To follow the bread crumbs back, here's one place to start.
________
Leaving Ephesus
We do not know for sure whether Paul wrote Galatians or Philippians from Ephesus. But we can feel confident that he wrote at least three letters to Corinth while he was there (he also made a visit to the city that Acts does not record, cf. 2 Cor. 2:1; 13:1). Perhaps surprisingly, we only have one of these three letters for certain, 1 Corinthians. Paul's first letter to Corinth urged the Corinthians to stay away from sexually immoral influences (1 Cor. 5:9), but this letter has not survived. [1] Paul's second letter is thus the one we now call "First" Corinthians.
Interestingly, the third letter Paul sent to Corinth was not 2 Corinthians. [2] It was a harsh letter--one Paul in hindsight was not so sure he should have sent (2 Cor. 7:8). Perhaps that is why it was not preserved. The story goes something like the following. We know from 1 Corinthians that there were some in the Corinthian church who questioned Paul's authority. Apparently, the conflict between Paul and these individuals led him to send an ultimatum, which he apparently sent in the hands of Titus (2 Cor. 2:9; 7:13).
Whether Paul wrote this letter before the imprisonment we are suggesting at Ephesus or while he was imprisoned, we cannot say. The stark attitude of Galatians fits the apparent tone of the harsh letter to Corinth more than the mellow attitude of his imprisonment in Philippians. 2 Corinthians 1-9 itself fits more with the tone of Philippians as well. Our hunch is thus that Paul wrote Galatians, then at some point thereafter this harsh letter to Corinth, sending it off with Titus.
Then there was the crisis with Demetrius the silversmith, who brought Paul up on charges. Paul was imprisoned. When news reached the Philippians, they sent one of their overseers, Epaphroditus, with material support. Paul wrote Philippians, giving his intention to come visit them. We wonder if Paul's punishment was to be banished from the city and if such a verdict might have played into the reason he does not return back through Ephesus his next time through the area (cf. Acts 20:16-17). [3]
Paul had perhaps earlier intended to go directly from Ephesus to Corinth (2 Cor. 1:16). He decides instead to go to Macedonia first, which some at Corinth apparently made an issue of, claiming that Paul was not a man of his word (2 Cor. 1:18-19). His desire to see the Philippians, especially after their support of him in prison, might also have played into his change of plans (Phil. 2:24).
The individual at Corinth apparently submitted, as did the entire community--at least on the surface (2 Cor. 2:5-11). The community disciplined the person in question, so much so that Paul even tells them to let up (2 Cor. 2:6-8). Some have suggested it might have been the man who was sleeping with his step-mother in 1 Corinthians 5. There Paul had told them to hand this person over to Satan (1 Cor. 5:5) and not to eat with him (5:11).
We cannot know for certain that this was the man in question, but he apparently submitted to the community, and the community to Paul. From this incident comes one of the most memorable verses on repentance in the Bible: "Godly grief produces a repentance that leads to salvation and brings no regret" (2 Cor. 7:10). So while Paul was not certain he had done the right thing at first, giving the church an ultimatum in relationship to his authority, his letter at least seems to work and, for the moment, he is glad he did it (7:8-9). As we will see, however, it is not clear that the community's submission was as solid as Paul thought.
[1] Unless, of course, 2 Corinthians 6:14-7:1 is a displaced fragment from this letter, has some have suggested.
[2] Although, again, some have suggested that 2 Corinthians 10-13 might be an excerpt from Paul's third, but now lost letter.
[3] 1 Clement mentions that Paul was once banished (5.6). It would also contribute to the reason there was no more room for Paul to minister in the east (Rom. 15:23).
Tuesday, December 15, 2009
Paul's Resume (Philippians IV)
The basic elements of this chapter thus far are:
Imprisoned at Ephesus?
Ephesus at the End
Living Worthy of the Gospel
And now part IV:
__________
Paul's Resume
In the middle of Paul's exhortations to rejoice in suffering and to have a servant attitude like Christ did, we suddenly find Paul warning the Philippians about "Judaizers," about those who would insist they need to get circumcised to be saved. The change in subject is so unexpected that some have even suggested Philippians 3 comes from some other letter Paul wrote to the Philippians. We probably do not have enough evidence to warrant such speculation, although it is of course possible. Nevertheless, assuming Paul has just recently written Galatians, as we think, then it makes sense that he would have these Judaizers in mind and would want to warn others in case they came to town.
So Paul suddenly changes subjects and warns the Philippians to "Beware of the dogs, beware of the evil workers, beware of those who mutilate the flesh!" Ironic, since a Jew might just as well refer to a non-Jew as an uncircumcised dog. Paul turns the tables and suggests that his enemies are the truly uncircumcised ones--their hearts are uncircumcised. In fact, they are not truly the "circumcision" (peritome) the ones God has set apart as His with this sign. They are the "mutilation" (katatome) who are bent on getting Gentile believers to convert fully to Judaism.
Some debate whether Paul is referring in these comments to non-believing or to Christian Jews. We think that, as in Galatians and as in 2 Corinthians 10-13, Paul is referring to other believers rather than to non-believing Jews in general. Since he has very recently written Galatians, he is very concerned that his ministry to Gentiles not be undermined elsewhere as well. He is concerned that his detractors might try to convince his churches to establish "a righteousness of my own that comes from the law" instead of a "righteousness from God based on faith" (Phil. 3:9).
But Paul also wants to make it clear that his Jewish credentials themselves are impeccable. He was circumcised the eighth day of his life like they were (3:5). Indeed, he speaks Aramaic as a first language and can read the Bible in the original Hebrew (3:5). Before he believed, he was a zealous Pharisee, like some of the strictest of all believers in Jerusalem (cf. Acts 15:5). As far as righteousness based on Law-keeping went, he was blameless (Phil. 3:6).
Paul thus was not like his opponents at Galatia, who did not even keep the Law themselves (Gal. 6:13). He had kept the Law as well as it could be kept. To see Peter and Barnabas feebly remove themselves from eating with Gentiles at Antioch must have been a joke. After all, he had really kept the Law. They had never kept the Law as well as he had a day in their lives (e.g., Gal. 2:14). Paul does not tell us here that he had been a miserable failure here or in Galatians. He just indicates it is not what God is looking for, and what God is looking for is so incredible, these sorts of things pale in comparison.
What God looks at is the faithful death of Jesus Christ on the cross, the faith of Jesus Christ. To participate in Christ's death through baptism (e.g., Rom. 6:3-4) and to share in his sufferings, is to look forward to a share in his resurrection as well (Phil. 3:10-11). All of Paul's past accomplishments and credentials as a faithful Jew are like rubbish when placed next to the excellence of what being in Christ offers.
Paul suggests that he is not yet guaranteed this resurrection of the dead (Phil. 3:11-12). He has not yet been perfected in this way, the perfection that will happen when the dead are raised. But he, as we, must continue throughout this life to pursue that goal and that prize, the prize of the heavenly call of the resurrection (3:14). We must continue to live a life worthy of the gospel (2:27), we must work out together our way to final salvation (2:12), knowing that God is inside and among us, working in us to bring His will and His good pleasure to pass (2:13). And if we are faithful by God's power, then one day God will "transform the body of our humiliation that it may be conformed to the body of his glory" (3:21).
Reflections
Philippians, like 1 Corinthians, is another one of the books of the Bible that seems to have such little distance between us and them. Here are two members of the congregation at odds with each other. Here is the ever present need for some in the church to stop thinking only of themselves and to begin to make others a priority. The hymn about Christ is one of the most majestic passages in the entire Bible, and its main point in Philippians is that we are to have the same servant attitude that Christ did.
These things are far more easily said than done. How many churches have you visited about which you could truly say that everyone was "of the same mind"? How many families are of this sort? How many denominational leaders? How many Christian colleges? Somehow we have a tendency to bicker far more over the details than to focus on our common mind and will.
Most of us in the West do not face the pressures we hear Paul mention in every one of his letters. Most of us do not really know the "sharing of his sufferings" (Phil. 3:10). And yet how few of us rejoice as Paul does in this letter? How many of us have learned to be content regardless of our circumstances? How many of us truly believe that we can do all all things through the strengthening of Christ?
We are also prone to misread Philippians 3:12-14 as being about our current imperfection and our need to forget our past failures and to keep pushing forward to get better. Certainly these are things we should do as well. But what Paul was forgetting was not his past moral failures but his past human accomplishments. And what he had not yet attained was not a blameless life--he feels quite comfortable telling the Philippians to follow his example (3:17) and expects them to be "pure and blameless" when Christ comes (1:10).
What he has not yet been guaranteed is the resurrection, the heavenly call, salvation. This is the goal and the prize, and it is for this end result that he urges the Philippians to live worthy lives and work together so that they all make it to the end. It may be faith alone that initially secures our right standing with God, but God has given us His holy Spirit thereafter actually to make us into the kind of people He planned for us to be in the first place. And it is only if we are faithful through that power that we will attain to the resurrection of the dead, according to Paul.
Imprisoned at Ephesus?
Ephesus at the End
Living Worthy of the Gospel
And now part IV:
__________
Paul's Resume
In the middle of Paul's exhortations to rejoice in suffering and to have a servant attitude like Christ did, we suddenly find Paul warning the Philippians about "Judaizers," about those who would insist they need to get circumcised to be saved. The change in subject is so unexpected that some have even suggested Philippians 3 comes from some other letter Paul wrote to the Philippians. We probably do not have enough evidence to warrant such speculation, although it is of course possible. Nevertheless, assuming Paul has just recently written Galatians, as we think, then it makes sense that he would have these Judaizers in mind and would want to warn others in case they came to town.
So Paul suddenly changes subjects and warns the Philippians to "Beware of the dogs, beware of the evil workers, beware of those who mutilate the flesh!" Ironic, since a Jew might just as well refer to a non-Jew as an uncircumcised dog. Paul turns the tables and suggests that his enemies are the truly uncircumcised ones--their hearts are uncircumcised. In fact, they are not truly the "circumcision" (peritome) the ones God has set apart as His with this sign. They are the "mutilation" (katatome) who are bent on getting Gentile believers to convert fully to Judaism.
Some debate whether Paul is referring in these comments to non-believing or to Christian Jews. We think that, as in Galatians and as in 2 Corinthians 10-13, Paul is referring to other believers rather than to non-believing Jews in general. Since he has very recently written Galatians, he is very concerned that his ministry to Gentiles not be undermined elsewhere as well. He is concerned that his detractors might try to convince his churches to establish "a righteousness of my own that comes from the law" instead of a "righteousness from God based on faith" (Phil. 3:9).
But Paul also wants to make it clear that his Jewish credentials themselves are impeccable. He was circumcised the eighth day of his life like they were (3:5). Indeed, he speaks Aramaic as a first language and can read the Bible in the original Hebrew (3:5). Before he believed, he was a zealous Pharisee, like some of the strictest of all believers in Jerusalem (cf. Acts 15:5). As far as righteousness based on Law-keeping went, he was blameless (Phil. 3:6).
Paul thus was not like his opponents at Galatia, who did not even keep the Law themselves (Gal. 6:13). He had kept the Law as well as it could be kept. To see Peter and Barnabas feebly remove themselves from eating with Gentiles at Antioch must have been a joke. After all, he had really kept the Law. They had never kept the Law as well as he had a day in their lives (e.g., Gal. 2:14). Paul does not tell us here that he had been a miserable failure here or in Galatians. He just indicates it is not what God is looking for, and what God is looking for is so incredible, these sorts of things pale in comparison.
What God looks at is the faithful death of Jesus Christ on the cross, the faith of Jesus Christ. To participate in Christ's death through baptism (e.g., Rom. 6:3-4) and to share in his sufferings, is to look forward to a share in his resurrection as well (Phil. 3:10-11). All of Paul's past accomplishments and credentials as a faithful Jew are like rubbish when placed next to the excellence of what being in Christ offers.
Paul suggests that he is not yet guaranteed this resurrection of the dead (Phil. 3:11-12). He has not yet been perfected in this way, the perfection that will happen when the dead are raised. But he, as we, must continue throughout this life to pursue that goal and that prize, the prize of the heavenly call of the resurrection (3:14). We must continue to live a life worthy of the gospel (2:27), we must work out together our way to final salvation (2:12), knowing that God is inside and among us, working in us to bring His will and His good pleasure to pass (2:13). And if we are faithful by God's power, then one day God will "transform the body of our humiliation that it may be conformed to the body of his glory" (3:21).
Reflections
Philippians, like 1 Corinthians, is another one of the books of the Bible that seems to have such little distance between us and them. Here are two members of the congregation at odds with each other. Here is the ever present need for some in the church to stop thinking only of themselves and to begin to make others a priority. The hymn about Christ is one of the most majestic passages in the entire Bible, and its main point in Philippians is that we are to have the same servant attitude that Christ did.
These things are far more easily said than done. How many churches have you visited about which you could truly say that everyone was "of the same mind"? How many families are of this sort? How many denominational leaders? How many Christian colleges? Somehow we have a tendency to bicker far more over the details than to focus on our common mind and will.
Most of us in the West do not face the pressures we hear Paul mention in every one of his letters. Most of us do not really know the "sharing of his sufferings" (Phil. 3:10). And yet how few of us rejoice as Paul does in this letter? How many of us have learned to be content regardless of our circumstances? How many of us truly believe that we can do all all things through the strengthening of Christ?
We are also prone to misread Philippians 3:12-14 as being about our current imperfection and our need to forget our past failures and to keep pushing forward to get better. Certainly these are things we should do as well. But what Paul was forgetting was not his past moral failures but his past human accomplishments. And what he had not yet attained was not a blameless life--he feels quite comfortable telling the Philippians to follow his example (3:17) and expects them to be "pure and blameless" when Christ comes (1:10).
What he has not yet been guaranteed is the resurrection, the heavenly call, salvation. This is the goal and the prize, and it is for this end result that he urges the Philippians to live worthy lives and work together so that they all make it to the end. It may be faith alone that initially secures our right standing with God, but God has given us His holy Spirit thereafter actually to make us into the kind of people He planned for us to be in the first place. And it is only if we are faithful through that power that we will attain to the resurrection of the dead, according to Paul.
Monday, December 14, 2009
Living Worthy of the Gospel (Philippians III)
The basic elements of this chapter thus far are:
Imprisoned at Ephesus?
Ephesus at the End
And now part III:
___________
Living Worthy of the Gospel
The key verse of Philippians would seem to be 1:27. After Paul has greeted the Philippians (1:1-2), after he has thanked God for them and rehearsed some of his current situation (1:3-26), he begins the body of the letter with an admonition to "live your life in a manner worthy of the gospel of Christ" (1:27). Most of the rest of the letter, we might argue, plays out this general instruction.
Perhaps the main goal Paul has in mind is for the Philippian church to be unified and loving toward one another, both in the face of opposition and in terms of tensions among themselves. Just after he tells them to live worthy lives, he says he wants to hear that they "are standing firm in one spirit, striving side by side with one mind for the faith of the gospel" (1:27). He wants them to be "of the same mind, having the same love, being in full accord and of one mind" (2:2). He wants them to look out not only for themselves but for others as well (2:4) and not to operate out of selfish ambition (2:3).
Near the end of the letter, he specifically calls out two women who worked together with him when he was at Philippi: Euodia and Syntyche (4:2). As he earlier encouraged the entire assembly, he urges them in particular to "be of the same mind in the Lord." These two had struggled beside Paul in the work of the gospel, along with someone named Clement and, perhaps, Epaphroditus. [1] But somewhere along the way they had come into conflict. As he had with the Corinthians, he urges the Philippians to heal the disunity among them.
The most majestic part of Philippians is the so called Philippian hymn of 2:6-11. Paul uses the example of Christ's selfless suffering for others as a model for how the Philippians should behave toward one another (2:5). We cannot be certain whether Christians somewhere actually sung these words. The rhythm of the words is not entirely clear and the lines are not all the same in length. Further, most scholars think that wherever the poem came from, Paul has interrupted it at some points with commentary. Would a group used to singing such words not have been irritated at having the flow of a hymn interrupted? [2]
Nevertheless, the words do have a rhythm to them, and we do know that the early Christians composed and used hymns in their worship (e.g., 1 Cor. 14:26). While we cannot know for certain, a good suggestion is that the hymn falls into three parts of four lines each, with Paul expanding on a few points. The places where we think Paul might have added to the hymn are in parentheses. The translation is our own:
Although he existed in the form of God,
He considered equality with God not something to exploit,
But he emptied himself,
Having taken the form of a servant.
Having become in the likeness of mortals,
And having been found in shape as a mortal,
He humbled himself,
Having become obedient to the point of death (even death on a cross).
Therefore, God even super-exalted him,
And graced on him the Name above every name,
That (at the name of Jesus) every knee should bow (whether in heaven or on earth or under the earth) and tongue confess,
That Jesus Christ is Lord (to the glory of God the Father).
This reconstruction, as all of them, is not without its problems, leading some simply to abandon the notion that we even have a clear poem here. Many are content to suggest that Paul has simply waxed somewhat poetic on the spot. The rhythm of our last stanza above in particular is difficult and different from the first two, which actually have somewhat of a parallel structure. Nevertheless, the poem seems to have enough rhythm with apparent interruptions to suggest that Paul is drawing from somewhere else here.
Several features of the hymn are quite remarkable. Most take the first stanza to be about Jesus' pre-existence before he assumed human form. [3] Yet the most remarkable part of the hymn is in the third stanza, where God gives to Jesus the "Name above every name." The "Name above every name" can hardly be anything but a reference to Yahweh, the very name of God. Yahweh was translated into Greek as "Lord," and so the Name that God bestowed on Jesus at the point of his resurrection was surely "Lord," not Jesus. The hymn thus sees Jesus receiving the very Name of God as God raises Jesus from the dead and super-exalts him to His right hand.
