Tuesday, December 07, 2010

Love God 1

I'm sitting in a guest house at Messiah College, a lovely Brethren college in Pennsylvania, helping with a program they're starting.  The landscape of the campus reminds me of Southern Wesleyan, although it's bigger.  The faculty are warm hearted like IWU's, although their academic orientation is more like Houghton's.  Nice place.

So this is my warm down for the day.  By the way, did you hear that IWU is proposing to loosen the reigns on its dancing policy?  I had a hearty Schenck laugh when I read the paragraph about "spontaneous dancing."  It can happen to Wesleyans, you know, that uncontrollable urge to flail your arms about in the most bizarre manner. ;-)  This spirit once came over me in Germany and I knocked a stein off of some passing waiter's tray into an ice cream buffet.  Ask my family.
___________
If you are not careful, theology and philosophy can quickly blur off into discussions that seem far removed from everyday reality.  It can be a by-product of trying to construct intellectual systems out of practical truths. For example, it is important to us as Christians to believe that God is in control.  It gives us hope, not to mention that it is part of our allegiance to him as king.  Yet it is also important for many of us, including the Wesleyan tradition, to affirm that everyone is important to God and that God wants us to try to see everyone be reconciled to him.

The problem comes when we then try to fill in the blanks.  For example, John Calvin (1500s) started with the  first truth--that God is in control--and then filled in the blanks as follows.  If God is in control, then he must decide even who comes to him and who does not.  Therefore, it must not be possible for just anyone to be reconciled to him.  He must choose who will be saved and in fact make them believe, leaving those he does not choose to continue on in condemnation and alienation.

The Wesleyan-Arminian tradition disagrees.  It finds this picture of God incompatible with the notion that God is love.  Calvinism is a beautiful intellectual system, but its picture of God does not seem to square with the dominant picture of God in the New Testament.  How does God love the world (John 3:16) or want everyone to be saved (1 Tim. 1:4) if he arbitrarily decides to save some and destroy others as a top down decision, with no input from those he is saving or damning whatsoever?

Indeed, this system inevitably leads to a very questionable view of God's values.  God becomes a slave to the rules.  He must have absolute justice.  He cannot simply forgive.  Someone must pay the last exquisite drop of blood in punishment.

God seems arbitrary.  With no apparent basis for choosing, God seems to decide arbitrarily to save some in order to show his great "mercy."  Then with equality no apparent reason he decides to fry everyone else.  The Calvinist might argue that they deserved to fry anyway, but they never had a chance.  God is loving to choose to save "you, you, and you," but "you, you, and you" did not matter anyway.

By contrast, the Wesleyan-Arminian tradition believes that the notion of God as love does not really make sense unless God would want to give everyone a chance.  Wesleyans have more often than not even believed that someone who has never heard about Jesus has a chance because God "lights everyone who comes into the world" (John 1:9).  We are "judged according to the light we have" rather than by our conscious thinking.  Notice again the heart orientation of the Wesleyan tradition, less worried about what is going on in a person's head.

John Wesley also tried to fill in the blanks, but we believe with the right overall sense of God's "nature."  If we start with God as love, then surely he finds a way to give everyone a chance.  Wesleyans call it "prevenient grace."  Calvin saw God's grace as all or nothing.  Either you had it and would be saved or you did not and were sunk.  Wesley thought God surely gives everyone at some point enough grace to signify a desire for more or to continue in darkness.  A person is thus saved entirely by God's power, but part of that power was invested on empowering you to make a choice.

Monday, December 06, 2010

Google thought...

I was sitting on a runway in Chicago today thinking Schencky thoughts as usual.  Here was one.

If I were the CEO of Google... or the president of a small dying college, I would either start a college as part of my company or, better, buy or cooperate with one about to go out of business.  The degree--a BS in Google whatever.  Why not let the industry cooperate with an innovative college to create a problem based curriculum whose main purpose is to feed a company like Google employees?

Google of course is just an example.  A degree in Intel whatever.  A degree in Boeing whatever.  Sure, we'll throw in humanities courses so these engineers have a soul.  Just because you can make a really nifty microbe that can wipe out the planet doesn't mean you should.  Sure, the college would insist the students get a little philosophy and history, not to mention an understanding of physics that is a little broader than how to put a transistor on a sheet of silicon.

But the building block model of learning is too slow to keep up with the cutting edge of the twenty-first century.  Technology companies should grow their own.  But to keep their people human, colleges could facilitate it.

What do you think?  I personally nodded off just after having this thought... ;-)

Sunday, December 05, 2010

God Looks on the Heart 3

Previous post is here.
________
This line of thought leads us to the question of absolute truth.  Does the pragmatic, Wesleyan tradition believe in absolute truth?  Do you mean, do we believe in truth, definite truths?  Well, of course.  What's the point of trying to communicate if there is no such thing as truth?

The question is more about how accurate or precise our systems of thought are.  The great thing about systematizing our thoughts is that it helps us process things.  Systems of thought help us grasp complex things and remember them.  Systems of thought help us see potential inconsistencies in the way we think.

Other traditions today have a clear penchant toward what we might call the Platonic.  Plato thought that truth was a matter of ideas and that the things we see around us are only imperfect shadows of the truths we can only access with our minds.  So many Christians who use code words like "worldview" have a tendency to think that everything we see and do around us is simply the outworking of some system of ideas in our heads. They might spend a great deal of time trying to get your ideas straight, thinking that if we can only get the system of ideas in your head right, then the rest--how you live--will take care of itself.

This way of thinking has a lot of problems.  For one, the vast majority of people do not live from day to day playing out their ideas.  The sentiment that "right insight leads to right action" sounds noble, and is a great ideal toward which to aspire. [1]  It just is not how most of us will ever operate.  Most people will change sooner if they work with God's help to change their habits, their physical actions.  According to most psychologists, this path is actually more effective in changing the way people think.  So the "get the ideas straight and the actions will follow" only proves to be true for a small number of us.  For most of us, the pattern is "get the habits straight and the ideas will follow."

