previous post
_________________
6. Narrative criticism, as practiced by Bauer, treated biblical narratives as self-contained stories. [1] I would use this as a tool in my own doctoral dissertation. A story has the basic elements of events, characters, and settings. Together, these constitute plot. Plot is told from a certain point of view by a narrator. There is narrative time and there is story time.
I sense that narrative criticism was an attractive method to pursue for biblical PhD students coming out of the Free Methodist and Wesleyan world because it was an acceptable way to bracket questions of historicity. You didn't address questions of whether Matthew was historical. You took the story at face value and analyzed it.
The situation reminds me a little of what I heard about Bud Bence at Candler in the 70s, I believe. He was told that he could not study Wesley as part of a theology PhD, because obviously Wesley was wrong. Bence could only study Wesley as a church history PhD.
So it was that biblical studies students could study biblical narratives and take them at face value because they were using a literary rather than a historical approach.
7. Narrative criticism came on the tails of a series of waves in biblical studies, waves that I learned somewhat about in Dr. Wang's New Testament History and Criticism class. As it often is, history is initially difficult for me because there are so many historical particulars and they almost never reduce to nice boxes. As an "NJ," I naturally do best with details that can be put into neat boxes. If I have the history somewhat in mind it is because I have revisited it.
The earliest ventures in modern biblical scholarship largely had to do with the text of the New Testament. This field is called textual criticism. I took a textual criticism course with Bob Lyon my second semester at Asbury. More to come.
In the late 1700s and 1800s, the Enlightenment began to ask its questions of the Bible. In the 1770s, the musings of a man named Reimarus were posthumously published in which he noted that Jesus seemed to say he would come back in a generation but didn't. In 1835, at the age of 33, David Strauss did not wait until he was dead to publish The Life of Jesus. He would never find thereafter a stable teaching position.
His book marks a turning point in the study of Jesus, not because it was particularly good. During my England days I read N. T. Wright's added chapter to Stephen Neill's The Interpretation of the New Testament in which he flogs Strauss for his kindergartenish sense of what a myth is.
However, Strauss raised the question that currently haunts the Lord-Liar-Lunatic argument of Lewis and McDowell. Up to Strauss, skeptics more or less accepted the events of the biblical accounts but explained them differently. So someone may have accepted that people unexpectedly had bread and fish, but really the problem was that others had food and weren't sharing. Or Jesus appeared to rise from the dead but really he was only mostly dead in good Princess Bride fashion.
These were all things I was first exposed to in Dr. Wang's class.
8. The late 1800s and early 1900s saw a gradual unraveling of confidence in the historicity of the biblical stories. The Gospel of John was first to go. It was just too different from the "synoptics" (Matthew, Mark, and Luke, so called because they looked very similar next to each other). B. H. Streeter laid out the four source hypothesis behind the synoptics in 1924--Mark, Q, M, and L. [2]
This was the phase of "source criticism," which in both the Old and New Testaments sought to find written sources behind biblical texts. In the Gospels, it was these. In the Old Testament, there was J E D and P explored behind the Pentateuch.
I've already mentioned William Wrede, who in his 1901 book on Mark, The Messianic Secret argued that Jesus never even claimed to be the Jewish Messiah. In Mark, only the demons really seem to understand that Jesus is the Messiah. And of course Wrede didn't believe in demons.
So Wrede supposes that Mark just made it up. How do you make someone a Messiah who didn't ever claim to be a Messiah, Wrede asked. Why you have it be a secret.
Exploration of written sources soon blurred into exploration of the oral traditions behind them. This phase was called "form criticism." It seems to me that there was a lot of misunderstanding of such things. Recent decades have seen much more informed explorations. It started with Walter Ong's, Orality and Literacy, which Wayne Goodwin exposed me to in my leadership class at Asbury. Works by Dale Allison and Jimmy Dunn also are much more sophisticated.
The culmination of this "first quest for the historical Jesus" was Albert Schweitzer's 1906 depiction of the quest to figure out who Jesus really was. He basically concludes that he was a crazy prophet that we wouldn't really recognize if we met him. Looking back, this was pretty much the end of the first quest.
For a time, Barth and Bultmann would rule the day with their neo-orthodoxy. For Barth, history wasn't what was important. Apologetics is exactly the wrong direction. We simply need to believe in the dogmatic truths about the Word of God, Jesus. Bultmann in a different way said that the Jesus of history was not important. He is prolegomena to Christian faith. What we need to do is demythologize the New Testament. It is really about finding authentic existence by an existentialist leap of faith, like a Jesus rising from the dead.
9. I mentioned that I took a course on Barth at Asbury with Steve Seamands. Barth seemed to be the flavor of the day. He certainly was at Princeton, and John Drury would end up doing his doctoral work on him. When I was there Lawson Stone seemed enamored with him, but that may have been a brief phase.
There were several things I found attractive about Barth. As a Wesleyan who was used to spiritualized readings of Scripture, I found the idea of the Bible becoming the word of God attractive. In my own categories, this was like when the Holy Spirit spoke to you through the words of the Bible or, as a Pentecostal might say, when you received a word of knowledge while reading the Bible. Somehow I doubt Barth meant it to be quite so non-intellectual.
I deeply appreciated his clarification that Jesus is the Word of God par excellence. The Bible gives witness to Jesus, and preaching gives witness to Jesus through the witness of Scripture. It seems to me quite impossible to deny this theologically John 1:14 is not talking about the Bible but about Jesus. Still, I have heard some fundamentalists warn about those who say Jesus is the true word of God.
What over time I decided I didn't like was Barth's rejection of all evidentiary reasoning when it comes to truths of this sort. It is no coincidence that his great work is the Dogmatics. When something is dogmatic, it is not up for debate or discussion. It is not derived by inductive reasoning. It just hangs there in thin air, an assumption to believe, and other things are deduced therefrom.
Let's just say I have intellectual sympathies for Brunner and Niebuhr.
For me, faith is reasonable. It does not "demand" a verdict necessarily, but it is not irrational. It is not Tertullian's "I believe because it is absurd." It is not Kierkegaard's blind leap of faith. It is more along the lines of Pascal's fuzzy sense of things. If you have faith it makes sense, but there is enough room for doubt that the person without faith can conclude otherwise.
I have come to see Barth and post-liberalism as giving up on the rationality of faith. It's like they gave up on trying to make sense of faith in the light of reason and just said that reason isn't what it's all about. It's just something you believe. I've wondered if there is some Reformed theology hiding here. If you are predestined, you will see it, so there's no need for proof.
10. It was after World War II that one of Bultmann's pupils, Ernst Kasemann, revived the quest, starting the so called new quest for the historical Jesus. The New Quest had rigid criteria so that only the most likely of sayings of Jesus made it through the process. [3] One key one was the criterion of dissimilarity. If a saying of Jesus did not fit well either with Judaism or Christianity, Jesus probably said it.
The problem here is that Jesus was a Jew and Christianity came out of him. So most of what he said is likely to stand somewhere on a continuum between both. Wright thus speaks of "double similarity." I slipped over to a conference at Dayton once (at United Seminary) where most of the criteria of such quests were deconstructed.
Somewhere in the 1960s there was a turn away from breaking the Gospels apart to how they were put together. Redaction criticism still looked at sources, but it looked at how the Gospel writers had edited them. The focus was not on the atoms but on the molecules.
Then as I said, by the 80s, narrative criticism had given up look at the sources altogether and was looking at narratives as wholes. Biblical studies was always a few decades behind broader literary criticism. New criticism had given up on authorial intent some time before biblical studies hit narrative criticism. They spoke of something called "the intentional fallacy," meaning that the meaning of a literary work is not dependent on the intent of an author which, after all, is a matter of minds and thus out of reach.
I think the intentional fallacy is in part itself a fallacy, but biblical studies was riding a wave. That wave would lead first to reader-response criticism, where the meaning of a text really was a matter of the reader. Stanley Fish should be mentioned somewhere in here. Then of course we end with Derrida and deconstruction. All of this is laid out well in Stephen Moore's Literary Criticism of the Gospels, which I also read in the first year of my doctoral work.
11. Dr. Wang's class introduced me to this history, and Dr. Bauer helped me join the flow of literary criticism in process. My good friend and fellow teaching fellow Bill Patrick was also on top of such things. He was another person who always made me feel stupid. How did he always know what the latest book was? And he understood them all.
I would in the end accept both the idea of original meaning and the notion of the polyvalence of a text. Was not the basic idea of reader-response what happened when different people read the Bible and (unreflectively) ended up with their own interpretations? Couldn't the Holy Spirit use this?
Once as a professor at IWU, a group of students read Kevin Vanhoozer's, Is There a Meaning in This Text? with me, a title meant to echo Fish. It seemed to me that Vanhoozer softened as he wrote the book. I smiled to think that he was realizing it wasn't as simple as he might have thought when he started writing.
The idea of respecting an author by attending to his or her intended meaning seemed like a nice try, but no dice, a Hail Mary that really doesn't hold up in the end. If I want to twist the words of Shakespeare, it doesn't matter to him. He's dead. It's a book, not a person.
No one who knows me should doubt that the originally intended meaning is important to me. But a text can and will be taken in ways the author never intended--or would like. Paul Ricoeur put it best when he spoke of the autonomy of a text. Once it is uttered, an author no longer has control over its meaning.
I'll end today simply by saying that Asbury set me up well to understand hermeneutics on a deep level. There will be more to say on the topic before I am through.
[1] For a sense of this layer of biblical studies in the 80s, see Rhoads and Michie's Mark as Story as well as Mark Allen Powell's, What is Narrative Criticism? David Smith of IWU was once going to teach Mark at a Christian high school in Indianapolis to give some of its teachers continuing education. When they saw the title, Mark as Story, they cancelled because they took it to mean that Mark was not history. Let's just say that's not what the title means.
When I got to England, I found some people who were not practicing narrative criticism in a disciplined way. They were not bracketing the historical but let their sense of the history "infect" their interpretations of the story.
[2] Mark was written first. There was also a written collection of Jesus' sayings called Q (for Quelle, "source"). M and L represented unique source material for Matthew and Luke respectively.
[3] Wright's chapter in Neill also criticized the tendency of the earlier quests to focus only on sayings and not on events. Sayings are much more polyvalent and thus squishy. Q can be a canvas on which many Jesuses can be painted. The third quest, which Wright was part of, amended that mistake.
Wednesday, January 08, 2020
Tuesday, January 07, 2020
Asbury Seminary 1
previous post
___________
1. I think I was mistaken about when I did construction and when I substitute pastored for my brother-in-law at Zephyrhills. I believe I did these the summer after I graduated from Central. I was taking classes at Central both summers there.
I've mentioned that I studied David Thompson's workbook for Machen in the summer before I matriculated at Asbury. I was a Greek major at Central but it wasn't enough. The study I did in the summer pushed me over the top. I was able to test out of Greek and go straight into New Testament Exegesis.
Asbury had a bit of a multiple-personality disorder thing going on in those days. You had the English Bible (EB) department headed by Robert Traina, also with David Bauer and David Thompson. Then you had what I might call the exegetical Bible professors who followed a more mainstream evangelical approach to exegesis. These included Bob Lyon, Dr. Wang, John Oswalt, and Lawson Stone had just arrived.
It was no problem to me. I gained greatly from both and found the dual perspective on exegesis enriching and helpful. There was no real contradiction between the two, and a synthesis is easily enough achieved. During my time there, Lawson Stone tried to integrate both approaches in an Isaiah 1-11 special topics course he did in Hebrew. I'll explain the two approaches as I go.
2. My first semester I had Ron Crown for New Testament Exegesis. He only taught for a year at Asbury. He was Free Methodist. Given where I was at in my journey, he seemed liberal to me. Mind you, that didn't bother me. I only struggled with guilt about myself. I had no problem learning from people I potentially disagreed with. His salvation was his own business.
There is a dynamic I've observed with people from more sectarian backgrounds. Think Amish. Think Mormon. Think Seventh Day Adventist. In my case, think holiness. We are so used to being weird that it is normal for our teachers and co-workers to be completely different from us. The run of the mill fundamentalist these days is trying to take over society. That was not the feel I had growing up.
In fact, some would say this only changed in the mid-80s. Before then, we accepted that we were just different. Jerry Falwell weaponized us and we've been trying to take over the United States ever since, not least with the current president.
We used Gordon Fee's New Testament Exegesis. I liked it. It was classical neo-evangelical exegesis in the manner of Fuller and Wheaton. It laid out so well the steps for historical-cultural interpretation in the old modernist way, and it assumed you knew Greek. I gained a lot from the class.
3. At the same time I was starting the classical exegetical route, I also had David Bauer for Matthew, my first introduction to what at the time they called "EB," English Bible. They would later rename the courses inductive Bible study in hope that students would do it in the original languages. [1]
The father of EB was none other than Robert Traina himself, the author of the famed textbook, Methodical Bible Study. [2] Bauer has since updated the approach with his Inductive Bible Study. To say that Bauer and Traina were/are both "J" personalities is an understatement. Bauer would often, on the spot, say something like, "There are three reasons you should take the southern stairway..."
The flavor of EB was that it focused overwhelmingly on the literary phase of interpretation. Yes, yes, you did eventually engage historical-cultural context. Yes, there was a point where you did synthesis of the whole Bible ("evaluation"). Yes, there was application at the end.
But these were not the focus of the EB classes, as I experienced them. It was the exegetical professors and those courses in the curriculum that more engaged the historical and especially the critical. EB, especially under Bauer, focused on the literary context of passages.
This only made sense because Dr. Bauer's dissertation work at Union (in Virginia, under Jack Kingsbury) was a narrative critical approach to the Gospel of Matthew. [3] I came to Asbury right in the heyday of literary critical approaches to the Bible. The 70s had done a lot of redaction criticism and structuralism. Now we were doing narrative criticism and would soon slide into reader-response and deconstruction. I found it all very stimulating. More to come.
Although I loved my Central professors, many of my seminary professors seemed to be on the next level. I often felt stupid at Central, but it was not so much my professors who made me feel this way. Some of my professors at Asbury were so advanced that just being around them made me feel stupid. This was especially true of Bauer. He just seemed to know everything.
As an aside, he also knew a lot of scholars. We used to joke about how he would say something like, "Of course I know Bud." (In this case, Paul "Bud" Achtemeier.)
4. English Bible had its own language. When Bauer surveyed Matthew, he identified one structural relationship as "recurrence of particularization with filial language." We learned expressions like "particularization" and "detailed observation."
I heard a funny story about a new professor at Asbury once upon a time who was going to be teaching some Bible and sat in on some inductive Bible study sessions to get a feel for its approach. This person had a doctorate in Bible but found themselves wondering what in the world they were hearing.
I have taught inductive Bible study many times over my years at Indiana Wesleyan and Wesley Seminary. Students from my early years might remember frequent references to Asbury Seminary as I taught exegesis. I still hope to finish my own book on how to study the Bible, and the methods I learned at Asbury in it are evident.
Let's think of inductive Bible study as a five step process:
5. Another strength of Traina's method was the integration phase, which he called "evaluation." Books like Hays and Duvall's Grasping God's Word does not really have a phase like this. It is a little more fundamentalist, a little more mainstream neo-evangelical.
But Traina is more reflective. When I was at Asbury, there was a real commitment to hearing each book of the Bible in context. When you listen, you hear the tensions. You hear the unique voices of each book. It becomes necessary to negotiate between the contextual voices. You have to find center points.
Hays and Duvall do not negotiate between voices. They go straight to application from each individual passage. That is a blind spot because it does not map each passage to the other passages of the Bible. Traina's method was more advanced...
[1] Jerry Walls used to call David Bauer "EB" as a nickname. Jerry had these bets with Bauer. The one I remember is when Jerry bet Bauer that he could get an article published with Interpretation. This was quite unlikely for a couple reasons, and Bauer knew it. For one, Interpretation is a biblical studies journal, and Jerry is a philosopher. More importantly, publishing in Interpretation is by invitation only. Bauer won the bet and got a Chinese meal out of it, I think.
[2] I regret that I was not able to take Traina. My first year at Asbury was his last. There was a mad scramble to take his Pentateuch class in the spring of 1988, and the class was full by the time a lowly first year like me tried to sign up. He had developed the method at Union in New York.
[3] I personally think Bauer's work is spectacular, but his The Structure of Matthew's Gospel was tepidly received, I think in large part because mainstream scholarship doesn't speak his language. I got the sense that when a new Provost came to Asbury in the early 00s, he tried to curb Asbury somewhat of its IBS ways.
I see Bauer has just published an introduction to the Gospel of Matthew. I ordered it immediately!
___________
1. I think I was mistaken about when I did construction and when I substitute pastored for my brother-in-law at Zephyrhills. I believe I did these the summer after I graduated from Central. I was taking classes at Central both summers there.
I've mentioned that I studied David Thompson's workbook for Machen in the summer before I matriculated at Asbury. I was a Greek major at Central but it wasn't enough. The study I did in the summer pushed me over the top. I was able to test out of Greek and go straight into New Testament Exegesis.
Asbury had a bit of a multiple-personality disorder thing going on in those days. You had the English Bible (EB) department headed by Robert Traina, also with David Bauer and David Thompson. Then you had what I might call the exegetical Bible professors who followed a more mainstream evangelical approach to exegesis. These included Bob Lyon, Dr. Wang, John Oswalt, and Lawson Stone had just arrived.
It was no problem to me. I gained greatly from both and found the dual perspective on exegesis enriching and helpful. There was no real contradiction between the two, and a synthesis is easily enough achieved. During my time there, Lawson Stone tried to integrate both approaches in an Isaiah 1-11 special topics course he did in Hebrew. I'll explain the two approaches as I go.
2. My first semester I had Ron Crown for New Testament Exegesis. He only taught for a year at Asbury. He was Free Methodist. Given where I was at in my journey, he seemed liberal to me. Mind you, that didn't bother me. I only struggled with guilt about myself. I had no problem learning from people I potentially disagreed with. His salvation was his own business.