Paul uses this hymn about Christ to show the Philippians both the attitude they should have and, just perhaps, what the ultimate benefit of such an attitude is. First, Jesus was none other than the Son of God, a status of royalty and kingship that none of them certainly had. Yet even with such a high status, Jesus did not consider his divine status as something to take advantage of. Rather he assumed the status of a servant. And even once he had assumed the shape of a mortal, even though he looked like any other human being, he humbled himself even further. He endured the most shameful form of capital punishment in use at the time: crucifixion.
It was to these lengths of service and sacrifice that Paul called the Philippians to embrace in the interests of each other. And of course as a result God took Christ even higher perhaps than he had been before. If he had been in the form of God before, now he was super-exalted with the very name of Yahweh. So also, perhaps Paul means to imply, the Philippians will eventually be exalted by God if they will be servants now.
The final chapter of Philippians is filled with other items of "worthy living" Paul advises as they live as citizens of heaven (1:27; 3:20). [4] Their true citizenship is not on earth, tied up with any earthly city or empire. Paul tells them not be anxious about anything but to rely on God (4:6). He tells them to let others see how gentle they are (4:5). He encourages them to think about noble and uplifting things (4:8). Throughout he has a mellow spirit. His ordeal has humbled him, and we see this same spirit in 2 Corinthians, which we date not long after Paul wrote Philippians.
[1] Paul addresses at this point "my loyal companion" or "my loyal yokefellow." Some have suggested the word yokefellow is actually this man's name, Syzygus. But we think Paul is likely referring to Epaphroditus, who probably was the one who delivered the letter of Philippians back to Philippi.
[2] Or so has argued N. T. Wright. One of his early books was a collection of articles titled The Climax of the Covenant (***), which includes articles on key texts about Christ like these verses from Philippians. Whether you agree with him or not, we put this book among the top fifty or so books one should read to master Paul's writings.
[3] With some notable exceptions. For example, James D. G. Dunn is perhaps the best known proponent of the idea that the first line is actually about Christ being the second Adam who undid the Fall (Christology in the Making ***). Adam was also in the "image of God," but he did grasp at equality with God. Jesus, in the same situation, did not grasp in that way. Dunn thus did not see any indication of Christ's pre-existence in the hymn, since it was as a human on earth that Jesus did not take advantage of being in the image of God. Most, however, have not followed Dunn's interpretation. For example, it is not clear that "form of God" means the same thing as "image of God."
However, a strong alternative to the majority position is the possibility that form of God relates to Jesus having the status of God, that is, of being God's Son. This view was most notably held by Eduard Schweizer (***). The idea that form of God has to do with status is supported by the fact that it is parallel to the phrase "form of a servant." The stanza thus comes to say that while Jesus had the status of God, he did not take advantage of that status, but instead took on the status of a servant. On this reading as well, it would not be entirely clear that Paul was referring to Jesus in some pre-existent state.
[4] N. T. Wright is at some pains to make it clear that this expression does not mean Paul is saying that we will go to heaven or spend eternity in heaven, only that heaven is where our empire is centered (***).
Imprisoned at Ephesus?
Ephesus at the End
And now part III:
___________
Living Worthy of the Gospel
The key verse of Philippians would seem to be 1:27. After Paul has greeted the Philippians (1:1-2), after he has thanked God for them and rehearsed some of his current situation (1:3-26), he begins the body of the letter with an admonition to "live your life in a manner worthy of the gospel of Christ" (1:27). Most of the rest of the letter, we might argue, plays out this general instruction.
Perhaps the main goal Paul has in mind is for the Philippian church to be unified and loving toward one another, both in the face of opposition and in terms of tensions among themselves. Just after he tells them to live worthy lives, he says he wants to hear that they "are standing firm in one spirit, striving side by side with one mind for the faith of the gospel" (1:27). He wants them to be "of the same mind, having the same love, being in full accord and of one mind" (2:2). He wants them to look out not only for themselves but for others as well (2:4) and not to operate out of selfish ambition (2:3).
Near the end of the letter, he specifically calls out two women who worked together with him when he was at Philippi: Euodia and Syntyche (4:2). As he earlier encouraged the entire assembly, he urges them in particular to "be of the same mind in the Lord." These two had struggled beside Paul in the work of the gospel, along with someone named Clement and, perhaps, Epaphroditus. [1] But somewhere along the way they had come into conflict. As he had with the Corinthians, he urges the Philippians to heal the disunity among them.
The most majestic part of Philippians is the so called Philippian hymn of 2:6-11. Paul uses the example of Christ's selfless suffering for others as a model for how the Philippians should behave toward one another (2:5). We cannot be certain whether Christians somewhere actually sung these words. The rhythm of the words is not entirely clear and the lines are not all the same in length. Further, most scholars think that wherever the poem came from, Paul has interrupted it at some points with commentary. Would a group used to singing such words not have been irritated at having the flow of a hymn interrupted? [2]
Nevertheless, the words do have a rhythm to them, and we do know that the early Christians composed and used hymns in their worship (e.g., 1 Cor. 14:26). While we cannot know for certain, a good suggestion is that the hymn falls into three parts of four lines each, with Paul expanding on a few points. The places where we think Paul might have added to the hymn are in parentheses. The translation is our own:
Although he existed in the form of God,
He considered equality with God not something to exploit,
But he emptied himself,
Having taken the form of a servant.
Having become in the likeness of mortals,
And having been found in shape as a mortal,
He humbled himself,
Having become obedient to the point of death (even death on a cross).
Therefore, God even super-exalted him,
And graced on him the Name above every name,
That (at the name of Jesus) every knee should bow (whether in heaven or on earth or under the earth) and tongue confess,
That Jesus Christ is Lord (to the glory of God the Father).
This reconstruction, as all of them, is not without its problems, leading some simply to abandon the notion that we even have a clear poem here. Many are content to suggest that Paul has simply waxed somewhat poetic on the spot. The rhythm of our last stanza above in particular is difficult and different from the first two, which actually have somewhat of a parallel structure. Nevertheless, the poem seems to have enough rhythm with apparent interruptions to suggest that Paul is drawing from somewhere else here.
Several features of the hymn are quite remarkable. Most take the first stanza to be about Jesus' pre-existence before he assumed human form. [3] Yet the most remarkable part of the hymn is in the third stanza, where God gives to Jesus the "Name above every name." The "Name above every name" can hardly be anything but a reference to Yahweh, the very name of God. Yahweh was translated into Greek as "Lord," and so the Name that God bestowed on Jesus at the point of his resurrection was surely "Lord," not Jesus. The hymn thus sees Jesus receiving the very Name of God as God raises Jesus from the dead and super-exalts him to His right hand.
Paul uses this hymn about Christ to show the Philippians both the attitude they should have and, just perhaps, what the ultimate benefit of such an attitude is. First, Jesus was none other than the Son of God, a status of royalty and kingship that none of them certainly had. Yet even with such a high status, Jesus did not consider his divine status as something to take advantage of. Rather he assumed the status of a servant. And even once he had assumed the shape of a mortal, even though he looked like any other human being, he humbled himself even further. He endured the most shameful form of capital punishment in use at the time: crucifixion.
It was to these lengths of service and sacrifice that Paul called the Philippians to embrace in the interests of each other. And of course as a result God took Christ even higher perhaps than he had been before. If he had been in the form of God before, now he was super-exalted with the very name of Yahweh. So also, perhaps Paul means to imply, the Philippians will eventually be exalted by God if they will be servants now.
The final chapter of Philippians is filled with other items of "worthy living" Paul advises as they live as citizens of heaven (1:27; 3:20). [4] Their true citizenship is not on earth, tied up with any earthly city or empire. Paul tells them not be anxious about anything but to rely on God (4:6). He tells them to let others see how gentle they are (4:5). He encourages them to think about noble and uplifting things (4:8). Throughout he has a mellow spirit. His ordeal has humbled him, and we see this same spirit in 2 Corinthians, which we date not long after Paul wrote Philippians.
[1] Paul addresses at this point "my loyal companion" or "my loyal yokefellow." Some have suggested the word yokefellow is actually this man's name, Syzygus. But we think Paul is likely referring to Epaphroditus, who probably was the one who delivered the letter of Philippians back to Philippi.
[2] Or so has argued N. T. Wright. One of his early books was a collection of articles titled The Climax of the Covenant (***), which includes articles on key texts about Christ like these verses from Philippians. Whether you agree with him or not, we put this book among the top fifty or so books one should read to master Paul's writings.
[3] With some notable exceptions. For example, James D. G. Dunn is perhaps the best known proponent of the idea that the first line is actually about Christ being the second Adam who undid the Fall (Christology in the Making ***). Adam was also in the "image of God," but he did grasp at equality with God. Jesus, in the same situation, did not grasp in that way. Dunn thus did not see any indication of Christ's pre-existence in the hymn, since it was as a human on earth that Jesus did not take advantage of being in the image of God. Most, however, have not followed Dunn's interpretation. For example, it is not clear that "form of God" means the same thing as "image of God."
However, a strong alternative to the majority position is the possibility that form of God relates to Jesus having the status of God, that is, of being God's Son. This view was most notably held by Eduard Schweizer (***). The idea that form of God has to do with status is supported by the fact that it is parallel to the phrase "form of a servant." The stanza thus comes to say that while Jesus had the status of God, he did not take advantage of that status, but instead took on the status of a servant. On this reading as well, it would not be entirely clear that Paul was referring to Jesus in some pre-existent state.
[4] N. T. Wright is at some pains to make it clear that this expression does not mean Paul is saying that we will go to heaven or spend eternity in heaven, only that heaven is where our empire is centered (***).
Ephesus at the End
If you haven't guessed, I really wanted to finish the first Paul book by the 15th, tomorrow. But I keep processing not only the details of what I think but also how to present it. I wrote the piece on Philemon, switched the order of the chapters, did half of Colossians, and finally decided to put all that stuff in the second volume. I really think Philemon in itself fits very nicely from Ephesus early in Paul's stay there (except for that comment about being an old man). But it just seems impossible--at least in writing for a more popular audience--to split up Philemon, Colossians, and Ephesians.
So I am back to chapter 9 again! Now it's titled, "Joy in the Face of Death," and it's about Philippians. I was able, however, to use a modified version of my earlier introduction to the Prison Epistles. In the end, even if you have been suffering through all these posts, you will still have to buy the book to see how it all ended up being shuffled around (and of course for the sex chapter :-).
___________
Ephesus at the End
We just quoted 2 Corinthians 1:8 above, where Paul says he had felt a "sentence of death" hanging over his head in his final days at Ephesus. Acts tells us about a silversmith named Demetrius who made shrines to the goddess Artemis (19:24). The temple of Artemis at Ephesus was one of the seven wonders of the ancient world, and you can still see a few of its pillars if you visit the ruins of the city. Acts says that Demetrius stirred up the guild of idol makers, who began to shout, "Great is Artemis of the Ephesians" until the city was all stirred up. They actually dragged some of Paul's coworkers into the theatre (which you can also still see today).
[insert picture of Ephesus theatre]
Although Acts says nothing of Demetrius bringing charges against Paul, it does mention that the city clerk brought up the possibility (19:38). We wonder if Acts is not in fact hinting at the fact that Demetrius did in fact bring up Paul on charges, and that Paul was imprisoned there at Ephesus awaiting trial for a significant amount of time. And we wonder if it was not during this time that Paul wrote Philippians, one of his most precious letters--and one in which he seems most humbled by his circumstances. Is it any surprise that, when Paul passed back through Asia, he did not stop at Ephesus, but met with its elders south of the city, in Miletus (Acts 20:16)? They come to him, and he avoids the city.
The tone of Philippians fits such an uncertain time. "For to me, living is Christ and dying is gain. If I am to live in the flesh, that means fruitful labor for me; and I do not know which I prefer. I am hard pressed between the two: my desire is to depart and be with Christ, for that is far better; but to remain in the flesh is more necessary for you" (1:21-24). Does this mood not fit what Paul says of his final days in Ephesus: "We do not want you to be unaware, brothers and sisters, of the affliction we experienced in Asia; for we were so utterly, unbearably crushed that we despaired of life itself. Indeed, we felt that we had received the sentence of death so that we would rely not on ourselves but on God who raises the dead" (2 Cor. 1:8-9)?
The logistics of Philippians also fit Ephesus better than Rome. For example, Philippians implies that news has gone back and forth between Rome and Ephesus at least four times between Paul's arrest and his writing of the letter. 1) News reached the Philippians of Paul's imprisonment. 2) They sent resources for him by way of a man named Epaphroditus. 3) Epaphroditus became ill and news of his sickness reached the Philippians. 4) News of the Philippians reaction at the illness of Epaphroditus travelled back to Paul. Certainly Paul was imprisoned long enough at Rome for news to travel back and forth this many times, even though each trip would take well over month, probably closer to two. But this back and forth would happen much more naturally between Philippi and Ephesus, perhaps only a little more than a week each way.
Paul also expresses confidence that he will ultimately be released (Phil. 1:25) and expects then to visit Philippi (2:24). He plans to send Timothy ahead with news of the outcome of his trial (2:23). Then when Timothy returns he hopes that he himself might come (2:19, 24). This is again quite a distance to wait for Timothy to get to Philippi and back from Rome. It makes much more sense from Ephesus.
Indeed, Acts does record Paul going to Philippi after leaving Ephesus. Meanwhile, Romans 15:23 tells us that Paul had no intention of ministering any more in the east when he left the region. He had his sights set on ministering even further west, in Spain (15:24). So if Paul was writing Philippians from Rome and thinking of going back east, he had changed his plans significantly from when he left the area. [1]
Mention of the imperial guard (1:13) and of Caesar's household (4:22) have easily given the impression that Paul was writing from Rome. But Ephesus was the capital of the Roman province of Asia and had a Roman proconsul seated there. He would also have imperial soldiers, and of course the entire administration of the Roman empire everywhere was part of Caesar's household, since a household included servants and all who served a "house." [2] So while these agents of Caesar would certainly be present in Rome, they were also present in Ephesus.
So while Paul could have written Philippians while imprisoned at Rome, Ephesus seems to fit the particulars of the letter as well or better. The main reason not to adopt this scenario remains one's sense of how much creativity and selection Acts employs. A quick comparison of Luke with Mark probably suffices to show Luke was not simply a passive chronographer. [3]
We thus suggest that at the end of Paul's stay at Ephesus, one of the metalworkers of the city likely brought charges against him, resulting in a prolonged imprisonment waiting to appear before the Roman proconsul. During that time he received support from the Philippian church by way of a man named Epaphroditus, who himself became deathly ill, but managed to recover. Paul writes Philippians in anticipation of his release, and promises to send Timothy with the news, as soon as Paul knows it.
[1] The same of course can be said of Philemon, where Paul tells Philemon to prepare a guest room for him (Phlm 22). If Philemon were written from Rome, it would also imply a significant change of trajectory for Paul.
[2] Thus we remember that Jesus was taken to the "praetorium" of Pilate in Jerusalem, the same word used in 1:13 is used in Mark 15:16.
[3] Or even a quick comparison of Luke 24 with Acts 1, which covers the same period.
So I am back to chapter 9 again! Now it's titled, "Joy in the Face of Death," and it's about Philippians. I was able, however, to use a modified version of my earlier introduction to the Prison Epistles. In the end, even if you have been suffering through all these posts, you will still have to buy the book to see how it all ended up being shuffled around (and of course for the sex chapter :-).
___________
Ephesus at the End
We just quoted 2 Corinthians 1:8 above, where Paul says he had felt a "sentence of death" hanging over his head in his final days at Ephesus. Acts tells us about a silversmith named Demetrius who made shrines to the goddess Artemis (19:24). The temple of Artemis at Ephesus was one of the seven wonders of the ancient world, and you can still see a few of its pillars if you visit the ruins of the city. Acts says that Demetrius stirred up the guild of idol makers, who began to shout, "Great is Artemis of the Ephesians" until the city was all stirred up. They actually dragged some of Paul's coworkers into the theatre (which you can also still see today).
[insert picture of Ephesus theatre]
Although Acts says nothing of Demetrius bringing charges against Paul, it does mention that the city clerk brought up the possibility (19:38). We wonder if Acts is not in fact hinting at the fact that Demetrius did in fact bring up Paul on charges, and that Paul was imprisoned there at Ephesus awaiting trial for a significant amount of time. And we wonder if it was not during this time that Paul wrote Philippians, one of his most precious letters--and one in which he seems most humbled by his circumstances. Is it any surprise that, when Paul passed back through Asia, he did not stop at Ephesus, but met with its elders south of the city, in Miletus (Acts 20:16)? They come to him, and he avoids the city.
The tone of Philippians fits such an uncertain time. "For to me, living is Christ and dying is gain. If I am to live in the flesh, that means fruitful labor for me; and I do not know which I prefer. I am hard pressed between the two: my desire is to depart and be with Christ, for that is far better; but to remain in the flesh is more necessary for you" (1:21-24). Does this mood not fit what Paul says of his final days in Ephesus: "We do not want you to be unaware, brothers and sisters, of the affliction we experienced in Asia; for we were so utterly, unbearably crushed that we despaired of life itself. Indeed, we felt that we had received the sentence of death so that we would rely not on ourselves but on God who raises the dead" (2 Cor. 1:8-9)?
The logistics of Philippians also fit Ephesus better than Rome. For example, Philippians implies that news has gone back and forth between Rome and Ephesus at least four times between Paul's arrest and his writing of the letter. 1) News reached the Philippians of Paul's imprisonment. 2) They sent resources for him by way of a man named Epaphroditus. 3) Epaphroditus became ill and news of his sickness reached the Philippians. 4) News of the Philippians reaction at the illness of Epaphroditus travelled back to Paul. Certainly Paul was imprisoned long enough at Rome for news to travel back and forth this many times, even though each trip would take well over month, probably closer to two. But this back and forth would happen much more naturally between Philippi and Ephesus, perhaps only a little more than a week each way.
Paul also expresses confidence that he will ultimately be released (Phil. 1:25) and expects then to visit Philippi (2:24). He plans to send Timothy ahead with news of the outcome of his trial (2:23). Then when Timothy returns he hopes that he himself might come (2:19, 24). This is again quite a distance to wait for Timothy to get to Philippi and back from Rome. It makes much more sense from Ephesus.