Indeed, the Bible itself does not lay out some neat system of ideas.  It is deeply ironic on the highest level that the vast majority of biblical texts are not theoretical, but contextual.  Romans is not a "compendium of systematic theology," as Luther's systematizer, Melanchthon, once said.  Romans is more systematic than Paul's other letters, but its argument and train of thought still have everything to do with a situation where Paul is introducing himself to a group that might potentially have heard bad things of him from his opponents.  If one wants to complain about Wesley writing sermons rather than a systematic theology, one might first start by complaining about the apostle Paul and, indeed, every book in the Bible.

So we see that the idea of a "biblical worldview," as helpful as it can be, has as much or more to do with the Christian thinkers who "find" it in the Bible as it does with the Bible itself.  The briefest look at how many different systems of thinking Christians have put together over the centuries shows this dynamic very quickly.  Since none of the books of the Bible themselves present a system of thought, such systems require not a little glue from those who construct them.  Such glue, thankfully, usually comes from a hefty dose of common Christian tradition--glue that the Holy Spirit has helped the Christians of the ages apply to the biblical texts.  But of course individual thinkers also are bound to mistake their own personalities and the perspectives of their situations for "Scripture alone."

This is not the place to unpack what really is involved in determining what "the Bible says."  First we have the meanings of individual texts, which we have no choice but to define according to the definitions and categories we know.  Even on this smallest of levels we are more likely to find meanings familiar to us rather than those of the original audiences to whom the biblical texts were literally written.  Then there is the matter of how we connect individual texts together.  Since they usually do not tell us how to fit them together, this is a process we must do.  We have no other choice.

So we prioritize them in terms of the meanings we have already given them.  We designate texts familiar to us as "clear" and those that seem strange to us as "unclear."  If the first meaning that suggests itself to us does not make sense to us or does not fit with our sense of what the Bible can say, we might reinterpret its meaning as best we can.  I am assuming throughout these last few paragraphs that the reader in question sincerely wants to hear what God has to say and submits to God's authority in Scripture.

The notion of "biblical worldview" as often as not leads a person to run roughshod over the biblical text.  It is one thing to find common themes throughout the Bible.  Love of God and neighbor, for example, pops up continually throughout the biblical texts.  It is another to mistake a Christian system of thinking for what the biblical texts themselves actually say.

For one thing, such systems usually undersell God's brilliance. When I think of how to illustrate what I mean, science often comes to mind.  If a person takes a high school or college science class, we often learn simple rules to start off.  We learn that objects fall at the same rate, no matter how heavy they are.  We learn that it takes so long to get across a certain distance moving at a certain speed.

But if we stay with science long enough, things get complicated.  Those things falling--we talked about them as points because in reality, air and wind get in the way.  Those things getting from A to B in a certain time--we learn that time slows down as an object approaches the speed of light.  Indeed, a lot of "real life" calculations require what are called statistical models.  Scientists see how most things behave because reality is too complicated to come up with a neat equation or rule to describe the situation.

Similarly, I am convinced that those of us who think we have neat little systems of theology to describe the truth of the Bible--let alone God--are going to be incredibly embarrassed in the kingdom of God.  The problem with systems of theology, in my opinion, is that I can understand them.  I do not think I would be able to understand God, at least not on a literal level.  After all, I have trouble understanding Einstein's theory of relativity.  Surely God is a bit more advanced still!  Surely his revelation to us is baby talk, "goo-goo ga-ga" that I can just get the gist of, even if I really am only getting the general impression.

The bottom line here is that I revel in the fact that God looks on the heart.  I have to think that those who are more oriented around the head are going to be very embarrassed for the first few moments of the kingdom.  And after all, if God is primarily interested in our heads, why does he not set us all straight?  We know each other too well to think that all the most spiritual people are Wesleyans or Baptists or Lutherans or Catholics or Reformed or Quakers.  There are equally spiritual, equally open, equally intelligent individuals in all denominations.  Correcting the finer points of our ideas just does not seem to be high on God's agenda.

And look at how long God took to send Christ.  Even those whose interpretation of Genesis leads them to believe in a young earth see God waiting thousands of years before Christ came, and even the staunchest Protestant will have to deal with God waiting over a thousand years to send Martin Luther to get things back on track.  Other Christians will see God waiting millions or even billions of years just to bring humanity into the world, let alone to redeem us!

In short, no likely understanding of God sees correcting our understanding as God's first order of business. God just has not moved that quickly in history.  And thus it is that while ideas matter to Wesleyans, the state of your heart and the state of your life are much more important.  Are you a Seventh-Day Adventist who worships on Saturday, believes our souls sleep before the resurrection, and maybe even stays away from pork?  Wesleyans would join almost all other Christians in thinking you probably have emphasized the wrong biblical passages.  But as Wesley said, "if your heart is as my heart... then put your hand in mine." [2]

[1] Plato's reporting of Socrates' philosophy.

[2] From his sermon, "On a Catholic Spirit."

Saturday, December 04, 2010

I wish I could understand this!


If I had nothing else to do and was independently wealthy, I'd sure spend some time trying to understand these two paragraphs from Wikipedia ;-)
______
Petr Hořava is well-known for his articles written with Edward Witten about the Hořava-Witten domain walls in M-theory.  These articles demonstrated that the ten-dimensional heterotic E8 x E8 string theory could be produced from 11-dimensional M-theory by making one of the dimensions have edges (the domain walls). This discovery provided crucial support for the conjecture that all string theories could arise as various limits of a single higher-dimensional theory.
Hořava is less well known for his discovery of D-branes, usually attributed to Dai, Leigh and Polchinski, who discovered them independently, also in 1989. In 2009, Hořava proposed a theory of gravity that separates space from time at high energy while matching some predictions of general relativity at lower energies

God Looks on the Heart 2

This is the second post (see the first here) of the second section (see the last of it here) of a little project that is  meant to capture my vision for the Wesleyan tradition in the early twenty-first century.
___________
Christianity does have two great absolutes of action: love God and love neighbor.  The rest is complicated.  These principles play themselves out in different ways in different times and places, and they play themselves out differently in different situations even within a particular context.  This is the approach that Jesus and Paul modeled in Scripture, and it is only our penchant for systematizing and easy answers that would lead us in a different direction.