There is a dynamic I've observed with people from more sectarian backgrounds. Think Amish. Think Mormon. Think Seventh Day Adventist. In my case, think holiness. We are so used to being weird that it is normal for our teachers and co-workers to be completely different from us. The run of the mill fundamentalist these days is trying to take over society. That was not the feel I had growing up.
In fact, some would say this only changed in the mid-80s. Before then, we accepted that we were just different. Jerry Falwell weaponized us and we've been trying to take over the United States ever since, not least with the current president.
We used Gordon Fee's New Testament Exegesis. I liked it. It was classical neo-evangelical exegesis in the manner of Fuller and Wheaton. It laid out so well the steps for historical-cultural interpretation in the old modernist way, and it assumed you knew Greek. I gained a lot from the class.
3. At the same time I was starting the classical exegetical route, I also had David Bauer for Matthew, my first introduction to what at the time they called "EB," English Bible. They would later rename the courses inductive Bible study in hope that students would do it in the original languages. [1]
The father of EB was none other than Robert Traina himself, the author of the famed textbook, Methodical Bible Study. [2] Bauer has since updated the approach with his Inductive Bible Study. To say that Bauer and Traina were/are both "J" personalities is an understatement. Bauer would often, on the spot, say something like, "There are three reasons you should take the southern stairway..."
The flavor of EB was that it focused overwhelmingly on the literary phase of interpretation. Yes, yes, you did eventually engage historical-cultural context. Yes, there was a point where you did synthesis of the whole Bible ("evaluation"). Yes, there was application at the end.
But these were not the focus of the EB classes, as I experienced them. It was the exegetical professors and those courses in the curriculum that more engaged the historical and especially the critical. EB, especially under Bauer, focused on the literary context of passages.
This only made sense because Dr. Bauer's dissertation work at Union (in Virginia, under Jack Kingsbury) was a narrative critical approach to the Gospel of Matthew. [3] I came to Asbury right in the heyday of literary critical approaches to the Bible. The 70s had done a lot of redaction criticism and structuralism. Now we were doing narrative criticism and would soon slide into reader-response and deconstruction. I found it all very stimulating. More to come.
Although I loved my Central professors, many of my seminary professors seemed to be on the next level. I often felt stupid at Central, but it was not so much my professors who made me feel this way. Some of my professors at Asbury were so advanced that just being around them made me feel stupid. This was especially true of Bauer. He just seemed to know everything.
As an aside, he also knew a lot of scholars. We used to joke about how he would say something like, "Of course I know Bud." (In this case, Paul "Bud" Achtemeier.)
4. English Bible had its own language. When Bauer surveyed Matthew, he identified one structural relationship as "recurrence of particularization with filial language." We learned expressions like "particularization" and "detailed observation."
I heard a funny story about a new professor at Asbury once upon a time who was going to be teaching some Bible and sat in on some inductive Bible study sessions to get a feel for its approach. This person had a doctorate in Bible but found themselves wondering what in the world they were hearing.
I have taught inductive Bible study many times over my years at Indiana Wesleyan and Wesley Seminary. Students from my early years might remember frequent references to Asbury Seminary as I taught exegesis. I still hope to finish my own book on how to study the Bible, and the methods I learned at Asbury in it are evident.
Let's think of inductive Bible study as a five step process:
- Preparation
- Observation
- Interpretation
- Integration
- Appropriation
5. Another strength of Traina's method was the integration phase, which he called "evaluation." Books like Hays and Duvall's Grasping God's Word does not really have a phase like this. It is a little more fundamentalist, a little more mainstream neo-evangelical.
But Traina is more reflective. When I was at Asbury, there was a real commitment to hearing each book of the Bible in context. When you listen, you hear the tensions. You hear the unique voices of each book. It becomes necessary to negotiate between the contextual voices. You have to find center points.
Hays and Duvall do not negotiate between voices. They go straight to application from each individual passage. That is a blind spot because it does not map each passage to the other passages of the Bible. Traina's method was more advanced...
[1] Jerry Walls used to call David Bauer "EB" as a nickname. Jerry had these bets with Bauer. The one I remember is when Jerry bet Bauer that he could get an article published with Interpretation. This was quite unlikely for a couple reasons, and Bauer knew it. For one, Interpretation is a biblical studies journal, and Jerry is a philosopher. More importantly, publishing in Interpretation is by invitation only. Bauer won the bet and got a Chinese meal out of it, I think.
[2] I regret that I was not able to take Traina. My first year at Asbury was his last. There was a mad scramble to take his Pentateuch class in the spring of 1988, and the class was full by the time a lowly first year like me tried to sign up. He had developed the method at Union in New York.
[3] I personally think Bauer's work is spectacular, but his The Structure of Matthew's Gospel was tepidly received, I think in large part because mainstream scholarship doesn't speak his language. I got the sense that when a new Provost came to Asbury in the early 00s, he tried to curb Asbury somewhat of its IBS ways.
I see Bauer has just published an introduction to the Gospel of Matthew. I ordered it immediately!
The Turning Point 11
previous post
_______________
51. I had to graduate in three years because my full tuition scholarship only applied up to the amount of credits necessary to graduate and I had come in as a sophomore because of AP credit. Before I knew that, I had worked out plans to stay a fourth year to finish my chemistry major and add a math major. Alas, it was not to be. [1]
So my third year at Central would be my final year in South Carolina. No more Table Rock. One of the most significant moments in my spiritual journey happened on my final Easter Sunday, April 19, 1987. I've mentioned the four most significant up to that point that I remember:
52. For some reason, I'm not sure why, I decided to read the book of Galatians before church on Easter Sunday. As I read it, I had a sinking feeling. Paul's opponents were trying to bind the Galatians to works, to circumcision, to the observance of days and seasons. But justification was by faith, not works. Paul attacked those focused on such works, on "weak and beggardly elements." He gets quite angry. If his opponents are so keen on cutting things off, he'd just as well they cut their whole thing off (Gal. 5:12).
The sinking feeling inside said, "Ken, you are not on Paul's side in this debate. You are on the side that Paul is arguing against."
That was a turning point. I had been building toward the turn, but that was the moment when the turn took place. It was also a major step toward a lasting spiritual peace.
I have come to see my previous self somewhat in terms of what Paul says of his brethren in Romans 10:2, "a zeal without knowledge." I think Paul thought of his previous self when he said this. He was so convinced he was right. He thought he was fighting for God. But he was actually misguided.
I have identified with Paul's story in more than one way. I don't have his personality. But I feel an affinity for his ideas. It's no wonder I am drawn to his writings in the Bible the most (even more than Hebrews :-).
Not that I was particularly zealous before, but I felt quite strongly about things about which I was mistaken. I see much of fundamentalist Christianity in this way. There is a great deal of zeal out there. It thinks it is standing up for God. It is laying down the law. But in some ways it is very mistaken. Sometimes it even fights against God's will and God's values.
53. There was some transition time. In my first years at seminary, I would have such joy and peace at Asbury. Then I would go home and the cloud of doubt would return. Was I wrong to start going to movies? Was I wrong to eat out on Sunday? Then I would go back to Asbury and the joy and peace would return. One cannot live in this back and forth forever. Eventually I decided for peace and joy.
I got into some discussions in those days. Sometimes I would apologize for arguing. "We're not arguing. We're just having a discussion." I eventually decided that argument was not productive. I was just venting. I wasn't sure I really wanted anyone to change their mind anyway.
It's OK for people to have different convictions and come to different conclusions, as long as no one gets hurt. I believe God is very patient with us. We are so overwhelmingly stupid. If he wants us to have any free will at all, he must choose to put up with our inevitable and continual idiocy.
54. In those days, Romans 14, 1 Corinthians 8-10, and Colossians 2 became my best friends. Romans 14 says that whether one observes the Jewish Sabbath or not is a matter of personal conviction (14:5). Colossians 2:16 tells a Gentile audience not to let anyone judge them in relation to the keeping of a Jewish Sabbath. [2] Paul basically tells these predominantly Gentile audiences that Sabbath observance is a matter of personal conviction.
In discussion, someone pushed back that the Sabbath is based on creation in Genesis 2:3. "I know," I responded. "it's amazing that Paul doesn't seem to care." There are obviously issues where Paul was not "relativistic" like this. Paul was an "absolutist" when it came to loving God, no exceptions. Paul was universal but apparently not an absolutist when it came to the prohibition on divorce, because he made an exception. But he is not a relativist on the issue of divorce.
But on some of the hot issues of his day--like eating meat sacrificed to idols--Paul was a relativist. "Nothing is unclean in itself. If someone thinks it is unclean, then it is unclean" (Rom. 14:14).
By the way, I would eventually realize how confused discussion of absolutes and relativism is. By "absolutes," most people really mean that there are things that are definitely wrong. But that's not what an absolute is. A moral absolute is a rule or principle to which there is no exception.
By the same token, if someone is a relativist on a particular issue, they do believe in right and wrong. They just think it is relative to the person or culture. So much of popular rhetoric like this is muddled, but it makes us feel smart and it justifies our "zeal without knowledge."
I have to wonder if a good deal of the relativist/absolutes rhetoric is really about a fear or anger about change. Language of absolutes really means, "You can't do something different than the tradition on this issue." Language of relativism really means, "You can't think differently than the rest of us."
But once you realize that the Bible makes exceptions to certain universal principles (like divorce or obeying the government) and once you realize that Paul sanctions personal convictions on some disputable issues, the rhetoric fails to achieve its subconscious goals. Now we are back to doing the hard work of ethical "improvisation" and "working out our salvation with fear and trembling" together.
55. Paul's comments in Romans 14 stand at the heart of my Wesleyan ethics. Yes, from one perspective, there are acts that are sins whether you intend them to be or not. If I drive without enough sleep and accidentally kill someone, I have in a very real sense wronged or sinned against the person I killed. There is such a thing as unintentional sin in the Bible.
But the heart of New Testament ethics lies with intent. Sin is when I know I shouldn't do something and I choose to do it. Sin is when I should do something and I choose not to do it. As Wesley said, sin properly so called is "a willful transgression against a known law of God."
In that sense, sin is most meaningfully a matter of what I think I am doing. Two people can do the same thing. One may think it wrong and intentionally violate a what they think is a "law of God." That person has sinned. Another may do the same thing but not do it thinking it wrong. That person has not sinned.
56. I did an honor's project my senior year. I did not yet have a computer that could print. I hand wrote out all the chapters and then we typed it up. Even during the graduation time, my mother was helping me type it up in a motel room. In those days if you mis-typed, you hand to type over the mistaken letter with whiteout, then retype it. Woe is you if you missed a line or needed to add something back in.
The title was "An Integration of Theological and Psychological Aspects of Holiness: An Initial Study of the Biblical Doctrine of Holiness and its Relationship to Human Psychology." At one point it was in the special collections room of the library at Central, off to the left when you go through the entrance. It is 128 pages and nine chapters--my first book, so to speak.
This study laid the ground work for the way my thought would develop later. My basic sense of the holiness of God as God being set apart is laid out here. To say that God is holy is to say that God is God. It is to say that God is not humanity and humanity is not God. It was my first foray into Hebrew although I had not studied it. The etymological fallacy pokes its head up here and there.
It has a section on anthropology before the Fall. I set out here my sense of how Adam could sin and Christ be tempted even though they did not have sinful natures. It was here that I suggested that they were tempted because a good drive was turned upon an inappropriate object. The desire for knowledge is good but the desire to each the wrong tree to get that knowledge is temptation to sin.
It is a little different than Augustine because I am following Paul in Romans 14:14. No act is intrinsically sinful. It is rather the context of the act, my intention in particular, that truly makes an act sinful. The seeds of my later nominalist tendencies were set here by Paul.
It looked at the Spirit-fillings in Acts. In this study I still argued for the two-step process of 1) conversion and 2) sanctification. But I realized the Samaritan incident of Acts 8 could be taken in the way I would soon take it in seminary--that they were not truly "in" until they had the Holy Spirit. I had that nagging feeling that I would have more than once in the next seven years. It said, you may be wrong on this Ken.
It was in this study that I concluded that sanctification and conversion were closely associated in Acts. It was here as a transitional thought that I concluded that, ideally, we would be entirely sanctified at conversion.
57. And so I graduated from Central. It was a crucible for me. It was a time for me to mature and grow up a little. Yes, I learned things and formed ideas. But more significant was the way it shaped the trajectory of my life.
I did not feel ready to pastor when I graduated. I was still only 20 years old in April of 1987. I was always the youngest for a long time. And then I wasn't. I decided to do what most Wesleyans used to do in my shoes. I went to Asbury Seminary.
[1] About 10 years ago I started working through college physics and calculus books as a kind of nerd mid-life crisis. Since I learn best by teaching, I started putting videos for each section on YouTube. It's still on my bucket list to finish those 1000+ page tomes. I now have over 1000 videos on YouTube and over 4300 subscribers.
[2] It's important to note that the Sabbath discussion of the Bible is entirely about Saturday (sundown Friday to sundown Saturday). A professor at Frankfort ingeniously once suggested that the expression, "the first of sabbaths" on Easter in Luke 24:1 meant that Easter was the first time the Sabbath was on Sunday. But this is just a figure of speech for the first day of the week. Monday would then be the "second of sabbaths." There is no Scriptural text that transfers the Jewish Sabbath to Sunday.
_______________
51. I had to graduate in three years because my full tuition scholarship only applied up to the amount of credits necessary to graduate and I had come in as a sophomore because of AP credit. Before I knew that, I had worked out plans to stay a fourth year to finish my chemistry major and add a math major. Alas, it was not to be. [1]
So my third year at Central would be my final year in South Carolina. No more Table Rock. One of the most significant moments in my spiritual journey happened on my final Easter Sunday, April 19, 1987. I've mentioned the four most significant up to that point that I remember:
- The moment on the stairs at home when I felt at peace about salvation (followed of course by periodic doubts)
- The moment in a field where I acutely felt God's presence as we caught up with a troubled boy who had run away from camp
- The moment in the car when I felt at peace about entire sanctification
- The moment in the library when I realized my sense of holiness standards was out of whack
52. For some reason, I'm not sure why, I decided to read the book of Galatians before church on Easter Sunday. As I read it, I had a sinking feeling. Paul's opponents were trying to bind the Galatians to works, to circumcision, to the observance of days and seasons. But justification was by faith, not works. Paul attacked those focused on such works, on "weak and beggardly elements." He gets quite angry. If his opponents are so keen on cutting things off, he'd just as well they cut their whole thing off (Gal. 5:12).
The sinking feeling inside said, "Ken, you are not on Paul's side in this debate. You are on the side that Paul is arguing against."
That was a turning point. I had been building toward the turn, but that was the moment when the turn took place. It was also a major step toward a lasting spiritual peace.
I have come to see my previous self somewhat in terms of what Paul says of his brethren in Romans 10:2, "a zeal without knowledge." I think Paul thought of his previous self when he said this. He was so convinced he was right. He thought he was fighting for God. But he was actually misguided.
I have identified with Paul's story in more than one way. I don't have his personality. But I feel an affinity for his ideas. It's no wonder I am drawn to his writings in the Bible the most (even more than Hebrews :-).
Not that I was particularly zealous before, but I felt quite strongly about things about which I was mistaken. I see much of fundamentalist Christianity in this way. There is a great deal of zeal out there. It thinks it is standing up for God. It is laying down the law. But in some ways it is very mistaken. Sometimes it even fights against God's will and God's values.
53. There was some transition time. In my first years at seminary, I would have such joy and peace at Asbury. Then I would go home and the cloud of doubt would return. Was I wrong to start going to movies? Was I wrong to eat out on Sunday? Then I would go back to Asbury and the joy and peace would return. One cannot live in this back and forth forever. Eventually I decided for peace and joy.
I got into some discussions in those days. Sometimes I would apologize for arguing. "We're not arguing. We're just having a discussion." I eventually decided that argument was not productive. I was just venting. I wasn't sure I really wanted anyone to change their mind anyway.
It's OK for people to have different convictions and come to different conclusions, as long as no one gets hurt. I believe God is very patient with us. We are so overwhelmingly stupid. If he wants us to have any free will at all, he must choose to put up with our inevitable and continual idiocy.
54. In those days, Romans 14, 1 Corinthians 8-10, and Colossians 2 became my best friends. Romans 14 says that whether one observes the Jewish Sabbath or not is a matter of personal conviction (14:5). Colossians 2:16 tells a Gentile audience not to let anyone judge them in relation to the keeping of a Jewish Sabbath. [2] Paul basically tells these predominantly Gentile audiences that Sabbath observance is a matter of personal conviction.
In discussion, someone pushed back that the Sabbath is based on creation in Genesis 2:3. "I know," I responded. "it's amazing that Paul doesn't seem to care." There are obviously issues where Paul was not "relativistic" like this. Paul was an "absolutist" when it came to loving God, no exceptions. Paul was universal but apparently not an absolutist when it came to the prohibition on divorce, because he made an exception. But he is not a relativist on the issue of divorce.
But on some of the hot issues of his day--like eating meat sacrificed to idols--Paul was a relativist. "Nothing is unclean in itself. If someone thinks it is unclean, then it is unclean" (Rom. 14:14).
By the way, I would eventually realize how confused discussion of absolutes and relativism is. By "absolutes," most people really mean that there are things that are definitely wrong. But that's not what an absolute is. A moral absolute is a rule or principle to which there is no exception.
By the same token, if someone is a relativist on a particular issue, they do believe in right and wrong. They just think it is relative to the person or culture. So much of popular rhetoric like this is muddled, but it makes us feel smart and it justifies our "zeal without knowledge."
I have to wonder if a good deal of the relativist/absolutes rhetoric is really about a fear or anger about change. Language of absolutes really means, "You can't do something different than the tradition on this issue." Language of relativism really means, "You can't think differently than the rest of us."
But once you realize that the Bible makes exceptions to certain universal principles (like divorce or obeying the government) and once you realize that Paul sanctions personal convictions on some disputable issues, the rhetoric fails to achieve its subconscious goals. Now we are back to doing the hard work of ethical "improvisation" and "working out our salvation with fear and trembling" together.