Indeed, Acts does record Paul going to Philippi after leaving Ephesus. Meanwhile, Romans 15:23 tells us that Paul had no intention of ministering any more in the east when he left the region. He had his sights set on ministering even further west, in Spain (15:24). So if Paul was writing Philippians from Rome and thinking of going back east, he had changed his plans significantly from when he left the area. [1]
Mention of the imperial guard (1:13) and of Caesar's household (4:22) have easily given the impression that Paul was writing from Rome. But Ephesus was the capital of the Roman province of Asia and had a Roman proconsul seated there. He would also have imperial soldiers, and of course the entire administration of the Roman empire everywhere was part of Caesar's household, since a household included servants and all who served a "house." [2] So while these agents of Caesar would certainly be present in Rome, they were also present in Ephesus.
So while Paul could have written Philippians while imprisoned at Rome, Ephesus seems to fit the particulars of the letter as well or better. The main reason not to adopt this scenario remains one's sense of how much creativity and selection Acts employs. A quick comparison of Luke with Mark probably suffices to show Luke was not simply a passive chronographer. [3]
We thus suggest that at the end of Paul's stay at Ephesus, one of the metalworkers of the city likely brought charges against him, resulting in a prolonged imprisonment waiting to appear before the Roman proconsul. During that time he received support from the Philippian church by way of a man named Epaphroditus, who himself became deathly ill, but managed to recover. Paul writes Philippians in anticipation of his release, and promises to send Timothy with the news, as soon as Paul knows it.
[1] The same of course can be said of Philemon, where Paul tells Philemon to prepare a guest room for him (Phlm 22). If Philemon were written from Rome, it would also imply a significant change of trajectory for Paul.
[2] Thus we remember that Jesus was taken to the "praetorium" of Pilate in Jerusalem, the same word used in 1:13 is used in Mark 15:16.
[3] Or even a quick comparison of Luke 24 with Acts 1, which covers the same period.
Philemon (Fighting Wild Beasts 2)
For the first entry of this chapter, see Imprisoned at Ephesus.
Philemon
This short letter only gives a few hints of its setting, but it gives enough for us to get the general picture. Paul calls himself a prisoner in verses 1 and 9, and mentions someone named Epaphras as his "fellow prisoner" in verse 23. More to the point, Paul mentions that he led Onesimus to faith while imprisoned (10) and indicates how helpful Onesimus has been to him throughout his imprisonment (13). Thus we conclude that Paul is in prison when he writes this letter.
Colossians 4:12 indicates that Epaphras was from the city of Colossae, to which Colossians is addressed. Indeed, Colossians and Philemon have in common other names like Mark, Aristarchus, Demas, Luke (Col. 4:10-14; Phlm 24) and Archippus (Col. 4:17; Phlm 2). Most have thus concluded that Philemon, to whom the letter is addressed, lived in Colossae, a city about a hundred miles east of Ephesus. [1]
If we leave Colossians out of consideration, the question of whether Paul was imprisoned in Ephesus or Rome when he wrote Philemon focuses on two things: 1) the proximity between Ephesus and Colossae and 2) Paul's apparent expectation that he will visit Colossae soon (Phlm 22). It is certainly possible that a slave from Colossae might find his way to Rome. Indeed, this slave Onesimus might have come to Rome with individuals like Epaphras and Aristarchus who were specifically sent there from the church at Colossae to aid Paul.
But in the end, it is far more likely that the church at Colossae would send help to Paul at Ephesus than at Rome. Rome was well over a thousand miles from Colossae and, depending on the route and time of year, could take months to get there. We can easily imagine the church hearing Paul was in prison and sending a group to him on a five or six day journey, especially if one of their own, Epaphras, had been arrested along with Paul. It is harder to imagine them sending the same group on a two month journey. And Paul apparently hopes Philemon will send Onesimus back to him (Phlm 14)--a four or five month expectation if Paul is in Rome.
Perhaps even more problematic is Paul's apparent plan to come to Colossae when he tells Philemon to prepare him a guest room (Phlm 22). Paul certainly was not thinking about heading back east when he had left the area. In Romans 15:23, Paul says there is no more room for him to work in the east, and he clearly has his eyes on a mission to Spain (Rom. 15:24). It is possible that Paul changed his mind during some four years of imprisonment in Caesarea and Rome, or that he does not really mean to come. After all, he does call himself an "old man" in Philemon 8. But if we take Paul straightforwardly, a plan to visit Colossae fits much better with an early imprisonment at Ephesus than with his time in Rome.
It is not entirely clear what exactly Onesimus had done to anger his master Philemon. It has often been suggested that he was a run-away (cf. Phlm 15), but there are other possibilities. For example, Philemon might have been upset with Onesimus because he had failed at some task. Perhaps he had been unsuccessful at some matter of business and had lost his master money of some significance. After all, Paul tells Philemon that he will pay for any loss he has suffered as a result of Onesimus (Phlm 18). And of course for this reason Onesimus might have stayed away for a bit.
We should not think of slaves in the ancient Mediterranean on quite the same terms as Americans think about slavery in the south before the Civil War. For one thing, race was not a defining feature in ancient slavery, although certainly the Romans did enslave foreigners when they defeated them. And while there were slaves of the servile sort that existed in the American South, many slaves in the ancient world were highly educated and functioned much more like an employee than as an absolute servant. It is quite possible that Onesimus was of this sort.
In any case, Onesimus had somehow angered Philemon. Since Paul speaks of sending Onesimus back to his owner, it would not seem that Onesimus met Paul because he himself had been imprisoned. Rather, it would seem that Onesimus sought Paul out to serve as a go-between with his master--or perhaps he ran into Paul seeking out Epaphras as a go-between. Slaves in trouble with their masters sometimes sought out a go-between in hope that the mediator might soften their owner's reception of them. For example, in the case of a runaway slave, the owner had the authority to put them to death.
Paul's request of Philemon is simple: welcome him back... as he would welcome Paul himself (Phlm 17). Paul never tells Philemon to give him his freedom, although some think Philemon 21 hints at it. Paul indicates he could command him to receive him back, since after all, he would be on a path to eternal death if it were not for Paul (8-9, 19). But Paul--mind you with the entire church listening in (2)--chooses rather to ask Philemon this favor. The fact that the book of Philemon is in Scripture perhaps hints that Philemon did in fact forgive Onesimus.
Whether Philemon sent Onesimus back to Paul, whether he ever emancipated him from slavery, these things we do not know. However, it is interesting that Paul never brings up slavery as an institution. The same Paul who in Galatians 3:28 says that in Christ there is neither slave or free does not tell slave owners to begin to set them free, even when he has the opportunity. He says not to receive Onesimus back as a slave, but he qualifies it by saying to receive him as "more than a slave" (16). In other words, Onesimus becomes a slave and a brother, "more than" a slave but a slave still.
Similarly, Paul says he knows Philemon will do more than he is asking (21). This statement could allude to emancipation, but perhaps it refers more likely to sending Onesimus back to continue helping provide for Paul in his imprisonment. In the end, it is probably our post-Civil War glasses that lead us to read more into Philemon than it actually says about giving Onesimus his freedom.
Yet few of us would now second guess the decisions of Western nations like Britain and the U.S. to do away with slavery. Certainly there were many Christians in the early 1800s who used the Bible and books like Philemon to argue that slavery was perfectly compatible with Christian faith. Some of them in fact criticized the way slave owning was often practiced, while not condemning the institution itself. They found in the Bible no basis for ending the institution, only a basis for reforming its practice. It would be easy to condemn these well-meaning individuals, but with a little effort we can see that they were conscientiously following their understanding of the Bible.
We would argue that we face a similar situation with women today, where many individuals conscientiously find no basis for women in ministry or for a structure in the home that does not always have the husband at the helm. This matter of looking beyond the letter of certain passages to where Scripture as a whole is a difficult business, the stuff of prophets, and not everyone is a prophet. Yet despite certain differences, we would argue that the situation is very similar. Slavery was a social institution of the broader culture then, just as patriarchal structures were. The heavenly principle was then as now no hierarchical distinction in the kingdom between slave and free, male or female. Nevertheless, Paul made concessions in the name of order and of keeping to the priorities of spreading the gospel.
Yet we suspect that Christians a hundred years from now will also find it hard to think well of those who sincerely oppose women in ministry today. How could they not have seen that the full place of women in the church and the home was the obvious outworking of the gospel? After all, there is no physical, intellectual, or psychological basis for such differentiation. Hopefully they will be charitable just as we should to those who could not see where God was leading 150 years ago.
An even more fundamental take-away from Philemon is the need for forgiveness toward one another. We do not really know what Philemon's temperament as a person was. Maybe he was a hard task-master. Maybe his expectations were unreasonable. Whatever the case, Paul presumably knew he was asking a lot of Philemon, to forgive this slave who had so wronged him, at least in his eyes.
It is often easy for us to forgive others, especially when it is not something that matters much to us. In fact, some people are so apologetic for minor things that they almost need forgiveness for asking our forgiveness too much! But Philemon is a reminder of our need to show forgiveness on the big things, the things that do matter a lot to us. I would like to think that God and I together, alone could work out that level of forgiveness on our own. But sometimes God has to use an outsider, like Paul, to come in and exert some pressure. I know what I think Philemon decided, as Archippus, Apphia, and the entire church at Colossae heard this letter read in their public assembly, and turned to Philemon to see what he would say.
[1] John Knox ingeniously suggested that it was actually Archippus who was the slave owner who lived at Colossae and that the letter of Philemon was in fact the lost letter to the Laodiceans mentioned in Colossians 4:16. Philemon would thus have been the overseer of the church at Laodicea. Few have followed Knox's suggestion (Philemon among the Letters of Paul, 91-108).
Philemon
This short letter only gives a few hints of its setting, but it gives enough for us to get the general picture. Paul calls himself a prisoner in verses 1 and 9, and mentions someone named Epaphras as his "fellow prisoner" in verse 23. More to the point, Paul mentions that he led Onesimus to faith while imprisoned (10) and indicates how helpful Onesimus has been to him throughout his imprisonment (13). Thus we conclude that Paul is in prison when he writes this letter.
Colossians 4:12 indicates that Epaphras was from the city of Colossae, to which Colossians is addressed. Indeed, Colossians and Philemon have in common other names like Mark, Aristarchus, Demas, Luke (Col. 4:10-14; Phlm 24) and Archippus (Col. 4:17; Phlm 2). Most have thus concluded that Philemon, to whom the letter is addressed, lived in Colossae, a city about a hundred miles east of Ephesus. [1]
If we leave Colossians out of consideration, the question of whether Paul was imprisoned in Ephesus or Rome when he wrote Philemon focuses on two things: 1) the proximity between Ephesus and Colossae and 2) Paul's apparent expectation that he will visit Colossae soon (Phlm 22). It is certainly possible that a slave from Colossae might find his way to Rome. Indeed, this slave Onesimus might have come to Rome with individuals like Epaphras and Aristarchus who were specifically sent there from the church at Colossae to aid Paul.
But in the end, it is far more likely that the church at Colossae would send help to Paul at Ephesus than at Rome. Rome was well over a thousand miles from Colossae and, depending on the route and time of year, could take months to get there. We can easily imagine the church hearing Paul was in prison and sending a group to him on a five or six day journey, especially if one of their own, Epaphras, had been arrested along with Paul. It is harder to imagine them sending the same group on a two month journey. And Paul apparently hopes Philemon will send Onesimus back to him (Phlm 14)--a four or five month expectation if Paul is in Rome.
Perhaps even more problematic is Paul's apparent plan to come to Colossae when he tells Philemon to prepare him a guest room (Phlm 22). Paul certainly was not thinking about heading back east when he had left the area. In Romans 15:23, Paul says there is no more room for him to work in the east, and he clearly has his eyes on a mission to Spain (Rom. 15:24). It is possible that Paul changed his mind during some four years of imprisonment in Caesarea and Rome, or that he does not really mean to come. After all, he does call himself an "old man" in Philemon 8. But if we take Paul straightforwardly, a plan to visit Colossae fits much better with an early imprisonment at Ephesus than with his time in Rome.
It is not entirely clear what exactly Onesimus had done to anger his master Philemon. It has often been suggested that he was a run-away (cf. Phlm 15), but there are other possibilities. For example, Philemon might have been upset with Onesimus because he had failed at some task. Perhaps he had been unsuccessful at some matter of business and had lost his master money of some significance. After all, Paul tells Philemon that he will pay for any loss he has suffered as a result of Onesimus (Phlm 18). And of course for this reason Onesimus might have stayed away for a bit.
We should not think of slaves in the ancient Mediterranean on quite the same terms as Americans think about slavery in the south before the Civil War. For one thing, race was not a defining feature in ancient slavery, although certainly the Romans did enslave foreigners when they defeated them. And while there were slaves of the servile sort that existed in the American South, many slaves in the ancient world were highly educated and functioned much more like an employee than as an absolute servant. It is quite possible that Onesimus was of this sort.
In any case, Onesimus had somehow angered Philemon. Since Paul speaks of sending Onesimus back to his owner, it would not seem that Onesimus met Paul because he himself had been imprisoned. Rather, it would seem that Onesimus sought Paul out to serve as a go-between with his master--or perhaps he ran into Paul seeking out Epaphras as a go-between. Slaves in trouble with their masters sometimes sought out a go-between in hope that the mediator might soften their owner's reception of them. For example, in the case of a runaway slave, the owner had the authority to put them to death.
Paul's request of Philemon is simple: welcome him back... as he would welcome Paul himself (Phlm 17). Paul never tells Philemon to give him his freedom, although some think Philemon 21 hints at it. Paul indicates he could command him to receive him back, since after all, he would be on a path to eternal death if it were not for Paul (8-9, 19). But Paul--mind you with the entire church listening in (2)--chooses rather to ask Philemon this favor. The fact that the book of Philemon is in Scripture perhaps hints that Philemon did in fact forgive Onesimus.
Whether Philemon sent Onesimus back to Paul, whether he ever emancipated him from slavery, these things we do not know. However, it is interesting that Paul never brings up slavery as an institution. The same Paul who in Galatians 3:28 says that in Christ there is neither slave or free does not tell slave owners to begin to set them free, even when he has the opportunity. He says not to receive Onesimus back as a slave, but he qualifies it by saying to receive him as "more than a slave" (16). In other words, Onesimus becomes a slave and a brother, "more than" a slave but a slave still.
Similarly, Paul says he knows Philemon will do more than he is asking (21). This statement could allude to emancipation, but perhaps it refers more likely to sending Onesimus back to continue helping provide for Paul in his imprisonment. In the end, it is probably our post-Civil War glasses that lead us to read more into Philemon than it actually says about giving Onesimus his freedom.
Yet few of us would now second guess the decisions of Western nations like Britain and the U.S. to do away with slavery. Certainly there were many Christians in the early 1800s who used the Bible and books like Philemon to argue that slavery was perfectly compatible with Christian faith. Some of them in fact criticized the way slave owning was often practiced, while not condemning the institution itself. They found in the Bible no basis for ending the institution, only a basis for reforming its practice. It would be easy to condemn these well-meaning individuals, but with a little effort we can see that they were conscientiously following their understanding of the Bible.
We would argue that we face a similar situation with women today, where many individuals conscientiously find no basis for women in ministry or for a structure in the home that does not always have the husband at the helm. This matter of looking beyond the letter of certain passages to where Scripture as a whole is a difficult business, the stuff of prophets, and not everyone is a prophet. Yet despite certain differences, we would argue that the situation is very similar. Slavery was a social institution of the broader culture then, just as patriarchal structures were. The heavenly principle was then as now no hierarchical distinction in the kingdom between slave and free, male or female. Nevertheless, Paul made concessions in the name of order and of keeping to the priorities of spreading the gospel.
Yet we suspect that Christians a hundred years from now will also find it hard to think well of those who sincerely oppose women in ministry today. How could they not have seen that the full place of women in the church and the home was the obvious outworking of the gospel? After all, there is no physical, intellectual, or psychological basis for such differentiation. Hopefully they will be charitable just as we should to those who could not see where God was leading 150 years ago.
An even more fundamental take-away from Philemon is the need for forgiveness toward one another. We do not really know what Philemon's temperament as a person was. Maybe he was a hard task-master. Maybe his expectations were unreasonable. Whatever the case, Paul presumably knew he was asking a lot of Philemon, to forgive this slave who had so wronged him, at least in his eyes.
It is often easy for us to forgive others, especially when it is not something that matters much to us. In fact, some people are so apologetic for minor things that they almost need forgiveness for asking our forgiveness too much! But Philemon is a reminder of our need to show forgiveness on the big things, the things that do matter a lot to us. I would like to think that God and I together, alone could work out that level of forgiveness on our own. But sometimes God has to use an outsider, like Paul, to come in and exert some pressure. I know what I think Philemon decided, as Archippus, Apphia, and the entire church at Colossae heard this letter read in their public assembly, and turned to Philemon to see what he would say.
[1] John Knox ingeniously suggested that it was actually Archippus who was the slave owner who lived at Colossae and that the letter of Philemon was in fact the lost letter to the Laodiceans mentioned in Colossians 4:16. Philemon would thus have been the overseer of the church at Laodicea. Few have followed Knox's suggestion (Philemon among the Letters of Paul, 91-108).
Fighting Wild Beasts (Philemon and Colossians)
To follow the thread of this writing project back, the previous post is here.
_______________
Imprisoned at Ephesus?
Four of the Pauline letters in the New Testament hint that they were written while Paul was in prison: Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians, and Philemon. [1] Traditionally, it has been thought that Paul wrote these from Rome while he was waiting to appear before the emperor Nero (cf. Acts 28:30-31). Of course none of them say where Paul was imprisoned, so various scholars have suggested other places Paul might have been when he wrote them, like Caesarea in Palestine or Ephesus in Asia Minor.
When thinking about these letters, it is important to realize that prison was not a punishment in the ancient world. Rather, a person went to prison as they waited to appear before the appropriate official. Then punishment was dispensed immediately when a verdict was reached, including possibilities like death, exile, or fines. While a person awaited their appearance, they would have to find someone on the outside to provide them with food and other necessities.
