Found this round-up of some web CEB reaction from a year ago on John Hobbins' blog: http://ancienthebrewpoetry.typepad.com/ancient_hebrew_poetry/2009/11/the-common-english-bible-a-roundup-of-posts-and-some-critical-notes.html.
It will be interesting to see where the CEB goes. I noticed this morning that while it goes with the "faithfulness of Jesus Christ" in Romans 3:22 it sticks with the traditional "faith in Jesus" in Galatians 2:16. Oops--must have been two different translation teams.
Other things I have mixed feelings about. While it's hard to hear "Son of Man" rendered as "the Human One" or "abomination that causes desolation" as "disgusting and destructive thing," I have to admit it is only because I have a doctorate in New Testament and I have no question but that the CEB's version would be more understandable to just about anyone.
Saturday, November 06, 2010
Friday, November 05, 2010
American Syncretism in Christian Worship
Couldn't come up with a better title. This week in the seminary's worship class they are looking at acts of worship beyond baptism, communion, and other sign acts (last week involved everything from tongues to footwashing). We're talking weddings, funerals, and things we might put in the category of "civil religion," including the frequent intersection of nationalism with Christian worship.
For example, I don't get too bent out of shape over it, but it seems very peculiar to put an American flag in the pulpit area. We are so used to this practice that it is hard for us to see how truly bizarre it is. To try to get at the bizarreness, imagine how Dietrich Bonhoeffer would respond if he had walked in after seeing Nazi flags in German churches? Picture a Brazilian flag on a pulpit in Brazil or a Russian flag in a Russian Orthodox chancel. Are we saying that we worship our country along with God or that our country is as holy as the cross. Imagine how we Protestants would react to an icon of a Christian saint up front--and it's at least Christian! God smiles.
There are other perspectives you commonly hear from worship professors, things that most American ministers have never even thought of. For example, although I think God is very patient, I would strongly urge couples getting married to include the congregation in communion if they are having it. Communion is not something two people do in private. It is a body of Christ thing.
Other things worship experts often say, perhaps with less force than the above: 1) having a wedding outside rather than in a church building hints at a mindset that is probably leaning more secular than Christian; 2) the Wedding March comes from A Midsummer Night's Dream, hardly a Christian drama, and is odd in a worship service; 3) close the casket at a funeral because a Christian funeral should be a worship service, and a worship service is more about God than the individual who has died; 4) some even argue against the typical time of testimonials to the dead person in the worship service of the funeral proper.
What are your thoughts? I always smile at a church that makes a big deal out of Memorial Day, the Fourth of July, and Mother's Day, but couldn't tell you what Advent or Ash Wednesday was to save its life. This is the typical syncretism of religion and culture that takes place everywhere in all religions.
For example, I don't get too bent out of shape over it, but it seems very peculiar to put an American flag in the pulpit area. We are so used to this practice that it is hard for us to see how truly bizarre it is. To try to get at the bizarreness, imagine how Dietrich Bonhoeffer would respond if he had walked in after seeing Nazi flags in German churches? Picture a Brazilian flag on a pulpit in Brazil or a Russian flag in a Russian Orthodox chancel. Are we saying that we worship our country along with God or that our country is as holy as the cross. Imagine how we Protestants would react to an icon of a Christian saint up front--and it's at least Christian! God smiles.
There are other perspectives you commonly hear from worship professors, things that most American ministers have never even thought of. For example, although I think God is very patient, I would strongly urge couples getting married to include the congregation in communion if they are having it. Communion is not something two people do in private. It is a body of Christ thing.
Other things worship experts often say, perhaps with less force than the above: 1) having a wedding outside rather than in a church building hints at a mindset that is probably leaning more secular than Christian; 2) the Wedding March comes from A Midsummer Night's Dream, hardly a Christian drama, and is odd in a worship service; 3) close the casket at a funeral because a Christian funeral should be a worship service, and a worship service is more about God than the individual who has died; 4) some even argue against the typical time of testimonials to the dead person in the worship service of the funeral proper.
What are your thoughts? I always smile at a church that makes a big deal out of Memorial Day, the Fourth of July, and Mother's Day, but couldn't tell you what Advent or Ash Wednesday was to save its life. This is the typical syncretism of religion and culture that takes place everywhere in all religions.
Thursday, November 04, 2010
$9.99 special on my Paul book...
This was the promo that went out today from my publisher: ;-)
_____________
Learn from Paul's Life and Letters
NEW!
SALE! Only $9.99! (Reg. $14.99)
Act Now! Sale ends Nov. 12.
Click HERE or call 1-800-493-7539.
Table of Contents and a FREE Excerpt! (This is the first chapter of the book)
Author Kenneth Schenck bridges time and culture to bring you Paul—Messenger of Grace. Immerse yourself in the world of one of history’s most polarizing figures to learn about his background, his conversion, his missionary journeys, and his letters. But this is not just a history book; each chapter concludes with the author’s reflections about how Paul’s life and letters can help shape our lives more into the image of Christ.
Paul—Messenger of Grace covers the earlier part of Paul’s life and ministry including the Bible books of 1Thessalonians, 1 and 2 Corinthians, Galatians, and Philippians.
Preview the Messenger of Grace Bible Studies!
Coming December 2010!
__________
There are two 5 week Bible study books in association with the book, both coming out next month, one on 1 Thessalonians and the second on Philippians.
_____________
Learn from Paul's Life and Letters
NEW!
SALE! Only $9.99! (Reg. $14.99)
Act Now! Sale ends Nov. 12.
Click HERE or call 1-800-493-7539.
Table of Contents and a FREE Excerpt! (This is the first chapter of the book)
Author Kenneth Schenck bridges time and culture to bring you Paul—Messenger of Grace. Immerse yourself in the world of one of history’s most polarizing figures to learn about his background, his conversion, his missionary journeys, and his letters. But this is not just a history book; each chapter concludes with the author’s reflections about how Paul’s life and letters can help shape our lives more into the image of Christ.
Paul—Messenger of Grace covers the earlier part of Paul’s life and ministry including the Bible books of 1Thessalonians, 1 and 2 Corinthians, Galatians, and Philippians.
Preview the Messenger of Grace Bible Studies!
Coming December 2010!
__________
There are two 5 week Bible study books in association with the book, both coming out next month, one on 1 Thessalonians and the second on Philippians.
Criteria of Missional Faithfulness
Lois Barrett in Treasure in Clay Jars has 8 criteria for taking the missional temperature of a church. I thought I'd summarize them in my own language:
1. Missionary Vocation: Does your congregation define success in terms of its faithfulness to Christ, not it terms of its numbers?
2. Missional Formation: Is your congregation eager to learn what it means to be a follower of Jesus?
3. Missional Courage: To what extent is the church willing to take risks for the sake of the gospel?
4. Missional Love: Does your congregation love one another as Christ loved the church?
5. Missional Worship: Is worship is the central act of your faith community and does it lead your people to testify to the gospel?
6. Missional Dependency: Does your community confess its dependency on the Holy Spirit in prayer?
7. Missional Agency: Does your congregation see itself as an agent to bring the kingdom of God on earth as in heaven?
8. Missional Authority: Does the Holy Spirit work through the leadership of your church so that the congregation has a missional mentality?
1. Missionary Vocation: Does your congregation define success in terms of its faithfulness to Christ, not it terms of its numbers?
2. Missional Formation: Is your congregation eager to learn what it means to be a follower of Jesus?
3. Missional Courage: To what extent is the church willing to take risks for the sake of the gospel?
4. Missional Love: Does your congregation love one another as Christ loved the church?
5. Missional Worship: Is worship is the central act of your faith community and does it lead your people to testify to the gospel?
6. Missional Dependency: Does your community confess its dependency on the Holy Spirit in prayer?
7. Missional Agency: Does your congregation see itself as an agent to bring the kingdom of God on earth as in heaven?
8. Missional Authority: Does the Holy Spirit work through the leadership of your church so that the congregation has a missional mentality?
Wednesday, November 03, 2010
Governmental Hopes
The results are in as you all know. The Republicans take the House by storm. The Dems and Harry Reid only narrowly keep the Senate. What are my hopes for this Congress?
1. I hope it will do what Republicans have often prided themselves on--cutting down the deficit. I don't know how they'll do it. I have fears about missteps in trying to do it. But I wish them all Godspeed in doing it.
2. I hope that both sides will be more flexible than they were these last two years. I hope both sides will let individual Senators vote their consciences rather than destroying those who break rank. The Dems don't have enough to filibuster in the House, so at least we won't see that. I hope we'll see up or down votes in the Senate.
3. I hope some of the good things the Democrats have wanted to do--and in the past some Republicans have wanted to do--will continue forward. Since the Republicans can relax now, I hope they will do some of the things they've opposed just to oppose. Let them take credit for it, sure. Either way, good would be done.