55. Paul's comments in Romans 14 stand at the heart of my Wesleyan ethics. Yes, from one perspective, there are acts that are sins whether you intend them to be or not. If I drive without enough sleep and accidentally kill someone, I have in a very real sense wronged or sinned against the person I killed. There is such a thing as unintentional sin in the Bible.
But the heart of New Testament ethics lies with intent. Sin is when I know I shouldn't do something and I choose to do it. Sin is when I should do something and I choose not to do it. As Wesley said, sin properly so called is "a willful transgression against a known law of God."
In that sense, sin is most meaningfully a matter of what I think I am doing. Two people can do the same thing. One may think it wrong and intentionally violate a what they think is a "law of God." That person has sinned. Another may do the same thing but not do it thinking it wrong. That person has not sinned.
56. I did an honor's project my senior year. I did not yet have a computer that could print. I hand wrote out all the chapters and then we typed it up. Even during the graduation time, my mother was helping me type it up in a motel room. In those days if you mis-typed, you hand to type over the mistaken letter with whiteout, then retype it. Woe is you if you missed a line or needed to add something back in.
The title was "An Integration of Theological and Psychological Aspects of Holiness: An Initial Study of the Biblical Doctrine of Holiness and its Relationship to Human Psychology." At one point it was in the special collections room of the library at Central, off to the left when you go through the entrance. It is 128 pages and nine chapters--my first book, so to speak.
This study laid the ground work for the way my thought would develop later. My basic sense of the holiness of God as God being set apart is laid out here. To say that God is holy is to say that God is God. It is to say that God is not humanity and humanity is not God. It was my first foray into Hebrew although I had not studied it. The etymological fallacy pokes its head up here and there.
It has a section on anthropology before the Fall. I set out here my sense of how Adam could sin and Christ be tempted even though they did not have sinful natures. It was here that I suggested that they were tempted because a good drive was turned upon an inappropriate object. The desire for knowledge is good but the desire to each the wrong tree to get that knowledge is temptation to sin.
It is a little different than Augustine because I am following Paul in Romans 14:14. No act is intrinsically sinful. It is rather the context of the act, my intention in particular, that truly makes an act sinful. The seeds of my later nominalist tendencies were set here by Paul.
It looked at the Spirit-fillings in Acts. In this study I still argued for the two-step process of 1) conversion and 2) sanctification. But I realized the Samaritan incident of Acts 8 could be taken in the way I would soon take it in seminary--that they were not truly "in" until they had the Holy Spirit. I had that nagging feeling that I would have more than once in the next seven years. It said, you may be wrong on this Ken.
It was in this study that I concluded that sanctification and conversion were closely associated in Acts. It was here as a transitional thought that I concluded that, ideally, we would be entirely sanctified at conversion.
57. And so I graduated from Central. It was a crucible for me. It was a time for me to mature and grow up a little. Yes, I learned things and formed ideas. But more significant was the way it shaped the trajectory of my life.
I did not feel ready to pastor when I graduated. I was still only 20 years old in April of 1987. I was always the youngest for a long time. And then I wasn't. I decided to do what most Wesleyans used to do in my shoes. I went to Asbury Seminary.
[1] About 10 years ago I started working through college physics and calculus books as a kind of nerd mid-life crisis. Since I learn best by teaching, I started putting videos for each section on YouTube. It's still on my bucket list to finish those 1000+ page tomes. I now have over 1000 videos on YouTube and over 4300 subscribers.
[2] It's important to note that the Sabbath discussion of the Bible is entirely about Saturday (sundown Friday to sundown Saturday). A professor at Frankfort ingeniously once suggested that the expression, "the first of sabbaths" on Easter in Luke 24:1 meant that Easter was the first time the Sabbath was on Sunday. But this is just a figure of speech for the first day of the week. Monday would then be the "second of sabbaths." There is no Scriptural text that transfers the Jewish Sabbath to Sunday.
Sunday, January 05, 2020
Ministry Classes 10
previous post
___________
43. Most of my practical ministry courses were taken with Ken Foutz. Students used to joke about "Uncle Ken's story hour," but I enjoyed his stories and found them helpful. They were practical examples of ministry that came from experience. One tidbit I remember that I have repeated is a comment he made on change in a leadership class. "If you make more than two major changes in your first year at a church, you'll be the third."
I believe I had Foutz for leadership, preaching, Christian ed, and pastoral counseling. I can't remember if I had a separate worship class, so I probably didn't. I remember we used Clinebell for pastoral counseling, a classic that I know David Vardaman has used at IWU. We had a hard time finding a good pastoral counseling book when we started Wesley Seminary.
When we were starting Wesley Seminary, I dreamed of us producing integrated textbooks that corresponded to the integrated curriculum. They would have embodied the spark that founded the seminary--practically focused, theoretically undergirded, integrated with Bible, theology, and church history on a profound rather than superficial level.
Oh well. It was not to be. I started to sketch out here what such a book might have looked like for pastoral care and counseling, but maybe I'll take some of those projects forward yet some day. :-)
44. I also had Dr. Foutz for Acts. That was the favorite class I had with him. I would also take Acts with David Bauer at Asbury but a great foundation was laid by Dr. Foutz. The outline I still use today for Acts came from that class (Jerusalem, 1-7; Judea and Samaria, 8-12; ends of the earth, 13-28). There are of course other outlines.
I seem to remember us talking about the theory that, after general failure at Athens (Acts 17), Paul purposed not to focus on intellectual arguments any more, but on the foolishness of preaching (1 Cor. 1). I don't know that Foutz espoused this view. I personally reject it soundly. It mixes and matches texts that don't go with each other. [1] I have also heard it elsewhere. [2]
It's quite possible that some of the practical lessons I have passed on from Acts over the years originated in his class.
I remember very much enjoying Marling Elliott for Poetic Books. It was here that I first learned about Hebrew parallelism. I can still hear Dr. Elliott in my head reading the beginning of Psalm 23 in Hebrew.
Perhaps I shouldn't tell an embarrassing side story, but I tried to sit on the front row right in front of Dr. Elliott so I wouldn't fall asleep in class. On one fateful day I must have been very tired because I made a comment and immediately fell asleep. Francis Scott Key (yes, that was his name) didn't hear what I said and asked me to repeat it. They had to wake me up to repeat what I'd said.
45. I also had Elliott for something like an apologetics class. I believe that was when I read C. S. Lewis' Mere Christianity. I remember struggling to understand what Lewis was saying. Sometimes things would go in. Sometimes I would read the same thing over and over again and it wouldn't go in.
I often felt very stupid in those days, because I couldn't understand any number of authors. I process the situation a little differently these days. For one, there are writers who intentionally write in a difficult way so that only those who are "worthy" can understand them. Think Hegel. Think idiot. As I used to say, they invent their own language and then call you stupid for not understanding them.
Sometimes I didn't have the categories to put them in. I would have to broaden these over time. I often felt like I didn't have a guide to show me the way, that I didn't have a translator who could speak my language.
I would later also remark to my own students, "I used to feel stupid when I read certain authors. Sometimes this was because I was stupid. But sometimes it was because they just didn't make sense."
An example would be Anselm's ontological argument for the existence of God. Let me frame it this way:
46. In those days, I did often struggle when reading to stay focused. This was before I drank coffee. Often I would read the same sentence over and over again. Woe is me if I read laying on the bed with the book on the floor. As my metabolism slowed over the years, I was able to read more and more in one sitting. Sometimes I still will read the last pages of a chapter and move back toward the front to hold my attention. With some more technical books I sometimes read a page a day. "A page a day and you'll be through before you know it."
I developed strategies over the years. Read aloud. Read aloud while standing. Read while walking. Read the paragraph. Lost it. Reread the paragraph. Lost it. REREAD THE PARAGRAPH. OK, got it. In high school and college it was often sheer will power that got me through reading.
And books are my closest friends. They are my one materialism. I must have thousands of them, much to my wife's frustration. We bought five large book shelves just in the move to Houghton alone to shelve them. (In Marion I had two offices, a garage, basement, and an attic) But I have hardly ever read a book with ease.
I think the ease with which I get bored has made me an above average teacher and preacher. I teach and preach so as not to bore myself. And let me just say as a side note that the typical church is no friend to the attention deficit. The typical Sunday "lecture" is torture, cruel and unusual punishment. Don't tell me that people should stomach it no matter what because of God. They won't and they aren't. You can beat your head against a wall but it's not going to move.
47. I never became a Lewis groupie, although I respect him greatly. Even though Francis Collins finds it persuasive, I don't think the common existence of human morality is the best argument for the existence of God. [3] Group conventions protect the continued existence of a group. They avoid feuding and inner-group violence. At the same time, such moralities often do not apply to those outside the group. Collins is a great scientist, but he seems to me an amateur when it comes to anthropology.
I first encountered the "Lord, Liar, Lunatic" argument through Josh McDowell's Evidence That Demands a Verdict. The way he and Lewis present it seems to have a serious blind spot that neither of them seems to engage. Lewis assumes that Jesus claimed to be God, but this is actually a matter of significant debate in biblical studies circles. In the early 1900s, William Wrede didn't think Jesus even claimed to be the Messiah, let alone God. Neither Lewis nor McDowell seem to realize that they need to establish that Jesus actually claimed to be God in the first place. This potentially pulls the rug out from under their arguments.
Lewis' arguments in relation to the problem of evil have grown on me. He largely speaks of suffering and evil as contexts of growth for us, the "chisel" by which God develops us. Shadowlands would later mark a significant moment in my own spiritual pilgrimage. More to come.
48. I believe that I had Dr. James Bross for systematic theology. I believe we used the one volume Wiley but I also remember using the two volume Contemporary Wesleyan Theology edited by Charles Carter. Wiley spoke my language, the Wesleyan language I had grown up with. I found Carter's work more difficult. I just didn't have a framework with which to process contemporary theological debates, even in broader Wesleyan circles.
I remember trying to understand the nuances of Bultmann. I seem to remember looking up some of his work in the library. But I just didn't have the categories yet to process him and others. I could only see the world through the paradigms I'd grown up with. I couldn't yet process the debates of the day. This has been a long journey, and it isn't over yet.
I would later take a course on Karl Barth with Steve Seamands at Asbury. I remember one class where I was trying to see if I understood him. "So he's saying we all have a God-shaped vacuum inside of us," I offered, a thought that is rather more Augustine. "No," Seamands replied, "he's actually saying something almost the opposite." :-) Oh well. More on Barth later.
49. At Central I had adjuncts for missions and evangelism. Jim Wiggins taught a course on the history of missions. Bill Phillippe taught evangelism. I attended Phillippe's funeral last year at College Wesleyan in Marion. John Maxwell preached it. Phillippe was an intriguing man, a businessman with a passion for evangelism, a philanthropist. There were only four or so of us in the class, going through his own materials. He tried to plant a church while I was a student.
I've already mentioned that Jim Wiggins was my pastoral mentor throughout college. I apprenticed with him in the old fashioned way. He took me under his wings and I went around with him, doing visitation mostly. We were of a similar theological stripe and background. He would go on to be district superintendent of Georgia.
There is nothing wrong with exercising the gifts God has given you to the fullest. Wiggins had gifts of leadership and it seemed obvious to me that he would enjoy using them. However, the holiness tradition did not allow a person to promote him or herself. It creates a bit of a conundrum. You have gifts to lead. You want to lead. But you have to be raised up to leadership by others. A fun dance to watch holiness people do!
50. My favorite professor at Central was Bob Black, who arrived my final year. It was a great win for Central. I was able to have him for a full year for church history. (Russ Gunsalus had him the previous year at Bartlesville.) Later, Brian Matherlee would tell me about his Romans course and I was jealous I was not able to take it.
I remember that it was a fun two classes. Amy Smith left gummy worms on his desk the day after we talked about the "Diet of Worms." There is a playful creativity in a lot of bright young minds that is why I love teaching and being involved with education. I remarked to some of my smart colleagues here at Houghton last semester how much I like being around smart people. Black's class was full of that playful creativity of bright young minds.
I wrote a paper at one point in his class suggesting that modern versions of the Bible could be corrupt because they were largely based on Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Vaticanus. I hypothesized that these two codices were two of the fifty commissioned by Constantine and carried out by Eusebius. Eusebius and Constantine, I noted, did not favor the orthodox position that Jesus was homoousios (of one substance) with the Father but offered the compromise that Jesus was homoiousios (of similar substance) with the Father. Therefore, heretical man commissions heretical manuscripts on which versions like the NIV are based and, voila, we should be using the King James.
"Ingenious," right? Ridiculous, actually. Dr. Black gently noted on my paper that the vast majority of differences between the text of Sinaiticus and Vaticanus had nothing to do with theology (no matter how Bart Ehrman sells his books today). Details, details. I would return to these questions in seminary.
[1] In other words, it is an unreflective, "pre-modern" argument that does not realize that Acts is not simply a tape recording but an account with a perspective. Luke is positive toward the sermon at Athens. I would say that, for Luke, Paul's sermon at Athens demonstrated that he was an intellectual on par with pagan intellectuals. Similarly, 1 Corinthians says nothing about a change of strategy when he got to Corinth. The glue of this theory is outside the dots and, moreover, is rooted in the anti-intellectualism of American fundamentalism.
[2] I seem to remember that a pastor of Stonewall Wesleyan in Lexington, Kentucky (before Larry Freels came) may have preached negatively toward Asbury Seminary using this passage. What an idiot! The result was that he pretty much lost all the seminary professors who attended Stonewall (and thus a lot of tithers) and, when I came to town, hardly any Wesleyan seminary students attended the church. He was embodying some foolish preaching all right.
[3] The Language of God. Lewis' arguments were instrumental in Collins becoming a believer. I celebrate that.
___________
43. Most of my practical ministry courses were taken with Ken Foutz. Students used to joke about "Uncle Ken's story hour," but I enjoyed his stories and found them helpful. They were practical examples of ministry that came from experience. One tidbit I remember that I have repeated is a comment he made on change in a leadership class. "If you make more than two major changes in your first year at a church, you'll be the third."
I believe I had Foutz for leadership, preaching, Christian ed, and pastoral counseling. I can't remember if I had a separate worship class, so I probably didn't. I remember we used Clinebell for pastoral counseling, a classic that I know David Vardaman has used at IWU. We had a hard time finding a good pastoral counseling book when we started Wesley Seminary.
When we were starting Wesley Seminary, I dreamed of us producing integrated textbooks that corresponded to the integrated curriculum. They would have embodied the spark that founded the seminary--practically focused, theoretically undergirded, integrated with Bible, theology, and church history on a profound rather than superficial level.
Oh well. It was not to be. I started to sketch out here what such a book might have looked like for pastoral care and counseling, but maybe I'll take some of those projects forward yet some day. :-)
44. I also had Dr. Foutz for Acts. That was the favorite class I had with him. I would also take Acts with David Bauer at Asbury but a great foundation was laid by Dr. Foutz. The outline I still use today for Acts came from that class (Jerusalem, 1-7; Judea and Samaria, 8-12; ends of the earth, 13-28). There are of course other outlines.
I seem to remember us talking about the theory that, after general failure at Athens (Acts 17), Paul purposed not to focus on intellectual arguments any more, but on the foolishness of preaching (1 Cor. 1). I don't know that Foutz espoused this view. I personally reject it soundly. It mixes and matches texts that don't go with each other. [1] I have also heard it elsewhere. [2]
It's quite possible that some of the practical lessons I have passed on from Acts over the years originated in his class.
I remember very much enjoying Marling Elliott for Poetic Books. It was here that I first learned about Hebrew parallelism. I can still hear Dr. Elliott in my head reading the beginning of Psalm 23 in Hebrew.
Perhaps I shouldn't tell an embarrassing side story, but I tried to sit on the front row right in front of Dr. Elliott so I wouldn't fall asleep in class. On one fateful day I must have been very tired because I made a comment and immediately fell asleep. Francis Scott Key (yes, that was his name) didn't hear what I said and asked me to repeat it. They had to wake me up to repeat what I'd said.
45. I also had Elliott for something like an apologetics class. I believe that was when I read C. S. Lewis' Mere Christianity. I remember struggling to understand what Lewis was saying. Sometimes things would go in. Sometimes I would read the same thing over and over again and it wouldn't go in.
I often felt very stupid in those days, because I couldn't understand any number of authors. I process the situation a little differently these days. For one, there are writers who intentionally write in a difficult way so that only those who are "worthy" can understand them. Think Hegel. Think idiot. As I used to say, they invent their own language and then call you stupid for not understanding them.
Sometimes I didn't have the categories to put them in. I would have to broaden these over time. I often felt like I didn't have a guide to show me the way, that I didn't have a translator who could speak my language.
I would later also remark to my own students, "I used to feel stupid when I read certain authors. Sometimes this was because I was stupid. But sometimes it was because they just didn't make sense."
An example would be Anselm's ontological argument for the existence of God. Let me frame it this way:
- The greatest possible Being exists in my mind.
- But this Being wouldn't actually be greatest if this Being didn't exist in the real world as well as in my mind.
- Therefore, God exists.
46. In those days, I did often struggle when reading to stay focused. This was before I drank coffee. Often I would read the same sentence over and over again. Woe is me if I read laying on the bed with the book on the floor. As my metabolism slowed over the years, I was able to read more and more in one sitting. Sometimes I still will read the last pages of a chapter and move back toward the front to hold my attention. With some more technical books I sometimes read a page a day. "A page a day and you'll be through before you know it."
I developed strategies over the years. Read aloud. Read aloud while standing. Read while walking. Read the paragraph. Lost it. Reread the paragraph. Lost it. REREAD THE PARAGRAPH. OK, got it. In high school and college it was often sheer will power that got me through reading.
And books are my closest friends. They are my one materialism. I must have thousands of them, much to my wife's frustration. We bought five large book shelves just in the move to Houghton alone to shelve them. (In Marion I had two offices, a garage, basement, and an attic) But I have hardly ever read a book with ease.