The book of Acts only tells of two imprisonments of any length of time: about two years in Caesarea after Paul was arrested in Jerusalem (ca. AD58-60) and then about two years under house arrest in Rome (ca. AD60-62). Acts also mentions a stint overnight in Philippi (16:23-39), and we cannot rule out the possibility that he spent a day or two in Corinth before he appeared before the Roman governor Gallio (Acts 18:12-17). 1 Clement, from the end of the first century, suggests Paul was imprisoned seven times (**). Although we cannot know if this number is correct, it is at least possible that Paul was imprisoned a few more times as well.
In particular, it is often suggested that Paul might have been imprisoned for a period of time during the some three years he was at Ephesus. Some strongly resist this idea because Acts does not tell us of any imprisonment at this time. Acts does tell of a rather serious incident at the end of Paul's stay at Ephesus involving a riot, but it merely says that Paul left Ephesus, "after the uproar had ceased" (20:1). Those who see Acts as an almost documentary style report of events might thus find it hard to think it would have put it this way if in fact Paul had a rather significant run in with the law at the time.
Nevertheless, there are good reasons to think that Acts is not just giving a videotape of the early church but is both presenting the story with creative artistry and emphasizing some things in a way that leads it to omit others. For example, in the incident where Paul was lowered down the side of Damascus in a basket, Acts only tells us that the Jews were plotting to kill him (9:23). It is only from Paul himself that we learn it was more the Arab ethnarch of the city under the Nabatean king Aretas IV who was trying to arrest him (2 Cor. 11:32). This was after a three year period involving some time spent in Arabia--likely in Aretas' kingdom. Acts tells us nothing of this sort. This is only one incident, but it may reflect a tendency on Acts' part to de-emphasize conflicts between the early Christians and Roman authorities and to emphasize "the Jews" as Paul's primary troublemakers.
Paul's own writings give us hints not only of one run in with the Romans at Ephesus, but possibly even two. Even as early during his stay there as 1 Corinthians, he mentions having fought with "wild animals" at Ephesus (15:32). No one takes this statement literally, since then Paul presumably would be dead. But surely the most likely way to take the statement is that Paul had some significant run in with the Roman authorities early in his stay at Ephesus.
But Paul alludes to an even more serious encounter with authorities around the time of the riot. In 2 Corinthians 1:8, just after he left Ephesus, Paul speaks of "the affliction we experienced in Asia." He goes on to say that, "we were so utterly, unbearably crushed that we despaired of life itself. Indeed, we felt that we had received the sentence of death." This sentiment seems stronger than merely being afraid he will be killed in a riot. It sounds rather more like Philippians 1 where Paul is hard pressed in his imprisonment to know whether he would rather have a verdict of death and go to be with Christ or whether it would be better for him to be acquitted (Phil. 1:21-24).
It may very well be, therefore, that Paul wrote all four of his "prison epistles" from Rome, but it is just as possible that he wrote some or all of them while he was imprisoned at Ephesus. We have decided to treat three of Paul's prison letters in this volume (Philemon, Colossians, and Philippians), then Ephesians in the next. We were torn about dividing them, since Ephesians has so many parallels to Colossians that it is also sometimes placed during the same imprisonment as Colossians. Similarly, while Ephesus seems a more likely place for Paul to write Philemon, Rome perhaps seems more likely for Colossians.
But for practical reasons, we have decided to look at Philemon, Colossians, and Philippians in this volume, picturing them in the context of Ephesus. We may take a moment in the next volume to ask what they might look like in the context of Rome a few years later. In this chapter in particular, we want to explore what it would look like for Philemon and Colossians to be written rather early during Paul's stay at Ephesus, not long after he arrived. The title of this chapter is thus an allusion to 1 Corinthians 15:32 and the possibility that Paul was imprisoned briefly even before he wrote 1 Corinthians. Then we will look at Philippians later in chapter 10. These settings do not change the message too greatly, but having such specific settings in mind might help us read the letters more vividly.
[1] This order has nothing to do with the order in which they were written but with their length. The earliest nearly complete manuscript of Paul's writings has them ordered from longest to shortest, with Hebrews second.
_______________
Imprisoned at Ephesus?
Four of the Pauline letters in the New Testament hint that they were written while Paul was in prison: Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians, and Philemon. [1] Traditionally, it has been thought that Paul wrote these from Rome while he was waiting to appear before the emperor Nero (cf. Acts 28:30-31). Of course none of them say where Paul was imprisoned, so various scholars have suggested other places Paul might have been when he wrote them, like Caesarea in Palestine or Ephesus in Asia Minor.
When thinking about these letters, it is important to realize that prison was not a punishment in the ancient world. Rather, a person went to prison as they waited to appear before the appropriate official. Then punishment was dispensed immediately when a verdict was reached, including possibilities like death, exile, or fines. While a person awaited their appearance, they would have to find someone on the outside to provide them with food and other necessities.
The book of Acts only tells of two imprisonments of any length of time: about two years in Caesarea after Paul was arrested in Jerusalem (ca. AD58-60) and then about two years under house arrest in Rome (ca. AD60-62). Acts also mentions a stint overnight in Philippi (16:23-39), and we cannot rule out the possibility that he spent a day or two in Corinth before he appeared before the Roman governor Gallio (Acts 18:12-17). 1 Clement, from the end of the first century, suggests Paul was imprisoned seven times (**). Although we cannot know if this number is correct, it is at least possible that Paul was imprisoned a few more times as well.
In particular, it is often suggested that Paul might have been imprisoned for a period of time during the some three years he was at Ephesus. Some strongly resist this idea because Acts does not tell us of any imprisonment at this time. Acts does tell of a rather serious incident at the end of Paul's stay at Ephesus involving a riot, but it merely says that Paul left Ephesus, "after the uproar had ceased" (20:1). Those who see Acts as an almost documentary style report of events might thus find it hard to think it would have put it this way if in fact Paul had a rather significant run in with the law at the time.
Nevertheless, there are good reasons to think that Acts is not just giving a videotape of the early church but is both presenting the story with creative artistry and emphasizing some things in a way that leads it to omit others. For example, in the incident where Paul was lowered down the side of Damascus in a basket, Acts only tells us that the Jews were plotting to kill him (9:23). It is only from Paul himself that we learn it was more the Arab ethnarch of the city under the Nabatean king Aretas IV who was trying to arrest him (2 Cor. 11:32). This was after a three year period involving some time spent in Arabia--likely in Aretas' kingdom. Acts tells us nothing of this sort. This is only one incident, but it may reflect a tendency on Acts' part to de-emphasize conflicts between the early Christians and Roman authorities and to emphasize "the Jews" as Paul's primary troublemakers.
Paul's own writings give us hints not only of one run in with the Romans at Ephesus, but possibly even two. Even as early during his stay there as 1 Corinthians, he mentions having fought with "wild animals" at Ephesus (15:32). No one takes this statement literally, since then Paul presumably would be dead. But surely the most likely way to take the statement is that Paul had some significant run in with the Roman authorities early in his stay at Ephesus.
But Paul alludes to an even more serious encounter with authorities around the time of the riot. In 2 Corinthians 1:8, just after he left Ephesus, Paul speaks of "the affliction we experienced in Asia." He goes on to say that, "we were so utterly, unbearably crushed that we despaired of life itself. Indeed, we felt that we had received the sentence of death." This sentiment seems stronger than merely being afraid he will be killed in a riot. It sounds rather more like Philippians 1 where Paul is hard pressed in his imprisonment to know whether he would rather have a verdict of death and go to be with Christ or whether it would be better for him to be acquitted (Phil. 1:21-24).
It may very well be, therefore, that Paul wrote all four of his "prison epistles" from Rome, but it is just as possible that he wrote some or all of them while he was imprisoned at Ephesus. We have decided to treat three of Paul's prison letters in this volume (Philemon, Colossians, and Philippians), then Ephesians in the next. We were torn about dividing them, since Ephesians has so many parallels to Colossians that it is also sometimes placed during the same imprisonment as Colossians. Similarly, while Ephesus seems a more likely place for Paul to write Philemon, Rome perhaps seems more likely for Colossians.
But for practical reasons, we have decided to look at Philemon, Colossians, and Philippians in this volume, picturing them in the context of Ephesus. We may take a moment in the next volume to ask what they might look like in the context of Rome a few years later. In this chapter in particular, we want to explore what it would look like for Philemon and Colossians to be written rather early during Paul's stay at Ephesus, not long after he arrived. The title of this chapter is thus an allusion to 1 Corinthians 15:32 and the possibility that Paul was imprisoned briefly even before he wrote 1 Corinthians. Then we will look at Philippians later in chapter 10. These settings do not change the message too greatly, but having such specific settings in mind might help us read the letters more vividly.
[1] This order has nothing to do with the order in which they were written but with their length. The earliest nearly complete manuscript of Paul's writings has them ordered from longest to shortest, with Hebrews second.
Sunday, December 13, 2009
Reflecting on Galatians (Mutiny 3)
The entries for this chapter draft have been:
The Setting of Galatians
The Message of Galatians
Mid-stream the dam of my mind broke and I surrendered the North Galatian hypothesis, due mainly to the prodding of Richard Fellows this past year. So the first entry above will be edited appropriately. Still many questions, of course.
___________
Reflections
Normally, those applying the book of Galatians immediately talk about the freedom we have in Christ from the oppression of our sin and failure. We do not have to worry about being good enough or smart enough, because God likes us. Certainly there is a lot of truth to these applications. Certainly we should be immensely grateful for a God who is gracious and compassionate, slow to anger and abounding in love (Jonah 4:2). As Paul says in Romans 4:7-8, quoting Psalm 32, "Blessed are those whose iniquities are forgiven, and whose sins are covered; blessed is the one against whom the Lord will not reckon sin."
At the same time, this teaching has often been presented in incorrect and unhelpful ways. For example, Paul has often been pitted against a legalistic Judaism that believed you had to earn your right status with God. Against this idea of "works-righteousness," they say, Paul comes with the revelation that you cannot be saved by your good works but by faith alone. Similarly, Martin Luther is championed by Protestants as setting the Roman Catholic Church straight, where he like Paul recognized the truth of justification by faith alone while the Catholics believed good works were necessary for salvation.
Again, there is some truth to these scenarios, although they do skew history a little. For example, the Jewish literature we have from the ancient world generally shows that Jews also believed it was only the grace of God that made a good relationship with God possible for them. They of course put a high premium on living a righteous life in response to God's grace, but so does the New Testament, if we are willing to listen to it. [1] The main difference is the centrality of Christ in procuring God's favor and the way Paul emphasizes the Holy Spirit as how one is empowered to live that righteous life.
The Roman Catholic Church has also dialogued significantly with the Lutheran Church in recent years and has acknowledged that justification is first and foremost on the basis of faith. [2] But it also insists that good works must follow for final salvation. When we get to 2 Corinthians in chapter 10 and then later come to Romans in our second volume, however, we will find that Paul himself says some similar things. Paul never actually uses the expression "justification by faith alone." That phrase comes rather from Martin Luther. [3]
Galatians does carry a warning to the legalistic. Legalism is not a matter of being conservative or being strict in your lifestyle. Legalism is an attitude that enjoys rules for their own sake and puts rules above the people they are meant to benefit. If Paul seems a little inconsistent, it is because he knows what God wants but brings different arguments at different times to get his audiences there. So he knows the Gentiles can be in by faith. He knows that Jewish and Gentile Christian should eat together. He wrestles to show these truths in the different situational arguments of his letters. [4]
One way we might summarize Paul's argument here is that people trump the rules, even sometimes the rules of Scripture. The purity regulations that drove the argument between Paul and Peter at Antioch were surely over how to play out the purity regulations of Leviticus. But the rule of the unity of Christians required that exceptions be made to those rules. Indeed, Galatians 4:9 seems shockingly to equate keeping the Jewish Law with enslavement to evil spiritual forces that hold power over the basic elements of the world.
Certainly Paul was an apostle, and we are not, but he shows at times a shocking liberty in the way he reinterprets Scripture to counteract his opponents. One of the most striking is his allegorical interpretation of Sarah and Hagar, the wife and concubine of Abraham respectively. Perhaps his opponents have used them as a parable of Jew and Gentile. Paul counters by allegorically considering Sarah the heavenly Jerusalem with Hagar the earthly one. Those who put too much primacy on the earthly city are enslaved like Hagar, while those who are part of the heavenly Jerusalem are free like Sarah.
Galatians is thus more than a reminder that God does not strictly judge us on how good we are but on our willingness to trust in His mercy. It is a reminder that, in our attempt to serve God, we can subtly find ourselves using Scripture and our traditions to undermine God's more fundamental purposes. The "fundamentalist" interpreters of the early 1800s had great biblical arguments why slavery was a perfectly legitimate Christian institution. Do not the household codes of Colossians and 1 Peter assume slavery and tell slaves to obey their masters? It was those like Paul who were able to see the more fundamental spiritual principles--more central than random verses--who pushed back against slavery. And so we have moved closer to the kingdom.
A similar battle is currently in play between those who believe God might call women to play any role of any kind in the church or the home. Once again, they have their verses in the household codes or in 1 Timothy. But there is little doubt in my mind as to where the church as a whole will move soon enough, following the more fundamental principle that "in Christ there is not male and female" (Gal. 3:28, my translation).
Another important principle we will return to both in this volume and the next is the importance of not allowing one's freedom to become an opportunity for sin. Galatians 5:16 is quite stark, "Walk in the Spirit and you certainly will not fulfill the desires of the flesh" (my translation). Here we find no pessimism of regular moral failure, no sense of sinning every day in word, thought, and deed. What we find rather is an optimism of the Spirit's power, that if we will only open ourselves up to the empowerment of the Spirit, we will find the fruit of the Spirit permeating our lives.
[1] Thus E. P. Sanders' famous line, keeping the Law for Jews was "about staying in, not getting in." We add to our list of books to master Paul the follow up to his first book, Paul, the Law, and the Jewish People (**).
[2] "Joint Declaration" ***.
[3] Indeed, the only place we find this expression is in James, which says that a person is not justified by faith alone (Jas. 2:24).
[4] Sanders put it this way, Paul argues from solution to problem. He knows that Christ is the answer, but he struggles to express the precise nature of the problem Christ solves. See his Paul (**).
The Setting of Galatians
The Message of Galatians
Mid-stream the dam of my mind broke and I surrendered the North Galatian hypothesis, due mainly to the prodding of Richard Fellows this past year. So the first entry above will be edited appropriately. Still many questions, of course.
___________
Reflections
Normally, those applying the book of Galatians immediately talk about the freedom we have in Christ from the oppression of our sin and failure. We do not have to worry about being good enough or smart enough, because God likes us. Certainly there is a lot of truth to these applications. Certainly we should be immensely grateful for a God who is gracious and compassionate, slow to anger and abounding in love (Jonah 4:2). As Paul says in Romans 4:7-8, quoting Psalm 32, "Blessed are those whose iniquities are forgiven, and whose sins are covered; blessed is the one against whom the Lord will not reckon sin."
At the same time, this teaching has often been presented in incorrect and unhelpful ways. For example, Paul has often been pitted against a legalistic Judaism that believed you had to earn your right status with God. Against this idea of "works-righteousness," they say, Paul comes with the revelation that you cannot be saved by your good works but by faith alone. Similarly, Martin Luther is championed by Protestants as setting the Roman Catholic Church straight, where he like Paul recognized the truth of justification by faith alone while the Catholics believed good works were necessary for salvation.
Again, there is some truth to these scenarios, although they do skew history a little. For example, the Jewish literature we have from the ancient world generally shows that Jews also believed it was only the grace of God that made a good relationship with God possible for them. They of course put a high premium on living a righteous life in response to God's grace, but so does the New Testament, if we are willing to listen to it. [1] The main difference is the centrality of Christ in procuring God's favor and the way Paul emphasizes the Holy Spirit as how one is empowered to live that righteous life.
The Roman Catholic Church has also dialogued significantly with the Lutheran Church in recent years and has acknowledged that justification is first and foremost on the basis of faith. [2] But it also insists that good works must follow for final salvation. When we get to 2 Corinthians in chapter 10 and then later come to Romans in our second volume, however, we will find that Paul himself says some similar things. Paul never actually uses the expression "justification by faith alone." That phrase comes rather from Martin Luther. [3]
Galatians does carry a warning to the legalistic. Legalism is not a matter of being conservative or being strict in your lifestyle. Legalism is an attitude that enjoys rules for their own sake and puts rules above the people they are meant to benefit. If Paul seems a little inconsistent, it is because he knows what God wants but brings different arguments at different times to get his audiences there. So he knows the Gentiles can be in by faith. He knows that Jewish and Gentile Christian should eat together. He wrestles to show these truths in the different situational arguments of his letters. [4]
One way we might summarize Paul's argument here is that people trump the rules, even sometimes the rules of Scripture. The purity regulations that drove the argument between Paul and Peter at Antioch were surely over how to play out the purity regulations of Leviticus. But the rule of the unity of Christians required that exceptions be made to those rules. Indeed, Galatians 4:9 seems shockingly to equate keeping the Jewish Law with enslavement to evil spiritual forces that hold power over the basic elements of the world.
Certainly Paul was an apostle, and we are not, but he shows at times a shocking liberty in the way he reinterprets Scripture to counteract his opponents. One of the most striking is his allegorical interpretation of Sarah and Hagar, the wife and concubine of Abraham respectively. Perhaps his opponents have used them as a parable of Jew and Gentile. Paul counters by allegorically considering Sarah the heavenly Jerusalem with Hagar the earthly one. Those who put too much primacy on the earthly city are enslaved like Hagar, while those who are part of the heavenly Jerusalem are free like Sarah.