The conflict in Mark 2 over the Sabbath is illuminating.  In this story, the Pharisees question why Jesus' disciples are violating the Sabbath by plucking grain on Saturday (2:24).  Jesus does not say, as the impulse of many today would be, that the Pharisees do not understand the Sabbath law.  He does not say, for example, that the Sabbath is about rest or worship.  Jesus accepts the accusation and argues instead that there is a time to make exceptions to the rule.  Did not David and the high priest make an exception to the rule against eating the bread of presentation because his fighting men were hungry?  In short, Jesus does not treat the Sabbath law as an absolute.

Indeed, Paul treats it as a matter of personal conviction in Romans 14:5.  Again, the impulse of some might say that it is only a legalistic keeping of the Sabbath that Paul rejects.  But where is there any evidence for such a position in the biblical text?  The Sabbath law in the Old Testament is a purely concrete law, not some abstract principle.  It is about not working from sundown Friday to sundown Saturday.  It is not about worshiping on Saturday.  It is not about taking some time off some day each week.  You will not get such abstractions from what the biblical texts actually say, only from an impulse to find some principle behind every specific command.

So we might be shocked to find Paul telling the Romans that keeping the Sabbath law is a matter of personal conviction (Rom. 14:5).  We might be shocked to hear Colossians telling its Gentile audience not to let anyone judge them for their observance of Sabbaths (Col. 2:16), connecting such observance to the "elemental spirits" (2:20, NRSV) that are limited to an earthly realm they have left behind as believers.  We will find no text in the New Testament that reduces the Sabbath law to a principle of rest or that transfers it to Sunday.  Instead, Paul relativizes this Ten Commandment, reducing it to a matter of personal conviction.

The point is that we should certainly start as Christians with the specific ethical commands of Scripture, but it is really the two great commands that are the absolutes: love God and love neighbor.  Because history and culture change, these principles must always be contextualized when it comes to specifics.  An insistence on keeping the letter of Scripture sometimes only results in peculiarity--we confuse women's hairstyles in the forties and fifties for keeping 1 Corinthians 11. At other times it can work against the main principles.

For example, it was the American "letteralists," the fundamentalists if you would, of the early 1800s that argued in favor of slavery as an institution.  Do not Colossians, Ephesians, and 1 Peter accept slavery as an institution, and tell slaves to submit to their masters even when their masters are unjust?  A careful reading of Philemon as well confirms that Paul even there does not tell this slave owner to free his slave Onesimus.  Following the letter and the specifics of Scripture did not lead to abolition but merely to reform within the institution.

It was thus groups like the Wesleyan Methodists and the Quakers who saw beyond the letter to the true absolute principles and worked for abolition.  The trajectory of the kingdom was clear enough--in Christ there is neither slave nor free (Gal. 3:28).  So why would we not abolish slavery now if we have the chance?  If we really viewed the slave as our neighbor, if we really treated them as we would have others treat us, would we not grant them their freedom?  Would we not rather make all humans our equal and abolish the very institution, the very earthly structure that facilitated "hate" of neighbor?

The heart of the Wesleyan tradition is thus not "letteralist" or fundamentalist.  It is principled, but on the two great ethical principles that appear consistently throughout the New Testament and that were anticipated in key Scriptures of the Old: love God and love neighbor.  The working out of the specifics may start with the specifics of Scripture, but it must end with the complex, corporate wrestling of the body of Christ with the specifics of any time and place, with a view to the trajectory of God's kingdom to come.

In the implementation of these two great principles, the Wesleyan tradition clearly has a tendency toward what is called "pragmatism," a focus on what works or what seems useful rather than on uncompromising principles.  Here we once again see a difference in flavor from other traditions.  The very word "compromise" is a dirty word in many Christian circles.  Some might stereotype a pragmatist as someone who either does not understand theory or who does not have the courage of will to stick to his or her principles.  What we are suggesting here instead is that the theory of the person who condemns us is in fact incorrect, as are some key principles.  The nature of love, the key principle, is to compromise on everything but the most central principles when it is appropriate.  For God, people trump rules.

This line of thought leads us to the question of absolute truth.  Does the pragmatic, Wesleyan tradition believe in absolute truth? ...

Friday, December 03, 2010

God Looks on the Heart 1

In 1 Samuel, when God is directing Samuel to anoint David king, Samuel first sees David's brother Eliab and thinks that surely he is the one to be king.  God's response is a text from which Wesleyans have often preached: "Do not look on his appearance or on the height of his stature, because I have rejected him; for the Lord does not see as mortals see; they look on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart" (1 Sam. 16:7, NRSV).  People look at outward appearance; God looks at the heart.

The Wesleyan tradition is not primarily oriented around what we as Christians believe, although beliefs are important.  Actions are also very important to our tradition, but even here, the Wesleyan tradition at its best is not primarily focused on behavior.  At its best, the Wesleyan tradition is focused on the heart rather than the head or the hands.

And rightly so.  Jesus himself in Mark 7 affirms this heart orientation when he rejects a focus on Levitical purity in deference to the attitude of the heart (Mark 7:20-23).  We also misunderstand Paul if we think his sense of God's standard of righteousness is really absolute.  We do not rightly understand Paul if we think his definition of sin is anything short of absolute perfection.  Sin for him is "whatever does not proceed from faith" (Rom. 14:23).  In other words, sin is primarily a matter of intention rather than performance. [1]

John Wesley did not start out intending to found a church.  In fact, he remained an Anglican minister till his death, even though he did ordain bishops for the newly formed United States of America.  When he gave the "Methodist" movement clarity on what to believe, he did not write a "systematic theology," as John Calvin had two hundred years before.  Instead, he bequeathed his followers a set of standard sermons.  If this movement of lay leaders and Anglican ministers would preach in agreement with those sermons, then they were part of the movement.