I think the ease with which I get bored has made me an above average teacher and preacher. I teach and preach so as not to bore myself. And let me just say as a side note that the typical church is no friend to the attention deficit. The typical Sunday "lecture" is torture, cruel and unusual punishment. Don't tell me that people should stomach it no matter what because of God. They won't and they aren't. You can beat your head against a wall but it's not going to move.
47. I never became a Lewis groupie, although I respect him greatly. Even though Francis Collins finds it persuasive, I don't think the common existence of human morality is the best argument for the existence of God. [3] Group conventions protect the continued existence of a group. They avoid feuding and inner-group violence. At the same time, such moralities often do not apply to those outside the group. Collins is a great scientist, but he seems to me an amateur when it comes to anthropology.
I first encountered the "Lord, Liar, Lunatic" argument through Josh McDowell's Evidence That Demands a Verdict. The way he and Lewis present it seems to have a serious blind spot that neither of them seems to engage. Lewis assumes that Jesus claimed to be God, but this is actually a matter of significant debate in biblical studies circles. In the early 1900s, William Wrede didn't think Jesus even claimed to be the Messiah, let alone God. Neither Lewis nor McDowell seem to realize that they need to establish that Jesus actually claimed to be God in the first place. This potentially pulls the rug out from under their arguments.
Lewis' arguments in relation to the problem of evil have grown on me. He largely speaks of suffering and evil as contexts of growth for us, the "chisel" by which God develops us. Shadowlands would later mark a significant moment in my own spiritual pilgrimage. More to come.
48. I believe that I had Dr. James Bross for systematic theology. I believe we used the one volume Wiley but I also remember using the two volume Contemporary Wesleyan Theology edited by Charles Carter. Wiley spoke my language, the Wesleyan language I had grown up with. I found Carter's work more difficult. I just didn't have a framework with which to process contemporary theological debates, even in broader Wesleyan circles.
I remember trying to understand the nuances of Bultmann. I seem to remember looking up some of his work in the library. But I just didn't have the categories yet to process him and others. I could only see the world through the paradigms I'd grown up with. I couldn't yet process the debates of the day. This has been a long journey, and it isn't over yet.
I would later take a course on Karl Barth with Steve Seamands at Asbury. I remember one class where I was trying to see if I understood him. "So he's saying we all have a God-shaped vacuum inside of us," I offered, a thought that is rather more Augustine. "No," Seamands replied, "he's actually saying something almost the opposite." :-) Oh well. More on Barth later.
49. At Central I had adjuncts for missions and evangelism. Jim Wiggins taught a course on the history of missions. Bill Phillippe taught evangelism. I attended Phillippe's funeral last year at College Wesleyan in Marion. John Maxwell preached it. Phillippe was an intriguing man, a businessman with a passion for evangelism, a philanthropist. There were only four or so of us in the class, going through his own materials. He tried to plant a church while I was a student.
I've already mentioned that Jim Wiggins was my pastoral mentor throughout college. I apprenticed with him in the old fashioned way. He took me under his wings and I went around with him, doing visitation mostly. We were of a similar theological stripe and background. He would go on to be district superintendent of Georgia.
There is nothing wrong with exercising the gifts God has given you to the fullest. Wiggins had gifts of leadership and it seemed obvious to me that he would enjoy using them. However, the holiness tradition did not allow a person to promote him or herself. It creates a bit of a conundrum. You have gifts to lead. You want to lead. But you have to be raised up to leadership by others. A fun dance to watch holiness people do!
50. My favorite professor at Central was Bob Black, who arrived my final year. It was a great win for Central. I was able to have him for a full year for church history. (Russ Gunsalus had him the previous year at Bartlesville.) Later, Brian Matherlee would tell me about his Romans course and I was jealous I was not able to take it.
I remember that it was a fun two classes. Amy Smith left gummy worms on his desk the day after we talked about the "Diet of Worms." There is a playful creativity in a lot of bright young minds that is why I love teaching and being involved with education. I remarked to some of my smart colleagues here at Houghton last semester how much I like being around smart people. Black's class was full of that playful creativity of bright young minds.
I wrote a paper at one point in his class suggesting that modern versions of the Bible could be corrupt because they were largely based on Codex Sinaiticus and Codex Vaticanus. I hypothesized that these two codices were two of the fifty commissioned by Constantine and carried out by Eusebius. Eusebius and Constantine, I noted, did not favor the orthodox position that Jesus was homoousios (of one substance) with the Father but offered the compromise that Jesus was homoiousios (of similar substance) with the Father. Therefore, heretical man commissions heretical manuscripts on which versions like the NIV are based and, voila, we should be using the King James.
"Ingenious," right? Ridiculous, actually. Dr. Black gently noted on my paper that the vast majority of differences between the text of Sinaiticus and Vaticanus had nothing to do with theology (no matter how Bart Ehrman sells his books today). Details, details. I would return to these questions in seminary.
[1] In other words, it is an unreflective, "pre-modern" argument that does not realize that Acts is not simply a tape recording but an account with a perspective. Luke is positive toward the sermon at Athens. I would say that, for Luke, Paul's sermon at Athens demonstrated that he was an intellectual on par with pagan intellectuals. Similarly, 1 Corinthians says nothing about a change of strategy when he got to Corinth. The glue of this theory is outside the dots and, moreover, is rooted in the anti-intellectualism of American fundamentalism.
[2] I seem to remember that a pastor of Stonewall Wesleyan in Lexington, Kentucky (before Larry Freels came) may have preached negatively toward Asbury Seminary using this passage. What an idiot! The result was that he pretty much lost all the seminary professors who attended Stonewall (and thus a lot of tithers) and, when I came to town, hardly any Wesleyan seminary students attended the church. He was embodying some foolish preaching all right.
[3] The Language of God. Lewis' arguments were instrumental in Collins becoming a believer. I celebrate that.
Traveling Ministry Teams 9
previous post
____________
38. My second year at Central (1985-86) was my first year studying for ministry, and one of the highlights was going on weekend ministry teams. Most of them seemed to be in North Carolina, but we also visited Kentucky, Georgia, and Florida. On a number of these trips, I was able to preach. It was great experience.
I don't know whose idea it was, but a lot of the trips were in a quartet, with me singing bass, Rodney Clark singing tenor, Laura (then) Strickland singing alto, and Jan (then) Fisher singing the lead. For some of the weekends, Stacey (then) Bodenhorn played the piano.
One of the most memorable trips was to Hudson Wesleyan Church in Florida, with Elmer Drury driving the van. Elmer was Keith Drury's older brother and he would die suddenly of a heart attack the next year. At that time, Elmer was doing the advancement and alumni work for the college, I believe. I don't remember much from the trip except that it was a highlight of the year.
39. In those days, I believed I needed to "pray down" each sermon. In my pre-ministerial training, the culture was that God revealed each sermon to you a little like God talking to Moses. You go up to the mountain and come back down with the sermon God had revealed to you for that week.
When I learned about the idea of planning out a series of sermons in advance, I engaged one of my earlier mentors. The immediate reaction was to think of this sort of approach to preaching as a very human one. It seemed to them to take the spiritual dimension of preaching away and change preaching into a matter of human thinking and planning.
By the way, we often would say growing up that a service was particularly visited by the Spirit if the pastor didn't get to preach because someone got blessed. Let's just say that the picture of God I grew up with was that of a very spontaneous God who showed himself most when he interrupted things. He sure didn't seem to plan ahead much, or at least he wanted to keep everyone on their toes. [1]
Back to my mentor. I responded to them, "Can't God see six months ahead to tell you what to preach earlier than the very week of the sermon?" The person thought for a second and then said, "In my experience God doesn't work that way."
I truly wanted to pray down every sermon, but let's just say that I often found myself Saturday the day before preaching without a clear sense of lightning. At the time I blamed myself for not praying harder in the week. No doubt I should have, but I don't think that was the main problem.
40. I just don't think that every believer gets "zapped" as often as every other believer. There are people who hear the Holy Spirit all the time. I envy them. Then there are people who think they get zapped all the time but really don't. They're just eating too much bacon.
But I was once encouraged when it dawned on me that Moses didn't really hear from God until he was eighty years old. I have a few benchmarks in my spiritual walk that I have mentioned. I would not be the only one to suggest that you keep track of those spiritual encounters so that you can look back at them when you enter a period of silence or perhaps have what some have called the "dark night of the soul."
When I was in England, I read the book Honest to God by John A. T. Robertson. I don't remember much of what was in the book except mainly that it went too far. But I did resonate with an experience he shared at the beginning of the book. He was talking about how, in theological college, everyone was having emotional experiences of God and he wasn't. The comment was striking to me. I wonder if one of the dangers of experientially-oriented traditions is to set up expectations that simply do not apply to everyone.
There are no doubt people who grow up in Pentecostal homes today who undergo some of my own pilgrimage. You are raised with a story that leads you to believe that you should be having these repeated and regular highly emotional encounters with God. And you pray for them, and you look at your navel in constant introspection wondering what's wrong with you.
I remember a young man when I was a boy who seemed to go to the altar at my home church in Florida every Sunday night. He never seemed to leave feeling like he had victory. Now it could have been that he simply wouldn't surrender everything to God. I do wonder, though, if he had the wrong expectations.
What would Christian experience look like for a Spock? I imagine it would be a sense of peace, not emotion of a more active sort.
41. When I am going to preach these days, I am looking for a certain peace about a topic or passage. Since I don't preach every Sunday, usually it is a matter of getting a sense of what to preach for a one time event. But I look in a number of directions.
Sometimes I look at the lectionary. [2] What are the passages that a very large number of preachers in the world are preaching about? There is nothing unspiritual about the lectionary, not at all. It guarantees that a congregation will hear from all of Scripture over time.
Sometimes I look at current events or the American calendar. There are two extremes here. First there is the church that cannot tell the difference between its patriotism and its Christianity. This is actually blasphemous but God is very patient with our ignorance. Then there is the other extreme that won't even mention Father's Day because it's not on the Christian calendar.
I reject both extremes. God can sanctify a pagan day and there's nothing unspiritual about preaching the liturgical calendar. I don't remember much from my worship class with Dr. Foutz at Central (maybe I didn't even have one?). I remember thinking that Don Boyd had gone too rigidly in the other way in seminary. Is the word of God reaching the congregation? Is God being glorified and worshiped? OK, we're good.
When we were looking to hire a worship professor at Wesley Seminary, one of my strong desires was that we not hire someone who had a rigid sense of how worship must always be done. There are many who think worship services must only be done one particular way and that all other ways are wrong. It's hard to look at the history of the whole church, especially the growing church in the southern hemisphere, and not conclude that God is far more flexible than some let on in this area.
So I now think/pray through a host of avenues like these until I have a good feeling about something, and that's what I preach. I figure God will tap me on the shoulder and redirect if I get it wrong. Could it be, though, in keeping with something I said earlier, that there are any number of different sermons that God would be happy for you could preach on a given occasion? I suspect so.
42. This might be a good place to mention a couple other trips I remember taking during my Central years. One was to the Washington DC area. It was in a Central van so we must have been singing or perhaps I was preaching. The stop lights didn't hang overhead in the capitol area and the driver of our van inadvertently ran a stop light and got stopped by the police. Not a pleasant moment.
My first visit ever to Marion, Indiana was for one of those college visit days to HQ in the spring of 1987. Headquarters was still in Marion. IWU was still Marion College. [3] We stayed in the now demolished Holiday Inn. At that point I believe Marion still had a Ponderosa and an Olive Garden by the mall. Harmon still ran in front of Noggle and the old student center was still across the street.
[1] As I've mentioned, my mother got a Bachelor of Divinity from Frankfort Pilgrim College in the 1940s. One of the courses she had to take was a preaching class. (Yes, that was completely normal in the holiness movement, for women to preach. In fact, in the 1940s, there was a higher percentage of female ministers in the Pilgrim church than there are in the Wesleyan Church today.)
One of the assignments they had to do was extemporaneous preaching. They drew a Scripture from a hat (or some such) and then had 5 minutes to come up with a sermon. I'm not sure what the value of the exercise was, but it certainly fits with the ethos of preaching I grew up with.
[2] The lectionary is a sequence of Scripture readings that, over the course of three years, goes through almost all of the Bible. One of the greatest values of the lectionary is that it takes a congregation through the whole counsel of God. I think we would find that, among those who think they pray down their sermons every week, there is a tendency to preach the same sermon over and over again from different passages. My dad used to write in the margin of his KJV the name of the preacher and date of a sermon.
[3] Indiana Wesleyan has long since earned its status as a university, but I will say we didn't entirely take the name change seriously when it first happened in 1988.
____________
38. My second year at Central (1985-86) was my first year studying for ministry, and one of the highlights was going on weekend ministry teams. Most of them seemed to be in North Carolina, but we also visited Kentucky, Georgia, and Florida. On a number of these trips, I was able to preach. It was great experience.
I don't know whose idea it was, but a lot of the trips were in a quartet, with me singing bass, Rodney Clark singing tenor, Laura (then) Strickland singing alto, and Jan (then) Fisher singing the lead. For some of the weekends, Stacey (then) Bodenhorn played the piano.
One of the most memorable trips was to Hudson Wesleyan Church in Florida, with Elmer Drury driving the van. Elmer was Keith Drury's older brother and he would die suddenly of a heart attack the next year. At that time, Elmer was doing the advancement and alumni work for the college, I believe. I don't remember much from the trip except that it was a highlight of the year.
39. In those days, I believed I needed to "pray down" each sermon. In my pre-ministerial training, the culture was that God revealed each sermon to you a little like God talking to Moses. You go up to the mountain and come back down with the sermon God had revealed to you for that week.
When I learned about the idea of planning out a series of sermons in advance, I engaged one of my earlier mentors. The immediate reaction was to think of this sort of approach to preaching as a very human one. It seemed to them to take the spiritual dimension of preaching away and change preaching into a matter of human thinking and planning.
By the way, we often would say growing up that a service was particularly visited by the Spirit if the pastor didn't get to preach because someone got blessed. Let's just say that the picture of God I grew up with was that of a very spontaneous God who showed himself most when he interrupted things. He sure didn't seem to plan ahead much, or at least he wanted to keep everyone on their toes. [1]
Back to my mentor. I responded to them, "Can't God see six months ahead to tell you what to preach earlier than the very week of the sermon?" The person thought for a second and then said, "In my experience God doesn't work that way."
I truly wanted to pray down every sermon, but let's just say that I often found myself Saturday the day before preaching without a clear sense of lightning. At the time I blamed myself for not praying harder in the week. No doubt I should have, but I don't think that was the main problem.
40. I just don't think that every believer gets "zapped" as often as every other believer. There are people who hear the Holy Spirit all the time. I envy them. Then there are people who think they get zapped all the time but really don't. They're just eating too much bacon.
But I was once encouraged when it dawned on me that Moses didn't really hear from God until he was eighty years old. I have a few benchmarks in my spiritual walk that I have mentioned. I would not be the only one to suggest that you keep track of those spiritual encounters so that you can look back at them when you enter a period of silence or perhaps have what some have called the "dark night of the soul."
When I was in England, I read the book Honest to God by John A. T. Robertson. I don't remember much of what was in the book except mainly that it went too far. But I did resonate with an experience he shared at the beginning of the book. He was talking about how, in theological college, everyone was having emotional experiences of God and he wasn't. The comment was striking to me. I wonder if one of the dangers of experientially-oriented traditions is to set up expectations that simply do not apply to everyone.
There are no doubt people who grow up in Pentecostal homes today who undergo some of my own pilgrimage. You are raised with a story that leads you to believe that you should be having these repeated and regular highly emotional encounters with God. And you pray for them, and you look at your navel in constant introspection wondering what's wrong with you.
I remember a young man when I was a boy who seemed to go to the altar at my home church in Florida every Sunday night. He never seemed to leave feeling like he had victory. Now it could have been that he simply wouldn't surrender everything to God. I do wonder, though, if he had the wrong expectations.
What would Christian experience look like for a Spock? I imagine it would be a sense of peace, not emotion of a more active sort.
41. When I am going to preach these days, I am looking for a certain peace about a topic or passage. Since I don't preach every Sunday, usually it is a matter of getting a sense of what to preach for a one time event. But I look in a number of directions.
Sometimes I look at the lectionary. [2] What are the passages that a very large number of preachers in the world are preaching about? There is nothing unspiritual about the lectionary, not at all. It guarantees that a congregation will hear from all of Scripture over time.
Sometimes I look at current events or the American calendar. There are two extremes here. First there is the church that cannot tell the difference between its patriotism and its Christianity. This is actually blasphemous but God is very patient with our ignorance. Then there is the other extreme that won't even mention Father's Day because it's not on the Christian calendar.
I reject both extremes. God can sanctify a pagan day and there's nothing unspiritual about preaching the liturgical calendar. I don't remember much from my worship class with Dr. Foutz at Central (maybe I didn't even have one?). I remember thinking that Don Boyd had gone too rigidly in the other way in seminary. Is the word of God reaching the congregation? Is God being glorified and worshiped? OK, we're good.
When we were looking to hire a worship professor at Wesley Seminary, one of my strong desires was that we not hire someone who had a rigid sense of how worship must always be done. There are many who think worship services must only be done one particular way and that all other ways are wrong. It's hard to look at the history of the whole church, especially the growing church in the southern hemisphere, and not conclude that God is far more flexible than some let on in this area.
So I now think/pray through a host of avenues like these until I have a good feeling about something, and that's what I preach. I figure God will tap me on the shoulder and redirect if I get it wrong. Could it be, though, in keeping with something I said earlier, that there are any number of different sermons that God would be happy for you could preach on a given occasion? I suspect so.
42. This might be a good place to mention a couple other trips I remember taking during my Central years. One was to the Washington DC area. It was in a Central van so we must have been singing or perhaps I was preaching. The stop lights didn't hang overhead in the capitol area and the driver of our van inadvertently ran a stop light and got stopped by the police. Not a pleasant moment.