Galatians is thus more than a reminder that God does not strictly judge us on how good we are but on our willingness to trust in His mercy. It is a reminder that, in our attempt to serve God, we can subtly find ourselves using Scripture and our traditions to undermine God's more fundamental purposes. The "fundamentalist" interpreters of the early 1800s had great biblical arguments why slavery was a perfectly legitimate Christian institution. Do not the household codes of Colossians and 1 Peter assume slavery and tell slaves to obey their masters? It was those like Paul who were able to see the more fundamental spiritual principles--more central than random verses--who pushed back against slavery. And so we have moved closer to the kingdom.
A similar battle is currently in play between those who believe God might call women to play any role of any kind in the church or the home. Once again, they have their verses in the household codes or in 1 Timothy. But there is little doubt in my mind as to where the church as a whole will move soon enough, following the more fundamental principle that "in Christ there is not male and female" (Gal. 3:28, my translation).
Another important principle we will return to both in this volume and the next is the importance of not allowing one's freedom to become an opportunity for sin. Galatians 5:16 is quite stark, "Walk in the Spirit and you certainly will not fulfill the desires of the flesh" (my translation). Here we find no pessimism of regular moral failure, no sense of sinning every day in word, thought, and deed. What we find rather is an optimism of the Spirit's power, that if we will only open ourselves up to the empowerment of the Spirit, we will find the fruit of the Spirit permeating our lives.
[1] Thus E. P. Sanders' famous line, keeping the Law for Jews was "about staying in, not getting in." We add to our list of books to master Paul the follow up to his first book, Paul, the Law, and the Jewish People (**).
[2] "Joint Declaration" ***.
[3] Indeed, the only place we find this expression is in James, which says that a person is not justified by faith alone (Jas. 2:24).
[4] Sanders put it this way, Paul argues from solution to problem. He knows that Christ is the answer, but he struggles to express the precise nature of the problem Christ solves. See his Paul (**).
The Message of Galatians (Mutiny 2)
To follow the chain back, see the previous entry of this chapter, The Setting of Galatians.
We continue with part 2 of chapter 8: "The Message of Galatians." Last night after long consideration, I finally conceded to myself that I need to give up the northern Galatia hypothesis. In any case, I can continue the chapter...
_____________
...
So the situation Galatians addresses is a primarily Gentile audience being urged to convert fully to Judaism by undergoing circumcision. Those who are trying to convince them are most likely Christian Jews, perhaps one key person in particular, who has come to Galatia from elsewhere, quite possibly from somewhere in Palestine like Antioch. It is important to recognize that their detractors claim to be Christians, not non-believing Jews. They are like the Christian Pharisees of Acts 15:5. Paul would probably consider them "false brothers" (e.g., Gal. 2:4), but they think of themselves as believers in Christ and the Jerusalem church likely would as well.
The central issue at debate is circumcision. If the meeting we call the Jerusalem Council was widely known, it is a little strange that we would find missionaries of a sort who are teaching that the Gentiles should get circumcised. [1] But we remember that Galatians 2:3 says Titus "was not compelled" to become circumcised, meaning it was still likely James and Peter's preference. It would thus be understandable if some were telling the Galatians they should fully commit and go the whole way.
One of the more peculiar features of the situation was the fact that these missionaries were apparently claiming that Paul himself agreed with them or at least had submitted to the authority of Jerusalem. They were apparently telling the Galatians that Paul himself thought it preferable for them to become circumcised (Gal. 5:11). How they made such an argument is puzzling to us, since we so strongly associate Paul with the opposite position. Perhaps he and Barnabas were still somewhat tentative on the subject when they came through the area on the first missionary journey. After all, it was after the first journey that Paul made the visit of Galatians 2 to Jerusalem. And Acts tells us that Paul circumcised Timothy at Lystra on his second journey (Acts 16:3), which certainly could have given the impression that circumcision was the optimal scenario.
Whatever they specifically argued, the undermining of his mission clearly infuriated him. This situation was personal, and no doubt reminded him of losing the argument at Antioch. Now they were tampering with his churches in his territory. One of the noticeable features of Galatians is the fact that Paul does not have a thanksgiving section at its opening, like his other letters. Instead, he launches into the Galatians in astonishment that they are beginning to act as if God's gracious acceptance of them is somehow not enough. They are beginning to observe aspects of the Jewish calendar (Gal. 4:10) and even to consider circumcision (5:2).
Paul's counterargument is not only that no amount of such "works of Law" could make one right with God. He is arguing that such Jewish particulars have no impact on one's status with God at all, particularly if one is a Gentile. To the Gentiles, God was offering a remarkable gift. Through the faithful death of Jesus the Messiah, he was offering both Jew and Gentile the possibility of being right with God regardless of how much wrongdoing a person had previously done. To try then to earn God's favor by keeping the particulars of the Jewish Law was a slap in God's face, tantamount to a rejection of His grace.
We have fallen off the log perhaps with the majority in thinking that Paul might be at Ephesus on his third missionary journey as he writes Galatians, perhaps not too long after he wrote 1 Corinthians. While many argue Paul's theology of getting right with God may have been intact very early on in his ministry, it does not really show itself in 1 Thessalonians and hardly in 1 Corinthians. [2] But just after our placement of Galatians in our reconstruction, we hear verses like Philippians 3:9 and then 2 Corinthians 5:21, culminating in Romans. Indeed, Philippians 3 and 2 Corinthians 10-13 address similar issues that Galatians does. We have from Galatians on a deeper exploration of what it might mean to be incorporated in Christ. [3] We even hear of "new creation" in Galatians (6:15) and 2 Corinthians (5:17).
Acts tells us that Paul rented out one Hall of Tyrannus while he was at Ephesus (19:9). Is it possible that Paul ran something like a school of interpretation while he was there? Is it possible that some of the arguments in Galatians are a product of his teaching there? These suggestions are all speculation, but they are not impossible.
The Message of Galatians
The heart of the message of Galatians is thus about what, in fact, makes a person right with God. The argument of Galatians is very thick, perhaps the thickest in the whole Bible. But the basic point is that Jesus is the only way to be right with God. Arguments over whether Gentiles need to get circumcised or whether you need to observe certain days certain ways are ultimately irrelevant to being right with God. Trusting in what God has done through Jesus--that's the ticket!
Of course there are countless debates both between scholars and churches over the details. Paul would no doubt be both perplexed and amused. It might be worth it to take just a little time to spell out what Paul was likely saying so that we can avoid some of the arguments between Christian groups today over theology.
First, it is important to hear exactly what Paul is arguing over concretely. Paul says that no matter how many "works of Law" a Jew might do, it will not make them right with God. It will not "justify" you. Five hundred years ago, Martin Luther heard Paul saying very generally that no one could earn God's favor. No matter how many good "works" you did, you could not earn a right standing with God.
Luther was of course correct. Paul did believe you could not earn God's favor (e.g., Rom. 4:4-5). Whether you were a Jew or a Gentile, all had wronged God and others at some point (e.g., Gal. 2:17; Rom. 3:23), thus requiring Him to overlook our sins. In other words, we all need God's grace, His "unmerited favor."
At the same time, Luther slightly changed the focus of Paul's argument. Particularly in Galatians, Paul is not really talking about faith versus good works in general. He is talking about whether "works of Law," that is the Jewish Law, could gain you right standing before God. [2] In other words, it was things like circumcision, the purity rules of Leviticus, and sabbath observance that were in the "bubble" above his head, not good works like feeding the poor or clothing the needy. One of the documents found among the Dead Sea Scrolls has an argument over "works of Law," and the things it has in mind are squabbles between Jewish groups over what makes a person unclean, not good works.
What Paul is arguing over, therefore, is the parts of the Jewish Law that were most distinctly Jewish, the things that distinguished the Jews ethnically from other people. Around the world, people knew that Jews did not eat pork and did not work on Saturday. These were exactly the kinds of "works of Law" that Paul is targeting. These are the sorts of things at Antioch that got in the way of Jewish and Gentile believers eating together. Paul's main point in Galatians is that none of these things actually help a person get in right standing with God.
In fact, relying on such things can be a slap in Christ's face. Here God has offered a free gift through Christ's death on the cross. It is a gift so good, no one could possibly deserve it. Yet you are insistent on trying to pay for it, and you cannot accept the gift for what it is.
Peter and James apparently agreed that a person could not be in right standing with God apart from trusting in Jesus' death. Paul uses an expression in Galatians 2:16 that scholars debate over, but we think Paul is saying that both he and Peter agree that you could only be right with God if you trusted in the faithful death of Jesus on the cross that one can become right with God. [3] But where they disagreed is in the value of keeping the Jewish particulars of the Mosaic Law. Paul goes on to say that those particulars do not help a person be right with God at all, while Peter and others still saw them playing a role in "justification," in being pronounced right with God. Only trust in what God has done through Christ works.
Paul uses Abraham as his fundamental example of this principle: "justification by faith." Abraham was a superb example because Paul could use him both as a model for the justification of Jews and Gentiles. Paul interpreted Genesis 15:6 to say that Abraham had faith in God, and God considered him right with him as a result (Gal. 3:6). Thus Abraham was a model to Gentiles of how to be right with God. Have faith in what God has done through Jesus the Christ and God will consider you righteous, right with Him. Paul understood Genesis 12:3's promise that all the nations would be blessed through Abraham as a promise that they would get right with God through faith, with Abraham showing them the way (Gal. 3:8-9, 14).
Paul's opponents no doubt had some arguments of their own, and most think Paul is responding to some of them in Galatians. One of the key questions he needed to answer was what the purpose of the Jewish Law was. If it was not meant to show how to be in right relationship with God, then what was it for? Paul's answer is that the Law was like a child's guardian (Gal. 4:24) that watches over it until it comes of age.
So also, the Law served several functions before Christ came. For example, it taught us the difference between right and wrong (e.g., Rom. 7:7). Paul here has seemed to shift a little in what he is talking about. When he was talking about "works of Law," he seemed to be thinking of what many Christians think of as the ritual or "ceremonial" parts of the Jewish Law. [4] But now he is talking about the heart of the Law, what later Christians would call the "moral law." The fact that Paul can glide without notice between these various parts of the Jewish Law is the primary source of confusion over what exactly he meant.
Before Christ, we were all, Paul taught, under the power of Sin in the world. Before Christ, the Law pointed out our weakness in the face of this power (e.g., Gal. 4:3). But now that Christ has come, God's Holy Spirit is available to empower us to do what is right. We no longer need the instruction of our guardian, the Law. We have the power of the Spirit inside us to keep the essence of the (moral) Law.
Galatians thus turns to an exhortation to the Galatians not to let their freedom from works of Law to lead to sinful living. This is the tight rope Paul's theology walks. On the one hand, he argues that the Jewish particulars of the Law cannot make us right with God, nor were we able to live above sin before Christ. But now Christ has enabled us to receive the Spirit of adoption and sonship. Now if we walk in the Spirit, we will not fulfill the desires of the flesh (Gal. 5:16).
Works of law cannot make us right with God, but if we have the Spirit inside us, fruit will follow. The fruit of the Spirit are things like love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control (Gal. 5:22-23). Quite different are the works of the flesh, things like sexual immorality, strife, jealousy, anger, and so forth (5:19-21).
And so Paul closes his letter to the Galatians, likely to churches in south Galatia like Iconium, Lystra, Derbe, and Pisidian Antioch. He points out the hypocrisy of those urging them to get circumcised. They are not models of Jewish Law keeping. And Paul would know, since he was once a Pharisee who paid close attention to such things. But in the end, it is neither circumcision nor uncircumcision that matters before God, he claims. It is the new creation of the Spirit made possible through the cross of Jesus the Messiah.
[1] Even though we called them "missionaries of a sort," we are not insistent at all that the main reason they have come to Galatia is to further instruct Paul's converts. They might just as likely have come into the area on other business.
[2] Another article in James Dunn's The New Perspective on Paul is a classic here, "Works of Law," ***.
[3] The expression is "the faith of Jesus Christ." To understand the debate, you have to look at a phrase like "love of God." What does this phrase mean? Is it God's love, as in "The love of God led Him to send His Son"? Or is it our love for God, as in "Your love of God should lead you to serve Him better"? The phrase Paul uses, "faith of Jesus," could also mean either the faithfulness of Jesus or faith in Jesus.
The three main reasons I finally concluded that the first expression in Gal. 2:16 and Rom. 3:22 refer to the faithfulness of Jesus are 1) Otherwise these verses are quite redundant, Galatians 2:16 then referring to faith in Christ three times in the same sentence, 2) the parallelism between Romans 5:19--"through the obedience of one person many will be established as righteous" and finally, 3) 2 Corinthians 4:13, while the train of thought is hard to follow, seems to say that just as Jesus had faith and was resurrected, so we must have faith and be resurrected. It thus seems to substantiate the notion that Jesus' faith was indeed one of Paul's categories.
[4] It is significant to point out that a Jew, indeed Paul himself, would not not have categorized things this way.
We continue with part 2 of chapter 8: "The Message of Galatians." Last night after long consideration, I finally conceded to myself that I need to give up the northern Galatia hypothesis. In any case, I can continue the chapter...
_____________
...
So the situation Galatians addresses is a primarily Gentile audience being urged to convert fully to Judaism by undergoing circumcision. Those who are trying to convince them are most likely Christian Jews, perhaps one key person in particular, who has come to Galatia from elsewhere, quite possibly from somewhere in Palestine like Antioch. It is important to recognize that their detractors claim to be Christians, not non-believing Jews. They are like the Christian Pharisees of Acts 15:5. Paul would probably consider them "false brothers" (e.g., Gal. 2:4), but they think of themselves as believers in Christ and the Jerusalem church likely would as well.
The central issue at debate is circumcision. If the meeting we call the Jerusalem Council was widely known, it is a little strange that we would find missionaries of a sort who are teaching that the Gentiles should get circumcised. [1] But we remember that Galatians 2:3 says Titus "was not compelled" to become circumcised, meaning it was still likely James and Peter's preference. It would thus be understandable if some were telling the Galatians they should fully commit and go the whole way.
One of the more peculiar features of the situation was the fact that these missionaries were apparently claiming that Paul himself agreed with them or at least had submitted to the authority of Jerusalem. They were apparently telling the Galatians that Paul himself thought it preferable for them to become circumcised (Gal. 5:11). How they made such an argument is puzzling to us, since we so strongly associate Paul with the opposite position. Perhaps he and Barnabas were still somewhat tentative on the subject when they came through the area on the first missionary journey. After all, it was after the first journey that Paul made the visit of Galatians 2 to Jerusalem. And Acts tells us that Paul circumcised Timothy at Lystra on his second journey (Acts 16:3), which certainly could have given the impression that circumcision was the optimal scenario.
Whatever they specifically argued, the undermining of his mission clearly infuriated him. This situation was personal, and no doubt reminded him of losing the argument at Antioch. Now they were tampering with his churches in his territory. One of the noticeable features of Galatians is the fact that Paul does not have a thanksgiving section at its opening, like his other letters. Instead, he launches into the Galatians in astonishment that they are beginning to act as if God's gracious acceptance of them is somehow not enough. They are beginning to observe aspects of the Jewish calendar (Gal. 4:10) and even to consider circumcision (5:2).
Paul's counterargument is not only that no amount of such "works of Law" could make one right with God. He is arguing that such Jewish particulars have no impact on one's status with God at all, particularly if one is a Gentile. To the Gentiles, God was offering a remarkable gift. Through the faithful death of Jesus the Messiah, he was offering both Jew and Gentile the possibility of being right with God regardless of how much wrongdoing a person had previously done. To try then to earn God's favor by keeping the particulars of the Jewish Law was a slap in God's face, tantamount to a rejection of His grace.
We have fallen off the log perhaps with the majority in thinking that Paul might be at Ephesus on his third missionary journey as he writes Galatians, perhaps not too long after he wrote 1 Corinthians. While many argue Paul's theology of getting right with God may have been intact very early on in his ministry, it does not really show itself in 1 Thessalonians and hardly in 1 Corinthians. [2] But just after our placement of Galatians in our reconstruction, we hear verses like Philippians 3:9 and then 2 Corinthians 5:21, culminating in Romans. Indeed, Philippians 3 and 2 Corinthians 10-13 address similar issues that Galatians does. We have from Galatians on a deeper exploration of what it might mean to be incorporated in Christ. [3] We even hear of "new creation" in Galatians (6:15) and 2 Corinthians (5:17).
Acts tells us that Paul rented out one Hall of Tyrannus while he was at Ephesus (19:9). Is it possible that Paul ran something like a school of interpretation while he was there? Is it possible that some of the arguments in Galatians are a product of his teaching there? These suggestions are all speculation, but they are not impossible.
The Message of Galatians
The heart of the message of Galatians is thus about what, in fact, makes a person right with God. The argument of Galatians is very thick, perhaps the thickest in the whole Bible. But the basic point is that Jesus is the only way to be right with God. Arguments over whether Gentiles need to get circumcised or whether you need to observe certain days certain ways are ultimately irrelevant to being right with God. Trusting in what God has done through Jesus--that's the ticket!
Of course there are countless debates both between scholars and churches over the details. Paul would no doubt be both perplexed and amused. It might be worth it to take just a little time to spell out what Paul was likely saying so that we can avoid some of the arguments between Christian groups today over theology.
First, it is important to hear exactly what Paul is arguing over concretely. Paul says that no matter how many "works of Law" a Jew might do, it will not make them right with God. It will not "justify" you. Five hundred years ago, Martin Luther heard Paul saying very generally that no one could earn God's favor. No matter how many good "works" you did, you could not earn a right standing with God.
Luther was of course correct. Paul did believe you could not earn God's favor (e.g., Rom. 4:4-5). Whether you were a Jew or a Gentile, all had wronged God and others at some point (e.g., Gal. 2:17; Rom. 3:23), thus requiring Him to overlook our sins. In other words, we all need God's grace, His "unmerited favor."
At the same time, Luther slightly changed the focus of Paul's argument. Particularly in Galatians, Paul is not really talking about faith versus good works in general. He is talking about whether "works of Law," that is the Jewish Law, could gain you right standing before God. [2] In other words, it was things like circumcision, the purity rules of Leviticus, and sabbath observance that were in the "bubble" above his head, not good works like feeding the poor or clothing the needy. One of the documents found among the Dead Sea Scrolls has an argument over "works of Law," and the things it has in mind are squabbles between Jewish groups over what makes a person unclean, not good works.