I'm not really expecting any of this, of course. I'm expecting gridlock as usual and many interesting/scary ideological battles to take place, nice things to blog on. ;-)
On the side, here's a post on the NIV around the blogosphere. The reaction seems pretty much the same as mine. Like the first link on that post, I sent in my suggestions where the NIV does voodoo with grammar and the text because of the ideologies of its translators. Pretty much ignored. One shining light, you'll see, is that it translates sarx as flesh in Romans. That was one of my suggestions too.
1. I hope it will do what Republicans have often prided themselves on--cutting down the deficit. I don't know how they'll do it. I have fears about missteps in trying to do it. But I wish them all Godspeed in doing it.
2. I hope that both sides will be more flexible than they were these last two years. I hope both sides will let individual Senators vote their consciences rather than destroying those who break rank. The Dems don't have enough to filibuster in the House, so at least we won't see that. I hope we'll see up or down votes in the Senate.
3. I hope some of the good things the Democrats have wanted to do--and in the past some Republicans have wanted to do--will continue forward. Since the Republicans can relax now, I hope they will do some of the things they've opposed just to oppose. Let them take credit for it, sure. Either way, good would be done.
I'm not really expecting any of this, of course. I'm expecting gridlock as usual and many interesting/scary ideological battles to take place, nice things to blog on. ;-)
On the side, here's a post on the NIV around the blogosphere. The reaction seems pretty much the same as mine. Like the first link on that post, I sent in my suggestions where the NIV does voodoo with grammar and the text because of the ideologies of its translators. Pretty much ignored. One shining light, you'll see, is that it translates sarx as flesh in Romans. That was one of my suggestions too.
Tuesday, November 02, 2010
IWU Religion Coffee Talk 1
I may not post any more of these, but it occurs to me it would be fun to have somewhere some of the ideas IWU undergraduate professors might joke about over coffee--ideological biases of a sort. This is not policy, this is not absolute. It's not even everyone. It's not make or break stuff. It's flavor, even prejudice.
Here's one that occurred to me today. As a piece of IWU mishnah, the word “worldview” immediately would cause knowing looks. The thoughts that immediately go through my head are 1) Reformed? Schaffer? Glenn Martin? (see James Smith's woes), 2) overly simplistic reduction of human motivations and machinations to overly simplistic macro-ideas, 3) inability to read the Bible in its complex contexts, reduction of the multi-genred Bible to overly simplistic propositions. ;-)
Who knows if I will ever come back to tell you the reaction "Barna" causes ;-)
Here's one that occurred to me today. As a piece of IWU mishnah, the word “worldview” immediately would cause knowing looks. The thoughts that immediately go through my head are 1) Reformed? Schaffer? Glenn Martin? (see James Smith's woes), 2) overly simplistic reduction of human motivations and machinations to overly simplistic macro-ideas, 3) inability to read the Bible in its complex contexts, reduction of the multi-genred Bible to overly simplistic propositions. ;-)
Who knows if I will ever come back to tell you the reaction "Barna" causes ;-)
Community as a higher order of reality
Christian Smith will be on campus November 10th to discuss his latest book, What is a Person? Some of us have been reading through it to prepare. Let me say he really is a "J" personality. The book is full of "before I get to x, I need to talk about y" and then "Y has four parts with 3 exceptions and 4 fallacies."
It's not necessarily a hard read--actually he's quite clear. But at one point I sent this link from Monty Python to my friends with the heading, "Christian Smith getting ready to make his point." We've finally concluded that he doesn't really have a point he's building toward. The point of each chapter is actually quite simple.
Here's the Reader's Digest version of his book:
1. Reality exists as something different from me knowing it (critical realism).
2. A person is a higher order of reality than the sum of our parts (against physical reductionism).
3. Much of our reality is socially constructed (against foundationalism), but not all of it (against extreme social constructivism).
4. We are not people apart from relational networks with others.
5. Much of the statistical research in sociology is crap. Correlation does not equal causation. Research that is purely quantitative is crap. Clear cause-effect relationships must be argued for from some theoretical framework.
Well, none of that is why I started this post. It occurred to me more clearly than ever how to frame the importance of community in relation to Christian life and why Barna doesn't know what he's talking about. One of the theories Christian Smith discusses is "emergence theory." As usual, it's a very simple concept pretty obvious to common sense but apparently heavily argued in some circles. It's the idea that there are levels of reality where the whole is greater than the sum of its parts.
For example, I am a biological machine. Some Christian thinkers are currently arguing that what we call the "soul" is not a separable part of me. For the sake of argument, let's say they're right. Nevertheless, myself as a person is a different order of reality. You could add up all the pieces to me but that would not equal me. "I" am a person and a person is a thing of a different order in its own right. I consider this pretty obvious, despite many in sociology currently who might resist it.
And now Schenck finally getting to his point. Genuine community is also like this. It is a different level of reality. Adding up the individuals in a community does not equal the reality of the community together. It is a higher order of reality that is an entity, an organism in its own right. This means you cannot be a complete Christian on your own in the woods. You will be lacking in your Christian identity. Even if you as an individual are more "spiritual" than everyone else in a particular place, you cannot be as spiritual as they are when they are together in Christian community.
This is the hypothesis that struck me today... no doubt one that would have Christian Smith responding, "Isn't that what I said?" ;-)
It's not necessarily a hard read--actually he's quite clear. But at one point I sent this link from Monty Python to my friends with the heading, "Christian Smith getting ready to make his point." We've finally concluded that he doesn't really have a point he's building toward. The point of each chapter is actually quite simple.
Here's the Reader's Digest version of his book:
1. Reality exists as something different from me knowing it (critical realism).
2. A person is a higher order of reality than the sum of our parts (against physical reductionism).
3. Much of our reality is socially constructed (against foundationalism), but not all of it (against extreme social constructivism).
4. We are not people apart from relational networks with others.
5. Much of the statistical research in sociology is crap. Correlation does not equal causation. Research that is purely quantitative is crap. Clear cause-effect relationships must be argued for from some theoretical framework.
Well, none of that is why I started this post. It occurred to me more clearly than ever how to frame the importance of community in relation to Christian life and why Barna doesn't know what he's talking about. One of the theories Christian Smith discusses is "emergence theory." As usual, it's a very simple concept pretty obvious to common sense but apparently heavily argued in some circles. It's the idea that there are levels of reality where the whole is greater than the sum of its parts.
For example, I am a biological machine. Some Christian thinkers are currently arguing that what we call the "soul" is not a separable part of me. For the sake of argument, let's say they're right. Nevertheless, myself as a person is a different order of reality. You could add up all the pieces to me but that would not equal me. "I" am a person and a person is a thing of a different order in its own right. I consider this pretty obvious, despite many in sociology currently who might resist it.
And now Schenck finally getting to his point. Genuine community is also like this. It is a different level of reality. Adding up the individuals in a community does not equal the reality of the community together. It is a higher order of reality that is an entity, an organism in its own right. This means you cannot be a complete Christian on your own in the woods. You will be lacking in your Christian identity. Even if you as an individual are more "spiritual" than everyone else in a particular place, you cannot be as spiritual as they are when they are together in Christian community.
This is the hypothesis that struck me today... no doubt one that would have Christian Smith responding, "Isn't that what I said?" ;-)
Monday, November 01, 2010
NIV, pronounced dead at 37
The NIV2010 revision is now available online. My spot check leads me to conclude that the NIV is now dead at the age of 37.
The NIV was never a very good translation from an inductive Bible study perspective. It wore the theology of its translators on its sleeves in numerous places where it added words and played interpretive possibilities.
The TNIV was a definite improvement, and I was prepared to make it the default for all my church and university writing. Of course politically, the use of "brothers and sisters" for "brothers" opened a door that the ESV walked through. The ESV has quickly become the (Calvinist) evangelical favorite. It is a better formal equivalence translation than the NIV ever was.
In this context, the NIV2010 would have had to hit some sort of wacky home run, and I was very curious to see what they would do. Instead, it is less than expected. It reverses clear gains of the TNIV while keeping the one aspect of the TNIV that ticked its clientele off--"brothers and sisters." So it now combines the skew of the NIV with the marketing challenges of the TNIV.
It's dead. There is nothing here to excite anyone and all the old embarrassments. I wash my hands of the NIV.
The NIV was never a very good translation from an inductive Bible study perspective. It wore the theology of its translators on its sleeves in numerous places where it added words and played interpretive possibilities.
The TNIV was a definite improvement, and I was prepared to make it the default for all my church and university writing. Of course politically, the use of "brothers and sisters" for "brothers" opened a door that the ESV walked through. The ESV has quickly become the (Calvinist) evangelical favorite. It is a better formal equivalence translation than the NIV ever was.