My first visit ever to Marion, Indiana was for one of those college visit days to HQ in the spring of 1987. Headquarters was still in Marion. IWU was still Marion College. [3] We stayed in the now demolished Holiday Inn. At that point I believe Marion still had a Ponderosa and an Olive Garden by the mall. Harmon still ran in front of Noggle and the old student center was still across the street.
[1] As I've mentioned, my mother got a Bachelor of Divinity from Frankfort Pilgrim College in the 1940s. One of the courses she had to take was a preaching class. (Yes, that was completely normal in the holiness movement, for women to preach. In fact, in the 1940s, there was a higher percentage of female ministers in the Pilgrim church than there are in the Wesleyan Church today.)
One of the assignments they had to do was extemporaneous preaching. They drew a Scripture from a hat (or some such) and then had 5 minutes to come up with a sermon. I'm not sure what the value of the exercise was, but it certainly fits with the ethos of preaching I grew up with.
[2] The lectionary is a sequence of Scripture readings that, over the course of three years, goes through almost all of the Bible. One of the greatest values of the lectionary is that it takes a congregation through the whole counsel of God. I think we would find that, among those who think they pray down their sermons every week, there is a tendency to preach the same sermon over and over again from different passages. My dad used to write in the margin of his KJV the name of the preacher and date of a sermon.
[3] Indiana Wesleyan has long since earned its status as a university, but I will say we didn't entirely take the name change seriously when it first happened in 1988.
Saturday, January 04, 2020
Adventures in Epistemology 8
previous post
_______________
29 cont.
You sometimes hear a lot of rhetoric about truth. But it is not really about truth but about tribe. The most likely thing to be truth is what has the most evidence in its favor in the simplest way without being too simple. I'll talk later about Barth, Reformed epistemology, and post-liberalism as a conflicting point of view.
In philosophy class, I would put several dots on the whiteboard. I would point out that there was an infinite number of ways to connect the dots.
Sure, many other pictures will always be possible. As I began to study the Bible formally, my scientific way of thinking stayed with me. And by scientific thinking I mean real world thinking. I mean life thinking. If you are looking for your keys, you go to the places you remember going recently. You probably don't walk to the next state on the hypothesis that you took a trip you don't remember taking, got amnesia, then hitchhiked home.
To be frank, a lot of people think in the crazy way. If you ever hear me say that an idea is "ingenious," maybe I mean it is really ingenious. Or I may mean it is preposterous but very clever indeed.
Over the next few years, I would increasingly come to the conclusion that the interpretations of a fundamentalist view of the Bible repeatedly involved "cooking the books" and special pleading. You might remember that I earlier considered myself detail-challenged but a savant at the big picture. It was this ability to see the big picture that repeatedly looked at arguments like Lindsell's and concluded that something wasn't quite right here. More to come.
30. The Devil is of course in the details. When forming my own hypotheses, I have had to learn to pay great attention to details. In Myers-Briggs terminology, I am a massive N, an intuitive. [1] People like me see connections. We see the big picture. We see the forest better than detailed people, who tend to focus on all the individual unique pieces of moss on every tree but may not be able to find their way to the road. [2]
Often when I start writing a paper, I see a possible pattern--patterns are the stuff of an N. But then as I learn the details, I realize the pattern has to be adjusted. Once I have all the details firmly in mind and have discerned a pattern, I usually have a compelling result. There is something exhilarating about this because concrete details are my "inferior function." Your inferior function is the letter opposite your greatest strength, in my case the S or "sensing" orientation. [3]
So I have learned to collect and wait for details. A theory is only as good as its ability to account for the details. The discernment of a pattern is a creative act. It is a birthing. It takes a threshold of mental energy. It is thus a cause of procrastination.
I am usually pleased with what is birthed, but the process can be tiring.
31. One of the most exciting set of ideas I encountered at Central was in my senior year in an interdisciplinary seminar with Dr. Martin LaBar. He introduced us to the ideas of Thomas Kuhn and his book The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. The phrase "paradigm shift" was pretty common at that time.
Kuhn argued, as it were, that we are predisposed to look at a particular subject matter in a certain way. [4] There are default paradigms that are the frameworks we assume when thinking about or talking about something. This applies to the Bible. It applies to what you do with your house. It applies to how you go about eating, how you roll the toilet paper or squeeze toothpaste. We are very often not aware of these prevailing paradigms.
At one point of the class, Dr. LaBar had us go to the window. He asked us what we saw. We saw cars in the parking lot. We saw trees and sky. Then a clever person said, "I see a window."
That was what he was going for. The prevailing paradigm of windows is that we look out of them. So most of us assumed his question was asking about the things outside the window. We were not predisposed to see the window itself.
32. This is an incredibly helpful tool of analysis. Growing up, I did not realize there was such at thing as a Wesleyan paradigm. I didn't realize that someone could read certain verses in a completely different way. In my teaching, I used to say that it is no surprise that a Wesleyan brings a "Wesleyan dictionary" to the Bible and concludes that it obviously teaches Wesleyan things while a Baptist comes to the Bible with a "Baptist dictionary" and concludes it obviously teaches Baptist things and so forth.
One of the most critical questions of today goes beyond whether the Bible has authority to the question of who decides what the Bible means. I self-published a book on this question once upon a time. As I think Joel Green once said, a Jehovah's Witness believes the Bible is inerrant, but their interpretations are quite strange. I am convinced that many of those involved in the Bible wars of the past were more fighting over a tribal flag than truly over the content of God's word.
There are all sorts of issues where a cross-section of people feel incredibly strongly about some issue and yet they have no idea that they are wearing a certain pair of glasses. When I had students write a position paper for New Testament Survey, I would warn them to be sure and write a paper 1) that was about the New Testament and 2) engaged a topic about which the New Testament spoke extensively. In their unreflective, "pre-modern" paradigms, there was a tendency to confuse certain legitimate Christian perspectives they had with New Testament perspectives.
For example, I cannot think of any verses in the New Testament that relate directly to abortion. In other words, there is no direct statement about the issue in the Bible. Christian perspectives on abortion involve theological discussions about life that expand upon basic principles and bear indirectly on this subject. Richard Hays, in The Moral Vision of the New Testament, has a chapter on abortion and ends up with the position that abortion does not fit well at all with biblical biases and values. However, he is a master scholar well beyond any freshman or sophomore student I've ever met. He argues for this position from the Bible indirectly.
33. Our paradigms make things seem obvious to us that are more us than there. There was a turning point in college in my feelings on holiness standards. The verses are there for some of these standards. Ironically, the New Testament is much clearer on the topic of jewelry than it is on abortion. Take 1 Peter 3:3--"Do not let the outward adornment [of a wife] be the braiding of hairs or the wearing of gold [jewelry] or the putting on of garments." Similarly there is 1 Timothy 2:9 which says a wife should not adorn herself with "braids and gold or pearls or costly garments."
So I in my first two years of college I struggled with whether I should marry someone who wore earrings (and thus whether I should date someone who wore jewelry). There were other key verses from my holiness background. Deuteronomy 22:5 forbade an Israelite woman from wearing that which pertains to a man. In my circles, this verse was used to argue that women should only wear skirts, not pants or slacks. [5] Then of course 1 Corinthians 11 was used to say that women should have long hair and men short hair.
When I wrote my commentary on 1 and 2 Corinthians, I concluded that Paul was primarily talking about the veiling of a woman's hair in 1 Corinthians 11. A hair veil (not a face veil) functioned a little like a wedding ring, as well as providing modesty. A house church was an intriguing social situation. You had men and women who weren't married to each other in close quarters. And you had women praying and prophesying in the worship.
I believe this created an awkward social situation, indeed, an awkward sexual situation. By wearing a hair veil they might normally have worn in public situations, this situation was brought under control. The woman "had authority" on her head that said, "I'm married and in proper relation to my husband" even though she was in the presence of other men, not least the putative males, angels and God.
The reason this passage is so difficult to interpret--and scholars are divided over its meaning too--is because it comes from a different world that had quite different paradigms from ours. The Bible was not written in universal paradigms because they hardly exist. When God spoke in the Bible, he spoke to real people. And if God was to be understood, he would need to speak in their paradigms.
34. Revelation must be incarnational if it is to be understood. It seems to me that a lot of people act like revelation is all about God saying great things on his terms with no interest in being understood by anyone. At least that is the consequence of their sense of revelation.
Actually, they think they understand. But the implication of their approach, what they are really implying, is that God revealed himself in their paradigms. The implication that they don't realize is that they are implying no one else in history, including the original audiences, has really understood the texts until them. This is especially true of those who think Revelation is finally about the current events of today, as if no one in all of history has understood what the book was really about.
In other words, what they are really saying when they say, "The Bible was revealed for all time" is "The Bible was revealed for me in my paradigms and not directly to everyone else in history."
There is a simple and undeniable syllogism here:
I debated this question when I was getting ready to test out of New Testament Survey. I borrowed my sister Debbie's copy of Merrill Tenney's New Testament Survey (which she used at Marion College). Tenney was talking about the historical context of 1 Thessalonians, including where it was geographically located and so forth.
I asked myself, would God have let anything into the Bible that didn't apply to all times and all places? For example, if Paul's instructions about hair were just for "that time" and not for "all time," would God have put 1 Corinthians in the Bible in this form?
Now of course I have shifted focus. Every single word of the Bible was for them. After all, it repeatedly addresses them. It is for us as Scripture but it was to them. The Bible itself models what for now I will call the re-appropriation of basic principles into new contexts. Even this statement is a little too Platonic for me but I will go with it for now.
Changes between the Old and New Testaments are not simply a matter of old covenant/new covenant. Underlying some of the old covenant/new covenant transition is a change of context from the Ancient Near East to the Mediterranean world. There are paradigm shifts lurking here (e.g., with regard to food laws).
In the end, the instructions of Scripture made sense within their contexts. As I argue in my New Testament Survey, "Doing what they did isn't doing what they did" if it doesn't have the same meaning and implications in our context. If a woman wore a veil today, it simply would not "do" or accomplish what Paul was trying to accomplish with his instructions to the Corinthians. It just wouldn't mean the same thing. Its specifics were a "that time" instruction.
I sometimes the example of greeting the brothers with a holy kiss in 1 Thessalonians 5:26. Doing that today in most churches certainly wouldn't mean now what it mean then. A holy handshake will probably do.
35. If I might synthesize Kuhn with a little Michel Foucault, paradigms focus on certain data and minimize other data. Meaning in a paradigm is a little like a word cloud. Certain things stand out large and others are small. We do not realize that it is our glasses that make them appear different sizes.
So in the holiness paradigm, earrings appear large in the word cloud of meaning. You notice them. Keith Drury has told me of a visit he made to a district conference where he perceived his wedding ring was completely distracting from his message. The eyes of the congregation followed the ring like people at a tennis match.
He finally stopped and said, "Is this a problem?" and took the ring off. He told me there was an audible sigh of relief and he had great rapport with the group from that point on in the message.
When I got married, my wife and I had wedding rings. To be honest, I found the ring annoying on my finger. For a long time I found myself fiddling with it. But I guarantee you there was zero pride involved with it. To me, it says that I am committed to a wife. I am not available. Not to wear a wedding ring could actually be an immoral act if one was trying to pretend not to be married.
Soon after I was married someone asked if they could look at my wedding ring (it has an inscription on the inside). They then proceeded to pretend like they were showing it off in a proud way, "Look at me!" The disconnect between how I viewed the ring and the way that, in their paradigm and word cloud, it surely must function could not have been more different.
This was the moment of paradigm shift for me in college. I realized that earrings and such were no different to the girls at Central than me combing my hair. [6] One moment in the library a certain girl with earrings broke the old paradigm. It rushed in on me that her wearing them had nothing whatsoever to do with ungodly pride.
I had prayed with Judy Huffman for God to show me if my sense of standards was wrong. He did. He showed me that I had those issues completely out of focus. The beginnings of a paradigm shift were in motion. [7]
36. Paradigms inevitably select certain data as significant and other data as insignificant. Then they usually ignore other data. The recent impeachment hearings would be fascinating to analyze in this light but of course I won't.
I was speaking to someone about the situation, trying to be conciliatory. The person felt that the other side (I won't say which) made up stuff. Certainly that could be true. But I suggested a more charitable scenario.
What if, I suggested, there are facts one through ten? What if side 1 is focusing on facts 3, 4, and 5 while side 2 is focusing on facts 6, 7, and 8? This is how paradigms work. One paradigm focuses on one set of data and has them large in the word cloud of meaning. The other focuses on other data and emphasizes them.
Of course interpretation is much more about the scaffolding we put alongside these "facts" than it is about the facts themselves. Nietzsche once said, "There are no facts, only interpretations." I don't fully agree, but there is some truth to his sentiment. I would rather go with what is called critical realism. Facts exist, but our apprehension of them will always be skewed somewhat.
I had James Bross for philosophy my senior year at Central. One of the concepts that stood out from the textbook he used was the notion of an "egocentric predicament." We are, as it were, stuck in our heads. I cannot get into your head and you cannot get into mine. The only hope is to input you as best I can into my computer.
Although I did not really understand Kant at the time, I find his epistemological framework helpful. [8] The content of our thinking comes through our senses. But the shape that content takes is a function of our minds. Post-Kuhn I would say a function of our paradigms. Our senses give us the content of the paper we are writing. Our minds (paradigms) are the Microsoft Word software that gives us a framework into which to put that content.
It is the same with understanding the Bible, by the way. The Bible provides the content but it is our paradigms that give shape to the content of the Bible (e.g., Wesleyan, evangelical, catholic, scholarly). The Bible does not come inputted already onto our hard drive. We have to input it, which means we have to interpret it. Our software puts the content of the Bible into the word cloud of our paradigms.
Any argument will do in an echo chamber. When you look at the Republicans and Democrats today, it often doesn't seem to matter what the whole data is. Republicans will select certain data and ignore others and the same with the Democrats. In the Democratic paradigm, Trump is a liar and a schemer, a selfish narcissist who will do anything to exalt himself and win over everyone else. In the dominant evangelical paradigm, Trump is a hero who is finally doing something about abortion and appointing judges who will eventually stop abortion. He is the man of the hour, God's man, perhaps even a godly man, whom God has appointed to restore America as a Christian nation.
These two paradigms are so starkly different that both sides almost have to make the other into evil fiends. For me as a philosopher, it is a source of despair.
But it is perfectly understandable. It fits everything I have come to believe about human epistemology. Humans are herd animals. We are tribal. We do not see the world as it is, what Kant called das Ding an sich. We see the world as it appears to us. We see the world through paradigms darkly.
37. Paradigms shift when anomalous data grabs the attention of someone and they are able to turn the tide of knowers toward a different way of evaluating the data in the word cloud. This often has a good deal to do with sociology. Indeed, Kuhn's hypothesis (which he pulled from back a little in the second edition) was that science wasn't about truth at all, that it was just an endless series of shifts.
I don't believe that myself. Kuhn was part of the postmodern shift. It's not just secular thinkers who built on this non-realism. The Christian community has also capitalized on a cultural situation where truth is what you believe without the possibility of falsification.
I call anomalous data, "naughty data," data that doesn't fit into your current paradigm. It could be verses of the Bible that don't fit your theology. These annoying outlying bits of data can sow the seeds of shifts.
My senior year of college one of the professor's daughters returned to college after a spiritual breakthrough. She had short hair, wore earrings. In short, she did not look like a holiness person in the slightest.
But she had such joy in the Lord! There was no question that she was fully sold out to God. She was so spiritually minded. It was another key bit of naughty data. This person had the fruit of the Spirit. This person demonstrated the sanctifying work of God in her life. But she didn't look anything like my holiness word cloud. Easter was coming...
[1] By the way, of all the things I learned in seminary, one of the most useful was the fact that people are different and that we all have different strengths and weaknesses. Myers-Briggs taught me that better than anything else, my first semester at seminary. Simple truth whose implications are often missed.
[2] At this point, a detail savant might respond, "Of course I know where the road is. You pass this maple tree with a very interesting third branch, then this pine tree with a burn spot about four feet up... then you reach the road. But this is not what I am saying. I am speaking of seeing the road in broad relation to everything else. They might not see the territory, only the map.
This is a problem in academic communities. We have bred academics to evolve into hyper-detailed, siloed scholars and have put detailed administrator personalities into leadership. They see the details of their disciplines oh so well--or the details of the institution or their part of the institution--so much better than others. They are so good at their thin slice of the pie that it is hard for them to believe that they are not right about everything.
[3] A sensing person does not tend to think abstractly but concretely. They see what is in front of them. By contrast, as I have sometimes remarked to my wife, "I've lived most of my life inside my head." There is a scene in Watership Down where the rabbit who understands symbols and metaphor is mocked and viewed with great suspicion by the concrete bunnies, but they simply cannot see what he sees. For a lighter example, see Drax in Guardians of the Galaxy.
[4] Kuhn was of course talking about science, but I will broaden the application.
[5] This was the issue I spoke with Dr. Dongell about where he pointed out that men and women both looked very similar in ancient times because the men wore robes that would look to us like dresses. It is now interesting to see this verse re-emerging in the transgender discussion.
[6] I started to say me wearing a tie, but there have been holiness people in the past who felt men shouldn't wear ties.
[7] Someone told me that if I changed on one of the holiness standards, I would change on all of them. The person said they had never seen it not be so. I denied it at the time but there was a great deal of truth to it. However, the change was not a matter of slippery-slope, as it was being framed. It was a matter of paradigm shift.
[8] I met with my high school friend Paul Herman a couple summers after graduation. He threw out Kant to me. I responded with Aquinas. But he was right. Philosophy cannot go back before Kant. Anything before Kant is just that much more unreflective, and we have become even more reflective since Kant.
_______________
29 cont.
You sometimes hear a lot of rhetoric about truth. But it is not really about truth but about tribe. The most likely thing to be truth is what has the most evidence in its favor in the simplest way without being too simple. I'll talk later about Barth, Reformed epistemology, and post-liberalism as a conflicting point of view.
In philosophy class, I would put several dots on the whiteboard. I would point out that there was an infinite number of ways to connect the dots.
- Sometimes you don't have enough dots to come up with any likely image at all.