Some might want to think less of these Methodists for such a practical orientation.  Wesley himself ironically had the personality of a purist, an idealist.  But his ideas also told him that the mission trumped his preferences.  So Wesley no doubt hated preaching outside church walls, something that simply was not done in his day.  His personality was such that he no doubt hated breaking this long standing understanding of where worship takes place.  But when he did not have a pulpit available, he did the next best thing.  He made an exception.

This is the ethos of the Wesleyan tradition, and we believe it flows nicely from Scripture.  Notice the difference in emphasis from that of some other Christians today.  One hears a lot today about how important absolutes are.  But the nature of absolutes is not to make exceptions.  Such was not Jesus' orientation, who was criticized for the exceptions he made.  Such was not the nature of Wesley, who compromised on non-essentials so that the essentials could take place.  Such rhetoric is foreign to the Wesleyan tradition, that wants to bring God's will to bear on this particular situation, not to force some supposed exceptionless rule on every situation...

[1] To be sure, one can also wrong another person unintentionally and a person can be unaware of sinful motives.  But the starting point for understanding sin is with intent.

Thursday, December 02, 2010

What's in a Denomination? 3

The two beginning posts in this series are here first and here second.
________
So what is distinctive about the Wesleyan tradition and the Wesleyan Church?  It is admittedly a little awkward even to ask this question.  Is it not much more important for us to accentuate the things we hold in common with all Christians everywhere: "one Lord, one faith, one baptism; one God and Father of us all" (Eph. 4:5-6)?

And indeed, we all do share most of our beliefs and practices in common with other Christians.  We believe in God the Father Almighty, who made heaven and earth from nothing.  We believe Jesus was God come to earth as a human like the rest of us, except without sin.  We believe he rose bodily from the dead and that we will too.  These are common Christian beliefs, the faith of the church universal.  We believe that if we truly love God and love our fellow human, we have met all God's expectations.

Nevertheless, despite how much we have in common, identity is most clearly defined in what is different, in our distinctives.  What is distinctive about the Wesleyan tradition, especially at this point in history?  These may not be completely unique among Christians, but a particular mix of convictions and emphases that helps you know our flavor, what might be different about us from some other places you might worship or train.

The following pages lay out a few areas where the Wesleyan tradition has a flavor that differs from some other traditions.  First, we tend to be a "pietist" tradition, which means that we are more concerned about a person's   devotion to God in heart and life than whether you have all your ideas straight.  Ideas matter, but we do not think they are God's first order of business.  We are thus primarily oriented around a person's intentions and how they play out in your life and living.

Secondly, our heritage is "Arminian."  Basically, we do not believe that God forces anyone to accept or reject him and that potentially anyone might be saved.  By the same token, God's grace to us requires faithfulness, such that those who turn their backs on God--even if they genuinely served him at one point--cannot ultimately be part of God's kingdom.  In this age, we thus see God's love as a more dominant characteristic than his justice or judgment.

Thirdly, the impact of John Wesley in particular on our identity is quite optimistic about the extent to which God wants to transform both us as individuals and the world in general.  We believe God can so thoroughly redeem an individual's heart that you can not only consistently make the right choices but that you can do it with delight.  We also do not believe that, in most contexts today, we need wait until the kingdom of God to see society change.  We believe in bringing good news to the poor and oppressed, what is often called "social justice" today.  Our particular brand of Wesleyanism was formed as an abolitionist movement against slavery. We have ordained women since the late 1800s and believe a woman can take any role of leadership in the church.

Lastly, our particular brand of Wesleyanism received its most distinctive identity from the "revivalist" movements of the late 1800s and early 1900s.  It thus shares with Pentecostal traditions an experiential emphasis on the Holy Spirit and his direction.  Our parentage in revivalism gives us an openness to hearing the Bible beyond its original meaning and to a spontaneity in mission and worship.  Like Wesley and so many revivalists, we are oriented around getting to the goal rather than on proper form or working out all the theoretical details.  The Spirit is with us on the journey to provide guidance and course correction...  

2.5 Million Dollar Gift to Wesley Seminary

The family that owns Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. has made a $2.5 million commitment to Indiana Wesleyan University for a new building that will house Wesley Seminary at Indiana Wesleyan University.

The IWU Board of Trustees, at a meeting in October, approved construction of the 21,000-square-foot seminary building that would include classrooms, faculty offices and a multi-purpose gathering place for students to study and fellowship.  The university is pursuing additional funding for the building, which is estimated to cost $7 million. Construction of the seminary building could begin as early as spring of 2011.

“We are pleased to assist Indiana Wesleyan with its new seminary building because of our family’s passion and vision to see universities train young men and women in the word of God,” said Tyler Green, Ministries Coordinator for Hobby Lobby Stores.  Tyler Green is the grandson of David and Barbara Green, the founders and owners of Hobby Lobby Stores. Tyler Green and his wife, Kristin, are IWU graduates.  Hobby Lobby Stores, a private company based in Oklahoma City, operates 457 stores nationwide. The company was founded in 1972.

“We are grateful not only for this generous gift but also for the friendship that has developed in recent years between the Green family and IWU,” said IWU President Henry Smith. “Barbara Green, because of her business expertise and her passion for ministry, has been an invaluable member of the IWU Board of Trustees.”

“This gift is a double blessing,” said Dr. Wayne Schmidt, Seminary vice president. “Its generosity makes our facility a reality, and the Green family so wonderfully represents that which we value. The Seminary already is becoming known for its innovation and expansion in order to meet the needs of those it serves.”

We're very grateful to the Green family for their continued investment in the university and now in the seminary.  Thanks always to God as well for his continued gifts! 