In this context, the NIV2010 would have had to hit some sort of wacky home run, and I was very curious to see what they would do. Instead, it is less than expected. It reverses clear gains of the TNIV while keeping the one aspect of the TNIV that ticked its clientele off--"brothers and sisters." So it now combines the skew of the NIV with the marketing challenges of the TNIV.
It's dead. There is nothing here to excite anyone and all the old embarrassments. I wash my hands of the NIV.
Election Tomorrow!
By all accounts, it looks like the Republicans will take back the House, possibly the Senate as well. I've been really surprised at how weak the Democratic response has been to the Tea Party and Republican ads and rhetoric. Anyone who reads my blog knows that my opinions are that:
In other news, it was my week to post on the seminary blog and I chose the topic Engaging Worldly Powers. Unfortunately for me, I'm up today at 3:30 to present at the Theological Seminar. My topic is "Otherworldly Afterlife with Resurrection." I'll have to go with PowerPoints since I've hardly had time to write a paper these days. It is part of my "Four Afterlife Trajectories in Second Temple Judaism" series, based on research I did on a Fulbright in Germany in 2004. Unfortunately, it took me 10 years to go from initial work to publication on my last scholarly book. I hope I can beat that this time.
- TARP bail-outs saved the world from a global depression, with many banks already having paid back substantial amounts.
- Obama saved thousands of jobs and a big hit on the economy by bailing out GM and Chrysler, with them already having paid back substantial amounts.
- The stimulus bill if anything may not have been enough, but is generally agreed by economists to have improved the economy.
- The health care bill aims at good goals that coincide with Christian goals, although we can debate about the details. The timing given the current debt is a question although something needs to be done and never is.
- The key to the housing crisis was not the lending practices of Fanny Mae and Freddie Mac, although these no doubt need reformed as well. It was what what Wall Street did with these debts, bundling them together and trading them, that created the economic tsunami. This means that regulation of these things is key, the opposite trajectory of those posed to take power tomorrow.
- Rhetoric about socialism or stealing from the people has a Christian sound but really is the typical syncretism of culture with Christianity. It has little to do with biblical teaching read in context and in fact in many respects is ironically opposed to biblical values.
- An approach to government that precludes it from "peripheral" good like supporting the arts or science or empowering the weak in the end will deconstruct America as we know it.
In other news, it was my week to post on the seminary blog and I chose the topic Engaging Worldly Powers. Unfortunately for me, I'm up today at 3:30 to present at the Theological Seminar. My topic is "Otherworldly Afterlife with Resurrection." I'll have to go with PowerPoints since I've hardly had time to write a paper these days. It is part of my "Four Afterlife Trajectories in Second Temple Judaism" series, based on research I did on a Fulbright in Germany in 2004. Unfortunately, it took me 10 years to go from initial work to publication on my last scholarly book. I hope I can beat that this time.
Sunday, October 31, 2010
Short Catechism 3: "God wants everyone to be saved"
This was originally my second, now revised to be third in a series of short chats I am having with my children to convey my sense of Christianity to them beyond what they might absorb from some other Christian activity. The first one was based on James 2:13: "Mercy trumps justice."
The second one is based on 1 Timothy 2:4--"God wants everyone to be saved and come to a knowledge of the truth." Several truths lurk in this verse:
1. First, that people need rescued. We Christians can quibble over things like how depraved the world and we are. But it is painfully obvious that an aweful lot of people are in trouble. They are enslaved to drugs, enslaved to poverty, enslaved to selfishness and greed, enslaved to pleasure and power. The human animal seems self-destructive by nature. The world is thoroughly in need of rescue, both spiritually and materially.
2. Secondly, God does not force anyone to be rescued. He does not predetermine who will be saved and who will not. If he did, everyone would be saved because he wants everyone to be saved. However it works in the mystery of his power and will, he does not force it. He gives everyone a chance.
3. Finally, we want everyone to be saved. We do not give up easily on the hard cases but, like God, work diligently to see them saved in every sense, spiritually and materially. We know the leopard can't change his spots, but God can. With mortals this is impossible, but with God all things are possible. We interact with the world in hope of salvation, not with the presumption of failure.
The second one is based on 1 Timothy 2:4--"God wants everyone to be saved and come to a knowledge of the truth." Several truths lurk in this verse:
1. First, that people need rescued. We Christians can quibble over things like how depraved the world and we are. But it is painfully obvious that an aweful lot of people are in trouble. They are enslaved to drugs, enslaved to poverty, enslaved to selfishness and greed, enslaved to pleasure and power. The human animal seems self-destructive by nature. The world is thoroughly in need of rescue, both spiritually and materially.
2. Secondly, God does not force anyone to be rescued. He does not predetermine who will be saved and who will not. If he did, everyone would be saved because he wants everyone to be saved. However it works in the mystery of his power and will, he does not force it. He gives everyone a chance.
3. Finally, we want everyone to be saved. We do not give up easily on the hard cases but, like God, work diligently to see them saved in every sense, spiritually and materially. We know the leopard can't change his spots, but God can. With mortals this is impossible, but with God all things are possible. We interact with the world in hope of salvation, not with the presumption of failure.
Friday, October 29, 2010
Thoughts on high school science education...
I took yesterday and today off to be with my family the last day of their Fall Break. We went to Chicago, a little more than 3 hrs away. This morning we were at the Museum of Science and Industry. I had the same feeling I've had for a while now.
We are a nation that makes fun of smart kids. The general populace not only feels comfortable questioning things overwhelmingly assumed by scientists. They villify them for it (e.g., the so called global warming conspiracy). We are increasingly a nation that doesn't want our government taking any of our money to invest in general scientific investigation. With our rhetoric against "earmarks" we are almost relegating the advance of science to things companies can make an immediate profit on or the government can protect or kill with (and you can imagine what this does for the arts that keep us human). In short, I worry about the long term prospects.
As for my idea... After what we have done at the new seminary to integrate Bible, theology, and church history with the practice of ministry, it is hard to look at the way we teach math and science in high school the same. First, there is just so much more to learn than thirty years ago when I started high school. I had a hilarious conversation recently with a college math professor who didn't like the fact they were teaching geometry and things so early. Her complaint was that a child's brain was not yet developed enough to get the abstractions accurately.
I laughed because her approach--don't teach it until they can get everything accurately--consigns math and science to almost no one. We have to start as early as possible, even if it involves imperfection (after all, Newtonian physics is imperfect). You can often learn something more quickly by learning it first a little wrongly and then perfecting your understanding later, like chiseling at a block of marble. You "learn it wrong to learn it right."
I wish I knew math and science well enough to integrate the teaching the way we have tried to integrate Bible, theology, and church history. Students from the earliest ages would work on various problems and learn the math and science to solve them. They would not learn some individual math or science item and then do an example about that one thing. They would learn it all in a bundle by constructing things, learn science by building things. They would create Tesla coils, launch projectiles, blow up things, and learn calculus, chemistry, and physics by doing it, in order to do it. It would be the "engineering project" that would dictate the interlocking items in math and science to learn.
To teach this way would require informed pedagogues mapping practical projects to a mega-list of math and science outcomes--individual bits to learn distributed among countless science projects. Then in college they could do it the traditional way, learning isolated and specialized disciplines in depth. But they would learn what science can do in middle and high school. They would do engineering type things in school and whet their appetite. No more abstract and seemingly irrelevant math and scientific theory. All of it would be integrated with the practice of science in high school. Then the depth stuff would come in college for those who go forward, which would be more than now because they would see what it can do.
By the way, getting college credit for AP is something you should only do if you don't plan on going on in that area. High school chemistry AP, for example, even if you get a 5 on the exam, is simply not adequate to go forward with a chemistry major. You need to start from the beginning again with university chemistry. High school chemistry won't carry you straight into analytical chemistry very well.
My thoughts...
We are a nation that makes fun of smart kids. The general populace not only feels comfortable questioning things overwhelmingly assumed by scientists. They villify them for it (e.g., the so called global warming conspiracy). We are increasingly a nation that doesn't want our government taking any of our money to invest in general scientific investigation. With our rhetoric against "earmarks" we are almost relegating the advance of science to things companies can make an immediate profit on or the government can protect or kill with (and you can imagine what this does for the arts that keep us human). In short, I worry about the long term prospects.
As for my idea... After what we have done at the new seminary to integrate Bible, theology, and church history with the practice of ministry, it is hard to look at the way we teach math and science in high school the same. First, there is just so much more to learn than thirty years ago when I started high school. I had a hilarious conversation recently with a college math professor who didn't like the fact they were teaching geometry and things so early. Her complaint was that a child's brain was not yet developed enough to get the abstractions accurately.
I laughed because her approach--don't teach it until they can get everything accurately--consigns math and science to almost no one. We have to start as early as possible, even if it involves imperfection (after all, Newtonian physics is imperfect). You can often learn something more quickly by learning it first a little wrongly and then perfecting your understanding later, like chiseling at a block of marble. You "learn it wrong to learn it right."