- Some drawings capture some of the dots but not all of them.
- A person might draw a picture that requires more dots outside the ones you have than around the ones you do have.
- Some drawings have contours completely unexpected by the dots you have--like twists and turns that the dots you have don't anticipate.
Sure, many other pictures will always be possible. As I began to study the Bible formally, my scientific way of thinking stayed with me. And by scientific thinking I mean real world thinking. I mean life thinking. If you are looking for your keys, you go to the places you remember going recently. You probably don't walk to the next state on the hypothesis that you took a trip you don't remember taking, got amnesia, then hitchhiked home.
To be frank, a lot of people think in the crazy way. If you ever hear me say that an idea is "ingenious," maybe I mean it is really ingenious. Or I may mean it is preposterous but very clever indeed.
Over the next few years, I would increasingly come to the conclusion that the interpretations of a fundamentalist view of the Bible repeatedly involved "cooking the books" and special pleading. You might remember that I earlier considered myself detail-challenged but a savant at the big picture. It was this ability to see the big picture that repeatedly looked at arguments like Lindsell's and concluded that something wasn't quite right here. More to come.
30. The Devil is of course in the details. When forming my own hypotheses, I have had to learn to pay great attention to details. In Myers-Briggs terminology, I am a massive N, an intuitive. [1] People like me see connections. We see the big picture. We see the forest better than detailed people, who tend to focus on all the individual unique pieces of moss on every tree but may not be able to find their way to the road. [2]
Often when I start writing a paper, I see a possible pattern--patterns are the stuff of an N. But then as I learn the details, I realize the pattern has to be adjusted. Once I have all the details firmly in mind and have discerned a pattern, I usually have a compelling result. There is something exhilarating about this because concrete details are my "inferior function." Your inferior function is the letter opposite your greatest strength, in my case the S or "sensing" orientation. [3]
So I have learned to collect and wait for details. A theory is only as good as its ability to account for the details. The discernment of a pattern is a creative act. It is a birthing. It takes a threshold of mental energy. It is thus a cause of procrastination.
I am usually pleased with what is birthed, but the process can be tiring.
31. One of the most exciting set of ideas I encountered at Central was in my senior year in an interdisciplinary seminar with Dr. Martin LaBar. He introduced us to the ideas of Thomas Kuhn and his book The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. The phrase "paradigm shift" was pretty common at that time.
Kuhn argued, as it were, that we are predisposed to look at a particular subject matter in a certain way. [4] There are default paradigms that are the frameworks we assume when thinking about or talking about something. This applies to the Bible. It applies to what you do with your house. It applies to how you go about eating, how you roll the toilet paper or squeeze toothpaste. We are very often not aware of these prevailing paradigms.
At one point of the class, Dr. LaBar had us go to the window. He asked us what we saw. We saw cars in the parking lot. We saw trees and sky. Then a clever person said, "I see a window."
That was what he was going for. The prevailing paradigm of windows is that we look out of them. So most of us assumed his question was asking about the things outside the window. We were not predisposed to see the window itself.
32. This is an incredibly helpful tool of analysis. Growing up, I did not realize there was such at thing as a Wesleyan paradigm. I didn't realize that someone could read certain verses in a completely different way. In my teaching, I used to say that it is no surprise that a Wesleyan brings a "Wesleyan dictionary" to the Bible and concludes that it obviously teaches Wesleyan things while a Baptist comes to the Bible with a "Baptist dictionary" and concludes it obviously teaches Baptist things and so forth.
One of the most critical questions of today goes beyond whether the Bible has authority to the question of who decides what the Bible means. I self-published a book on this question once upon a time. As I think Joel Green once said, a Jehovah's Witness believes the Bible is inerrant, but their interpretations are quite strange. I am convinced that many of those involved in the Bible wars of the past were more fighting over a tribal flag than truly over the content of God's word.
There are all sorts of issues where a cross-section of people feel incredibly strongly about some issue and yet they have no idea that they are wearing a certain pair of glasses. When I had students write a position paper for New Testament Survey, I would warn them to be sure and write a paper 1) that was about the New Testament and 2) engaged a topic about which the New Testament spoke extensively. In their unreflective, "pre-modern" paradigms, there was a tendency to confuse certain legitimate Christian perspectives they had with New Testament perspectives.
For example, I cannot think of any verses in the New Testament that relate directly to abortion. In other words, there is no direct statement about the issue in the Bible. Christian perspectives on abortion involve theological discussions about life that expand upon basic principles and bear indirectly on this subject. Richard Hays, in The Moral Vision of the New Testament, has a chapter on abortion and ends up with the position that abortion does not fit well at all with biblical biases and values. However, he is a master scholar well beyond any freshman or sophomore student I've ever met. He argues for this position from the Bible indirectly.
33. Our paradigms make things seem obvious to us that are more us than there. There was a turning point in college in my feelings on holiness standards. The verses are there for some of these standards. Ironically, the New Testament is much clearer on the topic of jewelry than it is on abortion. Take 1 Peter 3:3--"Do not let the outward adornment [of a wife] be the braiding of hairs or the wearing of gold [jewelry] or the putting on of garments." Similarly there is 1 Timothy 2:9 which says a wife should not adorn herself with "braids and gold or pearls or costly garments."
So I in my first two years of college I struggled with whether I should marry someone who wore earrings (and thus whether I should date someone who wore jewelry). There were other key verses from my holiness background. Deuteronomy 22:5 forbade an Israelite woman from wearing that which pertains to a man. In my circles, this verse was used to argue that women should only wear skirts, not pants or slacks. [5] Then of course 1 Corinthians 11 was used to say that women should have long hair and men short hair.
When I wrote my commentary on 1 and 2 Corinthians, I concluded that Paul was primarily talking about the veiling of a woman's hair in 1 Corinthians 11. A hair veil (not a face veil) functioned a little like a wedding ring, as well as providing modesty. A house church was an intriguing social situation. You had men and women who weren't married to each other in close quarters. And you had women praying and prophesying in the worship.
I believe this created an awkward social situation, indeed, an awkward sexual situation. By wearing a hair veil they might normally have worn in public situations, this situation was brought under control. The woman "had authority" on her head that said, "I'm married and in proper relation to my husband" even though she was in the presence of other men, not least the putative males, angels and God.
The reason this passage is so difficult to interpret--and scholars are divided over its meaning too--is because it comes from a different world that had quite different paradigms from ours. The Bible was not written in universal paradigms because they hardly exist. When God spoke in the Bible, he spoke to real people. And if God was to be understood, he would need to speak in their paradigms.
34. Revelation must be incarnational if it is to be understood. It seems to me that a lot of people act like revelation is all about God saying great things on his terms with no interest in being understood by anyone. At least that is the consequence of their sense of revelation.
Actually, they think they understand. But the implication of their approach, what they are really implying, is that God revealed himself in their paradigms. The implication that they don't realize is that they are implying no one else in history, including the original audiences, has really understood the texts until them. This is especially true of those who think Revelation is finally about the current events of today, as if no one in all of history has understood what the book was really about.
In other words, what they are really saying when they say, "The Bible was revealed for all time" is "The Bible was revealed for me in my paradigms and not directly to everyone else in history."
There is a simple and undeniable syllogism here:
- The Bible was initially addressed to specific audiences like Israelites, Romans, etc.
- God wanted them to understand the content revealed.
- They thought and understood things within certain paradigms.
- Their paradigms are quite often not our paradigms.
- Therefore, if we want to understand the original meaning of the Bible (aka, its actual meaning), we will have to do some cross-paradigm work.
I debated this question when I was getting ready to test out of New Testament Survey. I borrowed my sister Debbie's copy of Merrill Tenney's New Testament Survey (which she used at Marion College). Tenney was talking about the historical context of 1 Thessalonians, including where it was geographically located and so forth.
I asked myself, would God have let anything into the Bible that didn't apply to all times and all places? For example, if Paul's instructions about hair were just for "that time" and not for "all time," would God have put 1 Corinthians in the Bible in this form?
Now of course I have shifted focus. Every single word of the Bible was for them. After all, it repeatedly addresses them. It is for us as Scripture but it was to them. The Bible itself models what for now I will call the re-appropriation of basic principles into new contexts. Even this statement is a little too Platonic for me but I will go with it for now.
Changes between the Old and New Testaments are not simply a matter of old covenant/new covenant. Underlying some of the old covenant/new covenant transition is a change of context from the Ancient Near East to the Mediterranean world. There are paradigm shifts lurking here (e.g., with regard to food laws).
In the end, the instructions of Scripture made sense within their contexts. As I argue in my New Testament Survey, "Doing what they did isn't doing what they did" if it doesn't have the same meaning and implications in our context. If a woman wore a veil today, it simply would not "do" or accomplish what Paul was trying to accomplish with his instructions to the Corinthians. It just wouldn't mean the same thing. Its specifics were a "that time" instruction.
I sometimes the example of greeting the brothers with a holy kiss in 1 Thessalonians 5:26. Doing that today in most churches certainly wouldn't mean now what it mean then. A holy handshake will probably do.
35. If I might synthesize Kuhn with a little Michel Foucault, paradigms focus on certain data and minimize other data. Meaning in a paradigm is a little like a word cloud. Certain things stand out large and others are small. We do not realize that it is our glasses that make them appear different sizes.
So in the holiness paradigm, earrings appear large in the word cloud of meaning. You notice them. Keith Drury has told me of a visit he made to a district conference where he perceived his wedding ring was completely distracting from his message. The eyes of the congregation followed the ring like people at a tennis match.
He finally stopped and said, "Is this a problem?" and took the ring off. He told me there was an audible sigh of relief and he had great rapport with the group from that point on in the message.
When I got married, my wife and I had wedding rings. To be honest, I found the ring annoying on my finger. For a long time I found myself fiddling with it. But I guarantee you there was zero pride involved with it. To me, it says that I am committed to a wife. I am not available. Not to wear a wedding ring could actually be an immoral act if one was trying to pretend not to be married.
Soon after I was married someone asked if they could look at my wedding ring (it has an inscription on the inside). They then proceeded to pretend like they were showing it off in a proud way, "Look at me!" The disconnect between how I viewed the ring and the way that, in their paradigm and word cloud, it surely must function could not have been more different.
This was the moment of paradigm shift for me in college. I realized that earrings and such were no different to the girls at Central than me combing my hair. [6] One moment in the library a certain girl with earrings broke the old paradigm. It rushed in on me that her wearing them had nothing whatsoever to do with ungodly pride.
I had prayed with Judy Huffman for God to show me if my sense of standards was wrong. He did. He showed me that I had those issues completely out of focus. The beginnings of a paradigm shift were in motion. [7]
36. Paradigms inevitably select certain data as significant and other data as insignificant. Then they usually ignore other data. The recent impeachment hearings would be fascinating to analyze in this light but of course I won't.
I was speaking to someone about the situation, trying to be conciliatory. The person felt that the other side (I won't say which) made up stuff. Certainly that could be true. But I suggested a more charitable scenario.
What if, I suggested, there are facts one through ten? What if side 1 is focusing on facts 3, 4, and 5 while side 2 is focusing on facts 6, 7, and 8? This is how paradigms work. One paradigm focuses on one set of data and has them large in the word cloud of meaning. The other focuses on other data and emphasizes them.
Of course interpretation is much more about the scaffolding we put alongside these "facts" than it is about the facts themselves. Nietzsche once said, "There are no facts, only interpretations." I don't fully agree, but there is some truth to his sentiment. I would rather go with what is called critical realism. Facts exist, but our apprehension of them will always be skewed somewhat.
I had James Bross for philosophy my senior year at Central. One of the concepts that stood out from the textbook he used was the notion of an "egocentric predicament." We are, as it were, stuck in our heads. I cannot get into your head and you cannot get into mine. The only hope is to input you as best I can into my computer.
Although I did not really understand Kant at the time, I find his epistemological framework helpful. [8] The content of our thinking comes through our senses. But the shape that content takes is a function of our minds. Post-Kuhn I would say a function of our paradigms. Our senses give us the content of the paper we are writing. Our minds (paradigms) are the Microsoft Word software that gives us a framework into which to put that content.
It is the same with understanding the Bible, by the way. The Bible provides the content but it is our paradigms that give shape to the content of the Bible (e.g., Wesleyan, evangelical, catholic, scholarly). The Bible does not come inputted already onto our hard drive. We have to input it, which means we have to interpret it. Our software puts the content of the Bible into the word cloud of our paradigms.
Any argument will do in an echo chamber. When you look at the Republicans and Democrats today, it often doesn't seem to matter what the whole data is. Republicans will select certain data and ignore others and the same with the Democrats. In the Democratic paradigm, Trump is a liar and a schemer, a selfish narcissist who will do anything to exalt himself and win over everyone else. In the dominant evangelical paradigm, Trump is a hero who is finally doing something about abortion and appointing judges who will eventually stop abortion. He is the man of the hour, God's man, perhaps even a godly man, whom God has appointed to restore America as a Christian nation.
These two paradigms are so starkly different that both sides almost have to make the other into evil fiends. For me as a philosopher, it is a source of despair.
But it is perfectly understandable. It fits everything I have come to believe about human epistemology. Humans are herd animals. We are tribal. We do not see the world as it is, what Kant called das Ding an sich. We see the world as it appears to us. We see the world through paradigms darkly.
37. Paradigms shift when anomalous data grabs the attention of someone and they are able to turn the tide of knowers toward a different way of evaluating the data in the word cloud. This often has a good deal to do with sociology. Indeed, Kuhn's hypothesis (which he pulled from back a little in the second edition) was that science wasn't about truth at all, that it was just an endless series of shifts.
I don't believe that myself. Kuhn was part of the postmodern shift. It's not just secular thinkers who built on this non-realism. The Christian community has also capitalized on a cultural situation where truth is what you believe without the possibility of falsification.
I call anomalous data, "naughty data," data that doesn't fit into your current paradigm. It could be verses of the Bible that don't fit your theology. These annoying outlying bits of data can sow the seeds of shifts.
My senior year of college one of the professor's daughters returned to college after a spiritual breakthrough. She had short hair, wore earrings. In short, she did not look like a holiness person in the slightest.
But she had such joy in the Lord! There was no question that she was fully sold out to God. She was so spiritually minded. It was another key bit of naughty data. This person had the fruit of the Spirit. This person demonstrated the sanctifying work of God in her life. But she didn't look anything like my holiness word cloud. Easter was coming...
[1] By the way, of all the things I learned in seminary, one of the most useful was the fact that people are different and that we all have different strengths and weaknesses. Myers-Briggs taught me that better than anything else, my first semester at seminary. Simple truth whose implications are often missed.
[2] At this point, a detail savant might respond, "Of course I know where the road is. You pass this maple tree with a very interesting third branch, then this pine tree with a burn spot about four feet up... then you reach the road. But this is not what I am saying. I am speaking of seeing the road in broad relation to everything else. They might not see the territory, only the map.
This is a problem in academic communities. We have bred academics to evolve into hyper-detailed, siloed scholars and have put detailed administrator personalities into leadership. They see the details of their disciplines oh so well--or the details of the institution or their part of the institution--so much better than others. They are so good at their thin slice of the pie that it is hard for them to believe that they are not right about everything.
[3] A sensing person does not tend to think abstractly but concretely. They see what is in front of them. By contrast, as I have sometimes remarked to my wife, "I've lived most of my life inside my head." There is a scene in Watership Down where the rabbit who understands symbols and metaphor is mocked and viewed with great suspicion by the concrete bunnies, but they simply cannot see what he sees. For a lighter example, see Drax in Guardians of the Galaxy.
[4] Kuhn was of course talking about science, but I will broaden the application.
[5] This was the issue I spoke with Dr. Dongell about where he pointed out that men and women both looked very similar in ancient times because the men wore robes that would look to us like dresses. It is now interesting to see this verse re-emerging in the transgender discussion.
[6] I started to say me wearing a tie, but there have been holiness people in the past who felt men shouldn't wear ties.
[7] Someone told me that if I changed on one of the holiness standards, I would change on all of them. The person said they had never seen it not be so. I denied it at the time but there was a great deal of truth to it. However, the change was not a matter of slippery-slope, as it was being framed. It was a matter of paradigm shift.
[8] I met with my high school friend Paul Herman a couple summers after graduation. He threw out Kant to me. I responded with Aquinas. But he was right. Philosophy cannot go back before Kant. Anything before Kant is just that much more unreflective, and we have become even more reflective since Kant.
Friday, January 03, 2020
Entire Sanctification 7
previous post
___________________
24. So my mother drove me back to Central for May term while I sported a patch over my scratched eyeball. [1]
I always made the trip to Central from Fort Lauderdale in two stages. First was the drive to Lakeland where my brother-in-law was pastoring. Then the rest of the way. In those torturous days of 55 miles an hour, it took four hours to my sister's and another ten to Central. Only AM radio. Country Georgia stations. Torture.
In that decade of my hyper-conscience without cruise control, I spent almost half the time while I drove watching the analog speedometer. It was not fear of a ticket. It was fear of hell. One should obey the laws of the land and the speed limit is a law of the land. You could make an exception if someone was about to give birth. But under normal circumstances, a Christian should follow the speed limit as part of obeying God.
I used to say that I killed my conscience in seminary. Not really, of course. I mean I began to gain victory over whatever "demon" tortured me all those years to excess. One should of course generally obey the laws of the land. One should give to Caesar what is Caesar's. This is a good witness.
But there is also a huge difference between the law of the land and God's law. Human law is nowhere near as important as God's law, and sometimes human law is stupid. It can be evil. For example, Jim Crow laws were evil. There is a time to practice civil disobedience to work toward good. The Wesleyan Methodist Church was founded on civil disobedience in relation to slavery.
People like me pass laws. A big aha moment in relation to the Wesleyan Discipline was when I realized that people like me voted on the things they put in the Discipline. My dad treated the Discipline almost like it was the Bible. It was certainly law. I did grow up with a great reverence for the "fathers" who created the Discipline.