Wednesday, December 01, 2010

What's in a Denomination? 2

The first post in this series is here.  Although my verbosity may need edited, my intention is that this would be translated and used as an introduction to Wesley Seminary at IWU in Spanish, perhaps also for the Anglo students as well.
_____________
Denominations are not particularly popular these days, and understandably so.  At least in some parts of the Western world, the individual is more empowered than ever.  The idea of a bureaucracy or hierarchy dictating what you must believe or how you must behave is less and less attractive.  Veils of secrecy have also come down, revealing how spiritually ordinary, even inferior many Christian leaders are.  We hear of prominent Christian leaders having affairs or priests sexually abusing children.  In the "Information Age," things that used to be hidden all too easily come to light.

In my own pilgrimage, I used to hold ministers in much higher regard until I actually became one.  Then as I studied and I became a scholar, I realized that even those who made recommendations on denominational articles of religion and codes of practice were also individuals just like me.  I came to the conclusion that it was the charge of a minister that is sacred, the office of a minister, as it were.  And the beliefs and practices of denominations represent the convictions and commitments of a particular group of Christians, a sweet smelling offering to God rather than the final answer on absolute truth.

So I have come to believe that denominations can be servants of God as well as individuals, means of grace to those within their reach, if their leaders and participants have the right spirit, if they have the right perspective on their place in the universal church.  We sometimes speak of the "invisible church" to get at the truth that God's church cannot be identified with any one church or denomination.  Individuals within the Roman Catholic Church, in this view, are part of the invisible church, but the Roman Catholic Church is not the same as the church catholic, for the church catholic includes all true believers in all times, all places, and all churches.

At the same time, language of the invisible church is only a proverb for one side of the truth.  An equally true proverb is that there is no such thing as an invisible church.  The true church of God is always visible.  That is to say, God's people meet together and can be seen together visibly.  The visible church does not have to be in a dedicated church building.  Many if not most of the earliest believers met in houses.

But there is no such thing as a lone Christian.  The very notion of the "body of Christ" implies believers in connection with other believers in local assembly.  In fact, this is what the word "church" means in Greek, an assembly.  You do not have to meet in assembly every week to stay in Christian community.  Yes, you can experience God as an individual in a boat on a lake.  But your spiritual vibrancy will fade away if you do not connect for long.  Intentional removal of oneself from the body of Christ is a path away from the head of the body, Christ...

Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Launching the MDIV in Spanish

The greatest strength of IWU is its "can do" spirit, its eagerness to innovate.  It has been its orientation this last decade.  IWU isn't perfect.  It isn't necessarily the first adopter.  There's plenty of room for improvement.  Just because it is forward looking on this venture here today does not mean it will be on that issue or in the future.

But, man, what a ride it's been this last decade!

The latest instance is the launch of the MDIV entirely in Spanish this January, after just a year and a half as a seminary.  It's been quite a rush, with everyone in a flurry to get webpages and data systems in place, flipping the Spanish switch in Blackboard.  We've seen the future in Google Translate.  Man, it's not perfect but did you know you can set Google automatically to translate your incoming emails into English!

There's a whole philosophy at work here that I hope one day we'll give full expression to.  It's a pragmatist philosophy.  It's "we learn by doing."  It's "truth rises from the particulars rather than truth as the playing out of universals."  It's "truth is closely related to what works and systems of truth should correspond closely to the presenting data of reality."  The philosophical cloud brings to mind terms like pragmatism, Aristotle, empiricism, Occam, Wittgenstein, non-foundationalism, critical realism, etc.  It seems on an opposite end from Platonism, rationalism, presuppositionalism, foundationalism, fundamentalism.

It's the internet (statistically generated paths rather than pre-planned ones).  It's networking rather than top down hierarchy.  It's a Wikipedia that is mostly right and generated overnight rather than a project planned out over ten years.  It's Google translate that is based on a statistical model--probability--rather than a program in which a fluent expert  sits down and tries to program a dictionary.  It's learn what you need as you need it (and thus remember it) rather than learn the entire system and only then move to application (after you've largely forgotten it or never really learned it in the first place).  It's you almost always learn it a little wrongly first and then only later refine your understanding.  

In short, Erasmus wins.

I'm sure I'll blog more on the Spanish MDIV in the days to come.  This post didn't even start out about this.

FOX: "Bailout clipped taxpayers for $25 Billion"...

If you can't see, I'm smiling.  This FOX news article is about the fact that the current estimate for what the TARP bailout will cost the American people in the end is $25 billion.  The initial payout was $700 billion and the current final tally is half a previous estimate that was itself considered overly optimistic.

So what I'm smiling at is FOX's begrudging wording of the news in the worse way possible.  The news is that Bush/Obama's bailouts saved the economy and quickly stabilized the world economy for way, way less than anyone hoped.  The news is that Bush and Obama's decision was the right one and that FOX and the Tea Party were wrong on this one.

But I will take the faint praise of the FOX article anyway: "The bailout fund, known as the Troubled Asset Relief Program, became hugely unpopular with the public and in Congress. Advocates and even some critics, however, credit it for stabilizing the financial sector in the wake of Wall Street's meltdown in 2008."  Read between the lines: even economists who oppose the TARP bailout recognize that it stabilized the financial sector. 

The anger of the American people, at least on this particular subject, was misplaced, based on ignorance, and fanned by conservative rabble rousers who were wrong, at least on this one.

What's in a Denomination? 1

Wesley Seminary at Indiana Wesleyan University--that is quite a mouthful.  You can tell from the word "seminary" that it is a place to train ministers on the graduate level.  It is a place of education and training.

It is located "at Indiana Wesleyan University"--at least that is where its main offices and its main onsite classrooms are.  It is there where can find most of its faculty.  That is where you will soon find the "seminary building," its central hub, if you would.  Thus far, however, we have found the greatest demand for seminary education online.  If the traditional onsite seminary is struggling to find individuals who can move to their campuses for three years, the desire for training "on the job," in location out there where people are already doing ministry, is strong.  Indeed, it is like a torrent welled up and longing for release.