I wish I knew math and science well enough to integrate the teaching the way we have tried to integrate Bible, theology, and church history. Students from the earliest ages would work on various problems and learn the math and science to solve them. They would not learn some individual math or science item and then do an example about that one thing. They would learn it all in a bundle by constructing things, learn science by building things. They would create Tesla coils, launch projectiles, blow up things, and learn calculus, chemistry, and physics by doing it, in order to do it. It would be the "engineering project" that would dictate the interlocking items in math and science to learn.
To teach this way would require informed pedagogues mapping practical projects to a mega-list of math and science outcomes--individual bits to learn distributed among countless science projects. Then in college they could do it the traditional way, learning isolated and specialized disciplines in depth. But they would learn what science can do in middle and high school. They would do engineering type things in school and whet their appetite. No more abstract and seemingly irrelevant math and scientific theory. All of it would be integrated with the practice of science in high school. Then the depth stuff would come in college for those who go forward, which would be more than now because they would see what it can do.
By the way, getting college credit for AP is something you should only do if you don't plan on going on in that area. High school chemistry AP, for example, even if you get a 5 on the exam, is simply not adequate to go forward with a chemistry major. You need to start from the beginning again with university chemistry. High school chemistry won't carry you straight into analytical chemistry very well.
My thoughts...
My Paul book is out! (volume 1)
Paul: Messenger of Grace, is now available (also here if you want to go straight to the publisher). It covers:
Paul's early years, Paul's turn to Christ, 1 Thessalonians, 1 Corinthians, Galatians, Philippians, and 2 Corinthians. After giving my sense of the historical, I then reflect some on current issues in dialog with Paul's letters.
Wednesday, October 27, 2010
Women in the Pastorals 1 (9.3)
A modern, Western woman is likely to be taken aback when reading through 1 Timothy. After hearing 1 Timothy 2:11-12 for the first time, a teenage girl once remarked, "That's not really in there!" It reads in the New International Version, "A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a woman to teach or have authority over a man; she must be silent."
Here we come to a point of inner conflict. On the one hand, we are reading Scripture, which as Christians we understand to have authority over us. On the other hand, these verses seem to conflict with the gospel of Christ, so well captured in Galatians 3:28, "There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female." Some of 1 Timothy borderlines on the harsh toward women. For example, at one point it tells church leaders not to trust widows who say they will not remarry, because "their sensual desires overcome their dedication to Christ" (1 Tim. 5:11).
It is hard not to put a comment like this one in the category of the "situation specific" rather than the "timelessly applicable." What was going on in the context of 1 Timothy to provoke such strong rhetoric, which seems significantly different from Paul's tone and practice toward women in his earlier letters? To the modern reader, some of these comments sound as strange as Psalm 137:8-9 ("happy is he who... seizes your infants and dashes them against the rocks") or Galatians 5:12 ("I wish they would go the whole way and emasculate themselves").
Both in Paul's earlier letters and in the portrait of him in Acts, Paul seems to have a significantly different attitude toward women and widows. For example, 1 Timothy instructs church leaders not to support younger widows materially but to have their families take care of them until they get remarried (5:9, 11, 18). The system seems to have worked in this way. When a woman became a widow, the church would support her for the rest of her life if she committed never to remarry (5:9, 11).
In practice, however, younger widows apparently tended to go back on their vow and remarry, clearly a source of great irritation. In the meantime, those widows who did not were perceived to be "idlers," "gossips," and "busybodies" (5:13). The instruction to remarry seems to assume that if such widows would remarry, the duties of the household, husband, and family would instead preoccupy them with "bringing up children, showing hospitality, washing the feet of the saints, helping those in trouble and devoting herself to all kinds of good deeds" (5:10). So 1 Timothy instructs church leaders not to put a widow on the support list unless she is at least sixty years of age and has been a reputable wife and woman.
Again, such comments sound highly sexist to our Western ears. They are also quite different from what Paul has to say about widows in 1 Corinthians 7. There, he says that the ideal is for a widow not to remarry (7:40). Indeed, the instruction of the entire chapter assumes that the Lord is going to return very soon. "[T]he time is short. From now on those who have wives should live as if they had none... this world in its present form is passing away" (1 Cor. 7:29, 31).
Here is another major difference between Paul's earlier writings and the Pastorals. Writings like 1 Thessalonians and 1 Corinthians seem to operate under the assumption that Christ will return very soon indeed, probably even before Paul dies. By contrast, at least 1 and 2 Timothy look to some future time presumably after Paul's death: "in later times" (1 Tim. 4:1) and "in the last days" (2 Tim. 3:1). The shift from Christ's imminent return to his prolonged delay is a major shift between Paul's earlier writings and 1 Timothy.
So at the very least Paul's sense of widows in the church has changed or alternatively we are witnessing a church some time after Paul hunkering down for the long haul of history. Other instruction about women in the Pastorals has a similarly different tone than we find either in Paul's earlier letters or in the depiction of his ministry in Acts. For example, 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1 seem to assume that church overseers and deacons will be male (e.g., 1 Tim. 3:2, 8, 11; Tit. 1:6).
But Paul's earlier letters and Acts are full of women seemingly at all levels of participation in the ministry of the church. For example, we already saw in chapter 5 that Romans 16:1 refers to a woman named Phoebe as a deacon of the church of Cenchrea. We also saw in that chapter that Paul seems to consider a woman named Junia as an apostle--someone who had witnessed the risen Lord and called to proclaim the good news (Rom. 16:7). We do not explicitly find Paul referring to a woman as an overseer or an elder, but individuals like Priscilla (Rom. 16:3); Euodia, and Syntyche (Phil. 3:2) might easily have held this office in Paul's churches.
Again, the tone of 1 Timothy is surprising in this light. We concluded in chapter 5 that Romans 16 likely greeted individuals at Ephesus, the same location to which 1 Timothy most ostensibly relates. If Paul did not have a fourth missionary journey, the proximity of these two letters in time would make his sudden silence on women in ministry there jolting...
Here we come to a point of inner conflict. On the one hand, we are reading Scripture, which as Christians we understand to have authority over us. On the other hand, these verses seem to conflict with the gospel of Christ, so well captured in Galatians 3:28, "There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female." Some of 1 Timothy borderlines on the harsh toward women. For example, at one point it tells church leaders not to trust widows who say they will not remarry, because "their sensual desires overcome their dedication to Christ" (1 Tim. 5:11).
It is hard not to put a comment like this one in the category of the "situation specific" rather than the "timelessly applicable." What was going on in the context of 1 Timothy to provoke such strong rhetoric, which seems significantly different from Paul's tone and practice toward women in his earlier letters? To the modern reader, some of these comments sound as strange as Psalm 137:8-9 ("happy is he who... seizes your infants and dashes them against the rocks") or Galatians 5:12 ("I wish they would go the whole way and emasculate themselves").
Both in Paul's earlier letters and in the portrait of him in Acts, Paul seems to have a significantly different attitude toward women and widows. For example, 1 Timothy instructs church leaders not to support younger widows materially but to have their families take care of them until they get remarried (5:9, 11, 18). The system seems to have worked in this way. When a woman became a widow, the church would support her for the rest of her life if she committed never to remarry (5:9, 11).
In practice, however, younger widows apparently tended to go back on their vow and remarry, clearly a source of great irritation. In the meantime, those widows who did not were perceived to be "idlers," "gossips," and "busybodies" (5:13). The instruction to remarry seems to assume that if such widows would remarry, the duties of the household, husband, and family would instead preoccupy them with "bringing up children, showing hospitality, washing the feet of the saints, helping those in trouble and devoting herself to all kinds of good deeds" (5:10). So 1 Timothy instructs church leaders not to put a widow on the support list unless she is at least sixty years of age and has been a reputable wife and woman.
Again, such comments sound highly sexist to our Western ears. They are also quite different from what Paul has to say about widows in 1 Corinthians 7. There, he says that the ideal is for a widow not to remarry (7:40). Indeed, the instruction of the entire chapter assumes that the Lord is going to return very soon. "[T]he time is short. From now on those who have wives should live as if they had none... this world in its present form is passing away" (1 Cor. 7:29, 31).
Here is another major difference between Paul's earlier writings and the Pastorals. Writings like 1 Thessalonians and 1 Corinthians seem to operate under the assumption that Christ will return very soon indeed, probably even before Paul dies. By contrast, at least 1 and 2 Timothy look to some future time presumably after Paul's death: "in later times" (1 Tim. 4:1) and "in the last days" (2 Tim. 3:1). The shift from Christ's imminent return to his prolonged delay is a major shift between Paul's earlier writings and 1 Timothy.