But people like me created the Discipline. It's very sober. It definitely suggests that the Discipline is a work in progress. The older the material in the Discipline, the weightier its material is (e.g., the Articles of Religion). But if people like me create the Discipline, it is far from inerrant.
25. On my drive to Lakeland after Christmas 1984, I was worried about entire sanctification. I had not yet ticked off that box for certain with trips to the altar. The nineteenth century holiness movement, under the influence of Phoebe Palmer, did not have Wesley's sense that it could take a lifetime to reach perfect love or Christian perfection. At one point Wesley suspected that few would reach it in their lifetimes.
Palmer had promoted a different approach, and it was this approach that had underwritten the holiness revivals of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. I call Palmer's approach "name it claim it entire sanctification." She called it a "shorter way." Her basic question was, "Why should we wait to be entirely sanctified? What if God wants to perfect us now?"
Of course I never heard the name Phoebe Palmer growing up. As far as I knew, we were just reading the Bible and doing what it says. Chris Bounds presented options of sanctification at the 2008 General Conference: shorter, middle, longer. I heard that one General Superintendent remarked he had never heard of Phoebe Palmer, but perhaps he said he had never heard of this delineation.
It is another reminder that a lot of what we call the Bible is really tradition about the Bible. I'm not denying, by the way, that a person can be sanctified early in their Christian walk. In fact, in my college honor's project, I argued that it would ideally happen at the same time as conversion. More on sanctification later. I'm simply pointing out that what we mean by the Bible often isn't really the Bible, but some tribal tradition we confuse with the Bible.
In these days I genuinely once thought to myself, "How amazing it is that I just happened to be born into the church that has everything right. What are the odds?!" The more I could place myself in the flow of history, I began to speak of "the Wesleyan tradition" as one of many historical currents. Once using this language in conversation sparked this response: "Stop saying Wesleyan tradition. We just read the Bible and do what it says." :-)
26. On the drive to Lakeland I had a voice in my head. It could have been the Spirit. It might have been my neurotic self. "If you really were surrendered to God," it said. "if you really put God first, you would not go back to Central until you were entirely sanctified."
I really liked college. I didn't want to stay at home or at my sister's. I wanted to go back to college. I had in mind the sermons I had heard on Jacob wrestling with an angel in Genesis 32. "I will not let you go until you bless me." So if I really was fully surrendered to God, I would refuse to go back to college until God blessed me with entire sanctification.
I wrestled with this idea while I drove. My mother was completely unaware of the inner struggle.
Finally I said OK. "OK, Lord, I will not leave Lakeland until I am entirely sanctified. I will go in the sanctuary when we arrive and not leave until the work is done."
In that moment I felt a great release. I felt a great peace come over me, like the peace I experienced once about salvation on the stairs going to the second floor of our Fort Lauderdale house. When we arrived at Lakeland, I went into the sanctuary and thanked God. He was merciful on me, because there were plenty of other times when I prayed that I didn't find peace.
I want to emphasize this point. During that ten year period I prayed repeatedly for forgiveness looking for peace. I almost never had peace. I am immensely grateful for the peace of that moment.
By the way, I remember now that I had Theology of Holiness with Dongell as well. We used Jessop's Foundations of Doctrine. Another classic.
27. Flash forward to a year and a half later after poking my eye. I was in Marling Elliott's Greek Synoptic Gospels class. I always liked May term classes. You only had to focus on one course. It was easier to focus. The fall was always hardest with multiple courses and the descent into winter darkness and cold. The spring was always much better but still required balancing multiple courses. May was warm, beautiful, and focused.
I think it might have been in that class that I was first exposed to how Matthew 2:15 quotes Hosea 11:1. Elliott pointed out that Matthew sees the quote in relation to Jesus leaving Egypt. But that's not what Hosea 11 was about. Hosea 11:1 is about the exodus. So Hosea was not a prediction about Jesus. It reads, "When Israel was a child, I called my son out of Egypt, but the more I called them the more they served other gods." Was Matthew mistaken in saying this verse was fulfilled in the life of Jesus?
More on that question when I get to seminary. In college, I just smiled and thought to myself. "Interesting. I'll figure it out." There were some pages in the back of my Thompson Chain Reference Bible that showed prophesies fulfilled in the life of Jesus or the New Testament. It is an argument you hear sometimes. Christianity has to be true because of all the Scriptures fulfilled in Jesus. More to come.
28. My mother had given me The Battle for the Bible by Harold Lindsell. In the back he suggests some possible reconciliations of alleged discrepancies in the Bible. [2] One of them had to do with the denials of Peter in the Gospels. Lindsell, as a suggestion, proposed that there might have been six denials, three before the cock crowed once and three more before it crowed twice.
I didn't like that option. It sounded ridiculous. It didn't pass the sniff test for special pleading. The way I would later put it is that Lindsell created a fifth Gospel that was more unlike the actual Gospels than they are different from each other. He created his own Gospel version because a certain idea of inerrancy was important to him--in a sense more important to him than actually listening to the biblical texts themselves.
I was a little overconfident. I decided to write my final paper for the class on reconciling the Gospel accounts of Peter's denial. I started with Matthew and Mark. Piece of cake. Easily reconciled. Then I added Luke. Easy. It can be done.
About 4am in writing the paper I got to John. Couldn't figure it out. John is the one that is so different that Lindsell proposed six denials. I came up with what I could and turned in the paper in the morning with a sense of unfulfillment. Either I wasn't smart enough or, just maybe, they can't really be reconciled on the level of detail.
Eventually I concluded that my expectations on such things were wrong, I would sometimes say wryly that I just wasn't smart enough to figure out such things. There are some incredibly smart people who come up with the most ingenious proposals for some of these conundrums. I'm just not that smart.
What I'm really saying is that such "ingenious" proposals are usually too far fetched to be believable. There is a person who is incredibly smart at finagling details but lacks a big picture perspective to see that they have entered a twilight zone. The world of truth is not so much a matter of what is possible as about what is probable. The ingenious proposals of Lindsell and others might be possible but they are not the most obvious reading of the evidence. That is to say, they are not as likely to be true.
29. This relates to another comment I have sometimes made. The mentality that such approaches creates is one that fosters a conspiratorial view of the world. The truth is not sought where it is most likely to be found, but we see it where we want it to be found. We become suspicious of real experts and can create a culture of anti-knowledge that, if empowered enough, becomes a threat to society...
[1] I didn't have a car my first year of college. After that it was a Chevy Citation that had been one of my dad's company cars. Every year he got a company car because he did a lot of driving to assess car damage. Sometimes he would then buy them at a discount.
[2] At some point I also acquired about a 700 page book called Alleged Discrepancies.
___________________
24. So my mother drove me back to Central for May term while I sported a patch over my scratched eyeball. [1]
I always made the trip to Central from Fort Lauderdale in two stages. First was the drive to Lakeland where my brother-in-law was pastoring. Then the rest of the way. In those torturous days of 55 miles an hour, it took four hours to my sister's and another ten to Central. Only AM radio. Country Georgia stations. Torture.
In that decade of my hyper-conscience without cruise control, I spent almost half the time while I drove watching the analog speedometer. It was not fear of a ticket. It was fear of hell. One should obey the laws of the land and the speed limit is a law of the land. You could make an exception if someone was about to give birth. But under normal circumstances, a Christian should follow the speed limit as part of obeying God.
I used to say that I killed my conscience in seminary. Not really, of course. I mean I began to gain victory over whatever "demon" tortured me all those years to excess. One should of course generally obey the laws of the land. One should give to Caesar what is Caesar's. This is a good witness.
But there is also a huge difference between the law of the land and God's law. Human law is nowhere near as important as God's law, and sometimes human law is stupid. It can be evil. For example, Jim Crow laws were evil. There is a time to practice civil disobedience to work toward good. The Wesleyan Methodist Church was founded on civil disobedience in relation to slavery.
People like me pass laws. A big aha moment in relation to the Wesleyan Discipline was when I realized that people like me voted on the things they put in the Discipline. My dad treated the Discipline almost like it was the Bible. It was certainly law. I did grow up with a great reverence for the "fathers" who created the Discipline.
But people like me created the Discipline. It's very sober. It definitely suggests that the Discipline is a work in progress. The older the material in the Discipline, the weightier its material is (e.g., the Articles of Religion). But if people like me create the Discipline, it is far from inerrant.
25. On my drive to Lakeland after Christmas 1984, I was worried about entire sanctification. I had not yet ticked off that box for certain with trips to the altar. The nineteenth century holiness movement, under the influence of Phoebe Palmer, did not have Wesley's sense that it could take a lifetime to reach perfect love or Christian perfection. At one point Wesley suspected that few would reach it in their lifetimes.
Palmer had promoted a different approach, and it was this approach that had underwritten the holiness revivals of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. I call Palmer's approach "name it claim it entire sanctification." She called it a "shorter way." Her basic question was, "Why should we wait to be entirely sanctified? What if God wants to perfect us now?"
Of course I never heard the name Phoebe Palmer growing up. As far as I knew, we were just reading the Bible and doing what it says. Chris Bounds presented options of sanctification at the 2008 General Conference: shorter, middle, longer. I heard that one General Superintendent remarked he had never heard of Phoebe Palmer, but perhaps he said he had never heard of this delineation.
It is another reminder that a lot of what we call the Bible is really tradition about the Bible. I'm not denying, by the way, that a person can be sanctified early in their Christian walk. In fact, in my college honor's project, I argued that it would ideally happen at the same time as conversion. More on sanctification later. I'm simply pointing out that what we mean by the Bible often isn't really the Bible, but some tribal tradition we confuse with the Bible.
In these days I genuinely once thought to myself, "How amazing it is that I just happened to be born into the church that has everything right. What are the odds?!" The more I could place myself in the flow of history, I began to speak of "the Wesleyan tradition" as one of many historical currents. Once using this language in conversation sparked this response: "Stop saying Wesleyan tradition. We just read the Bible and do what it says." :-)
26. On the drive to Lakeland I had a voice in my head. It could have been the Spirit. It might have been my neurotic self. "If you really were surrendered to God," it said. "if you really put God first, you would not go back to Central until you were entirely sanctified."
I really liked college. I didn't want to stay at home or at my sister's. I wanted to go back to college. I had in mind the sermons I had heard on Jacob wrestling with an angel in Genesis 32. "I will not let you go until you bless me." So if I really was fully surrendered to God, I would refuse to go back to college until God blessed me with entire sanctification.
I wrestled with this idea while I drove. My mother was completely unaware of the inner struggle.
Finally I said OK. "OK, Lord, I will not leave Lakeland until I am entirely sanctified. I will go in the sanctuary when we arrive and not leave until the work is done."
In that moment I felt a great release. I felt a great peace come over me, like the peace I experienced once about salvation on the stairs going to the second floor of our Fort Lauderdale house. When we arrived at Lakeland, I went into the sanctuary and thanked God. He was merciful on me, because there were plenty of other times when I prayed that I didn't find peace.
I want to emphasize this point. During that ten year period I prayed repeatedly for forgiveness looking for peace. I almost never had peace. I am immensely grateful for the peace of that moment.
By the way, I remember now that I had Theology of Holiness with Dongell as well. We used Jessop's Foundations of Doctrine. Another classic.
27. Flash forward to a year and a half later after poking my eye. I was in Marling Elliott's Greek Synoptic Gospels class. I always liked May term classes. You only had to focus on one course. It was easier to focus. The fall was always hardest with multiple courses and the descent into winter darkness and cold. The spring was always much better but still required balancing multiple courses. May was warm, beautiful, and focused.
I think it might have been in that class that I was first exposed to how Matthew 2:15 quotes Hosea 11:1. Elliott pointed out that Matthew sees the quote in relation to Jesus leaving Egypt. But that's not what Hosea 11 was about. Hosea 11:1 is about the exodus. So Hosea was not a prediction about Jesus. It reads, "When Israel was a child, I called my son out of Egypt, but the more I called them the more they served other gods." Was Matthew mistaken in saying this verse was fulfilled in the life of Jesus?
More on that question when I get to seminary. In college, I just smiled and thought to myself. "Interesting. I'll figure it out." There were some pages in the back of my Thompson Chain Reference Bible that showed prophesies fulfilled in the life of Jesus or the New Testament. It is an argument you hear sometimes. Christianity has to be true because of all the Scriptures fulfilled in Jesus. More to come.
28. My mother had given me The Battle for the Bible by Harold Lindsell. In the back he suggests some possible reconciliations of alleged discrepancies in the Bible. [2] One of them had to do with the denials of Peter in the Gospels. Lindsell, as a suggestion, proposed that there might have been six denials, three before the cock crowed once and three more before it crowed twice.
I didn't like that option. It sounded ridiculous. It didn't pass the sniff test for special pleading. The way I would later put it is that Lindsell created a fifth Gospel that was more unlike the actual Gospels than they are different from each other. He created his own Gospel version because a certain idea of inerrancy was important to him--in a sense more important to him than actually listening to the biblical texts themselves.
I was a little overconfident. I decided to write my final paper for the class on reconciling the Gospel accounts of Peter's denial. I started with Matthew and Mark. Piece of cake. Easily reconciled. Then I added Luke. Easy. It can be done.
About 4am in writing the paper I got to John. Couldn't figure it out. John is the one that is so different that Lindsell proposed six denials. I came up with what I could and turned in the paper in the morning with a sense of unfulfillment. Either I wasn't smart enough or, just maybe, they can't really be reconciled on the level of detail.
Eventually I concluded that my expectations on such things were wrong, I would sometimes say wryly that I just wasn't smart enough to figure out such things. There are some incredibly smart people who come up with the most ingenious proposals for some of these conundrums. I'm just not that smart.
What I'm really saying is that such "ingenious" proposals are usually too far fetched to be believable. There is a person who is incredibly smart at finagling details but lacks a big picture perspective to see that they have entered a twilight zone. The world of truth is not so much a matter of what is possible as about what is probable. The ingenious proposals of Lindsell and others might be possible but they are not the most obvious reading of the evidence. That is to say, they are not as likely to be true.
29. This relates to another comment I have sometimes made. The mentality that such approaches creates is one that fosters a conspiratorial view of the world. The truth is not sought where it is most likely to be found, but we see it where we want it to be found. We become suspicious of real experts and can create a culture of anti-knowledge that, if empowered enough, becomes a threat to society...
[1] I didn't have a car my first year of college. After that it was a Chevy Citation that had been one of my dad's company cars. Every year he got a company car because he did a lot of driving to assess car damage. Sometimes he would then buy them at a discount.
[2] At some point I also acquired about a 700 page book called Alleged Discrepancies.
Thursday, January 02, 2020
A Ministry Major in Greek 6
previous post
__________________
18. I returned to Central in the fall of 1985 a Religion major. I would triple major in Religion, Bible, and Greek.
I was excited to take Greek and had Herb Dongell, whom I had previously had for OT Survey. He was old school and used J. Gresham Machen, the classic Greek textbook from of old. I liked Machen because it was bare bones and numbered. I would use it when I taught Greek at Asbury Seminary as a teaching fellow. Machen brought the facts. I brought the flavor. [1]
Dongell was a classic. When I got my first Greek New Testament my second year (a red Aland), I copied a quote from Melanchthon in the front that I got from Dongell. It went something like "Theology is nothing more than the application of the rules of grammar to the text of Scripture."
19. Of course that's rubbish. In seminary I would put another quote underneath it from Bob Lyon: "Context is everything." The meaning of words at a particular time and place is a function of the way those words are being used. Wittgenstein spoke of "language games" that evolve with collections of words in a particular "form of life." These are constantly developing, and the meanings of words and collections of words change over time.
So words don't have some constant or core meaning inside them. You must know the context in which words are used if you want to know what they mean at a particular time and place.
My understanding of how words work developed as I was exposed to Wittgenstein in England and as I continued to learn even in my early years teaching. While I was in college, one of the Christmas presents I asked for was Kittel's ten volume Theological Dictionary. This desire was under the influence of Dongell.
But of course Kittel is rife with the etymological and lexical fallacies. The etymological fallacy is the idea that the meaning of a word depends on the history and derivation of the word. The lexical fallacy is the idea that there is some core meaning of a word passed around every time the word is used. I only realized later that a section of my doctoral dissertation on the Greek word for perfection was riddled with the lexical fallacy.
Kittel is still helpful in that it helps you know some ancient secular usage of Greek words. That is, it is helpful as a tool to know the broader use of Greek words. But this magisterial piece of German work, unfortunately involving some Germans who were Nazi sympathizers, is basically full of fallacy. I wouldn't recommend it to anyone unless it was a gift or super-cheap.
20. And of course Christian theology has a much more complex basis than the mere meaning of individual Greek sentences. Once one knows how to read the books of the Bible in context, one will realize that they were written in individual historical situations. Following the principle that all language and human understanding is incarnated, each book of the Bible--in its original meaning--had a meaning at a time and place, in a context.
The idea of universal meaning is largely rooted in either ignorance or imprecision. There are some experiences that are somewhat omni-contextual. All humans die, so all humans to varying degrees understand death. We are all born. Many of us experience love. We all eat and poop. These experiences are common to all human contexts and provide some basis for "universal" meaning.
However, the connotations of these common experience often vary even still, and there is much more variation than most people would imagine in the way cultures process these common experiences. The "referents" might be in common, but the "sense" of our language has variations even in these most common of experiences.
This is why many colleges require some sort of intercultural experience. Left alone, we will simply assume that the meanings, paradigms, and thought patterns of our lives are the right ones for everyone and are universal. We thus will critique the way the fish swim in other currents and waters because we are ignorant of the water and current around us.
The bottom line is that the words of the Bible had original meanings, and they were ancient ones. Even a practice like lectio divina, which I support, is about God meeting you here and now where you are in your own understanding. Lectio divina holds no promise whatsoever of leading you to what the Bible actually meant, which was a function of the way words were being used within ancient paradigms and worldviews two to three thousand years ago.