What Paul is arguing over, therefore, is the parts of the Jewish Law that were most distinctly Jewish, the things that distinguished the Jews ethnically from other people. Around the world, people knew that Jews did not eat pork and did not work on Saturday. These were exactly the kinds of "works of Law" that Paul is targeting. These are the sorts of things at Antioch that got in the way of Jewish and Gentile believers eating together. Paul's main point in Galatians is that none of these things actually help a person get in right standing with God.
In fact, relying on such things can be a slap in Christ's face. Here God has offered a free gift through Christ's death on the cross. It is a gift so good, no one could possibly deserve it. Yet you are insistent on trying to pay for it, and you cannot accept the gift for what it is.
Peter and James apparently agreed that a person could not be in right standing with God apart from trusting in Jesus' death. Paul uses an expression in Galatians 2:16 that scholars debate over, but we think Paul is saying that both he and Peter agree that you could only be right with God if you trusted in the faithful death of Jesus on the cross that one can become right with God. [3] But where they disagreed is in the value of keeping the Jewish particulars of the Mosaic Law. Paul goes on to say that those particulars do not help a person be right with God at all, while Peter and others still saw them playing a role in "justification," in being pronounced right with God. Only trust in what God has done through Christ works.
Paul uses Abraham as his fundamental example of this principle: "justification by faith." Abraham was a superb example because Paul could use him both as a model for the justification of Jews and Gentiles. Paul interpreted Genesis 15:6 to say that Abraham had faith in God, and God considered him right with him as a result (Gal. 3:6). Thus Abraham was a model to Gentiles of how to be right with God. Have faith in what God has done through Jesus the Christ and God will consider you righteous, right with Him. Paul understood Genesis 12:3's promise that all the nations would be blessed through Abraham as a promise that they would get right with God through faith, with Abraham showing them the way (Gal. 3:8-9, 14).
Paul's opponents no doubt had some arguments of their own, and most think Paul is responding to some of them in Galatians. One of the key questions he needed to answer was what the purpose of the Jewish Law was. If it was not meant to show how to be in right relationship with God, then what was it for? Paul's answer is that the Law was like a child's guardian (Gal. 4:24) that watches over it until it comes of age.
So also, the Law served several functions before Christ came. For example, it taught us the difference between right and wrong (e.g., Rom. 7:7). Paul here has seemed to shift a little in what he is talking about. When he was talking about "works of Law," he seemed to be thinking of what many Christians think of as the ritual or "ceremonial" parts of the Jewish Law. [4] But now he is talking about the heart of the Law, what later Christians would call the "moral law." The fact that Paul can glide without notice between these various parts of the Jewish Law is the primary source of confusion over what exactly he meant.
Before Christ, we were all, Paul taught, under the power of Sin in the world. Before Christ, the Law pointed out our weakness in the face of this power (e.g., Gal. 4:3). But now that Christ has come, God's Holy Spirit is available to empower us to do what is right. We no longer need the instruction of our guardian, the Law. We have the power of the Spirit inside us to keep the essence of the (moral) Law.
Galatians thus turns to an exhortation to the Galatians not to let their freedom from works of Law to lead to sinful living. This is the tight rope Paul's theology walks. On the one hand, he argues that the Jewish particulars of the Law cannot make us right with God, nor were we able to live above sin before Christ. But now Christ has enabled us to receive the Spirit of adoption and sonship. Now if we walk in the Spirit, we will not fulfill the desires of the flesh (Gal. 5:16).
Works of law cannot make us right with God, but if we have the Spirit inside us, fruit will follow. The fruit of the Spirit are things like love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control (Gal. 5:22-23). Quite different are the works of the flesh, things like sexual immorality, strife, jealousy, anger, and so forth (5:19-21).
And so Paul closes his letter to the Galatians, likely to churches in south Galatia like Iconium, Lystra, Derbe, and Pisidian Antioch. He points out the hypocrisy of those urging them to get circumcised. They are not models of Jewish Law keeping. And Paul would know, since he was once a Pharisee who paid close attention to such things. But in the end, it is neither circumcision nor uncircumcision that matters before God, he claims. It is the new creation of the Spirit made possible through the cross of Jesus the Messiah.
[1] Even though we called them "missionaries of a sort," we are not insistent at all that the main reason they have come to Galatia is to further instruct Paul's converts. They might just as likely have come into the area on other business.
[2] Another article in James Dunn's The New Perspective on Paul is a classic here, "Works of Law," ***.
[3] The expression is "the faith of Jesus Christ." To understand the debate, you have to look at a phrase like "love of God." What does this phrase mean? Is it God's love, as in "The love of God led Him to send His Son"? Or is it our love for God, as in "Your love of God should lead you to serve Him better"? The phrase Paul uses, "faith of Jesus," could also mean either the faithfulness of Jesus or faith in Jesus.
The three main reasons I finally concluded that the first expression in Gal. 2:16 and Rom. 3:22 refer to the faithfulness of Jesus are 1) Otherwise these verses are quite redundant, Galatians 2:16 then referring to faith in Christ three times in the same sentence, 2) the parallelism between Romans 5:19--"through the obedience of one person many will be established as righteous" and finally, 3) 2 Corinthians 4:13, while the train of thought is hard to follow, seems to say that just as Jesus had faith and was resurrected, so we must have faith and be resurrected. It thus seems to substantiate the notion that Jesus' faith was indeed one of Paul's categories.
[4] It is significant to point out that a Jew, indeed Paul himself, would not not have categorized things this way.
Saturday, December 12, 2009
Paul: Mutiny in Galatia 1
To follow the chain back, see the previous entry in this series, Disagreement and Disorder at Corinth: Spiritual Gifts and Worship.
Now to begin chapter 8: Mutiny in Galatia.
____________
The Setting of Galatians
Most scholars agree that Paul wrote 1 Corinthians to Corinth while he was at Ephesus in the mid-50s. Not so with Galatians--here we find significantly different theories about when and where it was written, and to whom exactly. Until the twentieth century, the vast majority of scholars thought it was written by Paul at about the time we are placing it, from Ephesus or even later in his missionary journeys. But developments in our knowledge of Roman governance at the time facilitated many to place Galatians earlier in Paul's ministry, and to a slightly different audience. Eventually, the majority of evangelical scholars in the mid-twentieth century came to date it as the earliest of Paul's letters in order to work out some tensions between it and the book of Acts.
The position of the majority of evangelicals, first championed by F. F. Bruce, is thus that Galatians was the earliest of the letters Paul wrote, written perhaps from Antioch in about the year AD48 to the churches he and Barnabas had founded on their first missionary journey. [1] This is an ingenious reconstruction and one that very tidily cleans up a number of conundrums. In this scenario, Paul and Barnabas have recently finished their trip to cities like Iconium, Lystra, Derbe, and a different Antioch in Asia Minor, in the south central part of what is now modern day Turkey. We now know that this region was actually part of what the Romans called Galatia at the time, south Galatia.
In Bruce's reconstruction, the private meeting of Paul with Peter and James (Galatians 2:1-10) had taken place even before the first missionary journey. Bruce had ingeniously noticed that Paul had already gone up to Jerusalem before that journey because of a revelation about a famine (Acts 11:30). So Bruce speculated that the revelation that inspired Paul's visit to Jerusalem in Galatians 2:2 was the same revelation. After all, both the visit in Galatians 2 and the visit in Acts 11 are Paul's second visits to Jerusalem.
So in this scenario, before his first journey, Paul received private assurances from Peter and James that uncircumcised Gentiles can be Christians. But he returns after the journey to continued controversy over the issue among believers. The conflict comes to a head when Paul and Peter have a knock down drag out at Antioch over whether Jewish and Gentile believers can eat together and the Jewish believers not be defiled in terms of the holiness codes of Leviticus. James apparently pressures Peter not to eat with Gentiles, while Paul stands in front of the church and so much as calls Peter a hypocrite.
Meanwhile, an already ticked Paul hears that certain Jewish missionaries have infilitrated the very churches he and Barnabas just founded (Iconium, Lystra, Derbe, Pisidian Antioch). They are telling the Gentile believers there that they need to go all the way and fully convert to Judaism in order to be saved from God's coming wrath. Paul goes ballistic. [2] He writes them in the strongest terms that "works of Law" like circumcision do nothing whatsoever to make them right with God.
The controversy finally reaches such a fevered pitch that James and the leaders of the Jerusalem church call a meeting of all the key parties involved, the so called "Jerusalem Council" of Acts 15. The key positions are heard. Certain Christian Pharisees present their position (Acts 15:5). Peter champions the position that Gentiles will be saved by God's grace just as Jewish believers will (15:11). Barnabas and Paul share stories of the Gentile conversions on their missionary journey.
Finally, James--the half-brother of Jesus--renders a verdict. Gentiles do not need to be circumcised to be saved. But they do need to do four things. They need to stay away from things that have come into contact with idols (like meat). They need to refrain from acts of sexual immorality. They need to drain the blood from animals rather than strangle them to death and in general stay away from blood.
In one respect, this is an odd list of fundamental requirements for Gentiles. Many have connected it to the basic expectation God has of Noah after the Flood (e.g., Gen. 9:4). The idea here is that God requires of Gentiles what He required of Noah, while he expects of Jews what He required of Moses. Again, an ingenious suggestion, although we favor the interpretation that sees these four prohibitions as a solution to the question of how Jew and Gentile believer can eat together, rather than one of basic ethical requirements for Gentiles.
And thus, the conflict over Jewish and Gentile relations is largely settled and Peter and Paul move forward in unity and in common agreement on such issues. We might call this reconstruction of the setting of Galatians the "early South Galatian hypothesis," because it sees the letter written to the southern part of the Roman province of Galatia in about the year AD48 just before a Jerusalem Council in AD49. It creates a tidy scenario that accounts for some tensions between Galatians and Acts while maintaining a harmonious and orderly picture of the progress of the early church. We thus understand why it has been the most attractive reconstruction among evangelicals.
However, it faces some serious problems when it comes down to some of the details of Galatians and, for this reason, most scholars in general have not adopted it. Four items in particular seem to make it problematic. First, Bruce was almost certainly wrong to equate the "revelation" that led Paul to go up to Jerusalem somewhat privately (Gal. 2:2) with the revelation that led to the famine relief trip ("gift" trip) of Acts 11:30. The Acts 11 revelation had to do with the famine. The revelation Paul mentions has to do with his understanding of salvation for the Gentiles.
Even more problematic is the timing. In order to make the timing work, Bruce had to take the expression "Then after fourteen years" not to mean fourteen years after his previous visit but fourteen years since he first experienced the risen Jesus. Otherwise Paul's visit in Galatians is pushed too late for the "gift trip." But this interpretation is counterintuitive. Is not Paul's basic point in Galatians 1 and 2 that he had had limited contact with Jerusalem? Is his point not that he did not visit them the first time until three years after his conversion and then not again until fourteen years after that first visit?
Yes, this reading does present a tension with Acts, where the gift trip would have been an intervening visit. But we encounter many such tensions between the biblical accounts, and extensive experience with them leads one to let them fall where they lie rather than insist on reconciling them all. It is almost always necessary to twist one or more of such texts into some far less than obvious reconstruction to reconcile them, which is not the most obvious way to show them respect. It shows a greater valuing of a certain idea about the text than a valuing of the text itself!
The practice with the most integrity is one that lets each text say what it most likely says rather than apply one's intellect to conceive of some less than probable reconstruction. In the end, such hypotheses often create a scenario that is not represented by any of the texts one is actually trying to reconcile. One has substituted the text of the interpreter for all of the texts in question! [3] In this case, however, it is conceivable that the two texts might be reasonably reconciled. Paul is, after all, talking in Galatians 2 primarily about visits having to do with discussion on theological matters, and it is conceivable that he might omit from such a list of visits one that involved no real interaction between him and the Jerusalem leaders on such issues.
So the more likely timing of Galatians 2:1 puts Paul's visit to Jerusalem in Galatians 2 at about the same time as the Jerusalem Council of Acts 15. Most scholars have thus concluded that the two events were one and the same. Paul would thus present the event as somewhat of a private meeting, while Acts would present the event as more of a public one. Here we hit the fundamental reason why many evangelicals have gone with Bruce. Acts 15 is different enough from Galatians 2 to require us to see one as a less straightforwardly historical presentation of the event.
But whether one thinks Galatians 2 was just before the "Jerusalem Council" or is a slightly different version of it, the most likely timing places the writing of Galatians some time after the Jerusalem Council. What this means is that the conclusion of Peter and James in Jerusalem, however it actually played out, did not resolve all the issues between Jews and Gentiles. Indeed, we come now to a third reason why the early dating of Galatians does not seem to fit Galatians. Paul mentions in Galatians 4:13 that it was because of a weakness of his flesh that he preached to them "the very first time." It is a relatively small argument, since it is possible we are reading too much into the word. But the most natural way to take this Greek word is that Paul has already visited the Galatians more than once. If so, then Paul would not have written Galatians until at least after his second visit there, which was after the Jerusalem Conference.
We thus reach the second reconstruction of the setting of Galatians. This reconstruction still sees Paul writing Galatians to the churches of South Galatia (Iconium, Lystra, Derbe, Pisidian Antioch) but sees him doing it at some point during his second missionary journey, probably while he was at Corinth. In this scenario as it usually plays out, Peter took a trip north to Antioch after the Jerusalem Council, whatever its precise nature. For a time, he fellowshipped with Gentile Christians just as Paul and Barnabas did.
Then James, nervous that their allowance to Gentiles would lead Jewish believers also to slack off in their keeping of the Law, sends some people to check on what was going on at Antioch. They convince Peter and Barnabas that they cannot slack off on purity concerns just because the Gentiles can be saved without following them all. Paul goes ballistic, as in the other scenario.
There are two key differences to this scenario from the previous one. The one is the fact that Paul seems to lose this argument. After all, he tells us earlier in Galatians 2 that James, Peter, and John agreed with him on the issue of circumcision. If Peter and Barnabas had given in to his argument at Antioch, Paul would have told us in Galatians. The end result is that Paul's argument with Barnabas in Acts 15:39 probably was about more than just whether to take Mark along on their next trip. We remember that Acts, in keeping with its general approach, completely omits this controversy at Antioch. We have good reason to believe that Paul leaves Antioch on somewhat tense, perhaps even bad terms with the Jerusalem church. We can still feel that tension even when he returns to Jerusalem in Acts 21:20-22.
A second curiosity with this approach is what to make of the letter Acts 15 pictures being sent as a result of the Jerusalem Conference. As we hinted above, its four prohibitions would actually solve the matter of Jew and Gentile believer eating together, at least in the minds of people like James, Peter, and Barnabas. If Gentiles would stay away from strangled meat with the blood still in it, from meat that had been sacrified at a temple, and from sexual immorality, then Jewish believers could eat with Gentile believers. The early Galatians scenario was nice and neat on this question, because it considered the Antioch blow up to have happened before the Council.
But if the blow up at Antioch was after the Council, then the letter becomes anachronistic--at least if it is addressing the question of "table fellowship," who you eat with. [4] If it is only giving a bare bones "Noahic" list of general requirements for Gentiles, then there is no tension. But if it is telling Gentiles how they must get and prepare food in order that Jewish believers might eat with them, then we are forced to see Acts 15 as a somewhat syncopated presentation of what was in history a more complicated and drawn out struggle. In either case, it is clear that Paul did not agree with the letter's position. As we have seen, Paul neither mentions the letter nor takes its position when he deals with the Corinthians on the subject of meat sacrificed to idols. One way or another, Paul's relationship with the Jerusalem church continued to involve some tension, even into his second and third missionary journeys. And we saw this fact in 1 Corinthians where Paul mentions some at Corinth who might say they are "of Peter" in a way that distinstinguished them from Paul (1 Cor. 1:12)
We mentioned four problems with the early South Galatia theory, but we have only mentioned three of them so far. The fourth is a difficulty not only for the first reconstruction but also for the second one we have just mentioned. Paul says in Galatians 4:13 that he first preached the good news to them because of a physical problem. He goes on to say how they would have been glad to give him their own eyes if they could have (4:15). Paul thus seems to have been passing through some part of Galatia when he encountered eye problems that led him to change his plans for an extended period of time.
It is difficult to fit this description of Paul's founding visit with the depiction of Paul's first missionary journey in Acts 13-14. South Galatia was hardly on the way between Cyprus and Antioch. To go there required intentionality on Paul and Barnabas' part. To be sure, some scholars have questioned whether Paul took exactly this path historically. Some even suggest Paul might have been in Greece some ten years earlier than Acts depicts. But these reconstructions seem highly speculative. We really have no reason to question Acts' itinerary at this point.
On the other hand, this founding visit might fit Paul's itinerary leaving south Galatia on his second missionary journey, where Acts says he went on to travel "through the region of Phrygia and Galatia" (16:6). Indeed, could some of the forbidding of the Holy Spirit Acts 16 mentions be its way of referring to Paul's need to stay relatively put in north Galatia because of eye problems? It was this region of north Galatia, where the modern city of Ancyra is located, that most Christians thought Galatians was written until the twentieth century. That is because for most of antiquity, only this area was actually called Galatia. The ethnic Galatians, although they were long gone by the time of Paul, had lived in this northern region.
However, we must reckon with the fact that the Romans expanded the territory in 25BC to include the southern area. The cities of south Galatia thus were thus part of Galatia as well. We have decided to fall off the log with Galatians primarily written to the northern territory, classic Galatia, but we have to admit it is a close call. We must face the odd situation, for example, that we do not know the names of any churches Paul founded in this area, while we know many names of churches he founded in the south. Nevertheless, as we will see, we think Galatians fits the general preoccupations of Paul while at Ephesus better than when he was at Corinth.
[1] Paul: Apostle of the Heart Set Free. **
[2] That Paul is infuriated when he writes Galatians should not be in doubt given his comment that he would be quite pleased if these individuals bent on circumcision would just cut their whole thing off (Gal. 5:12).