So at the very least Paul's sense of widows in the church has changed or alternatively we are witnessing a church some time after Paul hunkering down for the long haul of history. Other instruction about women in the Pastorals has a similarly different tone than we find either in Paul's earlier letters or in the depiction of his ministry in Acts. For example, 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1 seem to assume that church overseers and deacons will be male (e.g., 1 Tim. 3:2, 8, 11; Tit. 1:6).
But Paul's earlier letters and Acts are full of women seemingly at all levels of participation in the ministry of the church. For example, we already saw in chapter 5 that Romans 16:1 refers to a woman named Phoebe as a deacon of the church of Cenchrea. We also saw in that chapter that Paul seems to consider a woman named Junia as an apostle--someone who had witnessed the risen Lord and called to proclaim the good news (Rom. 16:7). We do not explicitly find Paul referring to a woman as an overseer or an elder, but individuals like Priscilla (Rom. 16:3); Euodia, and Syntyche (Phil. 3:2) might easily have held this office in Paul's churches.
Again, the tone of 1 Timothy is surprising in this light. We concluded in chapter 5 that Romans 16 likely greeted individuals at Ephesus, the same location to which 1 Timothy most ostensibly relates. If Paul did not have a fourth missionary journey, the proximity of these two letters in time would make his sudden silence on women in ministry there jolting...
Common English Bible
I received a free copy of the New Testament of the CEB yesterday, the Common English Bible. You can see more about the project at http://www.commonenglishbible.com/. It's very readable, so somewhat dynamic. I haven't looked at it in too much detail yet, but I did enjoy Romans 3:21-26, the only translation as yet I know to have the courage to translate this way:
"But now God’s righteousness has been revealed apart from the Law, which is confirmed by the Law and the prophets. 22 God’s righteousness comes through the faithfulness of Jesus Christ for all who have faith in him. There’s no distinction. 23 All have sinned and fall short of God’s glory, 24 but all are treated as righteous freely by his grace because of a ransom that was paid by Christ Jesus. 25 Through his faithfulness, God displayed Jesus as the place of sacrifice where mercy is found by means of his blood. He did this to demonstrate his righteousness in passing over sins that happened before, 26 during the time of God’s patient tolerance. He also did this to demonstrate that he is righteous in the present time, and to treat the one who has faith in Jesus as righteous."
I don't like 3:23 but I think this has to be the best English translation of the passage ever... other than, of course, mine ;-)
"But now God’s righteousness has been revealed apart from the Law, which is confirmed by the Law and the prophets. 22 God’s righteousness comes through the faithfulness of Jesus Christ for all who have faith in him. There’s no distinction. 23 All have sinned and fall short of God’s glory, 24 but all are treated as righteous freely by his grace because of a ransom that was paid by Christ Jesus. 25 Through his faithfulness, God displayed Jesus as the place of sacrifice where mercy is found by means of his blood. He did this to demonstrate his righteousness in passing over sins that happened before, 26 during the time of God’s patient tolerance. He also did this to demonstrate that he is righteous in the present time, and to treat the one who has faith in Jesus as righteous."
I don't like 3:23 but I think this has to be the best English translation of the passage ever... other than, of course, mine ;-)
Tuesday, October 26, 2010
Ignatius, the Sabbath, and the Lord's Day
I needed to create a sample of "church historical precedents" for seminary classes. This isn't as polished as I'd like, but time has run out...
___________
Introduction
Ignatius of Antioch was bishop of the city of Antioch mentioned in Acts 13:1. It was located in the uppermost part of Palestine in Syria, where modern day Turkey suddenly juts out to the west. Around the year AD107 (González, 41), Ignatius was tried and condemned to death by Roman authorities in Antioch. He left behind seven letters to various churches and individuals, written on the course of his journey from Antioch to Rome, where he was presumably martyred.
In his letter to the Romans, he urges the church there not to try to rescue him from death (Ign. Rom. 4.1), perhaps by bribery or some other means. There he also tells us that he is being escorted by “wild beasts” or “leopards” (5.1; cf. 1 Cor. 15:32). In transit, he also writes the churches at Ephesus, Magnesia, Trallia, Philadelphia, Smyrna, and to Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna.
Judaizing Gentile Believers
The evidence of the New Testament is very clear that a significant number of believers in the early church insisted a male Gentile must be circumcised and convert to Judaism in order to be saved and fully become a Christ-follower (cf. Brown and Meier, 2004, p. 2-3). For example, while Paul may have considered these “Judaizing” individuals in Galatia to be “false brothers” (Gal. 2:4), they clearly did not view themselves this way (cf. Acts 15:1-5). His opponents were believers, perhaps even missionaries like him (cf. Dunn, 1993, pp. 9-11).
It would be inappropriate to think of such individuals only in terms of Jewish believers in Christ. Even Galatians never specifies whether Paul’s opponents are Jewish or Gentile, although it perhaps makes most sense to think of them as natural born Jews (cf. Gal. 6:13). The writings of Ignatius probably imply that some Gentiles advocated following the Jewish particulars of the Law even into the second century.
In Philadelphians 6.1, Ignatius says, “But if anyone interpret Judaism to you do not listen to him; for it is better to hear Christianity from the circumcised than Judaism from the uncircumcised.” On the one hand, the most natural way of taking this comment is that those who are pushing certain “Jewish” practices are uncircumcised (so also Robinson, 2009, 122). We are then left to debate exactly what it might mean to “interpret Judaism.” We can at least make an argument that Ignatius’ comments relate as much to the situation in his home city of Antioch as it does to something he might know about the city of Philadelphia.
His letter to the Magnesians has a similar comment. “Be not led astray by strange doctrines or by old fables which are profitless. For if we are living until now according to Judaism, we confess that we have not received grace” (Magn. 8.1). In Magnesians 10.3, Ignatius even goes so far as to say that “it is monstrous to talk of Jesus Christ and to practice Judaism.” Clearly there must have been Christians in Ignatius’ day who strongly advocated the importance of keeping elements of Jewish practice while probably falling just short of advocating circumcision.
The Lord’s Day not the Sabbath
The most concrete reference Ignatius makes to such a Jewish practice is in Magnesians 9.1: “If then they who walked in ancient customs came to a new hope, no longer living for the Sabbath, but for the Lord’s Day, on which also our life sprang up through him and his death.” Groups like the Seventh Day Adventists who believe Christians should still observe the Sabbath on Saturday tend to reinterpret this passage (e.g., Bacciochi, 1977, p. 213-23; Thiel, 2010). For example, Bob Thiel suggests that kyriakē refers to the Lord’s “way” rather than to the Lord’s day.
Such attempts however are clearly motivated by prior theological commitments rather than from the most natural reading of the text (e.g., Schoedel, 1985, pp. 123 n.3). On the one hand, it is true that a verb sabbatizo is used rather than the noun for Sabbath (e.g., Thiel, 2010). However, the cumulative case that it refers to observance of the Jewish Sabbath from sundown Friday to sundown Saturday is strong.
First, we have the background context of Philadelphians 6 and the immediate literary context of Magnesians 8 pointing us toward interpreting sabbatizo in relation to a specifically Jewish practice. Second, it is fairly clear from Revelation 1:10 that the kyriakē is a day, not a way. John of Revelation is in the Spirit on a particular day. It thus makes sense that to sabbatizo is to do something different from living according to the kyriakē, a different day. Finally, the allusion to the resurrection, “on which also our life sprang up through him and his death” (9.1), confirms a reference to Sunday, since it is clear in all the gospels that Jesus rose on the first day of the week (e.g., Matt. 28:1).
Conclusion
We conclude that tension continued to exist over whether Christians should observe the Jewish Sabbath or not into the second century AD. Ignatius, the bishop of Antioch, not only opposes observance of the Jewish Sabbath, but his language is very pejorative toward such individuals, who apparently were Gentile rather than Jewish believers in his context. His language treats them as marginal within the church. Further, Ignatius does not reinterpret the Sabbath as Sunday. He dispenses with it entirely as a Jewish practice. In this regard, Ignatius seems to be in strong continuity with both Romans 14:5 and Colossians 2:16.
Works Cited and Bibliography
Bacciocchi, Samuele. (1977). From Sabbath to Sunday: A Historical Investigation of the Rise of Sunday Observance in Early Christianity. Rome: Pontifical Gregorian University.
Brown, Raymond and Meier, John. (2004). Antioch and Rome: Cradles of New Testament Christianity. 2nd ed. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist.
Carson, D. A., ed. (1982). From Sabbath to Lord’s Day: A Biblical, Historical and Theological Investigation. Grand Rapids: Zondervan.
Dunn, James D. G. (1993). The Epistle to the Galatians. London: A & C Black.
González, Justo. (2009). The Story of Christianity: The Early Church to the Present Day. Peabody: MA: Prince.
Robinson, Thomas A. (2009). Ignatius of Antioch and the Parting of the Ways: Early Jewish-Christian Relations. Peabody, MA: Hendrickson.