Indiana Wesleyan University is a broader place of learning.  It has a traditional undergraduate campus and residential student population.  It has a massive adult program with many different degrees offered both at dozens of sites in Indiana and nearby states, as well as around the world online.  This existing infrastructure has made it possible to have a seminary that can survive economically.  

Finally, the words "Wesley" and "Wesleyan" show up prominently in our name.  This name locates us as a seminary in the Methodist tradition, a tradition that traces back to an eighteenth century English minister named John Wesley.  The Wesleyan tradition, as it is called, has a certain flavor that colors the kind of seminary education you receive at Wesley Seminary at IWU.  The next few pages aim to give you some sense of exactly what that flavor might be...

Monday, November 29, 2010

Bounds on Grace in the Fathers...

Is the Theological Seminar today at 3:30 in the IWU CM building, Room 122.  "Grace in the Early Church" is his topic, I believe.

Sunday, November 28, 2010

Ephesians: Colossians Expanded and Universalized

It is also fascinating to compare Ephesians to Colossians.  For example, at one point Ephesians is exactly the same as Colossians for over twenty-five words straight, namely, at the end when commending Tychicus to the audiences (Eph. 6:21-22; Col. 4:7-8).  For this reason, some have suggested that Ephesians might be the lost letter to the Laodiceans mentioned in Colossians 4:16.  Indeed, at no less than thirteen points, Ephesians and Colossians say either exactly or almost exactly the same thing, in the same order.[i]  Because in each case Colossians’ version seems more concretely related to its audience’s situation and because Ephesians seems to expand many of the points, it seems that Ephesians used Colossians as its starting point.  Ephesians in some respects is an expanded and universalized version of Colossians.


[i] E.g., Col. 1:14 and Eph. 1:7 (in whom we have redemption, through his blood); Col. 1:16-17 and Eph. 1:21 (above all spiritual powers); Col. 1:18 and Eph. 1:22-23 (head of the body, the church); Col. 1:21-22 and Eph. 2:16-17 (reconciling those far away through Christ’s blood); Col. 1:26-27 and Eph. 3:4-6 (mystery of the Gentiles’ inclusion); Col. 2:1 and Eph. 3:2 (audience has only heard, not seen Paul’s ministry); Col. 2:3 and Eph. 3:4 (mystery of Christ); Col. 2:15 and Eph. 3:10 (rulers and authorities) ; Col. 2:19 and Eph. 4:16 (body grows out of the head); Col. 3:9 and Eph. 4:22 (put off old self); Col. 3:9 and Eph. 4:25 (do not lie to each other); Col. 3:18-4:1 and Eph. 5:22-6:9 (household codes); Col. 4:7-8 and Eph. 6:21-22 (word for word closing).

Ephesians: Predestination (chap 7)

To God be praise for planning before creating the world to make his people holy and blameless (1:4). To God be praise for planning to reconcile heaven and earth to himself through Christ at just the right time in history (1:10). To God be praise for arranging ahead of time to adopt those who believe as his children (1:5). We have seen no predestination language of this sort elsewhere in Paul’s writings. Sure, Romans 9 is extensively about God’s right to predetermine the fate of his people, but Paul there does not really celebrate being a part of the “elect.” Ephesians 1 gives us the primary instance in the Pauline collection where we find a celebration of being part of the elect, being part of those chosen by God.

Even here, however, the celebration is for those who are already in. Ephesians 1 does not use predestination language to exclude those who are out or predict those who will come in. It is language that praises God collectively for those who are already in. It thus functions, as we argued in chapter 4, as “after the fact” language that relates more to believers as a whole than as individual believers.

Indeed, if we take predestination language in Ephesians 1 as some do, we run into all sorts of thorny problems. Some, for example, would suggest that God not only arranged for us to be saved but for Adam to fail in the first place so that we would need to be saved. Surely it is foolish for us to try to figure out the details of what God was thinking before the creation. How could we possibly understand such things? Surely the poetic comments of passages like Ephesians 1 are the barest of pictures.

God knew the world would need fixed. God knew he would fix it through Christ. God knew that not all would avail themselves of Christ and be rescued. The precise dynamics are mystery, and the biblical texts themselves gave their original audiences pictures they could understand. We know that God was and is in control of all things. We know that God’s desire is to save. We know that not everyone is rescued in the end. The connection of these dots is mystery.

Saturday, November 27, 2010

Works: Ephesians vs. Romans (chap 7)

Ephesians 2:8-9 have had an immense impact on the history of Christianity these last five hundred years because these are some of the key verses of the Protestant Reformation: “by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this not from yourselves, it is the gift of God—not by works, so that no one can boast.” Interpreters of Paul ever since have had a tendency to read Paul’s earlier letters through the lens of these verses. But there are some key distinctions between Ephesians 2:8-9 and letters like Romans and Galatians. It is actually Ephesians that is unusual for Paul.

For example, Paul does not usually speak of salvation in the past tense: “you have been saved.” Romans 5:9 speaks of how we will be saved from God’s wrath, namely, on the Day of Wrath which is to come. Salvation is thus something that has not yet happened literally. Even in Ephesians, “you have been saved” probably is a poetic way of saying that it is a sure thing. Because of God’s grace, because of the audience’s faith, their salvation is going to happen at the appropriate time.

A second difference is in what “works” are in mind. In Galatians and Romans, the works Paul has in mind are works of the Jewish Law. Paul may be writing to Gentiles, but he is defending his preaching in the light of objections from other Jewish believers. His basic message is that no one can be right with God by how well they keep the particulars of the Jewish Law, especially the parts that most distinguished Jew from Gentile: circumcision, food laws, Sabbath observance, and so forth.

But Ephesians is not a defense against Jewish opposition. Ephesians only uses the word “law” once, and there only to say that Christ has abolished it—also quite unlike Romans, as we will see below. So when Ephesians 2:9 says that its audience is not saved by works, it is saying something quite different from Romans 3:28. The works in question are not works of the Jewish Law, but good works in general. While Romans says that a Jew does not have an advantage before God because of the Jewish Law, Ephesians says that no one is good enough to escape God’s wrath.