Biblical theology first identifies the theologies of the biblical texts on their own terms. Then one can also speak of a biblical theology that systematizes these ideologies and ethics (many biblical theologians are not even willing to go this far, because in doing so one must move beyond what the individual texts meant. I believe it is quite allowed, especially if done reflectively). Then systematic theology brings this biblical theology into conversation with the Church, especially the debates of the 300s and 400s when the Trinity, the canon, and dual nature of Christ were finalized.
Melanchthon, for all his advances over earlier interpreters, was still somewhat unreflective (or "pre-modern") in his hermeneutic. It is my opinion that the 1800s saw a qualitative advance in historical consciousness within human history. The history of thought is not simply a cycle of many returns. There have been advances in understanding in the last two hundred years that surpass all of those before, in the same way that the science of today surpasses all of that before.
21. I should be clear that I loved Dongell. He was rigorous. He was demanding. I loved the challenge. He even made us learn the rules for accents. I would never ask of my Greek students what he asked of us because I became pragmatic. But I wanted to know everything myself.
I remember trying to tutor a dyslexic friend in the accents. "If the penultimate syllable is long and the ultimate syllable is short, and if the accent is on the penultimate syllable, it will take a circumflex accent." We both busted out laughing! What crazy rules! I never required students to know these rules. They didn't affect interpretation in the vast majority of cases.
Dongell passed on some of the older Greek grammar of A. T. Robertson, as well as some old "holiness grammar." For example, some of the older holiness writers argued that entire sanctification was instantaneous because 1 Thessalonians 5:23 used the aorist tense. The aorist tense, Robertson tells us, is a punctiliar kind of action (Aktionsart). Thus, argued the old timers, sanctification takes place in an instant.
This is mistaken. David Thompson's workbook on Machen (retired Wesleyan at Asbury) rightly tells that the aorist indicates an undefined kind of action. I went through his workbook in the summer of 87 so that I could pass the Greek entrance exam at Asbury. The aorist does look at action simply, so you might say it is punctilinear or punctiliar. It is a natural tense to use for instantaneous action but it does not in itself imply it... for that you need a context. :-)
As a quick example I pulled up Acts 28:30, which says that Paul remained (aorist tense) for two years under house arrest in Rome. Obviously this is not an instantaneous event.
Of course another potential blind spot in the older interpretation is that the "you" of 1 Thessalonians 5:23 is plural. Paul seems to be speaking of the sanctification of the entire congregation at Thessalonica. Western culture, because of the water in which we are swimming, assumes the "you" is a singular, and it finds evidence in the fact that body, soul, and spirit are singular. However, "there are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in your philosophy, Horatio."
22. What I gained from Dongell was grammar. The old school way. I was, once again, skipping a generation or two back to the late eighteen hundreds when the study of Greek grammar was really just getting going. Grammar is one of the starting points for interpretation. It is nowhere close to the ending point, but it is the beginning.
I would take Greek 2 and 1 Peter in Greek with Dr. Dongell. I can't remember what else. I remember 1 Peter being hard Greek (I still think a little surprising for an unlettered fisherman without significant help). I remember cramming for the first test by trying to memorize the interlinear of 1 Peter 1. I hate to say that I would not become really good at Greek until I started teaching it at Asbury.
The Christmas, probably of 86, my brother-in-law Denny asked if I wanted to read the Christmas story from Matthew in Greek. Let's just say it didn't go very well. As I would learn, the New Testament itself is a whole different animal than the canned Greek sentences of Machen.
23. Most of my upper Greek classes, I think, were taken from Dr. Marling Elliott. He was of quite a different temperament than Dongell. He was quiet. His classes seemed unstructured at times. He would stop periodically and ask, "Are we doing any good here?" He often seemed to have a sly grin on his face.
Dongell was more of a classic school teacher. You didn't want to fall asleep in his class. I think I only struggled once in one of his classes, and as I recall he was merciful.
I don't remember all the classes I had with Elliott. I remember taking Synoptics in Greek with him in a May term. I went home, it seems, and then was going to drive back probably in the summer of 86. As I sat down groggily to eat breakfast the morning of my return trip, I bent over just right as I was sitting down and hit my eye on an unwrapped candle. Story of my life.
I scratched my eye and would need to cover it for a bit. My mother ended up driving me back up...
[1] This is one complaint I have about the now standard Mounce text. He "talks" too much. Of course I do too, but Machen didn't.
__________________
18. I returned to Central in the fall of 1985 a Religion major. I would triple major in Religion, Bible, and Greek.
I was excited to take Greek and had Herb Dongell, whom I had previously had for OT Survey. He was old school and used J. Gresham Machen, the classic Greek textbook from of old. I liked Machen because it was bare bones and numbered. I would use it when I taught Greek at Asbury Seminary as a teaching fellow. Machen brought the facts. I brought the flavor. [1]
Dongell was a classic. When I got my first Greek New Testament my second year (a red Aland), I copied a quote from Melanchthon in the front that I got from Dongell. It went something like "Theology is nothing more than the application of the rules of grammar to the text of Scripture."
19. Of course that's rubbish. In seminary I would put another quote underneath it from Bob Lyon: "Context is everything." The meaning of words at a particular time and place is a function of the way those words are being used. Wittgenstein spoke of "language games" that evolve with collections of words in a particular "form of life." These are constantly developing, and the meanings of words and collections of words change over time.
So words don't have some constant or core meaning inside them. You must know the context in which words are used if you want to know what they mean at a particular time and place.
My understanding of how words work developed as I was exposed to Wittgenstein in England and as I continued to learn even in my early years teaching. While I was in college, one of the Christmas presents I asked for was Kittel's ten volume Theological Dictionary. This desire was under the influence of Dongell.
But of course Kittel is rife with the etymological and lexical fallacies. The etymological fallacy is the idea that the meaning of a word depends on the history and derivation of the word. The lexical fallacy is the idea that there is some core meaning of a word passed around every time the word is used. I only realized later that a section of my doctoral dissertation on the Greek word for perfection was riddled with the lexical fallacy.
Kittel is still helpful in that it helps you know some ancient secular usage of Greek words. That is, it is helpful as a tool to know the broader use of Greek words. But this magisterial piece of German work, unfortunately involving some Germans who were Nazi sympathizers, is basically full of fallacy. I wouldn't recommend it to anyone unless it was a gift or super-cheap.
20. And of course Christian theology has a much more complex basis than the mere meaning of individual Greek sentences. Once one knows how to read the books of the Bible in context, one will realize that they were written in individual historical situations. Following the principle that all language and human understanding is incarnated, each book of the Bible--in its original meaning--had a meaning at a time and place, in a context.
The idea of universal meaning is largely rooted in either ignorance or imprecision. There are some experiences that are somewhat omni-contextual. All humans die, so all humans to varying degrees understand death. We are all born. Many of us experience love. We all eat and poop. These experiences are common to all human contexts and provide some basis for "universal" meaning.
However, the connotations of these common experience often vary even still, and there is much more variation than most people would imagine in the way cultures process these common experiences. The "referents" might be in common, but the "sense" of our language has variations even in these most common of experiences.
This is why many colleges require some sort of intercultural experience. Left alone, we will simply assume that the meanings, paradigms, and thought patterns of our lives are the right ones for everyone and are universal. We thus will critique the way the fish swim in other currents and waters because we are ignorant of the water and current around us.
The bottom line is that the words of the Bible had original meanings, and they were ancient ones. Even a practice like lectio divina, which I support, is about God meeting you here and now where you are in your own understanding. Lectio divina holds no promise whatsoever of leading you to what the Bible actually meant, which was a function of the way words were being used within ancient paradigms and worldviews two to three thousand years ago.
Biblical theology first identifies the theologies of the biblical texts on their own terms. Then one can also speak of a biblical theology that systematizes these ideologies and ethics (many biblical theologians are not even willing to go this far, because in doing so one must move beyond what the individual texts meant. I believe it is quite allowed, especially if done reflectively). Then systematic theology brings this biblical theology into conversation with the Church, especially the debates of the 300s and 400s when the Trinity, the canon, and dual nature of Christ were finalized.
Melanchthon, for all his advances over earlier interpreters, was still somewhat unreflective (or "pre-modern") in his hermeneutic. It is my opinion that the 1800s saw a qualitative advance in historical consciousness within human history. The history of thought is not simply a cycle of many returns. There have been advances in understanding in the last two hundred years that surpass all of those before, in the same way that the science of today surpasses all of that before.
21. I should be clear that I loved Dongell. He was rigorous. He was demanding. I loved the challenge. He even made us learn the rules for accents. I would never ask of my Greek students what he asked of us because I became pragmatic. But I wanted to know everything myself.
I remember trying to tutor a dyslexic friend in the accents. "If the penultimate syllable is long and the ultimate syllable is short, and if the accent is on the penultimate syllable, it will take a circumflex accent." We both busted out laughing! What crazy rules! I never required students to know these rules. They didn't affect interpretation in the vast majority of cases.
Dongell passed on some of the older Greek grammar of A. T. Robertson, as well as some old "holiness grammar." For example, some of the older holiness writers argued that entire sanctification was instantaneous because 1 Thessalonians 5:23 used the aorist tense. The aorist tense, Robertson tells us, is a punctiliar kind of action (Aktionsart). Thus, argued the old timers, sanctification takes place in an instant.
This is mistaken. David Thompson's workbook on Machen (retired Wesleyan at Asbury) rightly tells that the aorist indicates an undefined kind of action. I went through his workbook in the summer of 87 so that I could pass the Greek entrance exam at Asbury. The aorist does look at action simply, so you might say it is punctilinear or punctiliar. It is a natural tense to use for instantaneous action but it does not in itself imply it... for that you need a context. :-)
As a quick example I pulled up Acts 28:30, which says that Paul remained (aorist tense) for two years under house arrest in Rome. Obviously this is not an instantaneous event.
Of course another potential blind spot in the older interpretation is that the "you" of 1 Thessalonians 5:23 is plural. Paul seems to be speaking of the sanctification of the entire congregation at Thessalonica. Western culture, because of the water in which we are swimming, assumes the "you" is a singular, and it finds evidence in the fact that body, soul, and spirit are singular. However, "there are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in your philosophy, Horatio."
22. What I gained from Dongell was grammar. The old school way. I was, once again, skipping a generation or two back to the late eighteen hundreds when the study of Greek grammar was really just getting going. Grammar is one of the starting points for interpretation. It is nowhere close to the ending point, but it is the beginning.
I would take Greek 2 and 1 Peter in Greek with Dr. Dongell. I can't remember what else. I remember 1 Peter being hard Greek (I still think a little surprising for an unlettered fisherman without significant help). I remember cramming for the first test by trying to memorize the interlinear of 1 Peter 1. I hate to say that I would not become really good at Greek until I started teaching it at Asbury.
The Christmas, probably of 86, my brother-in-law Denny asked if I wanted to read the Christmas story from Matthew in Greek. Let's just say it didn't go very well. As I would learn, the New Testament itself is a whole different animal than the canned Greek sentences of Machen.
23. Most of my upper Greek classes, I think, were taken from Dr. Marling Elliott. He was of quite a different temperament than Dongell. He was quiet. His classes seemed unstructured at times. He would stop periodically and ask, "Are we doing any good here?" He often seemed to have a sly grin on his face.
Dongell was more of a classic school teacher. You didn't want to fall asleep in his class. I think I only struggled once in one of his classes, and as I recall he was merciful.
I don't remember all the classes I had with Elliott. I remember taking Synoptics in Greek with him in a May term. I went home, it seems, and then was going to drive back probably in the summer of 86. As I sat down groggily to eat breakfast the morning of my return trip, I bent over just right as I was sitting down and hit my eye on an unwrapped candle. Story of my life.
I scratched my eye and would need to cover it for a bit. My mother ended up driving me back up...
[1] This is one complaint I have about the now standard Mounce text. He "talks" too much. Of course I do too, but Machen didn't.
Wednesday, January 01, 2020
Some Spring Initiatives
If you are looking to audit a course this spring online, here are some opportunities I am a part of at Houghton:
1. Linguistics - Steve Doty, a Wycliffe missionary, will be teaching Introduction to Linguistics and I will be beaming the class live Monday-Wednesday-Friday at 8:55 if there are some people interested in taking the class for audit or credit.
Did you know you can minor in something at Houghton without even being a Houghton student or without seeking a degree? How about a minor in Linguistics? Email me if you're interested (ken.schenck@houghton.edu).
2. Philosophy - whether you want to audit for ordination, for lifelong learning, or take it for credit and transfer it back somewhere, class with me starts the 13th. Eight live evening sessions on Monday nights. Want to know what an informed Christian worldview might look like?
3. Latin for Today - don't know what quid pro quo means? I'm teaching Latin 8 nights starting in March. Have a high school student wanting to get in some college credit before college? Want to audit yourself? Monday nights.
4. Intro to Ministry - I'm not teaching it, but Michael Jordan is teaching intro to ministry, beaming live from Watermark church in Buffalor in March. Feel a call to ministry? You can audit or take toward an Associate of Applied Science degree in Christian Ministries. Live Tuesday nights for 8 weeks.
Whew! A lot going on!
1. Linguistics - Steve Doty, a Wycliffe missionary, will be teaching Introduction to Linguistics and I will be beaming the class live Monday-Wednesday-Friday at 8:55 if there are some people interested in taking the class for audit or credit.
Did you know you can minor in something at Houghton without even being a Houghton student or without seeking a degree? How about a minor in Linguistics? Email me if you're interested (ken.schenck@houghton.edu).
2. Philosophy - whether you want to audit for ordination, for lifelong learning, or take it for credit and transfer it back somewhere, class with me starts the 13th. Eight live evening sessions on Monday nights. Want to know what an informed Christian worldview might look like?
3. Latin for Today - don't know what quid pro quo means? I'm teaching Latin 8 nights starting in March. Have a high school student wanting to get in some college credit before college? Want to audit yourself? Monday nights.
4. Intro to Ministry - I'm not teaching it, but Michael Jordan is teaching intro to ministry, beaming live from Watermark church in Buffalor in March. Feel a call to ministry? You can audit or take toward an Associate of Applied Science degree in Christian Ministries. Live Tuesday nights for 8 weeks.
Whew! A lot going on!
New Year's Resolutions (2020)
Ten Years
1. Should one set decade goals? Here's one:
In 10 years I wonder if my son will be a career Army man. In 10 years I wonder if Sophie will be doing something in the world of governmental service. I imagine Stefanie will still be living a sun-filled life in Miami, and Stacy a sun-filled life in California.
2. In 10 years I hope I'll still either be teaching or leading in some way in higher education. I would be delighted still to be at Houghton College. When I came to Houghton this past fall, I came planning to be here for the rest of my career. That's at least 2037.
3. In 10 years time I hope I will have finished some academic books that are in the back of my mind and in various stages of development. These include:
1. Should one set decade goals? Here's one:
- I hope still to be alive in 10 years. If so, I'll be 63.
In 10 years I wonder if my son will be a career Army man. In 10 years I wonder if Sophie will be doing something in the world of governmental service. I imagine Stefanie will still be living a sun-filled life in Miami, and Stacy a sun-filled life in California.
2. In 10 years I hope I'll still either be teaching or leading in some way in higher education. I would be delighted still to be at Houghton College. When I came to Houghton this past fall, I came planning to be here for the rest of my career. That's at least 2037.
3. In 10 years time I hope I will have finished some academic books that are in the back of my mind and in various stages of development. These include:
- Four Jewish Views of the Afterlife
- Salvation in the Making
- An academic commentary on Hebrews or perhaps a collection of essays on Hebrews that covers the whole book (I about have enough published for that already)
- A commentary on Philo's treatise, "Who is the Heir of All Things"
- A philosophy book on the nature of meaning
2020
4. This year my primary focus is enrollment growth at Houghton College. I want to contribute as much as I can to the growth of on-campus programs like data science and engineering, as well as to the goal of adding 100 new online students by next year at this time. Feel free to audit an online course, a new initiative!
5. Let's pick one of the academic books above as a focus for this year's writing. Four Jewish Views of the Afterlife it is. I started work on such a book in 2004 while on sabbatical in Germany.
6. I will continue my work on Patreon. I plan to continue looking at Genesis 1 in Hebrew, a verse a week. I will continue my weekly podcast, "Though the Bible in Ten Years."
A new addition is Greek lessons, primarily aimed at pastors. I plan to work through the Greek textbook I've written, putting videos on YouTube that go through it. Then I'll self-publish it at the end. (No publisher understandably seems interested in a Greek textbook.)
7. Books to read. There will no doubt be good books that surface in the course of the year, but I'd like to finish off some old ones. May I finally finish the following books this year. The months are just to give me focus. These are heavy books what will likely take all year.
9. Run. I'm missed running 3 miles under 30 minutes in 2019. I tore my knee in September. But I refuse to give up. I ran a mile Saturday under 10. I shall return!
4. This year my primary focus is enrollment growth at Houghton College. I want to contribute as much as I can to the growth of on-campus programs like data science and engineering, as well as to the goal of adding 100 new online students by next year at this time. Feel free to audit an online course, a new initiative!
5. Let's pick one of the academic books above as a focus for this year's writing. Four Jewish Views of the Afterlife it is. I started work on such a book in 2004 while on sabbatical in Germany.
6. I will continue my work on Patreon. I plan to continue looking at Genesis 1 in Hebrew, a verse a week. I will continue my weekly podcast, "Though the Bible in Ten Years."
A new addition is Greek lessons, primarily aimed at pastors. I plan to work through the Greek textbook I've written, putting videos on YouTube that go through it. Then I'll self-publish it at the end. (No publisher understandably seems interested in a Greek textbook.)
7. Books to read. There will no doubt be good books that surface in the course of the year, but I'd like to finish off some old ones. May I finally finish the following books this year. The months are just to give me focus. These are heavy books what will likely take all year.
- January: N. T. Wright, History and Eschatology
- February: Craig Keener, Christobiography
- March: Willie James Jennings
- April: Assorted N. T. Wright
- May: John Barclay
- June on: the above and TBD
9. Run. I'm missed running 3 miles under 30 minutes in 2019. I tore my knee in September. But I refuse to give up. I ran a mile Saturday under 10. I shall return!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