Schoedel, William R. (1985). Ignatius of Antioch. Philadelphia: Fortress.
Thiel, Bob. (retrieved October 26, 2010). “The Didache, Ignatius, and the Sabbath,” http://www.cogwriter.com/ignatius.htm.
___________
Introduction
Ignatius of Antioch was bishop of the city of Antioch mentioned in Acts 13:1. It was located in the uppermost part of Palestine in Syria, where modern day Turkey suddenly juts out to the west. Around the year AD107 (González, 41), Ignatius was tried and condemned to death by Roman authorities in Antioch. He left behind seven letters to various churches and individuals, written on the course of his journey from Antioch to Rome, where he was presumably martyred.
In his letter to the Romans, he urges the church there not to try to rescue him from death (Ign. Rom. 4.1), perhaps by bribery or some other means. There he also tells us that he is being escorted by “wild beasts” or “leopards” (5.1; cf. 1 Cor. 15:32). In transit, he also writes the churches at Ephesus, Magnesia, Trallia, Philadelphia, Smyrna, and to Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna.
Judaizing Gentile Believers
The evidence of the New Testament is very clear that a significant number of believers in the early church insisted a male Gentile must be circumcised and convert to Judaism in order to be saved and fully become a Christ-follower (cf. Brown and Meier, 2004, p. 2-3). For example, while Paul may have considered these “Judaizing” individuals in Galatia to be “false brothers” (Gal. 2:4), they clearly did not view themselves this way (cf. Acts 15:1-5). His opponents were believers, perhaps even missionaries like him (cf. Dunn, 1993, pp. 9-11).
It would be inappropriate to think of such individuals only in terms of Jewish believers in Christ. Even Galatians never specifies whether Paul’s opponents are Jewish or Gentile, although it perhaps makes most sense to think of them as natural born Jews (cf. Gal. 6:13). The writings of Ignatius probably imply that some Gentiles advocated following the Jewish particulars of the Law even into the second century.
In Philadelphians 6.1, Ignatius says, “But if anyone interpret Judaism to you do not listen to him; for it is better to hear Christianity from the circumcised than Judaism from the uncircumcised.” On the one hand, the most natural way of taking this comment is that those who are pushing certain “Jewish” practices are uncircumcised (so also Robinson, 2009, 122). We are then left to debate exactly what it might mean to “interpret Judaism.” We can at least make an argument that Ignatius’ comments relate as much to the situation in his home city of Antioch as it does to something he might know about the city of Philadelphia.
His letter to the Magnesians has a similar comment. “Be not led astray by strange doctrines or by old fables which are profitless. For if we are living until now according to Judaism, we confess that we have not received grace” (Magn. 8.1). In Magnesians 10.3, Ignatius even goes so far as to say that “it is monstrous to talk of Jesus Christ and to practice Judaism.” Clearly there must have been Christians in Ignatius’ day who strongly advocated the importance of keeping elements of Jewish practice while probably falling just short of advocating circumcision.
The Lord’s Day not the Sabbath
The most concrete reference Ignatius makes to such a Jewish practice is in Magnesians 9.1: “If then they who walked in ancient customs came to a new hope, no longer living for the Sabbath, but for the Lord’s Day, on which also our life sprang up through him and his death.” Groups like the Seventh Day Adventists who believe Christians should still observe the Sabbath on Saturday tend to reinterpret this passage (e.g., Bacciochi, 1977, p. 213-23; Thiel, 2010). For example, Bob Thiel suggests that kyriakē refers to the Lord’s “way” rather than to the Lord’s day.
Such attempts however are clearly motivated by prior theological commitments rather than from the most natural reading of the text (e.g., Schoedel, 1985, pp. 123 n.3). On the one hand, it is true that a verb sabbatizo is used rather than the noun for Sabbath (e.g., Thiel, 2010). However, the cumulative case that it refers to observance of the Jewish Sabbath from sundown Friday to sundown Saturday is strong.
First, we have the background context of Philadelphians 6 and the immediate literary context of Magnesians 8 pointing us toward interpreting sabbatizo in relation to a specifically Jewish practice. Second, it is fairly clear from Revelation 1:10 that the kyriakē is a day, not a way. John of Revelation is in the Spirit on a particular day. It thus makes sense that to sabbatizo is to do something different from living according to the kyriakē, a different day. Finally, the allusion to the resurrection, “on which also our life sprang up through him and his death” (9.1), confirms a reference to Sunday, since it is clear in all the gospels that Jesus rose on the first day of the week (e.g., Matt. 28:1).
Conclusion
We conclude that tension continued to exist over whether Christians should observe the Jewish Sabbath or not into the second century AD. Ignatius, the bishop of Antioch, not only opposes observance of the Jewish Sabbath, but his language is very pejorative toward such individuals, who apparently were Gentile rather than Jewish believers in his context. His language treats them as marginal within the church. Further, Ignatius does not reinterpret the Sabbath as Sunday. He dispenses with it entirely as a Jewish practice. In this regard, Ignatius seems to be in strong continuity with both Romans 14:5 and Colossians 2:16.
Works Cited and Bibliography
Bacciocchi, Samuele. (1977). From Sabbath to Sunday: A Historical Investigation of the Rise of Sunday Observance in Early Christianity. Rome: Pontifical Gregorian University.
Brown, Raymond and Meier, John. (2004). Antioch and Rome: Cradles of New Testament Christianity. 2nd ed. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist.
Carson, D. A., ed. (1982). From Sabbath to Lord’s Day: A Biblical, Historical and Theological Investigation. Grand Rapids: Zondervan.
Dunn, James D. G. (1993). The Epistle to the Galatians. London: A & C Black.
González, Justo. (2009). The Story of Christianity: The Early Church to the Present Day. Peabody: MA: Prince.
Robinson, Thomas A. (2009). Ignatius of Antioch and the Parting of the Ways: Early Jewish-Christian Relations. Peabody, MA: Hendrickson.
Schoedel, William R. (1985). Ignatius of Antioch. Philadelphia: Fortress.
Thiel, Bob. (retrieved October 26, 2010). “The Didache, Ignatius, and the Sabbath,” http://www.cogwriter.com/ignatius.htm.
Monday, October 25, 2010
How to be Saved (4.3)
The race is on to finish Paul 2...
______________
Enveloped in Paul’s thoughts about God’s plan for the Gentiles are some familiar verses. We have heard them in terms of “getting saved,” about “becoming a Christian,” about “getting to heaven.” For example, Romans 10:13 says "Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved," quoting Joel 2:32. Romans 10:9 features in the “Roman road,” a series of verses from Romans meant to lead a person through the logic of becoming a Christian. On the Roman road, Romans 3:23 first tells us that “all have sinned,” which of course includes me. Then Romans 6:23 tells me that the “wages” for my sin is death. But Romans 5:8 gives me hope—even though I was a sinner, Christ died for me. Finally, we come to our verse from this passage, Romans 10:9: “if you confess with your mouth, ‘Jesus is Lord,’ and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved.”
Hopefully the last few chapters have made it clear that, while this way of using these verses is not completely off, it approaches these verses a little differently than Paul did. For Paul, all these statements had to do with the question of whether Gentiles, non-Jews, could escape God’s coming judgment. This is what being saved and salvation means for Paul. It refers to escaping God’s wrathful judgment on the day when Christ returns to the earth and everyone gives him an account for the deeds they have done on earth—including believers for the things they have done after God forgives their sins (cf. 2 Cor. 5:10). In that sense, no one is literally saved yet because salvation is something that is yet to come, on the Day of Judgment. When we speak of “getting saved,” we are really speaking of our assurance of something that has not yet happened.
So in Paul’s mind, the “all” in “all have sinned” meant "both Jew and Gentile" rather than just Gentiles—all, both, have sinned. And Paul’s arguments about the wages of sin and Christ dying for the ungodly were situated in his mind in a story in which the Jewish Law set the standard for sin and Israel would eventually recognize that Jesus was its messiah. Later Christianity has universalized Paul’s thinking in ways that are not wrong, but are slightly out of context. The Law becomes the universal moral law rather than the Jewish Law. The “all” in “all have sinned” shifts to the individual trying to be justified and ultimately saved, rather than the Gentiles as well as the Jews.
So Romans 10:9 is also situated in a passage where Paul is asking why it is that so many Gentiles are headed for salvation while most Jews were not. Why? Paul says it is because they insisted on doing it their way rather than God’s way. God's way was to make the world right with him through trust in Jesus, but the Jews by and large wanted to be right with God through keeping the Jewish Law (9:30-33). They stumbled over God's plan for "righteousness," in this case a right standing before God, through Jesus (9:33). They tried to establish a right standing before God on their own, rather than what God had in mind (10:3). [1]
Christ is thus the goal of the Law, that to which the Jewish Law points (10:4). Some traditions take the phrase "Christ is the end of the law" to mean that Christ brings an end to the law. But it is far more likely that Paul is saying Christ is the goal, the telos of the Law. As Paul says in Galatians 3:24, the Law was a guardian, a tutor for the Jews to be ready for Christ (NASB). But now that Christ has come, born under the Law to redeem Jews under the Law (4:4-5), faith has come and neither Jews nor Gentiles need the tutor any more (3:25). We have "grown up" in the maturity of salvation history now to have the status of sons and daughters who no longer need the Law as our guardian...