[3] The most notorious example is of course Harold Linsell's suggestion in The Battle for the Bible (***) that Peter might have denied Jesus six times, three before a first crowing and three more before a second. He applied his ingenuity and created a scenario that differs more from each gospel text than each of them actually differ from each other!
[4] And here let us add to our list of books one might read to master Paul the masterful collection of essays by James D. G. Dunn over the years called, The New Perspective on Paul (***). His essay, "The Incident at Antioch" is, in our opinion, the most definitive discussion to date on the blow-up. Dunn takes the second scenario position on Galatians, that it was written in the early 50s from Corinth to southern Galatia.
Now to begin chapter 8: Mutiny in Galatia.
____________
The Setting of Galatians
Most scholars agree that Paul wrote 1 Corinthians to Corinth while he was at Ephesus in the mid-50s. Not so with Galatians--here we find significantly different theories about when and where it was written, and to whom exactly. Until the twentieth century, the vast majority of scholars thought it was written by Paul at about the time we are placing it, from Ephesus or even later in his missionary journeys. But developments in our knowledge of Roman governance at the time facilitated many to place Galatians earlier in Paul's ministry, and to a slightly different audience. Eventually, the majority of evangelical scholars in the mid-twentieth century came to date it as the earliest of Paul's letters in order to work out some tensions between it and the book of Acts.
The position of the majority of evangelicals, first championed by F. F. Bruce, is thus that Galatians was the earliest of the letters Paul wrote, written perhaps from Antioch in about the year AD48 to the churches he and Barnabas had founded on their first missionary journey. [1] This is an ingenious reconstruction and one that very tidily cleans up a number of conundrums. In this scenario, Paul and Barnabas have recently finished their trip to cities like Iconium, Lystra, Derbe, and a different Antioch in Asia Minor, in the south central part of what is now modern day Turkey. We now know that this region was actually part of what the Romans called Galatia at the time, south Galatia.
In Bruce's reconstruction, the private meeting of Paul with Peter and James (Galatians 2:1-10) had taken place even before the first missionary journey. Bruce had ingeniously noticed that Paul had already gone up to Jerusalem before that journey because of a revelation about a famine (Acts 11:30). So Bruce speculated that the revelation that inspired Paul's visit to Jerusalem in Galatians 2:2 was the same revelation. After all, both the visit in Galatians 2 and the visit in Acts 11 are Paul's second visits to Jerusalem.
So in this scenario, before his first journey, Paul received private assurances from Peter and James that uncircumcised Gentiles can be Christians. But he returns after the journey to continued controversy over the issue among believers. The conflict comes to a head when Paul and Peter have a knock down drag out at Antioch over whether Jewish and Gentile believers can eat together and the Jewish believers not be defiled in terms of the holiness codes of Leviticus. James apparently pressures Peter not to eat with Gentiles, while Paul stands in front of the church and so much as calls Peter a hypocrite.
Meanwhile, an already ticked Paul hears that certain Jewish missionaries have infilitrated the very churches he and Barnabas just founded (Iconium, Lystra, Derbe, Pisidian Antioch). They are telling the Gentile believers there that they need to go all the way and fully convert to Judaism in order to be saved from God's coming wrath. Paul goes ballistic. [2] He writes them in the strongest terms that "works of Law" like circumcision do nothing whatsoever to make them right with God.
The controversy finally reaches such a fevered pitch that James and the leaders of the Jerusalem church call a meeting of all the key parties involved, the so called "Jerusalem Council" of Acts 15. The key positions are heard. Certain Christian Pharisees present their position (Acts 15:5). Peter champions the position that Gentiles will be saved by God's grace just as Jewish believers will (15:11). Barnabas and Paul share stories of the Gentile conversions on their missionary journey.
Finally, James--the half-brother of Jesus--renders a verdict. Gentiles do not need to be circumcised to be saved. But they do need to do four things. They need to stay away from things that have come into contact with idols (like meat). They need to refrain from acts of sexual immorality. They need to drain the blood from animals rather than strangle them to death and in general stay away from blood.
In one respect, this is an odd list of fundamental requirements for Gentiles. Many have connected it to the basic expectation God has of Noah after the Flood (e.g., Gen. 9:4). The idea here is that God requires of Gentiles what He required of Noah, while he expects of Jews what He required of Moses. Again, an ingenious suggestion, although we favor the interpretation that sees these four prohibitions as a solution to the question of how Jew and Gentile believer can eat together, rather than one of basic ethical requirements for Gentiles.
And thus, the conflict over Jewish and Gentile relations is largely settled and Peter and Paul move forward in unity and in common agreement on such issues. We might call this reconstruction of the setting of Galatians the "early South Galatian hypothesis," because it sees the letter written to the southern part of the Roman province of Galatia in about the year AD48 just before a Jerusalem Council in AD49. It creates a tidy scenario that accounts for some tensions between Galatians and Acts while maintaining a harmonious and orderly picture of the progress of the early church. We thus understand why it has been the most attractive reconstruction among evangelicals.
However, it faces some serious problems when it comes down to some of the details of Galatians and, for this reason, most scholars in general have not adopted it. Four items in particular seem to make it problematic. First, Bruce was almost certainly wrong to equate the "revelation" that led Paul to go up to Jerusalem somewhat privately (Gal. 2:2) with the revelation that led to the famine relief trip ("gift" trip) of Acts 11:30. The Acts 11 revelation had to do with the famine. The revelation Paul mentions has to do with his understanding of salvation for the Gentiles.
Even more problematic is the timing. In order to make the timing work, Bruce had to take the expression "Then after fourteen years" not to mean fourteen years after his previous visit but fourteen years since he first experienced the risen Jesus. Otherwise Paul's visit in Galatians is pushed too late for the "gift trip." But this interpretation is counterintuitive. Is not Paul's basic point in Galatians 1 and 2 that he had had limited contact with Jerusalem? Is his point not that he did not visit them the first time until three years after his conversion and then not again until fourteen years after that first visit?
Yes, this reading does present a tension with Acts, where the gift trip would have been an intervening visit. But we encounter many such tensions between the biblical accounts, and extensive experience with them leads one to let them fall where they lie rather than insist on reconciling them all. It is almost always necessary to twist one or more of such texts into some far less than obvious reconstruction to reconcile them, which is not the most obvious way to show them respect. It shows a greater valuing of a certain idea about the text than a valuing of the text itself!
The practice with the most integrity is one that lets each text say what it most likely says rather than apply one's intellect to conceive of some less than probable reconstruction. In the end, such hypotheses often create a scenario that is not represented by any of the texts one is actually trying to reconcile. One has substituted the text of the interpreter for all of the texts in question! [3] In this case, however, it is conceivable that the two texts might be reasonably reconciled. Paul is, after all, talking in Galatians 2 primarily about visits having to do with discussion on theological matters, and it is conceivable that he might omit from such a list of visits one that involved no real interaction between him and the Jerusalem leaders on such issues.
So the more likely timing of Galatians 2:1 puts Paul's visit to Jerusalem in Galatians 2 at about the same time as the Jerusalem Council of Acts 15. Most scholars have thus concluded that the two events were one and the same. Paul would thus present the event as somewhat of a private meeting, while Acts would present the event as more of a public one. Here we hit the fundamental reason why many evangelicals have gone with Bruce. Acts 15 is different enough from Galatians 2 to require us to see one as a less straightforwardly historical presentation of the event.
But whether one thinks Galatians 2 was just before the "Jerusalem Council" or is a slightly different version of it, the most likely timing places the writing of Galatians some time after the Jerusalem Council. What this means is that the conclusion of Peter and James in Jerusalem, however it actually played out, did not resolve all the issues between Jews and Gentiles. Indeed, we come now to a third reason why the early dating of Galatians does not seem to fit Galatians. Paul mentions in Galatians 4:13 that it was because of a weakness of his flesh that he preached to them "the very first time." It is a relatively small argument, since it is possible we are reading too much into the word. But the most natural way to take this Greek word is that Paul has already visited the Galatians more than once. If so, then Paul would not have written Galatians until at least after his second visit there, which was after the Jerusalem Conference.
We thus reach the second reconstruction of the setting of Galatians. This reconstruction still sees Paul writing Galatians to the churches of South Galatia (Iconium, Lystra, Derbe, Pisidian Antioch) but sees him doing it at some point during his second missionary journey, probably while he was at Corinth. In this scenario as it usually plays out, Peter took a trip north to Antioch after the Jerusalem Council, whatever its precise nature. For a time, he fellowshipped with Gentile Christians just as Paul and Barnabas did.
Then James, nervous that their allowance to Gentiles would lead Jewish believers also to slack off in their keeping of the Law, sends some people to check on what was going on at Antioch. They convince Peter and Barnabas that they cannot slack off on purity concerns just because the Gentiles can be saved without following them all. Paul goes ballistic, as in the other scenario.
There are two key differences to this scenario from the previous one. The one is the fact that Paul seems to lose this argument. After all, he tells us earlier in Galatians 2 that James, Peter, and John agreed with him on the issue of circumcision. If Peter and Barnabas had given in to his argument at Antioch, Paul would have told us in Galatians. The end result is that Paul's argument with Barnabas in Acts 15:39 probably was about more than just whether to take Mark along on their next trip. We remember that Acts, in keeping with its general approach, completely omits this controversy at Antioch. We have good reason to believe that Paul leaves Antioch on somewhat tense, perhaps even bad terms with the Jerusalem church. We can still feel that tension even when he returns to Jerusalem in Acts 21:20-22.
A second curiosity with this approach is what to make of the letter Acts 15 pictures being sent as a result of the Jerusalem Conference. As we hinted above, its four prohibitions would actually solve the matter of Jew and Gentile believer eating together, at least in the minds of people like James, Peter, and Barnabas. If Gentiles would stay away from strangled meat with the blood still in it, from meat that had been sacrified at a temple, and from sexual immorality, then Jewish believers could eat with Gentile believers. The early Galatians scenario was nice and neat on this question, because it considered the Antioch blow up to have happened before the Council.
But if the blow up at Antioch was after the Council, then the letter becomes anachronistic--at least if it is addressing the question of "table fellowship," who you eat with. [4] If it is only giving a bare bones "Noahic" list of general requirements for Gentiles, then there is no tension. But if it is telling Gentiles how they must get and prepare food in order that Jewish believers might eat with them, then we are forced to see Acts 15 as a somewhat syncopated presentation of what was in history a more complicated and drawn out struggle. In either case, it is clear that Paul did not agree with the letter's position. As we have seen, Paul neither mentions the letter nor takes its position when he deals with the Corinthians on the subject of meat sacrificed to idols. One way or another, Paul's relationship with the Jerusalem church continued to involve some tension, even into his second and third missionary journeys. And we saw this fact in 1 Corinthians where Paul mentions some at Corinth who might say they are "of Peter" in a way that distinstinguished them from Paul (1 Cor. 1:12)
We mentioned four problems with the early South Galatia theory, but we have only mentioned three of them so far. The fourth is a difficulty not only for the first reconstruction but also for the second one we have just mentioned. Paul says in Galatians 4:13 that he first preached the good news to them because of a physical problem. He goes on to say how they would have been glad to give him their own eyes if they could have (4:15). Paul thus seems to have been passing through some part of Galatia when he encountered eye problems that led him to change his plans for an extended period of time.
It is difficult to fit this description of Paul's founding visit with the depiction of Paul's first missionary journey in Acts 13-14. South Galatia was hardly on the way between Cyprus and Antioch. To go there required intentionality on Paul and Barnabas' part. To be sure, some scholars have questioned whether Paul took exactly this path historically. Some even suggest Paul might have been in Greece some ten years earlier than Acts depicts. But these reconstructions seem highly speculative. We really have no reason to question Acts' itinerary at this point.
On the other hand, this founding visit might fit Paul's itinerary leaving south Galatia on his second missionary journey, where Acts says he went on to travel "through the region of Phrygia and Galatia" (16:6). Indeed, could some of the forbidding of the Holy Spirit Acts 16 mentions be its way of referring to Paul's need to stay relatively put in north Galatia because of eye problems? It was this region of north Galatia, where the modern city of Ancyra is located, that most Christians thought Galatians was written until the twentieth century. That is because for most of antiquity, only this area was actually called Galatia. The ethnic Galatians, although they were long gone by the time of Paul, had lived in this northern region.
However, we must reckon with the fact that the Romans expanded the territory in 25BC to include the southern area. The cities of south Galatia thus were thus part of Galatia as well. We have decided to fall off the log with Galatians primarily written to the northern territory, classic Galatia, but we have to admit it is a close call. We must face the odd situation, for example, that we do not know the names of any churches Paul founded in this area, while we know many names of churches he founded in the south. Nevertheless, as we will see, we think Galatians fits the general preoccupations of Paul while at Ephesus better than when he was at Corinth.
[1] Paul: Apostle of the Heart Set Free. **
[2] That Paul is infuriated when he writes Galatians should not be in doubt given his comment that he would be quite pleased if these individuals bent on circumcision would just cut their whole thing off (Gal. 5:12).
[3] The most notorious example is of course Harold Linsell's suggestion in The Battle for the Bible (***) that Peter might have denied Jesus six times, three before a first crowing and three more before a second. He applied his ingenuity and created a scenario that differs more from each gospel text than each of them actually differ from each other!
[4] And here let us add to our list of books one might read to master Paul the masterful collection of essays by James D. G. Dunn over the years called, The New Perspective on Paul (***). His essay, "The Incident at Antioch" is, in our opinion, the most definitive discussion to date on the blow-up. Dunn takes the second scenario position on Galatians, that it was written in the early 50s from Corinth to southern Galatia.
1 Corinthians Disorder 4: Spiritual Gifts and Worship
Previous posts in this series, Life Reflections on Paul and His Writings, include:
1a. Born at a Time and Place 1; 1b. Born at a Time and Place 2
2a. A Change in Life Direction; 2b A Change in Life Direction 2; 2c A Change in Life Direction 3
3a. The Unknown Years 1; 3b. The Unknown Years 2; 3c. The Unknown Years 3
4a. Life Beyond Death; 4b. Life Beyond Death; 4c. Life Beyond Death; 4d Life Beyond Death
5a. Disunity at Corinth; 5b. Disunity at Corinth 2; 5c. Disunity at Corinth 3
6 How Not to Have Sex
7a. Disagreement and Disorder 1; 7b. The Lord's Supper. 7c. Women and Worship
Now part 4 of "Disagreement and Disorder":
____________
Spiritual Gifts and Worship
1 Corinthians 12-14 form yet another sequence of thought, this time on "spiritual matters," principally spiritual gifts. [1] While chapter 12 treats spiritual gifts rather generally, Paul returns to two in particular in chapter 14: tongues and prophecy. If you remember, the second half of 1 Corinthians addresses questions that the Corinthians themselves have sent to Paul. The first had to do with sex within marriage and whether virgins should marry. The second had to do with meat that had been sacrificed to idols. Now Paul addresses questions they had about spiritual gifts.
The fact that Paul has sandwiched a beautiful tribute to love in the middle of this discussion gives us a fair sense of the heart of the problem. Those with varying gifts in the community are not showing love and respect for the gifts of others but instead thinking themselves superior because of the particluar gifts they have. After going through various kinds of spiritual gifts a person might have, as well as key roles in the church like apostles, prophets, teachers, and so forth, Paul sets out love as a more excellent preoccupation than all the various giftings a person might have.
When he returns to his answer in chapter 14, Paul gets down to business apparently with the heart of where the divisiveness lies. The entire tenor of 1 Corinthians 14 is to corral the practice of tongues speaking in Corinthian worship and to promote the practice of prophecy as more beneficial. "Pursue love and strive for the spiritual gifts, and especially that you may prophesy. For those who speak in a tongue do not speak to other people but to God; for nobody understands them, since they are speaking mysteries in the Spirit" (1 Cor. 14:1-2). This sense of correcting and steering the use of tongues continues throughout the chapter, and seems to indicate that it stood at the heart of their division over spiritual gifts.
It thus seems likely that some of the Corinthians thought themselves more spiritual than others in the church because they spoke in tongues. "If I speak in the tongues of mortals and of angels, but do not have love, I am a noisy gong or a clanging cymbal" (1 Cor. 13:1), Paul tells them. It does not matter that you speak in tongues if you are not loving toward others in the church.
He has perhaps already chastised these who think themselves spiritual back in 1 Corinthians 3:1: "I could not speak to you as spiritual people, but rather as people of the flesh, as infants in Christ." In the verses right before these, Paul spends some energy distinguishing between what a spiritual person is like in contrast to a "soulish" person, sometimes translated as an "unspiritual" or "natural" person. We might even translate it as a "merely animal" person. Given the same use of the word spiritual, it is easy to see a connection with the question about spiritual matters in chapters 12-14.
This suggestion might seem strange at first, that those who "possess knowledge" in 8:1, who think they are already kings on earth in the kingdom (4:8), are the same people as those who boast in their spiritual gift of tongues. Is this not the Apollos group, those who identify with the "university professor" from Alexandria? Is this not the group that knows "no idol in the world really exists" in distinction from the "less intelligent" people who are still superstitious?
What we are getting at is that the Western world pushes us to distinguish the intellectual people who know there is only one God and are not superstitious from the emotional people who have mystic religious experiences and believe in demons and lots of gods. We are not culturally programmed to think of people who speak in tongues as being the same kind of people who are intellectual. However, this way of categorizing people is modern, not ancient. Knowing God in the ancient world was an experiential kind of knowing rather than some Spock-like, dispassionate intellectual pursuit. The philosophies of individuals like Pythagoras and Plato were deeply mystical and religious.
The tongues speaking at Corinth was apparently not too unlike some of the pagan religious experiences that were known in Greece. Paul starts off chapter 12 talking about being "led astray to idols," a reference some think is to the kind of wild, frenzied activity that went along with the festivals of Dionysus (12:2). In 14:23, Paul suggests that an unbeliever coming into their meetings might think you are "out of your mind," which might also refer to some of the ecstatic kinds of religious experiences that sometimes took place in the so called mystery religions. Part of Paul's intention in these chapters is thus to avoid the appearance of pagan worship in the Christian assembly.