Interestingly, Ephesians is accordingly more positive toward works once one is "saved."  We are "created in Christ Jesus to do good works" (Eph. 2:10).  In Romans and Galatians, works of law are something a Gentile believer should not do.  Indeed, Paul tells the Galatians that if they become circumcised, Christ will be of no use to them (Gal. 5:2).  So works of Law are something a believer should not do, at least not a Gentile believer.  In Ephesians, by contrast, good works are a good thing.  They cannot save a person from God's wrath, but they are something God has created us to do in the name of Christ.

Friday, November 26, 2010

Household in Colossians (chap 6)

It is not hard to understand these instructions to the Colossians, a city that may very well have been destroyed by an earthquake in AD61. It is more difficult to know how to apply them. In the early 1800s, Colossians was one of many texts that those who opposed the abolition of slavery used to show that the New Testament accepted slavery as an institution. Certainly “there is neither… slave nor free” in Christ Jesus (Gal. 3:28). But Paul could reconcile this principle with the existence of slavery in the meantime. Sure, a time was coming when there would be no slaves, but for the time being each should “remain in the situation God called him to” (1 Cor. 7:24). “Were you a slave when you were called? Don’t let it trouble you—although if you can gain your freedom, do so” (7:21).

Of course Paul also thought that Christ would return far sooner than he has. In that same passage in 1 Corinthians, Paul wrote that “the time is short. From now on those who have wives should live as if they had none” (7:29). In 1 Corinthians, Paul does not think we have time to worry about our social location in society. Slavery would not exist in the kingdom of God, but he had more pressing things to do in the immanence of Christ’s return than work to free slaves.

Colossians does not have this same sense of urgency, and we should recognize the distinction. Social structures that were temporary in 1 Corinthians have become an accommodation to the structures of the age in Colossians. Although women will not be subordinated to husbands in the kingdom—they are not given in marriage there (e.g., Mark 12:25)—Colossians acquiesces to this social structure of the ancient world. And although there will be no slaves in the kingdom, Colossians assumes its continued practice in the meantime.

Indeed, Colossians only puts into effect one of the equal pairs in Galatians 3:28, namely, that of Jew and Greek. Colossians addresses Gentile believers, since in Colossians 2:13 Paul speaks of how they were uncircumcised in flesh when they believed. Colossians thus tells a Gentile audience not to worry about keeping the Jewish particulars of the Law. But slaves are still subordinated to masters, and wives to husbands.

Therefore, the entire Western world—not only the Western church—moved closer to the kingdom of God when it did away with slavery here on earth. It may be hard for us to feel how the church of two hundred years ago struggled with this question. Many Christians argued that slavery should be reformed rather than abolished, and they came to this conclusion from a fair reading of the biblical texts. We now recognize that it was those who looked more to the spiritual principle of “neither slave nor free” who were the true prophets of that day, not those who argued over the specific instructions like those in Colossians, given in specific ancient situations and cultures.

We believe it is the same today with regard to wives and husbands. On the one hand, those who merely try to reform the hierarchical relationship between husband and wife are to be commended for their piety and attention to detail. They want to ensure that husbands do indeed love and not abuse their perceived position of authority. Similarly, wives are affirmed as equally valuable in God’s eyes, only with a different God-ordained role to play. They are like those who preached against masters who abused their slaves but who still taught slaves to be obedient to their masters, as the Bible teaches.

In the end, however, those who merely want to reform marriage while retaining the hierarchical relationship are spiritually short-sighted. Like those who affirmed slavery as biblical, they are correct in the letter but incorrect in the Spirit. There is nothing about the structure of this world that implies a wife needs to be or should be subordinate to a man. Male anatomy and physiology does not automatically make a man a better thinker or leader than a woman, just as female anatomy and physiology does not make women worse thinkers or leaders. Logically, husbands and wives should cooperate in leadership, deferring in love to the needs and desires of the other, deferring to the gifts and expertise of the other.

We know from Scripture that God is leading women in this direction anyway. The kingdom will afford women complete equality with men. We know from practice that one cannot single out a person for leadership or insight on the basis of his or her gender. We know from Scripture that God has used both women and men both in prophetic and leadership roles. In short, if we can move closer to the kingdom now, why would we not?

The instructions of Scripture were not given for their own sake. They were given in a context and must be applied with careful consideration of how the principles might apply today. To work within the structure of a husband-wife hierarchy was already in Paul’s day a concession to the structures of this world. For us to perpetuate them now, however, is for us to move backward, away from the kingdom. In a time when the secular world has enacted the structures of the kingdom, how ironic it would be for the church to resist!

Thursday, November 25, 2010

The Dating of Luke-Acts

I was giving feedback on a seminary assignment and thought I would copy some of what I wrote here.
____________
I believe Luke-Acts was written after the destruction of the temple in AD70 because:

1. Almost all experts have concluded that Luke drew on Mark as a major source, and most experts date Mark either to the late 60s or the early 70s. Luke-Acts would thus have to date later.

There's a whole lot of thinking just behind that preliminary paragraph. For example, there is the synoptic question, the fact that Matthew, Mark, and Luke are so similar on a verbal level (although sometimes with minor variations) that it is a virtually unanimous position that the three stand in some relationship of literary dependence. Most think Mark was first with the others later. A minority think Matthew was first and the others later (I reject this position because Matthew's text is grammatically smoother than Mark, and it makes no sense that Mark would "rough up" Matthew's). But I know of no one who thinks Luke was first.

I'll leave it at that. One thing I'd like to push here is that most pastors have no idea how much minute examination of the biblical texts has led to these sorts of conclusions--or how much support they command among those who have done the homework. It is a disconnect seminary would ideally connect, while letting you come to your own conclusions. In any case, if Mark reached its final form not long after the destruction of Jerusalem (as I think) or even if it was written in the late 60s (as others think), it would place Luke-Acts later, likely after the destruction of the temple.