[1] The parallelism of 10:3 pushes us to take the phrase, "the righteousness of God" in 10:3 in reference to human righteousness more than God's righteousness as in 1:17. Of course Paul may intend a double entendre, as he may in Romans 3:21. Some like N. T. Wright insist that Paul always must mean God's righteousness when he uses the phrase (What Saint Paul Really Said ***), but this approach seems excessively rigid. Wright and others are correct that the background of the phrase pushes us toward God's righteousness as the default. But ultimately the immediate literary context must cast the deciding vote.
______________
Enveloped in Paul’s thoughts about God’s plan for the Gentiles are some familiar verses. We have heard them in terms of “getting saved,” about “becoming a Christian,” about “getting to heaven.” For example, Romans 10:13 says "Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved," quoting Joel 2:32. Romans 10:9 features in the “Roman road,” a series of verses from Romans meant to lead a person through the logic of becoming a Christian. On the Roman road, Romans 3:23 first tells us that “all have sinned,” which of course includes me. Then Romans 6:23 tells me that the “wages” for my sin is death. But Romans 5:8 gives me hope—even though I was a sinner, Christ died for me. Finally, we come to our verse from this passage, Romans 10:9: “if you confess with your mouth, ‘Jesus is Lord,’ and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved.”
Hopefully the last few chapters have made it clear that, while this way of using these verses is not completely off, it approaches these verses a little differently than Paul did. For Paul, all these statements had to do with the question of whether Gentiles, non-Jews, could escape God’s coming judgment. This is what being saved and salvation means for Paul. It refers to escaping God’s wrathful judgment on the day when Christ returns to the earth and everyone gives him an account for the deeds they have done on earth—including believers for the things they have done after God forgives their sins (cf. 2 Cor. 5:10). In that sense, no one is literally saved yet because salvation is something that is yet to come, on the Day of Judgment. When we speak of “getting saved,” we are really speaking of our assurance of something that has not yet happened.
So in Paul’s mind, the “all” in “all have sinned” meant "both Jew and Gentile" rather than just Gentiles—all, both, have sinned. And Paul’s arguments about the wages of sin and Christ dying for the ungodly were situated in his mind in a story in which the Jewish Law set the standard for sin and Israel would eventually recognize that Jesus was its messiah. Later Christianity has universalized Paul’s thinking in ways that are not wrong, but are slightly out of context. The Law becomes the universal moral law rather than the Jewish Law. The “all” in “all have sinned” shifts to the individual trying to be justified and ultimately saved, rather than the Gentiles as well as the Jews.
So Romans 10:9 is also situated in a passage where Paul is asking why it is that so many Gentiles are headed for salvation while most Jews were not. Why? Paul says it is because they insisted on doing it their way rather than God’s way. God's way was to make the world right with him through trust in Jesus, but the Jews by and large wanted to be right with God through keeping the Jewish Law (9:30-33). They stumbled over God's plan for "righteousness," in this case a right standing before God, through Jesus (9:33). They tried to establish a right standing before God on their own, rather than what God had in mind (10:3). [1]
Christ is thus the goal of the Law, that to which the Jewish Law points (10:4). Some traditions take the phrase "Christ is the end of the law" to mean that Christ brings an end to the law. But it is far more likely that Paul is saying Christ is the goal, the telos of the Law. As Paul says in Galatians 3:24, the Law was a guardian, a tutor for the Jews to be ready for Christ (NASB). But now that Christ has come, born under the Law to redeem Jews under the Law (4:4-5), faith has come and neither Jews nor Gentiles need the tutor any more (3:25). We have "grown up" in the maturity of salvation history now to have the status of sons and daughters who no longer need the Law as our guardian...
[1] The parallelism of 10:3 pushes us to take the phrase, "the righteousness of God" in 10:3 in reference to human righteousness more than God's righteousness as in 1:17. Of course Paul may intend a double entendre, as he may in Romans 3:21. Some like N. T. Wright insist that Paul always must mean God's righteousness when he uses the phrase (What Saint Paul Really Said ***), but this approach seems excessively rigid. Wright and others are correct that the background of the phrase pushes us toward God's righteousness as the default. But ultimately the immediate literary context must cast the deciding vote.
Bookflix?
I have seen the future and it is this article in Inside Higher Ed, "An Amazon Book Rental Plan." At least I hope it's the future. Mind you, Amazon doesn't do this yet. It just could be really nice.
The idea is something like Netflix.
So here's what would be my perfect world:
The idea is something like Netflix.
- I pay a monthly fee to have access to electronic books on Amazon or Google.
- I access those eBooks like I would access books in a library. I check one or two out at a time. Return them. Check out the next one.
So here's what would be my perfect world:
- Google/Amazon have all books in electronic format.
- You have a subscription, to where you pay a very small amount for every page you access.
- An even smaller amount is paid to each publisher/author each time a page of their book is accessed.
- Or you can purchase the book electronically because you will be accessing that book regularly.
Sunday, October 24, 2010
Short Catechism: "Mercy trumps justice"
It is important to me that my children know some of the key things I believe. Needless to say, they do not read my blog and their attention span for deep conversation is not very long. When my youngest two hit middle school, a certain window to their mind will be hard to open if it is not already open. So this last couple of years we've been oiling the hinges on that window.
One very key thing in my mind is the fact that even within Christianity, my children will be exposed to many forms of Christianity when I'm not looking. They might join a high school Bible study where the leader is Baptist beige or have Sunday School teachers or youth leaders who are fairly untrained Wesleyans. Even a pastor like Steve Deneff often says things that are different from what I think. Ultimately, they have to choose, but I would at least like them to know what I think. I would rather them intentionally and thoughtfully choose other options than merely to be driven and tossed by the winds, even the Christian winds of their environment.
Today I began with James 2:13: "Mercy trumps justice." Justice is when you receive a punishment equal to your wrongdoing. "An eye for an eye; a tooth for a tooth." If you intentionally break someone's arm, justice would be for them to break your arm back in exactly the same way.
My kind of Methodist and Wesleyan believes that God's character as love is more primary for him than God's character as just. We do not believe that God had to crucify Jesus because of some mindless rule about having to punish wrongdoing. God wants to forgive. That does not mean he does not punish. But God's punishment is meant to help us get on the right track, not to satisfy some underlying need for therapy that God has.
The cross is an astounding act of God's love, not only because Jesus took the punishment we deserved but because God could have forgiven us by divine fiat. But it was much more powerful for him to become us and suffer with us. It better satisfied the innate order of things and thus was more powerful to heal than a mere declaration.
One very key thing in my mind is the fact that even within Christianity, my children will be exposed to many forms of Christianity when I'm not looking. They might join a high school Bible study where the leader is Baptist beige or have Sunday School teachers or youth leaders who are fairly untrained Wesleyans. Even a pastor like Steve Deneff often says things that are different from what I think. Ultimately, they have to choose, but I would at least like them to know what I think. I would rather them intentionally and thoughtfully choose other options than merely to be driven and tossed by the winds, even the Christian winds of their environment.
Today I began with James 2:13: "Mercy trumps justice." Justice is when you receive a punishment equal to your wrongdoing. "An eye for an eye; a tooth for a tooth." If you intentionally break someone's arm, justice would be for them to break your arm back in exactly the same way.
My kind of Methodist and Wesleyan believes that God's character as love is more primary for him than God's character as just. We do not believe that God had to crucify Jesus because of some mindless rule about having to punish wrongdoing. God wants to forgive. That does not mean he does not punish. But God's punishment is meant to help us get on the right track, not to satisfy some underlying need for therapy that God has.
The cross is an astounding act of God's love, not only because Jesus took the punishment we deserved but because God could have forgiven us by divine fiat. But it was much more powerful for him to become us and suffer with us. It better satisfied the innate order of things and thus was more powerful to heal than a mere declaration.
Saturday, October 23, 2010
Strong and Weak (5.3)
Back-filling.
P.S. Saw Juan Williams on Fox this morning. Regardless of NPRs appropriateness, he's clearly better off from the incident. ;-)
________
Although Paul has never been to Rome, he arguably knows a little about the church there. [1] In particular, Roman believers seem to have argued over things like meat from pagan temples just like the Corinthians did. In Romans 14-15, Paul labels the two sides in such issues as the "strong" and the "weak." The strong are those whose faith is strong enough to eat meat that has been sacrificed to a pagan god or who can give every day to the Lord without worry (14:1-2). The weak are those who are troubled over the potential uncleaness of their meat or who feel constrained to observe the Jewish Sabbath (14:5).
