is clear that a person can be a scholar in one area of the Bible and not another. Similarly, there are biblical scholars who follow other methods.

[3] I say tends toward objectivity because none of us can be completely objective. However, it is clear that there are varying degrees of objectivity and, some, like those who pursue theological interpretation hard core have almost seemed to throw it out the window. If we can use the word objective in biblical studies, James Dunn is one of the most objective scholars I know. That doesn't mean he is right. It probably means he is more likely to be right.

[4] Form critics coined the phrase, Sitz im Leben, situation in life. They realized that a saying of Jesus may have had one Sitz im Leben in the ministry of Jesus, another in oral tradition, yet another when the saying made its way into the Gospel. Then of course there is my Sitz im Leben as a reader. All these contexts tweak the meaning of the saying, because the meaning of words is a function of context.

Thursday, January 09, 2020

Seminary - Textual Criticism 3

previous post
_______________
12. I think I had Wang in my second year. He and Oswalt taught the courses that exposed us to scholarship on the New and Old Testament, respectively. I'll return to them after some more thoughts on my first year at Asbury.

I mentioned earlier that learning about different personality types and Myers-Briggs was very beneficial to me. Today everyone is into Enneagrams, but they seem much more of a pop phenomenon to me, like a horoscope. To me, they are like Star Wars and Myers-Briggs is more like Star Trek. :-)

That some people recharge by getting alone (introverts) and others by getting around people (extroverts) seems to match reality. I have found the N (intuitive) - S (sensing) distinction incredibly descriptive of me and of others who are not like me. The N is more big picture and abstract. The S is more detailed and concrete.

Thinkers (T) and feelers (F) again aptly describes people who make decisions based on what they think is logical and those who follow more their values. That some people insist on closure (J - judging) and others are more open-ended (P - perceiving) is again very descriptive.

I have found these categories immensely helpful in describing human behavior. I do not take it as absolute. These letters just give labels to the way people tend to behave.

13. I believe it was also in my first semester that I had Stan Beck as something like a psychological mentor. I don't remember what they were called but I think there was a kind of psychological assessment that was part of every student's path through the MDIV.

We used to joke about his frankness on personal matters. It was like he would bluntly say sensitive words to see how we would react. In the dorm (I was in Grice) we would imitate him. "Why do you laugh when I say ...?" I think his assessment of me was that my development was a little slower than average. Then again, he also reminded me a little of the "Stuart Smalley" skit on SNL with Michael Jordan.

I did three supervised ministries while at Asbury, I think. At least one needed to be in a church. At least one needed to be in some other sort of ministry context. I think I did the one as youth minister for my home church in Fort Lauderdale in the summer. I believe Everett Putney was still pastor, although my sister Sharon would soon take over.

As a fun side note, there were some in my church that had convictions about eating in the sanctuary. I don't remember the basis but it might have been 1 Corinthians 11. The church in Fort Lauderdale had added on its back section as an expansion. So there was actually a step-down hall way that marked the barrier between the sanctuary and the Sunday school rooms and children's church.

Growing up, we had fellowship meals in the children's church area. Since it was set apart by the hallway, that seemed to satisfy the need for separation. But some were still uncomfortable, I believe, because it was still under the same roof. In the end, a duplex was purchased behind the church. When I was youth pastor, it was still two apartments. Eventually they would make it into an ACE school and my brother-in-law Dalbert would be the principal.

14. I did another supervised ministry at Harrodsburg Nursing Home. Those were some interesting days. I remember a 104 year old woman who always sat in the hallway. I tried to ask her historical questions but she said, "Honey, I hurt all over. I don't remember anything." Incidentally, while I'm thinking of it, I rode next to a Russian woman on the Eurostar in the spring of 1995 who had been the son of an Russian ambassador to Britain in the early days of communist Russia. [2] She had memories of seeing Anastasia and the Czar's family inside the grounds before they were executed.

I remember one lady who wasn't quite all there. She asked me once if I had time for a "quicky." On another occasion, I happened to be passing by her room when I heard her talking to herself scooting across the floor. "I'm going to the bathroom. I'm going to the bathroom. Just as I am without one plea but that thy blood was shed for me."