Whether this is the right reconstruction of the situation at Corinth, it seems clear enough that Paul's goal in 1 Corinthians 14 is to steer the use of tongues in worship in a healthy direction while not prohibiting its use. He begins the chapter praising prophecy as good for the congregation in contrast to the self-edifying benefit of tongues. He mentions briefly in verse 13 that a tongues-speaker should pray for the power to interpret their language and then returns again for another twelve verses to speak of the barrier creating effect of tongues on insider and visitor alike. Finally he concludes with concrete rules for tongues and prophecy, with the stipulation that tongues should not be used in worship unless an interpreter is present.
The entire tenor of the chapter is thus away from the use of tongues in public worship with the exception of those instances where an interpreter of the "languages" (the meaning of tongues) is present. This thrust is clear enough when Paul says tongues are not to be forbidden (14:39), which indicates that he has been limiting its practice but does not wish to eliminate it. A comment like, "I would like all of you to speak in tongues" (14:5) is like the young woman who tells a young man interested in her, "I like you, but I don't want to date you." The first statement is meant to ease the pain of the second. So also it would be great if they all spoke in tongues, but intelligible speech is really what is appropriate in worship. "I thank God that I speak in tongues more than all of you," Paul says to affirm the value of tongues. But only to go on to say, "nevertheless, in church I would rather speak five words with my mind, in order to instruct others also, than ten thousand words in a tongue" (14:18).
The rules that Paul lays down are to bring order to Corinthian worship. "All things should be done decently and in order" (14:40). Two or at the most three people should speak in tongues in any one worship time, and only if someone who has the gift to interpret is present. They should speak one at a time. The same applies to prophecy. As it is, Corinthian worship is chaotic: "When you come together, each one has a hymn, a lesson, a revelation, a tongue, or an interpretation" (14:26).
Since the beginning of the twentieth century, speaking in tongues has gained incredible prominence in Christian worship around the world. In fact, the fastest growing segment of Christianity in the world is the charismatic movement, particularly in the southern hemisphere. Some charismatic churches are careful to have interpretation of tongues speaking in worship, others are not. Clearly speaking in tongues is, as Paul said two thousand years ago, edifying to the person who has the experience.
What is happening when a person speaks in tongues? Is it an angelic language? Is it a psychological phenomenon that some brains are simply wired to experience? Different individuals will no doubt have different opinions on the question, and of course brain research might weigh in at some point with scientific evidence.
But what we know is that the experience is a blessing to the person so "gifted," and we should rejoice with those who rejoice as fellow believers. Paul's concern that a worship service be uplifting to everyone present and that it not be a bad witness to outsiders who visit also seem concerns that carry through to today. It may be possible, for example, that we have the benefit of so many different church options that those who attend tongues-speaking churches may actually find it uplifting to watch another believer speak in uninterpreted tongues. And such a church will rarely if ever be the sole representation of Christianity to the unbelievers in town. In other words, it may very well be that the limitations Paul places on tongues in worship may not apply in some charismatic churches.
By the same token, there may be some churches where the presence of tongues-speaking would be so divisive that Paul would encourage tongues-speakers there to practice their gift at home. The use of tongues in worship is not needed for the body and will only cause disorder. They can surrender their "rights" so as not to put a stumblingblock in front of the church.
Are tongues today the same as tongues so long ago? After all, tongues speaking was very rare in the two thousand years since the Corinthians till the Azusa street revivals of the early twentieth century. Some would say that tongues were purely an early church phenomenon to spread the gospel at first to people who spoke other languages. But we have no clear biblical basis on which to claim such a thing. [2] It is true that the tongues speaking in Acts 2 seems to be other human languages, but the tongues speaking of 1 Corinthians 14 may very well be conceptualized as angelic languages (cf. 1 Cor. 13:1), in any case languages not known to the congregation.
Some would say that those who speak in tongues are serving as conduits for demons and often curse God in other languages. These stories are often repeated with such a similar form that we suspect they are mostly urban legends with little or no basis in fact. In general it is dangerous to attribute to Satan what is actually the work of the Spirit. This is actually a sin Jesus says is unpardonable, so we should probably avoid such accusations (cf. Matt. 12:32).
I personally like to think that just as God often amplifies certain natural talents we have for ministry and Christian service, perhaps some people's brains are wired to have this experience in general. After all, we hear of these sorts of experiences not only among Christians but among other religious groups as well. [3] Perhaps God then "sanctifies" or amplifies this natural potentiality for such individuals, giving them a personal sense of blessing through the Holy Spirit. In any case, we cannot look down on this spiritual gift any more than we can think ourselves more spiritual than others for having it.
The lesson of the Corinthians is thus for the tongues-speaker--or in fact anyone with any special gift from God--not to think less of others in the community who do not have that gift. We are not more valuable to God because we have some particular gift. We may serve different functions in the body of Christ, but we are all of the same status, whether social or spiritual.
[1] 14:1 does not actually have the word "gifts." It simply says, "spiritual [matters]." However, the content of the chapters makes it clear that spiritual gifts are primarily in mind, especially tongues and prophecy.
[2] Some used to reference 1 Corinthians 13:8 as an indication that tongues would cease as a gift, but that is clearly not what the verse is saying. It is simply saying that languages come and go over time.
[3] It is hard to know when to date the Testament of Job, but it depicts the daughters of Job speaking in angelic tongues. That portion of the book may be influenced by Christians, but if it was part of the non-Christian Jewish part of the book, then we have an indication that some non-Christian Jews spoke in tongues.
1a. Born at a Time and Place 1; 1b. Born at a Time and Place 2
2a. A Change in Life Direction; 2b A Change in Life Direction 2; 2c A Change in Life Direction 3
3a. The Unknown Years 1; 3b. The Unknown Years 2; 3c. The Unknown Years 3
4a. Life Beyond Death; 4b. Life Beyond Death; 4c. Life Beyond Death; 4d Life Beyond Death
5a. Disunity at Corinth; 5b. Disunity at Corinth 2; 5c. Disunity at Corinth 3
6 How Not to Have Sex
7a. Disagreement and Disorder 1; 7b. The Lord's Supper. 7c. Women and Worship
Now part 4 of "Disagreement and Disorder":
____________
Spiritual Gifts and Worship
1 Corinthians 12-14 form yet another sequence of thought, this time on "spiritual matters," principally spiritual gifts. [1] While chapter 12 treats spiritual gifts rather generally, Paul returns to two in particular in chapter 14: tongues and prophecy. If you remember, the second half of 1 Corinthians addresses questions that the Corinthians themselves have sent to Paul. The first had to do with sex within marriage and whether virgins should marry. The second had to do with meat that had been sacrificed to idols. Now Paul addresses questions they had about spiritual gifts.
The fact that Paul has sandwiched a beautiful tribute to love in the middle of this discussion gives us a fair sense of the heart of the problem. Those with varying gifts in the community are not showing love and respect for the gifts of others but instead thinking themselves superior because of the particluar gifts they have. After going through various kinds of spiritual gifts a person might have, as well as key roles in the church like apostles, prophets, teachers, and so forth, Paul sets out love as a more excellent preoccupation than all the various giftings a person might have.
When he returns to his answer in chapter 14, Paul gets down to business apparently with the heart of where the divisiveness lies. The entire tenor of 1 Corinthians 14 is to corral the practice of tongues speaking in Corinthian worship and to promote the practice of prophecy as more beneficial. "Pursue love and strive for the spiritual gifts, and especially that you may prophesy. For those who speak in a tongue do not speak to other people but to God; for nobody understands them, since they are speaking mysteries in the Spirit" (1 Cor. 14:1-2). This sense of correcting and steering the use of tongues continues throughout the chapter, and seems to indicate that it stood at the heart of their division over spiritual gifts.
It thus seems likely that some of the Corinthians thought themselves more spiritual than others in the church because they spoke in tongues. "If I speak in the tongues of mortals and of angels, but do not have love, I am a noisy gong or a clanging cymbal" (1 Cor. 13:1), Paul tells them. It does not matter that you speak in tongues if you are not loving toward others in the church.
He has perhaps already chastised these who think themselves spiritual back in 1 Corinthians 3:1: "I could not speak to you as spiritual people, but rather as people of the flesh, as infants in Christ." In the verses right before these, Paul spends some energy distinguishing between what a spiritual person is like in contrast to a "soulish" person, sometimes translated as an "unspiritual" or "natural" person. We might even translate it as a "merely animal" person. Given the same use of the word spiritual, it is easy to see a connection with the question about spiritual matters in chapters 12-14.
This suggestion might seem strange at first, that those who "possess knowledge" in 8:1, who think they are already kings on earth in the kingdom (4:8), are the same people as those who boast in their spiritual gift of tongues. Is this not the Apollos group, those who identify with the "university professor" from Alexandria? Is this not the group that knows "no idol in the world really exists" in distinction from the "less intelligent" people who are still superstitious?
What we are getting at is that the Western world pushes us to distinguish the intellectual people who know there is only one God and are not superstitious from the emotional people who have mystic religious experiences and believe in demons and lots of gods. We are not culturally programmed to think of people who speak in tongues as being the same kind of people who are intellectual. However, this way of categorizing people is modern, not ancient. Knowing God in the ancient world was an experiential kind of knowing rather than some Spock-like, dispassionate intellectual pursuit. The philosophies of individuals like Pythagoras and Plato were deeply mystical and religious.
The tongues speaking at Corinth was apparently not too unlike some of the pagan religious experiences that were known in Greece. Paul starts off chapter 12 talking about being "led astray to idols," a reference some think is to the kind of wild, frenzied activity that went along with the festivals of Dionysus (12:2). In 14:23, Paul suggests that an unbeliever coming into their meetings might think you are "out of your mind," which might also refer to some of the ecstatic kinds of religious experiences that sometimes took place in the so called mystery religions. Part of Paul's intention in these chapters is thus to avoid the appearance of pagan worship in the Christian assembly.
Whether this is the right reconstruction of the situation at Corinth, it seems clear enough that Paul's goal in 1 Corinthians 14 is to steer the use of tongues in worship in a healthy direction while not prohibiting its use. He begins the chapter praising prophecy as good for the congregation in contrast to the self-edifying benefit of tongues. He mentions briefly in verse 13 that a tongues-speaker should pray for the power to interpret their language and then returns again for another twelve verses to speak of the barrier creating effect of tongues on insider and visitor alike. Finally he concludes with concrete rules for tongues and prophecy, with the stipulation that tongues should not be used in worship unless an interpreter is present.
The entire tenor of the chapter is thus away from the use of tongues in public worship with the exception of those instances where an interpreter of the "languages" (the meaning of tongues) is present. This thrust is clear enough when Paul says tongues are not to be forbidden (14:39), which indicates that he has been limiting its practice but does not wish to eliminate it. A comment like, "I would like all of you to speak in tongues" (14:5) is like the young woman who tells a young man interested in her, "I like you, but I don't want to date you." The first statement is meant to ease the pain of the second. So also it would be great if they all spoke in tongues, but intelligible speech is really what is appropriate in worship. "I thank God that I speak in tongues more than all of you," Paul says to affirm the value of tongues. But only to go on to say, "nevertheless, in church I would rather speak five words with my mind, in order to instruct others also, than ten thousand words in a tongue" (14:18).
The rules that Paul lays down are to bring order to Corinthian worship. "All things should be done decently and in order" (14:40). Two or at the most three people should speak in tongues in any one worship time, and only if someone who has the gift to interpret is present. They should speak one at a time. The same applies to prophecy. As it is, Corinthian worship is chaotic: "When you come together, each one has a hymn, a lesson, a revelation, a tongue, or an interpretation" (14:26).
Since the beginning of the twentieth century, speaking in tongues has gained incredible prominence in Christian worship around the world. In fact, the fastest growing segment of Christianity in the world is the charismatic movement, particularly in the southern hemisphere. Some charismatic churches are careful to have interpretation of tongues speaking in worship, others are not. Clearly speaking in tongues is, as Paul said two thousand years ago, edifying to the person who has the experience.
What is happening when a person speaks in tongues? Is it an angelic language? Is it a psychological phenomenon that some brains are simply wired to experience? Different individuals will no doubt have different opinions on the question, and of course brain research might weigh in at some point with scientific evidence.
But what we know is that the experience is a blessing to the person so "gifted," and we should rejoice with those who rejoice as fellow believers. Paul's concern that a worship service be uplifting to everyone present and that it not be a bad witness to outsiders who visit also seem concerns that carry through to today. It may be possible, for example, that we have the benefit of so many different church options that those who attend tongues-speaking churches may actually find it uplifting to watch another believer speak in uninterpreted tongues. And such a church will rarely if ever be the sole representation of Christianity to the unbelievers in town. In other words, it may very well be that the limitations Paul places on tongues in worship may not apply in some charismatic churches.
By the same token, there may be some churches where the presence of tongues-speaking would be so divisive that Paul would encourage tongues-speakers there to practice their gift at home. The use of tongues in worship is not needed for the body and will only cause disorder. They can surrender their "rights" so as not to put a stumblingblock in front of the church.
Are tongues today the same as tongues so long ago? After all, tongues speaking was very rare in the two thousand years since the Corinthians till the Azusa street revivals of the early twentieth century. Some would say that tongues were purely an early church phenomenon to spread the gospel at first to people who spoke other languages. But we have no clear biblical basis on which to claim such a thing. [2] It is true that the tongues speaking in Acts 2 seems to be other human languages, but the tongues speaking of 1 Corinthians 14 may very well be conceptualized as angelic languages (cf. 1 Cor. 13:1), in any case languages not known to the congregation.
Some would say that those who speak in tongues are serving as conduits for demons and often curse God in other languages. These stories are often repeated with such a similar form that we suspect they are mostly urban legends with little or no basis in fact. In general it is dangerous to attribute to Satan what is actually the work of the Spirit. This is actually a sin Jesus says is unpardonable, so we should probably avoid such accusations (cf. Matt. 12:32).
I personally like to think that just as God often amplifies certain natural talents we have for ministry and Christian service, perhaps some people's brains are wired to have this experience in general. After all, we hear of these sorts of experiences not only among Christians but among other religious groups as well. [3] Perhaps God then "sanctifies" or amplifies this natural potentiality for such individuals, giving them a personal sense of blessing through the Holy Spirit. In any case, we cannot look down on this spiritual gift any more than we can think ourselves more spiritual than others for having it.
The lesson of the Corinthians is thus for the tongues-speaker--or in fact anyone with any special gift from God--not to think less of others in the community who do not have that gift. We are not more valuable to God because we have some particular gift. We may serve different functions in the body of Christ, but we are all of the same status, whether social or spiritual.
[1] 14:1 does not actually have the word "gifts." It simply says, "spiritual [matters]." However, the content of the chapters makes it clear that spiritual gifts are primarily in mind, especially tongues and prophecy.
[2] Some used to reference 1 Corinthians 13:8 as an indication that tongues would cease as a gift, but that is clearly not what the verse is saying. It is simply saying that languages come and go over time.
[3] It is hard to know when to date the Testament of Job, but it depicts the daughters of Job speaking in angelic tongues. That portion of the book may be influenced by Christians, but if it was part of the non-Christian Jewish part of the book, then we have an indication that some non-Christian Jews spoke in tongues.
Friday, December 11, 2009
The Authorship of 2 Peter
The final exam in General Epistles approacheth, and it promises a mini-essay on the final exam about the authorship of 2 Peter. I told the students I would send them some notes on what points they should cover to get full points, although I am not demanding that they take any particular position on the issue. Most, I assume, will argue for literal Petrine authorship.
Here are the relevant data to consider in the essay:
1. The Greek style of 2 Peter
Here are the relevant data to consider in the essay:
1. The Greek style of 2 Peter
- Style is different from 1 Peter, often called "Asiatic"
- Would a Galilean fisherman write Greek with Homeric and classical Greek overtones?
- What if both 1 and 2 Peter were written by different secretaries, who were primarily responsible for its style and manner of presentation?
- Why would Peter borrow from Jude? If Jude is late, it would seem to preclude Peter.
- But we do not know for sure either when Peter or Jude died, when Jude as written, and of course some think Jude borrowed from 2 Peter.
- 1 Peter says the end of all things is near and that the judgment has begun. 2 Peter seems to say that in the future, scoffers will ask why Christ has not come back yet.
- This difference seems quite substantial. At the very least it would seem to imply a different audience from 1 Peter. But of course this is a tension Christians affirm even today. We affirm an imminent expectation of Christ's return while living as if the world might still be here in a hundred years.
- 3:3 says, scoffers will come. But 3:4 speaks of them in the present tense, "they forget."
- If pseudonymous, the shift surely would imply that the audience would know it was not really Peter writing, but a literary device, and thus no deception would be involved.
- Could be vivid writing, getting strongly into the heads of future scoffers; sometimes you can see what's coming, even though it's only starting
- 3:2 could be taken to talk about the apostles and founding Christian prophets in the past tense; 3:4 could be taken to say that the fathers of Christianity will die before the scoffers come.
- If pseudonymous, surely the implication would be that a literary device is in play, since anyone would notice a document talking about its putative author in the past tense.
- Apostles could be more general than the twelve; prophets could refer to OT prophets.
- Paul wrote to specific audiences. 2 Peter seems to be written to all Christians. 3:15 seems to imply that at least one of Paul's letters, perhaps Romans, was directed at the audience of 2 Peter, and thus all Christians. How naturally would the historical Peter have made this shift, to see Romans or Paul's letters as letters to all people rather than particular letters to particular audiences?
- If we believe in revelation, God could inform Peter of such a shift in an instant.
- Would Paul's writings be available somewhat universally within 10 years of their writing?
- It is possible.
- Paul's writings seem to be considered Scripture like the Old Testament writings--quite remarkable development within some ten years of their writing and by someone known to differ with Paul on various issues in the past.
- Again, God could inform Peter of such a shift in an instant.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