To be sure, we should take into account the strong possibility that there is an element of rhetoric here. Paul makes the "strong" feel good by putting them in a position of knowledge and strength. But his goal is to lead them to respect and honor those who are more conservative. In a sense, he massages the ego of the person who feels free to do certain things, while moving them in the direction of those who do not.
His argument is very similar to what he said about "disputable matters" at Corinth, although it is more general here in Romans. Paul gives no evidence in this chapter that the debate is a Jew-Gentile one at Rome. Indeed, we have argued throughout the book thus far that Paul's audience in Romans was predominantly Gentile. [2] We will grow in our thinking about the early church if we recognize the strong likelihood that there were both Jews who were "ultra-liberal" on these issues and Gentiles who were "ultra-conservative" on them.
Although Paul does not bring out the issue explicitly, the eating issue is almost certainly the same question he faced at Corinth--whether a believer should eat meat that has been sacrificed to an idol. In fact, he is writing Romans from the city of Corinth, where their saga was no doubt fresh in his mind. So when he mentions vegetarians (14:2), he is not talking about people who did not believe in killing animals and eating them. He is talking about people who are so concerned about potentially eating meat that had been sacrificed to a god that they preferred not to eat meat at all.
Several items of background are helpful here. [3] First, we should remember that meat was somewhat of a luxury. Most ancient people only had meat during city festivals, so not eating meat was nothing like the sacrifice it is today. And most of the meat available in a city probably came from nearby temples. Ancient sacrifices did not consume the whole animal. [4] Even after priests and the family of the sacrificer had eaten to their fill, a good deal of meat would be left over. Since it could not be refrigerated for later, it might easily make its way to the market place...
[1] Especially if Romans 16 gives greetings to individuals at Rome. However, see the final section of this chapter where we think it more likely that chapter was directed to the churches at Ephesus.
[2] You'll have to buy the book to hear the argument ;-)
[3] See chapter 7, "Disagreement and Disorder at Corinth, in the first Paul volume in this series, Paul: Messenger of Grace (Indianapolis: Wesleyan Publishing, 2010).
[4] The Jewish "whole burnt offering" was unique to Israel.
P.S. Saw Juan Williams on Fox this morning. Regardless of NPRs appropriateness, he's clearly better off from the incident. ;-)
________
Although Paul has never been to Rome, he arguably knows a little about the church there. [1] In particular, Roman believers seem to have argued over things like meat from pagan temples just like the Corinthians did. In Romans 14-15, Paul labels the two sides in such issues as the "strong" and the "weak." The strong are those whose faith is strong enough to eat meat that has been sacrificed to a pagan god or who can give every day to the Lord without worry (14:1-2). The weak are those who are troubled over the potential uncleaness of their meat or who feel constrained to observe the Jewish Sabbath (14:5).
To be sure, we should take into account the strong possibility that there is an element of rhetoric here. Paul makes the "strong" feel good by putting them in a position of knowledge and strength. But his goal is to lead them to respect and honor those who are more conservative. In a sense, he massages the ego of the person who feels free to do certain things, while moving them in the direction of those who do not.
His argument is very similar to what he said about "disputable matters" at Corinth, although it is more general here in Romans. Paul gives no evidence in this chapter that the debate is a Jew-Gentile one at Rome. Indeed, we have argued throughout the book thus far that Paul's audience in Romans was predominantly Gentile. [2] We will grow in our thinking about the early church if we recognize the strong likelihood that there were both Jews who were "ultra-liberal" on these issues and Gentiles who were "ultra-conservative" on them.
Although Paul does not bring out the issue explicitly, the eating issue is almost certainly the same question he faced at Corinth--whether a believer should eat meat that has been sacrificed to an idol. In fact, he is writing Romans from the city of Corinth, where their saga was no doubt fresh in his mind. So when he mentions vegetarians (14:2), he is not talking about people who did not believe in killing animals and eating them. He is talking about people who are so concerned about potentially eating meat that had been sacrificed to a god that they preferred not to eat meat at all.
Several items of background are helpful here. [3] First, we should remember that meat was somewhat of a luxury. Most ancient people only had meat during city festivals, so not eating meat was nothing like the sacrifice it is today. And most of the meat available in a city probably came from nearby temples. Ancient sacrifices did not consume the whole animal. [4] Even after priests and the family of the sacrificer had eaten to their fill, a good deal of meat would be left over. Since it could not be refrigerated for later, it might easily make its way to the market place...
[1] Especially if Romans 16 gives greetings to individuals at Rome. However, see the final section of this chapter where we think it more likely that chapter was directed to the churches at Ephesus.
[2] You'll have to buy the book to hear the argument ;-)
[3] See chapter 7, "Disagreement and Disorder at Corinth, in the first Paul volume in this series, Paul: Messenger of Grace (Indianapolis: Wesleyan Publishing, 2010).
[4] The Jewish "whole burnt offering" was unique to Israel.
Friday, October 22, 2010
The NPR Debacle
All kinds of insights and lessons to get from the firing of Juan Williams from NPR. First, I listen to NPR whenever I am in the car and one of their news programs is on. I highly value its "old school" style that insists its moderates try to maintain a neutral position. I highly affirm its insistence that its reporters not participate in pundit shows like O'Reilly's Fox program. In that sense, I agree that it would be difficult for him to be on the "opinion circuit" and work for NPR.
The first observation I have is thus that this firing was a long time coming. NPR had warned him and moved him around more than once already for dabbling in the much more lucrative and popular opinion circuit. In these sort of situations, institutions often are looking for an excuse to let someone go. Given the legal complications and potential lawsuits, the presenting reason for firing often is not the real reason. It's a fine line institutions walk.
Was this the right moment? A little weak, I think. NPR and other shows disgrace their own code by only playing Williams' initial comments without putting them in their full context. The CEO of NPR made another classic mistake by mentioning a "psychiatrist" in her explanation. It is so hard to hold your tongue as an administrator of this sort when doing this sort of thing. So she did exactly the same thing she is criticizing him for.
In a postmodern world, we know no one is objective. It is a blogger's world where I can blog my opinions without anyone fact checking me before I post. But we must have venues where moderators try to maintain objectivity. I don't know what I would do without some news outlets where I can't tell what position the moderator holds. I agree with the rule that says an NPR reporter can't appear on pundit TV shows. It is not for this comment, but for going on O'Reilly in the first place that Williams should be let go.
Meanwhile the outcry from Republicans is a sham. I am disappointed with the CEO of NPR, but NPR's presentation is one of the most objective I know. Even earlier this week I was thanking the Lord for having a source of news in the middle, whose position on the issues they cover is not immediately obvious to me. I was thinking it was because it is supported by donations from people like me rather than from advertisements and money moguls.
When you do not know the position of the reporter or moderator--that is a truth seeking operation. But when you know where the moderator stands and it is your position, you are most likely to be feeding your own bias and missing part of the bigger picture. We learn the truth by hearing the sides we disagree with on their own terms.
The first observation I have is thus that this firing was a long time coming. NPR had warned him and moved him around more than once already for dabbling in the much more lucrative and popular opinion circuit. In these sort of situations, institutions often are looking for an excuse to let someone go. Given the legal complications and potential lawsuits, the presenting reason for firing often is not the real reason. It's a fine line institutions walk.
Was this the right moment? A little weak, I think. NPR and other shows disgrace their own code by only playing Williams' initial comments without putting them in their full context. The CEO of NPR made another classic mistake by mentioning a "psychiatrist" in her explanation. It is so hard to hold your tongue as an administrator of this sort when doing this sort of thing. So she did exactly the same thing she is criticizing him for.
In a postmodern world, we know no one is objective. It is a blogger's world where I can blog my opinions without anyone fact checking me before I post. But we must have venues where moderators try to maintain objectivity. I don't know what I would do without some news outlets where I can't tell what position the moderator holds. I agree with the rule that says an NPR reporter can't appear on pundit TV shows. It is not for this comment, but for going on O'Reilly in the first place that Williams should be let go.
Meanwhile the outcry from Republicans is a sham. I am disappointed with the CEO of NPR, but NPR's presentation is one of the most objective I know. Even earlier this week I was thanking the Lord for having a source of news in the middle, whose position on the issues they cover is not immediately obvious to me. I was thinking it was because it is supported by donations from people like me rather than from advertisements and money moguls.
When you do not know the position of the reporter or moderator--that is a truth seeking operation. But when you know where the moderator stands and it is your position, you are most likely to be feeding your own bias and missing part of the bigger picture. We learn the truth by hearing the sides we disagree with on their own terms.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