I did my case study on the question of whether one should play along with a person with dementia or if you should correct them. I decided in general to play along. I think Beck may have been my supervisor for this one.

That reminds me of a Deep Thought by Jack Handy, something like "When John told me that he was on a deserted island enjoying a beautiful sunset, it took me quite a while to convince him that, no, he was in a straight jacket in a padded room in an insane asylum." When I was a teaching fellow, Bill Patrick and I used to read deep thought after deep thought. Bill used to make fun of me because of one lunch at Ramses in Lexington when, after a deep thought I exclaimed in the despondency of my inferiority, "He's a master."

15. I took textual criticism my second semester with Bob Lyon. I believe Dave Smith was in that class with me. I would never really become part of Lyon's "LO society." By the time I decided to join, it had become popular, which wasn't really what he was going for. The idea was the British concept of "loyal opposition," those who push back against the majority. A trendy LO society was of no interest to Lyon.

I was still in the early stages of my journey out of fundamentalism. Except for Cinderella in the fifth grade, the first movie I ever attended in the cinema was in my first year at Asbury. I went with my roommate Stewart Fowler and a couple others to see Dream Team.

Lyon was quite the champion of social justice. He was pushing compassion toward gay individuals before there was much discussion. I knew a student at Asbury, by the way, that came out of a gay background and ended up marrying and having children.

There was a team Lyon had for intermurals, the NeRPs (non-recruitable players). I did basketball intramurals and was a dangerous person to have on the floor. I was very fast and I could do a lay up on a fast break, but I could also accidentally knock someone out of the air in a dangerous way. I was on the floor when someone else caused Chris Bounds to break his ankle with similar antics.

Chris, of course, should never have been playing for the NERPs. He was an incredibly good basketball player. With him on the team, they began winning games. Before, the expectation was that they would lose every game.

16. Bob was a known textual scholar. I was impressed that he was footnoted as the pre-eminent scholar of Codex Ephraemi in Bruce Metzger's The Text of the New Testament. His course in textual criticism marked my transition from the King James Version to modern translations of the Bible.

Frankly there was a little peer pressure involved. After class one day, I asked Lyon a question once that revealed my background and he casually asked, "Are you a closet Textus Receptus man?" Like Peter, I denied it. :-) [1]

Textual criticism looks at two types of evidence. The first is external evidence based on manuscripts. The second is internal evidence that uses common sense--which original reading would best explain how other variations arose. I was not convinced in the end by external evidence. Families of manuscripts like Alexandrian, Western, Caesarian seemed like somewhat of a circular argument.

But the logic of internal evidence seems unassailable. Applying the logic of internal evidence to the variations of the manuscripts generally leads to the readings of modern versions. That is to say, using common sense tends to go against the text of the King James. The grouping of manuscripts seems to align with the results of internal evidence. The so called "Alexandrian" tradition tends to be older and to align with the cumulative results of following the internal evidence. The Byzantine tradition is later and looks like the end result of a long process of textual tidying.

Indeed, the textus receptus is a cleaner, more tidied text. It is a text fit for worship, like what results after something has been perfected for long term public consumption. This is what we would expect at the end of a process of standardization. We expect history to comb the hair of the material, not to mess it up. Thus the position of the vast majority of textual scholars fits the big picture common sense of internal evidence.

17. Take the ending of Mark. The oldest manuscripts don't have the verses after 16:8. Modern textual criticism would say that the best manuscripts do not have 16:9-20. But what convinced me was the internal evidence. The story starts over at 16:9 and it is told in a different way than before. It looks like different material.

I am acquainted with some very smart people who believe 16:9-20 was original. They have very sophisticated and ingenious arguments. But the most likely answer, the one that tries to be objective and follows the evidence to its most obvious conclusion, is that these verses were added later because 16:8 didn't seem like an appropriation conclusion. We can understand why someone would add 16:9-20. It is much harder to imagine why someone would remove it.

[1] The textus receptus refers to the "received text" that was based on the text of Greek New Testament that Erasmus put together in 1516. It is the Greek text behind the King James Version.

[2] The Eurostar is the train that goes through the chunnel back and forth between London and Paris. That particular trip, I believe, was back from Paris to London.