2. One example of the kind of painstaking and detailed work is when you compare the readings of the individual gospels and look for signs of how the theology of a particular gospel writer impacted the way they edited their sources. For example, when we compare Mark 13:14 with Luke 21:20, we see some clear signs of Luke's editing. Mark and Matthew both have the very ambiguous, "When you see the abomination that causes desolation standing where it should not be..." Luke's version is quite different, "When you see Jerusalem surrounded by armies, you know that its desolation is near."

Could Jesus have said both? Sure. Not likely. This is not a parable Jesus told over and over again. It is an explanation at a particular place and time. And when you have compared the gospels over and over again, you inevitably come to grips with the fact they are using each other and you accept that this is overwhelmingly likely to be Luke editing Mark. Again, there's no substitute for the long, painstaking comparison of the gospels if you really want to understand how this sort of thing works.

So notice how different Luke's inspired "Message" translation of Mark is. In Daniel 11, where the abomination language comes from, we would think it is the temple being desecrated. Matthew and Mark can easily be interpreted this way. The abomination is standing somewhere--in the temple in Daniel. To see it as armies surrounding Jerusalem is not what we would have expected.

In short, Luke's editing has all the marks of an explanation of the prophecy with the insight that comes from being after the events, after the destruction of Jerusalem in AD70. Mind you, I think Matthew is post-70 as well and it doesn't make these changes. But making such edits is part and parcel of the way the NT interprets the OT. Again, long, detailed examination of these patterns leaves us with this sort of strong impression.

In short, I find it very difficult to think of any open-minded way of arguing for a pre-70 date for Luke-Acts. Certainly if one is determined to argue for something, it is almost always possible to do so. In my mind, however, a true scholar of the Bible is someone who looks for what is most probable, not someone who applies their intellect to defend the possible but more convenient!

My opinions. You are welcome to disagree!

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

SBL Day 4 (2010)

By complete coincidence, I'm sitting next to James McGrath, good friend and fellow Dunnite, on the plane ride back to Indy from SBL (who is also blogging ;-).  I missed the bibliobloggers session yesterday he presented at (argh!).

Delta's giving free Wi-Fi on this flight in the name of Google Chrome this Thanksgiving season.  And now that I've left the hotel, let me make fun of the Hyatt Regency in Atlanta for charging us for drinking water, I mean charging for wireless in the hotel room.  So most of the time everyone went down to the Peachtree Center, which actually exists in the twenty-first century ;-)

But if that isn't all, I broke down the final day to do some grading in the room.  Come to find out, the Hyatt has two different rates for wireless the room.  A 10 buck rate to IM people and do some simple stuff at a slow rate and a "business" one at almost $13 to get full bandwidth and email with attachments.  Then my roomate, Eric Key, a student at Wesley, tried to get on in the room and they were going to charge him too to get on!

Today's twentieth century award goes to the Hyatt Regency in Atlanta.  In the sentiments of Eric's wife, Even cheap hotels offer free Wi-Fi.

Anyway, I went to the Philo Group this morning, which is always a delight for me.  It is just amazing how well these Philo scholars know their texts and the secondary literature.  There were presenters from Italy, Israel, and US, and John Barclay of Durham responded.

Then a seemless retraction from Atlanta, with my bulky carry on adequately stowed overhead, and free Wi-Fi in the air (and, let me say, I've been shocked to find Delta on time both to and from).  Today's twenty-first century award goes to Delta ;-)

Now back to work...

Colossians Excerpt

From my second, forthcoming Paul book:
_________
Once we have a clearer sense of what Colossians is combating, we can also clear up some misapplications of these passages. Many a Christian has used Colossians 2:8’s critique of a “philosophy,” to rail against education and “highfalutin” learning. It is the all too common, popular, and deeply ironic notion that education makes you “stupider.” Certainly learning can confuse a person. The great thing about common sense is that it works! At least it seems to work. It just often does not work for the reasons we tell ourselves.

I can think of at least two reasons why so many Americans, including very many American Christians, have a negative sense of education. The first is that it exposes our own ignorance both of ourselves and the world around us. Learning can expose the faultiness of our reasoning, and it can expose our prejudices. We may find out that we do not think certain things for the reasons we pretended we did. The darker or ignorant sides of our motivations may be laid bare, and none of us like to feel stupid.

So we laugh at those “nerds” who can do math and science, in part to cover our own inability to understand. We make fun of scientists who believe in global warming or evolution, when we might flunk a college class in biology or environmental science. It is unfortunately and ironically the American way to think our opinion is just as valid as those who are actually experts and have studied a particular subject for years. Despite the fact that we spend our nights watching cartoons or the latest comedy on TV, we somehow, amazingly, think that our uneducated hunches are just as valid as “so called” experts.

If part of the problem is ours, part of the problem also lies with the experts as well. They often disagree fundamentally with each other. Indeed, sometimes their theories do not seem to correspond at all to our experiences on the ground. If the greatest validation of a theory is that it work in the real world, then many theories of thinkers in various fields do not ring true. Again, the reason why common sense is so compelling is because it seems to work in everyday life.

Of course science does seem to work very well. We drive cars, ride airplanes, use cell phones and computers. If our common sense seems to conflict with the applied sciences, we should probably concede the battle. When it comes to more abstract fields like philosophy and theology, it is more difficult to see the pay off. So many thinkers seem to live in a self-contained world, like they are speaking a completely foreign language to everyday life. At least in part, therefore, some of them have perhaps earned our questions.

But one thing is clear. The Colossian philosophy was not like the philosophy class you would take at your local college. Colossians is not protesting against education or against theoretical thinking. Colossians was warning the believers at Colossae about a particular form of Jewish religious practice more akin to something you would find at a charismatic church than at a university. If we want to protest against some aspect of education or philosophy, we will have to indict it on its own merits rather than with some blanket condemnation based on the word “philosophy” in Colossians. Indeed, this is a great illustration of where learning about the context of Colossians helps us understand the truth more accurately.